View Full Version : Does IDW have the right to reprint Volume 4?
neatoman
05-09-2022, 07:12 AM
So with the recent introduction of Seri in the IDW comics, I've been wondering about IDW's rights to print Volume 4.
Volume 4 is so far one of the few exceptions to the Mirage books IDW hasn't printed yet. Most of the exemptions made have been in regards to copyright/royalty disputes and the Tales reprints seemingly just stopped due to a lack of sales. But so far, most of Volume 1, 2 and 3 have been published and those ones concluded quite a while ago. So it is curious as to why they haven't bothered to print Volume 4 yet, I know Laird has the right to continue publishing the book but I've never heard him or anyone else say this would prevent IDW from printing it. The only other reason I could think of is that the book remains unfinished but that would not prevent them from publishing a trade of the issues that do exist.
CyberCubed
05-09-2022, 12:18 PM
Yes there's no reason they wouldn't have the rights. They probably haven't done it since the series was never finished and stopped at issue 32. And unlike the Image series conclusion where they got to make 3 new issues to wrap up the series, here there's no way they'd convince Peter Laird to come back to do it.
Andrew NDB
05-09-2022, 12:26 PM
In the past Laird made allusions to IDW not having the right to reprint anything he put out after the sale happened. Which is, what, the last two issues of it?
Yes there's no reason they wouldn't have the rights. They probably haven't done it since the series was never finished and stopped at issue 32. And unlike the Image series conclusion where they got to make 3 new issues to wrap up the series, here there's no way they'd convince Peter Laird to come back to do it.
It's hard to imagine him doing anything but scoffing at them. Because it's not like he ever "left." He still has his 18 comics a year clause. He never came out and said the book is cancelled. The next issue could drop next month for all we know, and I think that's the way he likes it.
"Hey hurry up and finish so we can put out these trades!" probably wouldn't do much. Or it might, but I doubt it.
Sharman
05-10-2022, 05:29 AM
Oh, if only ...
superstaff
06-03-2022, 07:17 AM
It's hard to imagine him doing anything but scoffing at them. Because it's not like he ever "left." He still has his 18 comics a year clause. He never came out and said the book is cancelled. The next issue could drop next month for all we know, and I think that's the way he likes it.
Is it that he's butthurt over the reactions to volume 4? I mean, to be honest, volume 4 really was strange, and outright offputting. Some good ideas here and there, but overall just..."why?". I guess Laird sees opinions like mine, and it's made him resentful? I guess?
Leo656
06-03-2022, 07:28 AM
I guess Laird sees opinions like mine, and it's made him resentful? I guess?
It did even back then. I was clearing out my Inbox last night, and found some old PMs from 2003 where members were talking about how they knew for a fact Laird was hawking the forum, as in the Vol. 4 letter column he'd often recite almost word-for-word various 'Drome members' specific criticisms and then give some kind of snarky rebuttal, usually in the vein of "If you don't like it, don't buy it."
He did it to me ONCE as I recall - I'd told an anecdote here about having a conversation with a DC/Marvel penciller I'd recently bumped into at a signing, we'd just been shooting the sh*t about comic book artists, and somehow Lawson's name came up and the guy (whose name escapes me now) had nothing good to say, basically something like "I've seen little kids draw better than that guy". And in the very next issue Laird had a whole screed defending Lawson and he specifically mentioned that anecdote and how such an indictment was "ridiculous". So I was like "Ahhhh, okay, I see how it is."
But there were quite a few others here he did the same thing with, as well, and apparently in more detail.
I mean, I do believe that seeing such a negative response did in fact kill any remaining enthusiasm he'd had for doing the book, and that is a shame. But as I've always said, in a commercial medium and a book about popular pop culture characters, much as I'm in favor of artists being true to their own vision I think you *do* owe your fanbase SOMETHING.
There was most likely a satisfying Happy Medium somewhere in between Laird's "pure vision" for the book and what the audience expected/demanded, and I feel like he never even attempted to find his way there and just stuck to the former out of spite, then blamed the fanbase when the book didn't do better and in turn he decided to take his ball and go home.
But yeah, he was always pretty salty that people here weren't huge fans. But I don't think he ever truly tried to understand or appreciate Why Not.
mrmaczaps
06-03-2022, 08:51 AM
It did even back then. I was clearing out my Inbox last night, and found some old PMs from 2003 where members were talking about how they knew for a fact Laird was hawking the forum, as in the Vol. 4 letter column he'd often recite almost word-for-word various 'Drome members' specific criticisms and then give some kind of snarky rebuttal, usually in the vein of "If you don't like it, don't buy it."
He did it to me ONCE as I recall - I'd told an anecdote here about having a conversation with a DC/Marvel penciller I'd recently bumped into at a signing, we'd just been shooting the sh*t about comic book artists, and somehow Lawson's name came up and the guy (whose name escapes me now) had nothing good to say, basically something like "I've seen little kids draw better than that guy". And in the very next issue Laird had a whole screed defending Lawson and he specifically mentioned that anecdote and how such an indictment was "ridiculous". So I was like "Ahhhh, okay, I see how it is."
But there were quite a few others here he did the same thing with, as well, and apparently in more detail.
I mean, I do believe that seeing such a negative response did in fact kill any remaining enthusiasm he'd had for doing the book, and that is a shame. But as I've always said, in a commercial medium and a book about popular pop culture characters, much as I'm in favor of artists being true to their own vision I think you *do* owe your fanbase SOMETHING.
There was most likely a satisfying Happy Medium somewhere in between Laird's "pure vision" for the book and what the audience expected/demanded, and I feel like he never even attempted to find his way there and just stuck to the former out of spite, then blamed the fanbase when the book didn't do better and in turn he decided to take his ball and go home.
But yeah, he was always pretty salty that people here weren't huge fans. But I don't think he ever truly tried to understand or appreciate Why Not.
TBF, Laird isn't impressed at all with what Nick/IDW has been doing either and usually gets upset if people ask him about it all. Which is probably why he has also stopped doing his blogs... And while there is a bit in v4 thats not great, its not terrible either.
superstaff
06-03-2022, 09:03 AM
I mean, I do believe that seeing such a negative response did in fact kill any remaining enthusiasm he'd had for doing the book, and that is a shame. But as I've always said, in a commercial medium and a book about popular pop culture characters, much as I'm in favor of artists being true to their own vision I think you *do* owe your fanbase SOMETHING.
There was most likely a satisfying Happy Medium somewhere in between Laird's "pure vision" for the book and what the audience expected/demanded, and I feel like he never even attempted to find his way there and just stuck to the former out of spite, then blamed the fanbase when the book didn't do better and in turn he decided to take his ball and go home.
Yeah, this seems to happen very often with creators, more specifically in the comics fandom, and to be even more specific with TMNT in particular. I think there is also a happy medium between presenting your true vision as a writer, but also pleasing your fanbase. I also feel like some writers get very defensive about criticism, even the well meaning kind. I get some fans can be huge dicks about that, and some just troll without even really caring about the quality of writing. Still, I think, as a writer, it's all stuff that should be considered.
TBF, Laird isn't impressed at all with what Nick/IDW has been doing either and usually gets upset if people ask him about it all. Which is probably why he has also stopped doing his blogs... And while there is a bit in v4 thats not great, its not terrible either.
I get why he isn't into the new stuff at all, and I don't get how the fans can be surprised by that if they knew anything about Laird, even if they enjoy the Nick/IDW stuff.
It's still a shame he's divorced himself from the fanbase, and will probably never finish volume 4. I didn't like a lot of it (some ideas, and content, I did think were pretty neat), but...I'd have liked to see it finished anyhow, just to see where his ideas were going.
Leo656
06-03-2022, 09:11 AM
Laird basically tried to be all how David Lynch ended up doing "Twin Peaks: The Return", in the way he was all like "This is the story, it's not at all what you want/expect but tough rocks, deal with it."
It's just that David Lynch is DAVID LYNCH, and thus, Twin Peaks ended up being possibly even more compelling than anything the audience ever could have asked for. Whereas Laird's "pure" take just felt kind of... meandering and self-serving.
Watching "The Return", I was alternatively frustrated by not getting what I'd wanted and yet fascinated, intrigued, and overwhelmed by just how much BETTER it ended up being than any fanfic version I had in my head. That's the right way to do it.
Laird, sadly, is no David Lynch as a writer. But to be fair to him... nobody is. That guy's a f*cking madman and he just operates on a whole other level.
You think I like Snyder a bunch, don't let me get started on Lynch without bringing a blanket and some motherf*cking cocoa. :lol:
superstaff
06-03-2022, 09:27 AM
Oh, I agree with you about Lynch. He's a master storyteller, and director. The reason Twin Peaks The Return was satisfying was because it wasn't just...like a series of disconnected ideas that didn't mesh well with the series that came before it. I think one of the reasons volume 4 came off as poorly as it did was partly because Laird seemingly threw a bunch of weird things into the story just for the sake of it, and there wasn't any pay-off for it (partly because it was unfinished). It just left readers not understanding the point of any of it. It didn't help that the main cast were all scattered about, doing different things, and not really interacting together much at all. There wasn't a 'connective tissue' to anything that was happening, so to speak, at least not one that we got to see.
Coola Yagami
06-04-2022, 05:51 PM
Oh, I agree with you about Lynch. He's a master storyteller, and director. The reason Twin Peaks The Return was satisfying was because it wasn't just...like a series of disconnected ideas that didn't mesh well with the series that came before it. I think one of the reasons volume 4 came off as poorly as it did was partly because Laird seemingly threw a bunch of weird things into the story just for the sake of it, and there wasn't any pay-off for it (partly because it was unfinished). It just left readers not understanding the point of any of it. It didn't help that the main cast were all scattered about, doing different things, and not really interacting together much at all. There wasn't a 'connective tissue' to anything that was happening, so to speak, at least not one that we got to see.
I kinda feel like, Laird was going with the idea of brothers growing up and going their separate ways. Before the whole Utrom multi-universe thing, the world was still relatively 'normal' so the Turtles were pretty much forced to stick together because they only had each other. But now that the world had aliens in it and it eventually became kinda normal to co-exist with them and the Turtles could easily blend in as fellow aliens, now they were free to branch out into the world and follow their own paths.
I'm assuming eventually Volume 4 would have ended with some big threat that made the Turtles get back together again. Now normally I would say this would end the story on a happy note, that the brothers will always be brothers and always be together.... but this is Mirage. It would not honestly not surprise me if after the Turtles defeat the threat and high-five and maybe have a happy family dinner or whatever there is some mention somewhere stating 'and this is the last time all four of them were together'.
mrmaczaps
06-04-2022, 07:47 PM
I kinda feel like, Laird was going with the idea of brothers growing up and going their separate ways. Before the whole Utrom multi-universe thing, the world was still relatively 'normal' so the Turtles were pretty much forced to stick together because they only had each other. But now that the world had aliens in it and it eventually became kinda normal to co-exist with them and the Turtles could easily blend in as fellow aliens, now they were free to branch out into the world and follow their own paths.
I'm assuming eventually Volume 4 would have ended with some big threat that made the Turtles get back together again. Now normally I would say this would end the story on a happy note, that the brothers will always be brothers and always be together.... but this is Mirage. It would not honestly not surprise me if after the Turtles defeat the threat and high-five and maybe have a happy family dinner or whatever there is some mention somewhere stating 'and this is the last time all four of them were together'.
Most of the Tales stories that take place sometime in the future, shows that the guys all go their own ways... which is most real life like scenario... Would have been nice for Laird to tell a few of those stories in v4 before it ended but... he did his own thing too.
superstaff
06-04-2022, 10:07 PM
I'm assuming eventually Volume 4 would have ended with some big threat that made the Turtles get back together again. Now normally I would say this would end the story on a happy note, that the brothers will always be brothers and always be together.... but this is Mirage. It would not honestly not surprise me if after the Turtles defeat the threat and high-five and maybe have a happy family dinner or whatever there is some mention somewhere stating 'and this is the last time all four of them were together'.
That would still be a satisfying ending, if you ask me.
Zog The Magnificent
06-05-2022, 01:11 AM
That would still be a satisfying ending, if you ask me.
At this point, I'd take ANY ending. I hate loose ends more than I hate bad endings. I'd take the Necromomicon turning everyone into a chicken and then they all high five. At least then I could finally stop thinking about it.
Andrew NDB
06-05-2022, 01:11 AM
I wouldn't be surprised if Peter never really had an end in mind. That he was just going where the muse took him, wherever that might lead. I mean, probably a general sense of how each Turtle would end up in the distant future, not so much how that would be setup in Vol. 4's ending.
Even if Peter won't finish it couldn't IDW hire Jim Lawson and Eric Talbot to finish it up?
Andrew NDB
06-05-2022, 02:00 AM
Even if Peter won't finish it couldn't IDW hire Jim Lawson and Eric Talbot to finish it up?
I think so. But they'd have to ignore like the last two issues Peter did. Like, they wouldn't legally be able to reference them at all, I think.
Would they have any inclination to do so? Highly doubtful. More likely that at some point, if he truly makes up his mind that he'll never, ever revisit it, Laird would just give Jim his blessing to do a completion on his own and have it published for him.
Coola Yagami
06-05-2022, 02:44 AM
I think so. But they'd have to ignore like the last two issues Peter did. Like, they wouldn't legally be able to reference them at all, I think.
Hmm I kinda missed the specifics of that. I know he had the rights to make like 2 comics a year or whatever. Is it maybe cause the last 2 issues were digital only or something?
Andrew NDB
06-05-2022, 02:48 AM
Hmm I kinda missed the specifics of that. I know he had the rights to make like 2 comics a year or whatever. Is it maybe cause the last 2 issues were digital only or something?
No, it's because Nickelodeon only owns everything Peter did up until the sale. The last two issues he did after the sale, so they don't own them.
Coola Yagami
06-05-2022, 03:09 AM
No, it's because Nickelodeon only owns everything Peter did up until the sale. The last two issues he did after the sale, so they don't own them.
Ohhhh right. Dang. That really does put a damper on things. They'd literally would have to create all new versions of the last 2 issues and that defeats the whole purpose. Like how do you continue an ongoing story when you can't reference what happened just the issue before?
Our hero is about to fall off a cliff.... no he's not, now he's suddenly back home with this family as he was 2 issues before that cliffhanger.
frank_one
06-05-2022, 05:19 AM
Even if Peter won't finish it couldn't IDW hire Jim Lawson and Eric Talbot to finish it up?Lawson would never to it without Laird's blessing and I doubt Laird will ever accept of not being able to conclude the story himself.
mrmaczaps
06-05-2022, 05:30 AM
Lawson & Lavigne already both offered to finish off v4 and also to start a vol 5 under Mirage a few years back and it angered Laird that they even offered & had a plot detailed out for him... One or the both of them mentioned this at a signing once.
As far as Nick not owning the details of issues 31 & 32, my understanding is they own turtles & Laird just has the right to write/produce 18 issues a year and they'd still own those too. Its another reason why he hasn't done it because it doesn't make sense for him to do more, charge $10 cover price just so IDW can reprint it later at $3.99 (or whatever) and immediately make money on something that cost Laird money. (As he explained once at a Lavigne signing....)
I would love to have seen what Lavigne & Lawson had come up with though. Laird has to be involved in whatever q8 issues get done but that doesn't mean he can't enlist any/all of the Mirage guys to do the work itself & just over see it. Even if they just wrote a double sized final narration with few smaller insert drawings to wrap it up...
superstaff
06-05-2022, 08:48 AM
Lawson & Lavigne already both offered to finish off v4 and also to start a vol 5 under Mirage a few years back and it angered Laird that they even offered & had a plot detailed out for him... One or the both of them mentioned this at a signing once.
Man...
I get that TMNT is their baby, and I support creators rights, but...
Wow, Eastman and Laird are just. Ugh.
Eastman will eat up anything, it seems, no matter how dumb and disrespectful it is to the TMNT mythos. Laird is the opposite, and he'll throw a huge hissyfit at anything that doesn't 100% fit his vision, apparently. I guess I'd take Laird over Eastman, though they are both at such extreme ends of the spectrum that it's frustrating.
mrmaczaps
06-05-2022, 02:01 PM
Man...
I get that TMNT is their baby, and I support creators rights, but...
Wow, Eastman and Laird are just. Ugh.
Eastman will eat up anything, it seems, no matter how dumb and disrespectful it is to the TMNT mythos. Laird is the opposite, and he'll throw a huge hissyfit at anything that doesn't 100% fit his vision, apparently. I guess I'd take Laird over Eastman, though they are both at such extreme ends of the spectrum that it's frustrating.
Their best stuff is stuff they both worked on together.... it allows for a happy medium.
I would have loved to see what Lavigne & Lawson could have done together. That would have been great and not violated the "rules" with Nick as long as Laird over saw what was going on... as editor or whatever.
Andrew NDB
06-05-2022, 05:28 PM
Lawson & Lavigne already both offered to finish off v4 and also to start a vol 5 under Mirage a few years back and it angered Laird that they even offered & had a plot detailed out for him... One or the both of them mentioned this at a signing once.
As far as Nick not owning the details of issues 31 & 32, my understanding is they own turtles & Laird just has the right to write/produce 18 issues a year and they'd still own those too. Its another reason why he hasn't done it because it doesn't make sense for him to do more, charge $10 cover price just so IDW can reprint it later at $3.99 (or whatever) and immediately make money on something that cost Laird money. (As he explained once at a Lavigne signing....)
I would love to have seen what Lavigne & Lawson had come up with though. Laird has to be involved in whatever q8 issues get done but that doesn't mean he can't enlist any/all of the Mirage guys to do the work itself & just over see it. Even if they just wrote a double sized final narration with few smaller insert drawings to wrap it up...
No, Nick wouldn't own anything Laird does or creates in the 18 comics a year clause.
Also he answered me once that he couldn't just publish somebody else's stuff. He would have to -- legally -- be heavily involved in it, not just editorially.
mrmaczaps
06-05-2022, 05:54 PM
No, Nick wouldn't own anything Laird does or creates in the 18 comics a year clause.
Also he answered me once that he couldn't just publish somebody else's stuff. He would have to -- legally -- be heavily involved in it, not just editorially.
So if he drafted the script/outline and then let Lavigne & Lawson do the work then edited it, would that be enough? I know its odd to speculate but it just seems like he could have done something in the past decade to make use of the provision, otherwise why fight to include it in the sale?
If Nick owns the turtles, how would they not own anything he puts out? I heard him himself say he didn't want to do more at a cost to himself, self publishing it, just for nick/idw to be able to reprint it basically dirt cheap... seems really pointless again, for the clause to exist for both parties.
Andrew NDB
06-06-2022, 01:55 AM
So if he drafted the script/outline and then let Lavigne & Lawson do the work then edited it, would that be enough? I know its odd to speculate but it just seems like he could have done something in the past decade to make use of the provision, otherwise why fight to include it in the sale?
He's been very clear about why. To have the peace of mind while signing the deal that IF he so chose to, he could one day continue/complete Vol. 4. Rather than remove that possibility entirely, which would make him not want to sign.
If Nick owns the turtles, how would they not own anything he puts out?
Because that isn't the deal they signed. Though I admit, (and I'm sure it's airtight because it would've had to have been) I'm curious... not that he would, but out of curiosity could he put out a new issue of Vol. 4 and have Casey go nuts and shoot up a grocery store and Nick could have absolutely nothing to say about it? I'm not sure. There might be some Nick provisions in there. Maybe he does have to run any scripts/material up the flagpole to Nick for some measure of approvals and he didn't like that pretty quickly and that's part of why he didn't do much more Vol. 4.
mrmaczaps
06-06-2022, 09:48 AM
He's been very clear about why. To have the peace of mind while signing the deal that IF he so chose to, he could one day continue/complete Vol. 4. Rather than remove that possibility entirely, which would make him not want to sign.
Because that isn't the deal they signed. Though I admit, (and I'm sure it's airtight because it would've had to have been) I'm curious... not that he would, but out of curiosity could he put out a new issue of Vol. 4 and have Casey go nuts and shoot up a grocery store and Nick could have absolutely nothing to say about it? I'm not sure. There might be some Nick provisions in there. Maybe he does have to run any scripts/material up the flagpole to Nick for some measure of approvals and he didn't like that pretty quickly and that's part of why he didn't do much more Vol. 4.
Interesting theory. Quite the jump on character to use Casey. Lol
I don't know anymore than I heard him say he wouldn't want to put the work in, at cost to himself (even tho he can probably afford to do it) just to have IDW be able to turn around & reprint it [if/when they get to volume 4]. And again, while I can't prove it, it makes sense with the cover price of the last 4 issues of v4 being $10 that he'd not want to do all that work and then IDW gets copies & prints copies in China (or wherever) and cover price is $3.99 & they're mass produced to whatever they're printing these days, 20k copies?
I wish Laird well in his chillaxing & all, but I'd still hope he at least writes down where he was going so someday we might all gain access to closure of the series...
frank_one
06-06-2022, 01:13 PM
IF Laird managed to put an end to Vol 4 and to produce and print the remaining issues with his own money, THEN he could sell the rights for those last issues to Nickelodeon and gain his money back.
Coola Yagami
06-06-2022, 06:36 PM
It's kinda rough but at times I feel Laird is a grumpy old man that wished he never created the Turtles in the first place despite the fact that he most likely owes his current lifestyle to them.
Andrew NDB
06-06-2022, 06:40 PM
I wonder if Kevin and Peter time-traveled to their younger bodies in even the early 90s, knowing what they know now, if that would make things turn out differently.
Coola Yagami
06-06-2022, 06:43 PM
I wonder if Kevin and Peter time-traveled to their younger bodies in even the early 90s, knowing what they know now, if that would make things turn out differently.
Kevin would probably be too busy hushing Peter up cause Kevin might think of ways to maybe prevent selling out while Peter would be trying to yell out 'DON'T DO IT!!!! IT'LL RUIN YOUR LIVES' through Kev's hand.
mrmaczaps
06-06-2022, 09:39 PM
I wonder if Kevin and Peter time-traveled to their younger bodies in even the early 90s, knowing what they know now, if that would make things turn out differently.
Kevin might have saved some early Turtle money and bought out Laird? Or they stayed better friends, stayed together & built a turtle empire. Weekly books, NECA toys sooner, no more Playmates after the initial contract ended... lol. A better fleshed out vol 2, a fully completed back in the day vol 3, a vol 4 that has an ending... Maybe another volume of Tales? A Mirage vol 5 that gets weirder. A Turtles Multiverse book. A Lawson & Lavigne duo book. Maybe they never end vol 1 and just keep telling the later volumes stories without renumbering.... legacy numbering, lol...
Or maybe they fvck it all up and it just ends.
Andrew NDB
06-06-2022, 10:58 PM
Going the optimistic route, Kevin probably never would have bothered with buying Heavy Metal and never would have tried NT:TNM. The first movie would be the same but both of them would put their foot down for a proper TMNT II. 2k3 cartoon would had them both at the wheel. It'd also be nice to imagine Vol. 2 - 4 (or whatever) with them still doing comics together, however sporadically (maybe 4 issue events every once in a while between 15-20 issues of Lawson stuff).
AquaParade
06-08-2022, 02:45 PM
I wonder if Kevin and Peter time-traveled to their younger bodies in even the early 90s, knowing what they know now, if that would make things turn out differently.
Maybe it was too late, but if the property could have been reigned in and survived, we could be in a really cool place right now. It almost seems like it was headed that way, before Peter sold it.
I'd probably trade what we have now for the position Hellboy has typically been in. At least until that unfortunate recent film.
Seems comparable enough, if you focus on the comic aspect of TMNT.
Fans of Hellboy have much less to talk about, but it's of generally higher quality. They got a couple films that are much better than any TMNT film aside from the first.
Then there were those pretty cool direct-to-dvd animations based on stories from the comics - would have traded all the modern tmnt cartoons for something like that, in an instant.
I guess the point is that Hellboy is more quality than quantity. Maybe it's a pointless comparison, but you get the idea - quality>quantity.
On the bright side, I'm glad to be reading the current TMNT comics, playing the games, and keeping an eye out in case the property can strike gold in the movie department again, someday.
serpentnight
08-19-2022, 08:15 AM
According to this email I got from Mirage before they closed their doors they do.
Andrew NDB
08-19-2022, 09:59 AM
According to this email I got from Mirage before they closed their doors they do.
Again, except for the issues since the sale, yes.
serpentnight
08-19-2022, 10:32 AM
Again, except for the issues since the sale, yes.
There were also a few Tales- Vol. 2 issues featuring the Cowboys of Moo Mesa that had to be excluded from the Viacom sale for legal reasons.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.