PDA

View Full Version : TMNT: Mutant Mayhem


Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8]

Cowabung-Gal
11-26-2023, 04:40 PM
Does that need to be a shirt? Seth Rogan makes me drink.

I’d buy such a shirt :lol:

LeotheLateBloomer
11-27-2023, 08:15 AM
Well feel free to expand on it. :twink:

Seth Rogen makes me high.

oldmanwinters
12-08-2023, 11:47 AM
Half in the Bag gives about 2.5 minutes to Mutant Mayhem in Part 2 of their 2023 "Catch Up" video:
HZAXlcTjCmI#t=10m48s

Andrew NDB
12-08-2023, 11:58 AM
Half in the Bag gives about 2.5 minutes to Mutant Mayhem in Part 2 of their 2023 "Catch Up" video:
HZAXlcTjCmI#t=10m48s

Well, Jay does. He's the only one who saw it there. He calls it "charming." Meh.

oldmanwinters
12-08-2023, 02:13 PM
Well, Jay does. He's the only one who saw it there. He calls it "charming." Meh.

Considering the state of big studio cinema flicks in 2023, I think TMNTMM probably is in the top half of "it's okay" or "that was fun."

Zulithe
12-08-2023, 07:08 PM
Mike said he'd probably watch it after hearing what Jay thought. I mean considering how they feel about most movies, that's actually high praise.

TheBlueTurtle1
12-09-2023, 03:03 AM
Just watched the movie, I really hated it:(

Jephael
12-11-2023, 10:47 AM
I thought it was great for the pilot of another animated cartoon reboot (which is technically what it is), but it did not have to be a theatrical release. They could've just taken it straight to Paramount+ or Blu-Ray.

ranger_scout
12-11-2023, 08:37 PM
I honestly thought after all of the acclaim it received that it would've been nominated for the Golden Globe Award for Best Animated Film. I can't believe that Wish received a nomination instead.

https://deadline.com/2023/12/golden-globe-nominations-2024-1235660995/

TigerClaw
12-13-2023, 04:28 PM
Mutant Mayhem has been nominated for a Critics Choice Awards for Best Animated Feature.
https://twitter.com/TMNTMovie/status/1735044129598661085

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GBQdcNea4AEliIO?format=jpg&name=medium

Zulithe
12-19-2023, 09:07 PM
EMPIRE: Shredder Will Be ‘100 Times Scarier Than Superfly’ In The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Sequel – Exclusive

https://www.empireonline.com/movies/news/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutant-mayhem-sequel-shredder-100-times-scarier-than-superfly/

Cowabung-Gal
12-19-2023, 09:58 PM
EMPIRE: Shredder Will Be ‘100 Times Scarier Than Superfly’ In The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Sequel – Exclusive

https://www.empireonline.com/movies/news/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutant-mayhem-sequel-shredder-100-times-scarier-than-superfly/

Superfly was scary? :ohwell:

IndigoErth
12-20-2023, 02:32 PM
Easy goal to reach since he wasn't scary.

CyberCubed
12-20-2023, 04:39 PM
They probably mean to kids.

oldmanwinters
12-23-2023, 08:36 AM
EMPIRE: Shredder Will Be ‘100 Times Scarier Than Superfly’ In The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Sequel – Exclusive

https://www.empireonline.com/movies/news/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutant-mayhem-sequel-shredder-100-times-scarier-than-superfly/

Lolz

https://www.instagram.com/p/C1F_dRru2lw/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
https://i.imgur.com/p2qBCiOl.jpg
Not bad, IGN

Cowabung-Gal
12-23-2023, 10:27 AM
Lolz

https://www.instagram.com/p/C1F_dRru2lw/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
https://i.imgur.com/p2qBCiOl.jpg
Not bad, IGN

They should’ve added the one thing that’s scarier than even the Shredder: your mom when she’s mad at you.

IndigoErth
12-23-2023, 12:42 PM
LOL

Angry mom, then misplaced/lost phone, then stolen car.

Zulithe
12-28-2023, 06:26 AM
Deadline has the full official script to the film in their article:

https://deadline.com/2023/12/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutant-mayhem-screenplay-read-script-1235681379/

direct link to pdf (https://deadline.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Mutant-Mayhem-Read-The-Screenplay.pdf)

IndigoErth
12-28-2023, 07:33 AM
"I would say a good chunk of the movie is a lot of improvisation," said Micah Abbey.

Guess with the script and streaming of it both available, someone with enough time to kill could see just how true that statement is. And if any adlibed parts were decent or cringy crap that shouldn't have stayed in...

shihe
12-30-2023, 12:02 PM
For a while, since the movie trailer was revealed, I just felt so disappointed with tmnt as a whole.

Cause I just hated how it looked. The art style. Animation style. Redesigns. Everything.

But... I watched. Didn't love it, didn't hate it. Don't get the buzz around it. But at least I gave it a chance, just so I could move on. I'm not at all invested in this universe whatsoever.

Decided to rewatch every other show until it blows over and we get a new version.

The Inventive Donatello
01-05-2024, 02:34 PM
As a fan from the 80s it was an okay watch. I tend to like most films and be rather forgiving. I watched it at the cinema and it was fun in a forgettable way. I will probably watch it again maybe once every year or two as I do with most Turtles films.

However, the fact that this has been widely praised and the 1990 film is rated 'rotten' on rotten tomatoes seriously suggests to me that there's something wrong with some film critics. I really do not understand why anyone would like this more than the original film. You can call it nostalgia as I am in my forties now, but there are more heartfelt scenes in the first film (Splinter's talk with Raphael, Leo embracing Raph when he comes to in the the farmhouse, the campfire scene). The action is better too (especially the scene where the Foot ambush the guys in April's apartment and in the final fight with Shredder). This film seems sillier and emptier by comparison. Don't get me wrong - I am not saying that the original film (as much as I love it) should be considered a cinematic masterpiece. I do though consider it one of the better comic book films and am surprised that people prefer Mutant Mayhem.

I watch a fair amount of classic and foreign cinema (still plenty gaps there in my viewing), and in those respects my tastes tend to align with much film criticism. However, when it comes to entertainment, I think it is very important to keep an open mind and maintain your own opinions and free thinking, rather than always deferring to so-called 'experts' - Mutant Mayhem vs 1990 is an example of that.

Cowabung-Gal
01-05-2024, 03:02 PM
However, the fact that this has been widely praised and the 1990 film is rated 'rotten' on rotten tomatoes seriously suggests to me that there's something wrong with some film critics.

We’ve been saying that for years now, and Rotten Tomatoes has recently been exposed as a shill site that gives certain movies more praise than they truly deserve if the paycheck is big enough.

Mutant Mayhem, in my humble opinion, is absolute garbage compared to the 1990 classic. For instance, the turtles are nothing but common thieves in Mayhem, whereas in the 1990 film they at least pay for their pizza (but don’t tip the pizza guy if he’s late). Also, Splinter in the 1990 film is a wise and humble ninja master whom the turtles greatly respect while Mayhem Splinter is a bigoted joke of a dad who learned kung fu from movies and calls it ninjutsu and his sons think he’s a joke too.

Andrew NDB
01-05-2024, 03:03 PM
As a fan from the 80s it was an okay watch. I tend to like most films and be rather forgiving. I watched it at the cinema and it was fun in a forgettable way. I will probably watch it again maybe once every year or two as I do with most Turtles films.

However, the fact that this has been widely praised and the 1990 film is rated 'rotten' on rotten tomatoes seriously suggests to me that there's something wrong with some film critics. I really do not understand why anyone would like this more than the original film. You can call it nostalgia as I am in my forties now, but there are more heartfelt scenes in the first film (Splinter's talk with Raphael, Leo embracing Raph when he comes to in the the farmhouse, the campfire scene). The action is better too (especially the scene where the Foot ambush the guys in April's apartment and in the final fight with Shredder). This film seems sillier and emptier by comparison. Don't get me wrong - I am not saying that the original film (as much as I love it) should be considered a cinematic masterpiece. I do though consider it one of the better comic book films and am surprised that people prefer Mutant Mayhem.

I watch a fair amount of classic and foreign cinema (still plenty gaps there in my viewing), and in those respects my tastes tend to align with much film criticism. However, when it comes to entertainment, I think it is very important to keep an open mind and maintain your own opinions and free thinking, rather than always deferring to so-called 'experts' - Mutant Mayhem vs 1990 is an example of that.

Even talking about Mutant Mayhem to that extent or even comparing it to 1990 at all is affording the movie way, way more value than either its worth or how much value anyone that worked on the movie felt toward the TMNT to begin wtih.

We’ve been saying that for years now, and Rotten Tomatoes has recently been exposed as a shill site that gives certain movies more praise than they truly deserve if the paycheck is big enough.

Well, that's not quite right. Rotten Tomatoes can't be a shill site, it literally just tallies up reviewers' review scores to form an average... and you can see all of the specific reviews its pulling from. So there's total transparency. Now, are a lot of reviewers whose reviews are being tallied getting paid or "influenced" by a studio? That's a different conversation, but it has nothing to do with Rotten Tomatoes.

Mutant Mayhem, in my humble opinion, is absolute garbage compared to the 1990 classic.

Its garbage compared to garbage. Its very existence would be offensive if it was even worthy of being taken seriously as a movie, let alone a TMNT movie. But it's not.

The Inventive Donatello
01-05-2024, 03:57 PM
We’ve been saying that for years now, and Rotten Tomatoes has recently been exposed as a shill site that gives certain movies more praise than they truly deserve if the paycheck is big enough.

Mutant Mayhem, in my humble opinion, is absolute garbage compared to the 1990 classic. For instance, the turtles are nothing but common thieves in Mayhem, whereas in the 1990 film they at least pay for their pizza (but don’t tip the pizza guy if he’s late). Also, Splinter in the 1990 film is a wise and humble ninja master whom the turtles greatly respect while Mayhem Splinter is a bigoted joke of a dad who learned kung fu from movies and calls it ninjutsu and his sons think he’s a joke too.

The film's depiction of Splinter is probably its biggest betrayal to the franchise. I am all for trying new things or directions, but they made him into a joke character rather than the wise and sage one he is meant to be.

Even talking about Mutant Mayhem to that extent or even comparing it to 1990 at all is affording the movie way, way more value than either its worth or how much value anyone that worked on the movie felt toward the TMNT to begin wtih.

Yeah I suppose that is true as well. I was just expressing my confusion at how this can be rated as higher quality? It makes zero sense.

For the record, Rotten Tomatoes was just an example because it is an aggregator site, and it is very flawed because a score over 60 per cent (I believe) gets it rated fresh, when 6/10 is merely slightly above average rather than 'good'. I prefer metacritic or even letterboxd but even those are flawed.

But you are right - I shouldn't have mentioned it in the same breath as the original film. It just makes no sense having watched it that it's rated higher. I have also seen better or equal animated movies that have been destroyed so I am thinking someone is paying for reviews. This seems like the type of film that could be seen as mediocre or average, or widely castigated, but instead it's been praised. Some film criticism just seems so random to me.

Jeff
01-05-2024, 04:19 PM
The film's depiction of Splinter is probably its biggest betrayal to the franchise. I am all for trying new things or directions, but they made him into a joke character rather than the wise and sage one he is meant to be.

https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/002/560/313/3f1.png

https://i0.wp.com/www.comicsbeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Rise_splinter.png?w=526&ssl=1

The Inventive Donatello
01-05-2024, 04:22 PM
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/002/560/313/3f1.png

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/b/b0/Master_Splinter_ROTTMNT_Render.png/revision/latest?cb=20191201080919

Elaborate on what you mean.

In Mirage, Splinter prepares the guys for an assassination mission against Shredder. He has a his ruthless side for sure, same as in IDW. However, he's also always been wise and clever and cares deeply about them. He's never been a total muppet and joke character like he is in Mutant Mayhem (see edit for you correcting me there).

Edit: you mean Rise. I have never watched that show. Tried the first episode and didn't like it. I will watch it at some point probably for completion's sake, but it doesn't really appeal. I still enjoy 1987 for nostalgia purposes, 2003 is my favourite and a decent enough adaptation of the comics given the constraints Laird and others were under, and I enjoy the 2012 show too. But Rise isn't my thing.

I also said it was the film's biggest betrayal of the franchise, not that Splinter had never been treated with such disrespect elsewhere.

Is he even worse in Rise? Jesus.

Rise isn't even on my radar really hence me forgetting it.

Autbot_Benz
01-05-2024, 05:38 PM
Elaborate on what you mean.

In Mirage, Splinter prepares the guys for an assassination mission against Shredder. He has a his ruthless side for sure, same as in IDW. However, he's also always been wise and clever and cares deeply about them. He's never been a total muppet and joke character like he is in Mutant Mayhem (see edit for you correcting me there).

Edit: you mean Rise. I have never watched that show. Tried the first episode and didn't like it. I will watch it at some point probably for completion's sake, but it doesn't really appeal. I still enjoy 1987 for nostalgia purposes, 2003 is my favourite and a decent enough adaptation of the comics given the constraints Laird and others were under, and I enjoy the 2012 show too. But Rise isn't my thing.

I also said it was the film's biggest betrayal of the franchise, not that Splinter had never been treated with such disrespect elsewhere.

Is he even worse in Rise? Jesus.

Rise isn't even on my radar really hence me forgetting it.

They made Rise Splinter into this negligent lazy couch potato I never finished Rise (gave up after 5 episodes) but allegedly he got better

The Inventive Donatello
01-05-2024, 05:43 PM
They made Rise Splinter into this negligent lazy couch potato I never finished Rise (gave up after 5 episodes) but allegedly he got better

Fair enough. Thanks for letting me know. I remember seeing him act stupidly in the first episode which was part of what discouraged me from watching further.

Apparently the film is quite good though.

Jeff
01-06-2024, 02:25 PM
Is he even worse in Rise? Jesus.

Rise Splinter is way worse. It's indescribable how something as bad as that was greenlit and made it to the public.

shihe
01-06-2024, 03:32 PM
Rise Splinter does get better.
No, I don't care about rise.
But

SPOILER ALERT

He was basically Bruce Lee, fallen from grace when he got mutated, and ended up taking care of the turtles.
And constantly relieves his glory days watching himself (as a martial artist action movie actor) in his old movies, and just wasting away everyday.

But eventually, he snaps out of it, and goes on missions and everything.

I'd say his story is the highlight of Rise.

But you have to sit through a lot of filler episodes to start getting there. And then you have to sit through more filler, before the show dives back into his backstory again.


tl;dr Rise Splinter was a slow cook. Mayhem Splinter is just irredeemable garbage.

The Inventive Donatello
01-06-2024, 03:49 PM
Rise Splinter is way worse. It's indescribable how something as bad as that was greenlit and made it to the public.

Thanks for letting me know. Maybe one day I will watch it, not sure.

TheLabRat
01-07-2024, 07:56 AM
2012 Splinter is still one of the best incarnation of Splinter. I'm still remember that episode where he flat-out tells Leo "We're ninjas. Screw fighting fair, just win."
UK1yFuUpWIo
https://i.imgur.com/cPfELT4.jpg

LeotheLateBloomer
01-10-2024, 11:10 PM
Sooo... anyone see the rather nasty video of Leo's actor?

Hope Nick/Paramount says something, or does something. Biggs got kicked out for acting up and being trollish over the line, and now this kid doing this garbage? Was already put off on him by his likewise unprofessional trollish behavior around when the film was coming out, but this... WOW.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/17y1xfp/gumball_and_tmnt_actor_nicolas_cantu_verbally/

Nicolas Cantu, you've got some serious growing up to do, fast, before that kind of behavior catches up to you with a very hard lesson. Keep it up and it absolutely will.

Tbh, he's like what 20 now? If they want to be "authentic", they were probably going to recast him anyway lol. Funny how history repeats itself particularly when someone voices Leo.

Hell, if they take years to release the sequel, all of them could get replaced. Though unless Don's VA grows a pair, I'd be fine with him getting axed.

Autbot_Benz
01-11-2024, 05:30 PM
Mutant Mayhem got nominated for 6 Annie Awards

https://i.imgur.com/fKMT9um.png

Cowabung-Gal
01-12-2024, 08:30 PM
Mutant Mayhem got nominated for 6 Annie Awards

https://y.yarn.co/d7ecbe36-b543-4294-b8c8-3565c03f36f2_text.gif

IndigoErth
01-15-2024, 06:32 PM
Wondering if those villain movies Paramount+ had planned are even still happening. Been a couple years since it was mentioned and nothing else said. :tconfuse: (Might be unrelated to this thread since it they might not have been associated with the MM universe... though don't think that was clarified 100% and they packed it so full of villains it might as well be.)

Tbh, he's like what 20 now? If they want to be "authentic", they were probably going to recast him anyway lol. Funny how history repeats itself particularly when someone voices Leo.

Hell, if they take years to release the sequel, all of them could get replaced. Though unless Don's VA grows a pair, I'd be fine with him getting axed.
Poor Leo, he didn't used to have that problem pre-Nick, his VAs were always reliable back then.

Shame it seems like Nick may have completely ignored that incident since they remained silent. I guess it would be too much of a hassle to go recasting this soon. :roll: He better get his ass straightened out though, because that grace period could easily expire.

Side note, was given the talking Leo MM figure for Christmas and I may have to take the batteries out. Not being just some spiteful hater or anything, but the chosen quotes and that kid's voice outside of the film -- where I thought it worked well enough in the context of the big screen, but apparently less-so outside of it -- esp after THAT video recorded incident, are too cringy to bear any time the figure's sound could accidentally get triggered.


Not holding my breath on recasting for the sequel, esp if the Turtles are intended to be older, but assuming the VA kids' voices have likely matured between now and recording for it, even if the Turtles themselves are supposed to be older there is no guarantee that they will even still sound right for each them. But I guess that's what happens when you care more about the age of the actors rather how well they fit the characters. :trolleye:

Cowabung-Gal
01-15-2024, 08:14 PM
So wait, Nicholas Cantu is 20 years old, yet Seth Rogen bragged about how the turtles were all voiced by actual teenagers this time.

What else did you lie to us about, Kevin Smith?

LeotheLateBloomer
01-15-2024, 08:25 PM
Wondering if those villain movies Paramount+ had planned are even still happening. Been a couple years since it was mentioned and nothing else said. :tconfuse: (Might be unrelated to this thread since it they might not have been associated with the MM universe... though don't think that was clarified 100% and they packed it so full of villains it might as well be.)


Poor Leo, he didn't used to have that problem pre-Nick, his VAs were always reliable back then.

Shame it seems like Nick may have completely ignored that incident since they remained silent. I guess it would be too much of a hassle to go recasting this soon. :roll: He better get his ass straightened out though, because that grace period could easily expire.

Side note, was given the talking Leo MM figure for Christmas and I may have to take the batteries out. Not being just some spiteful hater or anything, but the chosen quotes and that kid's voice outside of the film -- where I thought it worked well enough in the context of the big screen, but apparently less-so outside of it -- esp after THAT video recorded incident, are too cringy to bear any time the figure's sound could accidentally get triggered.


Not holding my breath on recasting for the sequel, esp if the Turtles are intended to be older, but assuming the VA kids' voices have likely matured between now and recording for it, even if the Turtles themselves are supposed to be older there is no guarantee that they will even still sound right for each them. But I guess that's what happens when you care more about the age of the actors rather how well they fit the characters. :trolleye:

I checked his Wikipedia page and he's going to be 21 later so if he's kept, then they can't completely use the whole "voiced by real teenagers" thing as a marketing ploy for the sequel. Maybe let him drink a few to help push that hard edge angst.:tlol:

Aging the turtles up would at least give them a bit of a fighting chance against Shredder because as is, these losers will die in 10 seconds. Even this Splinter would get shredded without no connection to Hamato Yoshi.

IndigoErth
01-15-2024, 09:08 PM
Well it will at least be nice not to be bombarded with that "voiced by real teenagers!" BS as a way to try to sell it. lol

Really aught to be voiced by real turtles next time and stop human washing the reptiles, but not going to get much out of them unless things get inappropriate in the recording booth.

So wait, Nicholas Cantu is 20 years old, yet Seth Rogen bragged about how the turtles were all voiced by actual teenagers this time.
To be fair, this movie was announced nearly four years ago so he was still a teen by the time they got to recording.

Hamato_Clan
01-23-2024, 02:06 PM
Well no Oscar nom but that’s not surprising.

Andrew NDB
01-23-2024, 02:25 PM
Well no Oscar nom but that’s not surprising.

This is a real post you're making here?

Roseangelo
01-23-2024, 04:20 PM
This is a real post you're making here?

I think it's worth mentioning, because Nickelodeon has been hyping other nominations the movie has gotten, but it clearly only got those nominations because it is an animated movie that exists. No ability to Oscar hype this.

I'm honestly mad people still think this was a good movie.

Monty Mole
01-23-2024, 04:57 PM
I'm honestly mad people still think this was a good movie.

Probably cus it had no competition when it came out. It was either this, The Meg 2 or Blue Beetle.

Zulithe
01-23-2024, 05:05 PM
Well no Oscar nom but that’s not surprising.
You’re right! Let’s go farther: when you compare MM’s accolades to the 1990s film it’s actually quite embarrassing.

But not embarrassing In the way you probably would like.

How does that truth taste?

Cowabung-Gal
01-23-2024, 05:24 PM
I'm honestly mad people still think this was a good movie.

You’re not alone. It annoys me even more that some of them think it’s better than the 1990 film.

https://media1.tenor.com/m/XBLlEbYQoYsAAAAC/frustrated-stitch.gif

Andrew NDB
01-23-2024, 05:27 PM
I'm honestly mad people still think this was a good movie.

It's more annoying that people treat it as if it's a movie at all, or even held in that regard remotely. Like, the people that made it didn't... but you do? Why? Very stupid.

neatoman
01-23-2024, 05:32 PM
You’re not alone. It annoys me even more that some of them think it’s better than the 1990 film.

https://media1.tenor.com/m/XBLlEbYQoYsAAAAC/frustrated-stitch.gif

… Well, I guess to be fair, treating the turtles as little more than a vehicle to pass off pop culture references as jokes is a problem with both movies.

IndigoErth
01-23-2024, 06:00 PM
A lot of competition, so they'd have surely had to hit it out of the park for that to happen, and not sure they did.

I didn't hate it, it was a fun watch for what it was, esp with a 7-year-old in tow and going in with rather low bar expectations, and the interesting visual style is probably what appealed to me the most about it... but is it a great TMNT film? Meh. Some of those choices and cringy junk are a bit too niche even for a niche thing like TMNT.

If it wasn't in the running with a record amount of competition, many that may have also began during Covid when live action was off the table, maybe it would have had a shot at something, at least for the visual stuff.

Wentos
01-26-2024, 03:46 PM
I think it's a great movie. The art style is beautifully grungy and gross, the music by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross is incredible, and it's often very funny. I love the original Mirage comics and the 1990 movie as much as anyone, but Mutant Mayhem isn't trying to be those. It's taking the material and doing its own thing with it.

By the same token, I don't dislike Rise of the TMNT because it isn't the Mirage comics/1990 movie, I dislike it because the writing doesn't land for me and I don't like the designs of the turtles. I do my best to judge each iteration by its own merit, not by the expectations I project onto it as a TMNT fan.

Cowabung-Gal
01-27-2024, 09:30 PM
The art style is beautifully grungy and gross

Mmmm, no, it’s just gross.

https://media1.tenor.com/m/aQrqTQxEgyUAAAAC/tmnt-mutant-mayhem-april.gif

And the animation style is pretty much the same in ParaNorman so it’s not that unique

https://media1.tenor.com/m/0XVPpNlRPq8AAAAC/laika-paranorman.gif

Cowabung-Gal
01-27-2024, 10:35 PM
I personally love the look of both films but they're not the same.

Well, the human designs in both ParaNorman and Mutant Mayhem are oddly misshapen (for example, one of Norman’s eyes is bigger than the other and his nose is crooked just like April’s) and very ugly. I’d say they’re very similar.

tmntpower1988
01-28-2024, 09:09 AM
So Mutant Mayhem was going to originally be similar to the Christopher Nolan Batman movies:

https://insidethemagic.net/2023/08/tmnt-mutant-mayhem-nearly-ruined-franchise-christopher-nolans-batman-jb1/

I would have been interested to see that tbh

https://screenrant.com/tmnt-mutant-mayhem-shredder-utrom-tcri-twist/

There's a possibility in the sequel that the Shredder might be an alien, I hope they keep him human. That's the one thing that bothered me about the 2003 show was the Shredder being an Utrom even though I still love the show.

RaphaelinSTL
01-28-2024, 11:52 AM
I still had a lot of fun with it, and it's still my fourth favorite TMNT theatrically released film just right after the original '90s live-action trilogy. I just don't think anything will be able to top those for me.

That's the one thing that bothered me about the 2003 show was the Shredder being an Utrom even though I still love the show.

SAME! I'll never forget watching that episode with my late brother and both of us being super disappointed when that reveal happened.

IndigoErth
01-28-2024, 02:31 PM
Alien? He's just the warrior henchman of Cynthia Utrom then, isn't he. Bet the alien part is true, seeing how a human Shredder has no reason to have any beef with the Turtles or Splinter in this one.

tmntpower1988
01-29-2024, 08:28 AM
SAME! I'll never forget watching that episode with my late brother and both of us being super disappointed when that reveal happened.

Sorry to hear about your brother. The Utrom Shredder coming out of the armour for the first time he just didn't seem as threatening. I still do think he's a good villain though, just think it looks better when he's hidden inside the armour :lol: At least there was a real human Oroku Saki in season 5, so at least we know that Oroku Saki isn't some fake identity the Utrom Shredder made up.

shihe
01-29-2024, 03:44 PM
So Mutant Mayhem was going to originally be similar to the Christopher Nolan Batman movies:

https://insidethemagic.net/2023/08/tmnt-mutant-mayhem-nearly-ruined-franchise-christopher-nolans-batman-jb1/

I would have been interested to see that tbh

https://screenrant.com/tmnt-mutant-mayhem-shredder-utrom-tcri-twist/

There's a possibility in the sequel that the Shredder might be an alien, I hope they keep him human. That's the one thing that bothered me about the 2003 show was the Shredder being an Utrom even though I still love the show.


Now I just feel robbed. Even a Christopher Nolan-ESQUE ripoff would've been far better to me than MM, which the more I think about, the more I dislike it.

And yeah at this point, that's Shredder in name only, cause I'm sure he's gonna be Cynthia's lap dog Frankenstein monster.
I honestly don't care if he's an alien, not having any backstory with Splinter automatically makes me NOT care about Shredder whatsoever.

LeotheLateBloomer
01-30-2024, 08:46 AM
I don't know if Inside the Magic is a credible source. Furthermore, aren't the writers for this film known for writing comedy? And with Seth Rogen, I'm not convinced this is true.

tmntpower1988
02-02-2024, 10:03 AM
I don't know if Inside the Magic is a credible source. Furthermore, aren't the writers for this film known for writing comedy? And with Seth Rogen, I'm not convinced this is true.

You're probably right. I wish they'd make another Batman vs Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie I really want to see more of Joker Shredder.

Xav
02-02-2024, 11:34 PM
I don't know if Inside the Magic is a credible source. Furthermore, aren't the writers for this film known for writing comedy? And with Seth Rogen, I'm not convinced this is true.They are quoting an interview the director did for the Hollywood Reporter they aren't just making this up.

LeotheLateBloomer
02-03-2024, 05:36 PM
They are quoting an interview the director did for the Hollywood Reporter they aren't just making this up.

Well I don't follow Inside the Magic that much to know when they post something that's true, so I'll take your word for it. Usually they don't however.

It doesn't matter because the final product is what it is.:ohwell:

Drose18
02-03-2024, 07:35 PM
They are quoting an interview the director did for the Hollywood Reporter they aren't just making this up.

Also the actual quote from the director was more hinting at using Shredder in the sequel movie in a similar way to how The Dark Knight featured the Joker.

FredWolfLeonardo
02-04-2024, 05:58 AM
Just watched this.

Best tmnt movie ever made in my opinion. Superfly was so awesome as a villain and the turtles/Splinter/April were all great too.

LeotheLateBloomer
02-04-2024, 08:26 AM
Just watched this.

Best tmnt movie ever made in my opinion. Superfly was so awesome as a villain and the turtles/Splinter/April were all great too.

More than the 1990 movie, really?

Jeff
02-04-2024, 01:38 PM
I still had a lot of fun with it, and it's still my fourth favorite TMNT theatrically released film just right after the original '90s live-action trilogy. I just don't think anything will be able to top those for me.



SAME! I'll never forget watching that episode with my late brother and both of us being super disappointed when that reveal happened.

I remember loving it when it happened and I still love it. It was definitely a bold choice, but that's part of the reason why I love it. You can only see the same origin over and over again without it becoming dull. IDW pulled this off best, though...super nostalgic but also new and exciting!

FredWolfLeonardo
02-04-2024, 07:19 PM
More than the 1990 movie, really?

It's a personal bias but I do prefer animation to live action, and MM had a tone/story which couldn't really be told through live action like 1990.

When I see a tmnt film, I want to see lots of different monsters and unique visual/stylistic choices. MM delivers strongly on both.

TigerClaw
02-08-2024, 10:20 AM
Teaser for the Tales of the TMNT series based on Mutant Mayhem.

wJmQyv93qPY

neatoman
02-08-2024, 10:24 AM
Teaser for the Tales of the TMNT series based on Mutant Mayhem.

wJmQyv93qPY

Huh, kind of expected the show to just reuse the models and sets from the movie, but now that I think about it I'm pretty sure I heard it was going to be 2D before, so I'm not sure why I expected that. Anyway, maybe time to have a thread about the show?

Wildcat
02-08-2024, 10:48 AM
Ya I thought it was gonna be cgi but this art style still looks good.

IMJ
02-08-2024, 12:36 PM
Rise 2.0
And we are back to this being repurposed from Rise assets, which I remember pointing out, was hotly resisted and then the data came out that is what studios do.

Rise sucked, failed and they rebuilt the assets into this, movie first.

BornAgain
02-08-2024, 04:25 PM
Rise 2.0
And we are back to this being repurposed from Rise assets, which I remember pointing out, was hotly resisted and then the data came out that is what studios do.

Rise sucked, failed and they rebuilt the assets into this, movie first.

This has no connection to “Rise…”.

neatoman
02-08-2024, 06:19 PM
Rise 2.0
And we are back to this being repurposed from Rise assets, which I remember pointing out, was hotly resisted and then the data came out that is what studios do.

Rise sucked, failed and they rebuilt the assets into this, movie first.

This has no connection to “Rise…”.

What assets can a 2D animated show in a different style share? That makes no sense. This obviously replaced it in the sense that it's a new TMNT show but otherwise there's no connection.

Uh, yeah, what Optimus Primer said. What exactly is repurposed from Rise? The character models are clearly different and the backgrounds don't seem recycled either. Maybe they are using the same animation techniques or software to make this, but by that logic The Simpsons movie was "recycled" from the Curious George movie from the year prior.

At most they might be using scripts from Rise that never went into production, but how would you even be able to tell that from this teaser?

Zog The Magnificent
02-08-2024, 06:43 PM
Rise 2.0
And we are back to this being repurposed from Rise assets, which I remember pointing out, was hotly resisted and then the data came out that is what studios do.

Rise sucked, failed and they rebuilt the assets into this, movie first.

This has no connection to “Rise…”.

What assets can a 2D animated show in a different style share? That makes no sense. This obviously replaced it in the sense that it's a new TMNT show but otherwise there's no connection.

Uh, yeah, what Optimus Primer said. What exactly is repurposed from Rise? The character models are clearly different and the backgrounds don't seem recycled either. Maybe they are using the same animation techniques or software to make this, but by that logic The Simpsons movie was "recycled" from the Curious George movie from the year prior.

At most they might be using scripts from Rise that never went into production, but how would you even be able to tell that from this teaser?

Guys, you're all taking language that was clearly poetic way too literally. Obviously a 2D animated show doesn't actually have "assets."

All that was being said was that the basic building blocks that made Rise what it was (in terms of overall identity) have clearly been at the very least a large influence in this new iteration.

Whether or not you agree with that opinion is up to you, but acting as though the argument was that this show was literally made of "Rise Assets" is a misrepresentation of what was actually said at best.

CyberCubed
02-08-2024, 07:00 PM
The entire writing and animation staff on this is likely completely different than anyone who worked on Rise too.

IndigoErth
02-08-2024, 07:18 PM
Poetic, or probably just mistaken.

As far as 2D goes, I suppose decent but discarded ideas could be repurposed, likewise animation styles I guess (which kinda does look a little similar?), but "assets"... no, not like you could between 3D projects.

BornAgain
02-08-2024, 07:31 PM
Guys, you're all taking language that was clearly poetic way too literally. Obviously a 2D animated show doesn't actually have "assets."

All that was being said was that the basic building blocks that made Rise what it was (in terms of overall identity) have clearly been at the very least a large influence in this new iteration.

Whether or not you agree with that opinion is up to you, but acting as though the argument was that this show was literally made of "Rise Assets" is a misrepresentation of what was actually said at best.

Nah, we took it the most logical way imo. The post referenced “rebuilt” and “repurposed” assets. That doesn’t read as figurative and it’s not really clear what it would mean if it wasn’t literal. They “repurposed” the spirit of “Rise..”? I’m not seeing that either.

neatoman
02-08-2024, 07:53 PM
Guys, you're all taking language that was clearly poetic way too literally. Obviously a 2D animated show doesn't actually have "assets."

All that was being said was that the basic building blocks that made Rise what it was (in terms of overall identity) have clearly been at the very least a large influence in this new iteration.

Whether or not you agree with that opinion is up to you, but acting as though the argument was that this show was literally made of "Rise Assets" is a misrepresentation of what was actually said at best.

Then don't use the word "assets" when you mean "inspiration" or "ideas". Doing so implies something was directly reused, it is not a word typically used poetically.

And even if we accept that something about the concept being reused, what is that? Seriously, what is being reused? If I were to describe Rise in terms of what it did differently from what came before, it would be like this:

The main focus is a plotline is about an underground city full monsters.
The Turtles have magic weapons that give them supernatural powers used throughout the series.
There is an emphasis on over the top fight scenes.
Most older characters are disregarded in favor of brand new ones.
There are several notable exaggerations/changes to how the characters typically behave, for example with Splinter being lazy and inattentive.
The character design of the turtles makes them look extremely different from each other and how they traditionally looked.

I could probably go on but the point is that it's possible to describe in clear terms what Rise was like and what the direction of it was. Likewise it should be possible to concretely describe the direction of MM/Tales as well, thus making it possible to compare the two. But saying that MM/Tales is similar to Rise because it took the "assets" from it is hardly enough, you actually have to explain what it is about MM/Tales that is similar to Rise in order to argue for the comparison. If you can't say something like "The way the characters behave is similar of X and Y", then you don't even a bad argument, literally don't have an argument to begin with. And from where I am sitting, much of how I can describe Rise doesn't apply to Mutant Mayhem or (seemingly) Tales at all.

Just to be clear, I'm not trying to defend either MM/Tales or Rise here, or even make excuses. I'm saying you have to at least explain what the supposed similarites are in order to have anything that even resembles a point. Because from where I'm sitting, I really don't notice many similarities beyond what may just be coincidental or natural due to being adaptation of the same comic book series.

If no actual argument is made here, then from my point of view the logic just looks like:

"Rise was bad"
"Mutant Mayhem was bad"
"Rise was the most recent animated iteration before Mutant Mayhem"
"I can see some similarities between the two (which I won't state)"
"Therefore Rise directly inspired Mutant Mayhem"
"That's why they both suck"


Which is just faulty logic. You could do this with just about any two iterations of the franchise. Look, here's me explaining why TNM was bad:

"TMNT III was a bad movie"
"TNM was a bad show"
"TMNT III was the last live-action adaptation before TNM"
"They both had bad puppets, corny jokes and pointless plot turns"
"Therefore TMNT III must have inspired the direction of TNM"
"That's why they both suck"


And here's me explaining why the 2003 show and the first season of the 2012 show were both good:

"TMNT 2003 was a good show"
"TMNT 2012 is a good show so far"
"TMNT 2003 was the last TMNT show before 2012"
"They both ignored the FW show for the most part and had some adaptation of old comic book issues"
"Therefore TMNT 2003 must have inspired TMNT 2012"
"That's why they're both good"


Or how explaining why the last season of TMNT 2012 and Rise were bad?

"TMNT 2012 ended poorly"
"Rise is bad"
"TMNT 2012 was the last show before Rise"
"They both featured tons of human characters turning into mutants and had a plot about Shredder being brought back from the dead"
"Therefore TMNT 2012 must have inspired Rise"
"That's why they both suck"


It's just meaningless to argue like this because the similarities could be completely coincidental, even if they weren't how do you prove that and why are these ideas inherently bad? If you think MM/Tales and Rise both suck and suck for similar reasons, that's fine but you have to explain why they are similar and why these similarites are bad.

neatoman
02-08-2024, 08:42 PM
Like I said, the only reason I can see behind stating something like this is that someone might think both Rise and Mutant Mayhem are bad and just assume there is a connection because Rise ended half a year before Mutant Mayhem came out. Which is, at best, spurious reasoning. If you think there is a connection, at least try to show there is a connection.

Rise and Mutant Mayhem are part of the same franchise, you can find similarities between them and almost any other entry in said franchise, it's meaningless to just say they're similar and not explain why. Even if some of these similarities are unique to these two iterations and/or one directly inspired the other, how do you prove that? How are these unique elements not a natural "next step to take" in relation to any other previous iteration? And even if that is not the case, how is it not possible these similarities still aren't just a coincidence?

CyberCubed
02-08-2024, 09:14 PM
This is a big debate over literally nothing

neatoman
02-08-2024, 09:28 PM
This is a big debate over literally nothing

It's not even a debate, it's just pointing out that it is dumb to assume these two iterations of the franchise have anything to do with each other.

Zog The Magnificent
02-08-2024, 11:05 PM
It's not even a debate, it's just pointing out that it is dumb to assume these two iterations of the franchise have anything to do with each other.

I should clarify that I don't think they *actually* have anything to do with each other in a technical sense. From my view, they both take the same kind of irreverent tone, they both have a black April, they both have a version of Splinter who's kind of a loser, both have all four turtles being nearly the same character rather then being more distint, etc. And it's not even the same way as the '87 show, which despite all its faults had a certain charm to it. Both shows have a lot of core features in common, and both feel like they were made by people who really don't like or understand the franchise. They're different shows, but they're clearly made of the same basic pile of megabloks, instead of the legos the rest of the franchise is constructed of.

Cowabung-Gal
02-12-2024, 02:20 AM
Warning: Language

56PY-ldKhd8

Thank you for pointing this flaw out, Tatoruzu.

shihe
02-20-2024, 01:46 PM
Easy solution would be for them to take food thrown away by restaurants and grocery stores
At least it gives actual Grey morality rather than passing bad actions for good.

neatoman
02-20-2024, 04:41 PM
Easy solution would be for them to take food thrown away by restaurants and grocery stores
At least it gives actual Grey morality rather than passing bad actions for good.

I don't know how it's done in America but here the thrown away food is put into a garbage compactor immediately, it's not exactly possible to retrieve it.

Andrew NDB
02-20-2024, 05:10 PM
I don't know how it's done in America but here the thrown away food is put into a garbage compactor immediately, it's not exactly possible to retrieve it.

I don't think that's a thing here.

IndigoErth
02-20-2024, 08:54 PM
Wish it had come up more, opening the movie with the Turtles as shoplifters... yeah, real good message there, Rogen.

Raph even wasted those loaves of bread. Stabbing your grimy sais through them? That's gonna mold within a couple days in a dank sewer.

Cowabung-Gal
02-22-2024, 02:34 AM
Raph even wasted those loaves of bread. Stabbing your grimy sais through them? That's gonna mold within a couple days in a dank sewer.

You know what their defense will be: “It’s a kids movie about mutant ninja turtles. Who cares about the logic?”

Zulithe
02-22-2024, 03:09 AM
Wish it had come up more, opening the movie with the Turtles as shoplifters... yeah, real good message there, Rogen.
They are scavenging their environment. If they could only procure food by purely legitimate means they would have very limited options. Splinter, an actual former rat, an animal known for its 'thieving' ways in the human world, is their father/master/teacher, so what do you expect? There is also the outsider aspect: they are not a part of the human world, feel like they would never be allowed to either (something that is a journey in this movie, where they eventually are able to join it fully), why wouldn't you steal to get by in that situation? Splinter has reason to fear and hate humans at the start because as a rat he fully knows how much humans hate him. There is also a flashback scene that further establishes how much humans reject them.

Think about many famous stories where this is a theme. How about Oliver Twist. He's the protagonist, but due to his circumstances, he joins a band of thieves because that's what he has to do to survive. That doesn't make him any less of an admirable character, because the audience understands why.

Let's go a little farther. The turtles live in the sewer in just about every iteration of the TMNT. Do you think they are legally allowed to be living there? They are basically squatting on government owned/controlled land and are subject to being totally removed if anyone knew they were down there. I guess April should have turned them in to the city the moment she saw them living down there... after all that's the right thing to do, correct? They are squatting on city property. That's against the law. It's sending a bad message that April just goes along with their lawbreaking ways. They are also stealing electricity, probably water as well.

The turtles are in a very different place by the end of MM. While they are stealing to get by at the start of the movie, you wouldn't imagine them doing the same thing by the time the movie ends. There has been a character arc for their entire family.

The lengths some of you will go to find any problem with this movie so you can find more angles to attack it. It's truly amazing.

IndigoErth
02-22-2024, 09:00 AM
Where have I attacked it? Not all critiques or not being crazy about certain parts doesn't always equal an attack.

Is it what I'm wanting from TMNT right now? No. Were there things they decided to do that I'd have rather thay didn't? (Shoplifting scene, cringy stuff, school, etc.) Yes. Did I at least still find it a fun watch? Also yes. Am I confusing people with no perception of a grey area (not saying you nessessarily)? I dunno, maybe.

Andrew NDB
02-22-2024, 10:46 AM
To weigh in on this again, I don't personally like it because it hasn't really been a thing until now but I'm not too bent out of shape about the Turtles stealing. People expecting the TMNT to be "honorable ninja" are pretty dumb from the start, since "honorable ninja" is an oxymoron.

You know what their defense will be: “It’s a kids movie about mutant ninja turtles. Who cares about the logic?”

Yeah, the usual usage of Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law).

BornAgain
02-22-2024, 11:26 AM
No wonder Nickelodeon doesn’t want to do anything adult with TMNT. Such a weak hang up.

IMJ
02-22-2024, 12:23 PM
Guys, you're all taking language that was clearly poetic way too literally. Obviously a 2D animated show doesn't actually have "assets."

All that was being said was that the basic building blocks that made Rise what it was (in terms of overall identity) have clearly been at the very least a large influence in this new iteration.

Whether or not you agree with that opinion is up to you, but acting as though the argument was that this show was literally made of "Rise Assets" is a misrepresentation of what was actually said at best.

I appreciate this because it is in total alignment with the reality of the conversation, and points out pretty clearly the strange gas lighting that went on in response.

People's inability to discuss things in truth and on their own merits is unbelievable. Like - what world can anyone possibly be residing in, in their own mind, to create conflict over things that clearly never occurred to them or threatens their understanding over how the world works so badly that get tribal over it.
Absolutely ridiculous level of responses above, and I apologize to you for combining your point there with my current vitriol over it, but I'm absolutely disgusted by some of these people at times.

And on point to anyone else - a 2-D show does indeed have "assets" in terms of design and intellectual property, art direction, all of it. Those are all assets. And so if you took the design of Raphael from Rise and adapted the fundamental design for Mayhem, then you did indeed repurpose that asset for the show. The Fred Wolf designs are catalog assets and although not repurposed, those assets were used in "Turtles In Time" cartoon.

I am sorry that this rattles anyone's understanding of the world so badly that the clown army came out to fight against me that strongly over it, but many of the responses to what I was saying are categorically wrong.

IndigoErth
02-22-2024, 12:34 PM
Just one of those points I personally feel is better to stay vague and largely unexplained. Let people have their own theories.

If it's going to be given an explanation...why a kids movie where it's "hey, look how cool and stealthy they're being while they rob some places" and at a time when shoplifting by younger generations is increasing. (Was it to be relatable to a chunk of Gen Z who doesn't think stealing is a problem?) At least have them showing a bit of remorse for having no choice, because they know it's wrong and the MM Turtles WANT to be accepted and heroic. And maybe make it up to those shop owners in the end once they're known to the public.

Andrew NDB
02-22-2024, 01:11 PM
Again, don't care if they steal or not, but you just know TPTB are super proud of this. Like, "We did it! We found a truly original take on the TMNT! Nobody has ever shown how they get their stuff and WE did!" So that piece is annoying. Plus these writers are all big lefties who are counting the days until the socialist utopia. Which is to say, you just know the general idea is "screw those rich shop keepers, their wealth should be redistributed anyway to people like the poor, down-trodden TMNT!" and not just a kind of matter-of-fact "I guess they steal?"

For me, it's a combination of picking up junk people throw away in dumpsters or leave in alleys or ends up floating down the sewer. For food, honestly a mix of bugs and rats and whatever they could find. Until the April and Casey days, of course. No stealing whatsoever required.

LeotheLateBloomer
02-22-2024, 01:18 PM
The lengths some of you will go to find any problem with this movie so you can find more angles to attack it. It's truly amazing.

No offense but the lengths some of you will go to defend nearly everything about this movie is also truly amazing. It's just another person's opinion. You may not agree with it which is totally fine but there's no reason to get excited over a different viewpoint.

For all the problems I have with this movie, stealing supplies is not really a major deal for me. I can see why others take issue with it but to each his own.

Autbot_Benz
02-24-2024, 09:48 PM
Finally watched it tonight. I enjoyed it. Better than Bayturtles/Rise will never top the 1990 movie.

Enjoyed the animation too.

IMJ
02-25-2024, 10:51 AM
I think it's a sign of the mentality when some people here read "repurposed assets" and you join a tribe over it and then go on to use words like "I don't think they stole assets".

OMFG. I can't even begin to unpack the stupidity on display there... I can't....

BornAgain
02-25-2024, 02:42 PM
I guess I can see why the turtles stealing would rub people the wrong way given the context of society today along with the fact that it’s a movie aimed at children, who may not understand the complexity.

I think it’s easy to justify the turtles stealing given their unique situation though. Give them a break on that one - it’s not going to hurt the big chains and they are truly shunned by society.

They could just as easily dumpster dive though I suppose.

Andrew NDB
02-25-2024, 03:18 PM
I guess I can see why the turtles stealing would rub people the wrong way given the context of society today

As opposed to 10 years ago? Or 50?

IndigoErth
02-25-2024, 03:58 PM
along with the fact that it’s a movie aimed at children
The part that bugs me. If it was a film for older audiences that might be different, but kids young enough to still lack the maturity to understand that the good guys looking cool doing it doesn't make it okay... ehhh...



Though even for older audiences... I dunno, I just don't even find it an interesting solution. Also seems kind of out of character for characters in the "hero" genera of media (grey area or no), and I'd still rather there was some sign of being the good guys balanced with still needing to get by in life.

So... maybe don't go rob the grocery store, but rather swipe something from a street food vendor while his back was turned. And leave a few coins that had been picked up off the street, even if a mere fraction of the price, so it's at least a show of effort to do good despite the circumstances.

And seeing how stores also often have open, mildly damaged, or recently 'expired' things they don't even clearance and instead just end up chucking it, fictional easy access to this stuff breaks suspension of disbelief less imo... even if it doesn't make for an exciting scene going all Mission Impossible with shoplifting.

MM Turtles are just gonna go in there during open hours and we don't even see how? Come on. At least hitting a place after closing, when most of the lights are off and being stealthy to avoid camera would at least be more clever. But just rummaging through what people have tossed out sounds like a lot less effort.

Andrew NDB
02-25-2024, 06:23 PM
So... maybe don't go rob the grocery store, but rather swipe something from a street food vendor while his back was turned

That's much worse. Like, have them rob the probably family-based street food vendor who's barely getting by but not the big corporate Safeway or QFC?

IMJ
02-25-2024, 07:39 PM
Nowadays the social-puritans would have a problem with Michaelanglo stiffing the gig-economy worker when he said "never pay for price for late pizza!"

BornAgain
02-26-2024, 01:09 PM
As opposed to 10 years ago? Or 50?

Theft is out of control in places like California due to insane laws being passed, so yeah in a way it seems bit touchier now.

Personally I don’t mind if the TMNT steal but if you’re going to take a property about ninjas and sell it to wee children I guess you’re going to run into conundrums about what you want to glorify and what nuance they will understand.

That’s why they should just give them a little Sesame Street version and cater the brand towards slightly older fans who can handle mature themes.

Did you guys see that TLR was the top selling graphic novel of last year? The success of that book is ridiculous. You won’t convince me that a live-action version wouldn’t have made more money than Mutant Mayhem at the box office. Granted, it would cost more but that’s what audiences want to see from TMNT.

Selling strictly to kids is just another roll of the dice at the Pixar & Dreamworks casino which is why MM barely made money. Apparently TMNT merch sales were through the roof last year but no way that’s chalked up to MM.

IndigoErth
02-26-2024, 03:32 PM
That's much worse. Like, have them rob the probably family-based street food vendor who's barely getting by but not the big corporate Safeway or QFC?
Yeah, that isn't great, but purely from a standpoint of what might actually be most accessible to them, vs trying to hit up a store during open hours like the movie did and expected us to believe. Hey, I included a "pay what they can" part to try to make up for it a little, okay...

Shoplifting hurts everyone else in the long run too, not the corporations who will pass the loss on to anyone else but their own pockets, when prices get jacked up and jobs get cut. Sticking it to "the man" is only sticking it to the locals. No way are the rich guys at the top going to take the loss themselves.

LeotheLateBloomer
02-27-2024, 07:10 AM
Did you guys see that TLR was the top selling graphic novel of last year? The success of that book is ridiculous. You won’t convince me that a live-action version wouldn’t have made more money than Mutant Mayhem at the box office. Granted, it would cost more but that’s what audiences want to see from TMNT.

Selling strictly to kids is just another roll of the dice at the Pixar & Dreamworks casino which is why MM barely made money. Apparently TMNT merch sales were through the roof last year but no way that’s chalked up to MM.

You're definitely right but the question is if Paramount is smart enough to realize this. You know how them and Nickelodeon have been handling the brand in recent years.

tmntpower1988
02-27-2024, 10:49 AM
I wish they'd do more animated movies like the Batman vs TMNT one. Wish we got a sequel for it, really want to see more of Joker Shredder. A Last Ronin animated movie would be nice too or a live action one similar to the tone of the 1990 movie. I thought the 2007 movie was decent too, even if they made another one similar to that.

Cowabung-Gal
02-27-2024, 02:10 PM
Shoplifting hurts everyone else in the long run too, not the corporations who will pass the loss on to anyone else but their own pockets, when prices get jacked up and jobs get cut. Sticking it to "the man" is only sticking it to the locals. No way are the rich guys at the top going to take the loss themselves.

Exactly. Theft hurts the little guy more than anyone else, so are the Mayhem turtles misunderstood heroes or just thieving bums? They’re not the Robin Hood type of thieves since they’re only stealing for themselves and not helping those in the lower class. They’re not even the Aladdin type since Aladdin gave up his only loaf of bread to feed hungry orphans, even though he is starving too. Not exactly good role models for young children.

IndigoErth
02-27-2024, 04:19 PM
Wish we got a sequel for it, really want to see more of Joker Shredder.
Still shaking my head that they left off like they did, suggesting a possible sequel, and it was pretty well received, so then... nothing.

BornAgain
02-27-2024, 07:35 PM
They should get an anime studio like Madhouse to do the animation on a TLR adaptation.

I know many will be turned off by the mention of anime but it’s pretty much the only chance we have of it actually looking great on a direct-to-dvd budget. Compare their work on “Batman: Gotham Knights” (2009?) to the rest of DC’s animated home-released and be amazed at the difference in quality.

Man, that’s about the only way I want to see it adapted now.

I Crave Pizza No More
02-28-2024, 05:54 AM
For those complaining that shoplifting has no place in a kids movie, and that it's somehow a sign of the imminent radical left takeover that a movie would ever casually depict that sort of thing...you are demonstrating a stunning lack of awareness.

Do you have any idea how many silent comedies, movies that are 100 years old or more, show their protagonist stealing? Like, this isn't some new thing in society, or some new thing depicted in film. It's a pretty easy narrative device storytellers have used for a quick laugh or to show us something about a character or the film's setting.

Yes, it struck me as odd that the TMNT were shown shoplifting (I like Andrew's idea of them being scavengers), but for goodness sake maybe that's because it was lazy storytelling, or a misunderstanding of the ethos of the TMNT, more than some sort of indication that golden society as we knew it is crashing into the sun.

tmntpower1988
02-28-2024, 04:25 PM
Still shaking my head that they left off like they did, suggesting a possible sequel, and it was pretty well received, so then... nothing.

Yeah I hate it when they do that or when good shows get cancelled and end on a cliffhanger (I really wanted to see more of Dark Matter after it ended with that alien invasion).

KROW
03-16-2024, 09:56 PM
Okay, I finally got around to watching this and it wasn't that bad. The Splinter/Scumbug thing was unsettling for me and I really didn't care for Donatello's voice, but I liked how it had a shadow of Mutanimals in it, as well as the roles Bebop and Rocksteady took. Overall it was a dumb, fun flick. I've seen worse iterations of this franchise.

neatoman
03-16-2024, 10:51 PM
Okay, I finally got around to watching this and it wasn't that bad. The Splinter/Scumbug thing was unsettling for me and I really didn't care for Donatello's voice, but I liked how it had a shadow of Mutanimals in it, as well as the roles Bebop and Rocksteady took. Overall it was a dumb, fun flick. I've seen worse iterations of this franchise.

Sure it's not horrible or anything but the fact that the Turtles themselves are little more than vehicles for pop culture references, and that the film has a ton of characters who don't really do anything, are serious problems.

I also find it quite disheartening that the movie ends with the turtles just being straight up accepted into human society, that TCRI are straight up evil with no room for a misunderstanding, that Splinter quite literally just is a random rat and that most characters in this movie are just the lame Playmates creations that just existed to sell toys. It's so annoying to keep seeing Paramount just ape the "old successes" in a superficial way, while also disregarding what even shallow iterations like Fred Wolf got right.

TCRI should not be straight up evil, the Turtles should not be unambiguously accepted by the world at large, Splinter should have connections to something bigger and characters like Bebop and Rocksteady belong in the past.

Jeff
03-17-2024, 11:42 AM
Again, don't care if they steal or not, but you just know TPTB are super proud of this. Like, "We did it! We found a truly original take on the TMNT! Nobody has ever shown how they get their stuff and WE did!" So that piece is annoying. Plus these writers are all big lefties who are counting the days until the socialist utopia. Which is to say, you just know the general idea is "screw those rich shop keepers, their wealth should be redistributed anyway to people like the poor, down-trodden TMNT!" and not just a kind of matter-of-fact "I guess they steal?"

For me, it's a combination of picking up junk people throw away in dumpsters or leave in alleys or ends up floating down the sewer. For food, honestly a mix of bugs and rats and whatever they could find. Until the April and Casey days, of course. No stealing whatsoever required.

Ah yes, the big wigs of a multinational media corporation in America are trying to teach children to steal from business owners contributing taxes in a capitalist society. They did it! They showed us real folk!

Have you ever met a teenager, or been one yourself? Kids do stuff without thinking all the time. I've stolen **** from stores when I was a kid, and I'm sure most kids have at some point - but this was definitely not a representation of real life and some sort of subliminal message from rich people to sow crime amongst civilians.

TonySiegel
03-25-2024, 08:12 PM
Ah yes, the big wigs of a multinational media corporation in America are trying to teach children to steal from business owners contributing taxes in a capitalist society. They did it! They showed us real folk!

Have you ever met a teenager, or been one yourself? Kids do stuff without thinking all the time. I've stolen **** from stores when I was a kid, and I'm sure most kids have at some point - but this was definitely not a representation of real life and some sort of subliminal message from rich people to sow crime amongst civilians.

Heard this same argument from the curmudgeon folks at the comic book shop when the first Spiderverse movie dropped. I think people just can't stand change and don't realize that the real agenda is making $$$.

Comics, Hollywood and entertainment companies are casting a wider net to appeal to all audiences...

A Spiderman from the multiverse doing graffiti spoke to my soul... Old heads that hate change are out of touch for real...

Cowabung-Gal
03-25-2024, 08:44 PM
Comics, Hollywood and entertainment companies are casting a wider net to appeal to all audiences...

Especially the ones who don’t provide any financial support, aka the activists who spend all day whining about the evils of America, capitalism, Christianity, nuclear families, blah, blah, blah.

Why do you think the movie “The Birdcage”, which was released in 1996, did so well at the box office, yet “Bros”, which was released in 2022, was a complete disaster? I mean, “Bros” had way more LGBT content than “The Birdcage”, and the 2020’s are much more progressive than the 90s were. So what went wrong?

KROW
03-25-2024, 09:42 PM
I wasn't shocked about the stealing. Ninjas were paid assassins, mercenaries, and thieves, so it... kind of makes sense. Kinda-almost-maybe.

TheLabRat
03-28-2024, 01:25 PM
I wasn't shocked about the stealing. Ninjas were paid assassins, mercenaries, and thieves, so it... kind of makes sense. Kinda-almost-maybe.
Yes. That's what they're supposed to be. But the problem is that most people always see them as morden caped heroes. Even if they're hero, they're more like ancient greek heroes or pulp heroes like Conan the Barbarian. More morally gray and selfish, but still has some noble heart.

IndigoErth
03-28-2024, 02:27 PM
Still, the place they chose to do it is in a kid's movie, in the kid side of the franchise where they're firmly planted in the "hero" genre.

If it was a movie specifically for older audiences and took a bit of an antihero angle, maybe with a little included remorse about having no other choice, then whatever I guess... but "Hey kids, look how cool your fave heroes look stealing from the corner mom & pop shop(s)!" still doesn't sit well with me.

This is the same franchise that once had nunchucks banned out of the fear of imitation...


edit: Came back to mind that someone's brat ironically once stole stickers out of the remaining 2012 TMNT b-day cards I used to have in one of my stores some years ago, which of course is no better than stealing the whole card because now it would never sell and it's still a loss to the company. Yes, you're a fan of hero characters... therefore theft.

And considering how often I do find stickers or other add-ons (wristbands, key chains, hair clips, etc) stolen out of them because people refused to keep an eye on their kids (and now I try to place them high out of reach of younger kids if there is no designated spot for them) , maybe the anti-drug and pro-environment messages of the TMNT back in the day need to turn into anti-theft messages. :roll: (I know kids were doing some of that back in the day too, but it does seem more prevalent now with fewer parents paying attention to or feeling accountable for things their kids do in public.)

Cowabung-Gal
04-01-2024, 11:57 AM
First official look at Mutant Mayhem Shredder:

https://media1.tenor.com/m/rZo_iGGhdD0AAAAC/shredder-where.gif

April Fools :P

neatoman
04-01-2024, 12:36 PM
First official look at Mutant Mayhem Shredder:

https://media1.tenor.com/m/rZo_iGGhdD0AAAAC/shredder-where.gif

April Fools :P

But we already saw him.

IndigoErth
04-01-2024, 03:43 PM
Yeah, remember this vague image? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0)

KROW
04-01-2024, 11:14 PM
Artist rendering of the new film's Foot Soldier.

https://i.imgur.com/s4kU7MG.png

LeotheLateBloomer
04-09-2024, 10:40 PM
So my friend who didn't like the movie asked me this...what was the point in getting Jackie Chan to voice Splinter if he has no Asian origins?

IndigoErth
04-10-2024, 12:28 AM
Good question... What's the point of it then other than just packing the cast with recognizable names. Well, and maybe avoiding getting ire for white washing a character, but if he was always a rat and never even a pet...?



Also, reading that made OotS Leo's clueless, questioning expression (when the police chief asks "last name?") flash through my mind. I, too,stopped and mentally went "Uhhh..." lol

BornAgain
04-10-2024, 03:02 PM
Artist rendering of the new film's Foot Soldier.

https://i.imgur.com/s4kU7MG.png

lol, what happened to that guy who had a meltdown when we wouldn’t buy his theory that this was re-using Rise assets. He’ll probably have a an explanation for this.

TheLabRat
04-18-2024, 11:23 PM
Even Batman can do movies without Joker and find success. Spiderman can do movies without Venom or Green Goblin and still find success. This is a serious problem for TMNT. If TMNT can't make a movie about a Non-Shredder or Non-Krang villain successful then TMNT is going to die theatrically. Even Kung Fu Panda which is a bunch of animal martial artists like the Ninja Turtles can do differing villains. Are they all winners? No but the solid ones are entertaining enough.

Andrew NDB
04-19-2024, 12:18 AM
Even Batman can do movies without Joker and find success. Spiderman can do movies without Venom or Green Goblin and still find success. This is a serious problem for TMNT. If TMNT can't make a movie about a Non-Shredder or Non-Krang villain successful then TMNT is going to die theatrically. Even Kung Fu Panda which is a bunch of animal martial artists like the Ninja Turtles can do differing villains. Are they all winners? No but the solid ones are entertaining enough.

I've been saying that for decades now. If TMNT can't evolve past the need for Shredder (and in most cases, Bebop and Rocksteady and Krang and Technodrome) then it doesn't deserve to. I'd say the same thing for the sordid state of Star Trek -- it already did, but since the Kurtzman era I would say that if Star Trek can't evolve past Kirk'n Spock, Khan, original Enterprise connections or prequels involving such or in-betweens, then it doesn't deserve to whatsoever. And doing so is the antithesis of Star Trek because now we're just perennially trekking in a backwards circle jerk.

LeotheLateBloomer
04-19-2024, 05:31 PM
Even Batman can do movies without Joker and find success. Spiderman can do movies without Venom or Green Goblin and still find success. This is a serious problem for TMNT. If TMNT can't make a movie about a Non-Shredder or Non-Krang villain successful then TMNT is going to die theatrically. Even Kung Fu Panda which is a bunch of animal martial artists like the Ninja Turtles can do differing villains. Are they all winners? No but the solid ones are entertaining enough.

Aside the fact Oroku Saki is needed for the origin, I definitely agree with this. They could do the purple dragons, Triceratons, etc. I just think Viacom/Paramount play it too safe and it's lazy.

neatoman
04-19-2024, 05:46 PM
Speaking of Shredder and an origin, who is he in this continuity exactly? He's not the guy who wronged Splinter, there was no Hamato Yoshi to kill here, Splinter was just some literal street rat. He's not a major player in the New York underground, he'd be given more of a reason to show up in the first one if that was the case. He might be an Utrom given his apparent connections to TCRI at the end but I doubt they'll go there.

Are we really to just assume he's nothing more than a mercenary here?

Powder
04-19-2024, 06:47 PM
Speaking of Shredder and an origin, who is he in this continuity exactly? He's not the guy who wronged Splinter, there was no Hamato Yoshi to kill here, Splinter was just some literal street rat. He's not a major player in the New York underground, he'd be given more of a reason to show up in the first one if that was the case. He might be an Utrom given his apparent connections to TCRI at the end but I doubt they'll go there.

Are we really to just assume he's nothing more than a mercenary here?

I'm expecting there to be some sort of a soft retcon for the heroes' origins that finds a way to tie him in as a more significant figure that played a part from behind the scenes all along.

Technogeek29
04-19-2024, 06:49 PM
Ugh cant wait for the obnoxious fans who'll go "see told you so its made by people who resect the property."

jignat
04-20-2024, 10:59 AM
Ugh cant wait for the obnoxious fans who'll go "see told you so its made by people who resect the property."

I know this was a typo, but it is pretty funny if you've ever participated in surgery.

Technogeek29
04-20-2024, 03:14 PM
I know this was a typo, but it is pretty funny if you've ever participated in surgery.

:lol::lol::lol::lol:
I actually am a cardiologist so maybe that's why I made the typo?

Cowabung-Gal
04-26-2024, 02:54 PM
https://64.media.tumblr.com/7f7c6ffe62fbccaec45016f86fdd773e/230ac0c5aeffb3d7-83/s1280x1920/c75ab7b16d657d645384e6c9a119dda88ab654d5.jpg

Apparently this is Mutant Mayhem Casey Jones. Or at least the concept art for the character

https://media1.tenor.com/m/aK9Q5vEfofsAAAAC/segundo-sol-novela.gif

Roseangelo
04-26-2024, 03:12 PM
I am so glad I am not emotionally attached to any of this.

Zulithe
04-26-2024, 03:59 PM
not sure if this Casey rumor is just a big troll on the fanbase by someone or if it's legit... so hard to really know what to say about it.

I don't like it, to be frank.

neatoman
04-26-2024, 04:32 PM
Uhm... Yeah, so if this Casey Jones thing is real, then there was a very good chance this movie could literally have been what South Park was making fun of in the Panderverse special. You know, internal documents at Paramount and what not.
https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/07d76dc0-6c71-4162-8656-4712ade3ac0e

Autbot_Benz
04-26-2024, 04:41 PM
[QUOTE=Zulithe;1989421]not sure if this Casey rumor is just a big troll on the fanbase by someone or if it's legit... so hard to really know what to say about it.

It's fake

https://i.imgur.com/5UVcNcI.png

CyberCubed
04-26-2024, 04:44 PM
https://64.media.tumblr.com/7f7c6ffe62fbccaec45016f86fdd773e/230ac0c5aeffb3d7-83/s1280x1920/c75ab7b16d657d645384e6c9a119dda88ab654d5.jpg

Apparently this is Mutant Mayhem Casey Jones. Or at least the concept art for the character

https://media1.tenor.com/m/aK9Q5vEfofsAAAAC/segundo-sol-novela.gif

God let alone this being a female, but what is with them making every character fat and black?

Autbot_Benz
04-26-2024, 04:54 PM
God let alone this being a female, but what is with them making every character fat and black?

Shut the **** up about this. Not every character was fat and black you idiot

CyberCubed
04-26-2024, 04:58 PM
The above character is fat and black. I'm glad it's de-confirmed it isn't Casey though.

Autbot_Benz
04-26-2024, 05:01 PM
The above character is fat and black. I'm glad it's de-confirmed it isn't Casey though.

no she is Asian not black you moron

CyberCubed
04-26-2024, 05:32 PM
The shading of the skin is way too dark there. She doesn't look Asian to me at any rate.

Cowabung-Gal
04-26-2024, 06:39 PM
It’s on Justin Runfola’s website:

https://justin-runfola.com/#/tmntmutantmayhem/

So it might be indeed legit. She just didn’t end up being Casey in the final cut.

She was also on the bleachers watching Raph wrestle a guy in the gym:
https://64.media.tumblr.com/889a70d4887500a439253a00db0ad6c3/230ac0c5aeffb3d7-dc/s1280x1920/e912d459988f3ec17961863ae4455b2864450e79.pnj

CyberCubed
04-26-2024, 10:28 PM
I pray they don't ruin Casey, but seeing what they did to April, I don't really have much hope.

IndigoErth
04-27-2024, 12:54 AM
School wrestling always looked a bit awkward... and a mutant Turtle doing it isn't helping. Though there is a lack of wrestling uniforms in that art, so guess they may have realized this, too...

What a time we're in though that in my mind I wanted to default assume this was made with AI.

The shading of the skin is way too dark there. She doesn't look Asian to me at any rate.
You ARE aware that "Asian" comes in more variety than just the pale Chinese girls, right?

IndigoErth
04-28-2024, 01:14 AM
According to something I saw shared on Reddit, Bishop is a lady.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TMNT/comments/1cevgz9/new_info_on_tales_of_the_tmnt_and_first_look_at/

TurtleGurkle
05-02-2024, 03:43 PM
https://deadline.com/2024/05/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutant-mayhem-movie-profits-1235902581/

‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem’ Shockingly Slays Way To No. 4 In Deadline’s 2023 Most Valuable Blockbuster Tournament

Mostly driven by merchandise, nice to see a TMNT project on a list like this.

BornAgain
05-03-2024, 06:47 AM
Would that even be Mutant Mayhem merch or all TMNT merch?

Bc it’s hilarious if TLR sales are boosting these numbers.

And it would make a lot of sense seeing as the movie has finally been green lit when Nick didn’t want to do it before MM floundered at the box office.

CyberCubed
12-18-2025, 09:53 PM
So I watched the movie again after finishing the cartoon.

+ Animation + CG + fight scenes are very good

+ Voice acting is fine except Donatello, but his voice cracked during Season 2 of the cartoon so I'm fine with it now. But man in the movie he sounds like a little kid.

+ Superfly is OK as a main villain since they weren't using Shredder

+ Glad Splinter can fight and knows ninjitsu. Jackie Chan's voice for him was also great.

- Black April. "Nuff said

- Milking joke went on too long

- The Turtles were acting "too black" for me in certain scenes, like their dancing yolk song when April was filming them.

- Some overall things I don't like about the designs like Don wearing glasses, don't know why Leatherhead is female but eh.

- Turtles actually attending school at the end is very meh. Glad the show sidestepped this for the most part.


Overall though the theme they were going for about the Turtles being isolated from the world and wanting to belong was fine. Splinter hating humans since he was a normal rat was alright. The Mutanimals betraying Superfly and realizing killing all humans was wrong was fine, and their characters are fleshed out more in the cartoon aside from Mondo and Bebop/Rocksteady. The climax of the movie and the fight scenes with the human gangsters was also nice.

I also liked how the human citizens helped the Turtles and Splinter in the climax, which is a nice touch.

I don't dislike the movie or anything, it's not my take on TMNT, but it's not really bad either. It's alright for what it is. I hope Shredder is handled well in the next one.

ToTheNines
12-28-2025, 06:03 PM
So I watched the movie again after finishing the cartoon.

+ Animation + CG + fight scenes are very good

+ Voice acting is fine except Donatello, but his voice cracked during Season 2 of the cartoon so I'm fine with it now. But man in the movie he sounds like a little kid.

+ Superfly is OK as a main villain since they weren't using Shredder

+ Glad Splinter can fight and knows ninjitsu. Jackie Chan's voice for him was also great.

- Black April. "Nuff said

- Milking joke went on too long

- The Turtles were acting "too black" for me in certain scenes, like their dancing yolk song when April was filming them.

- Some overall things I don't like about the designs like Don wearing glasses, don't know why Leatherhead is female but eh.

- Turtles actually attending school at the end is very meh. Glad the show sidestepped this for the most part.


Overall though the theme they were going for about the Turtles being isolated from the world and wanting to belong was fine. Splinter hating humans since he was a normal rat was alright. The Mutanimals betraying Superfly and realizing killing all humans was wrong was fine, and their characters are fleshed out more in the cartoon aside from Mondo and Bebop/Rocksteady. The climax of the movie and the fight scenes with the human gangsters was also nice.

I also liked how the human citizens helped the Turtles and Splinter in the climax, which is a nice touch.

I don't dislike the movie or anything, it's not my take on TMNT, but it's not really bad either. It's alright for what it is. I hope Shredder is handled well in the next one.

I haven’t watched Season 2 yet, but I was bored in a hotel last summer and decided to re-watch this for the first time and see if my opinion changed. If anything, I liked it even less upon second viewing.

Other than no Hamato/Oroku feud in the origin, I mainly just thought the way Superfly got betrayed so easily was too mean spirited and then he just evolves into a mindless monster. And the high school thing is just a bridge too far. Insane, honestly.

Like, we all read hundreds of fan fics back in the day. Most of them weren’t the best piece of literature or anything, but a lot of them had really clever ideas and interesting concepts. Then of course there was just straight trash about a Turtle boinking some self-insert Mary Sue, a nonsense crossover and yes, the turtles going to ****ing high school. I’d never even give stuff like that a chance and just move on to something else.

But here we are 20 years later and Seth Rogen has brought it to theaters for this generation’s main TMNT universe.

Daytona
02-20-2026, 06:19 PM
Which do you all prefer - Mutant Mayhem or the 2012 series?

Just compare season 1 to the movie if it makes it easier but I’m asking in a general sense.

As someone who doesn’t necessarily feel like the target audience for either, I have to say I find the 2012 show to be much more watchable. Despite looking sort of crappy in comparison, I think the characters, storytelling, and general tone is a much better introduction, for kids, into the TMNT.

Presentation is the only aspect I feel like MM is better, which isn’t surprising given the budget.

ToTheNines
02-20-2026, 06:33 PM
You’re not gonna find many people here that don’t prefer the 2012 show to this movie.

Daytona
02-20-2026, 06:43 PM
2012 is surprisingly good. It really has no business making me laugh but I sometimes chuckle a couple times per episode. While the animation is clearly on a budget, they make good use of it and some of the fight choreography isn’t half bad. I feel like this team could have made a much better TMNT movie if they were given the budget and time.

Not trying to pile on Mutant Mayhem, but I just find them an interesting comparison and a good example of what makes TMNT work even when aiming at a younger or broader audience.

neatoman
02-20-2026, 07:31 PM
"The 2012 show or Mutant Mayhem?" seems like such an odd question to ask, one is a full TV show and the other is a movie, one clearly just has more time work with than the other. If it was between the 2012 show and Tales, then there would be more to discuss but I almost consider Tales to be something different from this movie despite sharing continuity.

Anyway, as unfair as the comparison is to make in the first place, I suppose the 2012 show wins out? The Turtles in Mutant Mayhem just kind of blend together, I can take the 2012 version of Splinter more seriously (even if I don't like the Mutated Yoshi" origin) and it's not like there is an episode of that show that just introduces a million characters in one episode as if we're meant to immediately care about them. That and the show clearly understood that just having the Turtles get accepted by society would kill the concept.

Still, I'd be lying if I told you the story of Mutant Mayhem didn't seem like it might as well have been recycled from a scrapped 2012 episode, I mean I've even said as much before. The difference, if I were to imagine what a version of this story could be like if told in the 2012 show, would probably just be that the Turtles would probably investigate Superfly (or whatever character he might be instead) for a less stupid reason than wanting to seem like heroes and enrolling in high school, otherwise it would be pretty similar. Maybe the mutants would need to swapped out for others to keep continuity and presumably the Turtles wouldn't be immediately interested in hanging out with them due to constantly meeting other mutants. Considering the 2012 show actually did the composite giant mutant fight... Twice... I really don't think there is that much which happens in this movie that would outlandish or out of place in that show.

CyberCubed
02-20-2026, 09:26 PM
Comparing a 124 episode series to a single movie and a 20 episode cartoon is really odd, the 2012 series simply has a gazillion times more content.

Of course the "bad things" from the movie like the Turtles going to school, the FAT BLACK April, Don wearing glasses, and I guess some weird stuff like Splinter not talking in the cartoon because they couldn't get Jackie Chan will always bring it down a bit.

Still I really liked the show, and Season 2 was better than the first. It's honestly a shame it got canceled.

Daytona
02-21-2026, 05:11 AM
I don’t think it’s an odd comparison at all. Both are essentially tmnt cartoons for kids. One has a bigger budget and one has more time to develop - but as I said, it’s more a general comparison of tone, direction, writing. You can easily compare the two with the given material - it’s a cartoon discussion not a heavyweight championship lol.

And like I said, just compare the first season if comparing a full show to a movie gives you a mental wedgie. There’s also the MM television show if you want to throw that in. Idk doesn’t seem that complicated to me.

Observe: “I think the television series handled Splinter way better. I like that how the 2012 show treated him as an imposing figure even to the turtles at times, whereas the movie went in the complete opposite direction and turned him sort of into a doting goofball.”

See? Easy.

ToTheNines
02-21-2026, 05:28 AM
I don’t think it’s odd either. That’s mostly all we do is compare and contrast the different versions between the comics/movies/cartoons.

Daytona
02-21-2026, 09:19 PM
Totally. But thanks everyone for sharing your opinions regardless.

I’ll take it a step further (just bc it’s Saturday night) and say I also find 2012 superior to the 2007 TMNT film. At least the first two seasons which is really all I’ve seen.

The 2007 film actually understands the tmnt pretty well and does a lot right but the story is dry as a crusty old rag and it loses me every time. It’s like the creators understand the world and the universe but didn’t do anything interesting with them.

Poweranimals
02-23-2026, 02:36 PM
It's 2012 and it's not even close.

TigerClaw
02-23-2026, 02:48 PM
Totally. But thanks everyone for sharing your opinions regardless.

I’ll take it a step further (just bc it’s Saturday night) and say I also find 2012 superior to the 2007 TMNT film. At least the first two seasons which is really all I’ve seen.

The 2007 film actually understands the tmnt pretty well and does a lot right but the story is dry as a crusty old rag and it loses me every time. It’s like the creators understand the world and the universe but didn’t do anything interesting with them.
2012 was good in some places. But I have issues with the directions they took some characters. a lot of it is characters in name only, and they aren't anything like the originals.

ToTheNines
02-23-2026, 03:06 PM
This movie got moved up a month to August 13th. I’m too lazy to link the source.

neatoman
02-23-2026, 03:28 PM
This movie got moved up a month to August 13th. I’m too lazy to link the source.

By "this movie" do you mean the sequel?

Autbot_Benz
04-02-2026, 06:41 PM
Looks like the sequel is the last with these guys

https://i.imgur.com/SFCgJ4y.png

neatoman
04-02-2026, 07:46 PM
Looks like the sequel is the last with these guys

https://i.imgur.com/SFCgJ4y.png

Yeah, kind of expected. They were cast on the basis that they would sound like actual teenagers because they were and they wouldn't remain teenagers forever anyway, so the whole reason behind was inherently flawed if they intended to make sequels.

Daytona
04-02-2026, 08:33 PM
Would be interesting to hear all the behind the scenes development for this series. I think it ended up being a slight disappointment for Nick in terms of performance. Show cancelled, possibly only one sequel from the look of things, and it was crazy how they backtracked on not wanting to make a last ronin movie that’d compete with this one, once the numbers came in.

Idk maybe the hot critical reception gave them a little hope but it also seems like they had a hard time nailing the direction of the first movie until late in the game. We know there was much more focus on high school antics at first. Between middling box office and swerving direction, it does make sense to end it here.

TMNT has a large fan base of all ages. It’s not just children. This movie mostly appeals to children if you ask me.

That said I’ll def give the sequel a chance. I kind of expect it to be a bit of a course correction. More ninjitsu and possibly a better script that didn’t need to be completely rewritten late in the game to get them out of school.

ZariusTwo
05-29-2026, 08:02 AM
Channel 4 screened this in the UK last weekend as part of the late May bank holiday.

It's a very boring film.

Barkworm
06-14-2026, 04:32 AM
I don't think it's boring, there's a lot of fun interaction between the characters, the action scenes are by far the best of any Ninja Turtles film, the score and choice of songs is great and overall it is just solidly done - unlike most Turtles films so far honestly.

The problem is the typical franchise dilemma. If you reboot stuff all the time, in the end it's so far removed from the initial version (or even other reboots you've enjoyed) that even if it's a charming as this one, you can't really recognize the original property anymore.

ToTheNines
06-14-2026, 02:12 PM
I don't think it's boring, there's a lot of fun interaction between the characters, the action scenes are by far the best of any Ninja Turtles film, the score and choice of songs is great and overall it is just solidly done - unlike most Turtles films so far honestly.

The problem is the typical franchise dilemma. If you reboot stuff all the time, in the end it's so far removed from the initial version (or even other reboots you've enjoyed) that even if it's a charming as this one, you can't really recognize the original property anymore.

I agree. It had a lot going for it and doesn’t feel too long when you sit through it.

But a not great script and a couple of really awful creative liberties ruin it.

sdp
06-14-2026, 05:03 PM
I also agree, I think many of us have that sentiment where we can see it's not a bad movie, it's just not TMNT enough. That doesn't mean it doesn't do some TMNT things right.

CyberCubed
06-15-2026, 09:38 AM
The biggest things that I didn't like:

1. That fat black April

2. The Turtles going to school at the end of the movie (thank god the show barely focused on this)

3. Splinter didn't have much a backstory yet, if he has no connection to Shredder in the next film that will suck.

4. Bebop/Rocksteady weren't humans in this incarnation.

neatoman
06-15-2026, 10:22 AM
Splinter didn't have much a backstory yet, if he has no connection to Shredder in the next film that will suck.


Unless we're talking reincarnation here, how could he? What, did Splinter poop in his dinner last time he visited New York or something?

Bebop/Rocksteady weren't humans in this incarnation.

That's probably the lamest aspect of these characters you could be attached to, and that's really saying something considering how they were always lame characters. It mattered so little in the FW cartoon that David Wise, the guy who wrote their origin episode in the first place, forgot about it.

CyberCubed
06-15-2026, 07:06 PM
A Bebop that is not black prior to mutation is not my Bebop. That's Bebop in name only. I want black people to be represented the right away (not with April), but a character who has always been black. If Bebop ain't black, I don't want it.

#NotMyBebop.

ToTheNines
06-15-2026, 09:00 PM
I hate fat black Bebop. Make him an animal from now on!

Heyowakka
06-15-2026, 10:25 PM
The intrusive thoughts have never been so powerful!

Barkworm
06-22-2026, 06:39 AM
I want black people to be represented the right away (not with April), but a character who has always been black.
And by "always" you mean maybe 15 minutes across three episodes out of more than a 100 in which that character appears.

sdp
06-23-2026, 12:28 PM
The thing about fat black April is I actually liked her character, she's good. Just not April. They should've named her Soshana or whatever Cubed named her before the movie came out :lol: It's as if in TMNT 2 imagine if Keno was named Casey Jones, people would've hated him but since he was Keno people were fine with him replacing Casey Jones.

Same with Rise April, she doesn't feel like April either all hyperactive and she's not fat there, but I like that character design. But it's not like the two black april's have anything in common, MM April is shy and insecure, which is unique to her and I like that.

April might've been inconsistent before but at least she mostly felt like the character, the only exception is 2012 April which I absolutely loath and will take Fat Black April anyday over her psychic BS of a character she was made into.

ToTheNines
06-27-2026, 08:24 PM
Yeah I appreciate any version of April that’s kind of a weirdo or outcast. It makes sense that that kind of person would just start spending most of their free time with mutant turtles lol. It’s really hard to buy the versions that are just normal, beautiful, well-adjusted women doing that. Especially the ones where she’s a famous news anchor haha.

I agree that 2012 April mostly sucks. I guess if you want to do the writers’ jobs for them, you can assume that she always felt ostracized without realizing it, growing up with alien DNA, and her father probably sheltered her knowing the Kraang were out there, so she probably had an odd upbringing. But this all headcanon on my part, the writers never show any of this.

CyberCubed
06-28-2026, 12:31 AM
2012 April has a great personality. It's just all the Kraang backstory stuff that doesn't really work well. In terms of her character and interaction with others, she's one of the best.

ToTheNines
06-28-2026, 12:10 PM
She was a bitch.

Daytona
06-28-2026, 03:06 PM
Mutant Mayhem did very little for me - I can’t even finish it in a sitting, but I am admittedly curious to see how much they try to course correct. I expect at least a bit of that.

It’s not like I’m holding my breath to love it but I could see it being enjoyable if they photo polish the script way more and bring back some missing elements. The former is actually possible as well bc I’m pretty sure they had to rewrite the first movie late in the game to remove a ton of botched high school elements.

TylerD
06-29-2026, 03:46 PM
The biggest things that I didn't like:

1. That fat black April

2. The Turtles going to school at the end of the movie (thank god the show barely focused on this)

3. Splinter didn't have much a backstory yet, if he has no connection to Shredder in the next film that will suck.

4. Bebop/Rocksteady weren't humans in this incarnation.
Lmfao. The fat black April. That killed me ?????

But I agree. I’m all for change, but this was ridiculous and hard to get past for me.

Andrew NDB
06-29-2026, 04:04 PM
4. Bebop/Rocksteady weren't humans in this incarnation.

Really? Then what were they? Let me guess: a rhino and warthog that instantly became sentient and knew English right after mutation?

Barkworm
06-29-2026, 06:44 PM
No, they were mutated as babies and learned English from their "big brother" Superfly who raised them and who had learned to speak before from their "father" Baxter Stockman.

neatoman
06-29-2026, 07:18 PM
Really? Then what were they? Let me guess: a rhino and warthog that instantly became sentient and knew English right after mutation?

No, they were mutated as babies and learned English from their "big brother" Superfly who raised them and who had learned to speak before from their "father" Baxter Stockman.

I kinda wonder why he chose those particular animals. An alligator that can speak and be reasoned with is still... You know... An alligator?

Jephael
07-25-2026, 11:25 PM
Really? Then what were they? Let me guess: a rhino and warthog that instantly became sentient and knew English right after mutation?

But when Splinter and the Turtles become sentient...

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRW48EOllvEqBQ01KA3N1k3ZhTzyyrLo 7Ty-IomHw-pEA&s