View Full Version : Venus Returning in IDW #127
hypered1
02-24-2022, 03:49 PM
Full article here:
https://gizmodo.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-venus-returns-idw-1848590161
Chris
02-24-2022, 03:50 PM
"Venus will make her first official debut in next month’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #127, by Campbell, Tunica, Pattison, and Lee. As part of the ongoing arc that has seen the Turtle brothers struggle to keep the peace in Mutant Town—a quarantined section of Manhattan’s East Side populated by the mutated human victims of a mutagenic bomb explosion—the team has been investigating a mysterious surgeon named Dr. Jasper Barlow, a mutant doctor who has been operating a cosmetic surgery lab offering to graft human skin grafts onto willing mutant residents of Mutant Town."
"Although the current storyline will wrap up in TMNT #130, Venus’ story will continue in the form of IDW’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Free Comic Book Day issue, due out May 7 as part of the annual comics celebration, which itself will set the stage for a major event in the ongoing series, the aforementioned Armageddon Game, set to begin later this year."
Full article from io9 here:
https://gizmodo.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-venus-returns-idw-1848590161
https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/c_fit,f_auto,g_center,pg_1,q_60,w_645/6ec83db0ec331986d7e06ede8a35648e.png
Andrew NDB
02-24-2022, 04:13 PM
I admit, I'm curious as to what the story will be here on her.
Is she really going to be Mei Pieh Chi? Will she truly be a non-sister sister separated from them when they were normal turtles? Will she actually be called Venus De Milo? Alternately, is she supposed to be the actual Venus, like from the NT:TNM universe? Probably not, right? Did her version of Chung I do the Frankenstein stuff to her?
CyberCubed
02-24-2022, 04:19 PM
She's basically Frakenturtle? Admittedly this news would be somewhat more interesting if we didn't have two other female Turtles in the series already, so this will make number 3.
Allio
02-24-2022, 04:20 PM
Not surprised. The whole Dragon thing always felt like we would be getting a “Next Mutation” arc, doesn’t help that Dr. Barlow gives off a Dr. Queese vibe.
I imagine the vibe is that This Venus is rebuilt with the missing Punk Frog as her base.
neatoman
02-24-2022, 04:33 PM
OK, for anyone who is confused about this:
No. She is not going to have the same or even a similar backstory to what she had in the Next Mutation. It's been all but officially confirmed that this new version of Venus isn't even really a mutant turtle, she is a mutant frog who has been surgically altered to resemble a turtle.
I'm guessing this change was made because:
Jennika is probably too similar in concept to the original version of Venus in the first place, as might be Lita as well.
Nobody likes Venus, she's quite possibly the most hated character in the franchise, both for the concept and the execution. Thus, nobody cares about any changes made to her.
neatoman
02-24-2022, 04:35 PM
Hey, so since she's basically just stitched together from different body parts, what are the odds of her story ending with her just falling apart?
Andrew NDB
02-24-2022, 04:38 PM
OK, for anyone who is confused about this:
No. She is not going to have the same or even a similar backstory to what she had in the Next Mutation. It's been all but officially confirmed that this new version of Venus isn't even really a mutant turtle, she is a mutant frog who has been surgically altered to resemble a turtle.
But... where is the head/brain coming from?
I'm guessing this change was made because:
1. Jennika is probably too similar in concept to the original version of Venus in the first place, as might be Lita as well.
I don't know who Lita is and I haven't really read any Jennika comics but... Jennika and Jennika's origins don't sound anything like Venus'. Does Jennika know magic shinobi powers? Does she constantly mess up American English sayings and such? Was she separated from them pre-mutation as a normal turtle? If the answer is "no" to those then I don't think the comparison is valid.
2.Nobody likes Venus, she's quite possibly the most hated character in the franchise, both for the concept and the execution. Thus, nobody cares about any changes made to her.
I wonder if the answer is really...
3. They legally can't use Venus De Milo because of some weird Saban rights thing... unless they change her up so drastically that it can't be considered the same character.
We know Campbell did try to use Venus earlier and was told "no," presumably because of rights issues. Maybe this is a way around it.
TigerClaw
02-24-2022, 04:41 PM
Full article here:
https://gizmodo.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-venus-returns-idw-1848590161
Here's what she looks like.
https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/c_fit,f_auto,g_center,pg_1,q_60,w_965/6ec83db0ec331986d7e06ede8a35648e.png
Allio
02-24-2022, 04:46 PM
3. They legally can't use Venus De Milo because of some weird Saban rights thing... unless they change her up so drastically that it can't be considered the same turtle
I doubt it, only because the TMNT franchise has been pretty open about what characters/stories can or cannot be reused (EX. The River) so I feel like if there were any legal issues about Venus we would have heard about them. We simply ever heard that she is the black sheep.
Andrew NDB
02-24-2022, 04:51 PM
I doubt it, only because the TMNT franchise has been pretty open about what characters/stories can or cannot be reused (EX. The River)
Well, that's kind of my point. They wanted Bloodsucker but they couldn't so they kind of concocted Wyrm together, no? Could be sort of the same idea going on with Venus/Not-Venus here.
so I feel like if there were any legal issues about Venus we would have heard about them. We simply ever heard that she is the black sheep.
I'm not so sure. So far in IDW, have there been any other NT:TNM elements that've shown up fairly intact?
oldmanwinters
02-24-2022, 04:53 PM
She’s an android.. or something… so tells me my gut.
Kyo Hisagi
02-24-2022, 04:54 PM
So I dunno if that's controversial or anything but. Yeah.
I have nothing against Venus but one of the very few things I didn't like about IDW comics even back then is that it had TOO MANY characters thrown into mix. You can't just put one hundred different characters into a comic book about four turtles and expect that all of them will have something to do.
It's basically X-Men situation all over again- when there were only 6 or 8 of them, that's cool. I can follow that. When there are 30, you need different teams. Then you introduce "new generation" of kids, and they need their own book too. When they are 200 of them... in ONE story... uh-oh.
When IDW's TMNT just started back in 2011, we had characters being introduced pretty slowly, one by one. It felt very well thought out. I didn't feel too overwhelmed, yet I knew I can expect my favourite characters to appear sometime later. People lost it when Bebop and Rocksteady finally appeared, it was so cool. Mutanimals didn't appear until much later, and it was a great decision.
Now? With all these new characters introduced in MutantTown already? It's just feels like "who else was there in previous TMNT books/movies/comics? Yeah let's put them here too!"
Some of the characters I really was interested in were killed off (Hun, Slash) with some others being completely brushed off (Casey and April) and some overstayed its welcome (Hob). Again- I am not against the idea of adding characters from different stories, I think it's actually pretty cool... if done right. But when you have that many to choose from, a lot of them will end up underused (like Null, ahem). So the question is- what exactly is the point here?... maybe we need time exploring all of these characters before we get even more?...
Would be cool to have "what-if" mini-series for this kind of stuff. Just something that happened to parallel universe' turtles. Or at least some sort of second series, like TMNT Universe. But I am pretty sure we're not getting that.
Sumac
02-24-2022, 06:11 PM
IDW stepped on the same mainline, that FW did - too many goddamn mutants.
Ninjinister
02-24-2022, 06:18 PM
3. They legally can't use Venus De Milo because of some weird Saban rights thing... unless they change her up so drastically that it can't be considered the same character.
We know Campbell did try to use Venus earlier and was told "no," presumably because of rights issues. Maybe this is a way around it.
I do remember either Bobby or Tom saying that they could use Venus, but chose not to, or didn't have a plan for her. I don't think it's a legal thing.
Bahamut810
02-24-2022, 06:33 PM
I am grooving on her character design.
neatoman
02-24-2022, 06:40 PM
But... where is the head/brain coming from?
I don't know what you mean by this.
I don't know who Lita is and I haven't really read any Jennika comics but... Jennika and Jennika's origins don't sound anything like Venus'. Does Jennika know magic shinobi powers? Does she constantly mess up American English sayings and such? Was she separated from them pre-mutation as a normal turtle? If the answer is "no" to those then I don't think the comparison is valid.
The concept of a fifth turtle in general, not so much the details. And if we're being honest, nobody really cares what Venus was like in the show and I honestly keep forgetting she has magic powers. The problem with her, Jennika, Lita and that Kirby character from the scrapped TMNT 4 is that the idea of a fifth turtle is an idea that is very misguided and feels like something out of a bad fan fic. All four of these characters could have been anything other than mutant turtles and they would still have served the same purpose. The only reason to make them mutant turtles is because someone erroneously thinks it makes them more memorable, which if it does, is only in the worst way possible.
Regardless, if this new Venus wasn't a surgically altered frog and still a turtle, then within the context of this series she would have been a human being turned into a turtle and thrust into mutant town. Which would have made her superficially similar to Jennika and Lita regardless of what they did to her otherwise.
I wonder if the answer is really...
3. They legally can't use Venus De Milo because of some weird Saban rights thing... unless they change her up so drastically that it can't be considered the same character.
We know Campbell did try to use Venus earlier and was told "no," presumably because of rights issues. Maybe this is a way around it.
I don't know... Maybe Saban/Hasbro/Disney (whoever the hell owns TNM right now, it's one of them) has the exclusive rights to Venus. But then again, Viacom hasn't had a problem using Fred Wolf or 4Kids characters, so I don't see why TNM characters should be a problem.
CyberCubed
02-24-2022, 07:02 PM
So I dunno if that's controversial or anything but. Yeah.
I have nothing against Venus but one of the very few things I didn't like about IDW comics even back then is that it had TOO MANY characters thrown into mix. You can't just put one hundred different characters into a comic book about four turtles and expect that all of them will have something to do.
It's basically X-Men situation all over again- when there were only 6 or 8 of them, that's cool. I can follow that. When there are 30, you need different teams. Then you introduce "new generation" of kids, and they need their own book too. When they are 200 of them... in ONE story... uh-oh.
When IDW's TMNT just started back in 2011, we had characters being introduced pretty slowly, one by one. It felt very well thought out. I didn't feel too overwhelmed, yet I knew I can expect my favourite characters to appear sometime later. People lost it when Bebop and Rocksteady finally appeared, it was so cool. Mutanimals didn't appear until much later, and it was a great decision.
Now? With all these new characters introduced in MutantTown already? It's just feels like "who else was there in previous TMNT books/movies/comics? Yeah let's put them here too!"
Some of the characters I really was interested in were killed off (Hun, Slash) with some others being completely brushed off (Casey and April) and some overstayed its welcome (Hob). Again- I am not against the idea of adding characters from different stories, I think it's actually pretty cool... if done right. But when you have that many to choose from, a lot of them will end up underused (like Null, ahem). So the question is- what exactly is the point here?... maybe we need time exploring all of these characters before we get even more?...
Would be cool to have "what-if" mini-series for this kind of stuff. Just something that happened to parallel universe' turtles. Or at least some sort of second series, like TMNT Universe. But I am pretty sure we're not getting that.
Hun and Slash being killed off is fine, their characters were getting stale and completed their character arcs. Honestly I would have killed off a few more of the villains, or had some stay dead like Shredder/Krang.
King Kahn
02-24-2022, 07:10 PM
I love it! They have a great track record of updating crazy concepts.
TigerClaw
02-24-2022, 07:16 PM
Apparently according to Sophie Campbell, Venus isn't quite a turtle, That's after I replied to her about the images she posted of Venus.
Chaotix12345
02-24-2022, 07:18 PM
Thought I recognized her "braid" on the FCBD cover, so not surprised. Given her artificial shell, I think it's pretty obvious that she's who the Punk Frogs REALLY have a score to settle with. Curious to learn her whole story and also how the previous mystical elements of her character factor into this version with the whole Frankenturtle thing. (The art seems to hint at it still being a thing, at least.)
TigerClaw
02-24-2022, 07:57 PM
All signs are pointing to this version of Venus being that Bonnie character that the Punk Frogs are looking for.
As to why she's called Venus? Its probably just that mutant surgeon giving her that name.
Bahamut810
02-24-2022, 08:06 PM
Apparently according to Sophie Campbell, Venus isn't quite a turtle, That's after I replied to her about the images she posted of Venus.
They have a yokai/spirit world thing going on...she could be a Kappa. Possibly one that was altered by the good Doctor to get rid of her head bowl.
ZariusTwo
02-25-2022, 04:15 AM
Now all we need is Zach:D
frank_one
02-25-2022, 09:24 AM
As to why she's called Venus? Its probably just that mutant surgeon giving her that name.Maybe the surgeon thinks its creation is beautiful and so he gives her the name of the ancient Roman goddess of beauty to celebrate her and his ability.
ChosenOne
02-25-2022, 10:41 AM
Missed opportunity if she doesn't have stitching halfway down both her upper arms.
RoyLo
02-25-2022, 11:06 AM
I'm kinda excited about it. I think it's mandatory to have a female turtle, so appeal to bigger audience. Think that most of the biggest franchises got females in the front row - Marvel & DC, GI Joe, Power Rangers, Thundercats, He-man, and even the Transformers have few. Heck, even Samurai Pizza Cats :lol:
But I also would love to get a proper introduction story for her this time.
Coola Yagami
02-25-2022, 11:23 AM
I'm kinda excited about it. I think it's mandatory to have a female turtle, so appeal to bigger audience. Think that most of the biggest franchises got females.
Um... Jennika?
hypered1
02-25-2022, 12:59 PM
Missed opportunity if she doesn't have stitching halfway down both her upper arms.
The FCBD cover and the pictures in the article attached to this thread show that she does indeed have stitches around both arms - left upper and right forearm. This somewhat reflects the statue as it has no left arm and a stump right arm (I'd post a pic but I'm not sure if it would be allowed).
hypered1
02-25-2022, 01:01 PM
Um... Jennika?
And Lita/ Future Lita.
hypered1
02-25-2022, 01:02 PM
Maybe the surgeon thinks its creation is beautiful and so he gives her the name of the ancient Roman goddess of beauty to celebrate her and his ability.
That's a pretty good theory actually.
Andrew NDB
02-25-2022, 01:06 PM
You know, there's a little bit of a Cyberfrog vibe from that Venus reveal there with the being put together, frog arm and glowing eyes and all.
https://i.ibb.co/2jyPk7H/jcbd0nbyl1y9ulwnw4t4.jpg
Is it possible she's a fan?
ChosenOne
02-25-2022, 02:49 PM
The FCBD cover and the pictures in the article attached to this thread show that she does indeed have stitches around both arms - left upper and right forearm. This somewhat reflects the statue as it has no left arm and a stump right arm (I'd post a pic but I'm not sure if it would be allowed).
Thanks for confirming, I'm glad she has them. It's a great visual pun.
Bahamut810
02-25-2022, 03:55 PM
You know, there's a little bit of a Cyberfrog vibe from that Venus reveal there with the being put together, frog arm and glowing eyes and all.
https://i.ibb.co/2jyPk7H/jcbd0nbyl1y9ulwnw4t4.jpg
Is it possible she's a fan?
Probably not that Campbell would admit.
CyberCubed
02-25-2022, 05:01 PM
So Venus was a Frog that got changed into a Turtle?
Bahamut810
02-25-2022, 05:13 PM
So Venus was a Frog that got changed into a Turtle?
Thinking about it, I wonder if they are going to try to smack people over the head with trans allegory?
Allio
02-25-2022, 05:23 PM
Isn’t that the thing about allegory? It’s all interpretations based on the readers. Like the recent ones claiming that the matrix trilogy is trans allegory.
I mean I wouldn’t call the original IDW’s Arcee mini being a trans allegory and it has the same plot here.
Andrew NDB
02-25-2022, 05:26 PM
So Venus was a Frog that got changed into a Turtle?
People keep saying that here... but it looks like just the one arm is a frog's? No?
TigerClaw
02-25-2022, 05:30 PM
People keep saying that here... but it looks like just the one arm is a frog's? No?
Sophie Campbell did say she's not quite a turtle.
Andrew NDB
02-25-2022, 05:32 PM
My guess is "cyborg mostly-turtle with at least one frog body part."
hypered1
02-25-2022, 06:23 PM
My guess is "cyborg mostly-turtle with at least one frog body part."
I've seen the concept art on Sophie's patreon, so I can confirm that Venus is about 50/50 between turtle and frog.
If Sophie puts it up on her twitter I'll link to it here.
CyberCubed
02-25-2022, 07:57 PM
Well at least Venus can't be gay in this series because Jennika is already a lesbian. I mean they can't have both female Turtles be gay can they? It would be kind of redundant.
neatoman
02-25-2022, 08:11 PM
Well at least Venus can't be gay in this series because Jennika is already a lesbian. I mean they can't have both female Turtles be gay can they? It would be kind of redundant.
... Flawless logic there, buddy...
CyberCubed
02-25-2022, 08:13 PM
I don't think there can be two lesbian Turtles. We hit our quota on that already.
neatoman
02-25-2022, 08:27 PM
I don't think there can be two lesbian Turtles. We hit our quota on that already.
... Uhm... There is no way of expressing what I'm thinking or bringing up something related that won't lead to this thread turning into another pointless **** show, so I'm not really going to say anything beyond how... You seem to lack a certain... Bit of information...
Allio
02-25-2022, 09:47 PM
he watches films on 1.35 speed, and thinks Dragon ball is the best anime and marathons every Pokémon episode every year. I wouldn’t take him serious.
Leo656
02-25-2022, 10:28 PM
... Uhm... There is no way of expressing what I'm thinking or bringing up something related that won't lead to this thread turning into another pointless **** show, so I'm not really going to say anything beyond how... You seem to lack a certain... Bit of information...
Have no fear buddy, I'm still around. And it's still my primary mission to ruin every f*cking thing I can. :tgrin:
But more to the discussion, I thought we'd long since established that All Chicks Are Gay? Now Cubed is saying "we can't have two of 'em in the same comic." What?
member_removed
02-26-2022, 03:34 AM
I don't think there can be two lesbian Turtles. We hit our quota on that already.
Don't kink shame me!
ProphetofGanja
02-26-2022, 10:44 AM
so did this creepy doctor guy just give a mutant frog a cyborg turtle shell and a ninja braid?
LeotheLateBloomer
02-26-2022, 11:14 AM
So...why exactly are they bringing her back?
frank_one
02-26-2022, 11:29 AM
Because they want to save her from decades of bullying.
LeotheLateBloomer
02-26-2022, 11:53 AM
Good luck!:tlol:
ChosenOne
02-26-2022, 05:24 PM
so did this creepy doctor guy just give a mutant frog a cyborg turtle shell and a ninja braid?
Don't forget a chunk of magic dragon!
lonewarrior20
02-26-2022, 05:33 PM
i'm wondering who's the "brain".
red1981
02-27-2022, 09:20 PM
she was not that bad in the live action show, and this version looks completely different from that version, also it looks like things are really picking up with the story even though i like the mutant town stuff, it looks like the turtles clan will have a bunch of villains to deal with coming up
Leo656
02-27-2022, 11:33 PM
she was not that bad in the live action show
Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat.
neatoman
02-28-2022, 05:27 AM
she was not that bad in the live action show
pDZ89gigJxE
r3hTwsvJV_A?
superstaff
02-28-2022, 11:04 AM
Well at least Venus can't be gay in this series because Jennika is already a lesbian. I mean they can't have both female Turtles be gay can they? It would be kind of redundant.
Wasn't she bi? Or was she revealed to be 100% a lesbian?
hypered1
02-28-2022, 12:29 PM
Wasn't she bi? Or was she revealed to be 100% a lesbian?
Jennika is bi, otherwise she wouldn't have looked twice at Casey.
mrmaczaps
02-28-2022, 12:40 PM
Wasn't she bi? Or was she revealed to be 100% a lesbian?
When women go both ways, they're bi. When men go both ways, they're just gay... Cubed Quote, pretty sure thats on another thread like this somewhere on here. Lol. [I think it was Cubed...]
Andrew NDB
02-28-2022, 12:52 PM
When women go both ways, they're bi. When men go both ways, they're just gay... Cubed Quote, pretty sure thats on another thread like this somewhere on here. Lol. [I think it was Cubed...]
I mean, it's generally true. Women can "dabble" and this or that and usually come back or make "dating" both genders a regular, non-big deal. But a dude? Pretty much once they go down the vortex of ass even a little bit, that's that. There's no getting out of that, like a quicksand.
I say this with no homophobia. I do have gay friends. It's just a general truth, as much as they've told me and as much as I've seen in my life with my own two eyes.
red1981
02-28-2022, 03:23 PM
why does it matter if one character is bi or gay, you know there is gay people out in the real world, plus we are talking about a comic that has animales that are mutated and talk and act like people that also know martial arts
red1981
02-28-2022, 03:28 PM
I am grooving on her character design.
i know me too i have this pic as my pc wallpaper its awesome looking
frank_one
02-28-2022, 03:55 PM
An anthropomorphic frog surgically changed into a female turtle. Now we are talking!
Andrew NDB
02-28-2022, 03:57 PM
plus we are talking about a comic that has animales that are mutated and talk and act like people that also know martial arts
Why in the world would anyone still be invoking Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law) in 2022?
Sumac
02-28-2022, 04:00 PM
why does it matter if one character is bi or gay, you know there is gay people out in the real world, plus we are talking about a comic that has animales that are mutated and talk and act like people that also know martial arts
Because, current writers are pedaling all this nonsense?
I wonder, how they will define Venus - "trans species"?
ProphetofGanja
02-28-2022, 05:36 PM
All signs are pointing to this version of Venus being that Bonnie character that the Punk Frogs are looking for.
As to why she's called Venus? Its probably just that mutant surgeon giving her that name.
I put $10 on her 'Venus di Milo' dubbing being shoehorned-in as fvck
Why in the world would anyone still be invoking Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law) in 2022?
Teach them the old magic, Andrew :lol:
red1981
02-28-2022, 10:15 PM
ive noticed a lot of the people hear think the image tmnt comics are the only good ones and i think only the first few issues of the image run are good, the rest are good reads but should not be held up as the best tmnt thing ever, its like saying the 87 cartoon is the only cartoon that is any good i seem to enjoy all versions, not so much the live action show or that weird anime version lol
Andrew NDB
02-28-2022, 10:26 PM
ive noticed a lot of the people hear think the image tmnt comics are the only good ones and i think
I don't know even one person here who has said Image are the only good ones. Now, I know people who have said that Mirage, which Image is an extension of, are the only good ones.
Ninjinister
03-01-2022, 04:12 PM
Why in the world would anyone still be invoking Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law) in 2022?
I still don't understand where the hell that came from and why it's so contentious.
In a series this fantastical, why are we suspending disbelief for stupid stuff like an alien goo anthropomorphizing Turtles and not less stupid stuff? Or in this case, why is it less stupid than actual **** in the real world?
Sharman
03-02-2022, 06:31 AM
I am intrigued by how the character looks in this iteration and the story possibilities that engenders.
Andrew NDB
03-03-2022, 12:14 PM
Here's Kevin being Kevin, on Venus:
https://www.cbr.com/tent-co-creator-comments-venus-return-eastman/?fbclid=IwAR1kO67eCqA5PT3FCHMdIPWV4ziCwq3EV_Ch4QcX M1C9XTeRJSwFu_sKXnU
mrmaczaps
03-03-2022, 01:07 PM
Here's Kevin being Kevin, on Venus:
https://www.cbr.com/tent-co-creator-comments-venus-return-eastman/?fbclid=IwAR1kO67eCqA5PT3FCHMdIPWV4ziCwq3EV_Ch4QcX M1C9XTeRJSwFu_sKXnU
The link says "tent co-creator".... lol.
Also, Sophie knocking it out of the park? Lol lol lol
Show Kevin the money... $$$$ This franchise is circling the drain fast.
Allio
03-03-2022, 02:12 PM
I put $10 on her 'Venus di Milo' dubbing being shoehorned-in as fvck
To be fair it, that is the origin of her name in Next Mutation (despite calling her Venus prior to giving her her the nickname.)
Andrew NDB
03-03-2022, 02:15 PM
To be fair it, that is the origin of her name in Next Mutation (despite calling her Venus prior to giving her her the nickname.)
Her name in Next Mutation is Mei Pieh Chi, her nickname is Venus de Milo. Let's see if Mei Pieh Chi is still Mei Pieh Chi.
Leo656
03-03-2022, 06:29 PM
The link says "tent co-creator".... lol.
Also, Sophie knocking it out of the park? Lol lol lol
Show Kevin the money... $$$$ This franchise is circling the drain fast.
By this point they should just drop all pretense. Have the guys "retire" and shift the book to focus on Jennika, Venus, etc. full-time so they can do the book they obviously would rather be putting out.
neatoman
03-03-2022, 06:34 PM
Despite the popularity of Jennika, fans kept hoping for a Venus return, and they're finally getting their wish.
I'm guessing Christopher Baggett has absolutely no fingers on the pulse of the fanbase, because neither of these character can be called popular. I'm willing to bet that if I were to make a poll right now, the most popular choice would be to have both characters removed and never spoken about ever again.
Andrew NDB
03-03-2022, 06:39 PM
I'm guessing Christopher Baggett has absolutely no fingers on the pulse of the fanbase, because neither of these character can be called popular. I'm willing to bet that if I were to make a poll right now, the most popular choice would be to have both characters removed and never spoken about ever again.
Yeah, he literally made up parts of his article there. At least, vastly distorted parts.
Galactus
03-03-2022, 07:02 PM
By this point they should just drop all pretense. Have the guys "retire" and shift the book to focus on Jennika, Venus, etc. full-time so they can do the book they obviously would rather be putting out.
Maybe for an arc but I imagine it would be more like they'd be spun off as their own thing than take over the main book.
Jester
03-03-2022, 07:17 PM
The show established Venus as having been in the same bowl as the other four turtles that fell down the sewer, though Splinter unknowingly left her behind. Venus was instead raised in Chinatown by Mei Pieh Chi, who taught her the art of Shinobi.
A person was paid to write this sentence....
Sumac
03-03-2022, 09:11 PM
Maybe for an arc but I imagine it would be more like they'd be spun off as their own thing than take over the main book.
The book is barely about Turtles already.
But, OK, **** it, let's make a TMNT book about nobodies liked by 2,5 mentally ill furries and the like, as opposed to Ninja Turtles. What can go wrong?
Leo656
03-03-2022, 09:20 PM
The book is barely about Turtles already.
But, OK, **** it, let's make a TMNT book about nobodies liked by 2,5 mentally ill furries and the like, as opposed to Ninja Turtles. What can go wrong?
I mean, that's been the case for two whole years and the IDW folks (who I'm sure would never, ever lie or embellish) swear that sales have never been better! :lol:
Which is why I say screw it. It's obvious they don't actually like doing Ninja Turtles, so just bench 'em altogether and see how well "Jennika and Friends" does on its own without the "TMNT" title holding things up. If IDW and the pink-hairs are honest, then it should sell a ton. So just do it already and drop all pretense.
Sumac
03-03-2022, 11:54 PM
What a petty end for the series.
Galactus
03-04-2022, 07:10 PM
I should probably say at the top of this post that I've never fully gotten on board the IDW TMNT train. The book is well made but I've never bought into it being the definitive version of TMNT that a lot fans labelled it as for years.
There's a few issues I have with the book but the two most relevant to this conversation is that the aesthetic from the various artists that have worked on the series have always leaned heavily on the characters looking very 'soft'. Even someone like Santalouco whose art on Secret History of the Foot Clan wasn't exactly edgy became a whole lot more cute when he was on the main book. Secondly the series has always been way too enthusiastic about bringing in other animal mutants particularly from other versions. Personally I've always thought less is more in this regard. In these respects Sophie Campbell's run is not all that different to Tom Waltz's. It's basically the ultimate evolution of what the IDW TMNT have always been; ultra cute and filled to the brim with mutants.The big difference between then and now is Sophie leans more heavily on slice of life character pieces and less on plot driven action. Admittedly the Mutant Town era has lasted longer than I thought it would but it wont last forever. The better received aspects of it will stick around in some fashion while the status quo is mostly restored because that's comics.
That being said I think it's unfair to say that the book is being is being made by people who don't want to make TMNT books. Sophie is a true blue fan that has done good work for Mirage and IDW previously. There has always been a sub-section of the fanbase that's pushed for more mutants in general and redeeming the concept of Venus and female turtles in general. Clearly there is an audience for this.
Also somewhere out there Jarrah White is taking a break from making Moon Landing Conspiracies to indulge in private time with that promo shot at Venus.
Leo656
03-04-2022, 07:55 PM
Yeah. And Rian Johnson is a "true blue" Star Wars fan, just ask him. That's why he made a movie that broke the entire mythos while making it a point to ruin every single thing anyone ever liked about it, in favor of his fanfiction ideas nobody wanted.
These people are all cut from the same cloth. "I'm a huge fan of ________ but what it REALLY needs is to be nothing like what anyone already likes about it. Then it'd be a lot better."
frank_one
03-04-2022, 08:23 PM
Sophie is a true blue fan that has done good work for MirageThis must be one of those Mandela effects. Sophie hasn't done anything for Mirage. Her only contribution was the covers for the Bad moon rising mini-series.
Galactus
03-04-2022, 08:32 PM
There is actual TMNT fan fiction written by Sophie Campbell from years ago. Even when she was a getting professional work in comics she still did her own fan fiction reworking of Secret of the Ooze which included something of a proto-Jennika.
Sophie is perfectly capable of telling more 'traditional' TMNT stories. Most of her work pre-Mutant Town fell into that category which was well received which is what I imagine secured her the regular gig. She even did an interesting pitch to Dark Horse for a TMNT series before Laird sold the franchise to Nickelodeon.
She's definitely got the credentials of a true fan even her tastes lean differently to ours. Clearly she is (or has become) much more open lots of mutants and the concept of a fifth turtle and this is the result of someone telling her "the book is all yours now so go nuts". It's not the direction I want for the book (although like I said I've never been the biggest fan of it) she's definitely a fan.
This must be one of those Mandela effects. Sophie hasn't done anything for Mirage. Her only contribution was the covers for the Bad moon rising mini-series.
Which was published by...?
CyberCubed
03-04-2022, 08:56 PM
is it strange a deviantart artist got to work officially on TMNT comics? She was just a fanart and fanfiction artist before she got hired professionally.
Leo656
03-04-2022, 09:10 PM
Nah, apparently it's the best way to get into the business now. Nothing really strange about it. One of the more well-known artists on the Sonic comic apparently started the same way. It's become pretty standard.
Sumac
03-04-2022, 11:58 PM
That being said I think it's unfair to say that the book is being is being made by people who don't want to make TMNT books. Sophie is a true blue fan that has done good work for Mirage and IDW previously.
There is actual TMNT fan fiction written by Sophie Campbell from years ago.
By this logic I am more than qualified to be writer on any TMNT comic book and, of course, I am a MEGA OMEGA ALPHA SUPER HYPER TRUE FAN, because, I've made TMNT fan comic books and scripts, since I was 7 year old (and sometimes I still do them)!!! :lol:
In general, anything regarding "true fan" argument is a retarded argument.
There is no such thing as a "true fan" and anyone who calls them that is just either pretentious idiot or an arrogant poser.
Calling Campbell qualified just, because, he was writing stuff for TMNT on his free time is stupid. By this logic, you can pick up anyone from Fanfiction.net or other fansites and call them "qualified" as well.
There has always been a sub-section of the fanbase that's pushed for more mutants in general and redeeming the concept of Venus and female turtles in general. Clearly there is an audience for this.
Most of them are either fans of FW, which as far removed from OG (and arguably really good) TMNT works as far as possible or retarded furry-shippers, who just want some canon material about humanoid animals ****ing each other brains out, because, those people are lonely virgins and missing few synapses.
Neither audience has anything to do with core TMNT stuff and shouldn't be listened to, when it comes to creating good and serious TMNT works.
frank_one
03-05-2022, 02:04 AM
Which was published by...?Those were covers, that's the only stuff by her published by Mirage. Mirage never published something written by her. No one here is criticizing her art style.
mrmaczaps
03-05-2022, 09:36 AM
Those were covers, that's the only stuff by her published by Mirage. Mirage never published something written by her. No one here is criticizing her art style.
I don't like Campbell's art... its bland & when colored by Camp, also too... neon is not the right word... pastel. Horrid colors for ninja. Camp should have stuck with furry fanfic. Too many Fred Wolf fans & not enough actual Mirage story fans working on the book. Whoever above said basically this is correct. IDW is a furry fanfic lovefest of the FW era which was already barely proper turtles.
ChosenOne
03-05-2022, 10:26 AM
There is actual TMNT fan fiction written by Sophie Campbell from years ago.
There is actual TMNT fan fiction written by Sophie Campbell from the past two years, too.
Sumac
03-05-2022, 10:39 AM
I don't like Campbell's art... its bland & when colored by Camp, also too... neon is not the right word... pastel. Horrid colors for ninja. Camp should have stuck with furry fanfic. Too many Fred Wolf fans & not enough actual Mirage story fans working on the book. Whoever above said basically this is correct. IDW is a furry fanfic lovefest of the FW era which was already barely proper turtles.
I don't think even FW fans would write this crap. FW fans more about fun, less about "rights of oppressed perverts furries".
MikeandRaph87
03-05-2022, 11:41 AM
I don't like Campbell's art... its bland & when colored by Camp, also too... neon is not the right word... pastel. Horrid colors for ninja. Camp should have stuck with furry fanfic. Too many Fred Wolf fans & not enough actual Mirage story fans working on the book. Whoever above said basically this is correct. IDW is a furry fanfic lovefest of the FW era which was already barely proper turtles.
Hold on there, I prefer the 1987 cartoon be the primary inspiration for the Turtles, but this comic is furry fiction plain and simple giving no TMNT fan what they want if sexually ambiguous mutants and the most hated character is being thrown in the mix. Asian cultures and environmentalism I can handle,but this...17 issues of Furry Town was enough to wait until Armageddon Game closes out this iteration.
Galactus
03-05-2022, 04:10 PM
By this logic I am more than qualified to be writer on any TMNT comic book and, of course, I am a MEGA OMEGA ALPHA SUPER HYPER TRUE FAN, because, I've made TMNT fan comic books and scripts, since I was 7 year old (and sometimes I still do them)!!! :lol:
In general, anything regarding "true fan" argument is a retarded argument.
There is no such thing as a "true fan" and anyone who calls them that is just either pretentious idiot or an arrogant poser.
Calling Campbell qualified just, because, he was writing stuff for TMNT on his free time is stupid. By this logic, you can pick up anyone from Fanfiction.net or other fansites and call them "qualified" as well.
The discussion here wasn't whether Sophie was qualified to professionally write the TMNT. It was whether she was a genuine fan and I think there is more than ample evidence to show she is a genuinely a fan of the property,
If we are going to discuss whether she's qualified to work on TMNT comics; She wrote and drew a number of creator owned comics which is presumably how she got the attention of Mirage to do covers for their Raphael mini series. She's worked on comics for Image, DC and other IDW titles. Her art and plotting on TMNT has always been popular which is probably why she got the gig as regular writer. You may not like her work but she's more qualified to write TMNT than some people that have worked on the property.
Most of them are either fans of FW, which as far removed from OG (and arguably really good) TMNT works as far as possible or retarded furry-shippers, who just want some canon material about humanoid animals ****ing each other brains out, because, those people are lonely virgins and missing few synapses.
Neither audience has anything to do with core TMNT stuff and shouldn't be listened to, when it comes to creating good and serious TMNT works.
This right after you give a lecture on there not being such a thing as a 'true' fan. Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm sure I've seen you advocate that future TMNT movies should be Fred Wolf cartoon based as that's the version most people care about (20 years ago you'd probably be right). The IDW book was already pretty Fred Wolf inspired and had a nothing is off limits thing going on in terms of incorporating characters from every version of TMNT...I mean Tom Waltz even used characters from Fast Forward and this was way before it was handed off to Sophie.
mrmaczaps
03-05-2022, 04:13 PM
Hold on there, I prefer the 1987 cartoon be the primary inspiration for the Turtles, but this comic is furry fiction plain and simple giving no TMNT fan what they want if sexually ambiguous mutants and the most hated character is being thrown in the mix. Asian cultures and environmentalism I can handle,but this...17 issues of Furry Town was enough to wait until Armageddon Game closes out this iteration.
I respect the cartoon for what it did to help the franchise but I abhor it in its entirety as "entertainment". A good chunk of the adventure series is straight up global warming propaganda... :tlol:
And I hate with a passion the color coding. Vol 1, issue 1 should be the basics of anything TMNT & go from there. First dozen or so Mirage issues would be fun if followed closely into a tri of movies, along with the Fugitoid one shot & the Triceratons. Could actually fit most of that into two movies then do a Return to New York & City at War for the 3rd film.
Allio
03-05-2022, 04:50 PM
is it strange a deviantart artist got to work officially on TMNT comics? She was just a fanart and fanfiction artist before she got hired professionally.
There is nothing wrong with Deviantart the website itself. It’s simply a place to post one’s fanart instead of creating one’s own website. Now while the content itself can be questionable, that just comes from how accessible the website is as a whole. It’s like Wattpad is for Writers, or Webtoons for comic artists.
Turtle Soup
03-05-2022, 06:18 PM
Yeah. And Rian Johnson is a "true blue" Star Wars fan, just ask him. That's why he made a movie that broke the entire mythos while making it a point to ruin every single thing anyone ever liked about it, in favor of his fanfiction ideas nobody wanted.
These people are all cut from the same cloth. "I'm a huge fan of ________ but what it REALLY needs is to be nothing like what anyone already likes about it. Then it'd be a lot better."
The Last Jedi is the 2nd best of the new SW movies, behind Rogue One.
MikeandRaph87
03-05-2022, 06:19 PM
I respect the cartoon for what it did to help the franchise but I abhor it in its entirety as "entertainment". A good chunk of the adventure series is straight up global warming propaganda... :tlol:
And I hate with a passion the color coding. Vol 1, issue 1 should be the basics of anything TMNT & go from there. First dozen or so Mirage issues would be fun if followed closely into a tri of movies, along with the Fugitoid one shot & the Triceratons. Could actually fit most of that into two movies then do a Return to New York & City at War for the 3rd film.
That reads like Stephen Murphy with Archie Comics TMNT Adventures.
I cannot for the life of me care about anything after The Shredder is dead for good after Return to New York. I need The Shredder and a reoccurring rogues gallery to care.
I also think the sexually ambiguous mutants of Mutant Town is somehow being confused with mutants who had actual names, identities, and something of a personality. Sure, TMNT (1987) had a high mutant count as the Mirage Comics and by extension the 2003 cartoon stuck with just Leatherhead outside of the four Turtles and Splinter. There needs to be a meet in the middle on that. Slash, Bebop, Rocksteady, and a couple of others that rotate per version. Slash can be the fifth turtle and no female Turtle needed. You are right that we don't need a high mutant count, but the characters need to be defined and have an impact on a story individually.
neatoman
03-05-2022, 06:50 PM
The Last Jedi is the 2nd best of the new SW movies, behind Rogue One.
That doesn't mean much when TFA, Solo and especially TROS are such crap movies to begin with.
CyberCubed
03-05-2022, 10:32 PM
I cannot for the life of me care about anything after The Shredder is dead for good after Return to New York. I need The Shredder and a reoccurring rogues gallery to care..
That's kind of odd to say since keeping Shredder around would make his character very repetitive. Outside of kids shows it never made sense for Shredder to be a recurring villain.
Sumac
03-06-2022, 06:48 AM
The discussion here wasn't whether Sophie was qualified to professionally write the TMNT. It was whether she was a genuine fan and I think there is more than ample evidence to show she is a genuinely a fan of the property,
Not quite sure if Campbell's current work can be a testament to that. :lol:
If we are going to discuss whether she's qualified to work on TMNT comics; She wrote and drew a number of creator owned comics which is presumably how she got the attention of Mirage to do covers for their Raphael mini series. She's worked on comics for Image, DC and other IDW titles. Her art and plotting on TMNT has always been popular which is probably why she got the gig as regular writer. You may not like her work but she's more qualified to write TMNT than some people that have worked on the property.
People change. Regardless of their accomplishments. It can be seen on example of many directors who were making masterpieces and this days produce only questionable works.
I am not particular familiar with Campbells' body of work, but I do not exclude that he once was a good artists and, possibly, writer. Whatever he has become nowadays - is whole another matter.
This right after you give a lecture on there not being such a thing as a 'true' fan. Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm sure I've seen you advocate that future TMNT movies should be Fred Wolf cartoon based as that's the version most people care about (20 years ago you'd probably be right). The IDW book was already pretty Fred Wolf inspired and had a nothing is off limits thing going on in terms of incorporating characters from every version of TMNT...I mean Tom Waltz even used characters from Fast Forward and this was way before it was handed off to Sophie.
It is really simple - those people are not fans at all. Or rather, they are not fans of TMNT.
I don't think I've ever advocated that future TMNT movies should be based on FW, I was saying that those movies are inevitability.
As for Waltz and Campbell, it is not about what they were doing in one single moment, but how it ended up as a whole.
I also think the sexually ambiguous mutants of Mutant Town is somehow being confused with mutants who had actual names, identities, and something of a personality. Sure, TMNT (1987) had a high mutant count as the Mirage Comics and by extension the 2003 cartoon stuck with just Leatherhead outside of the four Turtles and Splinter. There needs to be a meet in the middle on that. Slash, Bebop, Rocksteady, and a couple of others that rotate per version. Slash can be the fifth turtle and no female Turtle needed. You are right that we don't need a high mutant count, but the characters need to be defined and have an impact on a story individually.
Ideally I'd prefer mutant-less TMNT story or with as less appearance of other mutants as possible.
The Last Jedi is the 2nd best of the new SW movies, behind Rogue One.
My condolences to your taste.
mrmaczaps
03-06-2022, 04:18 PM
That reads like Stephen Murphy with Archie Comics TMNT Adventures.
I cannot for the life of me care about anything after The Shredder is dead for good after Return to New York. I need The Shredder and a reoccurring rogues gallery to care.
I also think the sexually ambiguous mutants of Mutant Town is somehow being confused with mutants who had actual names, identities, and something of a personality. Sure, TMNT (1987) had a high mutant count as the Mirage Comics and by extension the 2003 cartoon stuck with just Leatherhead outside of the four Turtles and Splinter. There needs to be a meet in the middle on that. Slash, Bebop, Rocksteady, and a couple of others that rotate per version. Slash can be the fifth turtle and no female Turtle needed. You are right that we don't need a high mutant count, but the characters need to be defined and have an impact on a story individually.
Shredder died in issue one. No further actual appearances of The Shredder happened. Clones & clone worms but no Shredder. As it should be... definitely too many mutants. Hard to make the guys unique if there are dozens of others around and gallons of ooze everywhere to make new ones at will... absolutely do NOT want more Braindead & Rockstupid. Love Leatherhead (Mirage version). Aliens are fine to add into the mix.
Sexually ambiguous is the way of most of these leftists "creators". Its lazy & quite stupid.
Andrew NDB
03-06-2022, 05:41 PM
Shredder died in issue one. No further actual appearances of The Shredder happened. Clones & clone worms but no Shredder.
Well... we'll see if "The Shredder" changes your mind. :)
Galactus
03-06-2022, 07:00 PM
Shredder died in issue one. No further actual appearances of The Shredder happened. Clones & clone worms but no Shredder. As it should be... definitely too many mutants. Hard to make the guys unique if there are dozens of others around and gallons of ooze everywhere to make new ones at will... absolutely do NOT want more Braindead & Rockstupid. Love Leatherhead (Mirage version). Aliens are fine to add into the mix.
It's pretty clear that the intention of Return To New York was that the Shredder the turtles fought in that story (and in Leonardo #1 and TMNT #10) was the actual Shredder given life again. That the worms rebuilt his body as soul was inside.
I believe the first mention that Saki was a clone was a letter to early Vol. 4 were a fan made a case for the idea they only fought the real Shredder once and Laird's response was something along the lines of "I've never thought of it that way but you could be right". So clearly prior to that Laird had intended the RTNY Shredder to be the real deal.
The Shredder Elite long put the idea in people's heads that worms must have been used for cloning since they all look like distorted clones of the Shredder but from design sketches and notes Laird has posted confirmed these were Foot Ninja that were also fed on by the worms. I guess they dressed like the Shredder for...reasons.
I suppose it's now as good as canon that version of the Shredder was a clone due to Murphy's Worms of Madness...still since that story also makes clear that the turtles thought the RTNY Shredder was the real deal even after finding out he was resurrected by the worms I'd prefer to put it down to a difference of philosophical opinion between the characters.
Sexually ambiguous is the way of most of these leftists "creators". Its lazy & quite stupid.
Has Sophie said that Jennika is supposed to be "sexually albiguous". I'm pretty sure she's canonically bisexual. Also are you down on left wing "creators" like Peter Laird and most of the Mirage crew?
mrmaczaps
03-07-2022, 11:22 AM
Has Sophie said that Jennika is supposed to be "sexually albiguous". I'm pretty sure she's canonically bisexual. Also are you down on left wing "creators" like Peter Laird and most of the Mirage crew?
I'm pretty Constitution or GTFO, so yeah. Leftists are fvcking nuts. Just straight facts.
hypered1
03-08-2022, 02:05 PM
New cover for #128:
https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT-128_Cover-A_rich-395x600.jpg
TigerClaw
03-08-2022, 04:03 PM
New cover for issue #127, Its a collaboration between Kevin Eastman and Sophie Campbell.
https://twitter.com/kevineastman86/status/1501311754370007040
UPDATE: The Cover for upcoming TMNT issue 127 Cover B is a collaboration with the AWESOME Sophie Campbell . @mooncalfe1 Hand colored by me #TMNT #TeamEastman
Sophie Campbell's response.
https://twitter.com/mooncalfe1/status/1501316389730242572
IT'S BEAUTIFUL. Such an honor!!! I'm flipping out!
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FNW7FJ2X0AM5Shi.jpg
Andrew NDB
03-08-2022, 04:27 PM
So a total of 1 frog foot and 1 frog arm. That looks like the only frog parts on her.
CyberCubed
03-08-2022, 04:54 PM
It's pretty clear that the intention of Return To New York was that the Shredder the turtles fought in that story (and in Leonardo #1 and TMNT #10) was the actual Shredder given life again. That the worms rebuilt his body as soul was inside.
I suppose it's now as good as canon that version of the Shredder was a clone due to Murphy's Worms of Madness...still since that story also makes clear that the turtles thought the RTNY Shredder was the real deal even after finding out he was resurrected by the worms I'd prefer to put it down to a difference of philosophical opinion between the characters.
I feel like Murphy's Tales issues with the shark Shredder make it obvious RTNY Shredder was a full-bred clone and the original was 100% dead as of the end of issue #1. Even if you say at the time PL/Kevin wrote Return to New York, I still don't think they intended it to be the original Shredder completely. It was left ambiguous when issue #10 happened.
I mean it doesn't really matter, but that's what it seemed like
Andrew NDB
03-08-2022, 05:02 PM
I feel like Murphy's Tales issues with the shark Shredder make it obvious RTNY Shredder was a full-bred clone and the original was 100% dead as of the end of issue #1. Even if you say at the time PL/Kevin wrote Return to New York, I still don't think they intended it to be the original Shredder completely. It was left ambiguous when issue #10 happened.
They definitely intended that to be the Shredder. It wasn't until it was brought up in the lettercol that Peter was like, "huh, I guess that wasn't technically him, you have a point."
And it's not quite just a clone. What is a clone? A clone is a memory-less duplicate of an original person or animal. An empty vessel. Now, if you make a clone and find a way to imbue it with all of the memories of the original... how would the clone be any different than the original? In the same way we "die" when we go to sleep and are "reborn" every morning that we wakeup? Only in Shredder's case, he died for real and was reborn within the shared consciousness of special worms that consumed his blown up remains. The difference is really academic, unless we get into debates about souls. And certainly that resurrected Saki had no reason to not believe he's Oroku Saki. Hell, he was grown from his real, original flesh that the worms ate. So in fact, it's less "cloning" that the worms did and more "put him back together" with basically a little bit of metaphoric glue.
mrmaczaps
03-08-2022, 05:51 PM
They definitely intended that to be the Shredder. It wasn't until it was brought up in the lettercol that Peter was like, "huh, I guess that wasn't technically him, you have a point."
And it's not quite just a clone. What is a clone? A clone is a memory-less duplicate of an original person or animal. An empty vessel. Now, if you make a clone and find a way to imbue it with all of the memories of the original... how would they clone be any different than the original? In the same way we "die" when we go to sleep and are "reborn" every morning that we wakeup? Only in Shredder's case, he died for real and was reborn within the shared consciousness of special worms that consumed his blown up remains. The difference is really academic, unless we get into debates about souls. And certainly that resurrected Saki had no reason to not believe he's Oroku Saki. Hell, he was grown from his real, original flesh that the worms ate. So in fact, it's less "cloning" that the worms did and more "put him back together" with basically a little bit of metaphoric glue.
That is certainly a different way of looking at it... but I'd still call it cloning and the worms being the way his identity & memories were transferred.
Andrew NDB
03-08-2022, 06:09 PM
That is certainly a different way of looking at it... but I'd still call it cloning and the worms being the way his identity & memories were transferred.
But there wasn't really any transferring going on. The memories were already there, in the bits of brain they nibbled on. Think, when Jason Voorhees get half his head blown off in Jason X, but then gets a nanite bath. Same basic idea, more or less. He wasn't suddenly a Jason clone, you see.
Zog The Magnificent
03-08-2022, 10:50 PM
I figured it was supposed to be that the first worm clone was more along the lines of "crudely put back together," but still the bona fide real Shredder with his soul and such, and that the Shark Shredder was a failed clone that only thought it was Shredder.
Andrew NDB
03-08-2022, 10:54 PM
I figured it was supposed to be that the first worm clone was more along the lines of "crudely put back together," but still the bona fide real Shredder with his soul and such, and that the Shark Shredder was a failed clone that only thought it was Shredder.
Yes on the first part. The Shredder Shark, more like... Saki was still in there a little but there wasn't enough of him left for the worms to make "live" anymore. So it was mostly "not Saki" at that point and mostly "shark brain." Like stitching 25% of someone's brain into the brain of someone who has been in a coma all their life, and suddenly woke up.
Zog The Magnificent
03-08-2022, 11:15 PM
Yes on the first part. The Shredder Shark, more like... Saki was still in there a little but there wasn't enough of him left for the worms to make "live" anymore. So it was mostly "not Saki" at that point and mostly "shark brain." Like stitching 25% of someone's brain into the brain of someone who has been in a coma all their life, and suddenly woke up.
I always was mildly confused by it. I don't entirely understand why it suddenly had a mental breakdown at the end of the story, compared to when it started. I guess it was because of the failed ritual or something, and then it combines with the Mystic, but then the next time we see it he has his original look, and is suddenly back to his regular Shredder personality. But then he dies right afterwards, so it doesn't really matter. Bottom line, I never fully understood exactly was supposed to be the deal with that thing.
Andrew NDB
03-08-2022, 11:58 PM
I always was mildly confused by it. I don't entirely understand why it suddenly had a mental breakdown at the end of the story, compared to when it started. I guess it was because of the failed ritual or something, and then it combines with the Mystic, but then the next time we see it he has his original look, and is suddenly back to his regular Shredder personality. But then he dies right afterwards, so it doesn't really matter. Bottom line, I never fully understood exactly was supposed to be the deal with that thing.
Different writers. You'll see it again, though (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1922374&postcount=213).
mrmaczaps
03-09-2022, 11:31 AM
But there wasn't really any transferring going on. The memories were already there, in the bits of brain they nibbled on. Think, when Jason Voorhees get half his head blown off in Jason X, but then gets a nanite bath. Same basic idea, more or less. He wasn't suddenly a Jason clone, you see.
The transfer is the worms being the "body" that now retains his consciousness or whatever. Akin maybe to growing clones for new body parts... the worms absorbed who/what Saki was & brought him back to life.
Coola Yagami
03-10-2022, 12:17 PM
The transfer is the worms being the "body" that now retains his consciousness or whatever. Akin maybe to growing clones for new body parts... the worms absorbed who/what Saki was & brought him back to life.
Wasn't Saki's reborn body literally thousands of worms clumped together to look like a human?
Andrew NDB
03-10-2022, 12:42 PM
Wasn't Saki's reborn body literally thousands of worms clumped together to look like a human?
Not exactly (and more like, "to become a human")... but technically yes. Looking, acting, and thinking like a human... the one whose remains they just consumed. If you look close at Saki's skin in Vol. 1, #21 you can see like big nasty pores all over it. But the worms did such a job that he was even able to grow a full head of hair. So we're talking flesh, skin, bones, hair follicles, eyeballs... this isn't simply a "bag of worms" walking around.
Coola Yagami
03-10-2022, 02:19 PM
Not exactly (and more like, "to become a human")... but technically yes. Looking, acting, and thinking like a human... the one whose remains they just consumed. If you look close at Saki's skin in Vol. 1, #21 you can see like big nasty pores all over it. But the worms did such a job that he was even able to grow a full head of hair. So we're talking flesh, skin, bones, hair follicles, eyeballs... this isn't simply a "bag of worms" walking around.
Been forever since I read those issues, I don't remember Return to New York dwelling too much on the worms other than 'this is how he came back'.
Weren't his remains eaten by a shark in the Tales follow up so now he was a human/shark hybrid? I think that one felt more worm heavy. Like in the Tales issue was it implied shredder basically fell apart into worms after he died? I seem to recall worms crawling around and Leo being grossed out by them, but this feels like a lifetime ago. Pre-Nick era even.
neatoman
03-10-2022, 02:33 PM
Well things might be getting a little off topic but **** it, why not?
So I have wondered, how do we know for sure that the Shredder who attacked April's apartment and the one killed by Leo were the same? Considering we see three failed attempts and given the later knowledge that the worms from the one Leo killed mutated further, there isn't much of a guarantee. So it should be possible that the one who attacked the apartment mutated into one of the three failures and the one who faced off against Leo is a replacement.
Coola Yagami
03-10-2022, 02:36 PM
Well things might be getting a little off topic but **** it, why not?
So I have wondered, how do we know for sure that the Shredder who attacked April's apartment and the one killed by Leo were the same? Considering we see three failed attempts and given the later knowledge that the worms from the one Leo killed mutated further, there isn't much of a guarantee. So it should be possible that the one who attacked the apartment mutated into one of the three failures and the one who faced off against Leo is a replacement.
You know, that's interesting. If the Saki that attacked the apartment mutated further but they got the worms to transfer what they could off him and onto Return to New York Saki, he'd have the same memories as if he were the one that nearly killed Leo.
Andrew NDB
03-10-2022, 03:21 PM
Weren't his remains eaten by a shark in the Tales follow up so now he was a human/shark hybrid? I think that one felt more worm heavy.
Because there was barely any Shredder remains to draw from at that point... and then suddenly the worms that were there assimilated a non-sentient shark's body and brain, adding that into the lion's share of things. Imagine you take 25% of your brain and consciousness -- only 25% -- and put that into a bear. It's not going to be you. It's going to be some kind of semi-aware mostly bear being.
So I have wondered, how do we know for sure that the Shredder who attacked April's apartment and the one killed by Leo were the same? Considering we see three failed attempts and given the later knowledge that the worms from the one Leo killed mutated further, there isn't much of a guarantee. So it should be possible that the one who attacked the apartment mutated into one of the three failures and the one who faced off against Leo is a replacement.
No, not possible. When Saki has his chat with Leo in Vol. 1, #21, he says "Three early experiments you met on your way here... the fourth time they fed on me. They ate, and began to think and act as one... form one structure... one being. I stood... grotesque... alive!!"
The key word there is "I." Not "the worm person before me stood."
neatoman
03-10-2022, 05:02 PM
No, not possible. When Saki has his chat with Leo in Vol. 1, #21, he says "Three early experiments you met on your way here... the fourth time they fed on me. They ate, and began to think and act as one... form one structure... one being. I stood... grotesque... alive!!"
The key word there is "I." Not "the worm person before me stood."
I went back and checked before I posted and I double checked to respond here.
He never directly claims to be the same clone as the Shredder from the Leo Micro, just that he is the fourth clone. There isn't a line like "when I attacked the apartment" that would confirm Clone 4 is indeed the one who attacked the apartment. He does however say "you saw me die" in reference to the real Oroku Saki, who he obviously isn't.
Sure, this is a question of interpretation and Clone 4 is probably meant to be the one who attacked the apartment. However, since the lines of Clone 4 are ambigious, don't have direct confirmation and Clone 4 referred to the original as himself, we can't know for certain.
Coola Yagami
03-10-2022, 05:25 PM
I think one of the most interesting things regarding clones and copies and all that was the teletransportation used in the IDW series. Where Fugitoid explains you pretty much die and a copy of you is recreated in the location you're being teleported to, with all and memories and stuff as if it were you.
It reminds me a bit of Rick and Morty where if you kill Rick a clone of him wakes up and continues exactly where he left off.
Andrew NDB
03-10-2022, 06:43 PM
He never directly claims to be the same clone as the Shredder from the Leo Micro
But why would he? That isn't a thing that's ever been in dispute.
just that he is the fourth clone. There isn't a line like "when I attacked the apartment" that would confirm Clone 4 is indeed the one who attacked the apartment.
Why would he suddenly start talking about the apartment? And would there even be enough blasted remains of Saki from Vol. 1 #1 to create two 100% self-realized Saki clones with perfect memory? The one itself seems a miracle.
neatoman
03-10-2022, 06:46 PM
I might also add that the "Worm Cloning" thing might be example of weaker writing in the Mirage books. While stories leading up to this reveal could have shown the Foot experimenting on worms or literally have given it any sort of foreshadowing whatsoever, the mutant clones just kind show up right before Shredder reveals he is a clone made of worms. It's not entirely awful, at least there was some mystery to how he rose planted into the mind of the reader, given what an obvious non-survival scenario his death in issue 1 was. The actual explanation however just sort of comes out of nowhere, I mean seriously, was there anything about the Foot having mutant worms or cloning tech before issue 21?
Andrew NDB
03-10-2022, 06:51 PM
I might also add that the "Worm Cloning" thing might be example of weaker writing in the Mirage books. While stories leading up to this reveal could have shown the Foot experimenting on worms or literally have given it any sort of foreshadowing whatsoever, the mutant clones just kind show up right before Shredder reveals he is a clone made of worms. It's not entirely awful, at least there was some mystery to how he rose planted into the mind of the reader, given what an obvious non-survival scenario his death in issue 1 was. The actual explanation however just sort of comes out of nowhere, I mean seriously, was there anything about the Foot having mutant worms or cloning tech before issue 21?
Of course not. I think Peter said he just read something about worms (https://nautil.us/decapitation-but-not-cannibalism-might-transmit-memories-1204/#:~:text=Half%20a%20century%20ago%2C%20experiments ,of%20another%20by%20eating%20it.) and they ran with it to explain the resurrection.
In fact, #21 might be the first spot its even hinted the Foot have high tech stuff and possibly mystic stuff going on. Until here they are just Saki's endless horde of Foot Soldiers.
Donnie
03-10-2022, 06:59 PM
Opining that Venus is not liked is a generalized garbage statement. Nobody cares if you hate Venus like most bandwagon "fans." The fact is that the Next Mutation had some excellent storylines they just weren't executed to their full potentials. Venus works as a character for all the reasons Andrew pointed out earlier in the thread. I don't give a **** about the IDW comics anymore, but I had to say my piece of Venus because I'm tired of all the casuals hating on TNM. Those Turtle designs had some really cool elements to them, the characters were interesting and they explored facets of each Turtle's personality, it was friggin' LIVE ACTION... I could go on. The writing was sound, but not properly executed at all times in the acting and tone. And some of those episodes are funny as hell.
The Next Mutation has its place in TMNT history.
neatoman
03-10-2022, 07:03 PM
But why would he? That isn't a thing that's ever been in dispute.
Why would he suddenly start talking about the apartment? And would there even be enough blasted remains of Saki from Vol. 1 #1 to create two 100% self-realized Saki clones with perfect memory? The one itself seems a miracle.
I think you're kind of missing the point. The point isn't that there ought to be multiple successful clones, it's just that there could be. I don't care if there are more than one, that probably wasn't the intention. What I'm questioning is the assumption that only one successful clone was made. If they had been talking about the apartment attack, that would be confirmation that he is indeed the same individual who attacked. The way it is written, he obviously isn't prompted to talk about it. Of course if Leo had something like "I've waited for this since you attacked us!" or something to that effect, it would have spurred it on. As for the amount of worms needed to make a successful clone, we need to remember here that we are talking about a fictional concept here, it is whatever the writer decides it is. If it's only possible to make one successful clone, fine. But in order for there to be no room for another interpretation, that the mutants could have seemed successful initially before they mutated or they made multiple successful ones in secret, that needs to made absolutely clear which it isn't.
Again, Clone 4 is probably meant to be one who attacked the apartment and the mutants are most likely just failures, you are right about that. But let's say I were to write a sequel to this story, what happened in canon would prevent me from writing it so that there were two or more seemingly successful clones?
Andrew NDB
03-11-2022, 12:27 AM
Again, Clone 4 is probably meant to be one who attacked the apartment and the mutants are most likely just failures, you are right about that. But let's say I were to write a sequel to this story, what happened in canon would prevent me from writing it so that there were two or more seemingly successful clones?
Nothing. You could easily fandangle that angle, if you wanted. Like, have another Saki step out of the shadows and explain how it was him in the apartment fight, but not him during RTNY? Do I understand that right? Yeah, that could work. Personally, I'd like Round 3 with Shredder and the Turtles to be with a Saki that remembers that last fight. Every stroke. Every wound. If you make it someone else, it would just be a new Round 2.
Because I am writing a sequel to this story, and that's what happens. :)
Sumac
03-11-2022, 02:04 AM
Opining that Venus is not liked is a generalized garbage statement. Nobody cares if you hate Venus like most bandwagon "fans." The fact is that the Next Mutation had some excellent storylines they just weren't executed to their full potentials. Venus works as a character for all the reasons Andrew pointed out earlier in the thread. I don't give a **** about the IDW comics anymore, but I had to say my piece of Venus because I'm tired of all the casuals hating on TNM. Those Turtle designs had some really cool elements to them, the characters were interesting and they explored facets of each Turtle's personality, it was friggin' LIVE ACTION... I could go on. The writing was sound, but not properly executed at all times in the acting and tone. And some of those episodes are funny as hell.
The Next Mutation has its place in TMNT history.
Oh boy, we have someone who thinks that TNM had good storylines. :ohwell:
Now I've seen everything.
Donnie
03-11-2022, 10:04 PM
Oh boy, we have someone who thinks that TNM had good storylines. :ohwell:
Now I've seen everything.
Never saw you around these parts, looks like you joined up for the Nick Turtles. Sounds like a typical, generic, lackluster response for somebody who probably hasn't been into TMNT their whole lives like die-hards like myself.
NM did have well-written, interesting story lines. Venus's origin alone is interesting. Donatello's need for a scientific relationship with Queeze. Michelangelo throwing a party full of humans because he wants to be accepted; his radio show as means of societal interaction which he so craved.
You don't know Turtles if you can't wrap your little brain around NM having good storylines that just weren't always wonderfully executed.
BASED post, are you a secret alt account of sdp? :lol:
I love everything about Venus and TNM
Hell yeah brother.
Leo656
03-12-2022, 12:08 AM
If you were around more you'd be aware that Sumac's TMNT preferences are on-record as being the FW cartoon and at least the early seasons of the 4Kids show.
A person isn't a n00b or a know-nothing simply because they find Next Mutation vapid or lacking in merit. To be blunt, that's how most people feel about that show. Even most people who claim affection for it do so ironically; i.e. "It's so bad it's good".
This "Next Mutation actually wasn't terrible!" stuff is just Internet People doing the "Hot Take" bullsh*t. I was around for the launch, I remember the hype on the school bus when we all raced home from school to watch the first episode, and how the next morning on said school bus we all collectively agreed never to speak of it again.
Not one person on planet Earth ever said that show was "good" until it became fashionable to do the whole "Ummmm, ACTUALLY..." thing on message boards and social media.
Love it sincerely if you want to, it doesn't bother me. But to say or imply that anyone who hates it is either a noob or a nitwit is disingenuous. Let's not.
neatoman
03-12-2022, 06:21 AM
Uh, yeah. The Next Mutation is total ****ing garbage, it is an example of why quality isn't entirely subjective when it comes to art and media, anyone who claims to like it is either lying, has problems or is blinded by a very peculiar sense of nostalgia.
Pointless cartoon sound effects everywhere, dubbing that needlessly went from english to english, clip shows despite only lasting 26 episodes in total, bad puppetry, recycled footage showing off the vehicles (it's not even something cool like robots combining like in Power Rangers), bad digital effects and more than enough times where the camera work makes it difficult to tell what is even going on. Look at that, I didn't even need to bring up the writing or acting to say that it sucks, that was all just editing, SFX and camera work. You know a show sucks when not even the camera work is decent. As for the writing, yeah that sucks too. Shredder's desire to be evil is allegedly purged in the first episode and somehow that doesn't mean "Turn the Foot to a righteous path" or "Shredder finds peace", instead it means "Shredder becomes a bitter hobo who still wants to be evil", like what the ****?
As bad as the Fred Wolf cartoon is, I can at least say I can understand most of what happens in it, even if it's stupid and/or full of filler scenes. And at least nostalgia for that one makes sense, it was a big fad and was basically on for nine years, TNM was hated from the start and only got one season.
Sumac
03-12-2022, 07:09 AM
If you were around more you'd be aware that Sumac's TMNT preferences are on-record as being the FW cartoon and at least the early seasons of the 4Kids show.
Might add original movie, Secret of the Ooze, 2007 and Forever to that list. :D
Never saw you around these parts, looks like you joined up for the Nick Turtles. Sounds like a typical, generic, lackluster response for somebody who probably hasn't been into TMNT their whole lives like die-hards like myself.
Wow, easy mate, you are trying to impress with your status of long time "TruE fan" so much, that I might start suspecting you yourself joined the fandom right about 2k3 end! :lol:
For your consideration I watched THM just a year or two after its premier and it was garbage back than and it is still garbage now. And I strongly dislike both Nick series, so you are off the mark, kid.
NM did have well-written, interesting story lines. Venus's origin alone is interesting. Donatello's need for a scientific relationship with Queeze. Michelangelo throwing a party full of humans because he wants to be accepted; his radio show as means of societal interaction which he so craved.
You don't know Turtles if you can't wrap your little brain around NM having good storylines that just weren't always wonderfully executed.
You are either heavily delusional or a troll.
This arguments sound literally like someone trying to justify why Bayformers are good and have a really deep storyline.
Donnie
03-12-2022, 08:29 AM
Might add original movie, Secret of the Ooze, 2007 and Forever to that list. :D
Wow, easy mate, you are trying to impress with your status of long time "TruE fan" so much, that I might start suspecting you yourself joined the fandom right about 2k3 end! :lol:
For your consideration I watched THM just a year or two after its premier and it was garbage back than and it is still garbage now. And I strongly dislike both Nick series, so you are off the mark, kid.
You are either heavily delusional or a troll.
This arguments sound literally like someone trying to justify why Bayformers are good and have a really deep storyline.
Haha, kid? I’m sure I’m older than you, guy. Been a die hard fan since the 80s, which I can say with confidence you have not been. You’re basically just rewording what I said to you; this is a lazy attempt at a retort with no substance. And I loathe the Bay turtles.
Trolls don’t have thousands of posts and long standing history here, bozo. I could make the same childish accusation of you - you’re a troll who doesn’t take TNM seriously on any level because the general mass of TMNT “fans” like to dismiss and hate on TNM for no good reason other than they are followers, bandwagon fans, not the real thing, saw the Nick TMNT and thought “oh boy I used to like the OT, this sure is cool!”
There’s nothing delusional about recognizing TNM had strong character development and well-written, thoughtful storylines, but unfortunately they weren’t always executed correctly or maturely due to many factors including direction and acting. The show was funny, too. Since you’re clearly a simpleton who ignored the character points I’ve already said, I won’t try to convince your newbie self anymore. And don’t “woah mate” me, you responded to my post with a sarcastic, meaningless, fluff reply that just proved the stereotype of the general “fan” I’m talking about. Hating on TNM because you don’t know any better. Or your little brain can’t open your mind to different viewpoints.
Your type reminded me why I stayed away from this place for years: toxic fake fans.
Sumac
03-12-2022, 11:08 AM
Haha, kid? I’m sure I’m older than you, guy. Been a die hard fan since the 80s, which I can say with confidence you have not been. You’re basically just rewording what I said to you; this is a lazy attempt at a retort with no substance. And I loathe the Bay turtles.
You are so adamant about using your "hardcore TMNT fan card" to assert your dominance in the discussion - it is pathetic, kid.
It doesn't matter how much time you were fan of the Turtles, 20 or 30 years, if your opinion is objectively out of there, it will stay that way.
Trolls don’t have thousands of posts and long standing history here, bozo. I could make the same childish accusation of you - you’re a troll who doesn’t take TNM seriously on any level because the general mass of TMNT “fans” like to dismiss and hate on TNM for no good reason other than they are followers, bandwagon fans, not the real thing, saw the Nick TMNT and thought “oh boy I used to like the OT, this sure is cool!”
Are you seriously pulling out "number of posts" card?! Like for real? :lol:
Damn, amazing. You are a comedy incarnate, dude.
Also, as I said before, I watched TNM few years after its premier, long before I got access to forums and have learnt what other TMNT fans think of this show, so my opinion is my own and not influenced by anything.
Also, I don't parrot opinions to fit in. Not my MO.
There’s nothing delusional about recognizing TNM had strong character development and well-written, thoughtful storylines, but unfortunately they weren’t always executed correctly or maturely due to many factors including direction and acting.
:teek::teek::teek:
I am starting to think you've dropped from some other dimension.
The show was funny, too.
If you were 5 year old, maybe.
But even FW, for all its childishness managed to be ahead of TNM, when it came to humor and general execution. Its not a high bar to clear, but still.
Since you’re clearly a simpleton who ignored the character points I’ve already said, I won’t try to convince your newbie self anymore. And don’t “woah mate” me, you responded to my post with a sarcastic, meaningless, fluff reply that just proved the stereotype of the general “fan” I’m talking about. Hating on TNM because you don’t know any better. Or your little brain can’t open your mind to different viewpoints.
Chill out. Its like a mere questioning your opinion a cardinal sin or something. Grow a thick skin and eat some anchovy and milk pizza, dude.
What I am trying to say no-one tries to still your Venus sleeping pillow, mate! :lol:
Your type reminded me why I stayed away from this place for years: toxic fake fans.
Now I am sure you a troll.
P.S.
I have more posts than you. :P
MikeandRaph87
03-12-2022, 12:08 PM
Look guys, Donnie is in the minority within fandom. He sees the good points of The Next Mutation. I think its crap though the concept of Venus and everything associated with her in particular. I blame her and Image for the dark period of 1998 to 2002. Among elite fans like us I am in the minority of fandom who thinks just like Next Mutation that Image is a horrible piece of crap that I choose to ignore as I do with Next Mutation. Despite more people liking Image than don't that post here on Technodrome Forums it is a highly disliked incarnation of the franchise overall. Let him have his opinion. He explained himself rather well and I can understand his opinion even if I do not agree with it I do respect it.
People were saying the series was turning around with #125 with the introductions of The Punk Frogs, Groundchuck, and Dirtbag. Notable characters who are finally appearing (though with Campbell involved I wanted them to not), but with Venus being introduced overdoing the female turtle bit and intertwining her with The Punk Frogs (who should not been any more than four males) suggest to me that IDW may not be listening to us fans like has been suggested.
Sumac
03-12-2022, 01:05 PM
I am not against his opinion per se, I myself have opinions about TMNT some people won't share here.
But I don't see why a mere comment about an unusual opinion warrants diatribe about "number of posts", "true and fake fans" and number of years person had spent as part of the fandom.
hypered1
03-12-2022, 01:07 PM
Oh, IDW are listening to the fans all right, just not the toxic mouth-breathers that infest this forum.
I've not read/ watched TNM or the Image run myself so I have no opinion on them either way, however if there's one thing that's constant among the voices here it's that a lot of people here are ridiculously resistant to change which itself is stupid considering that change is one of the main themes of the franchise.
TheJ-manTurtleMan
03-12-2022, 01:15 PM
Is there a preview yet for #127?
MikeandRaph87
03-12-2022, 01:25 PM
Is there a preview yet for #127?
https://leagueofcomicgeeks.com/comic/5438103/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-127?variant=9483597
According to League of Comic Geeks #127 has been pushed back to the same day as the fifth annual, March 30th. That being said it will not have a preview until the Friday before March 25th.
If the annual is not covering Armageddon Game does the free comic book day offering or is that supposed to cover Franken-Venus?
ChosenOne
03-12-2022, 03:10 PM
Oh, IDW are listening to the fans all right, just not the toxic mouth-breathers that infest this forum Twitter.
Now, now... If that were true, we wouldn't have got two whole years of furry fan fiction content under the guise of a TMNT comic. (Which are now behind us, thankfully.)
Venus has been a Frankenstein monster of an idea since day one, so it's nice of IDW to acknowledge that fact in a very literal way.
Sumac
03-12-2022, 05:47 PM
Oh, IDW are listening to the fans all right, just not the toxic mouth-breathers that infest this forum.
I've not read/ watched TNM or the Image run myself so I have no opinion on them either way, however if there's one thing that's constant among the voices here it's that a lot of people here are ridiculously resistant to change which itself is stupid considering that change is one of the main themes of the franchise.
There are good changes and bad changes, and if you have not noticed it, "ear-breather", majority of changes with this franchise were, quite recently, for the bad.
Unless you are a fun of the "Hulk-turtles" or a furry ****er.
hypered1
03-12-2022, 06:52 PM
There are good changes and bad changes, and if you have not noticed it, "ear-breather", majority of changes with this franchise were, quite recently, for the bad.
Unless you are a fun of the "Hulk-turtles" or a furry ****er.
I hate the Bay films and I'm not a furry, you're 0/2.
I'm just more open minded and not stuck in the past like some people.
Leo656
03-12-2022, 07:06 PM
Sumac, you're talking with people who think anyone with a dissenting opinion is a "Toxic Mouth-Breather", you think they're gonna get it? Jesus, guy. :lol: You got way more faith in these people than I do.
I also cannot stand the fact that people are only "allowed" to have a strong opinion on a subject so long as it's positive. Like, f*cking NO with that. People are allowed to hate things, and if they can articulate exactly What and Why, then all the better for it. I personally don't give a sh*t if someone agrees with me so long as their dissenting opinion makes sense and isn't just Blatant Nonsense and Bullsh*t. If it IS that, I call them a moron because an opinion with no substance is hot air and worth nothing. But if they make a valid point, then fine, agree to disagree. But "You don't like what I like and so you're 'toxic' and all that sh*t"? No, go f*ck your ass with that.
But no, man, people are allowed to want TMNT in their TMNT comics, and to want to see them doing Ninja Turtle things. They're allowed to not want a bunch of lesbian fanfic self-insert characters making kissy-face to take up more space than Ninja Turtles Doing Ninja Turtle Things in a Ninja Turtles Comic. As I've posited before, maybe some of these concepts and characters belong somewhere else, like in a spin-off mini-series, and if there REALLY is an audience for it then it should still sell just fine. And if there's not, it won't sell, and we'll all know for sure just how popular all this stuff Is or Isn't because the numbers will hash it out in black and white. But I think most people would prefer to see this stuff somewhere else. Some people would probably prefer it disappear completely, but I'll allow for the fact that perhaps the concepts have an audience and a place, just not this specific arena. I have a feeling most people would have a less-hostile opinion of the subject matter if it wasn't in the main TMNT book.
But even if they just plain hate it altogether... they're allowed to feel that way and not be called names about it. This "Only Gushing and Positive Opinions Are Valid" stuff the younger kids do nowadays? That's not "discourse", it's just bullsh*t circle-jerking.
Also? To pull a card from this younger generation's playbook, calling someone a "mouth-breather" is offensive to those of us who were born with chronic sinus conditions. So please, check your f*cking privilege you tofu-eating hypocrites. :trazz:
neatoman
03-12-2022, 07:25 PM
I hate the Bay films and I'm not a furry, you're 0/2.
I'm just more open minded and not stuck in the past like some people.
OK? Weird argument, has very little to do with determining quality. It is true that people can sometimes be resistant to change and I disagree with Sumac a lot, but changes can be very bad, it's not always rooted in mere discomfort. It is sad that some people feel the need to simply say the current run sucks because it's basically a furry comic or feel the need to bring up any personal details about Sophie to criticise it, makes it too easy to dismiss even legit criticism of the book as people "being stuck in the past" or "hateful bigots".
But let's not kid ourselves here, Sophie's run sucks. It sucks for very fundamental reasons and it isn't worth defending. Not that excuses bad behaviour but it's not like we need to say cow dung smells good because someone threw a rock at the cow (I seriously can't think of an established proverb here, I hope the metaphor makes any sense).
Well, back to the discussion regarding TNM, you should know it is is bad. Like it is really bad. It is so bad that despite hearing nothing but negative opinions about for years before I bothered to watch it, it was even worse than I expected. Yes, I went in with the lowest expectations possible and it still didn't meet them, if that isn't a mark of something that sucks I don't know what is. If you want proof that art can be objectively bad, TNM is a pretty good place to start looking for it.
lonewarrior20
03-13-2022, 12:08 AM
I really feel the people on this board should take this to heart.
https://64.media.tumblr.com/2d3df58625388081393ce85543a3715f/ac882afaebc692ae-67/s500x750/67e878dd055ecb7e40eb65bcbf9a3c47ae808950.jpg
Leo656
03-13-2022, 12:52 AM
Not when the Likers call the Not-Likers idiots and "toxic" and other dumb stuff, no.
Everyone gets an opinion. People are allowed to Not Like things you like. That's life. People need to accept that not every difference of opinion is a f*cking personal attack. People defending cartoons and TV shows as if they were their children, because someone else has the audacity to say out loud, "I think that thing sucks." Jesus.
Anyone who cannot handle an open exchange of dissenting opinions needs to go back to the sandbox and stay there. That goes WAY beyond Ninja Turtles and into some Real Life Sh*t about being mature enough to handle that not everyone in life will agree with you.
Sumac
03-13-2022, 03:26 AM
I hate the Bay films and I'm not a furry, you're 0/2.
I'm just more open minded and not stuck in the past like some people.
Eating any **** labeled TMNT that creators throw your way, is not being open-minded, its being desperate and having a bad taste.
Coola Yagami
03-13-2022, 03:59 AM
I really feel the people on this board should take this to heart.
https://64.media.tumblr.com/2d3df58625388081393ce85543a3715f/ac882afaebc692ae-67/s500x750/67e878dd055ecb7e40eb65bcbf9a3c47ae808950.jpg
Naw. If they openly admit they like something stupid, they can expect to be told they like something stupid. Sure, some people will agree with them, but they need to be prepared that not everybody will.
If they're just enjoying it and minding their own business, sure, no one will know, no one will care. It becomes a problem when they open their mouth about it expecting everyone to agree with them.
mrmaczaps
03-13-2022, 07:00 AM
Eating any **** labeled TMNT that creators throw your way, is not being open-minded, its being desperate and having a bad taste.
I really don't normally agree with Sumac, but this exactly. Some of you would enjoy stop motion turds shaped like turtles if someone made it and called it TMNT... and then say stupid things like "stuck in the past"... Have a little discernment. Just because the tmnt label is on it, does not make it enjoyable, good or worth my time and/or money... like Campbell's run on tmnt or rise or even tnm.
neatoman
03-13-2022, 08:52 AM
I really feel the people on this board should take this to heart.
https://64.media.tumblr.com/2d3df58625388081393ce85543a3715f/ac882afaebc692ae-67/s500x750/67e878dd055ecb7e40eb65bcbf9a3c47ae808950.jpg
Ah yes, the last refuge for people with bad taste...
ChosenOne
03-13-2022, 10:28 AM
I really feel the people on this board should take this to heart.
https://64.media.tumblr.com/2d3df58625388081393ce85543a3715f/ac882afaebc692ae-67/s500x750/67e878dd055ecb7e40eb65bcbf9a3c47ae808950.jpg
Well, let me tell you something, this is exactly how Nazi Germany started!
Coola Yagami
03-13-2022, 11:11 AM
This reminds me of when the first BayTurtles movie came out and do many people felt the need to say it was good, as if they would have to turn in their TMNT fan card and be banned off the forum it they said otherwise.
Leo656
03-13-2022, 11:24 AM
Haha, and then they started a Private Group for the sole purpose of talking sh*t about me. :lol: Fun times.
Coola Yagami
03-13-2022, 11:33 AM
Haha, and then they started a Private Group for the sole purpose of talking sh*t about me. :lol: Fun times.
Your heel run back then was legendary.
Leo656
03-13-2022, 11:39 AM
...I wasn't aware it ever stopped.:lol: Did I accidentally turn babyface at some point? Or like Nash am I just too cool to boo anymore?
Coola Yagami
03-13-2022, 12:15 PM
...I wasn't aware it ever stopped.:lol: Did I accidentally turn babyface at some point? Or like Nash am I just too cool to boo anymore?
By now you've reached the status where you can kick a baby into the crowd and they'll still cheer you man. You've become the cool heel.
ChosenOne
03-13-2022, 12:45 PM
This reminds me of when the first BayTurtles movie came out and do many people felt the need to say it was good, as if they would have to turn in their TMNT fan card and be banned off the forum it they said otherwise.
If you pretend they're human-sized and a guy in regular armor respectively, the Turtles vs Shredder showdown is legit one of the best in the entire franchise, though. Still doesn't make up for the rest of the movie but it's damn good on its own.
By now you've reached the status where you can kick a baby into the crowd and they'll still cheer you man. You've become the cool heel.
Could even shoot someone on Fifth Avenue at this point.
Leo656
03-13-2022, 01:53 PM
Could even shoot someone on Fifth Avenue at this point.
...Who says I haven't? :trazz:
ChosenOne
03-13-2022, 03:07 PM
...Who says I haven't? :trazz:
Good point. 2024 awaits!
Leo656
03-13-2022, 03:19 PM
Vote Roxx 2024! "Most politicians just TALK about grabbing 'em by the pussy, but Rikki Roxx walks the walk!"
Turtle Soup
03-13-2022, 06:12 PM
Most of the TMNT stuff that's come out in the last several years has been ******, yes. But also, this forum is quite obviously very toxic. Doesn't take more than browsing a few threads to see that. Peter Laird probably sold TMNT because he read a few posts on this forum.
Leo656
03-13-2022, 07:25 PM
Naaaaaaaah. Most of the time it's more like a bunch of guys at the bar talking sh*t and giving each other a hard time.
hypered1
03-14-2022, 03:35 AM
If it were a seedy dive bar in a redneck hick-town maybe.
ChosenOne
03-14-2022, 08:57 AM
LMAO at the people who badmouth this fine establishment while finding excuses to not finish their beer so they can keep hanging out with the guys. :lol:
Leo656
03-14-2022, 10:47 AM
LMAO at the people who badmouth this fine establishment while finding excuses to not finish their beer so they can keep hanging out with the guys. :lol:
Riiiiiiiiight? :lol:
AquaParade
03-14-2022, 11:20 AM
LMAO at the people who badmouth this fine establishment while finding excuses to not finish their beer so they can keep hanging out with the guys. :lol:
I feel like this was your experience reading the IDW TMNT book. :lol:
ChosenOne
03-14-2022, 11:31 AM
I feel like this was your experience reading the IDW TMNT book. :lol:
So you're allowing that Campbell's run was as toxic as some claim this forum is? Just so we're all on the same page. :lol:
hypered1
03-14-2022, 12:14 PM
So you're allowing that Campbell's run was as toxic as some claim this forum is? Just so we're all on the same page. :lol:
That's not what he's saying at all.
And he's right, you previous comment could just as easily refer to the people on here who continually complain about the current run in the comics when they could nay should be doing something far more constructive with their apparent abundance of time.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 12:27 PM
Which does nothing to change the fact that people who like Campbell's run really ought to have better taste and there's really no excuse for their lousy opinions.
People can say "You're so mean" but I'd argue that having awful taste is way worse than someone saying mean things. Like, I can hang out with mean people. I can't hang out with people who like black licorice or the music of The Grateful Dead. Sh*t's inexcusable, I won't enable it.
ChosenOne
03-14-2022, 12:37 PM
That's not what he's saying at all.
You people don't like it one bit when the shoe's on the other foot. Noted.
Jephael
03-14-2022, 03:28 PM
This is why I miss the creative side of the TMNT fan base. If we didn't like where the comics, movies or TV shows were going, we'd just write our own stories and head-canons. That's the beauty of fiction. And I know, Leo that you don't agree with me on this, but basically people are free to do whatever they want with these characters, even if it's just a fan fiction or fan art. Even stuff fans come up with don't always line up with each other. Me and Andrew worked on a couple of his stories together and we didn't always see eye to eye on how it was to be presented, but it still came out good.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 05:21 PM
I write silly fanfiction too, difference between me and some people is I'm not charging anyone four bucks an issue to read it.
I'm also well aware that the stuff I do fanfiction of is not in any way, shape or form what TMNT fans want to read in a consumer product. Some typical feedback I've gotten is (paraphrasing) "If this were a comic it'd be terrible but as 'just' a self-contained piece of fiction it's actually pretty good." If I ever were in a position to write a TMNT comic, I definitely wouldn't be using my fanfic ideas as the basis. It "works" in its own space but it wouldn't work as a product people pay for.
A lot of what I write is character drama and slice-of-life, too, so believe me, I totally get what Campbell is going for. It's just not proper for the context it's in. That kind of stuff is SO BORING to read on a monthly basis and especially in the context of what has always been an action-focused franchise.
In broad strokes, yes, "anyone can do what they want to do because it's all fiction." Except that completely ignores how disrespectful to the paying customer that is, to repeatedly ignore what they ask for and tell them "No, like what I'm doing or leave." If you're Dire Straits, you don't go onstage and obstinately refuse to play "Money For Nothing" just because you're sick of playing it; your obligation is to the paying customer and they paid to see the hits. Giving them blue-balls under the guise of "being creative" is an incredibly sh*tty thing to do to your audience.
So no, when people are supposed to pay you four bucks or whatever per issue for your "art", you do NOT get to do "whatever you want". You please the crowd or get off the goddamn stage. Otherwise, stay on DeviantArt and ff.net like the rest of us who are maybe "talented" but not necessarily great at making consumer art. You can't just jack off for two whole years while people are impatiently asking you to hurry up and get to the point already.
MikeandRaph87
03-14-2022, 06:08 PM
You can't just jack off for two whole years while people are impatiently asking you to hurry up and get to the point already.
I have accepted that Tom was burned out and focused on downsizing his focus to The Last Ronin and while The Last Ronin was produced to The Armageddon Game Campbell was meant to spin the wheel until the last arc was ready following the end of the Last Ronin limited series. In other words, Campbell was meant to keep it going nowhere until Tom was ready to write The Armageddon Game.
Galactus
03-14-2022, 06:16 PM
If the Mutant Town stuff had been say a 25 issue arc. I'm sure it would have been much better received. It's only been comparatively recently that there has been any real backlash against it.
I suspect that probably was the original plan Tom Waltz returning and Jennika and the better received characters sticking around or maybe spun off into their own thing. Either the early positive reaction to Campbell's and/or the success of The Last Ronin has meant that Sophie's had to extend her plans.
For me personally I can't get too worked up about it. While it's had a few stories I've really enjoyed the IDW book as a whole has always been just 'okay' for me and still remains just 'okay'. I don't even think Campbell's run is even that different to Waltz's. The book has always been very eager to fill up it's roster with cute animal mutants most of which ported over from every other iteration of the franchise. This is just the ultimate evolution of the approach. Heck I'd say it was almost inevitable they'd bring Venus back, heck they even teased it in that glimpse of the future were incidentally she looked a lot more like her traditional Next Mutation design which may be slight cause for hope for the fans who don't like her Frankenstein-inspired design.
Coola Yagami
03-14-2022, 07:19 PM
If the Mutant Town stuff had been say a 25 issue arc. I'm sure it would have been much better received.
Try 5, and that's pushing it. They should have moved on to other arcs leaving mutant town in the background, or feature it more in Jennika's minis or something.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 07:31 PM
Yeah, it's been about two years and people have been complaining for well over a year, so to say the backlash is "recent" isn't really accurate.
neatoman
03-14-2022, 07:35 PM
Yeah, people have been annoyed with this since at least 110. It was probably earlier than that but after 110 it had definitely overstayed it's welcome.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 07:42 PM
I mean is it even "slice of life" or "a breather arc" if it never ends and just keeps going?
It's like a four-hour brunch. It's not "brunch" anymore, it's just "lunch" now. Stop it.
Galactus
03-14-2022, 07:46 PM
I have little doubt that some people disliked it from the start. Any major change in the status quo is going to get fans riled up. There was definite fans from the jump and a lot were willing to 'enjoy the ride' until the status quo was restored.
Maybe it's observation bias but I've only started seeing youtubers get upset about recently. There's probably a few reasons for that but mainly that TMNT is no longer that monetizable. Since the franchise started it's downward spiral after the failure of Out Of The Shadows TMNT just doesn't generate the clicks. Even now I'm not sure that perpetual outrage machine has really riled people up to the extent the were able to get people upset about Kevin Smith supposedly woke MOTU series.
neatoman
03-14-2022, 08:09 PM
I mean is it even "slice of life" or "a breather arc" if it never ends and just keeps going?
It's like a four-hour brunch. It's not "brunch" anymore, it's just "lunch" now. Stop it.
The sad thing is that there are ways of creating the illusion of something happening without moving the plot along.
Considering how many things have been left on the side, it shouldn't be hard to write a series of irrelevant side stories. So let's say we had something like this:
Krang tries to reconnect with the Utroms but fails because Leatherhead won't let him.
Karai deals with trying to get some Splinter loyalists or something under control.
A day in the lives of the orphans living with the Fugitoid.
Ch'rell thinking back on his war days.
The Turtles going back to Stump Wrestling.
Dreadmon surviving alone out in the woods by himself.
Null doing further mutation experiments.
Revisiting one of the alternate timelines created by Bebop and Rocksteady.
Baxter Stockman dealing some cover up of his criminal activities.
The EPF doing experiments on the Dragon's carcass.
Manmoth on a hunting trip.
Xiang breaking out of prison.
The Neutrinos dealing with the fallout of Maligna's invasion.
Ace Duck doing some mercenary work.
Assuming these are one issue each, that is over a year's worth of content I managed pull out my ass right now. I didn't even need to look up anything that could work, these were all fairly easy to think of. Sure, they would still be filler stories but at least there would be some variety and illusion of substance...
mrmaczaps
03-14-2022, 08:19 PM
Yeah, people have been annoyed with this since at least 110. It was probably earlier than that but after 110 it had definitely overstayed it's welcome.
Its been annoying since issue 103. The entire run could be shortened into maybe 8 issues.
Bahamut810
03-14-2022, 08:43 PM
Try 5, and that's pushing it. They should have moved on to other arcs leaving mutant town in the background, or feature it more in Jennika's minis or something.
I think this right here would have been the best of both worlds. Have main TMNT, then spin off a Jennika in Mutant-town comic that cross over occasionally.
MikeandRaph87
03-14-2022, 09:01 PM
I think this right here would have been the best of both worlds. Have main TMNT, then spin off a Jennika in Mutant-town comic that cross over occasionally.
Yes, and I concur about it being a single arc and ending with the Turtles reunited after separately dealing with Splinter's sacrifice. The first arc was bad, especially #103. The pandemic cutting it off at that point and indication that it was one arc and we move on to dangling plot threads hurt it to. It built up false promise within me that ultimately failed to deliver. Stretching a bad thing that gets worse the more it's stretched. Keep going organically and give a side show to Jennika as protector of Mutant Town instead of Sheriff Raphael and let the numbers show we don't care.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 09:02 PM
What the f*ck even happened in Jennika's two (Jesus...) mini-series?
Whatever it was... something tells me it wasn't worth the real estate.
MikeandRaph87
03-14-2022, 09:11 PM
What the f*ck even happened in Jennika's two (Jesus...) mini-series?
Whatever it was... something tells me it wasn't worth the real estate.
Bebop and Rocksteady faked a cure for Mutant Town residents in the 1st one.
In the second one Jennika helped a girl who was separated from her mutated mother, who had hired her to kill her husband to take over his mob faction.
In other words you missed absolutely nothing as nothing has happened since #100.
Leo656
03-14-2022, 09:24 PM
So they couldn't just move the filler arcs to the spin-off minis because the spin-off minis were doing their own filler arcs which were adjacent to the main book's filler arc?
Jesus Christ. Kevin Nash booked WCW more competently than these people book their TMNT franchise.
And these IDW folks don't even have to worry about forcing Thunder to make sense. So that's pretty inexcusable on their end.
MikeandRaph87
03-14-2022, 09:35 PM
So they couldn't just move the filler arcs to the spin-off minis because the spin-off minis were doing their own filler arcs which were adjacent to the main book's filler arc?
Jesus Christ. Kevin Nash booked WCW more competently than these people book their TMNT franchise.
And these IDW folks don't even have to worry about forcing Thunder to make sense. So that's pretty inexcusable on their end.
You have to read the tie in comics to make sense of the NwO soap opera. Only what do you do when it's a comic book? :lol:
I am still waiting for The Armageddon Game. It's the long promised last hope.
ChosenOne
03-15-2022, 07:36 AM
I am still waiting for The Armageddon Game. It's the long promised last hope.
Putting all our hope in Armaggedon. What a decade.
AquaParade
03-15-2022, 08:54 AM
You people don't like it one bit when the shoe's on the other foot. Noted.
Lol, what? You’ve been reading a book that griefs you more than pleases you for years now. You actually pay to get pissed off and don’t seem to realize it, when you're calling people out for hanging around an establishment they don’t like. That’s comedy.
As for the book itself, I haven’t read it in years, because I don’t enjoy it. I just find the situation amusing. Your dollars, but I had to point out the obvious there.
Jephael
03-15-2022, 09:59 AM
when people are supposed to pay you four bucks or whatever per issue for your "art", you do NOT get to do "whatever you want". You please the crowd or get off the goddamn stage.
Okay so as a TMNT fan base what exactly do we want? We've been dancing around this subject for years now and all that ever comes out of it is "We want the Ninja Turtles we grew up with!" The problem is we never go into better detail about exactly what we want from those classic stories.
Also while I'm on the subject, one of my biggest pet peeves is when you ask people what they do want and all they do is rant about what they don't want. I bloody hate that! It's called a TO DO list, not a WHAT NOT TO DO list.
ChosenOne
03-15-2022, 12:01 PM
Lol, what? You’ve been reading a book that griefs you more than pleases you for years now. You actually pay to get pissed off and don’t seem to realize it, when your calling people out for hanging around an establishment they don’t like. That’s comedy.
As for the book itself, I haven’t read it in years, because I don’t enjoy it. I just find the situation amusing. Your dollars, but I had to point out the obvious there.
I paid because I knew the comic would get back on track eventually (and because I'm a friggin' completionist with a serious addiction to collecting anything and everything, you wouldn't like me when I'm collecty), after all the time and money I'd already sunk into it. And it did. My hope paid off. Whereas the Campbell groupies' only hope is in deluding themselves that she's a good writer, since everyone else sees right through the lie.
And you mean my euros.
Plus, this comic helped see me through the death of two loved ones in 2011 and 2016, when I most needed something to look forward to month after month. Don’t expect me to give up on it so easily.
hypered1
03-15-2022, 01:40 PM
I get what you're saying regarding wanting the complete collection, I'm the same, but it was made very clear that #101 was going to be a big shift in direction for the comic ahead time so much so that Tom and Bobby literally said it was intended as a jumping on/off point for fans old and new.
There was never any deceit or deception that Sophie's run would be very different from came before, heck even the tpbs were rebranded (and to a lesser extent the hardbacks are also presented slightly differently) to reflect these changes.
I'd even go as far as to say that everything encompassed within the first 13 hardbacks is a complete run of the IDW/ Tom Waltz comics and I've even said previously that Sophie's run probably should have been labelled/ marketed as IDW volume 2.
So honestly I get it that you want to stick with the series to see it to completion - I've got enough thorns digging into my sides from previous series or collections I have to drop before they ended to know full well that kind of irritation - but there was ample warning ahead of time of the changes that were coming and sticking with something out of sheer hubris isn't worth it in the long run to anyone's mental or financial wellbeing.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 02:06 PM
I get what you're saying regarding wanting the complete collection, I'm the same, but it was made very clear that #101 was going to be a big shift in direction for the comic ahead time so much so that Tom and Bobby literally said it was intended as a jumping on/off point for fans old and new.
No way they said it was a "jumping off" point. Did they?
hypered1
03-15-2022, 02:20 PM
No way they said it was a "jumping off" point. Did they?
Yes, they absolutely did say that.
Leo656
03-15-2022, 02:28 PM
Because telling people who are already giving you money, "We don't need or want you anymore" is brilliant business. Talk about "hubris"! Jesus.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 02:41 PM
Can you show me a quote? Because I can't believe that. That's not even just "saying the quiet part out loud," that is like the polar opposite of salesmanship.
I worked in sales a long time and I can't even fathom telling a customer, "We're giving you a jumping off point." Unfathomable.
hypered1
03-15-2022, 02:50 PM
Can you show me a quote? Because I can't believe that. That's not even just "saying the quiet part out loud," that is like the polar opposite of salesmanship.
I worked in sales a long time and I can't even fathom telling a customer, "We're giving you a jumping off point." Unfathomable.
It was somewhere on here during the run up to issue 100, can't recall exactly which thread it was and I'm not about to trawl 3 years worth of posts to find it because no one has that kind of time to waste.
And at any rate Bobby also expressed similar candour in several of the post-100 letters pages to the effect that it's ok to step away from something that you're no longer enjoying (ie: the current run) and that maybe a future iteration/ arc would be more appealing to the persons writing said letters.
MikeandRaph87
03-15-2022, 02:52 PM
It was somewhere on here during the run up to issue 100, can't recall exactly which thread it was and I'm not about to trawl 3 years worth of posts to find it because no one has that kind of time to waste.
And at any rate Bobby also expressed similar candour in several of the post-100 letters pages to the effect that it's ok to step away from something that you're no longer enjoying (ie: the current run) and that maybe a future iteration/ arc would be more appealing to the persons writing said letters.
Sophie Campbell told me that in a PM when I inquired her about the characterization of Tokka and Razhar just ahead of their first issue.
Leo656
03-15-2022, 03:01 PM
Can you show me a quote? Because I can't believe that. That's not even just "saying the quiet part out loud," that is like the polar opposite of salesmanship.
I worked in sales a long time and I can't even fathom telling a customer, "We're giving you a jumping off point." Unfathomable.
Considering all the people in the comics industry who suspect that IDW will be going out of business fairly soon, we can safely assume that "salesmanship" and "doing smart business" aren't things IDW is overly concerned with.
"We just wanna score points with pink-haired weirdos on Twitter and Tumblr" is apparently their business model. And by all accounts they all seem perfectly happy to go down with the ship.
Glad it's not my money.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 03:14 PM
Maybe it was meant ironically? Maybe the higher-ups (higher than Bobby) insisted on changes to make TMNT more cutesy and LGBTQy and Bobby and Tom just shrugged and were like, "Eh. Hey, if you guys want to jump ship, we really don't blame you" to the fans? That would make some semblance of sense.
I just can't believe either Bobby or Tom would behave that way to the fandom, the "don't like it? There's the door" kind of attitude. They've always seemed better than that to me.
hypered1
03-15-2022, 03:19 PM
Maybe it was meant ironically? Maybe the higher-ups (higher than Bobby) insisted on changes to make TMNT more cutesy and LGBTQy and Bobby and Tom just shrugged and were like, "Eh. Hey, if you guys want to jump ship, we really don't blame you" to the fans? That would make some semblance of sense.
I just can't believe either Bobby or Tom would behave that way to the fandom, the "don't like it? There's the door" kind of attitude. They've always seemed better than that to me.
As speculative as that is I can't deny that it could be a possibility, particularly as Bobby himself has since left the company, but there isn't really anything definitive either way.
neatoman
03-15-2022, 03:45 PM
" The sciences, each straining in its own direction, have hitherto harmed us little; but some day the piecing together of dissociated knowledge will open up such terrifying vistas of reality, and of our frightful position therein, that we shall either go mad from the revelation or flee from the light into the peace and safety of a new dark age.
...
The Thing cannot be described—there is no language for such abysms of shrieking and immemorial lunacy, such eldritch contradictions of all matter, force, and cosmic order."
MikeandRaph87
03-15-2022, 03:49 PM
Here it is:
'I'm familiar with the old Tokka & Rahzar episode of the cartoon but honestly I never liked that version of them that much! I like that they're such good friends and Rahzar is upset at Tokka getting captured and all that but I don't like that they're well-spoken adults, I feel like the whole concept of Tokka & Rahzar is them being children and not fully aware of what they're doing!
Regardless, though, we work further ahead on the story and the issues I'm doing with them in it are already written, so I can't really go back in and change their characterization or anything like that. Sorry!! I'm already working on the proposal for issues 118-121, so IDW Tokka and Rahzar are pretty much set in stone at this point. That doesn't mean that future writers couldn't take them in a direction more like their old cartoon versions, though, so you may get your wish one day. In the meantime know that other creators will take the reins after me and if you don't like my flavor don't drink it.'
TheJ-manTurtleMan
03-15-2022, 04:52 PM
The only way I read Campbell's TMNT is while i'm listening to The Greateful Dead and enjoying some black licorice.
Jephael
03-15-2022, 05:07 PM
Because telling people who are already giving you money, "We don't need or want you anymore" is brilliant business. Talk about "hubris"! Jesus.
Can you show me a quote? Because I can't believe that. That's not even just "saying the quiet part out loud," that is like the polar opposite of salesmanship.
I worked in sales a long time and I can't even fathom telling a customer, "We're giving you a jumping off point." Unfathomable.
Try working at McDonald's for a couple of years. We constantly get customers leaving in a huff saying that they're never coming back. Most of my managers be like "Don't let the door hitcha in the @$$ on the way out. Next, please!"
That's kind of the nature of the entertainment business. They could care less when long time fans are unhappy. Heck, I'm willing to bet there are fans of the Marvel comics who've read them since Spider-Man made his first big debut but they probably hate all of the movies that have come out, even the ones Sam Raimi made due to some big change, like omitting Gwen Stacy and replacing her with Mary Jane Watson in the famous bridge scene.
There's always going to be changes made to these characters, some for better and some for worse, but we each have our own personal opinions on these matters. There were things I didn't like about the 2012 cartoon, like how the Turtles were constantly butting heads with each other, especially in the first season. Like okay, I got that they were new to working as a team, but it just felt like they didn't trust each other very much for whatever reason, which to me felt very uncharacteristic of them.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 05:08 PM
Try working at McDonald's for a couple of years.
I did. When I was 16.
Jephael
03-15-2022, 05:09 PM
I did. When I was 16.
Well, I'm 41 and mentally retarded. What're ya gonna do?
hypered1
03-15-2022, 05:12 PM
Well, I'm 41 and mentally retarded. What're ya gonna do?
A jobs a job and income is income, there's no shame in how you earn it.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 05:14 PM
Well, I'm 41 and mentally retarded.
Whoa, since when? I thought you just had a CHARGE thing.
neatoman
03-15-2022, 05:14 PM
A jobs a job and income is income, there's no shame in how you earn it.
... Are you sure that's good general advice? I mean... I can think of quite a few things you can do for money but shouldn't...
Jephael
03-15-2022, 05:15 PM
Whoa, since when? I thought you just had a CHARGE thing.
That's what the R in CHARGE stands for, dude. Each letter represents a specific disability. Lucky for me it was just a mild case.
Andrew NDB
03-15-2022, 05:17 PM
Lucky for me it was just a mild case.
Just a dusting of it, then? Well that's good.
Jephael
03-15-2022, 05:19 PM
Just a dusting of it, then? Well that's good.
The funny part is I think I only have it in one half of my brain because my right eye and right ear both work perfectly, while on the left side they aren't up to full capacity. I used to have a hearing aid and glasses as a kid.
hypered1
03-15-2022, 05:19 PM
... Are you sure that's good general advice? I mean... I can think of quite a few things you can do for money but shouldn't...
Lol, fair point. Guess I should've said an honest job is an honest job instead!
red1981
03-16-2022, 10:12 PM
The funny part is I think I only have it in one half of my brain because my right eye and right ear both work perfectly, while on the left side they aren't up to full capacity. I used to have a hearing aid and glasses as a kid.
eleven years ago i was diagnosed with a type of brain cancer that most people dont live more then six months with, and i went through experimental surgery and took chemo that wasent approved in the usa, it was a bad year thinking i was going to die at any time well im still alive but the surgery caused brain damage that makes it hard for me to do many things in life, i cant work makes it hard for me to even type but i still do it even though its not so great but i really like the turtles since i was a kid and when i was sick the idw comic line gave me some good reading material
Leo656
03-16-2022, 10:39 PM
That's a bummer. Sorry to hear that.
red1981
03-16-2022, 10:53 PM
That's a bummer. Sorry to hear that.
this comic is my hobby in my opinion i think this venus will be treated better then that bad power rangers wanna be show
AquaParade
03-17-2022, 04:16 AM
eleven years ago i was diagnosed with a type of brain cancer that most people dont live more then six months with, and i went through experimental surgery and took chemo that wasent approved in the usa, it was a bad year thinking i was going to die at any time well im still alive but the surgery caused brain damage that makes it hard for me to do many things in life, i cant work makes it hard for me to even type but i still do it even though its not so great but i really like the turtles since i was a kid and when i was sick the idw comic line gave me some good reading material
That’s wild. Glad you’re still around and here with us.
red1981
03-18-2022, 11:31 PM
That’s wild. Glad you’re still around and here with us.
glade i can be part of this forum, i wish more people where reading the idw line because of me my brother and two friends are now big readers of the comic
neatoman
03-19-2022, 07:33 AM
glade i can be part of this forum, i wish more people where reading the idw line because of me my brother and two friends are now big readers of the comic
Did they get into it before or after you did?
MattOnWheels
03-23-2022, 04:44 PM
Im not going to say anything regarding the discourse here other than I look forward to Venus, personally, and have been enjoying the comic for the mosr part. If that means I have bad taste to some, fine. Im not going to attack anyone for not liking it. I think there's room for everyone here.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.