PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #130 discussion


TigerClaw
06-29-2022, 03:10 PM
Issue #130 just got released, I thought I make this thread to discuss this latest issue, I thought it was pretty good, It has some emotional moments.

shredder orokusaki
06-29-2022, 03:11 PM
Now iam ready to kill Leonardo! HAHHAHAAHAHAHAHA

lonewarrior20
06-29-2022, 03:36 PM
i enjoyed it. i wonder how bludgeon will do as a teacher. also had some good brutality in this one, sheena pulled a killer croc move.

TigerClaw
06-29-2022, 03:40 PM
i enjoyed it. i wonder how bludgeon will do as a teacher. also had some good brutality in this one, sheena pulled a killer croc move.
Also there were some emotional moments.

mrmaczaps
06-29-2022, 03:46 PM
Marginally better than the last 2 years but still super weak. Art is "mushy" for lack of a better term... I really wish they'd bring on a better creative team. I don't care about the entire zoo worth of weaka$$ characters. I want some ninja action & just the turtles. This book has become a sh!tty CW comic book series.

CyberCubed
06-29-2022, 04:54 PM
Man they did a Mortal Kombat fatality on Groundchuck. Kinda funny to see Groundchuck/Dirtbag as mindless zombie mutants here when they're getting major spotlight in the new game and original cartoon comic coming, and in this series they're introduced and killed off in less than 5 issues.

The Punk Frogs are ugly as hell and the artist made them look the same as the Turtles. Some of them looked just like Leonardo, it's really weird they didn't draw all their faces different. I guess this is it for them, I wouldn't be surprised if they move to Florida like they did in the original cartoon.

Venus with Bludgeon is odd if only because I guess she'd be with Karai and the Foot. Still don't know what to make up Shredder now but it's too early. This issue seemed to wrap things up for now setting the next arc up.

Carmen and the other mutants are useless extras though, it is proof the comic introduces way too many additional characters they don't need.

neatoman
06-29-2022, 06:12 PM
Ok, yeah this issue is trash. Why oh why did I fall for the improvements back in 125? The story looked like like it was taking a turn for the better but looking back, it's mostly just that 125 had improved pacing and the sub-plot on the island.

So here is one major flaw with this whole thing:
Clyde claims he saw a turtle abduct Bonnie in 125 and assumes it is Don because of the similar artificial shell. We find out a little later and it's reiterated in this that he actually saw Venus who is Bonnie herself. Now the obvious question is how does that even makes sense? He saw a single individual and believes he witnessed two? How did he make that mistake? I went ahead and checked and there is no direct explanation for how he got so confused. The reason it had to happen was in order for there to be conflict between the turtles and the frogs but it is far too flimsy

Anyway, the drama in this story is just really forced and awkward. Sheena killing Dirtbag is a pretty clear example of an overreaction just done for shock value, it is barely motivated on her part and it would have been enough for her to be in shock to run into Jennika's arms. Likewise I'm not sure I even understand the thought process of some of these characters, Don flat out rejecting the idea that Venus should reconnect with the frogs and then insisting that she shouldn't be regarded as Bonnie at all just seems bizarre to me.

On further reflection on this Punk Frog story, it really just is the pacing that has improved and that's mainly due to there being sub-plots than the main plot being appropriately paced out. On it's own it might possibly be the dumbest, forced garbage story in the TMNT franchise since Out of the Shadows.

TigerClaw
06-29-2022, 06:25 PM
I enjoyed the issue, It has some emotional moments in regards to Venus and the Punk Frogs, Also we are finally introduced to what could be a possible pairing, considering the significance of these two.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FWcmQsIXwAc7m-l?format=jpg&name=small

Coola Yagami
06-29-2022, 11:21 PM
So when does the Armageddon stuff start so I can start buying this again?

MikeandRaph87
06-30-2022, 02:38 AM
Ok, yeah this issue is trash. Why oh why did I fall for the improvements back in 125? The story looked like like it was taking a turn for the better but looking back, it's mostly just that 125 had improved pacing and the sub-plot on the island.

So here is one major flaw with this whole thing:
Clyde claims he saw a turtle abduct Bonnie in 125 and assumes it is Don because of the similar artificial shell. We find out a little later and it's reiterated in this that he actually saw Venus who is Bonnie herself. Now the obvious question is how does that even makes sense? He saw a single individual and believes he witnessed two? How did he make that mistake? I went ahead and checked and there is no direct explanation for how he got so confused. The reason it had to happen was in order for there to be conflict between the turtles and the frogs but it is far too flimsy

Anyway, the drama in this story is just really forced and awkward. Sheena killing Dirtbag is a pretty clear example of an overreaction just done for shock value, it is barely motivated on her part and it would have been enough for her to be in shock to run into Jennika's arms. Likewise I'm not sure I even understand the thought process of some of these characters, Don flat out rejecting the idea that Venus should not reconnect with the frogs and that she shouldn't be regarded as Bonnie at all just seems bizarre to me.

On further reflection on this Punk Frog story, it really just is the pacing that has improved and that's mainly due to there being sub-plots than the main plot being appropriately paced out. On it's own it might possibly be the dumbest, forced garbage story in the TMNT franchise since Out of the Shadows.

So we never learned anything about Groundchuck and Dirtbag? They are murdered by nobody characters without thought and nobody cared?

Leaving the Bonnie identity behind, it is like symbolism for gender identity politics. How is this comic 'improving? It sounds frustrating! I would rather see Groundchuck and Dirtbag expanded upon. Yet they are wasted.

neatoman
06-30-2022, 06:59 AM
So we never learned anything about Groundchuck and Dirtbag? They are murdered by nobody characters without thought and nobody cared?

Leaving the Bonnie identity behind, it is like symbolism for gender identity politics. How is this comic 'improving? It sounds frustrating! I would rather see Groundchuck and Dirtbag expanded upon. Yet they are wasted.

No, we do not find out anything about Groundchuck and Dirtbag, they're basically just a pair of Frankenstein creations that exist to be killed off. I don't even think they actually say anything.

The comic improved in the sense that it wasn't painfully uneventful anymore, which was the biggest problem. Of course, it is still really awkward and keeps neglecting important details, so it still can't be called good.

So when does the Armageddon stuff start so I can start buying this again?

TMNT: The Armageddon Game-Opening Moves #01 comes out in two weeks, with the actual series starting in September.

MikeandRaph87
06-30-2022, 07:05 AM
No, we do not find out anything about Groundchuck and Dirtbag, they're basically just a pair of Frankenstein creations that exist to be killed off. I don't even think they actually say anything.

The comic improved in the sense that it wasn't painfully uneventful anymore, which was the biggest problem. Of course, it is still really awkward and keeps neglecting important details, so it still can't be called good.

There was nothing Frankenstein about Dirtbag.

It is a shame that the pair are misused and their potential continues to be wasted!

ProphetofGanja
06-30-2022, 07:43 AM
Ok, yeah this issue is trash. Why oh why did I fall for the improvements back in 125? The story looked like like it was taking a turn for the better but looking back, it's mostly just that 125 had improved pacing and the sub-plot on the island.

So here is one major flaw with this whole thing:
Clyde claims he saw a turtle abduct Bonnie in 125 and assumes it is Don because of the similar artificial shell. We find out a little later and it's reiterated in this that he actually saw Venus who is Bonnie herself. Now the obvious question is how does that even makes sense? He saw a single individual and believes he witnessed two? How did he make that mistake? I went ahead and checked and there is no direct explanation for how he got so confused. The reason it had to happen was in order for there to be conflict between the turtles and the frogs but it is far too flimsy

Anyway, the drama in this story is just really forced and awkward. Sheena killing Dirtbag is a pretty clear example of an overreaction just done for shock value, it is barely motivated on her part and it would have been enough for her to be in shock to run into Jennika's arms. Likewise I'm not sure I even understand the thought process of some of these characters, Don flat out rejecting the idea that Venus should not reconnect with the frogs and that she shouldn't be regarded as Bonnie at all just seems bizarre to me.

On further reflection on this Punk Frog story, it really just is the pacing that has improved and that's mainly due to there being sub-plots than the main plot being appropriately paced out. On it's own it might possibly be the dumbest, forced garbage story in the TMNT franchise since Out of the Shadows.

Basically my thoughts exactly, man. The art was OK to me, not my favorite but totally acceptable. The story's plot and pacing, however, probably make it one of the absolute weakest issues in my opinion. Like you said, a lot of characters doing things that make no sense or are completely out of character... certain moments being brushed over completely (Leonardo is just like "OK yeah lemme call the bros" when Spooky Shredder is just like "we need to talk"?? yeah right), other moments dragging on waaay toooo longgggg, like why are we trying to get an emotional return on third-tier characters that haven't even appeared a dozen times yet

I didn't even attempt to reconcile the issues with Clyde thinking he saw one turtle at the scene of the crime but then mistakenly fingering Donnie, because it was all just so dumb I couldn't even bring myself to try :lol: Anyways, I'm looking forward to Armageddon Game, which I hope to be a return to form for IDW

Lord Nightwalker
06-30-2022, 08:16 AM
Honestly, I'm digging the redemption of Saki.
That's never been done before. And, leaves it wide open for a new villainous take or Shredder.
Could be done using the corpse of Karais father and the dragon scale. Could be a certain scary utrom takes up the mantle.
Either way, it's cool Saki gets to finally be himself, and we get to see that.
There's tons of potential here.
It just needs to be utilized.
And now we know how the four "Dark" turtles get made. I'm hoping it's one insane fight when they square off four on four. Unless they have a surprise, evil Jennika too. Regardless, this is the opportunity to show some decisive, viciously fast paced martial arts action.

MikeandRaph87
06-30-2022, 08:25 AM
Honestly, I'm digging the redemption of Saki.
That's never been done before. And, leaves it wide open for a new villainous take or Shredder.
Could be done using the corpse of Karais father and the dragon scale. Could be a certain scary utrom takes up the mantle.
Either way, it's cool Saki gets to finally be himself, and we get to see that.
There's tons of potential here.
It just needs to be utilized.
And now we know how the four "Dark" turtles get made. I'm hoping it's one insane fight when they square off four on four. Unless they have a surprise, evil Jennika too. Regardless, this is the opportunity to show some decisive, viciously fast paced martial arts action.

How were they created? I am not sure how the dragon scale works.

Reading this makes me feel justified in skipping the title and reading all of the tie-ins.

CyberCubed
06-30-2022, 08:49 AM
They should really do away with Carmen and the extra mutants like the ant guy, the hippo, the other shark, and so forth. Also Lita and the 3 weasels haven't appeared in awhile I forgot about them. Sheena being axed would be a good idea too.

Weird how Venus and Jennika are here but Venus being a recurring character will make them feel different besides the magic stuff.

Basically it's the same stuff the book has always had problems with and that's introducing way too many secondary and third-tier characters. We really don't need all these C-tier and D-tier characters around regularly.

TigerClaw
06-30-2022, 09:29 AM
They should really do away with Carmen and the extra mutants like the ant guy, the hippo, the other shark, and so forth. Also Lita and the 3 weasels haven't appeared in awhile I forgot about them. Sheena being axed would be a good idea too.

Weird how Venus and Jennika are here but Venus being a recurring character will make them feel different besides the magic stuff.

Basically it's the same stuff the book has always had problems with and that's introducing way too many secondary and third-tier characters. We really don't need all these C-tier and D-tier characters around regularly.
I 100% disagree, They are hear to stay, They are great additions to the series.

ProphetofGanja
06-30-2022, 09:57 AM
I 100% disagree, They are hear to stay, They are great additions to the series.

https://c.tenor.com/sxdFChvJrPsAAAAd/eminem-your-opinion-is-wrong.gif

TigerClaw
06-30-2022, 10:18 AM
https://c.tenor.com/sxdFChvJrPsAAAAd/eminem-your-opinion-is-wrong.gif
https://media.giphy.com/media/gzo6lUv8p8hMc/giphy.gif

Sumac
06-30-2022, 11:11 AM
Opinions of furries should always be discarded.

neatoman
06-30-2022, 11:34 AM
I 100% disagree, They are hear to stay, They are great additions to the series.

How are they "great" when they basically do nothing noteworthy?

TigerClaw
06-30-2022, 12:15 PM
How are they "great" when they basically do nothing noteworthy?
Who says they have to be noteworthy?

Andrew NDB
06-30-2022, 12:17 PM
Who says they have to be noteworthy?

The very minimal, basic writing standards since forever?

neatoman
06-30-2022, 12:55 PM
Who says they have to be noteworthy?

I'm not even sure how to respond to this, it is just a bizarre idea, so I'll just to list off as many possible responses I can think of and hope they seem appropriate:


In the simplest possible definition of a story, it is about characters initiating and altering events. Characters who do not do this barely have a function in the story and could potentially get cut.

In order for a character to leave an impact on the audience, they need to clear defining traits and a significant amount of focus put on them, otherwise it becomes hard to get invested in them.

If a character doesn't do much, there is very little between them and a background object, making them easy to forget.

If a character gets a lot of focus but serves very little purpose in the story, it pulls away from the events and characters that could actually interest the audience, making them largely pointless.

A character without defining traits or goals is one that lacks interesting traits and is thus a boring character.

There is such a thing as a bloated cast of characters, this can easily stretch the focus very thin and it becomes difficult to pay attention to what is going on.


I can probably think of even more but I hope you get the point.

Leo656
06-30-2022, 02:51 PM
Leaving the Bonnie identity behind, it is like symbolism for gender identity politics.

It's pretty clear that "Venus" is supposed to be symbolic of people who have "transitioned". That's the entire point.

This book is so ass. Every decision misguided from its conception and furthermore executed horribly.

How are they "great" when they basically do nothing noteworthy?

He gets to fap to them. That's the only f*cking thing he cares about. It's ridiculous.

mrmaczaps
06-30-2022, 04:16 PM
The only characters that matter in this book should be the turtles, the foot, Shredder/Splinter, Casey & April. Everyone else should be foot fodder... if they get a name, they need a function beyond crying all the time. So many wasted pages of useless, do nothing characters.... pandering.

ProphetofGanja
06-30-2022, 04:45 PM
https://media.giphy.com/media/gzo6lUv8p8hMc/giphy.gif

lmfao ya got me :lol:

https://c.tenor.com/LAcYOwpSIpcAAAAd/yugioh-no-u.gif

But seriously, folks, what's particularly frustrating about a lot of the stuff from the "Mutant Town" arc (as it's likely going to be known as), is that there were good ideas there, they just weren't executed very well. A lot of the ideas were terrible, too, though, and that has definitely impacted the quality of the series for the past year or so. So many characters have become pointless, functioning either as background stand-ins or plot devices, while SO FREAKING MANY new, pointless characters have been introduced, I can only imagine all the stupid wikia pages being generated for "Unnamed Ant Mutant #2" :roll: Nobody has any idea what to do with April, or Alopex, or Angel (remember her? Nobody does :lol:), or even some of these new characters like why the fvck is Sheena on the page so goddamn much? Jesus Christ where is Tom smh I need to eat dinner

Cloudrunner
06-30-2022, 11:46 PM
Who says they have to be noteworthy?

It feels like the overall resistance to your opinion on these forums has turned you into someone that just wants to be deliberately contrarian to everyone else here. I mean I don't EXACTLY blame you for it, there's an overwhelming amount of negativity here. And while I agree with those negative opinions there's only so much beating of a dead horse I can take before I get tired of it.

superstaff
07-01-2022, 11:19 AM
The only characters that matter in this book should be the turtles, the foot, Shredder/Splinter, Casey & April. Everyone else should be foot fodder... if they get a name, they need a function beyond crying all the time. So many wasted pages of useless, do nothing characters.... pandering.

Yes. The core characters should matter. I don't mind new characters. I think TMNT has a lot of weird, interesting characters that can be fun and entertaining. But as you said, they need a function beyond crying, and standing around... Even the core characters suck if they just cry and stand around doing nothing all the time, and they sure do in this series currently.

mrmaczaps
07-01-2022, 12:09 PM
Yes. The core characters should matter. I don't mind new characters. I think TMNT has a lot of weird, interesting characters that can be fun and entertaining. But as you said, they need a function beyond crying, and standing around... Even the core characters suck if they just cry and stand around doing nothing all the time, and they sure do in this series currently.

Most of the series for the last 30 issues has been standing around & crying. Ninja aren't the standing around and crying types.

TigerClaw
07-01-2022, 12:18 PM
Most of the series for the last 30 issues has been standing around & crying. Ninja aren't the standing around and crying types.
But they aren't ordinary ninjas, they are ninja turtles, and they are allowed to cry, The turtles in this comic seem way more human then normal humans.

mrmaczaps
07-01-2022, 01:49 PM
But they aren't ordinary ninjas, they are ninja turtles, and they are allowed to cry, The turtles in this comic seem way more human then normal humans.

This series sucks. They want to keep doing this series, they should call it teenage mutant crybaby turtle furries.

Andrew NDB
07-01-2022, 02:04 PM
Most of the series for the last 30 issues has been standing around & crying. Ninja aren't the standing around and crying types.

Well, they say you write what you know. It turns out, eh, well...

ChosenOne
07-01-2022, 02:57 PM
But they aren't ordinary ninjas, they are ninja turtles, and they are allowed to cry, The turtles in this comic seem way more human then normal humans.

So which is it? Are they Ninja Turtles or are they more human than normal humans...? Now I know for sure you're trolling.

Absolutely forgettable issue, utter trash that closes the arc with a whimper instead of the bang it started out with in #125. There are no words for how dumb this comic has become under Campbell.

Thank goodness for Waltz coming back to wrap it up!

Bahamut810
07-01-2022, 04:14 PM
It's pretty clear that "Venus" is supposed to be symbolic of people who have "transitioned". That's the entire point.

I really hope not. It would be a allegory of people peer pressured to be a transtrender individual with no hope of ever being able to recover from the 'process' she went through. She was literally being forced to transition in the comic.

Leo656
07-01-2022, 04:24 PM
I really hope not. It would be a allegory of people peer pressured to be a transtrender individual with no hope of ever being able to recover from the 'process' she went through. She was literally being forced to transition in the comic.

But she can leave her old life and "deadname" behind and be whatever/whoever she wants to be!

Pretty sure that is meant to be the takeaway.

Bahamut810
07-01-2022, 04:37 PM
But she can leave her old life and "deadname" behind and be whatever/whoever she wants to be!

Pretty sure that is meant to be the takeaway.

I really hope that people are looking too far into this being a potential allegory because of who wrote it. If it is intended to be a trans allegory...WOW.

ChosenOne
07-01-2022, 04:47 PM
I really hope that people are looking too far into this being a potential allegory because of who wrote it. If it is intended to be a trans allegory...WOW.

After all this time, do you really think subtlety is Campbell's strong suit?

She's writing what she knows and sees inside her little bubble, which leaves me terrified at the amount of casual, bloodthirsty maiming featured in several of her issues.

superstaff
07-02-2022, 08:44 AM
I really hope not. It would be a allegory of people peer pressured to be a transtrender individual with no hope of ever being able to recover from the 'process' she went through. She was literally being forced to transition in the comic.

It reminds me of how people thought Gren in Cowboy Bebop was meant to be positive trans representation, even though his backstory is that he was a man in the military who was later imprisoned, and during his time in prison, was forced to take experimental drugs with side effects that increased his estrogen, and had him grow breasts. He learned to live with it, though he was clearly very bitter and angry that being imprisoned (as a result of being betrayed by his friend) and drugged altered his body permanently. The man wasn't trans... He didn't feel discomfort in his original male body...

Hell, I just went to the Bebop wiki to confirm something in Gren's backstory, and the top comment there says 'trans rights'. Omfg..............................

Anyway, Venus (and Jennika, really) is not a great allegory for transition because it's forced on her, as you said. A better idea would be that Venus willingly altered her body because she disliked being a human or a frog or whatever. Or just put in a trans human into the story? Or...something? God, the poor writing in these modern stories piss me off. People don't...seem to have a grasp on how to appropriately convey nuance. Just take Gren in my comment. 'Trans rights'... UGH. GREN WAS NOT TRANSGENDER.

Bahamut810
07-02-2022, 10:32 PM
Anyway, Venus (and Jennika, really) is not a great allegory for transition because it's forced on her, as you said. A better idea would be that Venus willingly altered her body because she disliked being a human or a frog or whatever. Or just put in a trans human into the story? Or...something? God, the poor writing in these modern stories piss me off. People don't...seem to have a grasp on how to appropriately convey nuance. Just take Gren in my comment. 'Trans rights'... UGH. GREN WAS NOT TRANSGENDER.

I guess to be fair...he was in the Netflix series that bombed harder then Big Man over hiroshima.

superstaff
07-03-2022, 06:57 AM
I guess to be fair...he was in the Netflix series that bombed harder then Big Man over hiroshima.

Okay, but that's irrelevant to what I was saying. I'm solely talking about anime Gren.

ProphetofGanja
07-07-2022, 12:49 PM
All in all, sooo much of the Mutant Town story arc is ultimately skippable in the IDW TMNT canon. Like so much.

AquaParade
07-07-2022, 02:36 PM
I still think that when Mr. Waltz left, they should have let Campbell have their fun in Mutant Town, with Jennika, while sending the turtles back to Feudal Japan for a few years, via time travel. I think there is potential for interesting stories there and it'd be somewhat fresh.

Could have probably gotten guys like Sontolouco and Burnham for the Japan series, and had the best of both worlds, in a sense.

I have to wonder if that would have opened people up to Jennika a little more, seeing as they wouldn't feel like she is taking as much away from the other turtles. I don't have a big problem with the character, but it doesn't feel "organic" to me. I don't understand why she has to be a turtle to be a part of the Hamato clan, aside from just the novelty of having a girl turtle.

Although, it is a fun visual novelty to have five-tmnt posing on covers and such. The yellow bandana looks cool too. Idk, I'm sort of mixed on the concept overall.

Zog The Magnificent
07-07-2022, 03:01 PM
That's been one of this run's main problems. Not all of the ideas and concepts that Campbell came up with were bad ones. There are some really good ideas in there that, in the hands of a capable writer, say, oh, Tom Waltz, could have turned out great!

But instead, Campbell focused consistently on the least interesting parts of the initial premise, with more focus given to OCs, politics, and woke allegories, all while sidelining the actual main characters and not advancing the plot in any meaningful way for the longest time.

Mutant Town, at least in the context of this iteration of TMNT, was a great idea that made sense. But it was completely wasted and turned into a 30 issues and counting of meaningless characters and badly written melodrama.

MikeandRaph87
07-07-2022, 03:04 PM
I still think that when Mr. Waltz left, they should have let Campbell have their fun in Mutant Town, with Jennika, while sending the turtles back to Feudal Japan for a few years, via time travel. I think there is potential for interesting stories there and it'd be somewhat fresh.

Could have probably gotten guys like Sontolouco and Burnham for the Japan series, and had the best of both worlds, in a sense.

I have to wonder if that would have opened people up to Jennika a little more, seeing as they wouldn't feel like she is taking as much away from the other turtles. I don't have a big problem with the character, but it doesn't feel "organic" to me. I don't understand why she has to be a turtle to be a part of the Hamato clan, aside from just the novelty of having a girl turtle.

Although, it is a fun visual novelty to have five-tmnt posing on covers and such. The yellow bandana looks cool too. Idk, I'm sort of mixed on the concept overall.

Nah, Mutant Town should have been a mini-series after one arc. One arc was enough of a turn off and the readership response should have resulted in a course correction that resulted into any leftover story that Campbell had to be told in a mini-series like what happened with Tom King's run in the third volume of Batman. There are creators aside from Campbell who had previous experience with IDW's take on Ninja Turtles, who readers would have likely taken better to. I for one would have probably stayed on.

CyberCubed
07-07-2022, 04:55 PM
The thing is even when we move onto the next arc, it's not like Mutant Town or its characters are ever going away. Most of these characters will likely be in the Armaggedon games arc, or beyond, so we're basically stuck with them.

What would you do with Lita and the 3 Weasel kids? Sheena? Mona Lisa? Carmen? The various student mutants? etc? I can't see them ever being written out entirely because that's not how IDW operates, they always keep side characters around.

And now we have Venus and Jennika, two female Turtles, that will likely be here for the entire rest of the series.

MikeandRaph87
07-07-2022, 05:05 PM
The thing is even when we move onto the next arc, it's not like Mutant Town or its characters are ever going away. Most of these characters will likely be in the Armaggedon games arc, or beyond, so we're basically stuck with them.

What would you do with Lita and the 3 Weasel kids? Sheena? Mona Lisa? Carmen? The various student mutants? etc? I can't see them ever being written out entirely because that's not how IDW operates, they always keep side characters around.

And now we have Venus and Jennika, two female Turtles, that will likely be here for the entire rest of the series.

Demutated by Baxter Stockman taking the credit publicly. They move on and we get better stories without them. If any of them needs to die for drama so be it. Treating Groundchuck and Dirtbag established characters like fodder they may as well.

neatoman
07-07-2022, 05:06 PM
I'm wondering if the frogs getting out of Mutant Town is primarily meant to do two things:

Keep them out of the plot until someone feels like using them.
To prevent them from getting cured when the mass de-mutation wave happens.

Anyone else getting that feeling?

Andrew NDB
07-07-2022, 05:15 PM
The thing is even when we move onto the next arc, it's not like Mutant Town or its characters are ever going away. Most of these characters will likely be in the Armaggedon games arc, or beyond, so we're basically stuck with them.

What would you do with Lita and the 3 Weasel kids? Sheena? Mona Lisa? Carmen? The various student mutants? etc? I can't see them ever being written out entirely because that's not how IDW operates, they always keep side characters around.

Archie found a solution for getting rid of all of the Mutanimals. Maybe you guys can hope for the same?

mrmaczaps
07-07-2022, 05:17 PM
Archie found a solution for getting rid of all of the Mutanimals. Maybe you guys can hope for the same?

Perfect solution for Mutant Town.

Zog The Magnificent
07-07-2022, 05:48 PM
Archie found a solution for getting rid of all of the Mutanimals. Maybe you guys can hope for the same?

Perfect solution for Mutant Town.

We could have Armageddon Game start with a peaceful afternoon, showing various shots of the city and the various characters we've picked up over the arc. And then, BOOM! The arc kicks off with bombs all over the city from Rat King or some sort of orbital bombardment from Null. The only character still alive are the main characters, one or two frogs, maybe two or three random side characters, and maybe the weasels. Then the surviors go off with Jennika or Venus to a safe house or something, and the main characers are all that's left to deal with the problem. Put the others with the kids in Dimension X

MikeandRaph87
07-07-2022, 06:22 PM
We could have Armageddon Game start with a peaceful afternoon, showing various shots of the city and the various characters we've picked up over the arc. And then, BOOM! The arc kicks off with bombs all over the city from Rat King or some sort of orbital bombardment from Null. The only character still alive are the main characters, one or two frogs, maybe two or three random side characters, and maybe the weasels. Then the surviors go off with Jennika or Venus to a safe house or something, and the main characers are all that's left to deal with the problem. Put the others with the kids in Dimension X

I already alluded to this. Make it kind of like Coast City. 7 million were slaughtered BUT NO ACTUAL CHARACTERS died. Hal's family, Carol, and Tom were not in town nor any reoccurring villains. Same here. Jennika can be cured of her unique transformation and just before Honeycutt can administer the regular doses the portal goes awry and then the waiting population is atomized. Huge dramatic potential to draw from and no actual character of any true substance dies. It's an all around win except for Campbell and Tiger Claw. City at War title is used repeatedly whether directly drawing from the original story so why not but why not call it 'Megadeath'.

Zog The Magnificent
07-07-2022, 06:51 PM
I already alluded to this. Make it kind of like Coast City. 7 million were slaughtered BUT NO ACTUAL CHARACTERS died. Hal's family, Carol, and Tom were not in town nor any reoccurring villains. Same here. Jennika can be cured of her unique transformation and just before Honeycutt can administer the regular doses the portal goes awry and then the waiting population is atomized. Huge dramatic potential to draw from and no actual character of any true substance dies. It's an all around win except for Campbell and Tiger Claw. City at War title is used repeatedly whether directly drawing from the original story so why not but why not call it 'Megadeath'.

Drats, there I go getting my hopes up.

Of course, while we the readers wouldn't care and would actually rejoice if 90% of the current supporting cast were slaughtered, the main characters themselves care about the characters, which might make it weird when the single most traumatic thing to happen to them since their own deaths and Splinter's death was just never talked about. It would almost cheapen them as characters, which means that best case scenario, we'd still have to deal with 10 issues or so of angsting about it.

MikeandRaph87
07-07-2022, 06:59 PM
I was being nice and letting Jennika live demutated. Any way to put Mutant Town behind us. Whether ot be by Megadeath or a cure. Donatello cured the Underground mutants in the 2003 cartoon and Agent Bishop's accidental mutant virus so a catch all cure is not unreasonable. I also wager that a majority of fans who read and still read it don't like the plotline. When plotlines don't work change direction. As dumb as DC and Marvel can be at times they atleast acknowledge that at times. I vote for the Megadeath idea. Terracide carried on the reproecussions and justice was administered. Same can happen here. A competent writer can make it hold weight and not have the Turtles mope around for issues on end afterward.

mrmaczaps
07-07-2022, 07:16 PM
What about the guys just "wake up" from a Rat King induced nightmare that takes us back to issue 93 or 94 and everything for the last 34 to 36 issues never happened... boom, case closed. Then tell great stories.

MikeandRaph87
07-07-2022, 07:22 PM
What about the guys just "wake up" from a Rat King induced nightmare that takes us back to issue 93 or 94 and everything for the last 34 to 36 issues never happened... boom, case closed. Then tell great stories.

That could work as the opening of the FINAL issue and the Turtles contend with The Dragon with an actual fight and all plot points resolved in 39 pages out of 40 of content.


If we have the same creative team then a relaunch will not work. New creative team afterwards.

Sumac
07-08-2022, 01:46 PM
I don't find value in Mutant Town. Even, if IDW heavily leans into "a lot of mutants around" like FW series, it is much more prominent and basically cheapens concept of Turtles being unique.

Andrew NDB
07-08-2022, 01:58 PM
Is "Burnow Island" still a thing? Why not just relocate Mutant Town there?

MikeandRaph87
07-08-2022, 02:37 PM
Is "Burnow Island" still a thing? Why not just relocate Mutant Town there?

The Triceraton and Utrom populations are sharing it and it's been terraformed so it would be unhabitual to the human turned mutants.

Zog The Magnificent
07-08-2022, 03:50 PM
I'm telling you, just boot them all to Dimension X and then forget about them, like they did with all the orphans. And throw Jennika in there while you're at it. She can the their new manager or whatever, and then we never have to see any of them ever again.

CyberCubed
07-08-2022, 04:02 PM
It's funny, but it really does look like my predictions that Sophie would stay on till at least issue 150 is true. Even if the Armaggedon Game is Waltz story, it's still largely going to be handled or at least co-written by Sophie. So she's not leaving the main series either way.

MikeandRaph87
07-08-2022, 08:23 PM
I'm telling you, just boot them all to Dimension X and then forget about them, like they did with all the orphans. And throw Jennika in there while you're at it. She can the their new manager or whatever, and then we never have to see any of them ever again.

Bobby confessed that had they realized Mutant Town before deciding where to deposit the orphans they would have made the weasel trio and the albino turtle as well as a few others like the dart frog into the Mutant Town residents. It is mentioned somewhere within his thread.

CJStyles
07-11-2022, 11:52 PM
Glad I’m not missing out this on much since I stopped reading towards the beginning of mutant town. I wonder how sales have been due to this poor arc.

Zog The Magnificent
07-12-2022, 04:33 AM
Glad I’m not missing out this on much since I stopped reading towards the beginning of mutant town. I wonder how sales have been due to this poor arc.

There's no real way to know. We'll all say it's doing worse, then this one guy always comes in and cites these sales figures that can't be substantiated, and then someone else usually points out that that only shows retailers and not reader purchases, and then we all disagree about how much it actually sucks, then move onto something else until the next issue comes out, at which point we do the same thing all over again.

ProphetofGanja
07-12-2022, 07:29 AM
There's no real way to know. We'll all say it's doing worse, then this one guy always comes in and cites these sales figures that can't be substantiated, and then someone else usually points out that that only shows retailers and not reader purchases, and then we all disagree about how much it actually sucks, then move onto something else until the next issue comes out, at which point we do the same thing all over again.

https://i.gifer.com/Aojv.gif

hypered1
07-12-2022, 10:10 AM
There's no real way to know. We'll all say it's doing worse, then this one guy always comes in and cites these sales figures that can't be substantiated, and then someone else usually points out that that only shows retailers and not reader purchases, and then we all disagree about how much it actually sucks, then move onto something else until the next issue comes out, at which point we do the same thing all over again.

I'm not about to apologise for preferring tangible evidence over some toothless moron's hearsay.

superstaff
07-12-2022, 10:42 AM
There's no real way to know. We'll all say it's doing worse, then this one guy always comes in and cites these sales figures that can't be substantiated, and then someone else usually points out that that only shows retailers and not reader purchases, and then we all disagree about how much it actually sucks, then move onto something else until the next issue comes out, at which point we do the same thing all over again.

Yeah, basically.

Speaking of which, I don't get why people care either way. Let's say that they are selling like hotcakes, and IDW is making gangbusters on the comic. Does that somehow negate it from all criticism? Does that automatically make it 'better' because it's selling and a financial success? People use these sales numbers (and this applies to TV ratings and box office numbers too) as a d*ck measuring contest to 'prove' the quality of this junk, when it doesn't really prove that at all either. It just means more gullible saps forked over their money to buy this crap, and put the money into the IDW staff's pockets.

hypered1
07-12-2022, 11:05 AM
An audience is an audience even if it's not the one you think it should be.

superstaff
07-12-2022, 11:14 AM
An audience is an audience even if it's not the one you think it should be.

Okay, and? Who cares?

mrmaczaps
07-12-2022, 02:53 PM
An audience is an audience even if it's not the one you think it should be.

Wouldn't it be better to drop the woke bs and write better stories that appeal to a wider audience, that actually BUYS the books to make more money to sell more related products? Rather than staying stuck in the woke bs that has actual readers dropping off the series or only buying it to have a "complete" run? [I would think the first group would be better...]

This series continues to suck at best. Hopefully this new storyline ends the series. Then fire everyone currently working on the book and start over fresh & new.

superstaff
07-12-2022, 03:19 PM
Wouldn't it be better to drop the woke bs and write better stories that appeal to a wider audience, that actually BUYS the books to make more money to sell more related products? Rather than staying stuck in the woke bs that has actual readers dropping off the series or only buying it to have a "complete" run? [I would think the first group would be better...]

Because it's not about telling better stories, it's about 'sending a message'. It's really not about money, they don't care. Whether the comic is selling like hotcakes or flopping like toilet cakes, they don't give a f*ck, and it won't affect the quality of their output. People have been screaming "GO WOKE, GO BROKE" for years now (since 2016, maybe a little earlier), but...it's very clear that 'going broke' doesn't matter to them. At all. In fact, I think a lot of the investors for these sort of projects are willing to throw a ton of money at them if it means, like I said already, sending out the message they want it to.

This series continues to suck at best. Hopefully this new storyline ends the series. Then fire everyone currently working on the book and start over fresh & new.

My advice for you, and everyone else, is to give up. It's not going to get better, and the damage has basically been done. I don't think it'll magically improve after the mess that was Mutant Town, and Jennika being forced as one of the TMNT. It's done. Drop it if you hate it, and move on....... Easier said than done since entertainment sucks now, but...yeah. If you already dropped it then...whatever? I guess peek in these threads, and roll your eyes at how awful the comic is now.

mrmaczaps
07-12-2022, 03:58 PM
Because it's not about telling better stories, it's about 'sending a message'. It's really not about money, they don't care. Whether the comic is selling like hotcakes or flopping like toilet cakes, they don't give a f*ck, and it won't affect the quality of their output. People have been screaming "GO WOKE, GO BROKE" for years now (since 2016, maybe a little earlier), but...it's very clear that 'going broke' doesn't matter to them. At all. In fact, I think a lot of the investors for these sort of projects are willing to throw a ton of money at them if it means, like I said already, sending out the message they want it to.



My advice for you, and everyone else, is to give up. It's not going to get better, and the damage has basically been done. I don't think it'll magically improve after the mess that was Mutant Town, and Jennika being forced as one of the TMNT. It's done. Drop it if you hate it, and move on....... Easier said than done since entertainment sucks now, but...yeah. If you already dropped it then...whatever? I guess peek in these threads, and roll your eyes at how awful the comic is now.

I want to quit it but its like a bad car wreck & I can't seem to look away as I roll passed the body parts on the side of the road next to the car parts.... lol. 40 issues back, I gave up buying the RI covers... might just quit buying the A covers to save money.

Weapons@theready
07-13-2022, 12:23 PM
My advice for you, and everyone else, is to give up. It's not going to get better, and the damage has basically been done. .

Holding out through Armageddon Game and then I'm bowing out

CyberCubed
07-13-2022, 05:14 PM
That's basically what's happening, by issue 150 they will finish the main story arc. Now what they do from issue 151 onward remains to be seen, or if Sophie is replaced, etc.

MikeandRaph87
07-13-2022, 05:56 PM
That's basically what's happening, by issue 150 they will finish the main story arc. Now what they do from issue 151 onward remains to be seen, or if Sophie is replaced, etc.

When I went by my local shop to pick up Opening Moves#1 today another customer asked the employee how the new Daredevil series started off. He stated that it was the same creative team so it's the same as it has been. It's going to be the same case with Ninja Turtles if we have the same creative team relaunch or just the next arc it will not matter. So instead of starting from scratch we need a new creative team, whether it's a relaunch or the next issue #1_ _.

mrmaczaps
07-13-2022, 10:10 PM
When I went by my local shop to pick up Opening Moves#1 today another customer asked the employee how the new Daredevil series started off. He stated that it was the same creative team so it's the same as it has been. It's going to be the same case with Ninja Turtles if we have the same creative team relaunch or just the next arc it will not matter. So instead of starting from scratch we need a new creative team, whether it's a relaunch or the next issue #1_ _.

I'd honestly like to see a few things from IDW.

1. A new "Universe" anthology style book. Maybe every other month shipping. Do 2 or 3 stories per issue. 1st being the bulk of the story thats from any prior universe. Movie. Comics. Toons. Whatever is pre-existing. So, a post TMNT 3 movie tale that shows how they go from Turtles in Time to the 2007 TMNT film? Cool. Take no more than five issues to tell it. Then do one or two back up short stories. But these have to be a different version of the Turtles. Say like movie, cartoon, comics. Then rotate the arcs. Make the stories unfold in a way that allows for them to be reprinted with their own storylines later, so if someone doesn't like Rise or Bay Turtles, for example (like me), I could skip that later trade version... The primary story is he 1987 cartoon with a 2007 tmnt backup (maybe do the intended sequel storyline) and the 3rd backup tale could be something random that would fit the Mirage continuity, like finish off vol 4 with Lawson & Lavigne... if they'd be willing.

Next up would be an IDW dark & gritty adult TMNT comic, without all the toon influences, no Bebop, Rocksteady or Krang & hundreds of mutants of he week popping up...

Then the Ongoing can stay woke garbage and end...

But I'm not in charge, even if I do have a few good story ideas in my head. Even a way to end the Bay-verse & create the crossover.


Also, they could then do a giant Turtles Unlimited and merge all the versions for an epic crossover. But it'll never happen.


Also, a new volume of Tales with 2 short stories. They'd take place in the established IDW Univers3 but could, like Tales used to do, take place anywhere in the timeline. Random Raph before he meets his bros story? Yeah, dude! Random one off of Casey Jones (like the 2 parter in vol 1, but shorter)... Class of Pain starts there. But they have to be written/drawn by new talent, regardless of race, color, creed and all that other self segregating garbage identifiers and it can't contradict any established stories except for maybe retconning the sea turtles thing... lol.

MikeandRaph87
07-19-2022, 01:13 PM
IDW admitted the omission of the letters page and that it will return in the back of #133. I suggest that we write in to [email protected]. The constructive criticism and overall consensus among us should be printed instead of mindless praise.
-Hfhz-SmKNA

ChosenOne
07-19-2022, 01:26 PM
IDW admitted the omission of the letters page and that it will return in the back of #133. I suggest that we write in to [email protected]. The constructive criticism and overall consensus among us should be printed instead of mindless praise.
-Hfhz-SmKNA

I still find it damn funny that even considering the, ahem, curated nature of the letters page, they ran out of mindless praise and had to resort to printing actual criticism from real people instead of shills after a certain point.

Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 01:28 PM
I still find it damn funny that even considering the, ahem, curated nature of the letters page, they ran out of mindless praise and had to resort to printing actual criticism from real people instead of shills after a certain point.

Well, they didn't have to resort to that. They could've easily put a lot of FAKE letters in there, and I'm sure it wouldn't have been the first comic to do so in history. So credit should be given there.

Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 01:29 PM
IDW admitted the omission of the letters page and that it will return in the back of #133. I suggest that we write in to [email protected]. The constructive criticism and overall consensus among us should be printed instead of mindless praise.
-Hfhz-SmKNA

The bitterest truth is better than the sweetest lie.

ChosenOne
07-19-2022, 01:32 PM
Well, they didn't have to resort to that. They could've easily put a lot of FAKE letters in there, and I'm sure it wouldn't have been the first comic to do so in history. So credit should be given there.

Oh, I do think they tried that for a month or two first. Unless they got letters from our resident shills, but same difference.

MikeandRaph87
07-19-2022, 07:51 PM
I am asking for some of us to write in, but I am asking that it not blast the political messages and woke nature, but a constructive criticism showcasing the wheel spinning and generic mutated citizens and question the pause of open plots. Anything that you find fault with
without anyone jumping in to claim prejudice. Maybe

I am sure like myself that others question the big deal the battle of the bands was in-story or an unrecognized mayor of Mutant Town, but the giant waste of space it really was as far as plot advancement. Perhaps the inclusion of characters that I wanted to see, but just throwing them in doesn't work and just as the characters that stick around like Mona Lisa, Lita, the pig mutant, the weasels trio,etc. are not built up or serve any story purpose.