View Full Version : The 2007 movie timeline makes no sense
Leofan26
07-17-2022, 06:03 PM
I guess it’s supposed to be connected to the past 3 live action films but Karai wasn’t introduced till the 2003 series.
Not to mention the intense rivalry Leo and Raph had in this.
This felt more like a final for the 2003 series.
Does any one else feel this way?
CyberCubed
07-17-2022, 06:23 PM
Karai never appeared in the old movies, and this was the first time they met her. So what is the issue here?
Powder
07-17-2022, 07:02 PM
I take it as its own thing. Pretty sure Munroe just made a throwaway comment, regarding that supposed connection. Sure, there's a shelf of easter eggs, but I think that's all it was ever intended to be. Makes no sense for it to be anything else.
Jester
07-17-2022, 07:12 PM
I take it as its own thing. Pretty sure Munroe just made a throwaway comment, regarding that supposed connection. Sure, there's a shelf of easter eggs, but I think that's all it was ever intended to be. Makes no sense for it to be anything else.
Especially since some of those include trophies from adventures involving triceratons and the like.
Leo656
07-17-2022, 07:12 PM
It's like the people who made "Masters of the Universe: Revelation" saying "It's a sequel to the 1980s cartoon!" when no, it VERY clearly is NOT that. It'd make a ton more sense as a sequel to the 2003 MOTU reboot, if anything, but that show wasn't as popular so calling it "a sequel" to that wasn't going to get the same attention.
It's just stuff people say to get attention and doesn't hold up under any scrutiny whatsoever. All Marketing Is Spin. It wouldn't be a big deal, except that people take it seriously and then get angry when "Hey, this doesn't fit Perfectly!" Of course it doesn't, they lied, it's not actually a "sequel" or "follow-up" or any of that. People are supposed to understand that implicitly.
Andrew NDB
07-17-2022, 07:44 PM
It wasn't marketing. It was the writer/director telling us that it's a TMNT1-3 sequel. You can make your own head canon if you really want to, but that's on you.
Leo656
07-17-2022, 07:49 PM
Maybe in their opinion it was. Based on factual evidence, it was not. Just like MOTU: R.
That show wasn't a sequel to Filmation MOTU, it was its own thing with some Easter Eggs. The CGI TMNT movie, same thing. A blink-and-you'll-miss-it shot of a scepter does not a legit sequel make.
Zog The Magnificent
07-17-2022, 08:41 PM
I'm sorry, there's a debate on how this movie fits in with the three live action ones? It doesn't fit at all. It never has, it never was supposed to, it's always been it's own thing. I didn't even know that people were questioning it.
I mean, if a minor easter egg referencing something else counts as rock-solid, bona fide evidence of continuity, then the Archie comics are in continuity with Sonic because of that one time they appeared in a panel of Sonic. Unless, of course, that's just a minor little nod just for fun. Like the shelf in TMNT 2007.
Leo656
07-17-2022, 09:08 PM
Right, or like saying Archie Sonic was a continuation of Sonic SatAM, since they share characters and a few scant episodes of that cartoon were actually adapted into the comics.
Or better yet, like saying Archie TMNT was a sequel to the FW TMNT cartoon, because the book started out with a three-issue mini-series that adapted the cartoon, before IMMEDIATELY going off into its own thing that became highly contradictory of the thing it was a supposed "sequel" to.
There are shared elements between them. Some individual events may have happened in each "universe" mostly the same way, or even Exactly The Same Way.
But they're not legitimately "sequels" or "continuations". Even if at some vague point they were intended to be, and even if the writer tries to force it to fit, the fact remains they are generally incongruous with the thing they're supposedly continuing.
Andrew NDB
07-17-2022, 09:16 PM
There is no "they." It was the writer/director and he was very clear about it.
Leo656
07-17-2022, 09:22 PM
If he was serious about TMNT being a "sequel" to the original trilogy then he did a terrible f*cking job of it.
The evidence is weighted heavily on the side of, "It's its own thing with some callbacks", FAR more than "It's A Legit Sequel". You can "say" whatever you want, but you also have to follow through.
Kevin Smith can say over and over again, "MOTU: R is a sequel to Filmation!" But only a f*cking idiot would watch MOTU: R and actually still believe that. He was the "writer and director" of that show, and the fact is, what he said simply isn't true. MOTU: R contradicts Filmation MOTU at nearly every turn; he said what he said for marketing purposes, nothing more. It Gets Buzz.
Munroe and TMNT, same exact thing. Exactly the same thing. Marketing buzzwords that some people took way too seriously. He can say it until he's blue, he's still wrong.
What's the connective tissue? A single two-second shot at the very end of the movie. NOTHING else.
Reed Richards can't stretch far enough to make the "It's a sequel!" argument convincing.
Kevin Munroe posted on this forum and was always vague about it. I know because I always asked him, If you look at interviews online he always changes his answer and never gives it as "yeah it's a sequel". In fact IIRC he would say "events similar to the first movie and perhaps the second movie happened" and stuff like that.
It's not in continuity with the other live action movies. It's its own continuity. People just like to put it in that timeline because it's s movie and the ending Easter egg that has the time scepter but that's only an Easter egg. You don't see people arguing Sonic is in continuity with Archie TMNT.
The universe does resemble the 2k3 one a little but it doesn't make sense in that continuity either.
CyberCubed
07-17-2022, 10:50 PM
Especially since some of those include trophies from adventures involving triceratons and the like.
Remember in 2007 Mirage released a bunch of prequel comics that took place right before the 2007 movie. Most of them were to show they went on other adventures before the movie (it shows how Raph meets the original Nightwatcher and takes on his mantle, etc), and the Triceratons were obviously met in the movie universe at some point prior to the movie.
Zog The Magnificent
07-17-2022, 11:04 PM
It's a broad strokes stand-alone movie. The movie assumes you understand the basic details of the setting, like their basic personalities, the fact that they live in New York and fight the Foot Clan, and in general who the supporting cast is. That way the movie can do it's own thing without having to use time up establishing the setting.
Andrew NDB
07-17-2022, 11:32 PM
It's a broad strokes stand-alone movie. The movie assumes you understand the basic details of the setting, like their basic personalities, the fact that they live in New York and fight the Foot Clan, and in general who the supporting cast is. That way the movie can do it's own thing without having to use time up establishing the setting.
Basically, yes. But Munroe saw the first two movies as in continuity (and then there's the scepter from 3, which had to have been a late add-in) but did not want to scare new people away by broadly making it TMNT 4 or anything.
Truthfully it does not FEEL like TMNT 4, of course. But it was supposed to be. Kind of.
Leo656
07-17-2022, 11:49 PM
And "Superman Returns" is supposed to be "The REAL Superman III" according to the writer, director, and even WB who owns the entire shebang and can entirely dictate which Superman films are "canon" with each other and which aren't. But some people still push back on that, hard... mostly the ones who don't like the movie. But regardless, "Word of God" says it's "The Real Superman III".
That movie actually can make that case pretty strongly, though. A lot more strongly than TMNT can claim to be a sequel to the other TMNT movies, at any rate. It's still vague, and there's still contradictions or redundancies in spots, but SR actually works pretty well as a sequel to Superman II. In fact, without it, there'd be no real reason for SR to even exist, objectively.
TMNT can't say that. It exists, in a vacuum, as a complete standalone movie and the only connective tissue to the earlier films are stapled-on at the very end. They don't actually affect anything, and if you've never even seen the earlier films, it has no bearing on your ability to understand or enjoy that one on its own.
So again, if it IS a "sequel"... it's not any good at being That. I don't have any huge problems with the movie, other than it's... just kinda There. But a "sequel" should be more than just, "We did three movies, then we waited a while, and then did another movie that has nothing to do with the ones we did forever ago but is technically 'The Next One'."
Also, to be clear, if someone WANTS to pretend it's in the same universe as the original films, I don't have any huge problem with that either, that's their business. I prefer to look at it like Archie TMNT was to FW TMNT, an "offshoot universe" rather than a true "sequel" universe. "Some of the same things happened, some didn't, and the ones that did probably happened a little or a lot differently than what we saw originally." There's just too many incongruities, otherwise.
Monroe only said vague comments to appease fans who constantly bombarded him with "IS IT IN CONTINIUITY!@!111". Granted I was one of those but he was asked this literally all the time. The comics Cubed mentions further show how different this universe was from the previous movies. Clearly any sequel would've solidified that it was its own continuity as it built its own world that would contradict the previous movies. The only reason this is a debate is because the movie didn't get a sequel.
If you look up my posts leading up to 2007, I wanted the movie to be in continuity with the original films badly. But after I saw it and saw the universe the tie in material had made; It made no sense to keep it in continuity since it's its own thing basically. And I'm normally the one that wants to shoehorn continuities together for fun, it just doesn't make sense here.
This felt more like a final for the 2003 series.
Well it's incompatible with 2003 for various reasons but at the very least the turtles/april/casey/karai sort of share the same personalities so you'd be less lost than the different personalities the live action movies have. The success of the movie toys basically helped renew another season of 2k3 which is why Back to the Sewers despite being another season have new designs heavily influenced by the movie, hell April becomes a Ninja like the movie version was.
Now if you want the 2007 movie to be in continuity with something, I think it fits better as a movie for the 2012 movie. There's a few contradictions but makes more sense than 2k3/movie trilogy.
Turo602
07-18-2022, 12:43 AM
Honestly, I don't see how it doesn't fit. Obviously, it's very much its own thing like Superman Returns, but it was still made to feel like the other films had already happened, hence Shredder's absence, the Turtles' glory days behind them, and April and Casey being together.
Karai was only there because the cartoon had already established her as Shredder's daughter and leader of the foot. So even if she wasn't a thing in the old movies, we're supposed to accept that was a long time ago and the rest can be filled in by the cartoon.
To say it's a sequel to TMNT 3 would be wrong, but it was still made as a sort of catch-all in terms of continuity. Adults would be able to follow along because of the old films and kids would be up to speed from the cartoon.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 12:52 AM
Munroe wanted to do like a City at War movie next but mixed with Shredder's resurrection but that was never in the cards for a myriad of reasons. The 2003 cartoon was not really on his brain at any point in the 2007 movie or beyond.
Cowabung-Gal
07-18-2022, 09:20 PM
It’s about as confusing as the “Halloween” franchise, IMO.
Leo656
07-18-2022, 09:31 PM
Nah, nah, almost nothing is THAT bad. :lol:
Allio
07-19-2022, 11:14 AM
Karai never appeared in the old movies, and this was the first time they met her. So what is the issue here?
Been a moment since I watched the film. But I’m sure that Leo reacted to her as if they already met. Seems like they met prior to the 2007 film.
It’s about as confusing as the “Halloween” franchise, IMO.
Texas Chainsaw is worse. And that’s assuming the Netflix film didn’t add to the headache.
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 11:23 AM
Been a moment since I watched the film. But I’m sure that Leo reacted to her as if they already met. Seems like they met prior to the 2007 film.
I don't think there was. There certainly wasn't anything in the script about that.
Texas Chainsaw is worse. And that’s assuming the Netflix film didn’t add to the headache.
It did.
Antoniocafe
07-20-2022, 09:15 AM
In the 15 years since the movie came out, I don't think I've ever watched once where I felt that I was watching a sequel to the first three movies.
superstaff
07-20-2022, 09:28 AM
It’s about as confusing as the “Halloween” franchise, IMO.
Nah, nah, almost nothing is THAT bad. :lol:
Maybe it's because I love those dumb movies, but I don't find the Halloween franchise confusing at all. They're just splintered off.
Basically, there's three separate timelines:
H, H2, H4, H5, H6 (sometimes people include H3, trying to tie in the Silver Shamrock Corp to the cult, but...eh, up to viewer to decide, I guess)
H, H2, H20, HR
H, H2018, HK, HE
That's the basic gist of it. Mostly three separate continuities that are tied by the original for the most part, plus some spin-off stuff that few care about.
Oh, and there's the Rob Zombie sh*t, but those are definitely not connected to the '78 movie, and suck so much that fans pretend they don't exist.
Leo656
07-20-2022, 09:33 AM
Oh, and there's the Rob Zombie sh*t, but those are definitely not connected to the '78 movie, and suck so much that fans pretend they don't exist.
They're fine with me. II was weird.
I didn't grow up with the originals so they're not sacred to me, nor are the... "reimaginings" (I hesitate to call them "remakes", they're not really playing the same sport) blasphemy to me as they are to some. I just look at 'em in a vacuum as "just horror movies". They're "fine".
superstaff
07-20-2022, 09:46 AM
For me, I felt the first Rob Zombie one was just a photo copy remake with some dumb edgy stuff added in like Michael having crackhead parents which...I felt wasn't necessary.
Then II was weird like you said. A little too weird, in a way I didn't like.
I don't think Zombie understood the point of the original movie either. I'd delve into it more, but most of the time, people just tell me to stfu because they're just stupid horror movies. And they are, but...there is some depth to the original (and I think 4 'got' it too, actually).
Leo656
07-20-2022, 10:09 AM
I actually disagree, I think he totally "understood the point" of the original, and decided that rather than try and do an "actual remake" in the same vein - a guaranteed losing battle - he just decided to do a completely different take on the material altogether. Same name(s) but entirely different approach. Which is allowed.
There's an old saying in film that "You can't out-Hitchcock Hitchcock" and I suspect that was always on his mind when he did these. To even go anywhere near the original's style or sensibilities was only going to invite even more comparisons than the movie's title already did. So, absent of that, it makes sense to go into completely different territory and not even try to do anything the original did.
They're very much "Rob Zombie Movies" and people can like that or not - he's always hit-or-miss, with me - and people can forever argue whether something like Halloween ever "needed" to be remade in the first place, by anyone just in general. But I do think that removed of any and all expectations that being called "Halloween" inevitably carries with them, they're Pretty Good Horror Movies.
But see, I only saw the first one, of the original series. I find in talking to people that to really get anything out of the Zombie ones, most people have to be able to completely compartmentalize them. Human nature being what it is, that's not something most people can bring it upon themselves to do, let's just be honest. But it's easy for me to look at them in a vacuum because I have no other point of reference for the series, aside from the original which I saw WAY too late in my life for it to have any significant weight. It's a fine horror movie, don't get me wrong, but I saw it when I was, like, 30. So whereas most people speak of the original movie with a lot of reverence, it just isn't really possible for me to do that, even though I like the movie.
It's like Star Wars; you see that for the first time past a certain age, it's "just a movie", whereas to other people who saw it younger it's a whole life-changing thing. I'll never be as attached to the Halloween franchise as people who are "really" into it, so when I watch any of them, or the Zombie remakes, there's a whole level of detachment that affects the entire experience.
I mean, after all the caterwauling, I honestly expected to hate them and was a little surprised when I didn't. A lot of that has to do with how I wasn't comparing them to anything else, and at least some of it has to do with the fact that after hearing for ten years how they were "terrible, awful, worthless movies", when I finally saw them I realized that was some pretty strong hyperbole, and that I could easily rattle off about 500 horror movies that were way worse than those two.
So... yeah, I'unno. :lol:
------------
Allio was also right before, though; the Texas Chainsaw timeline is WAY more screwy, but I'm even less involved in THAT franchise and didn't even like the original much, so I try and tune those out.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.