PDA

View Full Version : So the last 30+ issues introduced 3 female Turtles


CyberCubed
07-29-2022, 07:43 PM
Jennika as a Turtle debuted in issue 97 (so right before Tom left):

https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51lQVmbAajL.jpg

Lita an albino Turtle girl also has her future self come back in time as a full fledged ninja turtle:

https://64.media.tumblr.com/33034b5c8d04a86517f8c22213a95180/41e512cbd7b8e6c1-4f/s540x810/fcc96e8c0144d90063738bd3b4766007e631e9fc.png

And we have the return of Venus, who in this version was a female Punk Frog named Bonnie before she got "transitioned" into a Turtle...for some reason:

https://www.freecomicbookday.com/news_images/257614_1500722_1.jpg

So we got 3 female Turtles added to the series within the last 30ish issues.

Is this enough "girl power" for you yet?

neatoman
07-29-2022, 08:01 PM
Well, adding more Mutant Ninja Turtles disrupts the the character dynamic and fails to grasp the point of the characters, this would be true regardless of the gender of these additional turtles. There are some understandable tolerances for Slash, Tokka or the clones from Fastforward given that they deviate a lot from the core turtles and are more like monsters that exist outside of their group rather than an attempt to add to the main characters.

Secondly, trying to add female turtles to give some "girl power" element to the series is a bit bizarre and misguided. More importantly, it ignores that female characters who could fill that role did in fact already exist, they just weren't mutant turtles. So what justifies this is... The previously mentioned disruption of character dynamic being employed deliberately... Which is dumb...

I know I've said this before but the subject keeps coming up.

TigerClaw
07-29-2022, 08:13 PM
Well, adding more Mutant Ninja Turtles disrupts the the character dynamic and fails to grasp the point of the characters, this would be true regardless of the gender of these additional turtles. There are some understandable tolerances for Slash, Tokka or the clones from Fastforward given that they deviate a lot from the core turtles and are more like monsters that exist outside of their group rather than an attempt to add to the main characters.

Secondly, trying to add female turtles to give some "girl power" element to the series is a bit bizarre and misguided. More importantly, it ignores that female characters who could fill that role did in fact already exist, they just weren't mutant turtles. So what justifies this is... The previously mentioned disruption of character dynamic being employed deliberately... Which is dumb...

I know I've said this before but the subject keeps coming up.
We have more female mutants when you include Sally Pride, Mona Lisa, Sheena, Mushroom, Zanna, and Zink the 3 weasels.

neatoman
07-29-2022, 08:17 PM
We have more female mutants when you include Sally Pride, Mona Lisa, Sheena, Mushroom, Zanna, and Zink the 3 weasels.

Yeah, which puts the purpose of Jennika, Lita and Venus even more in question than before.

Cowabung-Gal
07-29-2022, 09:53 PM
No. It will never be enough. We want MOAR.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vANzdwsIrg

Sumac
07-30-2022, 12:33 AM
Only one I can tolerate is the Venus, since she a legacy character of sorts and I believe can use some sort of redemption from her Scrappy. Obviously not at the expense of the classic TMNT group dynamic.

Cloudrunner
07-30-2022, 09:19 PM
I'll never forgive them for Jennika since she stole all the plot points from an actually good new character (Alopex) and relegated her to a useless girlfriend character while Jennika carried on to being a part of the group proper.

member_removed
07-31-2022, 01:09 AM
Only one I can tolerate is the Venus, since she a legacy character of sorts and I believe can use some sort of redemption from her Scrappy. Obviously not at the expense of the classic TMNT group dynamic.

People were pissed 25 years ago about Venus, Jenny may well become a Legacy character in the next 25 years.

Perhaps the powers that be at IDW have plans to introduce a 4th female turtle and spin the gals off in their own ongoing or minis. Honestly I can't imagine a target audience or demand for such a book.

Sumac
07-31-2022, 02:52 AM
People were pissed 25 years ago about Venus, Jenny may well become a Legacy character in the next 25 years.
Sure, but so far she is not yet that.

TigerClaw
07-31-2022, 09:31 AM
Sure, but so far she is not yet that.
I would love to see Jennika or any of the mutants appear in other medium besides the comics, So far we got a lot of characters that are only existing in the IDW comics that have yet to appear in any movies, TV shows, Or toys.

MikeandRaph87
07-31-2022, 09:47 AM
I would love to see Jennika or any of the mutants appear in other medium besides the comics, So far we got a lot of characters that are only existing in the IDW comics that have yet to appear in any movies, TV shows, Or toys.

It's best it stays that way. We have too many one dimensional characters. Instead of adding in characters that have yet to appear have an outlined purpose for them. Any new characters need to not just be background characters filling up page space to add to the quarantined zones population. All of this comes down to the writer stepping away for other projects and duties and given to someone who is spinning wheels, who should have stuck to art. Hey even Neal Adams can't write a solid story so its okay. Most writers need to stick with their field and artists the same. We desperately need a new writer after The Armageddon Game no matter what lies beyond the storyarc wrapping up.

CyberCubed
07-31-2022, 11:12 AM
Jennika won't become mainstream because comics are more obscure than TV shows.

Look at Next Mutation. It only lasted 1 season, and only aired from 1997-1998. You'd think Venus would be completely forgotten about. Instead she was constantly discussed even in the early 2000's and now here she is revived. A character who only appeared in a failed TV series that aired in the late 90's after Turtlemania was dead and buried.

Jennika has actually been around for 3 years now as a Turtle and she doesn't feel mainstream. Look at how much a TV show can promote a character compared to a comic.

Sumac
07-31-2022, 01:00 PM
Another good example is Karai - she existed since 1992, appeared in fighting games, but most people didn't really cared about her until she was reintroduced in the 2k3 series and 2k7 movie.

mrmaczaps
07-31-2022, 02:39 PM
Jennika as a Turtle debuted in issue 97 (so right before Tom left):

https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51lQVmbAajL.jpg

Lita an albino Turtle girl also has her future self come back in time as a full fledged ninja turtle:

https://64.media.tumblr.com/33034b5c8d04a86517f8c22213a95180/41e512cbd7b8e6c1-4f/s540x810/fcc96e8c0144d90063738bd3b4766007e631e9fc.png

And we have the return of Venus, who in this version was a female Punk Frog named Bonnie before she got "transitioned" into a Turtle...for some reason:

https://www.freecomicbookday.com/news_images/257614_1500722_1.jpg

So we got 3 female Turtles added to the series within the last 30ish issues.

Is this enough "girl power" for you yet?

Jennika was mutated in issue 95. Not 97. Last page of 95 and then issue 96 she is seen a bit too.

But they all suck. Very 2 dimensional. Lacking substance other than being female & turtle shaped.

Cowabung-Gal
07-31-2022, 03:29 PM
Perhaps the powers that be at IDW have plans to introduce a 4th female turtle and spin the gals off in their own ongoing or minis. Honestly I can't imagine a target audience or demand for such a book.

Somehow I get the feeling that the fourth female turtle will have black and yellow skin and her name will be Laquesha.

mrmaczaps
07-31-2022, 09:22 PM
Jannika isn't bad. She was first introduced as an interesting character and later became a turtle because of the plot. She wasn't just a female turtle. There is a difference.

She became 2 dimensional though. She was a great character & grew and then used as a plot device becoming a turtle via lack of options and then wasn't really used much at all for 5 issues... post 100 hasn't been kind to anyone at all. Downhill kind of fast & I originally liked the idea of her mutation... just **** writing from someone who should have stuck to fan fic and drawing.

CyberCubed
07-31-2022, 10:00 PM
Jenniika wasn't interesting as a human either. I remember people constantly complaining how boring she was from issues 51-95 and how she didn't really do much.

ChosenOne
08-01-2022, 02:46 PM
Jennika would've been more unique and compelling, even as a fully integrated member of Clan Hamato, if she had stayed human.

Bahamut810
08-01-2022, 05:44 PM
I mean...they are ok?

Jennika is an OC insert that has severe hints of Mary Sue. She is ok I guess, but the more she appears the more I roll my eyes.

Lita is...useless? Her biggest plot relevance that I can recall was co-opting Renet's place in the story. You can tell that Sophie wants you to think she is super cool and important, but she is just an adorable replacement for an established character.

Venus was cool. I liked the story around Venus. There was no real reason she had to be a turtle except the call back to the Saban character. I will be cool with her being a long term addition though!

ChosenOne
08-01-2022, 05:52 PM
Sadly, Campbell's technique for making us think a character is super cool and important is telling us so, instead of actually showing us why that's the case.

Zog The Magnificent
08-01-2022, 07:19 PM
Jennika was never an intersting character. She was a flat, uninteresting two-dimensional cardboard cutout of a character who hung around with Splinter and added no real value to the dynamic or the story, who was then turned into a turtle to artificially inflate her importance without actually doing the work to truly develop her. She was boring before, and she's still boring now, only now she takes up an important slot in the plot despite in no way earning it. Being turned into a turtle was itself the most interesting thing that ever happened to her, and even then, something happened to her. She still didn't do anything worthwhile.

CyberCubed
08-01-2022, 07:36 PM
jennika was never that interesting as a human, in a lot of issues I remember she only appeared for like 1 page with the same stoic expression and nothing more.

I mean a lot of the third-tier IDW characters are pretty dull or irrelevant after awhile, the problem is they keep appearing.

Cloudrunner
08-02-2022, 07:45 AM
I genuinely was not expecting Jennika to be part of the main cast while she was still human. She was just that... flat of a character. The more time went on the more obvious they were trying to force her into the plot but I genuinely didn't expect her to be turned into a turtle.

But that's not like the "Oh wow, what a twist I can't believe they did that!" exciting subversion of expectations. It was more like "Really? THAT character? That dull ass nothing of a character is the one you're trying to push for Summerslam? Okay..."

Honestly... if they had moved Venus' story to the forefront of the Mutant Town arc, like as one of the first things that happened (after the gang got back together, of course), I think she would have made a FAR more interesting female turtle addition. They could have had the same pandering publicity that they did with Jennika, just with a more interesting character. And it would have been positioned at a better time in the comic's release schedule to give a surge of interest in the series post #100. And before you say "But Jennika is a brand NEW turtle to the IP! That's why she got so much publicity!", my response to that would be "Well, then call the mutant half-turtle/half-frog (currently named Venus) Jennika instead." The names are basically interchangeable, and it's not like IDW Venus has any relation to previous iterations. So just say that the half-breed mutant is Jennika, the ALL NEW FEMALE TURTLE to the IP! Woooo, exciting! Problem solved.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
08-03-2022, 06:22 AM
Somehow I get the feeling that the fourth female turtle will have black and yellow skin and her name will be Laquesha.

Once we get four femle Ninja Turtles, the TMNT franchise will probably end up cancelled for a while, and then re-booted with an all-female main cast.

Cowabung-Gal
08-03-2022, 10:04 PM
Once we get four femle Ninja Turtles, the TMNT franchise will probably end up cancelled for a while, and then re-booted with an all-female main cast.

*gulp*

Sorry, threw up a little in my mouth just now

ChosenOne
08-04-2022, 10:33 AM
*gulp*

Sorry, threw up a little in my mouth just now

Please don't, that's how we get female Turtles.