PDA

View Full Version : TMNT II: The Secret of the Ooze... what went wrong?


Andrew NDB
08-24-2025, 11:18 PM
I'm sure we all loved the movie as kids (I know I did) but we can't look back and objectively say the second movie wasn't a RADICAL departure from the tone and quality of the first movie. I can think of the short list of main reasons why it stunk, and apparently torpedoed the movie franchise at that point (TMNT 3 only received a small budget and went out with an embarrassing whimper).

* Lack of time. They pumped this movie out in less than a year from when the first movie came out! Which is wild to me for a variety of reasons. I can't imagine on a script level they even had much time to refine things.

* It doesn't really sound like Eastman and Laird had veto power or really any creative control on this movie, for some reason or another (perhaps some kind of studio option in the original deal to get the first movie made they signed). I remember reading about Laird (or was it Eastman?) demanding that Casey Jones be in the movie but totally being ignored. This seems like a very different deal than when Kevin and Peter were continually saying "NO" to the horrible TMNT 4 script versions later on.

* Kowtowing to "parents groups." i.e., let's have the Turtles not use their weapons at all now and let's just have a slapstick/sight gag bonanza now. In a movie about ninjas. Yeesh.

* Badly used ideas. The crux of the movie is "I want to know where I came from" from the Turtles, but there really isn't any sort of catharsis or big revelations at all. They pretty much already knew everything they learn in this movie minus the name of the company behind it.

CyberCubed
08-25-2025, 06:21 AM
I mean Peter Laird did have some power, we know Bebop/Rocksteady were originally planned for the film but he vetoed it and that's the reason Rahzar/Tokka exist. I think he even commented on this as "recently" as one of the Vol. 4 letter pages but I don't remember which issue.

The movie was definitely made to be "lighter" for kids, the sense of darkness the first movie had was toned down entirely. I do think they set out what they wanted to do with the movie though, so in that way, it was a huge success. Ernie Reyes Jr. was fun, David Warner also really elevated that role where any other actor as Prof. Jordan Perry would have fell flat, even as a kid I thought David Warner's voice and acting was so cool and different than what I was used to in TMNT. Seeing Tatsu back was nice too. I also really liked seeing the inside of the Foot compound and showing how they pick up new recruits from NYC.

The Turtles costumes were very good, and I really did like April's new actress. As a kid I didn't even know the original April was replaced, I thought it was the same person. I do miss Casey Jones though.

But yeah, you can tell this was a kids movie. Super Shredder, more jokes, the fights were less serious and more "fun," so it was what it was.

frank_one
08-25-2025, 07:11 AM
The first movie did well but the studio thought they could do even better with a new movie more similar to the cartoon. Also, Steve Barron was the one pushing for a more serious tone and the use of the Mirage comics as the main source. Steve wasn't there during the second movie development.

Bran The Man
08-25-2025, 09:23 AM
Sometimes I feel like Secret of the Ooze was originally supposed to introduce Baxter Stockman, Bebop and Rocksteady, but for whatever reason, we got characters similar to them like Dr. Jordan Perry, Tokka and Rahzar.


I look at TMNT 2: Out of the Shadows and I'm like, "THAT'S what Secret of the Ooze SHOULD'VE been!"


EDIT: That's what I get for not reading. I never knew Peter Laird vetoed Bebop and Rocksteady!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
08-25-2025, 09:27 AM
* Badly used ideas. The crux of the movie is "I want to know where I came from" from the Turtles, but there really isn't any sort of catharsis or big revelations at all. They pretty much already knew everything they learn in this movie minus the name of the company behind it.

That's another reason to include TCRI and the Utroms.

d_osborn
08-25-2025, 10:52 AM
Golden Harvest removing Steve Barron and John Fenner is really what did it, imo. Finger pointed squarely at the producers for firing the OG crew, messing with the tone, no weapons, and crazy tight schedule. All of the above considered, it's a fun movie!

I have Laird's notes on the scripts and dailies for Secret of the Ooze. They were really trying to reign it in. My guess is that Golden Harvest and New Line had a schedule locked into place. E&L probably couldn't put their collective feet down in time without really hosing the (wildly lucrative) plan.

I'm not privy to the details of their approval rights. From what I can tell, it seems they didn't have much control after story treatment approvals. Eastman and Laird personally penned the treatment to the unproduced TMNT 4.

I remember reading about Laird (or was it Eastman?) demanding that Casey Jones be in the movie but totally being ignored. This seems like a very different deal than when Kevin and Peter were continually saying "NO" to the horrible TMNT 4 script versions later on.

I believe Casey was in the first draft of Langen's script. The Shellquel!

Leonardo87
08-26-2025, 02:35 PM
Golden Harvest removing Steve Barron and John Fenner is really what did it, imo. Finger pointed squarely at the producers for firing the OG crew, messing with the tone, no weapons, and crazy tight schedule. All of the above considered, it's a fun movie!

I have Laird's notes on the scripts and dailies for Secret of the Ooze. They were really trying to reign it in. My guess is that Golden Harvest and New Line had a schedule locked into place. E&L probably couldn't put their collective feet down in time without really hosing the (wildly lucrative) plan.

I'm not privy to the details of their approval rights. From what I can tell, it seems they didn't have much control after story treatment approvals. Eastman and Laird personally penned the treatment to the unproduced TMNT 4.


I believe Casey was in the first draft of Langen's script. The Shellquel!

Was there any differences in the dailies from Ooze? I'm very excited to see the rest from the Doc crew of 1990.

Daytona
08-26-2025, 04:40 PM
I do like Secret of the Ooze against all odds. It’s probably the only “goofy” version of TMNT I can sit down and enjoy.

Some would say it’s all “goofy”, but you know what I mean.

I suppose it’s because the actors still do a good job of portraying well established versions of the characters even if the script gives them less to do. It’s a major disappointment as a sequel but I don’t mind spending time around these versions of the characters. A bit like modern Simpsons.

Mr. Entertainment
09-03-2025, 07:05 PM
1. Not achieving a balance between the source material and cartoon elements like the first one did.

2. Trying to bring Shredder back when they should've went with Baxter Stockman as the villain, maybe some Foot remnants on the side.

3. Missing Elias Koteas as Casey Jones.

4. Speaking of Baxter, I don't really like when films try to connect this character with that character that are completely unsevered in the source material (thinking recent Spider-Man adaptations connecting Otto and Norman together), but I think if we're going to stick to the title of the picture, Stockman could've been an employee at TGRI in charge of the robotics division there.

To be honest, without April as Baxter's assistant, I struggle of a way to make him relevant throughout the whole film, so maybe have a secondary antagonist in there to spice things up. Possibly Tatsu taking over the reigns of the Foot and get his revenge on the Turtles and Splinter.

Mirror image
09-04-2025, 08:43 PM
* It doesn't really sound like Eastman and Laird had veto power or really any creative control on this movie, for some reason or another (perhaps some kind of studio option in the original deal to get the first movie made they signed). I remember reading about Laird (or was it Eastman?) demanding that Casey Jones be in the movie but totally being ignored. This seems like a very different deal than when Kevin and Peter were continually saying "NO" to the horrible TMNT 4 script versions later on.


As much as I respekt Eastman and Laird(especially Eastman) for giving us the turtles I will always disagree with their position that seems to be that Casey Jones is somehow essential to the turtles experience when Casey to me just seemed like the one member of the group(aside from master Splinter) who seemed a to be perhaps a bit more morally ambigious than the others. But maybe that is precisely because he did not show up in the second film, which as a kid was my only exposure to the turtles aside from the toys or because as far as the original source material is concerned only one of the stories from that book that I really hold in that high regard has Casey in it.

Mad Dog McMutt
09-05-2025, 03:17 AM
What I don't get is how in almost every version of the Ninja Turtles the creators put Casey Jones on the same level of fighting skills as the turtles. They are trained ninjas who almost do nothing but train and he is just a Vigilante who beats up people with sports equipment. I got no problem with Casey being stronger than most, but I think that putting him on the same level of the turtles is always a mistake, especially in the 2012 version. I don't get how he is capable of beating up Raph in the first movie. Maybe, I should have posted this in the controversial opinion thread.

Mirror image
09-05-2025, 10:15 AM
What I don't get is how in almost every version of the Ninja Turtles the creators put Casey Jones on the same level of fighting skills as the turtles. They are trained ninjas who almost do nothing but train and he is just a Vigilante who beats up people with sports equipment. I got no problem with Casey being stronger than most, but I think that putting him on the same level of the turtles is always a mistake, especially in the 2012 version. I don't get how he is capable of beating up Raph in the first movie. Maybe, I should have posted this in the controversial opinion thread.

The 2003 version was perhaps the only time when the writters thought of the fact that a retired bouncer who watched to many action flicks should not be on the same level as mutated reptiles with hard shells who have trained all their life to be the best at martial arts. As he is was often showed as the least cabapble when teaming up with the turtles.

Then again that show was produced by Peter Laird who unlike his creator Kevin Eastman does not show as much favoritism towards Casey Jones.

LeotheLateBloomer
09-08-2025, 06:12 PM
What went wrong? The same thing situation with Batman Returns to Batman Forever. Overprotective parents getting their panties in a twist and demanded for an "age-appropriate" sequel.

Andrew NDB
09-08-2025, 08:05 PM
Overprotective parents getting their panties in a twist and demanded for an "age-appropriate" sequel.

* Studios listening.

Autbot_Benz
09-08-2025, 09:10 PM
What went wrong? The same thing situation with Batman Returns to Batman Forever. Overprotective parents getting their panties in a twist and demanded for an "age-appropriate" sequel.

Exactly turtles 1 was Batman Returns SOTO was Batman Forever and Turtles 3 was Batman and Robin

Bran The Man
09-09-2025, 08:34 AM
And that was the thing I never understood.

As a parent, who takes their child/children to go see a movie called "Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles" and expects there to be little violence or weapon use?

SOTO and Batman Forever are still fun watches because it hadn't gotten COMPLETELY bad yet, but Turtles III and Batman & Robin do not have great replay value.

Mirror image
09-09-2025, 10:27 AM
And that was the thing I never understood.

As a parent, who takes their child/children to go see a movie called "Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles" and expects there to be little violence or weapon use?

SOTO and Batman Forever are still fun watches because it hadn't gotten COMPLETELY bad yet, but Turtles III and Batman & Robin do not have great replay value.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3 still has a better story than both Batman and Robin and SOTO. probably for the better that their never was a 4th movie because going by what the Next Mutation show turned out to be I think the 4th movie would have been the worst film out of all of them.

IMJ
09-09-2025, 02:35 PM
Ninja Turtles III made absolutely no sense.

BAM! Time travel. For some reason.

Mirror image
09-09-2025, 10:36 PM
Ninja Turtles III made absolutely no sense.

BAM! Time travel. For some reason.

Thanks for sumening up pretty much half the greatest momments in TMNT history be it in video games, cartoons, and comic books including the original ones from the Mirage's days.

jestergoblin
09-12-2025, 12:57 PM
The oral history on this movie is fantastic https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/what-went-wrong-with-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-2-secret-of-the-ooze/

Like Andrew said, it's bonkers this movie got made in less than a year.

oldmanwinters
09-12-2025, 01:46 PM
Like Andrew said, it's bonkers this movie got made in less than a year.

That might be the most impressive and unbelievable thing about the movie. The fact that it isn't terrible but actually looks great and is a lot of memorable fun is kinda the icing on the cake!

IF they had waited the typical 3-4 years for a sequel, maybe they would have found a way to work in Utroms/Krang and some of the outer-space thematic elements.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-15-2025, 11:12 AM
IF they had waited the typical 3-4 years for a sequel, maybe they would have found a way to work in Utroms/Krang and some of the outer-space thematic elements.

Sadly, there wasn't much time for that. Turtlemania had kicked in, and everyone just screamed for more! more! more! now! now! now!