View Full Version : Look like Jason Aaron wants April to be "She-Hulk"
TheLabRat
03-06-2025, 09:05 PM
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/april-oneil-new-casey-jones-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-11/
https://mlpnk72yciwc.i.optimole.com/cqhiHLc.IIZS~2ef73/w:600/h:922/q:75/https://bleedingcool.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/TMNT2024-11_cov_C.jpg
Cowabung-Gal
03-06-2025, 09:26 PM
Looks like I quit that series just in time. Stopped collecting after #5
CyberCubed
03-06-2025, 09:28 PM
From the thread title I thought this meant April was going to get a bunch of muscles through a mutation and become a man-woman.
But her wearing Casey's mask/gear while he's in the hospital is fine by me. Like it doesn't even matter.
neatoman
03-06-2025, 10:23 PM
Right... This is stupid... Not nearly as stupid as making her a psychic half-utrom ninja though, or many of the other random things people have tried to pull. Wearing a mask is relatively acceptable.
Allio
03-06-2025, 11:54 PM
This is like bottom on the list of what has happened to the character. Honestly it feels like most writers don’t know what to do with the character after the initial set.
Coola Yagami
03-07-2025, 12:41 AM
I mean... she was Nobody for a while in the actual Mirage comics... which was weird because it was never explained where she ever got the skills to fight crime. I'm assuming since she was doing this short stint around the time she discovered she was a drawing, she was pretty much suicidal because 'oh well, I'm a drawing anyway'.
Zog The Magnificent
03-07-2025, 12:42 AM
Right... This is stupid... Not nearly as stupid as making her a psychic half-utrom ninja though, or many of the other random things people have tried to pull. Wearing a mask is relatively acceptable.
I think her becoming Nobody and then quitting immediately was stupider. But this one is right there with it.
ToTheNines
03-07-2025, 04:40 AM
Basically every April ever stinks, except for Archie. I’ll give Hoag a pass too, I guess.
And yeah this looks bad and dumb. I am STRUGGLING to hang on to this series at this point. Don’t know how much longer I can do it.
I mean I am glad its not woke politics in a ridiculous premise where the primary objective of finding an anti-mutagen is seemingly discouraged based on the ridiculous reactions to curing the albino turtle girl.
Exactly. This just seems like something they'd try that hasn't really been done before. Doesn't really stink of woke $#!(, although it doesn't matter to me at this point. I haven't bought a TMNT book since issue 50 of the original IDW run.
Zog The Magnificent
03-07-2025, 10:54 AM
Exactly. This just seems like something they'd try that hasn't really been done before. Doesn't really stink of woke $#!(, although it doesn't matter to me at this point. I haven't bought a TMNT book since issue 50 of the original IDW run.
I dunno, it still kind of fits the same template that I've been seeing in a lot of garbage modern media. Consider:
-Male Character is removed from the story.
-Female Character takes over a "mantle" that wasn't a mantle. (There are literally articles calling her the "New Casey Jones," as if that's a superhero identity and not just his name).
-Female Character is an amazing girl boss who needs no one and is way better than the previous male character because she's a woman, while usually bringing the writer on board to preach about something we don't care about.
Time will tell if that last step comes true or not. I very much hope that that's not where they go. But it happened in Star Wars, Star Trek, DC comics, Marvel Comics, the MCU, Doctor Who, and a bunch of other things. I wouldn't be surprised if that's the way it went here. The "flawless girl boss" is an annoying trope born from bad writing that kills stories, and this very much has the potential to turn into exactly that.
CyberCubed
03-07-2025, 11:07 AM
I don't understand why you guys are making a big deal out of this, IDW usually does changes like this with the characters just to do away with it over time.
1. Casey took over the Purple Dragons as their leader for awhile, then that was over with
2. April went back to working for Baxter Stockman again for awhile, then that was over with
3. Casey just recently was working for Karai and the Foot Clan for awhile, now that's over with
4. Alopex wore a green bandana with the Turtles that only lasted a few issues, then that was over with
April is wearing Casey's gear until he recovers in the hospital, what is the big deal?
Zog The Magnificent
03-07-2025, 11:24 AM
I don't understand why you guys are making a big deal out of this, IDW usually does changes like this with the characters just to do away with it over time.
1. Casey took over the Purple Dragons as their leader for awhile, then that was over with
2. April went back to working for Baxter Stockman again for awhile, then that was over with
3. Casey just recently was working for Karai and the Foot Clan for awhile, now that's over with
4. Alopex wore a green bandana with the Turtles that only lasted a few issues, then that was over with
April is wearing Casey's gear until he recovers in the hospital, what is the big deal?
In none of those examples did the character replace and assume the role of a different character at the expense of the original. They were all natural evolutions of the characters. The only one you could kind of argue was Casey replacing Hun as the leader of the dragons, but since they had a personal antagonistic relationship, a rise and fall narrative was appropriate.
April being a street level vigilante, with Casey's weapons and mask, is taking over his character niche. It's the same reason (well, one of many) why so many people (myself included) hate Jennika: she stole the plot relevance and story roles of other characters, while being worse at them.
I dunno, it still kind of fits the same template that I've been seeing in a lot of garbage modern media. Consider:
-Male Character is removed from the story.
-Female Character takes over a "mantle" that wasn't a mantle. (There are literally articles calling her the "New Casey Jones," as if that's a superhero identity and not just his name).
-Female Character is an amazing girl boss who needs no one and is way better than the previous male character because she's a woman, while usually bringing the writer on board to preach about something we don't care about.
Time will tell if that last step comes true or not. I very much hope that that's not where they go. But it happened in Star Wars, Star Trek, DC comics, Marvel Comics, the MCU, Doctor Who, and a bunch of other things. I wouldn't be surprised if that's the way it went here. The "flawless girl boss" is an annoying trope born from bad writing that kills stories, and this very much has the potential to turn into exactly that.
Right - all good points and understandably so given the years of woke $#!(. This is what they did with Quasar as well. The "mantle" was "Protector of the Universe", but the liberal mania simply stated "blonde-haired male bad" and then they invented the logic that the "Mantle" was "Quasar" and turned the character into a white-haired lesbian.
So right, the foundational earmarks of woke $#!( are there.
I don't understand why you guys are making a big deal out of this, IDW usually does changes like this with the characters just to do away with it over time.
1. Casey took over the Purple Dragons as their leader for awhile, then that was over with
2. April went back to working for Baxter Stockman again for awhile, then that was over with
3. Casey just recently was working for Karai and the Foot Clan for awhile, now that's over with
4. Alopex wore a green bandana with the Turtles that only lasted a few issues, then that was over with
April is wearing Casey's gear until he recovers in the hospital, what is the big deal?
Right - all good points and what I'm leaning too as well. This is what years of woke $#!( get you though - uncertainty and doubt.
Zog The Magnificent
03-07-2025, 01:23 PM
Right - all good points and what I'm leaning too as well. This is what years of woke $#!( get you though - uncertainty and doubt.
This is ultimately the problem I have with the stupidity of many modern creators: they have created doubt and skepticism where it didn't previously exist. Just about every trope can be done well in the hands of a skilled writer, though some require more skill than others. When they made Harvey Dent black in Batman, no one cared. When a woman was the main character is something more action oriented, no one cared. But now we have to wonder every time if it's a sincere attempt at a story, or yet another soapbox session from a preachy author, especially if it's something set in a prexisting property that they, in their hubris, want to "leave their mark on."
Andrew NDB
03-07-2025, 01:25 PM
I mean... she was Nobody for a while in the actual Mirage comics... which was weird because it was never explained where she ever got the skills to fight crime.
But then you have to ask where did Casey even get the skills to fight crime?
Zog The Magnificent
03-07-2025, 01:32 PM
But then you have to ask where did Casey even get the skills to fight crime?
You don't really have to ask that. He was presented to us as a tough guy who knew how to fight at the start of the story. He came into the story with that pre-established. April was presented as a science type, somewhat timid, very mothery, and with a tendency to just kind of go along with what was happening, until some of her later character development. For HER to suddenly whip out fighting skills, as well as the fact that she is already at a steep physical disadvantage compared to Casey from just being a woman, an explanation is required. Otherwise, it's just incongruous with her character.
This is ultimately the problem I have with the stupidity of many modern creators: they have created doubt and skepticism where it didn't previously exist. Just about every trope can be done well in the hands of a skilled writer, though some require more skill than others. When they made Harvey Dent black in Batman, no one cared. When a woman was the main character is something more action oriented, no one cared. But now we have to wonder every time if it's a sincere attempt at a story, or yet another soapbox session from a preachy author, especially if it's something set in a prexisting property that they, in their hubris, want to "leave their mark on."
Exactly. But the remnants of woke $#!( liberalism can't compute this - they just put it on whoever has the commentary as "seeing woke in everything". They're wrong, but honestly who would have thought otherwise but them?
But then you have to ask where did Casey even get the skills to fight crime?
Well on that note Casey was always basically just a street level thug fighting other street level thugs. In most ways a basic Foot Ninja should by all rights be able to take him down....
Enscripture
03-07-2025, 04:02 PM
Is Donatello boney and skinny now because he's "The Nerd" like 2012? lol
Coola Yagami
03-07-2025, 09:43 PM
I think in this case Donatello was actually malnourished. He's kind of insane so eating right probably wasn't top priority.
TheLabRat
03-07-2025, 10:25 PM
It feels like IDW can't make up their mind. Every time they hype up some "new" ideas, but never go further.
- Dark Leo and B&R break Donnie's spine was just some unsessery misery lit.
- Old Hob drop mutagen bomb, and we only get a small town version of Zootopia story, instead of Raccoon City crisis.
- They set up all some foreshadowing about an evil dragon god, but in the end, he just shows up for a bit and then die.
- Shredder get a redemption, but he mostly just a fairy godmother, leaving his Foot Clan's mess to others to deal with.
- IDW Raph has an intersting past that could explain his anger issues, and his just want to be a farmer. But until now, they never explore it, and still make Raph the typical hothead.
neatoman
03-07-2025, 10:38 PM
It feels like IDW can't make up their mind. Every time they hype up some "new" ideas, but never go further.
- Dark Leo and B&R break Donnie's spine was just some unsessery misery lit.
- Old Hob drop mutagen bomb, and we only get a small town version of Zootopia story, instead of Raccoon City crisis.
- They set up all some foreshadowing about an evil dragon god, but in the end, he just shows up for a bit and then die.
- Shredder get a redemption, but he mostly just a fairy godmother, leaving his Foot Clan's mess to others to deal with.
- IDW Raph has an intersting past that could explain his anger issues, and his just want to be a farmer. But until now, they never explore it, and still make Raph the typical hothead.
I kind of need to object here. Many of these did in fact last a while at least or occured years apart. The "next big change" is one of the unfortunate side-effects of how comics are often written to temporarily draw in new readers, remember when Doctor Octopus posed as Spider-Man for nearly two years? While it's not really all that pretty, it is how many comics are written, a lot of them just have brief shakeups, courses that change when the readers aren't responding well or sometimes new writers just decide to do their own thing. It's hardly a unique problem.
Though I must say, Mutant Town is an idea they should have mercy killed early on.
CyberCubed
03-08-2025, 12:32 AM
I find it weird people are overreacting to April wearing Casey's mask/gear in this thread. It's obviously a short-term thing till Casey recovers in the hospital. April wearing Casey's mask has never been done before and looks cool on the cover.
We literally saw Casey Jones in a Foot uniform working for Karai for the previous few years, did anyone think he would be a permanent member of the Foot? Of course not, and sure enough he left the Foot in the last Mutant Nation issue (which took place before the new #1). It was a short-term thing when Karai recruited him for a short time and let him go.
ticktack
03-08-2025, 01:17 AM
She can come up with her own fighting style. Utilise her abilities and find out what works for her best.
Where we start calculating and thinking about smb's chance to win. Ahhh yes she's a thin woman. A bigger and prepared one would have been a better option for combat, absolutely true. About being prepared, anyone starts with smth and it is hard and unknown esp for a beginner. Generally, I wouldn't like anyone to throw themselves into fights and dangerous situation.
She can use calculation in every hit, creativity and being unpredictable. And make up techniques that could make everybody surprised. From Karai and teen Casey she can take unpredictibility and actually being prepared with tools, because that can change a lot in combat. Also I advice to take physical-prone women vitamins, since it can take pleny energy and tire you, immediately making you ineffective, she could. Unless well fed woman, which is also possible.
Out of topic. I have 2 OCs. Brother and sister. Like Selever and Rasazy (about like Catra and Cassandra). Mine are named Guild and Talena. I was also thinking about changing Guild's gender into female. *shade coming* To make up for the 1st and 2nd generation princesses on media, where male executioners didn't let them be fuller characters and show their full potential. Where they were waiting around for external factors to be saved, a dude or smth. And they were harmless, safe and homely like tradwife types. 2nd gen were opinionated but never throw a punch and strangely turned into damsels-in-distress by some purely mumbo-jumbo-magic reason. yup.
hypered1
03-08-2025, 07:02 AM
I'd like to point out that everyone seems to be forgetting that Casey himself taught April self defence shortly after they first met way back at the very beginning of the series. She also took part in the combat during City Fall using Harold's tech.
But I guess I shouldn't be surprised that usual bunch of whiny bitches are kicking up a fuss over nothing.
Coola Yagami
03-08-2025, 09:05 AM
I'd like to point out that everyone seems to be forgetting that Casey himself taught April self defence shortly after they first met way back at the very beginning of the series. She also took part in the combat during City Fall using Harold's tech.
But I guess I shouldn't be surprised that usual bunch of whiny bitches are kicking up a fuss over nothing.
Basic self defense isn't suitable when you're purposely patrolling for fights.
Also are you confusing April for Shadow?
hypered1
03-08-2025, 09:37 AM
Basic self defense isn't suitable when you're purposely patrolling for fights.
Also are you confusing April for Shadow?
I was referring to IDW V1 issues 3 - 4 & 26 - 28. She also outsmarted a rock soldier and incapacitated Dr. Miller (when they fought over the book in the bar, Jenny killed him in the car later) in the April Micro and Secret History respectively.
She also fought Kitsune with magic in issue 60.
The point being that IDW's April has never been a 'helpless little girl' or something for meatheads just ogle over.
Zog The Magnificent
03-08-2025, 12:01 PM
I was referring to IDW V1 issues 3 - 4 & 26 - 28. She also outsmarted a rock soldier and incapacitated Dr. Miller (when they fought over the book in the bar, Jenny killed him in the car later) in the April Micro and Secret History respectively.
She also fought Kitsune with magic in issue 60.
The point being that IDW's April has never been a 'helpless little girl' or something for meatheads just ogle over.
No one is saying she's helpless. But she's NOT a street fighter. She never has been. Her skills and contributions lie in other areas. And above all, she should NOT be taking Casey's role. If they wanted to have her get ninja training like so many other versions, giver her her own style, maybe even give her a "superhero" identity like Angel has with Nobody? Fine. But giving her Casey's stuff, and Casey's mask, and having her be "the new Casey Jones" is stupid, and comes at the expense of a preestablished character. You can do these kind of changes without it being at the expense of another. This way here is dumb.
ticktack
03-08-2025, 12:38 PM
She does practice. What's the problem. So many women of superhero genre are thrown into obscurity and shade, while males are allowed to have stories and character development. Simply, you don't need women to stay housewives forever and stay static especially when comic books are allowed to get experimental and have twists in approaches and stories. Casey isn't robbed of legacy or anything. His daughters can run around cosplaying his vigilante look but not April, for example. Casey has also been changing identities, being a purple dragon leader or foot recruit.
ticktack
03-08-2025, 12:39 PM
Happy March the 8th.
ticktack
03-08-2025, 01:55 PM
https://64.media.tumblr.com/e707e9220cbceeda92948c57f1bf6e13/e3a3d5bb6cba9a5b-30/s1280x1920/f5ad3ebdea07c0aba4aee1ab1e93ab6a9bd18381.jpg
Hey, look, the She-Hulk.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.