View Full Version : So I saw Mutant Mayhem, here's my review.
The Great Saiyaman
08-25-2023, 05:31 AM
So what are my thoughts on it?
The good:
- Eye Candy
- VERY well animated, the guys and the bad guys looked awesome, and the action was top-notch.
- I loved this April, I loved how she wasn't this skinny, almost-no-meat-on-the-bones chick her previous two incarnations were. (Of course my personal preference in women go out to girls like that, packing a few extra.)
- I thought that Splinter falling in love with the roach mutant (Who BTW was a female in the Dutch dub) was hilarious.
- I dug this version of Baxter Stockman, he was a loving, caring dad who just wanted to giver Superfly a good life.
- Recalling high school the way I personally went through it, made the school scenes recognizable. Especially the bullying part, sadly.
- The music, "Bigger faster, more" by the Four Non Blondes, is one of my all time favorite CD's. And I sang along with "What's up?" as soon as it came on.
The bad:
- Story, what friggin' story? I couldn't make heads or tails with this movie.
- That the TMNT aren't a righteous team morally was pretty made clear during the stealing scenes. But then again, they were never in the other versions either.
- Bebop and Rocksteady were just extras, we can badmouth Michael Bay all we want, but at least he made them into enjoyable characters. I for the life of me can't recall any of their dialog.
- Michelangelo. Much the same with Bebop and Rocksteady, was he even IN this movie? Also, what's the deal with him having the lowest voice out of all of them. I've said before that Greg Cipes to me was the PERFECT voice for Mikey, there was nothing of the lovable, zany goof ball that Cipes made of him.
- What's the deal with the Turtles being taught ninjitsu by watching martial arts movies? That's even worse than the Bay movies Splinter finding a book and teaching them. I guess it's meant to be a nod to the Rise series, as that Splinter was a martial arts movies actor.
- NO explanation on the Utrom Lady and her motives, NONE AT ALL!
- The boys starting to attend high school, I mean REALLY?
- Related to that, Leopril. Hey, I didn't mind Leo simping over April, I also didn't mind her returning those feelings. But hey, if Splinter and that roach mutant are seen kissing, then why were we withheld seeing Leo's first kiss? It would have been the perfect "Teen movie" ending.
-Shredder? No links to the Hamato clan, I'm reminded of those Spider-Man movies with the Symbiote suit, as every single one of them removes the comic book origin on how that Symbiote came to be in the first place.
So my rating in overall: it was a fun movie, but one with a little too many of "I don't know about THAT..." plot holes.
It's a 4.5 out of 10
Mad Dog McMutt
08-25-2023, 07:22 AM
What did you think about Donatello's voice?
The Great Saiyaman
08-25-2023, 07:34 AM
What did you think about Donatello's voice?
Seeing as how I saw the Dutch dub, high and whiney.
Cowabung-Gal
08-25-2023, 11:15 AM
The boys starting to attend high school, I mean REALLY?
90% of the fandom is thinking that. :ohwell:
Andrew NDB
08-25-2023, 11:45 AM
90% of the fandom is thinking that. :ohwell:
We're supposed to go: "Whooooaaaaa.... the TMNT in high school! #mindblown #socool #howcomenobodythoughtofthisbefore"
Coola Yagami
08-25-2023, 12:24 PM
It always amazes me how stupid they keep making the 'how the turtles learned their ninja skills'. Like they forget that all the fancy flips and whatnot they'll be doing during the movie, as well as mastery of their weapons and whatnot came from watching movies. I mean you can work out and stay fit all you want, but without actual training, there's no way you can do a back flip or a cartwheel 'just because'.
Well ****, let's binge watch some old Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan films for a weekend or two and become top tier martial artists then.
We're supposed to go: "Whooooaaaaa.... the TMNT in high school! #mindblown #socool #howcomenobodythoughtofthisbefore"
Ex-pe-TAY-SHUNNNSSS Sub-VER-T-eddddd!!!!!
Shinningbolt
08-25-2023, 12:55 PM
I swear to god that this movie is such a joke that even the elliptic mountains of Shilling it’s received can’t deflect from it. like seriously it’s basically the new coming out of our shells low for the franchise, post nick buyout. did Pete really go through that much during the volume 4 2k3 era for this to be something that happened two decades later did the Fred wolf fanboys hound him that much that Nick pivoted it on at all
LeotheLateBloomer
08-25-2023, 01:47 PM
What did you think about Donatello's voice?
I can't believe anyone could tolerate Don's voice. I just wanted him to shut up everytime he spoke. That line where he brought up "bacon, egg, and cheese", I was waiting for the gag from the older films where they were puzzled by his lame phrases and Mikey says to him, "Donnie, give it up!"
I swear to god that this movie is such a joke that even the elliptic mountains of Shilling it’s received can’t deflect from it. like seriously it’s basically the new coming out of our shells low for the franchise, post nick buyout. did Pete really go through that much during the volume 4 2k3 era for this to be something that happened two decades later did the Fred wolf fanboys hound him that much that Nick pivoted it on at all
I guess so. If that isn't selling out then I don't know what is.
IndigoErth
08-25-2023, 03:11 PM
As much as some people may argue that some kid's voices don't change until a bit later, which is understandable, sounding 8 is a bit extreme of a choice.
What as that "bacon, egg and cheese" thing...? Is that really some dorky NYC thing? Cubed? NYC I thought you were cooler and grittier than that. lol Somewhere it was mentioned that it was part of their ab-libbed junk and I then looked up their hometowns. Not a damn one of them are from NY, so was their ad-libbing still directed or were they just making up junk.
I didn't hate the movie, but there's definitely some issues I had.
Roseangelo
08-25-2023, 04:44 PM
In the last 34 years, I have never once had the thought, "Gee, the Turtles should go to high school!"
IndigoErth
08-25-2023, 06:40 PM
With this version being what it is... I don't really even feel "insulted" by the school thing, I just feel incredibly bored by the idea.
It feels like it would just make them become just like everything else. In the quest to be new and different it chose a theme of high school...a direction that's been done over and over by everything else.
What's wrong with a fictional fantasy of characters who exist outside of those confines of society and boring 'ol everyday human life. And yet still being able to be relatable in other, sometimes less direct, ways.
The Great Saiyaman
08-25-2023, 07:48 PM
It always amazes me how stupid they keep making the 'how the turtles learned their ninja skills'. Like they forget that all the fancy flips and whatnot they'll be doing during the movie, as well as mastery of their weapons and whatnot came from watching movies. I mean you can work out and stay fit all you want, but without actual training, there's no way you can do a back flip or a cartwheel 'just because'.
Well ****, let's binge watch some old Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan films for a weekend or two and become top tier martial artists then.
Or to quote the 2012 Donatello...
What, you think you can just put a sword under your pillow and wake up a samurai?
https://nonstopnerd748323109.files.wordpress.com/2023/06/tm2.jpg?w=436
Shinningbolt
08-26-2023, 03:36 AM
2 of the few people pushing back against this ****
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k (http://https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k)
http://https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kTohjN-Nkds
Never bend the knee
Andrew NDB
08-26-2023, 03:43 AM
2 of the few people pushing back against this ****
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k (http://https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k)
http://https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kTohjN-Nkds
Never bend the knee
I'm not disagreeing with your sentiment... but both of those videos are stupid. I watched most of each. Also, let me help you.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kTohjN-Nkds
Shinningbolt
08-26-2023, 05:03 AM
I'm not disagreeing with your sentiment... but both of those videos are stupid. I watched most of each. Also, let me help you.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EywL2OKsT_k
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kTohjN-Nkds I didnt expect my posts to get this many replies but I guess it’s just the general sentiment being expressed. also what was it in the videos you disagreed with im genuinely curious they seemed to be from long time fans with firsthand historical experience. Btw are people actually up this early using the site in general or am I just in a time zone different from most of you.
terrorblade
08-26-2023, 05:44 AM
As much as some people may argue that some kid's voices don't change until a bit later, which is understandable, sounding 8 is a bit extreme of a choice.
What as that "bacon, egg and cheese" thing...? Is that really some dorky NYC thing? Cubed? NYC I thought you were cooler and grittier than that. lol Somewhere it was mentioned that it was part of their ab-libbed junk and I then looked up their hometowns. Not a damn one of them are from NY, so was their ad-libbing still directed or were they just making up junk.
I didn't hate the movie, but there's definitely some issues I had.
Wonder why didn't they swap Mikey and Donnie's voice actors, both of them sound weird imo.
I did enjoy the film overall but their voices were a little distracting, also this is probably the least smartest version of Donatello. I don't remember him doing anything techie or smart at all, he's just your average pop culture geek rather than a nerdy genius like he is usually portrayed.
The Great Saiyaman
08-26-2023, 06:25 AM
Wonder why didn't they swap Mikey and Donnie's voice actors, both of them sound weird imo.
I did enjoy the film overall but their voices were a little distracting, also this is probably the least smartest version of Donatello. I don't remember him doing anything techie or smart at all, he's just your average pop culture geek rather than a nerdy genius like he is usually portrayed.
And to once again quote his 2012 counterpart...
What, you think you can just put a sword under your pillow and wake up a samurai?
Seeing as how this Donatello apparently believes so...
Cowabung-Gal
08-26-2023, 10:29 AM
Or to quote the 2012 Donatello...
What, you think you can just put a sword under your pillow and wake up a samurai?
I love that quote. :D
Related to that, Leopril. Hey, I didn't mind Leo simping over April, I also didn't mind her returning those feelings. But hey, if Splinter and that roach mutant are seen kissing, then why were we withheld seeing Leo's first kiss? It would have been the perfect "Teen movie" ending.
In fairness, April hasn't obviously returned those feelings (at least so far). Leo asks if April will accompany him to prom, and a beat after she agrees she says, "Wait, we're just going as friends, right?" So given that asked-for clarification, I'd have been surprised to see a kiss. (Something to look forward to in the series, if their friendship progresses to something more...?)
Looney Turtles
08-27-2023, 10:31 PM
In the last 34 years, I have never once had the thought, "Gee, the Turtles should go to high school!"
Sam here. Maybe April. Casey and Irma, but definitely not the Turtles. They don't belong there.
In fairness, April hasn't obviously returned those feelings (at least so far). Leo asks if April will accompany him to prom, and a beat after she agrees she says, "Wait, we're just going as friends, right?" So given that asked-for clarification, I'd have been surprised to see a kiss. (Something to look forward to in the series, if their friendship progresses to something more...?)
Yep, exactly this. Leo's crush on April is nothing compared to Donnie's crush on her in 2012 series.
In the last 34 years, I have never once had the thought, "Gee, the Turtles should go to high school!"
I've had that thought, but admittedly one of my favorite issues of the Mirage series was the dream issue Matt Howarth did. Incidentally, "Nardo" was also Leo's apparent last name in that one! :tgrin:
But also, high school is such an integral part of the teenage experience that I'm kinda surprised it took this long for them to get around to putting the Turtles in high school. I'm here for the experiment.
Coola Yagami
08-30-2023, 09:55 AM
I've had that thought, but admittedly one of my favorite issues of the Mirage series was the dream issue Matt Howarth did. Incidentally, "Nardo" was also Leo's apparent last name in that one! :tgrin:
But also, high school is such an integral part of the teenage experience that I'm kinda surprised it took this long for them to get around to putting the Turtles in high school. I'm here for the experiment.
Most teens don't grow up isolated in the sewers and train in martial arts. Their 'high school' was their ninjitsu training.
Rooish
08-30-2023, 03:11 PM
Wonder why didn't they swap Mikey and Donnie's voice actors, both of them sound weird imo.
I did enjoy the film overall but their voices were a little distracting, also this is probably the least smartest version of Donatello. I don't remember him doing anything techie or smart at all, he's just your average pop culture geek rather than a nerdy genius like he is usually portrayed.
I found this totally refreshing. It was nice to see a Donatello who doesn't have impossible all fields of science powers for no reason.
I also found Michelangelo refreshing. He like, wasn't annoying at all. Just a sweet guy.
I found this totally refreshing. It was nice to see a Donatello who doesn't have impossible all fields of science powers for no reason.
I also found Michelangelo refreshing. He like, wasn't annoying at all. Just a sweet guy.
I'm with you here -- I liked that Don didn't come off as a supergenius (yet), and I found this Mikey *way* less grating than the 2003 and 2012 versions. I imagine we'll get to see Don shine more when he's taking high school science courses, though!
Andrew NDB
08-31-2023, 01:54 AM
I imagine we'll get to see Don shine more when he's taking high school science courses, though!
*shudder* :tconfuse:
IndigoErth
08-31-2023, 03:42 PM
Season 1, Ep 12: The Attack of the Failing Grades!
Donatello's technology obsession is proving difficult to juggle with keeping up in school and getting enough sleep. Will he ever be able to quit Tictok in time to improve his grades so he doesn't get left out of the school trip to the science museum?!
Just remembered that scribbled piece of paper "tease" that seemed like it was just a thing and really of no real connection to the movie... that 100% gave away the ending.
edit:
Season 1, Ep 15: No, Still Absolutely Not!
Raph's high school team has qualified for Northeast regionals! But there's only one problem, he can't go because he's too weird and the world outside New York City isn't ready for that, and without enough teammates the whole team will be disqualified!
yeahduderad
08-31-2023, 07:37 PM
I just saw the movie today. I was just so confused. it's almost like the people who made this film have no clue about the Ninja Turtles franchise whatsoever. i felt like they gave them a 20-minute refresher course on the turtles and a list of character names and said "ok, go make a movie" - I was so confused the whole time. I didn't even feel like I was watching a turtles movie. Maybe I'll have to watch it again and it'll grow on me. but I don't know. and I couldn't stand the fact that Superfly was just ice cube talking. like, c'mon man. ridiculous. There's about a hundred other things I could complain about but I don't feel like taking the time right now. But heres a few, Donnies voice, wtf. He did no tech stuff. There was literally NO character development for any villains and barely for the turtles. They referenced Raph's "rage" like twice and called Leo "leader" like twice. It was just strange. It was like the people who wrote and made this film have no idea about the turtles. So confusing to me. I feel the Michael Bay turtle films even did a better job presenting the turtles individual personalities along with Bebop and Rocksteady. Like someone posted earlier, they completely wasted bebop and rocksteady. Like what were they doing? I don't know what seth rogen was thinking. I dont think he's anywhere close to as hardcore of a turtle fan as he lets on. And OMG i don't even want to get started on the high school thing. I should slap seth rogen in his mouth.
Cowabung-Gal
08-31-2023, 07:55 PM
I don't know what seth rogen was thinking. I dont think he's anywhere close to as hardcore of a turtle fan as he lets on.
They all claim to be hardcore fans, then they prove just how ignorant they are of the franchises that they adapt.
yeahduderad
08-31-2023, 10:02 PM
it might sound crazy. but as i was watching the movie i was literally thinking to myself, "oh man, poor Peter Laird. There's no way hes going to enjoy this." I dont know about Eastman, but man...
MikeandRaph87
08-31-2023, 10:15 PM
it might sound crazy. but as i was watching the movie i was literally thinking to myself, "oh man, poor Peter Laird. There's no way hes going to enjoy this." I dont know about Eastman, but man...
No, I was thinking the same thing and this is something that 1987 cartoon fans and black and white comic fans can agree on disliking and see as not who the Turtles are.
LeotheLateBloomer
08-31-2023, 11:53 PM
it might sound crazy. but as i was watching the movie i was literally thinking to myself, "oh man, poor Peter Laird. There's no way hes going to enjoy this." I dont know about Eastman, but man...
This so much!
No, I was thinking the same thing and this is something that 1987 cartoon fans and black and white comic fans can agree on disliking and see as not who the Turtles are.
I agree, this movie was so lame. If I was Peter or Kevin, I'd never sign an autograph for Seth Rogen after watching this.
I don't think Laird has much room to criticize considering what he did to April in Volume 4.
Drose18
09-01-2023, 11:33 AM
Kevin is actually in the movie so I'm not so sure he is as upset about the movie as you guys are.
Also his cameo may have been the best easter egg in the movie imo
yeahduderad
09-01-2023, 01:35 PM
I didn't hate the movie. I understand it's a version of the turtles for a new generation. If we're lucky, we'll look back on this turtle run one day and call it the "rogen turtles" or something like that ya know.
I'm going to re-watch the movie and I'm sure I'll grow to like it, maybe love it. Because like everyone on these forums, I love the turtles and hold them close to my heart. (bury me with my turtle toys and my OG movie 1990 VHS).
I'm just more of a fan that gravitates toward the darker, more serious tone of the turtles. But they can't always cater to my portion of the fan base, I get it. Like I enjoy the tone of the IDW comics. While I don't agree with all the choices, I enjoy the overall look and more serious/darker tone some of them take. And the Mirage volumes are top-tier for me (well, most of it).
I always have other older turtle material to feed my needs. But we might as well get used to the "rogen turtles" for now. From what we've seen, they approved a sequel to the movie and a Paramount Plus series.
Like I never liked Rise of the TMNT. But I've been watching it on Paramount Plus and it's growing on me. It's still my turtles. Just Different.
Cowabung-Gal
09-01-2023, 01:58 PM
But we might as well get used to the "rogen turtles" for now. From what we've seen, they approved a sequel to the movie and a Paramount Plus series.
Or we could just ignore both the sequel and Paramount series. We don’t have to watch every single thing that has “TMNT” slapped onto it, especially if it’s hot garbage.
LeotheLateBloomer
09-01-2023, 03:27 PM
I'm going to re-watch the movie and I'm sure I'll grow to like it, maybe love it.
It's hitting streaming soon so you might as well wait.
CyberCubed
09-01-2023, 08:34 PM
I'm assuming Splinter was the pet of Hamato Yoshi, and they're saving that connection for the next film when Shredder shows up. I doubt this Splinter didn't know anything about martial arts at all considering how well he fought.
yeahduderad
09-01-2023, 08:52 PM
Or we could just ignore both the sequel and Paramount series. We don’t have to watch every single thing that has “TMNT” slapped onto it, especially if it’s hot garbage.
i agree. that's exactly what i did with ROTMNT forever.
and yes i just got it on digital, so i can watch again
yeahduderad
09-01-2023, 08:53 PM
I'm assuming Splinter was the pet of Hamato Yoshi, and they're saving that connection for the next film when Shredder shows up. I doubt this Splinter didn't know anything about martial arts at all considering how well he fought.
yeah, that would be a good way tp do it. fingers crossed.
LeotheLateBloomer
09-01-2023, 08:58 PM
I'm assuming Splinter was the pet of Hamato Yoshi, and they're saving that connection for the next film when Shredder shows up. I doubt this Splinter didn't know anything about martial arts at all considering how well he fought.
Did you even see the movie?
CyberCubed
09-01-2023, 09:17 PM
Splinter never said he didn't know any martial arts, just that he thought it would be a great way to teach them watching TV. How did Splinter do so well at fighting? Where did the weapons come from, etc?
Roseangelo
09-02-2023, 12:16 AM
Did the people who liked this movie see something completely different than what I did? I mean, I have my suspicions that someone was paid to endorse this movie, but other than that, I don't get it at all.
CyberCubed
09-02-2023, 12:38 AM
Having just seen it tonight for the first time, there were definitely some parts of the movie I really liked. And I can see the dynamic between the brothers and what they were going for. Admittedly the movie started to drag a bit when Superfly got mutated into a giant, I feel the pacing was a little off in the backhalf of the movie. I did like the theme of the Turtles wanting to be accepted by society, even though the end result (going to human school), isn't what I wanted.
The animation/fight scenes/music were all pretty good though.A lot of the jokes didn't land, but I wasn't the target audience.
Monty Mole
09-02-2023, 12:40 AM
Did the people who liked this movie see something completely different than what I did? I mean, I have my suspicions that someone was paid to endorse this movie, but other than that, I don't get it at all.
I wouldn't be surprised. Wasn't Mr. Beast paid to promote this?
Roseangelo
09-02-2023, 12:59 AM
I wouldn't be surprised. Wasn't Mr. Beast paid to promote this?
Oh, I'm sure more than one person was.
Too bad most threads are filled with toxic political posts from people who don't want to watch the movie and done let others discuss it so I guess I'll just post here since there's less of it. I watched it recently as well:
-Love the art style and the music. They nail it
-April is fine, mutants are fine. Still mad they gender/race bent/origin bent them but I mean at the end of the day it doesn't really matter in the movie, minor details really.
Love the banter between characters, they nailed it
-in general its a feel good movie and it succeeds at that
Baxter was great, I think they can say he didn't actually die though that would take away from his role in this movie. In that way I think you could also retcon that Superfly is indeed Baxter if they really wanted to.
I think Cynthia will be revealed to be Krang in the sequel.
Turtles in high school seems like a big no no but then again it's not the first continuity that people know the turtles exist and interact with them so I can live with it if it's handled well in the sequel. Which it might. They succeeded in making a good TMNT movie despite all the horrible decisions on paper. The movie didnt set my world on fire but I felt I enjoyed it quite a bit.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.