View Full Version : If Casey and April had a son... (in Mirage)
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 01:57 AM
... what should he be named?
And remember, Casey Jones' real full name is Arnold Bernid Jones. "Casey" is just a nickname.
neatoman
02-02-2022, 05:21 AM
How much input did Laird have on the creation of Cody from FastForward? If he did have significant input, then I wouldn't be shocked if he would have gone with Cody in this scenario.
If I personally had to write a Mirage story about this idea, I might go with Cody because latter era Mirage didn't seem to mind bringing in 4Kids ideas anyway. But to tell you the truth, I don't think I would have a preference and might just pick a name at random, probably a common American boy's name like John or Mike... Wait, scratch Mike, that might give someone ideas along with Leo, Raph and Don... Oh, and certainly not Baxter, they would never name their son Baxter.
In the IDW continuity, I have wondered if it would work for a story if they had a kid named Cody who was also the reincarnation of Darius Dunn.
Coola Yagami
02-02-2022, 08:47 AM
... what should he be named?
And remember, Casey Jones' real full name is Arnold Bernid Jones. "Casey" is just a nickname.
Pre 4Kids, probably some common name like Joseph, Kyle, etc, or maybe even Arnold Jr.
Post 4Kids, since TMNT just loves to self-reference itself and other iterations, will purposely call him Cody cause 'hey hey, like Cody from Fast Forward, get it? huh? huh? GET IT?'.
frank_one
02-02-2022, 09:11 AM
His adopted daughter's name is Shadow so I would opt for something like Light, Bright, Sunrise, Soleil or other names that refer to the light or the sun.
mrmaczaps
02-02-2022, 10:31 AM
... what should he be named?
And remember, Casey Jones' real full name is Arnold Bernid Jones. "Casey" is just a nickname.
Wasn't Casey a Junior already? Or was that something done during the 2k3 series?
oldmanwinters
02-02-2022, 11:42 AM
Raphie Jr.
Or maybe let's finally go ahead and make "Ralph" TMNT canon.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 11:57 AM
Wasn't Casey a Junior already? Or was that something done during the 2k3 series?
I don't think there was anything about that in Mirage. His dad is Herb Jones, not Arnold.
Zog The Magnificent
02-02-2022, 05:23 PM
Wait a minute, Casey's name was never "Arnold Bernid Jones." His name was originally "Casey Bernid Jones" before eventually being retconned into "Arnold Casey Jones," which I'm pretty sure happened in Tales #56.
That said, I'm fairly certain he'd name his son Casey. No Jr., just Casey and Little Casey.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 05:28 PM
Wait a minute, Casey's name was never "Arnold Bernid Jones." His name was originally "Casey Bernid Jones" before eventually being retconned into "Arnold Casey Jones," which I'm pretty sure happened in Tales #56.
Kind of. Clearly at some point Arnold only identified with his nickname, "Casey," and not Arnold. It'd be like if my name was Antoine Fuchelli but I really only ever answered to "Al." If I were to write my name, I would say it is "Al Fuchelli." "Arnold Casey Jones" works as long as you put quote marks around the Casey. Arnold "Casey" Jones is correct, but that doesn't mean "Bernid" goes anywhere.
Of course, I don't think "Arnold" Jones was even a thought until CAW. But it seems fairly compatible with everything else.
Zog The Magnificent
02-02-2022, 05:44 PM
Kind of. Clearly at some point Arnold only identified with his nickname, "Casey," and not Arnold. It'd be like if my name was Antoine Fuchelli but I really only ever answered to "Al." If I were to write my name, I would say it is "Al Fuchelli." "Arnold Casey Jones" works as long as you put quote marks around the Casey. Arnold "Casey" Jones is correct, but that doesn't mean "Bernid" goes anywhere.
Of course, I don't think "Arnold" Jones was even a thought until CAW. But it seems fairly compatible with everything else.
I don't think that's quite correct. He was clearly referred to as "Casey Bernid Jones" in #11, and then as "Arnold Casey Jones" in Tales #56. It seems more likely that Casey really was his first name initially, and then this was retconned in order to have some synergy with the 2003 show, where his first name was Arnold and his middle name was Casey, something that subsequent versions seem to do as well. Plus, it makes more sense that he would go by Casey anyways if it was his middle name, since "Arnold Bernid Jones" has nothing in it that would sounds like Casey. I know sometimes nicknames are just words that have to do with their personality, but they're not usually just entirely different names.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 05:48 PM
I don't think that's quite correct. He was clearly referred to as "Casey Bernid Jones" in #11, and then as "Arnold Casey Jones" in Tales #56. It seems more likely that Casey really was his first name initially, and then this was retconned in order to have some synergy with the 2003 show, where his first name was Arnold and his middle name was Casey, something that subsequent versions seem to do as well. Plus, it makes more sense that he would go by Casey anyways if it was his middle name, since "Arnold Bernid Jones" has nothing in it that would sounds like Casey. I know sometimes nicknames are just words that have to do with their personality, but they're not usually just entirely different names.
No, I don't reckon Tristan Jones had the power to retcon any names so I'd wager Arnold "Casey" Bernid Jones stands. "Arnold Casey Jones" with Casey intended to be the middle name was most likely a mistake or an oversight on Steve Murphy's part proofreading Tristan's script, if anything. That was also the pocket of time when Laird wasn't even actively monitoring the book.
Zog The Magnificent
02-02-2022, 05:53 PM
No, I don't reckon Tristan Jones had the power to retcon any names so I'd wager Arnold "Casey" Bernid Jones stands. "Arnold Casey Jones" with Casey intended to be the middle name was most likely a mistake or an oversight on Steve Murphy's part of Tristan's script, if anything. That was also the pocket of time when Laird wasn't actively monitoring the book.
Well, I suppose there's really no way to 100% confirm either position, unless anyone happens to have a direct line to Laird or Murphy.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 05:55 PM
Well, I suppose there's really no way to 100% confirm either position, unless anyone happens to have a direct line to Laird or Murphy.
Laird, no. Murphy, yes... but he never remembers anything. I'll ask Tristan what he remembers, just for fun.
Leo656
02-02-2022, 06:38 PM
If it were being written right now, their hypothetical child would choose their own name and gender independent from any parental suggestions or input.
After all, who are April and Casey to undermine their child's agency in such a way? Assigning a name or gender to a child is a form of child abuse, nothing more.
mrmaczaps
02-02-2022, 08:03 PM
If it were being written right now, their hypothetical child would choose their own name and gender independent from any parental suggestions or input.
After all, who are April and Casey to undermine their child's agency in such a way? Assigning a name or gender to a child is a form of child abuse, nothing more.
Sh!t man, don't give them ideas...
Leo656
02-02-2022, 08:07 PM
You know that's how Campbell would write it.
oldmanwinters
02-02-2022, 08:09 PM
If it were being written right now, their hypothetical child would choose their own name and gender independent from any parental suggestions or input.
After all, who are April and Casey to undermine their child's agency in such a way? Assigning a name or gender to a child is a form of child abuse, nothing more.
I mean... what even is Mirage April? Just a drawing brought to life because a frustrated artist tied a magical crystal to an ink pen.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 08:18 PM
I mean... what even is Mirage April? Just a drawing brought to life because a frustrated artist tied a magical crystal to an ink pen.
That's like saying "What even is this guy standing over there? Just a chance meeting of a sperm and an ovum."
I mean, same difference if the result is the same.
Leo656
02-02-2022, 08:21 PM
I mean... what even is Mirage April? Just a drawing brought to life because a frustrated artist tied a magical crystal to an ink pen.
Sh*t like that is why I always have to chuckle whenever people hold up Mirage as the purest and most sacrosanct form of TMNT media.
Because while every iteration of TMNT has had some mind-numbingly stupid stuff, that right there is WAY up there on the "Y'all Smokin' Crack, Dawg" scale. Like, if you hate some of the FW stuff but can try and defend THAT, then your bias is showing.
I mean, the whole meta thing they were trying to do with it wasn't even clever or cute. "I mean, if you think about it... ALL these characters are just 'magical drawings brought to life by the power of imagination', right? Riiiight?!" :roll: Barf.
I'm calling it, that sh*t was one of Laird's acid flashbacks from his college days. Or maybe he did shrooms again for old times' sake and this was the result. Either way... not good.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 08:23 PM
It was rather tragic and triumphant at the same time. People are dumb.
MikeandRaph87
02-02-2022, 08:26 PM
I just watched The Old Turtles Den's latest video. I have been aware of the highly unpopular and out of nowhere revelation that April O'Neil is an inked drawing come to life. However, I never knew the additional details. It was Renet who showed her and apparently they became cockroaches and had sex with cockroaches while observing her father? This is Frank Miller level insane! What drug was Peter Laird on? :teek::sick:
Leo656
02-02-2022, 08:28 PM
Chuck Austen wrote probably the worst Superman arc of all time. It was so bad that he got kicked off of it two issues before his 12-issue run was over and a ghostwriter finished it. It was wretched. Pretty unanimously sh*t on to this day by anyone who likes Superman comics.
BUT. Chuck Austen, at least, didn't turn Lois Lane into a time-traveling cockroach and in turn have her eat sh*t and partake in cockroach orgies, with the explanation of "this is all so as to protect the space-time continuum".
So as much as I hate to do it, I have to say that Chuck Austen is a better writer than Peter Laird.
Because time travel isn't real, and all of the above was a deliberate choice. He CHOSE to write that and charge people four bucks an issue to read it.
There's a reason most of these people never got paid to do comics unless they were paying themselves. It's a harsh truth, but harsh truths are still truths.
I just watched The Old Turtles Den's latest video. I have been aware of the highly unpopular and out of nowhere revelation that April O'Neil is an inked drawing come to life. However, I never knew the additional details. It was Renet who showed her and apparently they became cockroaches and had sex with cockroaches while observing her father? This is Frank Miller level insane! What drug was Peter Laird on? :teek::sick:
Even Frank Miller never did anything quite THAT bad. Yes, I'm including "Holy Terror", because that at least is funny if viewed as a farce.
It wasn't written as a farce, but I find that anything Miller wrote after 1987 HAS to be read as a farce or else it completely falls apart.
I mean, "Dark Knight Strikes Again" was pretty unforgivable. BUT. No time-traveling cockroach orgies featuring iconic and beloved characters. So it's still ahead on points, even if Superman f*cking Wonder Woman clear through the side of a mountain was pretty questionable.
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 08:31 PM
It was about a guy who desperately wanted to have a baby... who through sheer force of will -- and yes, the Kirby crystal -- was able to do so.
Everything else in the periphery (the cockroach stuff) is just that -- in the periphery. People get lost in the weeds about that. The whole thing was just meant to send April on a self-discovery journey... which admittedly didn't really go anywhere special. But the idea was sound.
MikeandRaph87
02-02-2022, 08:44 PM
The inked drawing thing is unnecessary and stupid, but adding the cockroaches piece I just, I just can't keep going, '...'. I thought maybe you Mirage heads can help my head to stop spinning.
I chose Arnold II, but I did do preferring Arnold III. I like the idea of Casey being the II.
Leo656
02-02-2022, 08:44 PM
"April as a drawing" was silly, but not the worst of it by half.
That Other Stuff still happened. He wrote it, and asked people to pay for it. You can't just ask people to ignore it. It's right there on the page, and it's terrible. Indefensibly bad. He had every opportunity NOT to write that sequence of events, and to put literally anything else on paper. He made a choice.
"We exist as phantoms outside of space/time when we travel to the past, so we can observe but not interact, so as to preserve the space-time continuum." There's just one solution that might be a bit cliche' but also isn't f*cking terrible and stupid. I could come up with a dozen more in an hour.
You want people to ignore that sh*t, you simply don't write it. Once it's out there, its out there.
Again, I know Eastman & Laird are the Patron Saints of TMNT and thus we're all supposed to kiss their asses and worship every dumb thing they ever put on paper, but I refuse. First of all, even at its best TMNT simply ain't that cool and never was, and secondly, as I've said a million times there's a reason neither guy ever did anything else of note. If they were any good at writing they'd have a giant stack of writing credits outside of TMNT, and it would be stuff people in real life have seen or heard of. And no, "They were too busy running the merch machine and thus didn't have time to write other stuff" isn't a good excuse for why they never actually "made it".
The fact is, they're not good writers. They had a good idea once and managed to leverage it into a fad that sold a lot of toys, and that part had nothing to do with them. Several of their own employees wrote the TMNT characters much better than they themselves ever did. Some of the worst stuff in the "real" TMNT universe, that being Mirage, came from the pens of Kevin and Pete. There's no ignoring or excusing it.
There's a reason people get so hung up on the time-travel cockroach orgy. Because it's f*cking terrible. It's a perfect example of why whenever people gnash their teeth and insist that Mirage is the true be-all end-all of TMNT, 99% of people just roll their eyes and laugh. "OK Boomer."
People have every right to still sh*t on that story 20 years later. It's easily one of the worst things TMNT ever produced, and worse still, it was "canon" to the prime universe.
Not okay.
Zog The Magnificent
02-02-2022, 09:09 PM
Yeah, I'm with Leo on that one. I disagree with the idea that Eastman and Laird were bad writers in general; maybe they just wanted to write the one thing. I have one project I'm working on, and once it's done, I'm done. There's no doubt, though, that they had some pretty bad stories. Every writer does.
But yeah, "Magic Doodle Baby" followed by cockroach orgy is always what comes to mind any time anyone holds up Mirage as the absolute pinacle of all TMNT. I'm a lot more leniant. I have my favorites, but there are things I like about every version, even Rise, and Rise is not that great. But Rise never stooped to "Magic Doodle Baby" followed by cockroach orgy. That was all Prime universe.
I think the argument focusing only on the themes, that it's a father desperate for a child who was able to will one into existence through magic, is a bit disingenuous. I could have a story about the sorrow of life passing you by as you get older, but If I express it through a slap stick comedy with a really heavy monologue in the middle, or in a gross out cartoon, then I've done a bad job of it. It doesn't really matter what the intention is, Laird wrote it as doodle baby with time traveling cockroaches. That happened. We can't just ignore it, because that's the story he chose to write. He could have had it happen ANY way he wanted, and he went with that. And that was stupid. WAY stupider than most things that have come out in other iterations. Any time anyone tries to say "April having psycic powers is super dumb," all I can think is "Uh, Magic Doodle Baby."
Even psychic powers made more sense in context than doodle baby cockroach sex.
frank_one
02-02-2022, 09:39 PM
Kev and Pete were never supposed to win a Pulitzer anyway.
Leo656
02-02-2022, 09:47 PM
I could force myself to not be mad at Magic Doodle Baby April, IF that's as far as it went.
Again, I got the "metafictional" point of it, even if I rolled my eyes at it. In and of itself? Silly but not altogether awful, even though it'll never be canon to me. April is a person, a regular human being (in-universe), and that's my "headcanon". BUT, at the end of the day if Laird wanted to undermine that by making April a magic drawing to make some belabored point which most people weren't even going to get or understand, that's his prerogative. He created her, after all. But it's a great example of how despite being co-creator of TMNT, the guy has never had a f*cking clue as to why other people like it or what they want from it. Pretty much ALL of Vol. 4 speaks to that, because that book is nothing but Laird's mid-life crisis put to paper while TMNT fans all over the world said "Uhhh... none of this is what I want from my Ninja Turtles. Wha' hoppen, guy?"
I mean, if you ask anybody if April is a magic drawing, or a psychic Utrom mutant, or I don't know what, they'll say "No, she's just a regular person, are you high?" Not even Laird can overwrite that. Again, his creation, he can SAY that she's really a magic drawing. But he's outvoted. Once you create a piece of pop culture entertainment, it belongs to the world and not you anymore. So when you make such a ludicrous retcon to one of your own creations, you technically have that right BUT you can't be shocked or put-off when everyone who previously enjoyed your work tells you you've lost your goddamn mind.
But again, since Mirage isn't canon to me anyway, I could just shrug off Magic Doodle Baby April as some more nonsense I don't care about at all, like Renet or Savanti Romero or a LOT of other stuff in Mirage. If that was ALL that happened, it wouldn't be the end of the world.
But the time-travel cockroach orgy sh*t still happened, and was the dumbest f*cking thing ever, and took a plotline that started off as "Huh... that's weird" and took it deep into "Dude, I think this guy has some f*cking legit problems" territory. I mean who even THINKS of that kinda sh*t, and furthermore, who the hell thinks that's what TMNT fans ever wanted to read about? Give me a f*cking break, man.
-----------------
As far as Laird's writing credentials or aspirations, I might be wrong but the story I always heard was, once upon a time he wanted to be a "real" writer, and then TMNT happened, and he got hit with the one-two punch of being too busy running the machine and then nobody wanting to give him an opportunity because he was "the TMNT guy".
I empathize, and I can see that being partly the case. But I also have to think that if he'd actually written anything that was truly good or noteworthy outside of TMNT then he would have seen it take off. Many of his peers had some level of crossover success writing things outside what they were best known for, so it's not like it's impossible. My personal opinion is, while he isn't a "bad" writer he also isn't very good, or at least, not enough to write anything that would be commercially successful.
All the "flavor" of Mirage TMNT seemingly came from Kevin "spicing up" Laird's half of the work, and Kevin in a vacuum has proven that he isn't great on his own either. He pulls down some hot tail, but he struggles greatly with writing plots or running a successful business. Just calling it like it is, here. Just like Peter, his success outside of TMNT is... well...
Sounds like I'm "bashing", I know, but I'm just being objective since I didn't read any of the Mirage stuff until I was almost 20 and was thoroughly underwhelmed when I did. SOME of it is among the best TMNT stuff ever, but some of it is also among the worst and you've gotta take the bad with the good or else you're just not being honest. There is a LOT of bad Mirage TMNT, and the cockroach thing has to be way up there (or down there, depending).
Andrew NDB
02-02-2022, 10:16 PM
As time goes on, I think it becomes more clear who excelled at what. Peter understood story, sci-fi, irony and character exploration. Kevin brought the style, the pizzazz, the Frank Miller-isms, ninja action, the showmanship and the "edge." Creatively almost everything Kevin brought to the table that was cool was largely borrowed from other things he liked and read or watched, repurposed. Which is fine, he did it well. Mostly I think his best contribution to the K&P days of Mirage was keeping what Peter was doing more palatable and exciting in nice, tight cohesive stories.
Compare any sampling of like, 2 or 3 issues of Vol. 4 (totally devoid of Kevin) to say, the 2012 annual at IDW (totally devoid of Peter) and you'll see what I mean.
I chose Arnold II, but I did do preferring Arnold III. I like the idea of Casey being the II.
Except he isn't. His dad is Herb Jones.
April is a person, a regular human being (in-universe), and that's my "headcanon".
That's not very profound to say... because she is. Crystal origin or not. Coming from the crystal doesn't make her any more or less human and never did. She's even been examined on a genetic level in Vol. 4 and they couldn't discern anything weird about her... only that her DNA does not share any DNA with Robyn, her sister. That's what started the whole thing.
"But cockroach orgies! They ruined April! blah blah!" Oh, shut up.
Leo656
02-02-2022, 10:39 PM
I don't think the retcon of April's origin was in any way "profound" either, even though it was clearly meant to be taken that way.
There is an exactly 0% chance that when Kevin and Peter created the character, that THAT was what they had in mind for her. It comes off like what it is: an obvious ass-pull retcon from someone who'd run out of ideas, no different from Bendis's "Jor-El was really a BAD GUY" or the "Bruce Wayne's parents were EVIL RICH PEOPLE" stuff that's become en vogue in recent years. None of that stuff was ever what was intended for those characters, and everyone knows that, which is why most people reject those takes. "Everything You Knew Is WRONG!" is like, one of the laziest storytelling devices that exists.
Quite frankly, I suspect you're more forgiving of it since it was indeed Laird himself who wrote it, and that it was a Mirage-published storyline and therefore "official canon". I have no way of knowing for a fact that you'd hate it if someone like Campbell or Murphy or someone else wrote it, or if that it had first been done outside of Mirage and was, like, a Nick thing or a FW thing. But I have a strong feeling that if that same plotline had first been presented as, say, an episode of the FW cartoon or the Nick cartoon, or as something in a movie, you'd think it was dumb as most people do.
I can't prove it, as I'm not in your head and can't read your thought balloons. BUT, it's what my gut tells me. If you say otherwise, I have no choice but to believe you. But that's how it reads, to me. You've been openly very dismissive of a lot of things in various TMNT media that are WAY less dumb than April Is A Magic Drawing, so I can't wrap my head around your defense of this one at all. But you do you, buddy. Nobody can change your mind and that's why you're such an institution here. :)
I can't help but notice you don't even try to defend the cockroach stuff. Probably a wise move. It's not defensible. :trazz: Again, ALL he had to do was NOT write that part of the story and we wouldn't be having this conversation. That was his ultimate George Lucas Moment, where at least ONE person in the room should have spoken up and said "Nah, man, this ain't the way." But I get the feeling that wasn't how Mirage operated, and that nobody was gonna speak up even though they knew that part was terrible.
Galactus
02-03-2022, 08:41 PM
I feel I should probably state that in one of those Q & A sessions Laird used to do on the comment section of his blog he said that he regrets making April a creation of Kirby's crystal. I have a suspicion that he meant to do more with it down the line but he's also said more than once that he re-thought his original intended ending to Vol. 4 so whatever he intended to go with the idea was probably no longer relevant.
For the record I've always thought the inspiration for April origin was less Laird trying to be meta-textual but purposefully symbolic of real life on the couples who are struggling to start a family and go the route of IVF to conceive. I remember around the time there was a slight resurgence in people against assisted reproduction and I can definitely see that being something Laird would want to use in Vol. 4. A lot of that book was him drawing on what was relevant in the news at the time.
I could have done without such a vivid description of what it's like to live life as a cockroach but it's not like it was something that was referenced again.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.