View Full Version : Volume 4 timeline question
ToTheNines
04-10-2025, 01:57 PM
Very regretfully, I sold my Vol. 4 issues about 5 years ago. I wanted to offload them before any reprints devalued them, but now it looks like we may never see them reprinted. Oh well.
Anyway, since I can't look this up, I have a question: When #12 picks up after the gap following Splinter's funeral, it must be early November since Tales #39 (a Halloween issue) takes place during that time.
So if #12 is early November, is there any significant break in the narrative to allow for Christmas/Winter to pass and put the book in 2003? I don't have a great recollection of the back half of the story, but most issues pretty much ran right into the next all the way up to #32, if I remember correctly.
I know this is autistic minutia and doesn't really matter, but can anyone advise?
Zog The Magnificent
04-10-2025, 05:08 PM
Very regretfully, I sold my Vol. 4 issues about 5 years ago. I wanted to offload them before any reprints devalued them, but now it looks like we may never see them reprinted. Oh well.
Anyway, since I can't look this up, I have a question: When #12 picks up after the gap following Splinter's funeral, it must be early November since Tales #39 (a Halloween issue) takes place during that time.
So if #12 is early November, is there any significant break in the narrative to allow for Christmas/Winter to pass and put the book in 2003? I don't have a great recollection of the back half of the story, but most issues pretty much ran right into the next all the way up to #32, if I remember correctly.
I know this is autistic minutia and doesn't really matter, but can anyone advise?
As far as I can tell, there really isn't. 13-20 or so definitely take place over the course of a few days, which can be measured from Mikey's time with Seri, and everything else proceeds so incrementally that it doesn't seem that any time passes. The most you get is when April leaves on her road trip, and by the time she comes back I think you could maybe argue that, at most, a month had passed. And she leaves in #23 and makes it back in #31, so that could maybe push you through the end of the year.
But everything else moves so slowly, with just about every issue consisting of long conversations and the occasional fight scene. It's muddied by the fact that some plot lines, like Mikey going from war prisoner to murderous commando, which seems like it should take a really long time, also seem to only take place in a few days. When just about every issue moves each subplot by only 4-8 pages, which then take years in real time to release, it kind of warps the perception of time. But based on what actually happens in the back half, It seems like it's over the course of a week or two, a month at most, which I guess would get you to December.
Andrew NDB
04-10-2025, 05:24 PM
I wish I'd have had the foresight to buy up a bunch of extra copies of those last 3 or 4 Vol. 4 issues to now sell. I could put my kids through college with that.
Zog The Magnificent
04-10-2025, 07:05 PM
I wish I'd have had the foresight to buy up a bunch of extra copies of those last 3 or 4 Vol. 4 issues to now sell. I could put my kids through college with that.
I wish I'd known about Mirage TMNT at all at the time. I still haven't been able to get a copy of #29, 30, or 32. Though somehow I got #31. Someone sold it for cheap a while ago. But at this point, I'll likely never have a copy without first becoming exceedingly wealthy, which I don't see happening.
CyberCubed
04-10-2025, 10:33 PM
I still have all those last issues of Vol. 4, I remember thinking Mirage charging $10 for a single issue was insane when it came out...little did I know at the time how much they would be worth years later. :lol:
And the funny thing is it was available to order for YEARS. Anyone could have ordered themselves like 10 copies of those final issues and gotten them. Then they all disappeared. We're really all kicking ourselves for not ordering extra copies when we had the chance.
I do suspect IDW will collect Vol. 4 eventually, but until then I can't part with them. Do they still go for close to $1000 each or did they go down since then?
Zog The Magnificent
04-10-2025, 11:21 PM
Routinely 800 up to a couple thousand on Ebay, and showing no signs of ever going down.
CyberCubed
04-10-2025, 11:29 PM
Well one day mine will go there...but not anytime soon.
I need guarantee IDW will reprint the series before I sell.
Andrew NDB
04-10-2025, 11:30 PM
Well one day mine will go there...
Why? You don't even need the money.
CyberCubed
04-10-2025, 11:41 PM
Why? You don't even need the money.
Well more money is always good, even if I don't need it now. Also as I've gotten older once collections come out I realize I don't need the single issues anymore, and IDW's more recent collections have gotten better (keeping black and white for Vol.1 and Tales, keeping Vol. 2's original coloring), so if they ever do Vol. 4 it'll be in black and white as well.
The only thing you really lose is the old letters pages, which are fun to read for nostalgic value but not really that important. The collections keep the covers and all pages.
But so far Vol. 4 isn't confirmed to ever be happening at IDW, so I'm not going to sell anytime soon unless we get a hint its coming. I think they're going to re-release Image again first as they never released it in black and white yet.
ToTheNines
04-11-2025, 04:00 AM
As far as I can tell, there really isn't. 13-20 or so definitely take place over the course of a few days, which can be measured from Mikey's time with Seri, and everything else proceeds so incrementally that it doesn't seem that any time passes. The most you get is when April leaves on her road trip, and by the time she comes back I think you could maybe argue that, at most, a month had passed. And she leaves in #23 and makes it back in #31, so that could maybe push you through the end of the year.
But everything else moves so slowly, with just about every issue consisting of long conversations and the occasional fight scene. It's muddied by the fact that some plot lines, like Mikey going from war prisoner to murderous commando, which seems like it should take a really long time, also seem to only take place in a few days. When just about every issue moves each subplot by only 4-8 pages, which then take years in real time to release, it kind of warps the perception of time. But based on what actually happens in the back half, It seems like it's over the course of a week or two, a month at most, which I guess would get you to December.
Awesome, thank you for confirming!
I wish I'd have had the foresight to buy up a bunch of extra copies of those last 3 or 4 Vol. 4 issues to now sell. I could put my kids through college with that.
Dude, seriously. I started collecting in like 2006, and for about 5 years the same damn issues of Volume 4 would sit there at each of the local shops I visited. Never even crossed my mind that it might be wise to scoop them up.
Then with those later direct issues… my instinct was to buy one or two extra because I figured they’d be worth about $100 someday LMAO!
But at the time $10 plus shipping seemed so ridiculous that I said **** it. Dummy.
I wish I'd known about Mirage TMNT at all at the time. I still haven't been able to get a copy of #29, 30, or 32. Though somehow I got #31. Someone sold it for cheap a while ago. But at this point, I'll likely never have a copy without first becoming exceedingly wealthy, which I don't see happening.
That’s basically what I told myself when I sold mine. Foolishly hopeful that someday I would have Boomer money to blow on buying my collection back. Or at the very least, that IDW would reprint.
Getting scared that neither will happen, at this point.
Roseangelo
04-11-2025, 12:00 PM
I've honestly been considering selling these issues. I hate this series and don't think I care about being "complete" as much anymore. We'll see.
ToTheNines
04-11-2025, 12:11 PM
I've honestly been considering selling these issues. I hate this series and don't think I care about being "complete" as much anymore. We'll see.
Am I making this up, or do I recall Peter telling you off for having some simple critiques in the lettercol of one of the early issues?
Coola Yagami
04-11-2025, 12:38 PM
This reminds me of the time an old comic book shop told me about how rare and how valuable the classic Mirage comics were (and this was before IDW started making them, this was still mid-Tales of the TMNT Vol2 era).
He basically told me if I ever ran into a Mirage TMNT comic in the wild, like at a yard sale or so, you know where it's just older folks getting rid of their kids comic books without knowing the value, to act as normal and chill as possible and just buy as if you were buying a regular book. Don't act as if you're getting a hundred dollar comic for ten bucks.
It's all something any self-respecting comic collector would already know, but I did nod politely and listen along as if he was telling me the secret of life itself. Though to be fair, finding a copy of Mirage TMNT # 1 first printing in mint condition and buying if off some old lady for a few bucks might be considered the secret of life to many people here.
Andrew NDB
04-11-2025, 12:51 PM
I still remember around 1999-2000 there was a copy of TMNT #1, first print at my local comic store for $300. I'd always look at it and marvel at it, and wonder about the day when I'd have an extra $300 to buy it.
CyberCubed
04-11-2025, 02:29 PM
Checked ebay and someone is selling Vol 4 #32 and it's up to $700 at the moment. It has 25 watchers so its bound to sell for a lot more:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/176940784420?_skw=ninja+turtles+volume+4+issue+30&itmmeta=01JRK54WWFXYMFWP8D7SVTY85S&hash=item29327e1b24:g:fbIAAeSwc3tn21Ek&itmprp=enc%3AAQAKAAAA4FkggFvd1GGDu0w3yXCmi1exB34zH KhJrspswgG9Pz%2FhGMkhnhdjw5I0YQubfCQ8NNikSwlcH5O%2 BLO%2B5yEmpz3nxHacybRCwi1Inh6DvgBPd7vsWN6BqLPq2Ppa k01lihRhDnXi%2FmDoalzo%2BshxDc1arolx1MfeYmSIjzfx1W k4iaCrJFAQPuPknha%2FZcqK2sXBqcM58RAPuaN0%2BPsIDAJb nPCUcbOH%2Bj%2Fz3L9pvTgf0FE0lf%2FRLznLsKyL2pOVC3Kt 8A85bsTAq%2F8xlAiFPBmGoCPJpe4ZY6pLjRrPxqrUM%7Ctkp% 3ABk9SR7DOk-XEZQ
Seems a little low, but it's not graded or anything. Maybe in the next few years I'll put mine up. Someone needs to ask IDW when their Vol. 4 collection is coming though.
Zog The Magnificent
04-11-2025, 05:14 PM
Besides the collecting itself (which IS fun), and the fact that I just like single issuse, the Letter Column is for me the biggest reason why I try to go after original issues, in any comic, whenever I can. I love reading the letters columns. It's the whole reason I'm buying the Walking Dead Deluxe; it comes with the original letters.
Trades are objectively cheaper, higher quality, and more space efficient than single issues. But that doesn't mean I still won't be going out of my way to find every single issue of almost every series I read. (Though modern series don't have them as much, so you don't miss much getting trades, beyond the simple pleasure of having a run of comics).
I probably won't be able to get Vol. 1 or those last vol. 4 issues, but I'm still holding out hope for the Vol. 2 singles, the first 25 issues of Tales, and Tales #70. And honestly? Vol. 4 too, because if there's anything I've learned, it's that if you wait long enough, eventually everything you want to buy will be put up for sale by someone for a reasonable enough price. It's all a waiting game, and I can be very persistent.
ToTheNines
04-12-2025, 04:07 AM
Besides the collecting itself (which IS fun)
Definitely used to be. Nowadays the shops don’t hold on to their inventory for too long, so the back issue bins aren’t what they used to be.
the Letter Column is for me the biggest reason why I try to go after original issues, in any comic, whenever I can. I love reading the letters columns.
Agreed. There’s also unique pinups sometimes, nostalgic ads, interesting opening blurbs from the editor.
A unique one I just remembered: there was an issue of TMNT Volume 4 with a legitimately challenging crossword puzzle. I got all but two answers. I actually filled it in the book lol, so someone out there has a very rare comic book with my atrocious handwriting in it.
It's the whole reason I'm buying the Walking Dead Deluxe; it comes with the original letters.
That’s cool, I didn’t know that. I sold my Walking Dead collection years ago as well, but I have at least one letter that got printed. Was later in the run, definitely post-150.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.