View Full Version : The Roger Corman movie
neatoman
05-23-2025, 08:45 AM
So if that thing had actually been made, what do you think the reputation of TMNT would have been? In case you don't know, before the 1990 movie was pitched Roger Corman came with his own idea, which was to have comedians like Billy Crystal portray the Turtles not with animatronic masks but just facepaint. I think it might even have been pitched before the FW cartoon but I can't find a source on that.
There is always some auteur bull $#!( from some "thespian" clown who thinks they are smarter than the source material.
The first rumblings of Iron Man cast Tom Cruise in a clear plexi helmet so you could see his face. Hollywood history is replete with that kind of thinking.
So to answer your question, I think the reputation would have been "failed". Totally.
neatoman
05-23-2025, 09:12 AM
There is always some auteur bull $#!( from some "thespian" clown who thinks they are smarter than the source material.
The first rumblings of Iron Man cast Tom Cruise in a clear plexi helmet so you could see his face. Hollywood history is replete with that kind of thinking.
So to answer your question, I think the reputation would have been "failed". Totally.
Auteur? Roger Corman? There are many instances where that is the correct assumption but Corman could hardly be described as an "auteur", in this case it was probably just a budget decision or least the idea that the actors' faces need to be shown for the sake of marketing.
Auteur? Roger Corman? There are many instances where that is the correct assumption but Corman could hardly be described as an "auteur", in this case it was probably just a budget decision or least the idea that the actors' faces need to be shown for the sake of marketing.
That's actually how most "auteur" creators work, dude. It's much the same as the "boutique toy" conversation. It's the illusion of "complete and utter quality". In film that "complete and utter quality" is the "artistic statement" or "getting it done". It's all the same. :lol:
Showing the actor's faces for the sake of marketing implies "smarter than the source material". Auteur. In your example you're defending it (your word choice implies defense: 'probably just a budget decision"), but it's still a "smarter than the source material" line of thought.
neatoman
05-23-2025, 03:12 PM
That's actually how most "auteur" creators work, dude. It's much the same as the "boutique toy" conversation. It's the illusion of "complete and utter quality". In film that "complete and utter quality" is the "artistic statement" or "getting it done". It's all the same. :lol:
Showing the actor's faces for the sake of marketing implies "smarter than the source material". Auteur. In your example you're defending it (your word choice implies defense: 'probably just a budget decision"), but it's still a "smarter than the source material" line of thought.
Well I'm not defending the idea of splashing green makeup on Billy Crystal and calling it Donatello the Ninja Turtle as a good idea (or even acceptable one), it just sounds stupid no matter what. I think there's a clear difference between "The face paint shall represent the way society bla bla bla bla and that's why this is so much better than taking the source material at face value" and "Let's just do face paint instead of animatronics to cut corners" or "This thing gotta make money, let's make sure the stars' faces can be seen so people know it's them".
Again no, I don't really think I am defending this stupid idea, it's just that I don't imagine the idea was "we're better" as much as it was "we don't give a damn and just want money".
Again no, I don't really think I am defending this stupid idea, it's just that I don't imagine the idea was "we're better" as much as it was "we don't give a damn and just want money".
Well I admit that my angle there was the use of "Auteur" as a representation of "ego" in filmmaking, but that's not such a stretch - I think that's part of it. Found this on my newsfeed here and thought this was a nice way to illustrate it:
Did Team America Mark the Moment Quentin Tarantino Became an Auteur? (https://nofilmschool.com/quentin-tarantino-team-america)
Filmmakers become auteurs by making a lot of original movies and putting their voice into them. They add so much of themselves into the movie that you can identify who directed the work by watching just a few scenes.
That's a great way for them to encapsulate that. And to point - that can happen because of vision (Spielberg) or even ego (arguably Tarantino), or both.
So when it comes to Corman? I imagine, "Oh yeah I can churn that out for next to nothing and this is how..." e.g., "smarter than the source material".
ToTheNines
05-24-2025, 06:26 AM
So if that thing had actually been made, what do you think the reputation of TMNT would have been? In case you don't know, before the 1990 movie was pitched Roger Corman came with his own idea, which was to have comedians like Billy Crystal portray the Turtles not with animatronic masks but just facepaint. I think it might even have been pitched before the FW cartoon but I can't find a source on that.
I’m pretty sure this was around 1987-88, iirc.
Someone should make a short film like this as a joke while Billy Crystal is still alive. Who else was on the list? Sam Kinison for sure.
There is always some auteur bull $#!( from some "thespian" clown who thinks they are smarter than the source material.
The first rumblings of Iron Man cast Tom Cruise in a clear plexi helmet so you could see his face. Hollywood history is replete with that kind of thinking.
So to answer your question, I think the reputation would have been "failed". Totally.
Tom Cruise would have been fine in role, as hard as it is to imagine anyone other than Downey doing it. Never knew about the clear helmet though. That’s pretty funny.
neatoman
05-24-2025, 12:23 PM
I’m pretty sure this was around 1987-88, iirc.
That's... An unfortunate timespan for trying to determine if this was pitched before or after the FW show aired. If it's 87 then it was probably pitched before it came out (though likely during the production of season 1) but if it was 88 then it would have been after.
d_osborn
05-24-2025, 03:23 PM
The idea of a Roger Corman TMNT film is mutated balderdash.
Roger Corman sold New World Pictures in 1983, well before New World pitched Eastman & Laird their wild TMNT adaptation. I'd love to read the treatment. Topless nuts roller skating with uzis is nuts. It sounds like a discarded idea from the first NES TMNT game, lol.
Andrew NDB
05-24-2025, 03:35 PM
Honestly I'd like to travel to the alternate timeline where this movie happened and watch it. But just for a visit.
The Great Saiyaman
05-24-2025, 04:45 PM
There is always some auteur bull $#!( from some "thespian" clown who thinks they are smarter than the source material.
The first rumblings of Iron Man cast Tom Cruise in a clear plexi helmet so you could see his face. Hollywood history is replete with that kind of thinking.
So to answer your question, I think the reputation would have been "failed". Totally.
Heh, that reminds my of all those fighter pilot movies from the eighties (Such as "Top Gun") where as soon as the pilots take to the skies, they would flip up the helmet visor and take the breathing mask off.
Which is something TRUE fighter pilots NEVER do, but it's so they can show their faces.
Andrew NDB
05-24-2025, 06:02 PM
It only super bothered me in Spider-Man 3. We finally get full-on Venom and they keep showing Topher's face every 3 seconds. Why?
Oh ya. Spider-man 3 was like - the poster child example of that.
The Great Saiyaman
05-25-2025, 03:38 AM
It only super bothered me in Spider-Man 3. We finally get full-on Venom and they keep showing Topher's face every 3 seconds. Why?
I wouldn't say "Full on Venom" because...
https://media.titanbooks.com/catalog/products/VenomFactor.jpg
Yeah, Todd McFarlane said that the biggest disappointment with Venom in Spider-man 3, was that he wasn't big. Telling the director, "You've got Venom all wrong, he's too skinny, he should be almost as huge as the Hulk."
And having mentioned McFarlane... It might be just me, but I think that a toothy grin instead of that slimy, drooling monster mouth, is way more creepy and disturbing.
https://www.cnet.com/a/img/resize/8eeeb2d857755c3b4dcafa7c3641fa70b6e89970/hub/2021/12/09/3c3071dc-ff77-4685-8ee5-2e33e3711732/venom-in-asm-299.jpg?auto=webp&width=768
Andrew NDB
05-25-2025, 04:40 AM
I'm just saying, at that point in Spider-Man 3 I was fully ready and psyched to see Venom. And just Venom. But they just kept doing that weird face warp to show Topher. And who tf was even Topher then? It wasn't like he was RBJ circa Avengers 1. Why did we NEED that? For what purpose?
neatoman
05-25-2025, 06:25 AM
... Was Topher Grace ever a big enough box office draw to justify it from a marketing standpoint?
... Was Topher Grace ever a big enough box office draw to justify it from a marketing standpoint?
I think there was that window of time where they felt that he might be.... he had just come off the two Ocean's 11 flicks and before that he was big on That 70's Show.
I also think they felt that he'd be a "dark side foil" to Peter because he was sort of a match for Tobey McGuire when in fact they should have put a big bully actor into Brock's shoes as opposed to a whiny b!t(h character.
But hey... this is the same Hollywood that wanted Iron Man in a clear plastic helmet to see his face and has spent ten years delivering woke content that no one really wants.
Mr. Entertainment
07-21-2025, 04:00 PM
Turtles that looked more like the C.H.U.D. monsters rather than humanoid animals.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.