PDA

View Full Version : Last Ronin ending


neatoman
04-27-2022, 06:11 AM
Can't believe there wasn't a thread. Anyway, here's what happens:

Mike has a conversation with the hallucinations of his brothers and when he relises they are not of any help they go away.
Mike goes into Hiroto's headquaters and kills all the guards and eventually faces off against two very powerful opponents.
April is trapped in a flooded sewer and Casey Marie has to go and rescue her.
Mike comes face to face with Hiroto, who uses a nanomachine version of the Shredder armor, declares that he hates his mom, kills her and starts to fight Mike.
Mike finds holes in the armor and uses the weapons of his brothers to attack Hiroto and eventually it looks like he's done in by Leo's sword.
Hiroto manages to slice Mike in the stomach, the two are forced down a sewer and into a drainage ditch where they continue to fight.
Hiroto seemingly drowns in the mud and Mike can't recover from his wounds.
Casey Marie laments that she can't continue her training with him and he tells her to know peace.
Mike either has an death hallucination or goes to an afterlife where he is back in the past with his family and Casey.
The epilogue shows that April is in the process of creating four new mutant turtles, with a "to be continued" capping it off.


I liked it but I'm not sure I'd call what the characters do in the epilogue the right thing.

AquaParade
04-27-2022, 07:59 AM
The epilogue was one of the more interesting parts to me. I actually think it’s sort of poetic that a new beginning may have found it’s way in.

As for the the rest of the issue, it was okay. I think this series started stronger than it ended. Everything felt like it had to wrap up too quickly and it felt a bit messy. The layouts weren’t up to the golden standard of Return to New York.

I’d say that it got the job done and did leave me excited to see what comes next. Definitely a good looking issue, but, yeah, felt a bit messy.

Awesome mini-series, overall. Glad it happened. Not one of the very best tmnt comics but a great one, and the first authentic-feeling one in a long time. Thanks to the whole team.

Weapons@theready
04-27-2022, 10:35 AM
Series as a whole would have benefited from fleshing Oroku Hiroto more. Also, the time between issues really took me out of my initial excitement. Overall I enjoyed it but those are my two main issues with the series as a whole

AquaParade
04-27-2022, 11:02 AM
Series as a whole would have benefited from fleshing Oroku Hiroto more. Also, the time between issues really took me out of my initial excitement. Overall I enjoyed it but those are my two main issues with the series as a whole

Agreed. And I couldn't help but wonder if they had alternate plans for Karai at one point.

jestergoblin
04-27-2022, 11:22 AM
Just finished.

I loved the line:

"Our bloodline is the shared mutagen that runs through our veins."

But so much of the book felt like The Dark Knight but with TMNT, down to the fight in the mud - I'm shocked we didn't see Ronin ride a horse.

Sumac
04-27-2022, 11:23 AM
Will the new Turtles in a Ronin-verse have the same names or they will be named after different artists or maybe scientists or whatnot? Providing, if there is any continuation in the first place...

Andrew NDB
04-27-2022, 11:29 AM
This seems like the water spitting moment:

The epilogue shows that April is in the process of creating four new mutant turtles, with a "to be continued" capping it off.

And I suspect it's more to add a glimmer of light to what is a pretty bleak ending on paper than any interest in actually doing: TMNT: The Next Generation in a Post Apocalyptic Future.

Also, are we supposed to look very far into April's "long-term exposure to mutagen"? Because it kind of reads like a Turtle f***ed April and then April f***ed Casey. Or she f***ed a Turtle somewhere in the middle of it all.

And not much of a curtain call for Hiroto. He dies in a small explosion off-panel (it's his suit that explodes, right? yet he looks pretty OK right after, as in intact and not messed up or bloody), then just sort of is laid in the mud? Must be more Nick censorship or sticky notes going on here because this is a super tame and almost blood-free finale and no way the way Eastman wanted it to be in 1987.

AquaParade
04-27-2022, 12:08 PM
This seems like the water spitting moment:



I suspect it's more to add a glimmer of light to what is a pretty bleak ending on paper than any interest in actually doing: TMNT: The Next Generation in a Post Apocalyptic Future.

Also, are we supposed to look very far into April's "long-term exposure to mutagen"? Because it kind of reads like a Turtle f***ed April and then April f***ed Casey. Or she f***ed a Turtle somewhere in the middle of it all.

And not much of a curtain call for Hiroto. He dies in a small explosion off-panel (it's his suit that explodes, right? yet he looks pretty OK right after, as in intact and not messed up or bloody), then just sort of is laid in the mud? Must be more Nick censorship or sticky notes going on here because this is a super tame and almost blood-free finale and no way the way Eastman wanted it to be in 1987.

Didn't Saki go out in a similar way in issue #1? Donatello whacked him and he fell into his own grenade or something.
I agree that it didn't feel as epic as something like RTNY Part 3, but I don't see much reason to believe there was editorial interference, when we've already seen gallons of blood in this series, particularly issue #2. Even this issue made a point to highlight that Mikey was assassinating mobs of human foot ninja.

I think what I find sort of disappointing is the lack of a real thematic element to the book. I thought there would be something to say about the cycle of revenge that has dominated the turtle's and Saki's lives. Didn't really go there.

I don't want to sound too down on the book, I just had high expectations. At the end of the day, it's still one of the best modern comic books I've read in a good while. Refreshing compared to much of what has been on the market.

Allio
04-27-2022, 12:21 PM
Kind of a ethical question of what seemingly forcing mutation on those four turtles. What happens if they gain sentience and hate the freak that they were turned into


Also, are we supposed to look very far into April's "long-term exposure to mutagen"? Because it kind of reads like a Turtle f***ed April and then April f***ed Casey. Or she f***ed a Turtle somewhere in the middle of it all.



Nothing like that. She describes it like how in Static Shock how Richie gains his powers because he was around Virgil that was still emitting the chemicals that gave him his powers.

Basically April and Casey had been around radiated people that they essentially got a secondhand high.

Andrew NDB
04-27-2022, 12:36 PM
Didn't Saki go out in a similar way in issue #1? Donatello whacked him and he fell into his own grenade or something.

Yeah, but Saki was literally blown up. As in, into little bits of bloody kibble and gore and bits of armor.

This Hiroto guy explodes but... doesn't? Like, at all? It reads very tame and neutered on the page, his exit there. No, I can't believe that's Eastman's vision for that at all and there was absolutely some compromise there with Nick, 100%.

Basically April and Casey had been around radiated people that they essentially got a secondhand high.

I don't think it's ever been said in any universe that I'm aware of that the Turtles have radiation, or that the ooze is radioactive. People seem to assume that, but I've not seen anything that it is.

Leo656
04-27-2022, 12:42 PM
Also pretty sure that's some of the junkiest junk science that's ever been attempted even for this shoddy franchise, regardless.

But I like Andrew's "Spider-Man: Reign"-inspired theory the best so let's just assume that's what happened. :lol: After April realized she was "just" a magical sketch, and well after she went back in time and had cockroach sex in a cockroach body, let's just say she said "F*ck it" and finally decided to give in to the longstanding curiosity she absolutely always had about what a romp with a mutant turtle would be like. Why the f*ck not? "It's not inter-species, she's just a drawing!" :lol:

Coola Yagami
04-27-2022, 12:51 PM
Also pretty sure that's some of the junkiest junk science that's ever been attempted even for this shoddy franchise, regardless.

But I like Andrew's "Spider-Man: Reign"-inspired theory the best so let's just assume that's what happened. :lol: After April realized she was "just" a magical sketch, and well after she went back in time and had cockroach sex in a cockroach body, let's just say she said "F*ck it" and finally decided to give in to the longstanding curiosity she absolutely always had about what a romp with a mutant turtle would be like. Why the f*ck not? "It's not inter-species, she's just a drawing!" :lol:

*April gets gangbanged by all 4 Turtles at once* "I'm not a whore, I'm a drawing so it doesn't matter! Keep telling yourself that O'Neil!"

AquaParade
04-27-2022, 12:51 PM
Did they just drop the "secondary mutation" thing?

Andrew NDB
04-27-2022, 02:28 PM
But I like Andrew's "Spider-Man: Reign"-inspired theory the best so let's just assume that's what happened. :lol: After April realized she was "just" a magical sketch, and well after she went back in time and had cockroach sex in a cockroach body, let's just say she said "F*ck it" and finally decided to give in to the longstanding curiosity she absolutely always had about what a romp with a mutant turtle would be like. Why the f*ck not? "It's not inter-species, she's just a drawing!" :lol:

But I mean, what's more likely?

A) That radiation from the mutagen in the Turtles' bloods somehow leaked into April from the air, even though in 35 years we've never heard of there being radiation in the mutagen or the Turtles and no one has ever gotten "infected" by them by proximity before.

or

B) Sometime over the years one of the Turtles made a deposit into April and the mutagen leaked into her that way. And then the Case-Man, that dirty dog, picked up one of the Turtles' sloppy seconds rawhide-style. Maybe these events were even simultaneous. Sick little monkeys.

Leo656
04-27-2022, 02:38 PM
Both of those scenarios are infinitely more likely than me ever using Spoiler tags, or showing any respect whatsoever to the Spoiler-sensitive. That much I can say with great certainty.

Weapons@theready
04-27-2022, 03:53 PM
The ongoing crew is getting ideas for Mutant Town

CyberCubed
04-27-2022, 04:50 PM
It almost seemed like it was all going to be a dream of Michelangelo by the end. Despite the "To be continued" I don't think this will get a sequel. It took way too long for this mini-series to come out. The art was really nice and the story ended as you expected it too, nothing special but it was fine. They wasted a bit too many pages with the flooding of the sewers and April/Casey being underwater though, most of it was just filler.

I'm not sure what took this series so long to come out, it all should have been done by last year as a quick mini-series.

AquaParade
04-27-2022, 05:12 PM
There will definitely be a sequel or prequel. Possibly both. It’s too successful.

neatoman
04-27-2022, 06:16 PM
Can't believe I have to deal with this ******** and I seriously hope this is just a joke... No, I seriously do not think April and Casey got contaminated from turtle semen, I don't think that is the intention and if you seriously think that is the most plausible explanation, I'm not sure sure you understand how semen works. The mutagen is not DNA, it alters DNA but it isn't DNA itself, the Turtles themselves did not need to get covered in semen to be mutated in the first place. While I don't think there is any direct mention of the mutagen being a radioactive substance in any previous iteration (though I think 4Kids implied it and it certainly is in the upcoming Seth Rogen movie), this does not exclude it from being radioactive in this version. The mutagen being radioactive in nature being a common assumption is fair because:

Radioactive substances are proven to be mutagenic in nature. Granted, in real life they do not typically produce desirable results and more often than not they're quite undesirable, but they do cause mutations.
The comic book tradition TMNT draws upon had a tendency to use radioactivity as a crutch. Daredevil, Hulk, Spider-Man, Fantastic Four, Captain Atom, Negative Man and quite a few other characters got their power from radiation. Granted, by the time the TMNT rolled onto the scene it was starting to become an outdated concept but it still happens even to this day.

Even if we assume it's not radioactivity we are still talking about two people spending a lot of time around these mutants. If there is enough mutagenic substance released from skin flakes, breathing or any other form of bodily byproduct they can still get in contact with that. It's the reason someone allergic to dogs can stand right next to a dog outside for hours without noticing any problem but getting inside a room where a dog has spent a lot of time will cause problems.

... Why do I keep going out of my way to argue about this kind of thing?...

The ongoing crew is getting ideas for Mutant Town

Uh, what does this have to do with Mutant Town? Last Ronin is clearly part of a self-contained continuity, it has nothing to do with the IDW continuity or Mutant Town. The mutagen even seems to be operating under Mirage rules where it only makes humanoids instead of hybrids.

It almost seemed like it was all going to be a dream of Michelangelo by the end. Despite the "To be continued" I don't think this will get a sequel. It took way too long for this mini-series to come out. The art was really nice and the story ended as you expected it too, nothing special but it was fine. They wasted a bit too many pages with the flooding of the sewers and April/Casey being underwater though, most of it was just filler.

I'm not sure what took this series so long to come out, it all should have been done by last year as a quick mini-series.

I wouldn't exactly call it a cliffhanger, yeah the "to be continued" does imply the intention to continue it but I see it more as an open ending. This story isn't exactly demanding a continuation aside from those last three words.

Allio
04-27-2022, 07:10 PM
Overall a decent ending. Since ultimately does come down having to split Mikey up from the other characters to have his one-on-one. Only downside of that is that the subplot did feel kind of forced just to have the one-on-one.

superstaff
04-28-2022, 07:00 AM
Is it just me or is the reception not super glowing for the ending?

I'm not really seeing much fanfare for the ending, mostly just "yeah, ok, it ended, cool."

I am seeing debates about mutant turtle semen, however.......

Leo656
04-28-2022, 07:13 AM
All roads lead to spooge. :lol:

"Circle of Life", or... something.

In all seriousness, to cover something someone else said earlier about the series feeling like it started hotter than it ended... that's honestly most things. For one thing, it's hard to sustain momentum, for another, Endings Are Hard, and three, we're hardwired to be more critical of Endings than Beginnings because the ending is the last thing you see, therefore, it's going to be the most recent thing on your mind and the last thing you dwell upon.

Unless you come up with the ending first, and work backwards from that, it is incredibly difficult to have The Ending be the best and most powerful moment of any story. This is why most wrestling matches are booked with the finish first and everything building towards it; you want the very last thing people see to be the most memorable.

But most stories are not written that way. Some are, most aren't. But it's really the only way to have the ending be the "best" or most satisfying part.
-----------

Plus, I don't have the numbers but between delays and just The Way Things Are, a ton of buzz fell off as the series went on and I wouldn't be shocked if a ton of people who picked up the first one or two issues were not there for the ending. They may have completely stopped paying attention to the release dates so they may not even know it finally came out.

For TMNT fans this was a Big Huge Deal, but for most people it was just one of several comics they pick up. Gotta remember that as well.

AquaParade
04-28-2022, 09:04 AM
I think the ending was slightly disappointing, but it's still dominating sales charts - both issue #5 and now the hardcover collection - so I think most people stuck with it.

I wouldn't agree with the notion that this was a big deal for TMNT fans, but no one else, unless we are counting "casual" tmnt fans, who came out and supported this thing in droves all the way through. I guess it would have to speak to just how many TMNT fans are still out there, waiting for good stories. Financially, it's nothing less than a huge success.

Mexiun
04-28-2022, 09:49 AM
Is it just me or is the reception not super glowing for the ending?

I'm not really seeing much fanfare for the ending, mostly just "yeah, ok, it ended, cool."

I am seeing debates about mutant turtle semen, however.......

I have that personally with myself though, i was beyond hyped for the issue but once it ended i was like "Alright thats cool" and just... yeah, moved on.
It was unexpected that i was like that though, i did tell my girlfriend all about it but thats it.

AquaParade
04-28-2022, 09:56 AM
My wild guess is that Kevin, himself, spent too much time tinkering with #5, back and forth, until it ended up as a "muddy brown" color, metaphorically.

Or Kevin took on too much work at once, and just exhausted himself, while trying to wrap this up. It's no secret that he's been behind on this book, since the day it was announced (not his fault), and all the while, he's been apparently turning in work for other tmnt projects, whether that's Neca box art, stuff for his website, or whatever other tmnt ventures he gets into.

I actually feel like each issue of this series was worse than the previous issue. #1 & 2 started out extremely sharp, and by issue #5, it was just "pretty good".

Those Escorza brothers really are great though. I love the texture and detail to their pencils.

Andrew NDB
04-28-2022, 10:39 AM
Or there was a big fiasco with Nick and approvals. Art and content had to be changed, etc. No way in hell was that ending what was originally envisioned.

And I think Kevin's involvement in this is overstated a little. Sure it's mostly his story synopsis with Peter from 1987 (and I do believe the story is mostly Kevin's, as he's mainly the Frank Miller guy and not Peter), dusted off and repurposed. Sure Kevin did all the layouts. I'm just not sure when it came to the scripting part of things Kevin was much more than a guy throwing notes at Waltz.

AquaParade
04-28-2022, 11:03 AM
Or there was a big fiasco with Nick and approvals. Art and content had to be changed, etc. No way in hell was that ending what was originally envisioned.

I can't imagine that scenario, because the whole series is extremely violent, featuring even the turtles slaughtering hordes of human ninja.

What are you imagining would be "out of bounds" to the point that it would effect more than just a couple panels (e.i. Saki getting his head lobbed off - which would have been pretty cool, admittedly)?

I mean, it's possible, but even then, I can't imagine it having an effect on the entire issue.

Unlesssssssssss....didn't the head of Nickelodeon recently change? How recently, if so? Is it possible he tried to come put this thing out, with his boot, during the making of the final issue? Just a wild theory with little basis.

And I think Kevin's involvement in this is overstated a little. Sure it's mostly his story synopsis with Peter from 1987 (and I do believe the story is mostly Kevin's, as he's mainly the Frank Miller guy and not Peter), dusted off and repurposed. Sure Kevin did all the layouts. I'm just not sure when it came to the scripting part of things Kevin was much more than a guy throwing notes at Waltz.

Based on what?

I'd argue that doing all the layouts is a huge part of the job. It directs the tone and the pace of the entire story. Let alone when those layouts are based on your own outline, character designs, etc.
Layouts are one of the things Kevin is sort of known for, as a storyteller. He's never been the best penciller, but fans of Mirage comics know he has an eye for action-choreography.

Besides, it just feels like a Kevin Eastman story down to the bone - the way it moves and paces itself, the violence, the action, the Frank Miller influences. The only thing it's missing are a pair of big-honking-boobs.
Even the way the character's speak feel more in line with the Mirage books, than the IDW ongoing. It's got all his strengths and his flaws.

Moreover, I just don't see any evidence for this. It'd be an interesting "hunch", but once you listen to enough interviews he's done over the last few years, it just becomes sort of obvious that he is knee-deep in this series.

There's just too much evidence against this to form a strong argument, besides "well, IDW overplayed Peter's involvement at first, so!" which only goes about an inch. You need more than that to even have a conspiracy theory.

Ninjinister
04-28-2022, 11:24 AM
lmaoooo Hiroto went full Kylo

neatoman
04-28-2022, 03:20 PM
A part I felt was a bit weird was Hiroto keeping his mother frozen only to outright kill her. I get that he's nuts but it does seem a bit... Off. I'm also curious as to who his father was, I guess it's not all that important but it might have been interesting to know.

While I think it's meant to be ambiguous, I'd like to know if Mike being back with his family was intended to be a dying hallucination or the afterlife. I'm leaning more toward the former because the latter seems a little too sappy for me.

And yes, April creating new mutant turtles is not ethical. I get that if they want to build on this continuity and keep the "Ninja Turtles" name there needs to be mutant ninja turtles around for it to make sense. It's just that making new ones when the old ones had to deal with being social outsiders isn't exactly good thing to do. It's not exactly like buying a new puppy when the old dog died.

And... Well, obviously this story doesn't really fit any previously established continuity but does anyone think there is one that it doesn't contradict too much?

AquaParade
04-28-2022, 03:32 PM
Kevin was saying part of the reason he likes the oversized format is that you can fit this series alongside the original few oversized issues. I think he intends it to build off that original Mirage continuity, before carving it’s own path and ending up here.

red1981
04-28-2022, 10:26 PM
A part I felt was a bit weird was Hiroto keeping his mother frozen only to outright kill her. I get that he's nuts but it does seem a bit... Off. I'm also curious as to who his father was, I guess it's not all that important but it might have been interesting to know.

While I think it's meant to be ambiguous, I'd like to know if Mike being back with his family was intended to be a dying hallucination or the afterlife. I'm leaning more toward the former because the latter seems a little too sappy for me.

And yes, April creating new mutant turtles is not ethical. I get that if they want to build on this continuity and keep the "Ninja Turtles" name there needs to be mutant ninja turtles around for it to make sense. It's just that making new ones when the old ones had to deal with being social outsiders isn't exactly good thing to do. It's not exactly like buying a new puppy when the old dog died.

And... Well, obviously this story doesn't really fit any previously established continuity but does anyone think there is one that it doesn't contradict too much?

i think with the ending they have it opens for more stories in this version of turtles

Andrew NDB
04-29-2022, 12:03 AM
Kevin was saying part of the reason he likes the oversized format is that you can fit this series alongside the original few oversized issues. I think he intends it to build off that original Mirage continuity, before carving it’s own path and ending up here.

That was what he was talking about after the Nick sale. His pitch for a maxi-series shopped around that just picked up after "Return to New York" but not "City at War." There's some shades of "Last Ronin" to it but not much, but maybe that'd be the idea with some kind of ongoing Last Ronin prequel series. Except now it'd be some kind of alternate IDW/Mirage hybrid universe like Last Ronin is.

Kyo Hisagi
04-29-2022, 12:28 AM
I liked the ending. Could have been better, but still pretty decent.

What I didn't like:
1) Obvious "there's going to be more" bait
2) That said bait do we really need 4 more turtles just to show that "circle continues"? Why 4 exactly, why not 2? Are they going to be called like Raphael 2 or Raphael Jr or what? What's next, they are gonna find yet another Saki to fight with? :lol:
3) Casey's daughter being a mutant. Like.. why. Why do you need that. She could just be a regular human
4) Hiroto killed his own mother... and he waited for Mike to show up so he could do it the most idiotic/dramatic way :lol: he could kill her FOR YEARS but decided not to.

But overall it's a nice finale to a pretty good series. There's not much to add.

CyberCubed
04-29-2022, 06:25 AM
I suppose the difference is while this mini-series was good, it really is just a 5-part elseworlds tale in a dystopian future where most of the main cast is dead. This concept has been done a million times in both TMNT and other franchises. That's why after it ends there's not much to talk about because well the events don't really matter for any particular series.

Lord Nightwalker
04-29-2022, 06:53 AM
In answer to your fourth dislike, I think it wasn't just his hatred and lunacy, but that he wanted to rob Mike of that particular goal. That's best, least spoilers way I can put it.
Just a thought though. Nothing else.

Leo656
04-29-2022, 07:38 AM
I suppose the difference is while this mini-series was good, it really is just a 5-part elseworlds tale in a dystopian future where most of the main cast is dead. This concept has been done a million times in both TMNT and other franchises. That's why after it ends there's not much to talk about because well the events don't really matter for any particular series.

It's an interesting point. As a rule I'm a huge fan of Elseworlds stories but at the end of the day they're all just amusing diversions with no strong emotional investment for me since I know for a fact the events depicted within them will never "really" happen in-canon (and in many cases I wouldn't want them to, even in the case of some of my favorite Elseworlds).

I'm sure this one would have more impact with at least some people if it were explicitly presented as "The Last Mirage TMNT Story" or "The Last IDW TMNT Story" with no confusion that it may not be. As simply "the last TMNT story of some amalgamated TMNT universe that never existed outside of this one story", it's a bit less impactful. It's "the end" of something that technically never even existed, since it's not Mirage canon, IDW canon, or any other canon but its own.

Of course, that's not going to matter as much or even at all to every single person, but it inarguably matters to some people.

I don't mind saying, Cubed, that your insights and inputs when you're not playing your character can occasionally be pretty meaningful and I wouldn't mind seeing more of that.

AquaParade
04-29-2022, 08:34 AM
Canon is a huge deal for many comic readers. I tend to just enjoy a good story, regardless. I see canon as a tool to be used, not a ball and chain to be worn.

But at the same time, with my love of Mirage, had it been tied more heavily to that continuity, it may have had a bigger impact on me, but it’s hard to say. I suppose I’m just grateful that it feels like a Mirage story, which is the type of TMNT comic I want to read.
And while it may not be “canon” to an established universe, it’s still coming from Kevin himself, which is damn cool, compared to most franchises, that are 35+ years old and getting their version of “DKR”. No one else can really say that. So in some ways, it’s the most “canon” of all.

I agree with those critiques, Ryo Hisagi. I think one of the reasons this issue feels like one of the weakest is bc it became clear that some of these built up plots weren’t really going anywhere. Why did Karai stick around? Why did Casey need a mutation plot? Why did Mikey need a second-mutation plot? Those things don’t really add up in a satisfying way, imo.

Luckily, I wasn’t really there for those aspects in the first place, but it felt choppy.

Leo656
04-29-2022, 08:53 AM
Side rant, triggered by this conversation.

One of the biggest bummers about Mirage is that it never got - and never will get - a proper ending, even though it's sort of implied throughout that the creators had a definitive ending in mind that they were hinting at/building towards, but we never got to see because the money ran out and the creators lost interest/focus.

It sort of feels like a rip that arguably the most "important" TMNT universe of all just sort of went away, with so many things unresolved. Granted, not everything in life gets a satisfying conclusion, but again, there were times in Mirage where it looked like it might all be building to Something... and then Something didn't happen. And now, it never will.

This might be "the closest we'll ever get" but it's still clearly not anywhere close to what a "real" Mirage ending would be. And I'm outspoken that Mirage doesn't even impress me all that much, but it's still disappointing to me that it's doomed to forever be open-ended. Its fans deserved better.

I always felt like Vol. 4 should probably have been more about tying up loose ends and "closing the book" rather than introducing a bunch MORE plot threads that were never going to go anywhere. That was some poor resource management on Laird's part. Like yeah, he got to tell the story he felt like telling - such as it was - but c'mon, which would most people prefer to have had? An "actual ending" for the series that started it all, or a bunch of fever-dream scribbles that went nowhere and ended with no resolution at all? Especially knowing as we do Now that such an ending is forever impossible.

AquaParade
04-29-2022, 09:33 AM
I might be in the minority, but I love the open-ended nature of Mirage. Had they not planted seeds as to where the turtles end up, I’d feel different. But I find the ambiguous nature to not only fit the “slice-of-life” tone of Mirage, but also to be quite touching. I like the mystery of wondering where Mikey wound up, or wondering what type of fallout led to the events seen in “Old Times.”
Like a horror-movie monster, sometimes less is more.

There’s just enough there to stoke your imagination. In some ways, it feels much more organic than a proper “the end” finale.

Again, I’m probably the minority. I know comic readers can be very anal about canon and such.

Leo656
04-29-2022, 09:44 AM
I love comics, it's just something about the medium that is inherently flawed. It's the only place where you're allowed/encouraged to tell a story that has (and never will have) an ending. And that's a big reason the medium has never been more popular than it is, and will always remain niche.

I mean individual stories within a larger series obviously have endings. But it's like, there will never be an official "Last Superman Story", "Last Batman Story", and so on, since these characters are now more something to merchandise than actual "characters" within "stories". The stories they exist in no longer even matter, they're mostly just a way to maintain copyright so they can keep making toys.

One reason a lot of people cite manga as being better than "regular" comic books is because for better or worse, and even if it takes them decades to get there, there's usually a Beginning, Middle, and End to whatever saga it is.

"Power of imagination", sure, and I totally get that - no "official" ending for TMNT, Superman, or Batman would ever be as satisfying as what we write in our heads; just look at how people reacted to the Star Wars prequels and sequels as proof of that - but still. You could never get away with it in a "proper" storytelling medium. Stories are supposed to have three acts; in comics, in the "longform" sense and not simply talking individual arcs, you only ever get Act I and Act II, and then you have to make up your own Act III.

Imagine if Tolkien never wrote "Return of the King" and told everyone to just "use their imagination" as to how it all wrapped up. People wouldn't stand for it, and that mythos wouldn't still be remembered and revered. Nobody would ever revisit the first two books for anything but a lark, knowing they'd never get any sort of resolution/conclusion.

One of those things that makes comics "great", I supposed. Just saying.

AquaParade
04-29-2022, 09:49 AM
For the Big 2, that’s mostly true.

But there are a lot of comics with planned beginnings and endings, outside of them, of course. Stuff like Preacher, The Invisibles, Kill or be Killed, Seven to Eternity. Those are some of my favorite comics with actual endings.

I wouldn’t be surprised to see IDW tmnt get a definitive ending at some point. When sales dwindle, it will have deserved it, for maintaining such consistency over such a long period of time. Then maybe they can “reboot” after that or something. Not an end for the characters, but an end for that version of them.

This is why I don’t need everything to be canon all the time, like a lot of fellow readers. Let things die every once in a while.

neatoman
04-29-2022, 10:08 AM
Yeah, it's mostly big publishers who steer the medium in the direction of indefinite storytelling, smaller publishers (especially when it comes to creator owned books) are less likely to do this. Granted, that could have more to do with lower sales and creator experiencing fatigue but it still isn't as big of a problem with smaller books. And of course Marvel and DC books don't really ever end, the shared universe concept practically begs for characters to keep popping up regardless of how many books get cancelled.

And it's not even a problem with just comic books. The James Bond movies kept getting made despite Eon running out of books to adapt by the fifteenth one, and they somehow made ten more (so far). Not to mention how Christopher Tolkien somehow managed to "edit the unfinished works of his father" into about twenty or so volumes.

It's just more noticeable with comics because:

They are published on a near monthly basis and can last decades on this schedule.
They're dirt cheap to make and thus always easy to justify.
When successful, they get side-books, effectively increasing the output.
Literally anyone will pick up the license if they think they can squeeze out some profit from it.

AquaParade
04-29-2022, 11:15 AM
Speaking of comic continuity, I thought it was very clever of Jonathan Hickman to somewhat dissolve the notion of death in his recent X-Men comic run.

Since these are never-ending stories, like we are pointing out, characters are constantly being killed off and resurrected, essentially as a sales/story gimmick.

But Hickman said "Fine - any mutant who dies can be easily resurrected. Tension of death = deflated". Again, for comics, with the current state they are in, I found that to be a great move. From there, he leans into the implications of immortality. Also, preemptively putting his foot down on any "DEATH OF ____" gimmicks, which Marvel would have undoubtedly found a way to shove into his story.

Instead of fighting against the current, you lean into it, and you take advantage of it, if you can.

neatoman
04-29-2022, 11:25 AM
I like how Slott explained how dead Supervillains keep showing up without explanation.
"Hobgoblin salvages their stuff and rents it out to random thugs who want the instant reputation that comes from being an impostor."
So simple yet so effective in solving continuity errors.

Sumac
04-30-2022, 04:45 AM
IMO, ending is what makes a story.
I hate retards who say "journey is more important than an ending". This people completely miss the point of storytelling.

And I must admit ending stories is hard, because, you get attached to the characters you are writing, but at some point you must put a definite stop to them, otherwise you end up with a meaningless pile of noodles which go nowhere for no reason.

It is OK, if you're making a series, which doesn't have a continuity or consist of standalone stories, so each one can be viewed / read on its own. But if you make a continuous story, I feel, its still is supposed to adhere to BME (beginning - middle - end) rule. Otherwise, its just pile of nothing

Filespit
04-30-2022, 08:29 AM
Overall I'm satisfied with The Last Ronin. It started really strong but got slightly weaker with each issue, but that does in no way mean it's bad. I feel the ending was expected, but it still felt a bit rushed. I would've like something more, don't know exactly what, but something.

The epilogue is very exciting to me. Hopefully this means there's a completely new Turtle team coming, not some kind of cloning or recreation thing. Perhaps it's time for Bernini?
I've really enjoyed the excitement around the series and I believe it's been an important piece of the TMNT franchise.

Also I LOVED Ben Bishop's artwork. I sincerely hope he gets to do more TMNT stuff going forward.

superstaff
04-30-2022, 08:30 AM
IMO, ending is what makes a story.
I hate retards who say "journey is more important than an ending". This people completely miss the point of storytelling.


Yeah, I also agree that endings are what make a story.

The ending is essentially the entire thesis of the story. It's where you receive the main message that the author is trying to convey. It's the viewer/reader's reward for making it to the end. It's the most important part of a story, with the beginning being second because the importance of the beginning is to draw the audience in from the get-go.

I think a very bad ending can ruin the entire story, too.

Sumac
04-30-2022, 10:50 AM
Yeah, I also agree that endings are what make a story.

The ending is essentially the entire thesis of the story. It's where you receive the main message that the author is trying to convey. It's the viewer/reader's reward for making it to the end. It's the most important part of a story, with the beginning being second because the importance of the beginning is to draw the audience in from the get-go.

I think a very bad ending can ruin the entire story, too.
Indeed.
Which is why I hate "journey is a goal" mentality. Journey becomes worthless, if an ending is bad.

superstaff
04-30-2022, 11:41 AM
Indeed.
Which is why I hate "journey is a goal" mentality. Journey becomes worthless, if an ending is bad.

Some people can forgive a bad ending if the journey is fun. And I guess sometimes that's enough. I personally feel that a bad ending can ruin the whole thing, especially if it's an ending that spits on what came before it.

King Kahn
05-01-2022, 02:10 PM
Kind of a ethical question of what seemingly forcing mutation on those four turtles. What happens if they gain sentience and hate the freak that they were turned into



Nothing like that. She describes it like how in Static Shock how Richie gains his powers because he was around Virgil that was still emitting the chemicals that gave him his powers.

Basically April and Casey had been around radiated people that they essentially got a secondhand high.

yeah this is how I took it. Like radiation exposure, not through sex.

King Kahn
05-01-2022, 02:12 PM
Both of those scenarios are infinitely more likely than me ever using Spoiler tags, or showing any respect whatsoever to the Spoiler-sensitive. That much I can say with great certainty.

especially in a thread called "Last Ronin Ending". If you come into a thread called that and don't expect to get spoiled....

King Kahn
05-01-2022, 02:23 PM
Yeah, but Saki was literally blown up. As in, into little bits of bloody kibble and gore and bits of armor.

This Hiroto guy explodes but... doesn't? Like, at all? It reads very tame and neutered on the page, his exit there. No, I can't believe that's Eastman's vision for that at all and there was absolutely some compromise there with Nick, 100%.



I don't think it's ever been said in any universe that I'm aware of that the Turtles have radiation, or that the ooze is radioactive. People seem to assume that, but I've not seen anything that it is.

The ooze glows in the dark, akin to the old trope of radioactive materials glowing in the dark or making those exposed glow.

Also the ooze is supposed to be literally the same stuff that turned daredevil blind and gave him his powers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daredevil_(Marvel_Comics_character)

It was radioactive waste that spilled on him, hence the ooze is radioactive.

But hey, if you want to keep that slashfic of turtle ****ing alive by all means live your best life man. lol

Leo656
05-01-2022, 02:39 PM
especially in a thread called "Last Ronin Ending". If you come into a thread called that and don't expect to get spoiled....

For the most part it just annoys me that "grown-ups' get SO bent about that stuff. It's like it'll literally "ruin" the entire experience if you know a tiny bit about what's going to happen in advance. These are the epitome of First-World Problems.

"God forbid I know how a movie or comic book ends, I totally can't get into it now." Well, then you're simple.

I wouldn't care at all if people didn't get all hyperbolic about it. "NO SPOILERS or it's permanent Block, not even joking." F*cking relax, man. I've never deliberately "ruined" anything for anyone but every time I encounter that sh*t I'm tempted, just out of pure spite. I demand that these people find out what Real Problems are and I'm forever tempted to f*ck their day in the ear just because they're annoying me.

Science also overwhelmingly establishes that people enjoy A Thing more when they know what they're getting no matter how many people insist that they want to be surprised; they're forever underwhelmed and end up complaining when they go into things cold (this comic being a case in point for many). My insistence that people face and accept Reality pushes me to make these people get with the program.

My politeness always wins out, but Lord it's hard sometimes.

Ninjinister
05-01-2022, 07:05 PM
Kevin was saying part of the reason he likes the oversized format is that you can fit this series alongside the original few oversized issues. I think he intends it to build off that original Mirage continuity, before carving it’s own path and ending up here.

I mean there's quite a bit that contradicts Mirage canon, Karai being Saki's daughter, for one.

AquaParade
05-01-2022, 08:12 PM
I mean there's quite a bit that contradicts Mirage canon, Karai being Saki's daughter, for one.

Yeah, but that comes after the first few issues, in CaW.

Leo656
05-01-2022, 08:23 PM
I know the horse has left the barn forever on Karai being Saki's daughter, or daughter-figure, to the point where even Eastman refers to her as such now, and maybe it actually works better that way (I guess it must, since it's become pretty much Hard Canon everywhere else outside of Mirage), but on some level it makes me annoyed. Simply because that absolutely wasn't the role she was created for and so making her that is a direct repudiation of the original version of the character.

I mean, I guess at least Kevin now wishes she'd been created as Shredder's daughter in the first place (not sure what Peter thinks, although he did approve it in 4Kids so I guess he's fine with it Sometimes). But... she wasn't.

I'unno. Maybe we should pretend that when Superboy Prime punched Time it just retconned it so Karai was Shredder's daughter in Mirage as well, just for simplicity's sake. :trazz: At least one of the original creators clearly regrets not having come up with it first, and the other one is at the very least okay with it being the case Sometimes.

AquaParade
05-01-2022, 08:41 PM
I like the idea of Karai being a character independent of Saki, but it does make sense to give him a daughter, given the themes of family & revenge, and I can see why Karai would be squeezed into that position.

Sumac
05-02-2022, 07:12 AM
I dislike how from Shredder's equal, Karai has become his subordinate.

superstaff
05-02-2022, 07:57 AM
This may sound odd but I feel like I agree with you both, AquaParade and Sumac.

On one hand, I do dislike that she went from a character that had her own agency, and was basically Shredder's equal, and has now become more of a subordinate (I was about to use lackey, but that's way too harsh, she's really not on the same level as, say, Bebop and Rocksteady).

But on the other hand, her being more of a daughter does go nicely with the themes of family (most of which were made or found, and not based on blood relations as much in the TMNT universe) and revenge. I think it depends on the writing whether it's done well or not. Some incarnations do better with it than others.

Andrew NDB
05-02-2022, 10:58 AM
I like the idea of Karai being a character independent of Saki, but it does make sense to give him a daughter, given the themes of family & revenge, and I can see why Karai would be squeezed into that position.

I don't. You want to give Saki a daughter? Great, here's Pimiko. Use her.

I dislike how from Shredder's equal, Karai has become his subordinate.

Arguably she was even his superior. Leader of Japan Foot > Leader of NY Foot.

I just don't understand how it isn't more upsetting to people, particularly women. You have this awesome character that is Saki's superior, a leader, even a mother... and then in everything else she needs to be Saki's wayward daughter? What?

Leo656
05-02-2022, 11:15 AM
Arguably she was even his superior. Leader of Japan Foot > Leader of NY Foot.

I just don't understand how it isn't more upsetting to people, particularly women. You have this awesome character that is Saki's superior, a leader, even a mother... and then in everything else she needs to be Saki's wayward daughter? What?


At some point someone probably realized that women universally make terrible bosses. :trazz:

Coola Yagami
05-02-2022, 01:17 PM
I don't. You want to give Saki a daughter? Great, here's Pimiko. Use her.



Arguably she was even his superior. Leader of Japan Foot > Leader of NY Foot.

I just don't understand how it isn't more upsetting to people, particularly women. You have this awesome character that is Saki's superior, a leader, even a mother... and then in everything else she needs to be Saki's wayward daughter? What?

I think the problem is Karai only works when Shredder is gone and dead. We never see them interact in Mirage so we never got to actually see her call the shots or berate Saki for failure or whatever.

Since Shredder usually shown as alive and the big bad of the show, I guess people aren't ready to either show him reporting back to her or his boss, or having Shredder be perma-dead before Karai even makes an appearance.

If you make them share screentime, Shredder usually being the big bad forced her to his subordinate or some sort. 2K3 almost nailed it had the plan had been to keep Ch'Rell dead after his 2nd or so defeat.

AquaParade
05-02-2022, 01:45 PM
I don't. You want to give Saki a daughter? Great, here's Pimiko. Use her.


Hmm...makes sense.

Wasn't Karai introduced as Saki's "daughter" in 2k3, or am I misremembering?
If that's the case, I suppose Peter wanted to use a Mirage character and - help me again - wasn't Pimiko created within the Image run?

I mean, he could have created a new character too, I suppose.

I do like the idea of Karai being an equal, or more, to Saki.

Maybe we will see further remixes on the character in the future. Karai could be Saki's daughter, he doesn't know about, who comes from Japan and shreds his ass, before revealing herself and being the one to put an end to him.

Idk, either way I agree that she's cooler when she's not a subordinate to Saki.

Sumac
05-02-2022, 02:28 PM
But on the other hand, her being more of a daughter does go nicely with the themes of family (most of which were made or found, and not based on blood relations as much in the TMNT universe) and revenge. I think it depends on the writing whether it's done well or not. Some incarnations do better with it than others.
I like idea of two families fighting, but I don't like it being Karai, because, it takes pre-existing character and turns into something it is not.
As a fan of FW series, I am not sure, if I can complain about it, though. :lol::lol:

Arguably she was even his superior. Leader of Japan Foot > Leader of NY Foot.
Precisely.

I just don't understand how it isn't more upsetting to people, particularly women. You have this awesome character that is Saki's superior, a leader, even a mother... and then in everything else she needs to be Saki's wayward daughter? What?
I think it is, and pardon my bluntness, because, almost no-one cares much about Mirage'verse.
And most people have been introduced to Karai via 2k3 series or 2k7 movie, so they simply don't know who she was before.

If I was in charge of TMNT series of my own, I'd rectified that injustice, though I don't think everyone would like all of my "creative decisions". :lol:

Leo656
05-02-2022, 02:48 PM
That's basically how it always works. Spin-off media always supersedes the original source material because it becomes more well-known. "Nobody reads comics" and that's always been the case compared to how many people watch cartoons or movies, so it really "doesn't matter" whatever was established in the source material. "The source material doesn't count, only the stuff people actually know counts."

"You mean Mikey wasn't always a pizza-obsessed brain-dead idiot? Well, that's how *I* first met him, so that's who he is To Me. You mean Raphael WASN'T a 'wacky prankster', he was an angry violent loner? Well, *I* know him best from the cartoon, so I don't care what some comic book I never read says, even if it came first. You mean Karai wasn't Shredder's daughter, she was his BOSS? Well, she's his daughter in every other version, and I like it better that way anyway, so that comic is wrong. They just didn't have it all figured out yet."

That's how it works. So even though Karai was invented to be Shredder's superior... doesn't matter, she's his kid now. Not only has it been done in media that's been seen by way more people, it wasn't just once or twice but Every Single Time. So now the original source material is the sole outlier, and as odd as that is, there's no going back on it Now. It's just been too consistently overwritten. Just like Mikey will never be anything but a moron again, and so forth. It's just impossible to go back on these things once they become so established in more popular media.

Sharman
05-03-2022, 12:47 PM
I don't. You want to give Saki a daughter? Great, here's Pimiko. Use her.



Arguably she was even his superior. Leader of Japan Foot > Leader of NY Foot.

I just don't understand how it isn't more upsetting to people, particularly women. You have this awesome character that is Saki's superior, a leader, even a mother... and then in everything else she needs to be Saki's wayward daughter? What?

Great points

Sharman
05-03-2022, 12:48 PM
That was what he was talking about after the Nick sale. His pitch for a maxi-series shopped around that just picked up after "Return to New York" but not "City at War." There's some shades of "Last Ronin" to it but not much, but maybe that'd be the idea with some kind of ongoing Last Ronin prequel series. Except now it'd be some kind of alternate IDW/Mirage hybrid universe like Last Ronin is.

Interesting idea. I'd never heard that before.

AquaParade
05-03-2022, 12:50 PM
Interesting idea. I'd never heard that before.

Same here. Excluding City at War would have been a hard pill for me to swallow. I feel like it's such a great continuation of those early Mirage issues. It follows the logical path of "Now, what?".

The four turtles were raised to assassinate Oroku Saki - they did it. Where do they go from here? What do they owe Splinter?
All really interesting ideas that actually play off and develop the themes of the original story.

Sharman
05-04-2022, 03:56 PM
Same here. Excluding City at War would have been a hard pill for me to swallow. I feel like it's such a great continuation of those early Mirage issues. It follows the logical path of "Now, what?".

The four turtles were raised to assassinate Oroku Saki - they did it. Where do they go from here? What do they owe Splinter?
All really interesting ideas that actually play off and develop the themes of the original story.

Yes, I agree that it was a most approprite continuation. But a "what if" tangent is always intriguing.

NinjaPug
06-22-2022, 08:33 PM
Waltz interview:

Q: The final issue ends with an Epilogue and a "To Be Continued…” Are there plans for a sequel that explores this world further? Is that last image setting up an attempt to make new mutants or to literally bring back the original turtles?

A: Oh… standby, sports fans. I can’t give specifics yet, but suffice to say, we are not done with what we are now lovingly calling "The Ronin-verse." Big announcements coming soon!

https://www.cbr.com/tmnt-last-ronin-tom-waltz-interview/

Andrew NDB
06-22-2022, 09:04 PM
Well, there it is. Probably prequel material first.

Bahamut810
06-22-2022, 10:38 PM
Awesome. I am glad it seems like they arent giving up their cash cow.

mrmaczaps
06-22-2022, 11:03 PM
I liked Ronin, sort of... just too bad sales/story on the ongoing has sucked so bad in the 2+ years since the regulars have been gone to do LR.

The ending was too predictable and safe... I really don't care to see a post- LR series and doing stories post whatever universe LR is the future of just doesn't interest me either really... IDW needs to maybe skip the Ongoing forward a couple years & focus on GREAT story telling and move the narrative the hell on from the garbage Mutant City...

They could always take a page from Mirage & do a Tales of series and just do small arcs that take place in random spots along the turtles timeline and as long as they don't mess up previous stories in the existing universe, its all good. Then do a new title, call it tmnt furries or something and let Campy keep going with this clusterfvck of a storyline.... see which one sells more copies. :tlol:

AquaParade
07-02-2022, 08:54 AM
The hardcover collection is already #2 on Amazon's Graphic Novel Best Sellers, and it isn't even out yet.

I'm not buying it though. It's obviously the gimped version, because there are barely any extras in the back. No concept art, outline, sketches, and just a handful of covers. Pretty sad.

Anxiously awaiting whatever Deluxe edition they may release. Hope it doesn't take too long.

DK2
07-02-2022, 05:15 PM
I saw it too Last Ronins HC. It was disapointing that there werent any extra supplements. Just the main variant covers. I was hoping for the original plotted outline to read at least. Just surprised its more or less bare bones. Nothing from the directors cut or the other sketches one shot that had come out either among the extras.

Allio
07-06-2022, 08:04 AM
And... Well, obviously this story doesn't really fit any previously established continuity but does anyone think there is one that it doesn't contradict too much?

If you count TMNT part of the original trilogy series, this could just be slotted in as an ending to that. I mean TMNT doesn’t at all establish Karai’s relationship to Shredder.I mean outside of some character stuff like Fugitoid and Baxter. Though Baxter can fit the tone of those films.

NinjaPug
07-09-2022, 01:45 PM
Looks like we’ll be getting an update on the “Roninverse” in two weeks at SDCC.

TMNT: Secrets of the Roninverse and Armageddon Game
Saturday, July 23, 2022
10:00 AM - 11:00 AM PST

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comics have never been hotter! With the critically acclaimed The Last Ronin having reached its senses-shattering conclusion, fans have been left reeling with one burning question: What's next? TMNT co-creator Kevin Eastman, Tom Waltz, Ben Bishop, Erik Burnham, and moderator Charles Beacham tease what's next for "The Roninverse," IDW's ongoing continuity, Armageddon Game, and Saturday Morning Adventures.

AquaParade
07-09-2022, 04:42 PM
Interested to see where this goes. TLR was a blessing but there's definitely room for improvement.

I'm expecting we'll see both a prequel and a sequel series. I'm actually more interested in seeing the follow up to issue #5's ending.

I think a story featuring four new turtles could be really cool, if it feels like it has a reason to exist. Like it plays off past tmnt stories in a meaningful way.

That said, I think they still need to justify their existence. Why did Casey and April decide to do that? I'm still not sure I understand that. If they can come up with a good reason, I'm interested.

And yeah, the success of the book continues to astound. The single issues were just the prelude, because hardcover collections is where most people seem to be these days. It's already selling out and topping major sales charts on sites like Amazon and IST. If we thought it was successful before, we haven't even seen the long term evergreen sales this book will have.

It's just nice to see this version of TMNT get a win.

NinjaPug
07-22-2022, 09:28 AM
The Oral History of The Last Ronin

https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/last-ronin-tmnt-oral-history

AquaParade
07-22-2022, 09:36 AM
The Oral History of The Last Ronin

https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/last-ronin-tmnt-oral-history

Stoked to read this. Thanks.

mrmaczaps
07-22-2022, 06:15 PM
From that other thread, they're going to make one of the turtles gay in the follow up LR story... but then can they call it the Last Ronin if there are 4 more baby mutant turtles running around? Lol

Stu_Padasso
08-03-2022, 01:21 AM
Got the hardcover come in so I got to reread the whole thing through. I wasn’t expecting a “happy” ending so I wasn’t surprised how things would turn out. The last issue did feel a bit flat in some parts. With all the build-up with cybernetics and nanotechnology I was almost expecting them to pull off a Necrosha and “resurrect” Michelangelo’s family under Hiroto’s control only to have Mikey sacrifice himself to save them. Instead we got a couple of mini-boss fights with characters that we’ve never seen before and don’t have much reason to care about before the main event.

Still, probably far better than most of the crap the Big 2 are pushing.

So, uh, are we not going to talk about how despite April’s claim that she and Casey were “contaminated “ by their contact with the turtles neither of them had been mutated or demonstrated any augmented abilities that Casey Marie had including being able to hold her breath under water for long periods of time? Or the interesting choice of clothing that Casey Marie is wearing in the epilogue?

AquaParade
08-03-2022, 01:57 AM
The whole second mutation angle felt off to me. They hinted at it with Mikey too but it didn’t go anywhere other then to explain why he could endure so much damage.

And does Casey need a mutation to be interesting? Can’t she just be a ninja with human capabilities like Saki? I guess that’s not my choice to make but it felt like a needless complication to make her a little stronger.

Diorm
08-19-2022, 08:21 AM
I got the HC version too and was able to finish the series. I had a problem with Karai being killed by Hiroto just like that at the end. It felt like there was a bigger plan and they decided to kill her at the end (because they were late in releasing this series and had to cut it short?)

What I was expecting is that there would be a conversation with her and the ronin and a fight for who started the last conflict with the two clans. Because when you read issue 2, both sides think the other started it. So I was expecting like someone set them both up and all those killing were because of a third party. Imagine the turtles being killed because of a misunderstanding.

Cowabung-Gal
08-19-2022, 11:13 AM
Personally I loved the ending.

Was it perfect? No. Was it a bit rushed? Yes. But I felt satisfied nonetheless. It ended beautifully in my opinion. Mikey reuniting with his family in the afterlife, that brought a tear to my eye. Plus the last image of the series (before the epilogue) is of the whole family standing on a rooftop, and if you recall, the cover of the very first TMNT issue had the four turtles standing on a rooftop too.

Andrew NDB
08-19-2022, 11:20 AM
I got the HC version too and was able to finish the series. I had a problem with Karai being killed by Hiroto just like that at the end. It felt like there was a bigger plan and they decided to kill her at the end (because they were late in releasing this series and had to cut it short?)

There was definitely no timetable they (TPTB) were racing against in any way. That seems clear.

CyberCubed
08-19-2022, 01:26 PM
I assume it's because I'm older now but I read this when it came out and completely forgot everything about it besides some basic things.

AquaParade
08-19-2022, 02:53 PM
My opinion: The sub plots were all over the place. I couldn’t connect with the point of Karai being there and the second mutation felt superfluous. Personally, I don’t even like the idea of it. Everything feels a little more dangerous, without the “superpowers”. Casey always got along without them.

I think this story would have benefited from being told in less issues. The present timeline dragged, while they stalled to format each issue around a flashback.
At the least, I didn’t feel that they took advantage of the present timeline, despite spending five issues there.

The first issue was the best, imo, because it was paced wholly within the present timeline and allowed Kevin to do what he does best - action-packed choreography with cool characters and just a little bit of drama.




What this series nailed was tone, art, and characters. It just feels right when Kevin is writing the TMNT, in terms of character voices. And finally, we’re allowed to embrace all the themes that make tmnt great: legacy, revenge, family, and kick-ass ninja action that pulls no punches. It does that well. I don’t think it reaches the level of Return to New York or City at War, but it comes close.

They reeled most people in on premise alone, and I’d even go as far as to say that I think a lot of people overlooked the execution because the concept was great. This is what a whole generation of people want from TMNT.

So, the book isn’t perfect but it’s a giant step in the right direction. I suppose this makes the next Ronin series interesting - there is room for improvement and I want to see it fulfilled.




I’ve gotta say, I’m sort of looking forward to the potential of seeing a story set in the aftermath of TLR. I’ve never been naturally appreciative of a fifth turtle coming into the fray, for different reasons, yet I am intrigued by a whole new set of turtles, living in the legacy of the four turtles we know.

Yeah, that’s a concept that interests me, at least with Eastman and the Escorza brothers sketching it out (and that truly is tied into the appeal, for me). Sort of a Batman Beyond of the TMNT, In very general terms. Could be cool.

Btw, the hardcover reached the 11th spot on the New York Times Best Seller list.

TheLabRat
03-29-2023, 01:44 PM
A person who breaks her promise still has "honor"? Such a cheap and hypocritical honor.

Cowabung-Gal
03-29-2023, 02:14 PM
A person who breaks her promise still has "honor"? Such a cheap and hypocritical honor.

I’m starting to think that someone from the Foot Clan deliberately broke the truce by committing a crime, like murdering a fellow clan member, and pinning the blame on Clan Hamato. It may have all been just a misunderstanding on Karai’s part, if she is in fact an honorable person as Mikey implies. I can imagine Tatsu, Shredder’s right-hand man, conspiring to break the truce since he despises the turtles for murdering his master. I think he’d rather die than coexist with the enemy. Of course, as of yet Tatsu doesn’t exist in the Last Ronin-verse, but it could explain how the truce abruptly ended.

Cowabung-Gal
02-23-2024, 01:32 AM
It took me a couple of years to finally notice this, but Hiroto went out the same way his grandfather the Shredder did in the first issue of the Mirage series: with a bang.

https://static1.cbrimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/last-ronin-1.jpg?q=50&fit=crop&w=943&dpr=1.5

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/9LtrT-FAlNBVv184VrQVMYchEA4ewX-207eiIg3hz_Ra932_Iwr4eU4pAeYBXTXhv1LyybUnSSQt3lRbN 9Qm8a_gVcVrqt6GKu2Dv-J7iVJktgLVPYm6ZGJvWgL2dlm5b6C3za7w

DexVcx
02-29-2024, 12:24 AM
Let's hope last ronin 2 doesn't ruin it

jignat
06-09-2024, 12:35 PM
TMNT : The Last Ronin (2022) Review

Comic Miniseries
No Spoilers....

Premise: After 3 of the TMNT and some of their close allies are brutally killed, a lone turtle vows vengeance and will end those responsible.


Notes:

This is set in its own continuity, not the Mirage or IDW TMNT. Despite that, you can follow most of the story if you have any familiarity with the franchise.

For those wondering , it is in full color with a handful of pages in black and white for occasional flashbacks.

Pros:

The tone and action. Most people in mainstream have forgotten but tmnt started as a solidly PG-13 indie comic. This series goes back to that.

The protagonist does kill some villains and flashbacks to the deaths of the others are shown.

He has survivors guilt and nightmares about the others.

The art is done by some artists I am unfamiliar with Isaac Escorza, Esau Escorza, and Ben Bishop. IMO, the art is solid and reminds me of Michael Dooney. The black and white flashbacks are drawn by CO creator Kevin Eastman.

Cons:

The "worst" thing about this story is that it feels like Frank Millers "The Dark Knight Returns" was used as a mad libs template that TMNT was shoehorned Into. There are some blade runner elements too. I could overlook it if the story was more emotional for me but a certain "vehicle" , a female character, and the end of a certain fight stuck out in my mind as being too similar.

The main villain is pretty one note. He tries to come off as very "high class" and bad ass but it feels hollow. His direct interaction with the deceased characters is limited to 2/5 of them. Also the final battle is intercut with the allies in a perilous situation in the sewers and it detracts from the urgency.


There is a two page epilogue with a sequel hook that feels clumsy.


Overall: 7/10.

Nice art/tone for a what if story that's a change of pace from most of the movies/cartoons,but a bit overrated.

BornAgain
06-10-2024, 11:39 AM
I mostly agree. It’s a bit overrated but that speaks to how hungry people were for a more mature TMNT story. The concept and tone took the book into the stratosphere. Nick should be pleased but also embarrassed for not taking advantage of the IP like this a long time ago.

CyberCubed
06-10-2024, 04:02 PM
Yeah, I'm not sure why casuals ate it up so much, probably because as you said, most people never saw a "mature" TMNT story and just knew the Turtles through the cartoons.

For the rest of us, I dunno, the story was fine. It's a well written and drawn "elseworlds" tale, but nothing groundbreaking. I enjoyed it but I only read it once and I can barely remember the story. I probably won't revisit it for another few years.

Drose18
06-10-2024, 04:12 PM
I need to re-read TLR too but I remember really enjoying lost years. Biggest downside to both is that they needed some more pages to better flesh out pretty much everything other than the other three + splinter's deaths.

TheLabRat
06-11-2024, 04:13 AM
Those flashbacks in main books were a bit unnecessary and I think they should have focus on current timeline story. And I still think kill Mikey in finale was bad idea.

BornAgain
06-11-2024, 06:13 AM
Yeah, I'm not sure why casuals ate it up so much, probably because as you said, most people never saw a "mature" TMNT story and just knew the Turtles through the cartoons.

For the rest of us, I dunno, the story was fine. It's a well written and drawn "elseworlds" tale, but nothing groundbreaking. I enjoyed it but I only read it once and I can barely remember the story. I probably won't revisit it for another few years.

Yeah, look how our generation supports Marvel, Batman, or even Joker and Deadpool. We want this stuff to grow with us. Everyone else did, but the turtles weren’t allowed to. The turtles, who were probably the single biggest children’s property of a generation were nowhere to be found. While its peers took advantage of the zeitgeist, TMNT continued to regurgitate for the same children’s demographic and drive-off without the generation that made them.


It was a humongous build-up that was finally unleashed. Nick had no idea what they have, so bless Kevin for saving his babies.

Andrew NDB
06-11-2024, 11:25 AM
Yeah, I'm not sure why casuals ate it up so much

I think a mix of, while they never read the Mirage stuff themselves, they were aware of it and zeroed in on this as some kind of a "Dark Knight Returns" to it all while being as equally as accessible. If that makes sense. Like there's a large number of people pop culturally aware of "there's this DARK TURTLES thing known as Mirage over here in the corner I've only heard whispers about!" without actually having read anything of it, and then here comes "Oh wow, the GRAND FINALE of it THIRTY YEARS IN THE MAKING!!" even though that was deceptive marketing and all around wrong.

CyberCubed
03-03-2025, 12:45 PM
I just caught up on The Last Ronin II with all the future Turtles (there's only 1 issue left), and this is honestly really dull. These new Turtles have the bare minimum of characterisation and the villains are a bunch of nonsensical business men mixed with street gangs like the purple dragons. April looks like Jamie Lee Curtis and it's really taking me out of it.

The Last Ronin should of just stayed that initial 5 issue mini-series, which was fine for what it was (if a little overrated). Turning it into a on-going series was a mistake. I really hope there's no more after this.

sdp
03-03-2025, 12:55 PM
all the casuals that love The Last Ronin are those 87 Gen X boomers who found out about mirage in the 2010s when geek culture became mainstream. They're all those redditor type fans who will correct you into saying "but in the Mirage comics" as if they've read anything besides issue #1 and buying the IDW collections. They're so ****ing annoying and will be the first ones to say "IN THE MIRAGE THEY ALL WORE RED BANDANNAS" while being the first commenters to ask for Rocksteady and Bebop in any incarnation of the turtles.
They're truly the worst and I wish them all painful deaths.

We'll continue to get TLR slop until those consoomers stop buying so who knows, perhaps that game and movie do come out one day as they try to justify liking a little kids cartoon about mutant turtles because "the comics are mature actually" while enjoying mutant town. Instead of having real balls and just accepting the fact that they like mutant turtles aimed at kids.

IMJ
03-03-2025, 02:25 PM
all the casuals that love The Last Ronin are those 87 Gen X boomers

There's SDP with his latest pencil-whip of the term "Boomer".

They're truly the worst and I wish them all painful deaths.

I..... oh God I want to run with that ball here.... but... sigh

ToTheNines
03-03-2025, 04:25 PM
all the casuals that love The Last Ronin are those 87 Gen X boomers who found out about mirage in the 2010s when geek culture became mainstream. They're all those redditor type fans who will correct you into saying "but in the Mirage comics" as if they've read anything besides issue #1 and buying the IDW collections. They're so ****ing annoying and will be the first ones to say "IN THE MIRAGE THEY ALL WORE RED BANDANNAS" while being the first commenters to ask for Rocksteady and Bebop in any incarnation of the turtles.
They're truly the worst and I wish them all painful deaths.

We'll continue to get TLR slop until those consoomers stop buying so who knows, perhaps that game and movie do come out one day as they try to justify liking a little kids cartoon about mutant turtles because "the comics are mature actually" while enjoying mutant town. Instead of having real balls and just accepting the fact that they like mutant turtles aimed at kids.

Incredible post. No notes!

jignat
03-03-2025, 06:46 PM
Another weak element of TLR is that all the heroes and villains are pretty black/white.
I was expecting some "gray" morality or a villain/hero turn of some sort.

I wish there were more surprises.
I was thinking of getting the TLR 2 if it was significantly different, but I guess not.

TheLabRat
03-03-2025, 10:47 PM
It's weird that only New York is some kind of cyberpunk dystopia. Other places look like post-apocalyptic wastelands or third world. Japan in TLR is like a feudal country, they don't even have hinawaju(flintlock gun). In the Lost Years comic, there is a international gangs based out of Rome are terrorizing people in rural Japan.

Wentos
03-05-2025, 10:13 AM
The Last Ronin should of just stayed that initial 5 issue mini-series, which was fine for what it was (if a little overrated). Turning it into a on-going series was a mistake. I really hope there's no more after this.
Yet another similarity to The Dark Knight Returns!

Andrew NDB
03-05-2025, 10:21 AM
Yet another similarity to The Dark Knight Returns!

More like literally Frank Miller's "Ronin."

Zog The Magnificent
03-05-2025, 08:07 PM
Yet another similarity to The Dark Knight Returns!

Well, following the pattern, we should actually hope for a third one. The third Dark Knight Comic was much better, after the severely terrible second one. And then there was a fourth one shot, and I never read it. I have no idea what happens in Golden Child.

Of course, I don't really know if anyone actually needs it, because I agree with the sentiment that it should have just been a one off.

CyberCubed
04-30-2025, 01:41 PM
Last Ronin II #5 came out today, ending the second series. It was a whole lot of nothing besides April dying. But she's an old woman now so it doesn't matter. I legit could not tell you what the villains were trying to do besides the usual "take over the city" type stuff. The new Turtles just aren't interesting. Sadly it ended on another cliffhanger of sorts so there's probably going to be a Last Ronin III.

I was ready for this "universe" to be over.

TheLabRat
04-30-2025, 08:05 PM
Agreed, the new TLR series is feels like drawing legs on a snake.

They made another the turtles vs foot clan story instead of create new rival for the new turtles. This makes everything Mikey does pointless.

HotJuicyBurgers
05-01-2025, 03:26 PM
Ummm… yah was this series supposed to be longer and was cut short? Like honestly what? Feel like they just had that “moment” so something could happen this issue because otherwise what else did happen this issue?

ToTheNines
05-01-2025, 03:29 PM
**** the god damn last ronin!

AlZarkovski
05-01-2025, 03:52 PM
Well, following the pattern, we should actually hope for a third one.

Last Ronin III confirmed (https://www.ign.com/articles/tmnt-the-last-ronin-ii-ends-in-major-tragedy-for-the-new-turtles?fbclid=IwY2xjawKAvbRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkE TF1WXJudXFMMjVYN0VOZ2Z5AR4JuEOCeSv_4AltT0GzPEOnp8a 7DWzuTa2QpwaAtwHGt0uMIR7R5PZPbCI3iQ_aem_xPqaML3Rfb Y3WkT2ijvedQ) and soon.

neatoman
05-01-2025, 04:37 PM
Last Ronin III confirmed (https://www.ign.com/articles/tmnt-the-last-ronin-ii-ends-in-major-tragedy-for-the-new-turtles?fbclid=IwY2xjawKAvbRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkE TF1WXJudXFMMjVYN0VOZ2Z5AR4JuEOCeSv_4AltT0GzPEOnp8a 7DWzuTa2QpwaAtwHGt0uMIR7R5PZPbCI3iQ_aem_xPqaML3Rfb Y3WkT2ijvedQ) and soon.

Did Last Ronin II sell well in comparison to the first one? Or at least well by normal standards?

MikeandRaph87
05-01-2025, 05:34 PM
Last Ronin III confirmed (https://www.ign.com/articles/tmnt-the-last-ronin-ii-ends-in-major-tragedy-for-the-new-turtles?fbclid=IwY2xjawKAvbRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkE TF1WXJudXFMMjVYN0VOZ2Z5AR4JuEOCeSv_4AltT0GzPEOnp8a 7DWzuTa2QpwaAtwHGt0uMIR7R5PZPbCI3iQ_aem_xPqaML3Rfb Y3WkT2ijvedQ) and soon.

Without Michaelangelo it is not The Last Ronin. A 4th mini? Its already milked dry, I would have argued at least after The Lost Years. IDW's deserate crutch to stay alive is what a 4th Last Ronin mini is.

This is like how The Sequel trilogy craps all over The Originial trilogy. Dont try to tell me ' let the past die, kill it if you have to' or 'somehow Shredder has returned'.:roll:

CyberCubed
05-01-2025, 05:36 PM
Why can't things just ever like...end.

Zog The Magnificent
05-01-2025, 07:17 PM
Why can't things just ever like...end.

Amen.

Or, even better, end and then NOT get dug back up later, which is almost worse than going on too long in the first place.

TheLabRat
05-02-2025, 12:20 AM
Without Michaelangelo it is not The Last Ronin. A 4th mini? Its already milked dry, I would have argued at least after The Lost Years. IDW's deserate crutch to stay alive is what a 4th Last Ronin mini is.

This is like how The Sequel trilogy craps all over The Originial trilogy. Dont try to tell me ' let the past die, kill it if you have to' or 'somehow Shredder has returned'.:roll:

Although The Lost Years story is already bad for me...

ToTheNines
05-02-2025, 04:07 AM
Last Ronin III confirmed (https://www.ign.com/articles/tmnt-the-last-ronin-ii-ends-in-major-tragedy-for-the-new-turtles?fbclid=IwY2xjawKAvbRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkE TF1WXJudXFMMjVYN0VOZ2Z5AR4JuEOCeSv_4AltT0GzPEOnp8a 7DWzuTa2QpwaAtwHGt0uMIR7R5PZPbCI3iQ_aem_xPqaML3Rfb Y3WkT2ijvedQ) and soon.

Pain.

The casuals are dabbing on us.

Allio
05-03-2025, 12:51 AM
Why can't things just ever like...end.

I don’t know. Ask Batman

TheLabRat
06-01-2025, 11:17 AM
Another weak element of TLR is that all the heroes and villains are pretty black/white.
I was expecting some "gray" morality or a villain/hero turn of some sort.

I wish there were more surprises.
I was thinking of getting the TLR 2 if it was significantly different, but I guess not.
I think is because Hiroto is just boring, he doesn't actually do anything that make you hate him, or even some really crazy, horrible stuff like use the bodies of Splinter and Donnie as specimens or even transform them into cyborgs as his slave warriors, slaughtering all the Hamato Clan in Japan, doing something terrible to April, or maybe he just has an Oedipus complex, but there is a plot where he date and sleep with a robot that looks like Karai.