PDA

View Full Version : idw dead comic walking..


Vegita-San
09-09-2022, 03:29 AM
Get woke...well...you know the rest of it

0ZpEwL4KRa8

hypered1
09-09-2022, 05:01 AM
Clownfish is a hate-bait, troll channel - nothing in that video will be even remotely factual.

Vegita-San
09-09-2022, 07:44 AM
hey andrew, time for the plant meme :).

And no, clownfish isn't right wing either. try another one.

TigerClaw
09-09-2022, 08:37 AM
Where are they getting this news from? Because I didn't find anything about some of these comics leaving IDW, The only news I found was Stan Sakai going back to Dark Horse, And that's it.

There news sources tend to be very questionable.

hypered1
09-09-2022, 08:53 AM
hey andrew, time for the plant meme :).

And no, clownfish isn't right wing either. try another one.

I never said anything about their political leanings, I was pointing out that they're professional bulls***ters.

ChosenOne
09-09-2022, 10:09 AM
Imagine if they had brought up sales numbers.

hypered1
09-09-2022, 10:31 AM
Imagine if they had brought up sales numbers.

The latest available sales number are for April where Last Ronin #5 took top spot with 100K sales: https://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2022/2022-04.html

AquaParade
09-09-2022, 11:09 AM
Clownfish is a hate-bait, troll channel - nothing in that video will be even remotely factual.

Agreed. Even when they have a good point, they take it too far. A lot of their predictions have blown up in their face.

Plus, at the end of the day, the woman on that channel just has a super grating and abrasive way of speaking. She is someone who yells at their audience, to express their anger at whoever their video is about, and it's just hard to listen to.

Besides, last time we had this discussion, it ended with Tom Waltz coming and setting everyone straight on the sales. I know there was some pushback on that, but the latest hardcover collection of Sophie Campbell's TMNT has been on the Top Seller list of online graphic novel stores for like a month. So, at the least, lets leave the TMNT line out of it this time - it's successful.

And to be clear, I haven't even been a fan of it for like 5 years, so.

IMJ
09-09-2022, 11:42 AM
Even when they have a good point, they take it too far.

This. And they frequently make very good points, but then it gets lost in excess and those rants.

CyberCubed
09-09-2022, 04:11 PM
Honestly this is all nonsense, even if IDW sales may be down.

I've been seeing people say "IDW is dying" for like the last 5-6 years now and nothing has changed. In fact I'm pretty sure it was the same exact guy on youtube that made this video years ago.

Bahamut810
09-09-2022, 05:04 PM
Where are they getting this news from? Because I didn't find anything about some of these comics leaving IDW, The only news I found was Stan Sakai going back to Dark Horse, And that's it.

There news sources tend to be very questionable.

Which part? Losing GI Joe and Transformers? That came out at the end of last year I think. Here (https://www.comicsbeat.com/idw-loses-transformers-and-gi-joe-licenses-announces-2021-results/#:~:text=A%20busy%20news%20day%20for,and%20Dungeon s%20%26%20Dragons%2C%20however.) is a link to a source talking about them losing the licenses and some of their financial info.

This. And they frequently make very good points, but then it gets lost in excess and those rants.

Meh? I don't listen to them to terribly often, but when I have in the past year every time they make an educated guess they make sure to make a big deal that its an educated guess.

Coola Yagami
09-09-2022, 05:46 PM
Don't they usually post links and screencaps of sources for their news. They just don't say thing to say things, and they predicted everything about Kevin Smith's He-Man despite his constant denials.

They make good points often and Sparklez is usually good at reminding people #notallwomen. She hates all the woke feminist crap too.

Leo656
09-09-2022, 06:22 PM
Don't they usually post links and screencaps of sources for their news. They just don't say thing to say things, and they predicted everything about Kevin Smith's He-Man despite his constant denials.


Actually, provably false.

They're a Manufactured Outrage Channel. Nothing to see here.

Vegita-San
09-10-2022, 03:25 PM
Pretty much everyone agrees they where spot on with he-man, and kevin smith still owes them an apology. guess all that whoring didn't do him good on clerks 3 reviews.

Vegita-San
09-10-2022, 03:27 PM
This. And they frequently make very good points, but then it gets lost in excess and those rants.

the rants are part of the fun and passion. I especially hope for one of the rare 'fire rants'. if you watch often enough, you know what that is.

IMJ
09-10-2022, 06:55 PM
hope for one of the rare 'fire rants'.

Yeah I've got to say that embracing her instability as part of their show was brilliant....

Leo656
09-10-2022, 07:26 PM
Pretty much everyone who didn't watch the show but got their "opinions" from YouTube as Standard Operating Procedure agrees they where spot on with he-man, and kevin smith still owes them an apology.

Fixed for accuracy.

neatoman
09-10-2022, 07:36 PM
Phft...

Ok... So basically, IDW appears to be losing several licenses and some creator owned stuff is jumping ship as well. And there does seem to be a downward trend of IDW's sales as well, not to mention attempts to find someone willing buy out the company.

I don't really think any of those things are in dispute.

However, we do know that Last Ronin sold really well and that IDW are making a prequel to it, along with Armageddon Game, it's tie-ins and a Fred Wolf mini. Even if the main is selling poorly which... Well let's talk about that further down... It still seems like IDW is fairly confident in the TMNT brand in general, so I don't think there is much reason to worry about IDW's hold on the TMNT license specifically. At least not for the foreseeable future.

If we do entertain the idea that IDW might lose the license soon, I'm not worried given that I am confident that Armageddon Game will likely wrap any of the plotlines anyone actually cared about and I don't think that many people really care to read more about Mutant Town and whatever other meaningless pseudo-plots can take place in that setting. If IDW were to keep the license but simply reboot the title with a fresh new continuity after Armageddon Game, I'd be cool with that, not because I think Mutant Town did irreparable damage the possibility of making more decent stories in that continuity but because Armageddon Game could potentially be a decent ending. If they were to lose the license, it would pretty much mean a reboot anyway which I'm obviously fine with.

As for the sales data... It states that in March 2022, TMNT main series, Spawn, Saga, Little Monsters, Something Is Killing the Children and Scorched all sold better than Spider-Man, Punisher, X-Men, Venom, Hulk, Thor, Ghost Rider, Star Wars and Avengers... I'm sorry but I don't believe that to be accurate, it seems like a giant fluke. The fact that the numbers for April looks more typical just makes me wonder what's going on.

Warboss74
09-10-2022, 09:05 PM
Comichron just reports the Diamond numbers. Marvel moved their main distribution to Penguin Random House in October 2021. To get the accurate rankings for the Marvel books, you need to look at their projected sales. Comichron assumes the wholesale sales from Diamond account for 36% of their sales based on previous reporting from Marvel and PRH. IDW just switched to the same model this month, so we'll have to keep that in mind when discussing the sales going forward.

Bahamut810
09-10-2022, 10:34 PM
Fixed for accuracy.

I watched the show, and they were spot on.

They said that it seemed like it was going to be the Teela show and that He-man was going to step aside. Kevin Smith tried to say that was not the case. Some quotes if I remember right "He-man will not step aside." and "This show is about He-man". All the commercials had He-man front and center. All the advertisement had He-Man front and center. All of the Merch had He-man front and center. All of it.

The show was not about He-Man, it was about Teela and how He-man was abusive to the POWERFUL WOMAN who don't need no He-man. He was then stepped aside and it was about how AMAZING Teela was (they made sure to tell you in the first minutes of the show) to remind you how she didn't need no He-Man. The very end was Teela *allowing* He-man to remain He-man at her behest because she realized how AMAZING and AWESOME she was and changed the rules so she was the most powerful forever.

AquaParade
09-11-2022, 07:36 AM
Who cares about He-Man though. Only weirdos like He-Man.

Coola Yagami
09-11-2022, 10:47 AM
Who cares about He-Man though. Only weirdos like He-Man.

Let's not go too far there. He-Man and the crew are awesome.

oldmanwinters
09-11-2022, 07:29 PM
Even CBR published an article saying the book is past its prime:
https://www.cbr.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-ruined-mutant-town-idw/

Coola Yagami
09-11-2022, 07:54 PM
Even CBR published an article saying the book is past its prime:
https://www.cbr.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-ruined-mutant-town-idw/

Yeah but CBR is CBR. Screw those guys.

Though I'm surprised they actually spoke ill of mutant town and didn't act like it's the best story ever thanks to Sophie and all the representation. Surprised the writer of this article wasn't fired or some nonsense. I guess TMNT is so forgotten it's not even on the Twitter outrage radar anymore.

Stu_Padasso
09-11-2022, 11:44 PM
I have to agree with the author that they should have kept most of the Mutant Town arc in the Jennika series or another spin-off.

But as Coola said, It’s CBR. They have a reputation for being shill access media that doesn’t call out the BS a lot of the publishers are doing. It makes me wonder why they would do it now.

Andrew NDB
09-12-2022, 12:03 AM
Who cares about He-Man though. Only weirdos like He-Man.

Well... there's a part of me that agrees with you, but ionno. I might feel differently if I'd have watched He-Man at exactly the "right" time. Though some pretty OK people like some pretty weird sh**.

Coola Yagami
09-12-2022, 12:08 AM
I have to agree with the author that they should have kept most of the Mutant Town arc in the Jennika series or another spin-off.

But as Coola said, It’s CBR. They have a reputation for being shill access media that doesn’t call out the BS a lot of the publishers are doing. It makes me wonder why they would do it now.

ehh probably cause

1- slow news day

and

2- it's been long enough now that it's 'safe' to diss mutant town and not enough people on Twitter care about it enough to come at him. This dude would have not have dared touch it a year ago, especially since Sophie was writing it. Definitely not around the time where that one issue showed Jennika kissing pork gal.

Leo656
09-12-2022, 03:25 AM
I watched the show, and they were spot on.

They said that it seemed like it was going to be the Teela show and that He-man was going to step aside. Kevin Smith tried to say that was not the case. Some quotes if I remember right "He-man will not step aside." and "This show is about He-man". All the commercials had He-man front and center. All the advertisement had He-Man front and center. All of the Merch had He-man front and center. All of it.

The show was not about He-Man, it was about Teela and how He-man was abusive to the POWERFUL WOMAN who don't need no He-man. He was then stepped aside and it was about how AMAZING Teela was (they made sure to tell you in the first minutes of the show) to remind you how she didn't need no He-Man. The very end was Teela *allowing* He-man to remain He-man at her behest because she realized how AMAZING and AWESOME she was and changed the rules so she was the most powerful forever.

It was actually about how all of Eternia went to sh*t without He-Man around, thus how important he (and the example he set for those around him) actually was in the grand scheme of things, but I guess projection is easy when you go into something already expecting to see certain things.

I'm also confused about where Adam rejecting the eternal reward promised to him in the afterlife so he could come back to life and save the universe was him "stepping aside", but again... I didn't have my opinion on the show pre-written by clickbait websites, so that's a factor.

If nothing else that show was a wonderful Rorschach test of the audience, although what it reveals is nothing good.
----------

Also, I can't help but snicker at how many people on this forum throw shade at He-Man considering that TMNT is by far the stupidest thing to ever become popular. Even just the premise; "Star Wars Meets Lord of the Rings" is an amazing premise. "Mutant Surfer Turtles Who Eat Pizza In A Sewer In-Between Fighting The Worst Rogues' Gallery In Comic Book History" is a terrible premise, and it gets dumber the more it's spoken of out loud.

As for "only weirdos", the MOTU forum is full of six-figure earners like doctors and lawyers. The TMNT fandom is full of autists and people living on public assistance. You guys do NOT want to play the "Let's Compare Lives" game with any other fandom, trust me.

But sure, it's all dumb and "gay" because the main character - a barbarian - dresses like a barbarian. Thus only weirdos and gay people like it. Sure.

The lack of self-awareness from people who like awful things like goddamn Ninja Turtles turning around and saying other things are dumb never ceases to amaze me. Your favorite thing is trash, so "glass houses" etc.

AquaParade
09-12-2022, 05:20 AM
I only said that to annoy you because you constantly take pride in bashing TMNT and it’s fans, while taking residence on a TMNT forum - clearly to try and troll people.


That was easy. And fun. I guess I get why you do this, to an extent.

I mean, at least I’m not hanging out on a He-Man forum saying this, which would show a desperation for attention, imo. Other then that, was just giving you a taste of own medicine, tbh.

Anyway, He-Man is fine. I’m too ignorant to actually talk crap on it and Skeletor is a badass.

No hard feelings, but that clearly didn’t sit well with you, so maybe consider that next time you decide to insult the fan base/communities of brands you aren’t passionate about - especially when standing next to all of them.

Anarchistguy
09-12-2022, 09:55 AM
Who cares about He-Man though. Only weirdos like He-Man.

And I suppose the TMNT fan base is comprised of nothing but well-adjusted people?

AquaParade
09-12-2022, 10:22 AM
And I suppose the TMNT fan base is comprised of nothing but well-adjusted people?

See above.

Apologies to all lovers of He-Man. And Leo, I guess.

ChosenOne
09-12-2022, 01:28 PM
And I suppose the TMNT fan base is comprised of nothing but well-adjusted people?

Show me any fan base that is.

clockstomper
09-12-2022, 05:24 PM
It was actually about how all of Eternia went to sh*t without He-Man around, thus how important he (and the example he set for those around him) actually was in the grand scheme of things, but I guess projection is easy when you go into something already expecting to see certain things.

I'm also confused about where Adam rejecting the eternal reward promised to him in the afterlife so he could come back to life and save the universe was him "stepping aside", but again... I didn't have my opinion on the show pre-written by clickbait websites, so that's a factor.

If nothing else that show was a wonderful Rorschach test of the audience, although what it reveals is nothing good.
----------

Also, I can't help but snicker at how many people on this forum throw shade at He-Man considering that TMNT is by far the stupidest thing to ever become popular. Even just the premise; "Star Wars Meets Lord of the Rings" is an amazing premise. "Mutant Surfer Turtles Who Eat Pizza In A Sewer In-Between Fighting The Worst Rogues' Gallery In Comic Book History" is a terrible premise, and it gets dumber the more it's spoken of out loud.

As for "only weirdos", the MOTU forum is full of six-figure earners like doctors and lawyers. The TMNT fandom is full of autists and people living on public assistance. You guys do NOT want to play the "Let's Compare Lives" game with any other fandom, trust me.

But sure, it's all dumb and "gay" because the main character - a barbarian - dresses like a barbarian. Thus only weirdos and gay people like it. Sure.

The lack of self-awareness from people who like awful things like goddamn Ninja Turtles turning around and saying other things are dumb never ceases to amaze me. Your favorite thing is trash, so "glass houses" etc.

I agree with this in terms of not denigrating fandoms, He-Man is still selling **** for a reason.

That said, can't agree about Revelation, it seems to embody the very thing you are correctly calling out: being contemptuous about the franchise itself. That goes around a lot at Netflix, buy popular IP rights, instantly get embarrassed upon viewing the source material, hire outsiders to "fix" it. Even though it has proven success. Resident Evil, Cowboy Bebop etc. Retooled to fit current trends and fix what isn't broken. I guess we were lucky Rise of the TMNT and Cobra Kai got their starts at other networks so they're actually done by people who are deep into the franchise.

If Netflix had gotten their paws on the TMNT rights lock stock and barrel they'd probably recoil in horror at the Fred Wolf series and demand the Turtles be turned human and be played by the cast of Riverdale. I guess you could say we have sort have been there already, Platinum Dunes seemed to have no faith in people liking the Turtles so the 2014 film was made to rest primarily on the name recognition of Megan Fox.

Even if I put the Netflix thing aside, I can't really follow a main character that screams at mourning parents, that's not getting me on their side. Especially if they weren't the type of person that would ever do that in previous iterations. It's a mistake people familiar with the franchise wouldn't make.

Bahamut810
09-12-2022, 06:46 PM
It was actually about how all of Eternia went to sh*t without He-Man around, thus how important he (and the example he set for those around him) actually was in the grand scheme of things, but I guess projection is easy when you go into something already expecting to see certain things.

I'm also confused about where Adam rejecting the eternal reward promised to him in the afterlife so he could come back to life and save the universe was him "stepping aside", but again... I didn't have my opinion on the show pre-written by clickbait websites, so that's a factor.

If nothing else that show was a wonderful Rorschach test of the audience, although what it reveals is nothing good.

We have had this discussion before and we will probably remain in disagreement, but just because someone agrees with something does not mean they get their opinion "pre-written by clickbait websites".

However, it was about how Eternia went to **** whithout *magic*, and Teela having her hero's journey to bring it back. The show set its own tone when the first 5~10 minutes were nothing but them telling you how AMAZING Teela is.

He was initially stepped aside when he was killed in the first episode and every bit of advertisement and creator dialogue turned out to be a lie. He-man was only there to be the backdrop for how amazing Teela was. The show literally ended by Adam admitting to being completely unnecessary and Teela taking up the mantle of the most powerful being in the universe then allowing him to tag along when she wants to be awesome in the future.

oldmanwinters
04-05-2024, 01:38 PM
Five more notable heads rolled this week at IDW:
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/major-redundancies-hit-idw-publishing-tonight/
The elimination of the HR department will likely make it a much easier process to cut more positions as need arises.

CyberCubed
04-05-2024, 04:16 PM
Funny this is all happening when TMNT comic output at IDW is larger than ever. Like they're going to be releasing like 5-6 different ongoing TMNT comics each month come June/August.

oldmanwinters
04-05-2024, 05:38 PM
Funny this is all happening when TMNT comic output at IDW is larger than ever. Like they're going to be releasing like 5-6 different ongoing TMNT comics each month come June/August.

It truly is a dizzy-ing output for a franchise I always thought was niche for comic book readers/collectors. Now the Turtles crossover with other IPs about as much as Batman did back in the day. Its been a wild decade, for sure!

Andrew NDB
04-05-2024, 05:45 PM
Funny this is all happening when TMNT comic output at IDW is larger than ever. Like they're going to be releasing like 5-6 different ongoing TMNT comics each month come June/August.

https://media.tenor.com/7Y_LQlg5M8oAAAAM/bailing-water.gif

CyberCubed
04-05-2024, 06:05 PM
I mean if IDW wants to go all out, throwing as many darts to the board as possible before they truly can't afford it anymore seems like the thing to do. And I'm sure Jason Aaron's paycheck is not cheap either, he'll probably make 5x times the same money Sophie made on the same monthly comic. Whenever I think of the money aspect, how much it costs to print all these comics, pay the writers and artists, and everything else...I honestly have no idea how a company can afford it.

Vegita-San
04-05-2024, 06:16 PM
think ol' ross is still there ruining the book with mutant town stuff?


IIRC, I thought I read somewhere they where going to reboot it with a new team? checked out at issue 100

CyberCubed
04-05-2024, 06:50 PM
think ol' ross is still there ruining the book with mutant town stuff?


IIRC, I thought I read somewhere they where going to reboot it with a new team? checked out at issue 100

I don't know how you don't know this, the series is starting over with a new #1 but keeping the same continuity with Jason Aaron being the new head writer replacing Sophie. This has been known for a few months now.

Tom and Sophie will still be writing some of the mini-series.

neatoman
04-05-2024, 08:00 PM
Uh, yeah. Mutant Town itself will probably stick around in some capacity but the run finally ending. Though considering what an embarrassment it represents, I wouldn't be surprised if that whole aspect is toned down and (somehow) written out quietly.

Andrew NDB
04-05-2024, 10:21 PM
The smartest move would have been just, "a year has passed, maybe Mutant Town and all of those extra side characters are still out there but we're not going to feature them or talk about them for the foreseeable future."

Bahamut810
04-05-2024, 10:43 PM
Funny this is all happening when TMNT comic output at IDW is larger than ever. Like they're going to be releasing like 5-6 different ongoing TMNT comics each month come June/August.

They have to do something to try to keep the company going. TLR proved this was a franchise that could make them the money they need to continue. The last time Tom Waltz was on here he assured us that things were just fine right as IDW was being delisted from the stock market. Last I checked the stock was at a record low (like 40 cents I think?). If this is what is selling then heck yeah they are going to double down on success. All us whales are what's keeping the company afloat.

Stu_Padasso
04-06-2024, 12:21 AM
They have to do something to try to keep the company going. TLR proved this was a franchise that could make them the money they need to continue. The last time Tom Waltz was on here he assured us that things were just fine right as IDW was being delisted from the stock market. Last I checked the stock was at a record low (like 40 cents I think?). If this is what is selling then heck yeah they are going to double down on success. All us whales are what's keeping the company afloat.

Fourty Cents?! Boy, I should really check that Powerball ticket I bought a couple days ago.

*evil chuckle*

Hey, Andrew. How does the title of “Editor in Chief” sound to you?

CyberCubed
04-06-2024, 01:36 AM
They have to do something to try to keep the company going. TLR proved this was a franchise that could make them the money they need to continue. The last time Tom Waltz was on here he assured us that things were just fine right as IDW was being delisted from the stock market. Last I checked the stock was at a record low (like 40 cents I think?). If this is what is selling then heck yeah they are going to double down on success. All us whales are what's keeping the company afloat.

Is TMNT the only thing keeping them afloat at this point? They still have the Sonic license I believe. They also make Star Trek comics that literally nobody reads.

Andrew NDB
04-06-2024, 01:39 AM
They also make Star Trek comics that literally nobody reads.

They make Star Trek comics that are loathsome. Though to be fair, nobody has really been able to get successful Star Trek comics going for very long since the 90s. It's just a hell of a thing for them to try and makes ones now based on stuff like Discovery, when even 20, 30 years ago nobody could even make them work when they were based on actually quality Star Trek series.

Hey, Andrew. How does the title of “Editor in Chief” sound to you?

It sounds like not a lot of job security, at the current trajectory. Though "showrunning" Star Trek and TMNT comics? Oh, that would be amazing. For as long as that could possibly last.

TheLabRat
04-06-2024, 04:54 AM
The whole Mutant Town thing has the potential to do better and explore. But they wasted so much time writing Netflix teenage slice-of-life drama. The Turtles no longer look like ninjas. They don't seem to worry about their ninja identities being revealed to the public.

GameCobra
04-06-2024, 08:35 AM
The Sonic series I'm hearing is doing ok.

As for Mutant Town: When it was first introduced back in issue 101, I thought it was amazing when it first came out. Moving the turtles to a slice of life after everything that happened in issue 100 felt liike an amazing change for awhile.

The honestly problem with it is that it focused on it for too long. As soon as Alopex got her green bandana, that was the moment the comic should've jumped right back into the action. I loved when they were defending the dojo from hob's goons at the time and hoped for more action like that, but it got too laid back after that.

MikeandRaph87
04-06-2024, 09:39 AM
The Sonic series I'm hearing is doing ok.

As for Mutant Town: When it was first introduced back in issue 101, I thought it was amazing when it first came out. Moving the turtles to a slice of life after everything that happened in issue 100 felt liike an amazing change for awhile.

The honestly problem with it is that it focused on it for too long. As soon as Alopex got her green bandana, that was the moment the comic should've jumped right back into the action. I loved when they were defending the dojo from hob's goons at the time and hoped for more action like that, but it got too laid back after that.

#101-#105 was a horrible breather arc, but with the Turtles a unit once more they should have focused on finding a cure for the innocent humans who were victims of Hob's mutagen bomb. In other iterations Donatello toiled night and day until he came up with a retro-mutagen. Then #106 it's back to action and build towards Armaggon Game, ease off some of the dangling plotlines that Tom did not rush to a close in City at War. However, it went on and on. What we got from #149's reaction to Lita being cured shows that they had no intention on finding a cure which completely out of character and makes no sense plot-wise either.

TheLabRat
04-06-2024, 10:36 AM
Some villains like Stockman and Null should doing something important in Mutant Town arc. At least they should kill some members of Mighty Mutanimals because these two are also enemies of Mighty Mutanimals. But no, and even in AG, they're mostly just sit, watch and do nothing.

Coola Yagami
04-06-2024, 11:59 AM
Mutant Town should have been the backdrop, not the main focus. Get back to the action, maybe injure one of the Turtles, and while they heal up you can see all the Mutant Town characters.

Another idea I had was make the next big bad blow up Mutant Town. Not only would it get rid of it, it would also be a big build up and great way to introduce the next big threat.

CyberCubed
04-06-2024, 05:49 PM
They make Star Trek comics that are loathsome. Though to be fair, nobody has really been able to get successful Star Trek comics going for very long since the 90s. It's just a hell of a thing for them to try and makes ones now based on stuff like Discovery, when even 20, 30 years ago nobody could even make them work when they were based on actually quality Star Trek series.

The weirdest thing about the Star Trek comics is they just exist and are not acknowledged officially or anything. Like there's a whole storyline where Sisko comes back to Deep Space 9 after being with the prophets and there's a whole sequel series to DS9 taking place after the last season, but of course none of it is really "canon" since the TV shows will never acknowledge it.

There's a whole bunch of comics for Kirk/Spock, for Picard after TNG, but they're not acknowledged at all as if they don't exist. Like the stories are not considered canon or part of the timeline, yet they still keep making them.

I guess the rule of thumb for Star Trek is if it doesn't happen in a TV show or movie, it's not canon. So all those Star Trek novels and comic books since the 90's are like...just there.

oldmanwinters
04-06-2024, 07:50 PM
The weirdest thing about the Star Trek comics is they just exist and are not acknowledged officially or anything. Like there's a whole storyline where Sisko comes back to Deep Space 9 after being with the prophets and there's a whole sequel series to DS9 taking place after the last season, but of course none of it is really "canon" since the TV shows will never acknowledge it.

There's a whole bunch of comics for Kirk/Spock, for Picard after TNG, but they're not acknowledged at all as if they don't exist. Like the stories are not considered canon or part of the timeline, yet they still keep making them.

I guess the rule of thumb for Star Trek is if it doesn't happen in a TV show or movie, it's not canon. So all those Star Trek novels and comic books since the 90's are like...just there.
Pretty much the same for most film franchises, especially Star Wars after the Disney sale. I suppose Indiana Jones at least throws some easter eggs at the games and books and the old TV show.

TheLabRat
04-08-2024, 11:57 AM
Hob could have been a great villain, but apparently Waltz and Campbell totally screwed him over. He hates humans including human mutants, but then he suddenly care about human mutants for no reason. It's not like Hob doesn't have the makings of a villain, like being a child slavery trafficking criminal, it's just that I don't understand why they Insist that Hob is a hero or antihero.

Andrew NDB
04-08-2024, 12:32 PM
The weirdest thing about the Star Trek comics is they just exist and are not acknowledged officially or anything. Like there's a whole storyline where Sisko comes back to Deep Space 9 after being with the prophets and there's a whole sequel series to DS9 taking place after the last season, but of course none of it is really "canon" since the TV shows will never acknowledge it.

There's a whole bunch of comics for Kirk/Spock, for Picard after TNG, but they're not acknowledged at all as if they don't exist. Like the stories are not considered canon or part of the timeline, yet they still keep making them.

I guess the rule of thumb for Star Trek is if it doesn't happen in a TV show or movie, it's not canon. So all those Star Trek novels and comic books since the 90's are like...just there.

Even newer comics post-JJ, where they specifically promised the comics would count like in "Countdown." All of that invalidated by season 1 of "Picard."

BornAgain
04-12-2024, 07:10 AM
Big comic news coming today.

Quite the week for TMNT fans.

Bahamut810
04-12-2024, 10:56 PM
Whats happening now?

BornAgain
04-13-2024, 12:45 AM
Whats happening now?

Sorry, should have clarified it was the 40th anniversary issue. Tbh I was under the impression that Laird and Eastman were doing a short story but it’s just a cover. Still cool though.

Andrew NDB
05-17-2024, 12:06 PM
I'm sure these two will turn things around for IDW.

https://manage.kmail-lists.com/subscriptions/web-view?a=TKBjFa&c=01GAHNFNJXPKTTSYR8NSMKKJ73&k=f24bfb3e24e1124cdd3a9c43c52b10aa&g=WP5kFK&m=01HY3K7E66AJW0HPEDM879ZCNR&r=3hUusrUN