View Full Version : Extremely disappointed to hear the comics got woke and political
Cipher
07-18-2022, 12:31 AM
...in 1988.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FX4QOXkUEAAZtjO?format=png&name=small
ChosenOne
07-18-2022, 07:08 AM
Oh, yeah, totally the same thing. :roll:
neatoman
07-18-2022, 08:33 AM
The exact "spiel" mentioned goes like this:
Besides-- There are no innocents! We are all guilty of letting America slide from greatness into the muck of mediocrity-- Allowing our perfect nation to become a haven for unwholesome aliens like you! The Committee to Rebuild American Patriotism would have changed all that-- We would have begun a nuclear tidal wave would have swept this country-- The world-- Clean!
And in case someone is unfamiliar with the issue or has only seen the 4Kids adaptation, Skonk isn't calling the mutants "aliens" because he has mistaken them for extra-terrestrials, he thinks they're part of some kind of foreign communist conspiracy. Skonk's exact political beliefs are somewhat unclear beyond disliking communists and thinking people should do their part for America.
I'm not entirely sure what the Reagan connection is, I mostly just know about Reaganomics and "Tear down this wall", if he said anything about nuking the countryside to inspire patriotism or America being a haven for communists you'll let me know. Seems more like McCarthy to me.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 10:44 AM
...in 1988.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FX4QOXkUEAAZtjO?format=png&name=small
Naw. Not like it is nowadays.
...in 1988.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FX4QOXkUEAAZtjO?format=png&name=small
That's not what "woke" is. You are tone deaf. My guess is that you read this and put a half retard smile on your face and scoff at the reply instead of actually trying to compute how out of touch you are through your example.
And this is how it's going to evolve - the generation of mouth breathers will continue to make distinctions-where-there-are-none or connections-by-thread with a strengthening weave of nonsense and insist that they are informed and correct.
Critical thinking errors of the highest order.
Skonk's exact political beliefs are somewhat unclear beyond disliking communists and thinking people should do their part for America.
Well done here - not because of the positioning but for shining an experiential light on a story that many of us probably haven't read.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 11:00 AM
Yeah. "Something-something-Reagan, 2nd amendment and people who own guns bad because reasons" is hardly what's going on now.
Though it's always been interesting that the moment Kevin and Peter stopped doing their partnership (#12) that's where Peter chose to take the story. And it's fine. It's just interesting, and shows what interests each one over the other, if left to their own devices.
mrmaczaps
07-18-2022, 11:09 AM
TMNT Archies series went hard Leftist political... even some of the main Mirage series got a little lunie preachy bs. Yet, they were fine showing the Turtles with full autos & other firearms & scifi shooters... without being responsible with/for showing proper care/use of said firearms. Which is typical leftist. Laird is super lefty but I tend to think Eastman just stays neutral as he used to own a tank. (Everyone should....)
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 11:19 AM
TMNT Archies series went hard Leftist political...
But I wouldn't say in a too preachy way. Though I gotta say, as a small child reading those Archies I had it in my head that even by the year 2000 all of the rainforests would be long burned away entirely. Because of those comics. I remember asking my parents, "Is there any rainforest left??"
Laird is super lefty but I tend to think Eastman just stays neutral as he used to own a tank. (Everyone should....)
There's no way Eastman could be a leftist. That dude is like obsessed with guns in everything he does.
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 11:47 AM
Wasn't General Blanque a fascist dictator who wanted genocide?
ChosenOne
07-18-2022, 11:59 AM
But I wouldn't say in a too preachy way. Though I gotta say, as a small child reading those Archies I had it in my head that even by the year 2000 all of the rainforests would be long burned away entirely. Because of those comics. I remember asking my parents, "Is there any rainforest left??"
Funny thing is, that's actually one of the many factors that drove me away from the somewhat leftie mindset I had as a child. There's only so many decades you can live through while hearing that tired old "Only ten years left to change it around!" spiel before you start to zone out and see it for what it is. No wonder it's always the kids, aka the ones with the least life experience, they try to brainwash.
Zog The Magnificent
07-18-2022, 12:20 PM
Funny thing is, that's actually one of the many factors that drove me away from the somewhat leftie mindset I had as a child. There's only so many decades you can live through while hearing that tired old "Only ten years left to change it around!" spiel before you start to zone out and see it for what it is. No wonder it's always the kids, aka the ones with the least life experience, they try to brainwash.
It's always been "10 years to save it!" It was 10 years 30 years ago, it was 10 years 20 years ago, and it's still 10 years now. Could it be that this brand of environmental preaching is entirely full of it?
Nah, couldn't be...
ChosenOne
07-18-2022, 01:10 PM
It's always been "10 years to save it!" It was 10 years 30 years ago, it was 10 years 20 years ago, and it's still 10 years now. Could it be that this brand of environmental preaching is entirely full of it?
Nah, couldn't be...
Sure, you say that now, but wait 10 years and you'll see! And then 10 more years after that, and then... You get 10 years, and you get 10 years, and you get 10 years, everybody gets 10 years to save the world! I wonder which will arrive first, their big Waterworld thing or GRRM's The Winds of Winter... :roll:
mrmaczaps
07-18-2022, 01:41 PM
Sure, you say that now, but wait 10 years and you'll see! And then 10 more years after that, and then... You get 10 years, and you get 10 years, and you get 10 years, everybody gets 10 years to save the world! I wonder which will arrive first, their big Waterworld thing or GRRM's The Winds of Winter... :roll:
Yeah, its been "10 years" for my entire life...
Also, I swiped your banner image... lol.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 01:46 PM
And what would I know? I was like a 9 year old kid when those came out. Jagwar was telling me in the comic that millions of acres of rainforest were getting burned every day or whatever, who am I to question him? Sounded like an insurmountable problem.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 03:02 PM
Didn't Cudley send the turtles to the future by mistake where the greenhouse effect caused mass flooding and stuff. I wonder if it was the future-future or like say... 2012 and we already passed that year in real life.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 03:04 PM
Didn't Cudley send the turtles to the future by mistake where the greenhouse effect caused mass flooding and stuff. I wonder if it was the future-future or like say... 2012 and we already passed that year in real life.
Yeah, and that was pretty early on. Pollution of the ocean got some spotlight, too.
It's always been "10 years to save it!" It was 10 years 30 years ago, it was 10 years 20 years ago, and it's still 10 years now. Could it be that this brand of environmental preaching is entirely full of it?
Nah, couldn't be...
I think the one I've been hearing the most lately is that we have 10 years left in which we can make a difference. If we don't, then it's all over for sure 10 years after that.
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 04:00 PM
Wasn't 2021 recorded to be the warmest/hottest year on Earth in terms of temperatures around the world? And 2022 looks to be the same? There's news stories right now of Spain/Portugal and people dying in heat waves in Europe.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2022, 04:07 PM
Wasn't 2021 recorded to be the warmest/hottest year on Earth in terms of temperatures around the world?
No. It was tied for 6th place.
mrmaczaps
07-18-2022, 04:35 PM
There's no way Eastman could be a leftist. That dude is like obsessed with guns in everything he does.
Not that he would say anything about any of that at a show or whatever... lol. Too bad he doesn't too.
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 04:40 PM
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-QvMMceJnQd4/UybYd2F4vBI/AAAAAAAAA14/32HaE8TCKXs/s1600/TMNTBodyCount+%25285%2529.jpg
Kevin Eastman with nothing holding him back.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
07-18-2022, 04:45 PM
Didn't Cudley send the turtles to the future by mistake where the greenhouse effect caused mass flooding and stuff. I wonder if it was the future-future or like say... 2012 and we already passed that year in real life.
Cudley sent the Turtles 100 years into the future.
ChosenOne
07-18-2022, 04:47 PM
Also, I swiped your banner image... lol.
Feel free!
And what would I know? I was like a 9 year old kid when those came out. Jagwar was telling me in the comic that millions of acres of rainforest were getting burned every day or whatever, who am I to question him? Sounded like an insurmountable problem.
And the lesson is, don't believe everything talking cartoon animals tell you.
Didn't Cudley send the turtles to the future by mistake where the greenhouse effect caused mass flooding and stuff. I wonder if it was the future-future or like say... 2012 and we already passed that year in real life.
All in all, not a good year for doomsday prophecies.
I think the one I've been hearing the most lately is that we have 10 years left in which we can make a difference. If we don't, then it's all over for sure 10 years after that.
And they'll still be saying the exact same thing 10 years from now.
Wasn't 2021 recorded to be the warmest/hottest year on Earth in terms of temperatures around the world? And 2022 looks to be the same? There's news stories right now of Spain/Portugal and people dying in heat waves in Europe.
Said records only go back to the Victorian era, so always take that "ever" with a bucketload of salt. Talk about human hubris to assume there's anything we can do about Earth's natural cycles except adapt to survive them. We didn't start it, we can't stop it, no more than we started or stopped the extinction of the dinosaurs, the various Ice Ages, yada, yada, yada.
I'm actually in one of the hottest regions in Portugal right now. Everyone who's not an alarmist calls it Summer. As in, the time of the year when there's supposed to be heat waves.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 06:12 PM
But I wouldn't say in a too preachy way. Though I gotta say, as a small child reading those Archies I had it in my head that even by the year 2000 all of the rainforests would be long burned away entirely. Because of those comics. I remember asking my parents, "Is there any rainforest left??"
There's no way Eastman could be a leftist. That dude is like obsessed with guns in everything he does.
That doesn't necessarily mean anything. I love movies like Terminator, Robocop and Predator and I don't own a gun nor have I ever considered obtaining one.
If Eastman mostly draws action and sci-fi comics then obviously he's gonna "need" to give guns to his characters.
You can enjoy things in a fictional universe context that you don't in real life. Kinda like lesbian sex, for example. If I see Chun-Li and Mai Shiranui going down on each other I get excited, but if I see two women in real life making out in front of me? Nope.
Leo656
07-18-2022, 06:35 PM
Good point, man. My writing confuses some people because it's got a lot of religious symbolism and allegory and whatnot, despite me being borderline atheist. I like it in fiction and it's another "tool" in the writer's toolbox but that doesn't mean I'm all into it in Real Life.
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 07:06 PM
In that Mirage issue Skonk is also a black man, yet the 4kids adaption changed him to a white guy remember?
And that was back in 2005. Even in 2005 they thought a black guy as a terrorist was too bad for kids, so he was changed to a white guy in the episode. Even back in 2005 it was "woke" for a black guy to be a gun-toting terrorist.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 07:15 PM
In that Mirage issue Skonk is also a black man, yet the 4kids adaption changed him to a white guy remember?
And that was back in 2005. Even in 2005 they thought a black guy as a terrorist was too bad for kids, so he was changed to a white guy in the episode. Even back in 2005 it was "woke" for a black guy to be a gun-toting terrorist.
How often do we even see black people as main villains nowadays? Is there any major series or property that has a black villain? The only one to spring to my mind is the Rocky series. And that started in the 70s already. Plus, I wouldn't call Apollo Creed a villain. Clubber Lang? Maybe. But I guess Ivan Drago is considered the biggest antagonist/opponent Rocky faced...
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 07:18 PM
How often do we even see black people as main villains nowadays? Is there any major series or property that has a black villain? The only one to spring to my mind is the Rocky series. And that started in the 70s already. Plus, I wouldn't call Apollo Creed a villain. Clubber Lang? Maybe. But I guess Ivan Drago is considered the biggest antagonist/opponent Rocky faced...
The only time blacks are villains is when the protagonists are also black. Closest thing I can think of is Miles Morales Spider-man, in both "Into the Spider-verse" and the Miles Morales videogame on PS4/PS5, you have Miles' uncle who is of course black as one of the main villains. In the movie Kingpin is still the overall villain though.
But if the protagonists are mostly white, I can't think of any major black villains anymore who aren't "legacy" characters created decades ago.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 07:23 PM
The only time blacks are villains is when the protagonists are also black. Closest thing I can think of is Miles Morales Spider-man, in both "Into the Spider-verse" and the Miles Morales videogame on PS4/PS5, you have Miles uncle who is of course black as one of the main villains. In the movie Kingpin is still the overall villain though.
But if the protagonists are mostly white, I can't think of any major black villains anymore who aren't "legacy" characters created decades ago.
Did you know that opening of the arcade version of Street Fighter 2 has a white guy punching a black guy in the face? It was changed in the US to a white guy punching another white guy because... you know. And that game came out in the early 90s. In Japan, no one saw an issue with a white guy punching a black guy. They just saw it as two dudes fighting, which is what it really is.
There was a Resident Evil game that drew controversy in the States as well because it had black zombies in it or something and killing black people in a video game was seen as problematic, apparently.
In the live action Doom movie from the early-mid 2000s, The Rock's character becomes a bad guy midway through the film. I know he's not "fully black" but seems like yoyre considered black in the US even if only one of your parents or grandparents is. So I guess it counts.
hypered1
07-18-2022, 07:35 PM
Did you know that opening of the arcade version of Street Fighter 2 has a white guy punching a black guy in the face? It was changed in the US to a white guy punching another white guy because... you know. And that game came out in the early 90s. In Japan, no one saw an issue with a white guy punching a black guy. They just saw it as two dudes fighting, which is what it really is.
There was a Resident Evil game that drew controversy in the States as well because it had black zombies in it or something and killing black people in a video game was seen as problematic, apparently.
In the live action Doom movie from the early-mid 2000s, The Rock's character becomes a bad guy midway through the film. I know he's not "fully black" but seems like yoyre considered black in the US even if only one of your parents or grandparents is. So I guess it counts.
The Resident Evil game was RE5 which is set in Africa where the majority of residents are black, so the complaints were nonsensical at best.
CyberCubed
07-18-2022, 07:35 PM
Yeah that's why the only time you see black villains is in Black Panther where the entire cast is black. Blacks can have black villains, or like Spider-man Miles Morales, but you can't have a black villain if you cast is white.
For that matter does Batman have any primary black villains? Unless I'm blanking on one I don't think so?
mrmaczaps
07-18-2022, 07:42 PM
That doesn't necessarily mean anything. I love movies like Terminator, Robocop and Predator and I don't own a gun nor have I ever considered obtaining one.
If Eastman mostly draws action and sci-fi comics then obviously he's gonna "need" to give guns to his characters.
You can enjoy things in a fictional universe context that you don't in real life. Kinda like lesbian sex, for example. If I see Chun-Li and Mai Shiranui going down on each other I get excited, but if I see two women in real life making out in front of me? Nope.
Why not though?
And at some point early in the money making years, Eastman bought himself a literal tank so he at least used to be pro2a/America.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 07:45 PM
Yeah that's why the only time you see black villains is in Black Panther where the entire cast is black. Blacks can have black villains, or like Spider-man Miles Morales, but you can't have a black villain if you cast is white.
For that matter does Batman have any primary black villains? Unless I'm blanking on one I don't think so?
I'm no expert on Batman, but lemme try to name the villains in his series...
Joker, Penguin, Two Face, Scarecrow, Bane, Two Face... none of them are black. I know Hale Berry played Catwoman in a movie but is the character originally black? And is she a villain per se?
Prowler
07-18-2022, 08:02 PM
The Resident Evil game was RE5 which is set in Africa where the majority of residents are black, so the complaints were nonsensical at best.
Of course they were. And sadly, I'm not surprised those same people who complained about it don't have any logical thinking skills or common sense. It's like you can never win with them. If you don't put black people in your work you're called a racist. But if you do... you're getting called a racist as well unless you make them the lead heroes or something.
Galactus
07-18-2022, 08:14 PM
The whole idea that comics used to be apolitical is always a pleasant fantasy. Most of them have been right from the inception of the medium. When people look back at older comics and either the political message is so benign by today's standards that they don't see how it could have been a controversial point back in the day. Think of the cover of the first Captain America comic having Steve Rogers punch Hitler, that would seem to be a pretty normal thing in a world were Adolph Hitler and the Nazis being bad is pretty much accepted fact (although not as much as it used to be sadly) but back in 1941 when there was a very strong pro-Nazi sentiment that was hugely controversial. For people kids who read things like Captain America quit and becoming Nomad they they probably were not politically engaged at that age to see how politically charged that whole story was. If that story was published now I guarantee comicsgate would be all over it and Tucker Carlson would have a whole segment with Dean Cain saying "even Captain America isn't allowed to like America now". The original Mirage TMNT isn't exactly politically charged but it does have it's moments and always leans left.
Assuming Kevin Eastman is a closet right winger because he uses guns a lot in his stories is flawed reasoning. People appreciate things in fiction that they would never advocate for in real life. If we are going to use his work to try and gauge his real life opinions in Bodycount Casey Jones refused to use guns repeatedly saying "I hate guns" and after getting a hooked on them Raph swears off them after Casey is shot. Maybe that's him sneaking in his long held beliefs on guns in real life, perhaps it's reflecting on a real life change in attitude...either way it's hardly an endorsement for the gun lobby.
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/ZE6u9qEtZIUszDRmaidnb7_SAjde5Sp-_BerEv9IB5eUIt8Et3ixXPUsrlLJWYLK_Ps2DIlhijm3jntf3p vGX2pyYguQioxwypwZWRxowTgt59QVG7KEFXfQjH6v6v9BH7vW E3-_R072-hFn_DX7UW-dJHkpaHj3eCBSaP7LDuEcqxfJdFwJ-zefkLRQ0aOzEqANtpc9nb5MUSXC-h-xVKwC7Mem5DHgEvjjslOpwWa-5m06Abf4Ph3OeobEsa7R7t4n7wG7lX5KrmhqY5Pc-hDrq56BAOBvLldwsdR2fW5nd2_1D8ba54S4bguDE3bDuUVKoPN m6PK7LcXU1_UI-V7G8-Y0POXu1-mSpo-OAXQc7qhPJY_q89LrvOSr1N44ftncbGVI9rIcXcyUiBDJBcC4u 84qc0qW0FmS3GOIcAC-4ER5DWcK_F8IZdFbyuASNCUFnqVyPnR6nSNeDrIqiugZEcB6KB A-SlbwQpD3Ao7-8T8lpSwfBPVvMyuFP_5ykLe9MShVCQGPxmnnhQO127EJzDu2-HB35Z3lLmiiJf2Wa-pFP1umL_CpyfUhmPpKWv-6WXKi97_ucXVsYik0H16Nl4QvbkXBy6deOGcPV9t0TS8VWG9Dc DJ7ueUf--aB6wfTTBpkVfz2HD2dRm2cQko_hzWgLe839ZJ5qAeSAXh2bidQ L68phzaxDgn5pxP3931eOSvxSa4jzpM60G8OXAuY3-GGDUUCM4hMdJdaQs_0ZQbxxeqYqk-8Kg=w458-h700-no?authuser=0
The vibe I've always gotten from him is that he isn't particularly politically engaged. Of course I could be entirely wrong but considering that the entire Mirage crew lean left it seems strange to assume that he's the odd one out based on nothing.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 09:21 PM
I do wonder why there weren't comics about the characters going after Bin Laden, or Bin Laden being the big mastermind behind this or that when in the past comics weren't afraid to show them go after Hitler during his actual heyday.
I think the real issue is the politics have taken over way too much. Subtlety is gone, it's way too on the nose, and a lot of the escapism is gone. Plus now it's 10X more lecturing, 10X less actual action. It's become politics first and then maaaaaybe some story. Maybe. Too many things nowadays lead off with 'first gay this,first Muslim that' 'what's the story about? who are the villains?' 'dude who cares, it's the first gay Muslim, that's all you need'.
In the Captain America comics, they have shown Hitler, but there was still a story, a fantasy about how a regular dude gained powers thanks to a super soldier serum and how that affected his life, etc. And of course, still action and adventure.
But nowadays it's like Iceman is gay... and that's the whole story. I swear issue 5 or so of his first gay mini-series randomly threw Juggernaut in there cause 'oh hey... comics... um.... we gotta put some sort of bad guy in there for him to fight.... I guess."
I mean, no one cares about 5-6 issues about Iceman coming out to his parents, which shouldn't be a big deal when he already came out as mutant. And seeing how it tanked and got cancelled, apparently no one on 'the left side of history' cared either.
The irony being you already had a gay hero, Northstar, but rather than build him up, he's pretty much forgotten in lieu of making a straight guy gay for the headlines it would cause. I swear, they use the characters as props. Ok Northstar, you already got the first gay wedding cover, now go away until we need you for... idk... next year's Pride or something. It's insulting.
The other issue with politics is that they're always one sided. There's never the other side of the coin, and everything is always universally portrayed as leftish stuff good, rightish stuff bad, leftish dude is useful, rightish dude is useless, etc. People just don't work that way.
I mean most of these heroes would save the president if they were in danger. They'd never ever publish a story where Superman swoops in and saves Trump for an assassination attempt from Metallo or someone without at the very least making him give a look of disgust without the dude being fired and pretty much crucified on social media.
Leo656
07-18-2022, 09:39 PM
Right, it's not that anybody thinks comics were ever "apolitical", that isn't what annoys people.
It's that nowadays "the political message" is the ENTIRE POINT of even publishing a comic at all, and furthermore, that it's all very heavy-handed and one-sided.
If it were less prevalent, less blatant, and it wasn't all entirely left-leaning, people might not find it so annoying. Saying "You silly bastards, comics have ALWAYS been political!" is reductive and ignores what people are actually griping about.
I really don't think there's an especially strong demand for "Right-wing" comics or anything, I think people just feel like the entire medium is being used as a propaganda tool for One Side Entirely and that storytelling is getting lost in all the preaching and finger-wagging. Subtlety used to be a thing. Giving people of an opposing viewpoint Equal Time used to be a thing. Now, those aren't things, and people are mad.
Like, does anyone especially WANT to be preached to about "accepting trans people" in a f*cking Batman comic? Nah. Just for one example. Even a person who agrees with the general message can look at that and be like, "Jesus, this is a little overboard now." And they do.
In the case of TMNT, I checked out on Mirage Vol. 4 mentally once Laird started using it as a soapbox to whine about how Gore should have won the election. I'm like "Dude, come on, I just got home from work and I wanna relax, and instead I'm being finger-wagged by a f*cking comic book." It was annoying.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 10:08 PM
Galactus is usually like that. He also tried to convince us April had always been black even though that has been disproved countless times already. So I'm not surprised he is being reductive and saying the typical "MOVIES HAVE ALWAYS BEEN POLITICAL!" argument in this thread.
Subtlety used to be a thing. Not to mention you didn't feel like the writers were shoving their views down your throat and making that thing the entire point of their work.
We've reached a point where lobbies pretty much IMPOSE their political agendas in every medium, and if someone in the industry doesn't follow that "rule" they get cancelled.
Japan is still somewhat immune to that. Most of the outrage aimed at anime and manga comes from American and some European fans.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 10:13 PM
Japan is still somewhat immune to that. Most of the outrage aimed at anime and manga comes from American and some European fans.
That's another thing that bothers me. These woke assholes want Japanese media created in Japan for Japanese audiences (America is a fun bonus of course) to cater to their ****** American woke agendas. No, you **** off with that nonsense and go watch your woke CW shows and leave us to enjoy our anime alone as is.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 10:18 PM
That's another thing that bothers me. These woke assholes want Japanese media created in Japan for Japanese audiences (America is a fun bonus of course) to cater to their ****** American woke agendas. No, you **** off with that nonsense and go watch your woke CW shows and leave us to enjoy our anime alone as is.
Some One Piece fans are legitimately bothered by the fact the women in One Piece have massive knockers and that Nami's and Robin's boobs tripled in size throughout the years.
OK, I know it's unrealistic, ut who the hell cares?! It's a series whose main character is a young man who can turn his body into rubber because he ate a ****ing fruit :lol:. Why don't they bitch about that as well? Also, what kind of straight man would have a problem with the busty ladies of One Piece?
But the OP fandom doesn't hold a candle to the MHA fandom with its hatred for Mineta and its aversion to Ochako's and Momo's hero outfits and bodies. Yet, many of those same fans who complain about that are drawing yaoi fanart of Bakugo and Deku in the meantime :lol:
Leo656
07-18-2022, 10:29 PM
Thanks to Geena Davis, there's an actual group working in Hollywood right now whose entire job is to go over every script and ensure it has the "acceptable" number of gays, trans, and non-whites in it, before anyone can even think about producing it.
If you wanted to faithfully remake something like Seven Samurai, for example, you can't. Not now. Not enough gays or black people in it. So you can remake it so that every one of the characters is a different shade of non-white LGBTQ+, or else, you can't make the movie at all.
That's f*cking ass. It's ridiculous. Too far. If a person can't see why that's bad, they've got their head up their ass.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 10:32 PM
Thanks to Geena Davis, there's an actual group working in Hollywood right now whose entire job is to go over every script and ensure it has the "acceptable" number of gays, trans, and non-whites in it, before anyone can even think about producing it.
If you wanted to faithfully remake something like Seven Samurai, for example, you can't. Not now. Not enough gays or black people in it. So you can remake it so that every one of the characters is a different shade of non-white LGBTQ+, or else, you can't make the movie at all.
That's f*cking ass. It's ridiculous. Too far. If a person can't see why that's bad, they've got their head up their ass.
People complained about The Witcher games not gaming any black characters in it.
The Witcher, a Polish video game series about Slavic mythology. Most of the Eastern Europeans I've talked to only seen like 5 black people in their entire lives. This Polish guy told me he didn't see a black person outside of TV and movies for the first time in his life until he was 20.
But yeah, go insert 5 black characters in every Polish, Russian, Japanese or Korean game, movie, series, comic, etc from now on. That's very realistic and believable alright...
Leo656
07-18-2022, 10:38 PM
Aw, yeah, the Polish people in my family who actually came from Poland were pretty unapologetically racist. The whole "only saw 5 black people in their entire lives" thing is no exaggeration, other than if it even WAS 5, that'd be a lot for some of them. More like two, at most. And of course all they ever knew of them were the jokes and stereotypes, so to them that was "factual information".
Every single thing I've ever heard about Polish people has proven itself 100% true, though. None of it good.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 10:41 PM
Aw, yeah, the Polish people in my family who actually came from Poland were pretty unapologetically racist. The whole "only saw 5 black people in their entire lives" thing is no exaggeration, other than if it even WAS 5, that'd be a lot for some of them. More like two, at most. And of course all they ever knew of them were the jokes and stereotypes, so to them that was "factual information".
Every single thing I've ever heard about Polish people has proven itself 100% true, though. None of it good.
Well the people I talk to online are generally around 25-40. Nowadays with travelling being more common they might see 5 in their lifetimes instead of 1. Back in the 50s there were literally zero black people in Poland. Nowadays there's... about 25, I guess?
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 10:55 PM
Some One Piece fans are legitimately bothered by the fact the women in One Piece have massive knockers and that Nami's and Robin's boobs tripled in size throughout the years.
OK, I know it's unrealistic, ut who the hell cares?! It's a series whose main character is a young man who can turn his body into rubber because he ate a ****ing fruit :lol:. Why don't they bitch about that as well? Also, what kind of straight man would have a problem with the busty ladies of One Piece?
But the OP fandom doesn't hold a candle to the MHA fandom with its hatred for Mineta and its aversion to Ochako's and Momo's hero outfits and bodies. Yet, many of those same fans who complain about that are drawing yaoi fanart of Bakugo and Deku in the meantime :lol:
IKR it's like just admit anime is not for you and move the **** on.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 10:59 PM
IKR it's like just admit anime is not for you and move the **** on.
Popular shounen anime attracts tons of normies, which are people who don't normally watch anime. Just like people from my generation only watched DBZ, Pokémon and Captain Tsubasa an dmaybe Digimon and Yu Gi Oh and that's it. So I guess it's not so surprising that they're not aware that fanservice and the token perverted character are pretty much standard in anime/manga.
Honestly I feel like Western civilization is going backwards. Which is ironic considering how supposedly progressive a lot of young people are nowadays. Yet attractive women showing cleavage seems to offend them. Where's the logic in that?
Leo656
07-18-2022, 11:01 PM
Anybody who'd complain about Nami's tits is Teh Gay.
I don't even give a sh*t about anime. :lol: Just sayin'.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 11:05 PM
Anybody who'd complain about Nami's tits is Teh Gay.
I don't even give a sh*t about anime. :lol: Just sayin'.
If FW April was in a modern day TMNT cartoon I bet tons of people would bitch about her as well. Meanwhile they have no issues with April being 13 and kissing Donatello.
If you ask me, they're the ones who are weird.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2022, 11:05 PM
I don't even see the big deal. Everybody loves attractive women. Other women like attractive women. Even gays like attractive women (even though they have no desire to **** em).
I mean how can these people that want to normalize polygamy and practice hook up culture get so worked up about anime boobs? Sure I'm ****ing Lindsay and Chelsea behind Chloe's back but Nami's animated boobies offend me.
Prowler
07-18-2022, 11:10 PM
I don't even see the big deal. Everybody loves attractive women. Other women like attractive women. Even gays like attractive women (even though they have no desire to **** em).
I mean how can these people that want to normalize polygamy and practice hook up culture get so worked up about anime boobs? Sure I'm ****ing Lindsay and Chelsea behind Chloe's back but Nami's animated boobies offend me.
Well a lot of those SJWs/woke people are lesbian women and a lot of them aren't very attractive, to out it nicely, so it's probably jealousy. And they probably hope they can slowly change the beauty ideal to overweight women with pink coloured hair. Well good luck with that. Because that's gonna be difficult.
Funny thing is, Nami and Robin are both very well written characters and arguably the two smartest members of the Straw Hat pirates. So reducing them to their tits is very unfair. If anything their bodies are a bonus. I guess women can't be both intelligent and sexy anymore or something.
Also, there's a study that states that there's actually a high correlation between large breasts and intelligence in women. Food for thought. Mother nature might as well go all the way through and give a woman two of the best qualities she could have: brains and boobs. ;)
Cowabung-Gal
07-18-2022, 11:10 PM
I remember reading Ben Bishop’s political tweets, which unsurprisingly were all about bashing Republicans and praising Democrats. I think he stopped being political after the rise in gas prices though. He may have even deleted the tweets, though I could be wrong. I actually got to meet him at the Lexington Comic Con. Hardly anyone visited his booth, while over a hundred people waited in line for over five hours, including yours truly, just to meet Kevin Eastman. Well, what did Bishop expect? He’s a woke artist in a red state. :lol:
Prowler
07-18-2022, 11:20 PM
I remember reading Ben Bishop’s political tweets, which unsurprisingly were all about bashing Republicans and praising Democrats. I think he stopped being political after the rise in gas prices though. He may have even deleted the tweets, though I could be wrong. I actually got to meet him at the Lexington Comic Con. Hardly anyone visited his booth, while over a hundred people waited in line for over five hours, including yours truly, just to meet Kevin Eastman. Well, what did Bishop expect? He’s a woke artist in a red state. :lol:
Depending on what he said and what his views are(is he more on the "radical" side of the spectrum?) I don't think an artist having a different political ideology from yours should affect your opinion of their work. That being said, depending on the kind of stuff he's said, Bishop should be wiser not to be so outspoken if he has views that are unpopular in his area, because that might alienate the audience... which seems like it did.
Celebrities and other famous people should be more diplomatic about their political views. Everyone has the right to an opinion, but when you're a public figure and your fans are your life hood, you should have some common sense and avoid saying things that might make you lose fans and thus lose money.
Cowabung-Gal
07-18-2022, 11:31 PM
Depending on what he said and what his views are(is he more on the "radical" side of the spectrum?) I don't think an artist having a different political ideology from yours should affect your opinion of their work. That being said, depending on the kind of stuff he's said, Bishop should be wiser not to be so outspoken if he has views that are unpopular in his area, because that might alienate the audience... which seems like it did.
Celebrities and other famous people should be more diplomatic about their political views. Everyone has the right to an opinion, but when you're a public figure and your fans are your life hood, you should have some common sense and avoid saying things that might make you lose fans and thus lose money.
You have common sense, which is why Disney will never hire you.
But while Bishop, like the rest of us, has the right to express his political opinions, he should’ve kept in mind that Kentuckians have Twitter accounts, too, and a lot of them are pretty bitter about the gas prices right now. It’s just not good for business.
Coola Yagami
07-19-2022, 12:09 AM
Depending on what he said and what his views are(is he more on the "radical" side of the spectrum?) I don't think an artist having a different political ideology from yours should affect your opinion of their work. That being said, depending on the kind of stuff he's said, Bishop should be wiser not to be so outspoken if he has views that are unpopular in his area, because that might alienate the audience... which seems like it did.
Celebrities and other famous people should be more diplomatic about their political views. Everyone has the right to an opinion, but when you're a public figure and your fans are your life hood, you should have some common sense and avoid saying things that might make you lose fans and thus lose money.
You'd think so, but lately the hot new thing celebs do is spout their awful opinions and tell their own fans 'if you don't agree/disagree with this or that stance, unfollow me. I don't want people like YOU as fans anyway'.
Lately George Takei has been one of the nastier ones saying that kind of crap. Then he'll wonder why his lines at cons are getting smaller and smaller.
The Left loves to say you have the freedom to your opinion but just keep in mind that there will be consequences. They forget that rule also applies to them. To a lesser degree sure, but they're not immune.
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 12:17 AM
You'd think so, but lately the hot new thing celebs do is spout their awful opinions and tell their own fans 'if you don't agree/disagree with this or that stance, unfollow me. I don't want people like YOU as fans anyway'.
“If you don’t like my politics, don’t buy my book.”
About a year later…
“Why is no one buying my book?! I’m broke and I need money!”
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 12:40 AM
“If you don’t like my politics, don’t buy my book.”
About a year later…
“Why is no one buying my book?! I’m broke and I need money!”
There's several also hilarious steps missing in the middle of that, but yes.
Coola Yagami
07-19-2022, 12:42 AM
I like how Young Rippa parodied that in one of his tweets.
"If you don't like my politics, you can still buy my book."
Leo656
07-19-2022, 01:06 AM
Sh*t like that is why Dan Jurgens is my all-time favorite comics creator.
Not only do I love his artwork and his writing style - although I confess, never in my life had I ever seen or heard Superman say "WHOA!" before Jurgens did it, and he does it A LOT, with him :lol: - but I mean, I can't tell you one thing about the guy's politics. At all. I don't know if anyone even knows.
What's mostly known and been said about Jurgens is, "He's the nicest guy in the business." That's all you hear, not a peep otherwise. Just, "He's such a nice guy, and he works SO hard." 30+ years in the business and no whispers, scandals or scuttlebutt. He works hard, he's good with Continuity Stuff, I think he's Canadian, I believe he's married, and he's known for taking the people who interview him out to lunch, paying for their meal, and then asking them if they need a ride anywhere. That's the most you hear about, with him, you never hear anything else. What are his politics? Damned if I know. If he's Canadian, he probably leans left, but I swear you couldn't glean anything about it from his work alone.
The industry could use a LOT more people like That Guy, that's all I gotta say.
Coola Yagami
07-19-2022, 01:36 AM
although I confess, never in my life had I ever seen or heard Superman say "WHOA!" before Jurgens did it, and he does it A LOT, with him :lol:
Superman is just channeling his inner Keanu Reeves.
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 01:40 AM
Sh*t like that is why Dan Jurgens is my all-time favorite comics creator.
Not only do I love his artwork and his writing style - although I confess, never in my life had I ever seen or heard Superman say "WHOA!" before Jurgens did it, and he does it A LOT, with him :lol: - but I mean, I can't tell you one thing about the guy's politics. At all. I don't know if anyone even knows.
What's mostly known and been said about Jurgens is, "He's the nicest guy in the business." That's all you hear, not a peep otherwise. Just, "He's such a nice guy, and he works SO hard." 30+ years in the business and no whispers, scandals or scuttlebutt. He works hard, he's good with Continuity Stuff, I think he's Canadian, I believe he's married, and he's known for taking the people who interview him out to lunch, paying for their meal, and then asking them if they need a ride anywhere. That's the most you hear about, with him, you never hear anything else. What are his politics? Damned if I know. If he's Canadian, he probably leans left, but I swear you couldn't glean anything about it from his work alone.
The industry could use a LOT more people like That Guy, that's all I gotta say.
Interesting. And I dig that.
Leo656
07-19-2022, 02:05 AM
Superman is just channeling his inner Keanu Reeves.
I wouldn't doubt it. According to Jurgens's 1993 output from when he had Clark rooming with jimmy for a while, Clark is something of a heavy metal aficionado. :lol: You haven't lived until you see a panel of Lois walking in on Jimmy and Clark having an honest-to-God in-depth discussion about the finer points of heavy metal music. It's bliss.
All joking aside I kinda dug it, though. Some people thought it was a bit forced, but the idea was just to reinforce the notion that Clark's a relatively open-minded guy. Like, the character at the time had been in print for 50+ years but on-paper he was only like 35; there's nothing wrong with establishing something to push back against the idea some people have had that he was some kind of old fart who only listened to Pat Boone or whatever. It was cool to see him have an honest connection with one of his younger friends, as well. Gave them more of a "big brother/little brother" vibe, which they're supposed to have anyway.
Interesting. And I dig that.
Ah, yeah. Once upon a time Wizard or some magazine did an interview/article on him and the writer literally kept stopping to say to the reader "It just cannot be overstated what a nice guy Dan Jurgens is."
I have some stuff he signed that my Dad got off QVC or whatever, but I have never met him in person. It's on the ol' Bucket List. There's actually VERY few comics creators I'd care to meet at all but he's tops, for sure.
I've told the Romeo Tanghal story before, and he was splendid as well. Really, really great guy. I gotta find the stuff he drew for me, I hope it isn't too messed up.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 05:51 AM
I'm not entirely sure what the Reagan connection is, I mostly just know about Reaganomics and "Tear down this wall", if he said anything about nuking the countryside to inspire patriotism or America being a haven for communists you'll let me know. Seems more like McCarthy to me.
Here are the relevant panels as to the motivation of the antagonists in "Survivalists," and the "spiel" in question:
https://i.imgur.com/oxkxpA4.png
https://i.imgur.com/8KSAmia.png
I would suspect it had something to do with Reagan running on a great deal of his own regressive, rhetoric and conflation of patriotic values with a reverence of past eras--economically but also demographically. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Make_America_Great_Again#Ronald_Reagan
I would expect this had all sorts of spill-over into fringe rhetoric, much like politics have now, although I wasn't alive at the time for specifics. Laird, however, was.
I think this is just an example of how much we lose sight on exactly how political past works--and in particular past TMNT works, which was the thrust of this--could be. The rhetoric Skonk is parodying (maybe only barely) in the issue was very likely rhetoric readers may have been hearing from family members, or may even have recognized in themselves. Likewise, content considered extremely political now might seem completely apolitical to readers decades in the future, just for changing social norms and lacking the context of the time to understand the controversies it nestled itself in.
This is an honest question: What rhetoric in the past five years do you think Skonk's most closely resembles, and how would readers react to slightly altered--or even identical--dialogue were the issue published today?
That's not what "woke" is.
What is woke?
Well done here - not because of the positioning but for shining an experiential light on a story that many of us probably haven't read.
I would certainly hope that people in this thread would have read the issue in question (and most of Mirage and maybe Archie). Have you not?
For real though, I'm going to guess that on this board, the people who haven't read the issue would be in the minority. Anyone who hasn't, the IDW "Ultimate" Collections are a steal digitally or in paperback, or you can wait for the "Compendium" edition which includes (finally) black and white Tales issues this fall.
Yeah. "Something-something-Reagan, 2nd amendment and people who own guns bad because reasons" is hardly what's going on now.
Though it's always been interesting that the moment Kevin and Peter stopped doing their partnership (#12) that's where Peter chose to take the story. And it's fine. It's just interesting, and shows what interests each one over the other, if left to their own devices.
What is going on now and how is it any different? Concretely?
I haven't read any of Campbell's IDW run, so I genuinely wouldn't know, but I can say that one of the reasons (among others) I jumped off IDW in the 30s or so was its (almost loud) lack of willingness to touch on any real-world issues or things of weight to its author(s), while grappling with them in some form had always been a staple of TMNT comics to me. In many ways, the Waltz run was the outlier.
I don't know if Campbell's actually changed that (certainly it would be a more interesting book to me if it had) or if reactions are simply overblown, and readers who were enjoying IDW's TMNT up to #100 would be welcome to have their own thoughts about it, but it would simply be in good company with nearly all but the Waltz run prior. Even if you were to make an argument like "Oh, well, it was just Laird and Murphy" (I don't think that's true, but for the sake of argument), they were responsible for the vast majority of the TMNT's total publishing content across Mirage and Archie, and set the ultimate tone and mood for the book(s) early on, so I'm not sure what Turtles books we're talking about without them.
Off of the topic but because it's interesting: For Laird, while, absolutely, he lets some unabashedly left-leaning politics into his work, I think what's more notable about his solo work versus Eastman's early on--and I've been noting this during a current reread--is that he's in a hurry to turn the book into a much more cerebral, melancholy affair. Bittersweet, downbeat endings are attached to all three of the Donatello one-shot (largely attributed to him), "Survivalists" and "Doom Dome!," and he's the one who seems to have first locked into the formula that would come to dominate much of Volume 1 and especially Tales Vol. 2 in "1. TMNT leisure activity, 2. They encounter an ancient civilization under a laundromat or some sort of insane, comic-booky weirdness, 3. A somber reminder about mortality or a real-world issue." Laird is quickly turning the book into a somber, bizarre little indie anthology comic at this point, whereas Eastman is still treating it like a platform for fun gags and action, and I think that's pretty indicative of how they'd both continue to view the book itself and the general property over the years. Laird is also the one to set the ball rolling on the downbeat future-era Turtles stories, in "Old Times" for Plastron Cafe.
What strikes me more about "Survivalists" than its politics then, is giving the ending to Don's basic sympathy with the idea of cherishing survival, melancholy note that that is. But the issue's politics still can't be mistaken as being anything other than quite loud. Again, I don't think you'd see a similar issue come out today without it raising some stink on this forum, much as those in this thread like to claim otherwise:
https://i.imgur.com/9NOpJTB.png
(Incidentally, "Survivalists" is an excellent issue, and much like "Donatello," an important herald of the tone and nature of the book to come, if not quite as good as that one.)
But I wouldn't say in a too preachy way.
Not too preachy?? (https://imgur.com/a/zz5krwy) :lol:
Now, that said, I absolutely hold that up as a strength of Adventures, in particular because it's a kids' title. The impression is very much that Murphy felt obligated to use his position on a wide-reaching kids' book to affect some sort of positive change, rather than simply offer something as insipid as the cartoon was, and that's admirable (especially since he also churned out both a much more fun version of the toy line/cartoon lore and compelling character drama while at it). Even if trite environmental messages were par for the course in the early '90s, the specificity with which Murphy went for them was not--nor were keeping the sites on corporations rather than consumers or introducing many of the book's other issues, from classism to apartheid to a crash course on world religions (to the chagrin of some of the letters' writers, who he lets own themselves by placing them without response between more open-minded commentary) to war to slavery in third-world countries to ... you name it. The book got around. And though it was always didactic, it was getting around to a lot of very non-textbook issues, especially at the time. I think it did leave an impression on those grounds, while also hooking kids with its story, and that balancing act should be celebrated.
If you want to see an author phoning in environmental messages out of obligation, by the way, look no further than the abysmal Archie "Specials." Murphy's always 100 percent sincere in what he's writing, and that shines through.
But, to the point of the thread, what he's writing is always lefty politics, and always touching on things that could, and did, cause controversy among some of the book's right-leaning readers/parents of readers at the time.
That's TMNT Adventures. A darling of this fandom (and rightfully so). To a large extent, that's also Mirage, where he was one of its most prominent voices.
There's no way Eastman could be a leftist. That dude is like obsessed with guns in everything he does.
I wouldn't be so quick to guess at Eastman's personal voting record, although it wouldn't particularly surprise me if he leaned right. (Someone else brought up whether that mightn't cause friction with the rest of the Mirage staff, but ... I mean, it's possible it did, as they didn't exactly all stay tight, right? Anyway.)
But I don't think use of guns in his fiction alone is any solid window into that. I'd be happy to see the Second Amendment repealed, and yet super-duper-shoot-'em'-up-heavy Hellsing is still in my shortlist of manga/comics. I'm pretty sure the Wachowskis aren't rallying for gun deregulation anytime soon, and yet they reinvented standards for Hollywood firearm action. So Eastman liking and homaging John Woo films and other gun action in his comics isn't quite the *ahem* smoking gun it might seem to be. Although this is notably all beside the point of the thread.
On that note, it's worth noting what is actually said of and shown on guns in Turtles comics Eastman has his name on as either co- or sole writer:
https://i.imgur.com/KYdxTo2.png
https://i.imgur.com/ANCpYXW.png
https://i.imgur.com/kYVqNAR.png
And then even in Bodycount, Casey constantly reiterates his dislike for guns as mentioned in Tales Vol. 1 #1, and Raph apologizes for getting too into them.
You can kind of see where Adventures Leonardo was pulling from.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 05:57 AM
**Forgive the double post; ran over the character limit**
Didn't Cudley send the turtles to the future by mistake where the greenhouse effect caused mass flooding and stuff. I wonder if it was the future-future or like say... 2012 and we already passed that year in real life.
Despite Cudley's promise that it was simply one potential outcome in the first arc, it is the canonical future of that universe. (And, likewise, a similar greenhouse-gas future awaits the Mirage universe.) It is also set 100 years in the future (around 2090-the early 2100s), as mentioned. No 2012 prediction.
https://i.imgur.com/Pz7kLxI.png
This was a long series of responses, but: Is whatever IDW's doing now really that much more left-leaning or didactic than much of Mirage and Adventures? ****, I kind of want to see it if it is. Even if just Laird, Lawson, Murphy--they were the defining voices on those books. If they weren't your thing, I can understand taking issue, but a melancholy touching on current issues, often somewhat (or very) left-leaning if one is looking to label them, was part of their DNA. In that regard, IDW's vehemently apolitical Saturday-morning action serial approach was kind of the odd man out. Again, for better or worse, but I can't understand drawing a line on that if those series are still in your good graces.
I think another thing that's apparent is that come ten years time, people will look at whatever is raising hackles over being too political, too woke for genre comics today, and not see in it anything controversial at all. Chronological distance tends to obscure that, such that we can look at something like #12 in Mirage and somehow come away not seeing anything pointedly political at all.
--That was all about TMNT comics. This next bit isn't, but was too ridiculous to not respond to.--
Thanks to Geena Davis, there's an actual group working in Hollywood right now whose entire job is to go over every script and ensure it has the "acceptable" number of gays, trans, and non-whites in it, before anyone can even think about producing it.
1) You haven't seen a blockbuster movie in the past few years that didn't have gay characters in it?
2) Movie studios are going to play to their bottom line, so if there's focus-testing for this that or the other thing, including diversity quotient, that's nothing new. If it hurt their bottom line, they wouldn't go for it. As with all focus-tested results, some results will feel clunkier than others, but these aren't worth singling out anymore than a hot-babe or muscly-dude quotient would have been for studio projects prior. If you want something that doesn't feel cynical, you'll have to look outside of tentpole films, and that's been the case for, god, decades, and to some extent forever.
3) You're arguing about the boogeyman of a (studio-elected) mandatory minimum for representation in a certain scale of project. There was a mandatory cap in decades prior, which was zero. Was that better?
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
07-19-2022, 06:21 AM
In 1988, the United Nations presented a report about the consequenses of global warming. A new. wave of environmentalism (the first was in the early 1970's) spread. During the upcoming years, climate was on everyone's lips, but the proposed solutions were never as extreme as during later waves. This peaked in June 1992 when the Agenda 21 was adopted during the United Nations Environmental Conference in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Captain Planet was launched in September 1990, and Toxic Crusaders had already aired in mid 1990. So, eco-awareness was a big thing in comics and cartoons during those years. Of course, TMNT Adventures also attempted to ride that wave.
mrmaczaps
07-19-2022, 07:10 AM
I wouldn't be so quick to guess at Eastman's personal voting record, although it wouldn't particularly surprise me if he leaned right. (Someone else brought up whether that mightn't cause friction with the rest of the Mirage staff, but ... I mean, it's possible it did, as they didn't exactly all stay tight, right? Anyway.)
But I don't think use of guns in his fiction alone is any solid window into that. I'd be happy to see the Second Amendment repealed, and yet super-duper-shoot-'em'-up-heavy Hellsing is still in my shortlist of manga/comics. I'm pretty sure the Wachowskis aren't rallying for gun deregulation anytime soon, and yet they reinvented standards for Hollywood firearm action. So Eastman liking and homaging John Woo films and other gun action in his comics isn't quite the *ahem* smoking gun it might seem to be. Although this is notably all beside the point of the thread.
You ***want*** to be enslaved by the Government? No firearms puts all lives at risk & everyone in MORE danger.
Eastman is an opportunist. Of the bunch, he seems most guarded about what he believes but I still wouldn't call him a conservative at all. Its all about the money there....
I would like to hear more about the tank he bought & what ever happened to it. Lol
Cipher
07-19-2022, 07:25 AM
You ***want*** to be enslaved by the Government? No firearms puts all lives at risk & everyone in MORE danger.
Yes. I want to be enslaved by the government.
Eastman is an opportunist. Of the bunch, he seems most guarded about what he believes but I still wouldn't call him a conservative at all. Its all about the money there....
I would like to hear more about the tank he bought & what ever happened to it. Lol
Eastman's political persuasion being "opportunist" is absolutely something I can buy. :lol: Outside of him though, Mirage (and certainly Archie) tended to put out books with some regularity that I think would have been fodder for "get woke, go broke" criticism today, were either their publishing shifted to the present or current audiences shifted back in time. (And heck, basically were, just using different verbiage. Scope Adventure's letter pages, and I'm sure Mirage caught some never published.) Even the "I hate guns" asides present in Eastman's own issues (Tales #1, Vol. 1#14), would have engendered an angry YouTube rant or two.
Either comics both now and then are worse off for it, or the rhetoric now has become more kneejerk and overblown. You can probably guess which way I lean, though not if you're as bad at guessing that as guessing my motivation on political stances.
ChosenOne
07-19-2022, 08:56 AM
https://i.ibb.co/gRTY693/tumblr-lmusu1oh5-H1qcie3x540.gif
Cipher
07-19-2022, 09:11 AM
Lol @ it only taking four posts on a comic book to get to speculation on my sex life.
Never change, y'all.
Leo656
07-19-2022, 09:23 AM
I have no dog in this but that is the choppiest gif I've seen in like 10 years. Blargh.
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 10:19 AM
What is woke?
Woke is genderbending, racebending, and/or queerifying established straight white male characters for token points. Woke is taking a big dump on the American flag while proudly waving the Marxist flag. Woke is making every female character an unstoppable, one-dimensional Mary-Sue while making every male character a weak bumbling idiot, you know, for “girl power”. Woke is making at least 60% of the cast LGBTQ+. Woke is calling fans the “enemy” simply for criticizing poorly written non-white/gay characters that were only added in for representation.
Sheesh, I tired myself trying to explain it.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 10:32 AM
Thank you for taking the time to answer. Responses and a few questions below.
Woke is genderbending, racebending, and/or queerifying established straight white male characters for token points.
Got it.
Woke is taking a big dump on the American flag while proudly waving the Marxist flag.
What does this look like, in a comic book?
Woke is making every female character an unstoppable, one-dimensional Mary-Sue while making every male character a weak bumbling idiot, you know, for “girl power”.
Got it.
Questions: Which books do or would you say are close to doing that?
Is it worse, the same, or better if male characters are unstoppable but female ones don't play much of a role? Also, can you think of any books that do, did, or were close to doing that? I can come up with a few.
Woke is making at least 60% of the cast LGBTQ+.
Why does this matter?
Woke is calling fans the “enemy” simply for criticizing poorly written non-white/gay characters that were only added in for representation.
Got it.
Question: Is this is substantially different from having it out in letters columns with people writing in angry over religious representation in stories, or other political aspects?
Overall questions: "Woke" (the thing that you get to go broke) seems to pertain mainly issues of representation, right? Especially ones seen as pertaining to active political debate? Is that substantially different from working in a stance on other issues that have been part of active political or social debate, as past TMNT books have done? If these subjects are central to the author's experiences, should they be kept out of the book?
hypered1
07-19-2022, 10:51 AM
The term 'woke' is entirely misused these days: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/woke&ved=2ahUKEwjb-cCDp4X5AhXIgVwKHVWQAEIQFnoECEcQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1msCNPvxdpfdKvZBvbKsOI
CyberCubed
07-19-2022, 10:53 AM
There is a quota of the number of gay/lesbian characters before something can be woke. It used to be about black characters now it's about orientation.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 10:57 AM
The term 'woke' is entirely misused these days: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/woke&ved=2ahUKEwjb-cCDp4X5AhXIgVwKHVWQAEIQFnoECEcQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1msCNPvxdpfdKvZBvbKsOI
Woah, now! That definition sounds like it could apply to quite a few Mirage and Archie books.
But everyone was okay with them, so that can't be it.
There is a quota of the number of gay/lesbian characters before something can be woke. It used to be about black characters now it's about orientation.
What is the argument being made here in regards to Black or gay characters then?
That we need to keep them ... under ... a certain limit? ... To not be woke and go broke?
You're totally right that these same arguments would have applied to Black characters in the past. Thanks for pointing that out! What would have been the acceptable cap on them to prevent this trend toward wokeness?
hypered1
07-19-2022, 11:04 AM
Woah, now! That definition sounds like it could apply to quite a few Mirage and Archie books.
But everyone was okay with them, so that can't be it.
Well that's what you get when the ignorant try to weaponise that which they do not understand.
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 11:10 AM
There is a quota of the number of gay/lesbian characters before something can be woke. It used to be about black characters now it's about orientation.
I don't think so. It could be the 90s and you could make a movie or comic or whatever about a group of black friends and no one would say that was "woke."
Cipher
07-19-2022, 11:15 AM
I don't think so. It could be the 90s and you could make a movie or comic or whatever about a group of black friends and no one would say that was "woke."
So what changed? The content or the reactions?
And to get back to the focus of this thread, did TMNT comics ever change (except under Waltz), or do we just feel different ways about what topics they touch? (This is assuming Campbell's even brought back topical/personal writing period, and I still feel like maybe everyone's blowing things out of proportion and IDW is the same reference-oriented light action serial it's always been + like, a gay character, but heck, I'll at least check out IDW Collection 14 now to see.)
(Also, for Mirage/Laird: Was this woke? Or was it okay because she wasn't didn't make up a high enough percentage of the cast?)
https://i.imgur.com/4KZVHff.png
Also holy **** that name that's so bad
ChosenOne
07-19-2022, 11:19 AM
I have no dog in this but that is the choppiest gif I've seen in like 10 years. Blargh.
You mean "BlARRRgh".
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 11:21 AM
So what changed? The content or the reactions?
Content.
(Also, for Mirage/Laird: Was this woke? Or was it okay because she wasn't didn't make up a high enough percentage of the cast?)
https://i.imgur.com/4KZVHff.png
Also holy **** that name that's so bad
Some blink and you miss it thing from Vol. 4? No. Not woke. Just a "who cares?"/"who even noticed?" thing.
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 11:23 AM
Why does this matter?
Let me better explain it so that I won’t come off as some homophobic bigot.
I didn’t say if 50% of the entire cast was LGBTQ+. I said at least 60%, because unless you were making an actual LGBTQ+ comic/movie, that would be considered unrealistic overrepresentation and even pandering. And often the authors who are more worried checking inclusion boxes end up making poorly written characters that actually end up offending the targeted minority groups. And woke is all about pandering.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 11:36 AM
I haven't read IDW TMNT since somewhere around City Fall but from what I gather, basically there was 100 issues that were story-driven then suddenly said story was forcibly grinded to a halt and everything was made to be about LGBTQ and Lizzo-style body positivity stuff and the like.
I swear I'm going to read this and it's going to be, like, exactly the same string of old-version references and Saturday-morning action drama + more LGBT characters in the past and occasional glances at real-world topics that matter to the author. The last things I heard about the book were that it was working in Tokka and Rhazar, the Punk Frogs, and Venus.
But: Overarching plot grinding to a halt to touch on issues personal and political of import to the author feels a lot like ... past TMNT comics? If it's actually that, and if it's not as good as (I think) the Mirage and Archie writers were, that could be due to other craft failings, but I don't see the idea that it would be on principle anywhere. I just don't really see the difference between working in some LGBT issues or body positivity or whatever else, if the topics are tackled sincerely, and Laird taking swipes at far-right rhetoric in the '80s or Murphy ... literally any of the things Murphy touched on ... in the '90s. I would argue the Mirage and Archie books tended to be more personal-topical than explicitly political-topical, but they were still touching freely on things that had at least some political and social debate. Frankly, touching on LGBT experiences, etc., is pretty far on the personal-topical side as well.
Let me better explain it so that I won’t come off as some homophobic bigot.
I didn’t say if 50% of the entire cast was LGBTQ+. I said at least 60%, because unless you were making an actual LGBTQ+ comic/movie, that would be considered unrealistic overrepresentation and even pandering. And often the authors who are more worried checking inclusion boxes end up making poorly written characters that actually end up offending the targeted minority groups. And woke is all about pandering.
Okay, so, more questions:
1) Is the current TMNT comic 60 percent LGBT? If not, then is it fine?
2) If the story is about a gay community, can it have a 60 percent+ LGBT cast? Or is that topic inherently woke and bad?
3) What's the difference between pandering and sincerity if the author cares about the topic they're tackling? Does the distinction matter?
Related and to keep this focused, were Mirage or Archie TMNT ever pandering? (I would argue yes, in the non-Murphy Archie specials, but outside of those.)
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 12:00 PM
Okay, so, more questions:
1) Is the current TMNT comic 60 percent LGBT? If not, then is it fine?
2) If the story is about a gay community, can it have a 60 percent+ LGBT cast? Or is that topic inherently woke and bad? Can a story be inherently woke and disingenuous just by being about a particular group?
3) What's the difference between pandering and sincerity if the author cares about the topic they're tackling? Does the distinction matter?
Related and to keep this focused, were Mirage or Archie TMNT ever pandering? (I would argue yes, in the non-Murphy Archie specials, but outside of those.)
I actually stopped reading the comic after issue #113, so I’m not sure how many LGBT characters are in there now, but last time I checked, it was about, what, 20%, maybe less? But I also remember it having crappy fanfiction-esque writing as well as some unnecessary political analogies (for example the MAGA people protesting the idea of letting mutants back into society in the “Jennika” series) and Jennika becoming a Mary-Sue that now dates chicks because she got dumped/betrayed by her two previous boyfriends (because men suck, right?). I left because I saw how unbearably woke it was becoming.
I loved the TV show “The Proud Family”, even though I’m not black. Why? Because all of the main characters were funny, well-written, and more importantly, relatable, and the show didn’t portray all white people as uncaring insensitive monsters; sure there were a couple, but the rest were pretty decent characters. That show was not “woke” despite it being a “black” show. The same applies to “The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air”. Everyone of all races could enjoy those shows, not just black people. Did those shows tackle the topics of racism and prejudice? Yes, but it wasn’t done in a way that made you feel bad about being born white like how a lot of woke shows/comics do.
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 12:07 PM
"When activism/diversity for the sake of diversity/virtue signaling for this cause or that cause or this group becomes the driving force of a creative work, overshadowing everything or almost everything else going on in it" is the answer I think Cipher is digging for. But I think he already knew that.
I loved the TV show “The Proud Family”, even though I’m not black. Why? Because all of the main characters were funny, well-written, and more importantly, relatable, and the show didn’t portray all white people as uncaring insensitive monsters; sure there were a couple, but the rest were pretty decent characters. That show was not “woke” despite it being a “black” show.
Is that what that is? I thought "The Proud Family" was a big LGBTQ thing.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 12:10 PM
Okay, see, now we're at least getting into nitty gritty about what may or may not feel sincere about how it tackles issues, which is at least something I can engage with. On bits of execution like that, I can't comment without having read it.
Yes, but it wasn’t done in a way that made you feel bad about being born white like how a lot of woke shows/comics do.
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.
Certainly seemed like the older TMNT comics could occasionally make people feel about about being of certain political views (immigration, anything anti-environmentalism, Murphy letting intolerant Christian parents quietly dunk on themselves in letter columns, Laird taking potshots at essentially MAGA rhetoric two three decades removed, etc.), but they weren't hurting anyone and that kind of comes with the territory of touching on something sincere. You run the risk of putting off those who don't identify with it.
Now, how adeptly or how sincerely it seems like recent TMNT is doing all of that, again, I can't say. But the opening quip of this thread was to get at: Unless it's handled in the clumsiest way imaginable, it isn't new territory for even widely celebrated TMNT comics. Just new territory for IDW (the outlier), and maybe new issues.
"When activism/diversity for the sake of diversity/virtue signaling for this cause or that cause or this group becomes the driving force of a creative work, overshadowing everything or almost everything else going on in it" is the answer I think Cipher is digging for. But I think he already knew that.
I don't now that I would have put it that way--I think activism in a certain respect being the driving work of a piece can still lend toward quality work, especially with pulp comics when tend to not be all that subtle in the first place. I especially think that's true of Adventures, where a lot of time the topic leads the plot, but Murphy still turns in a fun, engaging series around it, and engenders even more good will since I like that he's trying to not waste his opportunity on a kids' book with that reach. Even at its least subtle, my overwhelming sense is "This is the only way this man could sleep at night" rather than "He's trying to score brownie points." There's a bit of that energy, and not just from him, in portions of Mirage as well. Again, not always directly political, but you got the sense that multiple writers really were working through things that felt close to them. I like that.
But "virtue signaling"? Sure, if we take that to mean the empty gesturing toward something the author doesn't care about either, or can't mesh germanely with their storytelling, and that lack of caring generally leads to poor storytelling results on a number of fronts not just related to what it tackles.
Is Campbell making empty gestures? I wouldn't have thought so (frankly I still kind of doubt the gestures are being made so heavily period in a book where major beats(?) are still based around "This thing is back!" that I found so exhausting under Waltz--who, full apologies if you're reading this), but heck, maybe it's clunky.
But yeah, obviously a lot of my rhetoric here is leading. But other spots are genuinely my wondering where people are drawing lines and how they're viewing things.
hypered1
07-19-2022, 12:31 PM
I actually stopped reading the comic after issue #113, so I’m not sure how many LGBT characters are in there now, but last time I checked, it was about, what, 20%, maybe less?
There have been 3 confirmed LGBTQ+ characters: Jennika, Sheena and Lindsay Baker; about 3% out of a cast of maybe 100 or so that's about right for a group of that size: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/how-many-people-lgbt/
I left because I saw how unbearably woke it was becoming.
And you've proven my point that most people don't actually know what woke means > 'aware of and actively attentive to important facts and issues (especially issues of racial and social justice)' as per the dictionary definition I posted
ChosenOne
07-19-2022, 12:32 PM
Something, something in the dungeon.
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 12:33 PM
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.
Well, you explain why Jennika started dating Sheena. Was it because they have real chemistry (which I don’t see and it feels weird and forced to me), or is it because Jennika got screwed over by men her entire life and thought that women would treat her better? If Jennika was a lesbian from the beginning but started dating Casey and became bisexual like she is now, you think the SJWs would handle that change well? Heck no. They’d scream “homophobia” until their faces turned blue, even though bisexuality is part of the LGBTQ+ category. I know someone who got crap for making the “Hazbin Hotel” character Angel Dust bisexual in her fan art, even though he is portrayed as gay in the show. And given that both of Jenny’s boyfriends were straight white males, it wouldn’t be a stretch to assume that Sophie made her date Sheena because she, herself, has a personal vendetta against straight white men.
Andrew NDB
07-19-2022, 12:33 PM
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.
The right question to ask here is, "Does it try to?"
And I don't know the answer. All I've known about IDW TMNT for a long time now is that it isn't for me, and that has nothing to do with wokeness or anything.
Certainly seemed like the older TMNT comics could occasionally make people feel about about being of certain political views (immigration, anything anti-environmentalism, Murphy letting intolerant Christian parents quietly dunk on themselves in letter columns, Laird taking potshots at essentially MAGA rhetoric two three decades removed, etc.), but they weren't hurting anyone and that kind of comes with the territory of touching on something sincere. You run the risk of putting off those who don't identify with it.
Occasionally. And I would leave the letter column out of the equation because it's the letter column.
Maybe the difference is that what little of this there was in Mirage and Archie, it was because the main plot of a given issue did not grind to a halt to dwell on whatever the issue at hand was (pollution, global warming, etc.). I suppose you could point to fleeting spots in Vol. 4, but while I dig it there was hardly a lot of momentum in the overall narrative to begin with for it not to grind to a halt here and there.
And then -- it appears -- that there is large pockets of IDW TMNT material where it's like the author reaching through the comic book, waving an arm at the reader, "Look? See? Fat is beautiful. And look over here, healthy lesbian relationship. See over there? Another one. Oh, wait! Right! Coming out stories, got it covered! Over here and here and here. Elections are a big deal right now, I got that covered next issue, too!" And so on.
But I don't know.
I don't now that I would have put it that way--I think activism in a certain respect being the driving work of a piece can still lend toward quality work, especially with pulp comics when tend to not be all that subtle in the first place. I especially think that's true of Adventures, where a lot of time the topic leads the plot
Hm... what would be examples of TMNTA issues where it led the plot?
But "virtue signaling"? Sure, if we take that to mean the empty gesturing toward something the author doesn't care about either,
It can be something they care about. But mostly it is the looking for the likes and the high fives from "the community" and/or their echo chamber of like-minded people that is the motivating factor at play. The search for validation and affirmation that they're doing good fighting the good fight, on the right side of history, etc.
Cowabung-Gal
07-19-2022, 12:36 PM
There have been 3 confirmed LGBTQ+ characters: Jennika, Sheila and Lindsay Baker; about 3% out of a cast of maybe 100 or so that's about right for a group of that size: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/how-many-people-lgbt/
You forgot the raccoon and his platypus boyfriend, as well as the blue poison dart frog Jay.
hypered1
07-19-2022, 12:42 PM
You forgot the raccoon and his platypus boyfriend, as well as the blue poison dart frog Jay.
Still doesn't make up an excessive amount of characters and those three, Bandit, Puggle and Jay are all minor recurring characters at best.
CyberCubed
07-19-2022, 07:15 PM
Cipher if you saw this out of context would you assume this belonged in TMNT:
https://i.imgur.com/OBMrEXi.jpeg
For reference, this is Jennika (a female mutant turtle), and Sheena, a female pig mutant who was a human rockstar. Keep in note when Jennika was human, she had a crush on Casey Jones and they apparently briefly became a couple off-screen and broke up.
Now that Jennika is a mutant Turtle, she suddenly went full lesbo with a female pig mutant. Now we have two lesbian mutants in TMNT instead of an action franchise about the Turtles fighting ninjas and battling aliens or mutants.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 07:21 PM
Lmao, you guys.
So, I read the second volume of the Campbell run, #106-110, since it was free with Kindle Unlimited. As prep, I also read through about half of the IDW Collection #12, since it was also included, just so I had a little chunk of the later Waltz era for comparison.
Quick praise for the the 12th collection: I was pleasantly surprised by and really enjoyed Ian Flynn's Michelangelo one-shot and Ryan Ferrier's Mutagen Man-Mondo two-parter in Universe. The main book issues included let me kind of cold, but I didn't have any context and they were plot-heavy, so I don't think I can respond fairly to them. (Feeling extremely plot heavy with scant character moments was one of the things that got me to eventually drop the book, but things may have changed and this was just the wrong spot to drop in. Or not, and anyway, to each their own.)
For the Campbell issues ... this was what the fuss was about?
I enjoyed them a lot more than I had most of IDW when I was reading it, but I'm still not sure it's my thing. I do like that we have more downtime, and the interesting roles it's put characters like the Turtles Hob into though (the issue with him where the weasels sneak in really piqued my interest, and the weasels themselves are also great, even though I have no idea what's up with them). I also got a chuckle here and there, out of bits like the Koya-Karai-Bludgeon scene, the weasels and Hob, and a few other sections. It feels like it's really doing something new, even though the "remember X?" reliance in certain spots still got me. It's IDW.
Anyway, here's the tally on what people told me was too woke about it, or too different from whatever previous Turtles books have done:
--------------
Touching on real-world issues: Five pages.
Alopex and Mona discuss how the government isn't looking out for them, which could be read as an allusion to governments failing marginalized communities in general. One page. Ripe for commentary, but in this case it's also an immediate setup for discussing more Mutant Town government establishment talk, which is a natural avenue for storytelling and I'm guessing something for future plot points?
Michelangelo watches talking heads inaccurately discuss mutants on the news, and then a reporter asks him weird mating questions before even getting his name. Two pages. Yeah, that's probably a trans allegory, huh? But it's a good one and germane to the characters and setting. If you don't want to read it as one, incidentally, you don't have to, as it fits right into the plot without being overt or didactic at all, which was a mode Mirage and Archie hardly ever turned to for their real-world topics, much as I love them and their bluntness. If you want to just read it as a beat for Michelangelo's motivation you can, but if you want to put two and two together on discussing groups in media without their representation or immediately asking about people's junk not being great, that's there too. I was told this was the unsubtle one. What about this is less subtle than Laird plucking far-right-wing rhetoric for villains, greenhouse-gas futures, Radical waxing about industrialization next to neon buffalo signs, or Jagwar taking a moment to shout about deforestation mid-action, I'm not sure.
Mona fails to earn her parents' sympathies over a video call. Two pages. Yeah, that's a trans allegory. See above.
Also, Michelangelo being inspired by that encounter to start his own radio show is interesting and just a decent, human story angle. I like that. It's not really a political allegory at all, unless championing the power of humanistic journalism and storytelling counts as one. Makes good use of his character.
LGBT characters: Two.
The only characters' whose sexuality I know isn't straight in this five-issue volume are Jennika and her girlfriend. Are we at 60 percent yet?
Girls being invincible and guys sucking: Zero.
Jennika does exactly the same things in the action scenes as the other Turtles, winning or losing when the group does.
Raph beats a female biker in a race.
Later, the Turtles beat a female lemur who invades their house.
All other female characters: April, Mona, Alopex, Sally, Sheena, Karai, Koya ... am I missing anyone? ... don't get any action this volume.
So that's actually ... one instance of a girl doing the same things the rest of her all-guy group is, and two of girls losing to guys.
Not that it would be a problem if the ratio skewed the other way, but this was the unnatural, distracting girl-power that was putting people off the book? Feminists need a better rep.
Gender/race/sexualitybending: Zero.
Race isn't much of a factor when the bulk of the book has become mutant animals, but all the human characters who showed up had the same skin tones as their initial appearances.
There've been a grand total of 2.5 instances of that in TMNT history ever, right? Two of which, Baxter in the original cartoon, and Eric Saks only very narrowly not replacing Oroku Saki in the first Bay movie, where moving non-white characters to white ones, with only Rise's April being the opposite?
There were no genderbent characters in these issues. I'm aware of two in the IDW book that came up during the Waltz era though, in Null and Jagwar?
No sexuality switches with existing characters that I saw here. At least two of the Turtles were shown/implied to be straight, and I know this April is, etc. The only two explicitly non-straight characters were new ones, which I thought was the right way to do it.
Sh*itting on the American flag and holding up a Marxist one: Zero. Y'all had me excited.
"Remember X?": Two.
Road Hogs
Tokka and Rahzar (the volume cliffhanger)
This was something I was curious about on my own, since I found so distracting in previous IDW material, where I was constantly wishing it would have the confidence to do its own thing. That feels like pandering to me, and always took/takes me out of the book, since it leads to cliffhangers and plot beats that feel like they hinge solely on recognition. I can't say if the rate of that coming up has gotten any better or worse. Two per volume feels maybe on the low side compared to the past, but still pretty high. Anyway, it's still IDW Turtles-ing.
--------------
It's ... IDW, with a little more space for unexplored character territory (the Hob direction is so good; that I'm genuinely curious about, and he was one of the best parts of the book back when I was reading it, as one of its original ones) and some touching on real-world personal/social issues at a rate of five pages per volume. Which I'd absolutely rather have than not, and which puts it more in company of previous Turtle books, but this isn't exactly dominating the content I read. Mirage circa Tales Vol. 2 and Archie would have gotten up to things far less subtle at a higher rate on that front. Again, for better or for worse.
What was there definitely did not feel like pandering; I'm sure that's stuff that's actually on Campbell's mind and that she's been through, just as Laird, Murphy and co. were getting at things near to them. And again: Five pages. One of them's hardly even an allegory.
If you don't enjoy the story direction, then obviously feel free to not enjoy it--and I can see why people who were super gung-ho on the Waltz era over any other Turtles books might not be having a great time. But the talk about this feeling more politically pandering or issue-heavy than any pre-Waltz TMNT comics is so disingenuous. I say having read all that pre-Waltz stuff up and down, and now having read this for comparison.
Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?
EDIT -- Other note: I also liked the page of Sheena, Mona and Jennika sitting around drinking beer and discussing bands. That feels believable for a group of recently mutated girls, and it's the kind of moment I don't remember getting much space anywhere in at least the first 30 or so issues under Waltz + the spin-offs. I remember wanting moments like that, since it felt very all-plot all-the-time--even during the "downtime" Northampton arc.
TigerClaw
07-19-2022, 07:41 PM
Lmao, you guys.
So, I read the second volume of the Campbell run, #106-110, since it was free with Kindle Unlimited. As prep, I also read through about half of the IDW Collection #12, since it was also included, just so I had a little chunk of the later Waltz era for comparison.
Quick praise for the the 12th collection: I was pleasantly surprised by and really enjoyed Ian Flynn's Michelangelo one-shot and Ryan Ferrier's Mutagen Man-Mondo two-parter in Universe. The main book issues included let me kind of cold, but I didn't have any context and they were plot-heavy, so I don't think I can respond fairly to them. (Feeling extremely plot heavy with scant character moments was one of the things that got me to eventually drop the book, but things may have changed and this was just the wrong spot to drop in. Or not, and anyway, to each their own.)
For the Campbell issues ... this was what the fuss was about?
I enjoyed them a lot more than I had most of IDW when I was reading it, but I'm still not sure it's my thing. I do like that we have more downtime, and the interesting roles it's put characters like the Turtles Hob into though (the issue with him where the weasels sneak in really piqued my interest, and the weasels themselves are also great, even though I have no idea what's up with them). I also got a chuckle here and there, out of bits like the Koya-Karai-Bludgeon scene, the weasels and Hob, and a few other sections. It feels like it's really doing something new, even though the "remember X?" reliance in certain spots still got me. It's IDW.
Anyway, here's the tally on what people told me was too woke about it, or too different from whatever previous Turtles books have done:
--------------
Touching on real-world issues: Five pages.
Alopex and Mona discuss how the government isn't looking out for them, which could be read as an allusion to governments failing marginalized communities in general. One page. Ripe for commentary, but in this case it's also an immediate setup for discussing more Mutant Town government establishment talk, which is a natural avenue for storytelling and I'm guessing something for future plot points?
Michelangelo watches talking heads inaccurately discuss mutants on the news, and then a reporter asks him weird mating questions before even getting his name. Two pages. Yeah, that's probably a trans allegory, huh? But it's a good one and germane to the characters and setting. If you don't want to read it as one, incidentally, you don't have to, as it fits right into the plot without being overt or didactic at all, which was a mode Mirage and Archie hardly ever turned to for their real-world topics, much as I love them and their bluntness. If you want to just read it as a beat for Michelangelo's motivation you can, but if you want to put two and two together on discussing groups in media without their representation or immediately asking about people's junk not being great, that's there too. I was told this was the unsubtle one. What about this is less subtle than Laird plucking far-right-wing rhetoric for villains, greenhouse-gas futures, Radical waxing about industrialization next to neon buffalo signs, or Jagwar taking a moment to shout about deforestation mid-action, I'm not sure.
Mona fails to earn her parents' sympathies over a video call. Two pages. Yeah, that's a trans allegory. See above.
Also, Michelangelo being inspired by that encounter to start his own radio show is interesting and just a decent, human story angle. I like that. It's not really a political allegory at all, unless championing the power of humanistic journalism and storytelling counts as one. Makes good use of his character.
LGBT characters: Two.
The only characters' whose sexuality I know isn't straight in this five-issue volume are Jennika and her girlfriend's. Are we at 60 percent yet?
Girls being invincible and guys sucking: 0.
Jennika does exactly the same things in the action scenes as the other Turtles, winning or losing when the group does.
Raph beats a female biker in a race.
Later, the Turtles beat a female lemur who invades their house.
All other female characters: April, Mona, Alopex, Sally, Sheena, Karai, Koya ... am I missing anyone? ... don't get any action this volume. So that's actually ... one instance of a girl doing the same things the rest of her all-guy group is, and two of girls losing to guys.
Not that it would be a problem if the ratio skewed the other way, but this was the unnatural, distracting girl-power that was putting people off the book?
Remember X?: Two.
Road Hogs
Tokka and Rahzar (the volume cliffhanger)
This was something I was curious about on my own, since I found so distracting in previous IDW material, where I was constantly wishing it would have the confidence to do its own thing. That feels like pandering to me, and always takes me out of the book. I can't say if the rate of that coming up has gotten any better or worse. Two per volume feels maybe on the low side compared to the past, but still pretty high. Anyway, it's still IDW Turtles-ing.
--------------
It's ... IDW, with a little more space for unexplored character territory (the Hob direction is so good; that I'm genuinely curious about, and he was one of the best parts of the book back when I was reading it, as one of its original ones) and some touching on real-world personal/social issues at a rate of five pages per volume. Which I'd absolutely rather have than not, and which puts it more in company of previous Turtle books, but this isn't exactly dominating the content I read. Mirage circa Tales Vol. 2 and Archie would have gotten up to things far less subtle at a higher rate on that front. Again, for better or for worse.
What was there definitely did not feel like pandering; I'm sure that's stuff that's actually on Campbell's mind and that she's been through, just as Laird, Murphy and co. were getting at things near to them. And again: Five pages. One of them's hardly even an allegory.
If you don't enjoy the story direction, then feel free to not enjoy it, and I can see why people who were super gung-ho on the Waltz era over any other Turtles books might not be having a great time. But the talk about this feeling more politically pandering or issue-heavy than any pre-Waltz TMNT comics is so disingenuous.
Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?
And finally after many issues, Raph and Alopex are officially a couple, Raph's relationship with Ninjara in the archie comic didn't last forever since it was near the end of the comic's run when it abruptly got canceled.
But I could see this pairing lasting for way much longer.
neatoman
07-19-2022, 07:45 PM
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.
I'm sorry but the problem isn't so much what the writer wanted to make, it's just that in a purely structural sense, this run is utterly broken. It doesn't qualify as a functional story.
hypered1
07-19-2022, 07:56 PM
Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?
In the IDW series human-born mutants just kinda become random animals unless it's done in a controlled environment like Bebop and Rocksteady. Animal-borns stay the same.
I'll also save you some trouble; a good chunk of the bashing done to the current run is purely because Sophie Campbell is trans to the point that people have directly attacked her, including dead-naming her, with little-to-no connection with the comics themselves.
Cipher
07-19-2022, 07:57 PM
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.
I can see why people would feel that way if they were into the Waltz material, which was always very much a plot-first serial. I enjoyed what I peaked into here more, but sure, I can see why current readers may not like the mode/pacing switch. I suspect the readers who were super into the Waltz material were also ones not super hep on what Mirage became, whereas, as a fan of that material, I feel like I'd be most at home in IDW post-100.
Anyway, that's totally fair! But others have assured me, including in this thread, that something was somehow different/worse about its commentary specifically, and ... I just don't see that.
I have to bite my tongue on the conflict resolution comment and how I felt about the earlier IDW material. I suspect that if that's still an issue, it would be more in a "So what's changed?" vein.
Leo656
07-19-2022, 08:17 PM
I'll also save you some trouble; a good chunk of the bashing done to the current run is purely because Sophie Campbell is trans to the point that people have directly attacked her, including dead-naming her, with little-to-no connection with the comics themselves.
Nah. That's projection. Typical "What you REALLY mean is THIS..." stuff.
I mean, I am quite sure a couple of people here are mad at that - and you can tell Who those people are in just about every case - but that's assuredly not the case for every single person who hates the run or even the majority. It's a convenient bogeyman to point at - "Those awful transphobes!" - but I remain unconvinced.
mrmaczaps
07-19-2022, 08:37 PM
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.
I'm sorry but the problem isn't so much what the writer wanted to make, it's just that in a purely structural sense, this run is utterly broken. It doesn't qualify as a functional story.
All that and the highlights of new characters being introduced are like fireworks, all light show & no dead terrorists. Lol or foot clan...
The jennika minis both sucked less than the ongoing and yet none of those two stories tied back into the main much at all... and mostly could have been told in the ongoing.
neatoman
07-19-2022, 09:02 PM
I have to bite my tongue on the conflict resolution comment and how I felt about the earlier IDW material. I suspect that if that's still an issue, it would be more in a "So what's changed?" vein.
A fundamental difference between Waltz and Campbell is that Waltz has a much better understanding of cause and effect. So let's take Bebop and Rocksteady as an example, since that might be the most obvious thing.
Right, so even though I'm not convinced Waltz really cares that much about Bebop and Rocksteady, given how little he used them and how much they come across like outsiders to the character drama, he still writes them fairly consistently. In issue 42, Shredder assigns them to guard Donatello in case he attempts to betray Shredder during the invasion plan, when Shredder believes he has he orders them to kill him which they attempt to do, even if they are almost distracted by Metalhead. They then leave because Karai orders them to return to HQ and don't make sure Don is dead as a result, this allows Don to temporarily use the Metalhead body while he is getting surgery. Later on during the gauntlet, their tendency to get distracted and carelessness is used to defeat them. When Splinter takes control of the Foot, they let go because of their violent nature and loyalty to the Shredder.
As for Campbell's attempt to write them, it's seriously confusing. They're sent into Mutant Town to look for Karai who is missing but seemingly just forget their mission and goes into the nightclub to kick the band off the stage and start playing their own music. Then they are willing to follow orders again after a little while and when they come across Tokka and Rahzar, they start fighting them. During this fight, they attempt to kill Tokka and Rahzar, at which point they are stopped by being offered a battle of the bands, at which point they once again start ignoring orders and completely stop trying to fight Tokka and Rahzar. When the battle of the bands eventually comes, they don't even play because they think the other band is too good and just leave peacefully.
The way Waltz writes them follow a clear line of events that make sense with what we know about them and they always act in character, which in this case means obedient, dumb and violent, which each new action being influenced by the previous ones. While Campbell tries to write them in character to some extent, Campbell also keeps having them act out of character in case it suits the story and the conflict keeps ending abruptly with no clear cause and effect in place.
In short, Campbell's writing is far less coherent, and don't even get me started on the whole "It looked like Venus abducted herself" gibberish in the most recent issue.
Topsu
07-20-2022, 05:50 AM
In short, Campbell's writing is far less coherent, and I don't even get me started on the whole "It looked like Venus abducted herself" gibberish in the most recent issue.
At some points I really felt punk frogs story could've been good, but then it had some of the worst art in series, and then that "abduction" that made really no sense at all.
I don't really hate Campbell run, it has it's good points, but it's been a slow burner. Can't remember anything as stupidly written as Venus abduction tho.
CyberCubed
07-21-2022, 09:01 AM
Did anyone else think April and Oyuki were having lesbian sex behind the scenes in the Archie series? I always got that vibe from them since they were living together. I wish we could have known.
Cowabung-Gal
07-21-2022, 11:38 AM
Did anyone else think April and Oyuki were having lesbian sex behind the scenes in the Archie series? I always got that vibe from them since they were living together. I wish we could have known.
Well, given that Casey Jones never made an appearance in the Archie comics…
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
07-21-2022, 12:27 PM
Well, given that Casey Jones never made an appearance in the Archie comics…
Unless you take the TMNT Breakfast Cereals comics from Ralston Purina as Archie canon (even if he never had any April O'Neil romance).
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/09/tmnt-cereal-comics-1-2-and-3-ralston.html
Leo656
07-21-2022, 05:21 PM
It's definitely my headcanon but I can't say if that was the intended message or not.
neatoman
07-21-2022, 06:08 PM
Well, I've seen at least seven different pieces of art inspired by a certain scene from the 4Kids cartoon, so people who want to see this sort of thing will see it in anything...
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/e4cecc68-3793-437d-aa68-55a342225ab8/dbn8qps-c59f915a-a715-4a9e-94f8-d7c671a047e3.png/v1/fill/w_1024,h_1024,strp/karai_april_request_by_inover_myhead_dbn8qps-fullview.png?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI 1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNh NWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMT g4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7 ImhlaWdodCI6Ijw9MTAyNCIsInBhdGgiOiJcL2ZcL2U0Y2VjYz Y4LTM3OTMtNDM3ZC1hYTY4LTU1YTM0MjIyNWFiOFwvZGJuOHFw cy1jNTlmOTE1YS1hNzE1LTRhOWUtOTRmOC1kN2M2NzFhMDQ3ZT MucG5nIiwid2lkdGgiOiI8PTEwMjQifV1dLCJhdWQiOlsidXJu OnNlcnZpY2U6aW1hZ2Uub3BlcmF0aW9ucyJdfQ.5sJFu87MGki 8JdE2J6CeKU5oagTQR3NoVQFq1bi4jHk
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/dc8518e5-490e-4b49-892d-b624b7de0c89/dc5b5lx-cd945325-cceb-4c03-9010-3400d770f1c6.png/v1/fill/w_1024,h_745,strp/unexpected_by_chlodnikus_dc5b5lx-fullview.png?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI 1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNh NWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMT g4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7 ImhlaWdodCI6Ijw9NzQ1IiwicGF0aCI6IlwvZlwvZGM4NTE4ZT UtNDkwZS00YjQ5LTg5MmQtYjYyNGI3ZGUwYzg5XC9kYzViNWx4 LWNkOTQ1MzI1LWNjZWItNGMwMy05MDEwLTM0MDBkNzcwZjFjNi 5wbmciLCJ3aWR0aCI6Ijw9MTAyNCJ9XV0sImF1ZCI6WyJ1cm46 c2VydmljZTppbWFnZS5vcGVyYXRpb25zIl19.UHb076T5x3Pcf q6BEgd6w0FVVrSihU6LKcEo_JRNtfE
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/9c4d386c-ea5b-4263-b384-ee246e6f158f/dbuz0xl-ff849365-aebe-4e5e-b3aa-2f61fee48d05.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJ IUzI1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQz NzNhNWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZT BkMTg4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6 W1t7InBhdGgiOiJcL2ZcLzljNGQzODZjLWVhNWItNDI2My1iMz g0LWVlMjQ2ZTZmMTU4ZlwvZGJ1ejB4bC1mZjg0OTM2NS1hZWJl LTRlNWUtYjNhYS0yZjYxZmVlNDhkMDUuanBnIn1dXSwiYXVkIj pbInVybjpzZXJ2aWNlOmZpbGUuZG93bmxvYWQiXX0.VZPkju3c _qz1Py9Ilo0GgYXusrC4JgYH2r_vfFMZGqQ
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/897d6194-93fc-491b-a133-021569b2c0a8/dbtohqh-d043bedf-cc55-4d9b-90e0-611b74ffb03d.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJ IUzI1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQz NzNhNWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZT BkMTg4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6 W1t7InBhdGgiOiJcL2ZcLzg5N2Q2MTk0LTkzZmMtNDkxYi1hMT MzLTAyMTU2OWIyYzBhOFwvZGJ0b2hxaC1kMDQzYmVkZi1jYzU1 LTRkOWItOTBlMC02MTFiNzRmZmIwM2QuanBnIn1dXSwiYXVkIj pbInVybjpzZXJ2aWNlOmZpbGUuZG93bmxvYWQiXX0.cxlR9OkL dGTbARR3bc_RVdXVSVKwJAoitXzqVShzI4k
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/3c592a85-4cd9-4e7d-97c5-4eedb5bada6d/dbk02xb-422d821c-8653-4bda-8cae-d53a973034e5.png/v1/fill/w_1024,h_764,q_80,strp/april_o_neil_and_karai_by_brakdanych99253_dbk02xb-fullview.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI 1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNh NWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMT g4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7 ImhlaWdodCI6Ijw9NzY0IiwicGF0aCI6IlwvZlwvM2M1OTJhOD UtNGNkOS00ZTdkLTk3YzUtNGVlZGI1YmFkYTZkXC9kYmswMnhi LTQyMmQ4MjFjLTg2NTMtNGJkYS04Y2FlLWQ1M2E5NzMwMzRlNS 5wbmciLCJ3aWR0aCI6Ijw9MTAyNCJ9XV0sImF1ZCI6WyJ1cm46 c2VydmljZTppbWFnZS5vcGVyYXRpb25zIl19.2ZvE9oDvo1mrR 1v4YTlzCu-s3d1t2ZwZ2k1f52ufqco
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/5861af88-7b74-41bf-be68-25635e3a71c3/dc4pobg-853631fa-f5f7-47cf-8725-cc106388bba0.png/v1/fill/w_934,h_742,q_80,strp/commission_april_and_karai_2003_by_alicecherie_dc4 pobg-fullview.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI 1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNh NWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMT g4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7 ImhlaWdodCI6Ijw9NzQyIiwicGF0aCI6IlwvZlwvNTg2MWFmOD gtN2I3NC00MWJmLWJlNjgtMjU2MzVlM2E3MWMzXC9kYzRwb2Jn LTg1MzYzMWZhLWY1ZjctNDdjZi04NzI1LWNjMTA2Mzg4YmJhMC 5wbmciLCJ3aWR0aCI6Ijw9OTM0In1dXSwiYXVkIjpbInVybjpz ZXJ2aWNlOmltYWdlLm9wZXJhdGlvbnMiXX0.gL4rdyfMebyIbZ 1vo2bPgyL4AloHGDLPxGvOZaZHgrE
https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca887773594c2.wixmp.com/f/b93a2bd8-dbbc-4f05-b076-83a5f46b41b0/de5nkzu-2160c478-5c39-4d71-bd3b-b6e552010d55.png/v1/fill/w_1280,h_1024,q_80,strp/_commission__april_o_neil_x_karai_tmnt_2003_by_raf aelmerce_de5nkzu-fullview.jpg?token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI 1NiJ9.eyJzdWIiOiJ1cm46YXBwOjdlMGQxODg5ODIyNjQzNzNh NWYwZDQxNWVhMGQyNmUwIiwiaXNzIjoidXJuOmFwcDo3ZTBkMT g4OTgyMjY0MzczYTVmMGQ0MTVlYTBkMjZlMCIsIm9iaiI6W1t7 ImhlaWdodCI6Ijw9MTAyNCIsInBhdGgiOiJcL2ZcL2I5M2EyYm Q4LWRiYmMtNGYwNS1iMDc2LTgzYTVmNDZiNDFiMFwvZGU1bmt6 dS0yMTYwYzQ3OC01YzM5LTRkNzEtYmQzYi1iNmU1NTIwMTBkNT UucG5nIiwid2lkdGgiOiI8PTEyODAifV1dLCJhdWQiOlsidXJu OnNlcnZpY2U6aW1hZ2Uub3BlcmF0aW9ucyJdfQ.j2dyOpjOMer vUXIC3KzydM72ONrSKoSsdaHukhTEWS0
Did I say seven by the way? I meant seven... That I can show here without getting banned...
Zog The Magnificent
07-21-2022, 06:54 PM
Okay, I've been mostly staying out of this conversation, because sometimes I'm just not in the mood, y'know? With that said...
The comic, in it's current form, is woke. Woke as in "pushing or normalizing a clear agenda related to certain elements of political correctness" (in broadest terms), not what ever other nonsense definition was used to counter that assertation which, let's be honest, is not the colloquial definition that everyone understands and uses in this context.
Secondly, trying to objectively qualify wokeness into a number that you can measure is fool's errand, and also an entirely flawed way of determining wokeness. It's not like something isn't woke if it only has 3 lesbians in it, but as soon as you have 4, then it becomes woke. It's a matter of the context of how the characters are added, how they figure into the narrative, how the writer uses and portrays them, and, in the case of longer running franchises, how does it compare to both the context of the story and how the work handled it previously. Trying to act like the comic is not woke because of the actual physical number of pages that something appears on is not only flawed, but disingenious. Remember, even Darth Vader only has 12 minutes of actual screen time in A New Hope, but it's more about his overall presence in the film and his effect on the narrative and characters. It's the same principle with wokeness. Not only what it does, but how does it actually feel?
Ever since Campbell took over post #100, we have seen a marked increase in traditional woke elements; forced diversity, characters who check boxes before having strong personalities, denegrading of preivous characters, especially men, left leaning politics, pandering, and heavy handed preaching. Campbell's run has had each of these in spades. Jennika, a female version of the turtles, who despite being an uninteresting and unpopular character, is now constantly at the forefront of the plot, and, I might add, a character who was straight, and then suddenly became bisexual. It is no conincidence that the kiss between her and Sheena, another token chacter, happened during an issue released in June.
Besides that, you will notice that Sally, who has been hinted as being gay by the creators, is now sporting a very gender non-comformative outfit, alongside a huge increase in overall prominence. This by itself would not be anything of note, but combined with everything else it's quite telling. In fact, most of the OCs that Cambell has introduced have been gender-nonconforming characters, with many being women despite in no way looking like women, and serving to little more than check off a box.
Besides this, there are also the clear biases present; the "important" plot actions being carried out predominately by Jennika or one of Cambell's OCs, the sidelining of the actual main characters of the book, and the clear and present pandering, as well as the heavy-handed political messages, such as the aforementioned "Not quite MAGA" hats.
Besides all of the this, the comic in general is poorly written. The comic was a slow burn before, but these days NOTHING related to the ongoing plot even develops on the side. We had 25 straight issues of Mutant Town nonsense, developing no significant plot arcs, and focusing on Cambell OCs who didn't have enough character to carry any amount of narrative, as well as inconsistent and at times just plain awful writing, like the aforementioned Bebop and Rockstead example, or the stupid "Venus abducting herself" thing. This comic is overall a shell of it's former self, with woke elements being a clear overarching prescence at the expense of the actual things the majority of readers care about, and in general is badly put together.
The previous comics were not woke for a few simple reasons. Essentially, older comics used politics in general less, presented them in a more even handed fashion, kept them more limited to broader general issues rather than increadibly specific and devisive issues, and usually didn't tell you what to think, instead presenting an idea and letting you come to your own conclusion. Additionally, characters were not put in because they were gay or black, but because they were good characters. It's one thing to have a gay character; it's antother thing entirely when they constantly remind you of it and it's their most significant trait. Who you're having sex with should not be a person's most significant trait, and whenever it is it's a clear sign of wokeness. Plot and characters should always come before wondering how many different ethnicities or sexualities are in the comic, and this is a problem that is unfortunately not limited to just comics. Anyways, that's pretty much the jist of it, and if I keep going I'd probably just repeat myself or ramble.
Cowabung-Gal
07-21-2022, 07:04 PM
Okay, I've been mostly staying out of this conversation, because sometimes I'm just not in the mood, y'know? With that said...
The comic, in it's current form, is woke. Woke as in "pushing or normalizing a clear agenda related to certain elements of political correctness" (in broadest terms), not what ever other nonsense definition was used to counter that assertation which, let's be honest, is not the colloquial definition that everyone understands and uses in this context.
Secondly, trying to objectively qualify wokeness into a number that you can measure is fool's errand, and also an entirely flawed way of determining wokeness. It's not like something isn't woke if it only has 3 lesbians in it, but as soon as you have 4, then it becomes woke. It's a matter of the context of how the characters are added, how they figure into the narrative, how the writer uses and portrays them, and, in the case of longer running franchises, how does it compare to both the context of the story and how the work handled it previously. Trying to act like the comic is not woke because of the actual physical number of pages that something appears on is not only flawed, but disingenious. Remember, even Darth Vader only has 12 minutes of actual screen time in A New Hope, but it's more about his overall presence in the film and his effect on the narrative and characters. It's the same principle with wokeness. Not only what it does, but how does it actually feel?
Ever since Campbell took over post #100, we have seen a marked increase in traditional woke elements; forced diversity, characters who check boxes before having strong personalities, denegrading of preivous characters, especially men, left leaning politics, pandering, and heavy handed preaching. Campbell's run has had each of these in spades. Jennika, a female version of the turtles, who despite being an uninteresting and unpopular character, is now constantly at the forefront of the plot, and, I might add, a character who was straight, and then suddenly became bisexual. It is no conincidence that the kiss between her and Sheena, another token chacter, happened during an issue released in June.
Besides that, you will notice that Sally, who has been hinted as being gay by the creators, is now sporting a very gender non-comformative outfit, alongside a huge increase in overall prominence. This by itself would not be anything of note, but combined with everything else it's quite telling. In fact, most of the OCs that Cambell has introduced have been gender-nonconforming characters, with many being women despite in no way looking like women, and serving to little more than check off a box.
Besides this, there are also the clear biases present; the "important" plot actions being carried out predominately by Jennika or one of Cambell's OCs, the sidelining of the actual main characters of the book, and the clear and present pandering, as well as the heavy-handed political messages, such as the aforementioned "Not quite MAGA" hats.
Besides all of the this, the comic in general is poorly written. The comic was a slow burn before, but these days NOTHING related to the ongoing plot even develops on the side. We had 25 straight issues of Mutant Town nonsense, developing no significant plot arcs, and focusing on Cambell OCs who didn't have enough character to carry any amount of narrative, as well as inconsistent and at times just plain awful writing, like the aforementioned Bebop and Rockstead example, or the stupid "Venus abducting herself" thing. This comic is overall a shell of it's former self, with woke elements being a clear overarching prescence at the expense of the actual things the majority of readers care about, and in general is badly put together.
The previous comics were not woke for a few simple reasons. Essentially, older comics used politics in general less, presented them in a more even handed fashion, kept them more limited to broader general issues rather than increadibly specific and devisive issues, and usually didn't tell you what to think, instead presenting an idea and letting you come to your own conclusion. Additionally, characters were not put in because they were gay or black, but because they were good characters. It's one thing to have a gay character; it's antother thing entirely when they constantly remind you of it and it's their most significant trait. Who you're having sex with should not be a person's most significant trait, and whenever it is it's a clear sign of wokeness. Plot and characters should always come before wondering how many different ethnicities or sexualities are in the comic, and this is a problem that is unfortunately not limited to just comics. Anyways, that's pretty much the jist of it, and if I keep going I'd probably just repeat myself or ramble.
Well said. Couldn’t have said it better myself.
CyberCubed
07-21-2022, 07:14 PM
Reasons Mirage wasn't woke:
1. Only 2 main female characters, April and Karai. April was seldom used at times, and Karai was basically a villain who formed a truce and was then pushed to the sidelines. Neither of them took over the book from the core cast.
2. No gay or lesbian characters. Granted it was the 80's and 90's so it wasn't common back then. The word "transgender" did not exist outside The Jerry Springer show.
3. No forced diversity. Only black characters were villains like Skonk, General Blanque was white, most recurring characters were white. There was some Native American pandering but that was mostly from Murphy
4. There was a quota on things. It was a mostly white male-centered series, with only the occasional female or "person of color" introduced and not a single homosexual character as far as the eye could see.
It's why nobody thought of these things back then, because none of this was an issue. TMNT had an almost all white main cast, barely any females of note, and no diversity, and more importantly no gay or lesbian characters. And nobody cared for 25+ years all the way to the end of Volume 4 and Tales V. 2 in 2010.
mrmaczaps
07-21-2022, 09:17 PM
Okay, I've been mostly staying out of this conversation, because sometimes I'm just not in the mood, y'know? With that said...
The comic, in it's current form, is woke. Woke as in "pushing or normalizing a clear agenda related to certain elements of political correctness" (in broadest terms), not what ever other nonsense definition was used to counter that assertation which, let's be honest, is not the colloquial definition that everyone understands and uses in this context.
Secondly, trying to objectively qualify wokeness into a number that you can measure is fool's errand, and also an entirely flawed way of determining wokeness. It's not like something isn't woke if it only has 3 lesbians in it, but as soon as you have 4, then it becomes woke. It's a matter of the context of how the characters are added, how they figure into the narrative, how the writer uses and portrays them, and, in the case of longer running franchises, how does it compare to both the context of the story and how the work handled it previously. Trying to act like the comic is not woke because of the actual physical number of pages that something appears on is not only flawed, but disingenious. Remember, even Darth Vader only has 12 minutes of actual screen time in A New Hope, but it's more about his overall presence in the film and his effect on the narrative and characters. It's the same principle with wokeness. Not only what it does, but how does it actually feel?
Ever since Campbell took over post #100, we have seen a marked increase in traditional woke elements; forced diversity, characters who check boxes before having strong personalities, denegrading of preivous characters, especially men, left leaning politics, pandering, and heavy handed preaching. Campbell's run has had each of these in spades. Jennika, a female version of the turtles, who despite being an uninteresting and unpopular character, is now constantly at the forefront of the plot, and, I might add, a character who was straight, and then suddenly became bisexual. It is no conincidence that the kiss between her and Sheena, another token chacter, happened during an issue released in June.
Besides that, you will notice that Sally, who has been hinted as being gay by the creators, is now sporting a very gender non-comformative outfit, alongside a huge increase in overall prominence. This by itself would not be anything of note, but combined with everything else it's quite telling. In fact, most of the OCs that Cambell has introduced have been gender-nonconforming characters, with many being women despite in no way looking like women, and serving to little more than check off a box.
Besides this, there are also the clear biases present; the "important" plot actions being carried out predominately by Jennika or one of Cambell's OCs, the sidelining of the actual main characters of the book, and the clear and present pandering, as well as the heavy-handed political messages, such as the aforementioned "Not quite MAGA" hats.
Besides all of the this, the comic in general is poorly written. The comic was a slow burn before, but these days NOTHING related to the ongoing plot even develops on the side. We had 25 straight issues of Mutant Town nonsense, developing no significant plot arcs, and focusing on Cambell OCs who didn't have enough character to carry any amount of narrative, as well as inconsistent and at times just plain awful writing, like the aforementioned Bebop and Rockstead example, or the stupid "Venus abducting herself" thing. This comic is overall a shell of it's former self, with woke elements being a clear overarching prescence at the expense of the actual things the majority of readers care about, and in general is badly put together.
The previous comics were not woke for a few simple reasons. Essentially, older comics used politics in general less, presented them in a more even handed fashion, kept them more limited to broader general issues rather than increadibly specific and devisive issues, and usually didn't tell you what to think, instead presenting an idea and letting you come to your own conclusion. Additionally, characters were not put in because they were gay or black, but because they were good characters. It's one thing to have a gay character; it's antother thing entirely when they constantly remind you of it and it's their most significant trait. Who you're having sex with should not be a person's most significant trait, and whenever it is it's a clear sign of wokeness. Plot and characters should always come before wondering how many different ethnicities or sexualities are in the comic, and this is a problem that is unfortunately not limited to just comics. Anyways, that's pretty much the jist of it, and if I keep going I'd probably just repeat myself or ramble.
Well said. Couldn’t have said it better myself.
Ditto annnnnd ditto. Great. Well done. Exactly.
ryu238
12-20-2024, 09:43 PM
Okay, I've been mostly staying out of this conversation, because sometimes I'm just not in the mood, y'know? With that said...
The comic, in it's current form, is woke. Woke as in "pushing or normalizing a clear agenda related to certain elements of political correctness" (in broadest terms), not what ever other nonsense definition was used to counter that assertation which, let's be honest, is not the colloquial definition that everyone understands and uses in this context.
Secondly, trying to objectively qualify wokeness into a number that you can measure is fool's errand, and also an entirely flawed way of determining wokeness. It's not like something isn't woke if it only has 3 lesbians in it, but as soon as you have 4, then it becomes woke. It's a matter of the context of how the characters are added, how they figure into the narrative, how the writer uses and portrays them, and, in the case of longer running franchises, how does it compare to both the context of the story and how the work handled it previously. Trying to act like the comic is not woke because of the actual physical number of pages that something appears on is not only flawed, but disingenious. Remember, even Darth Vader only has 12 minutes of actual screen time in A New Hope, but it's more about his overall presence in the film and his effect on the narrative and characters. It's the same principle with wokeness. Not only what it does, but how does it actually feel?
Ever since Campbell took over post #100, we have seen a marked increase in traditional woke elements; forced diversity, characters who check boxes before having strong personalities, denegrading of preivous characters, especially men, left leaning politics, pandering, and heavy handed preaching. Campbell's run has had each of these in spades. Jennika, a female version of the turtles, who despite being an uninteresting and unpopular character, is now constantly at the forefront of the plot, and, I might add, a character who was straight, and then suddenly became bisexual. It is no conincidence that the kiss between her and Sheena, another token chacter, happened during an issue released in June.
Besides that, you will notice that Sally, who has been hinted as being gay by the creators, is now sporting a very gender non-comformative outfit, alongside a huge increase in overall prominence. This by itself would not be anything of note, but combined with everything else it's quite telling. In fact, most of the OCs that Cambell has introduced have been gender-nonconforming characters, with many being women despite in no way looking like women, and serving to little more than check off a box.
Besides this, there are also the clear biases present; the "important" plot actions being carried out predominately by Jennika or one of Cambell's OCs, the sidelining of the actual main characters of the book, and the clear and present pandering, as well as the heavy-handed political messages, such as the aforementioned "Not quite MAGA" hats.
Besides all of the this, the comic in general is poorly written. The comic was a slow burn before, but these days NOTHING related to the ongoing plot even develops on the side. We had 25 straight issues of Mutant Town nonsense, developing no significant plot arcs, and focusing on Cambell OCs who didn't have enough character to carry any amount of narrative, as well as inconsistent and at times just plain awful writing, like the aforementioned Bebop and Rockstead example, or the stupid "Venus abducting herself" thing. This comic is overall a shell of it's former self, with woke elements being a clear overarching prescence at the expense of the actual things the majority of readers care about, and in general is badly put together.
The previous comics were not woke for a few simple reasons. Essentially, older comics used politics in general less, presented them in a more even handed fashion, kept them more limited to broader general issues rather than increadibly specific and devisive issues, and usually didn't tell you what to think, instead presenting an idea and letting you come to your own conclusion. Additionally, characters were not put in because they were gay or black, but because they were good characters. It's one thing to have a gay character; it's antother thing entirely when they constantly remind you of it and it's their most significant trait. Who you're having sex with should not be a person's most significant trait, and whenever it is it's a clear sign of wokeness. Plot and characters should always come before wondering how many different ethnicities or sexualities are in the comic, and this is a problem that is unfortunately not limited to just comics. Anyways, that's pretty much the jist of it, and if I keep going I'd probably just repeat myself or ramble.
And here is someone who did quantify the comics "wokness" and showed you are full of ****: https://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1938207&postcount=92
Off course by saying that the comics wern't "woke" you are explicitly ignoring the Archie comics (https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/ComicBook/TeenageMutantNinjaTurtlesAdventures)
The book had an environmentalist tone, with green aesops galore. It also introduced young readers to political topics such as Apartheid, the Chinese occupation of Tibet, the Gulf War, and even showing the more unpleasant aspects of Christopher Columbus' "discovery" of the Western Hemisphere and the Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. While the quality of the actual stories was variable and debatable, several of the concepts introduced here proved quite popular with fans of the franchise, some of whom continue to hope that elements from the book will be introduced in further incarnations.
So yeah, you are a tourist.
Reasons Mirage wasn't woke:
1. Only 2 main female characters, April and Karai. April was seldom used at times, and Karai was basically a villain who formed a truce and was then pushed to the sidelines. Neither of them took over the book from the core cast.
2. No gay or lesbian characters. Granted it was the 80's and 90's so it wasn't common back then. The word "transgender" did not exist outside The Jerry Springer show.
3. No forced diversity. Only black characters were villains like Skonk, General Blanque was white, most recurring characters were white. There was some Native American pandering but that was mostly from Murphy
4. There was a quota on things. It was a mostly white male-centered series, with only the occasional female or "person of color" introduced and not a single homosexual character as far as the eye could see.
It's why nobody thought of these things back then, because none of this was an issue. TMNT had an almost all white main cast, barely any females of note, and no diversity, and more importantly no gay or lesbian characters. And nobody cared for 25+ years all the way to the end of Volume 4 and Tales V. 2 in 2010.
The main cast were 4 ninja turtles. Calling them "white males" is condensending. Likewise wasn't April biracial as per one of the creators? You are right nobody cared about wokness before tourists like you acted like it never existed in your faulty memories.
Andrew NDB
12-21-2024, 12:04 AM
Off course by saying that the comics wern't "woke" you are explicitly ignoring the Archie comics (https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/ComicBook/TeenageMutantNinjaTurtlesAdventures)
Nothing woke Murphy did with the Archies ever came at the cost of story. It was always story and characters FIRST... and then if he can sprinkle in a little bit of "I hate guns!" or "the rainforest is burning 1,000,000 acres everyday!" or "the world will be totally flooded by 1998!" lectures on top, so be it. That's fine. A lot of writers of the era were the same, and none of that was ever bothersome, even in hindsight and it's always surprising to me that people pretend they can't see the difference there now. With a lot of what we've been seeing over the past years is "The Message™" first, and then... hey, if there's time/space, maybe we can sprinkle a little story or character development in there as an afterthought. And I'm not really pointing the finger at IDW... this has been almost all mainstream comics for a while now. And I've talked to writers who went into the industry with wide eyes and ambitions and were basically hamstrung into doing the bidding of activists by the higher-ups.
ToTheNines
12-21-2024, 05:16 AM
I was just watching The Simpsons this week. And it’s crazy how you can watch that and clearly tell that the people behind that show were all liberals, but it’s still great.
I don’t know when it changed, but now when anyone lets their politics bleed in to their art, it’s dog sh*t. I guess that’s because “politics” itself has become so clownish and brain dead. It’s impossible to come off any other way?
neatoman
12-21-2024, 06:20 AM
I was just watching The Simpsons this week. And it’s crazy how you can watch that and clearly tell that the people behind that show were all liberals, but it’s still great.
I don’t know when it changed, but now when anyone lets their politics bleed in to their art, it’s dog sh*t. I guess that’s because “politics” itself has become so clownish and brain dead. It’s impossible to come off any other way?
It's commonly accepted that American Dad became better a couple of seasons in, because the writers were forced to flesh Stan out into a more complete character than the simplistic straw conservative he was initially conceived as. They could obviously only do "The conservative is wrong because he's a conservative" thing for so long before they pretty much covered debunking all the typical political points they wanted to. So the result is that the show leaned more into Stan's stubbornness, insecurities and desire for control, which aren't necessarily expressed in the form of political opinions. The point is that the political satire, which still remained, was longer became the primary focus and the characters were changed to be more easily used for other types of stories.
As for the Simpsons, well... The writers of the early episodes pretty much knew that from the start.
I don’t know when it changed, but now when anyone lets their politics bleed in to their art, it’s dog sh*t.
Hard to disagree with this, although when it's done in extreme and undeniable parody it's pretty hard to not to laugh or enjoy it, be it commentary on the left or the right....
ToTheNines
12-21-2024, 01:16 PM
Hard to disagree with this, although when it's done in extreme and undeniable parody it's pretty hard to not to laugh or enjoy it, be it commentary on the left or the right....
Good point. Trashing the other side can be pretty funny sometimes. But earnestly trying to get some big point across is almost always cringe.
Slightly off topic, but whatever: obviously SNL style “Orange Man bad” is played out and not funny. But I always crack up when Shane Gillis makes fun of him. Love this sketch:
aTGDlljjgEc
neatoman
12-21-2024, 02:17 PM
If you want an absurd example from the Simpsons itself:
60Fxz-NL5hA?si=lGJsW2MSOE2McLnL
Cloudrunner
12-23-2024, 02:54 PM
So yeah, you are a tourist.
Is there a reason you resurrected a bunch of 2 year old threads to **** talk people who have either already been banned or just aren't around to pay attention anymore? As well as calling people "tourists" who've clearly been around these forums and made literally hundreds of times more posts than you? What exactly are you trying to prove?
Andrew NDB
12-23-2024, 03:40 PM
Is there a reason you resurrected a bunch of 2 year old threads to **** talk people who have either already been banned or just aren't around to pay attention anymore?
What is it the leftists always say? Ah yes: "Why doesn't it bother you so much??"
Cloudrunner
12-23-2024, 08:31 PM
What is it the leftists always say? Ah yes: "Why doesn't it bother you so much??"
I am 100% certain that the person I was asking the question of is a leftist.
TheLabRat
01-02-2025, 09:41 AM
"Humans are bad" and "Mutants vs Humans" in IDW TMNT is kinda cliche and stupid. Perhaps some animal mutant also hate other species of animals. A rabbit mutant may take this opportunity to slaughter some stray animals, such as cats and dogs.
Andrew NDB
01-02-2025, 10:48 AM
It was a mostly white male-centered series
It was a mostly green male-centered series.
Coola Yagami
01-02-2025, 11:03 AM
It was a mostly green male-centered series.
Exactly. It's like the forget that the turtles aren't even human. They might be humanoid, but they're turtles. Animals aren't 'white' or any other race.
Andrew NDB
01-02-2025, 11:39 AM
It's like the lefties who were upset about there not being enough black or Asian people on various Star Trek shows. What about the ACTUAL ALIENS on the show? Isn't that about as diverse as it can get? How in the world does that not count?
But then it's, "But they're not ACTUALLY aliens!" and that's really missing the point, I think.
CyberCubed
01-02-2025, 03:47 PM
In Star Trek you can legitimately say there was a lack of Indian/hindu characters since there weren't many indian actors at the time. There's also a weird lack of hispanic characters in Star Trek, unless you count B'Elanna Torres and some one-off characters. Even then some actors who are hispanic in real life have their races changed like Chakotay.
Zog The Magnificent
01-03-2025, 10:51 PM
Honestly, when it comes to all that, the question I always come away with is "Who the hell cares?"
Because honestly, it doesn't matter a lick how many of whichever kind of person is in a story. It shouldn't, at least, but it's made to matter. Just write a good story. Put in whoever needs to be in it. If they happen to be more diverse, great. If they happen to all be the same, great. Just use what you need for the story. It really shouldn't matter beyond that.
Coola Yagami
01-04-2025, 02:07 AM
Honestly, when it comes to all that, the question I always come away with is "Who the hell cares?"
Because honestly, it doesn't matter a lick how many of whichever kind of person is in a story. It shouldn't, at least, but it's made to matter. Just write a good story. Put in whoever needs to be in it. If they happen to be more diverse, great. If they happen to all be the same, great. Just use what you need for the story. It really shouldn't matter beyond that.
But but but too many honkeys??
Zog The Magnificent
01-04-2025, 02:26 AM
But but but too many honkeys??
I yearn for the day when saying something has too many white people in it is just as douchy as saying it has too many black people or too many jews or too many women or what have you. Because really, those should all be equally douchy statements.
Coola Yagami
01-04-2025, 10:35 AM
I yearn for the day when saying something has too many white people in it is just as douchy as saying it has too many black people or too many jews or too many women or what have you. Because really, those should all be equally douchy statements.
People are so uppity about racism these days, they forget that 'white' is also a race. Including white people themselves.
Cloudrunner
01-07-2025, 01:54 PM
People are so uppity about racism these days, they forget that 'white' is also a race. Including white people themselves.
They didn't "forget", they carefully crafted a system of language and narrative that allows them to be racist against white people without repercussion. They've built upon this for years, through education, entertainment, and government institutions. Where hating white people is okay because they're the oppressors. Because of "systemic racism". Because they've got their own definition of racism that is designed very specifically against white people.
The type of people you're describing ARE racists. They are some of the most hateful people in modern day. Equivalent or worse to the KKK. And they've spent many years manipulating western society to dehumanize white people.
Coola Yagami
01-07-2025, 10:07 PM
They didn't "forget", they carefully crafted a system of language and narrative that allows them to be racist against white people without repercussion. They've built upon this for years, through education, entertainment, and government institutions. Where hating white people is okay because they're the oppressors. Because of "systemic racism". Because they've got their own definition of racism that is designed very specifically against white people.
The type of people you're describing ARE racists. They are some of the most hateful people in modern day. Equivalent or worse to the KKK. And they've spent many years manipulating western society to dehumanize white people.
Pretty much why Gina Carano was fired, for pointing this out. The fact that first certain groups of people are dehumanized... then everyone is ok when they are treated badly.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.