PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #11 preview and discussion


hypered1
08-27-2025, 07:49 AM
https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_01-min.jpg?resize=999%2C1536&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_02-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_03-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_04-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_05-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_06-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/aiptcomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/TMNT2024-11_Page_07-min.jpg?w=750&ssl=1

ToTheNines
08-27-2025, 08:45 AM
lol… this is somehow getting even stupider. Amazing.

Such a waste of great art. Will definitely not miss Aaron.

hypered1
08-27-2025, 09:23 AM
Only just found out this issue has been pushed back to next week.

Coola Yagami
08-27-2025, 09:27 AM
It's so weird seeing the Turtles treated as somewhat regular people. I know the story needs to progress and sooner or later some incarnations do reach the status of 'the Turtles no longer have to hide in the shadows and can walk around like regular people', but I always do miss when they had to hide in the shadows.

Kinda like whenever the sewer lair gets destroyed or compromised and the turtles have to hide in churches, abandoned train stations or water towers. I eventually miss when they had their sewer lair.

GameCobra
08-27-2025, 09:48 AM
I just find it odd that New York in general is backing up the turtles the way they are. Feels more like a Marvel move in my opinion,lol.

It's so weird seeing the Turtles treated as somewhat regular people. I know the story needs to progress and sooner or later some incarnations do reach the status of 'the Turtles no longer have to hide in the shadows and can walk around like regular people', but I always do miss when they had to hide in the shadows.

Kinda like whenever the sewer lair gets destroyed or compromised and the turtles have to hide in churches, abandoned train stations or water towers. I eventually miss when they had their sewer lair.

I find i'm always getting attached to their new homes, but the sewers and the Splinter Dojo seem to be the two that stand out the most for me. Mainly because the difference is bigger than night and day. I was actually hoping when they got the dojo that they would finally stop abandoning their homes for a change, but I also sadly knew better. Yeesh.

TheLabRat
08-27-2025, 10:20 AM
I really don't like what they did to Donnie. Turned him into a crazy hippie.

It's so weird seeing the Turtles treated as somewhat regular people. I know the story needs to progress and sooner or later some incarnations do reach the status of 'the Turtles no longer have to hide in the shadows and can walk around like regular people', but I always do miss when they had to hide in the shadows.

Kinda like whenever the sewer lair gets destroyed or compromised and the turtles have to hide in churches, abandoned train stations or water towers. I eventually miss when they had their sewer lair.

Maybe one day they can go to Dimension X and start a new life. They have no obligation to spend their lives protecting New York.

CyberCubed
08-27-2025, 12:49 PM
This is Jason Aaron's second to last issue, most of his run honestly just felt like padding and stalling to whatever the next writer does with Karai. Also does Hale remind anyone else of a lamer version of The Penguin from Batman?

Dancefloran
08-27-2025, 01:31 PM
It's so weird seeing the Turtles treated as somewhat regular people. I know the story needs to progress and sooner or later some incarnations do reach the status of 'the Turtles no longer have to hide in the shadows and can walk around like regular people', but I always do miss when they had to hide in the shadows.

Kinda like whenever the sewer lair gets destroyed or compromised and the turtles have to hide in churches, abandoned train stations or water towers. I eventually miss when they had their sewer lair.

Good point. I always thought that the "mutants are accepted now" after the armageddon game was out of the blue.
Now it's different since we know there was this Sally/Stockman US tour, but I feel this wasn't really adressed in any story.

Daytona
08-27-2025, 10:38 PM
I thought the run started out great and Aaron showed a great voice for each turtle in the individual issues. I’ve been a bit lost since the second arc begins. Hoping he’ll wrap it up in a way that surprises me but I don’t really get it right now.

Dancefloran
08-28-2025, 12:55 AM
I have been enjoying Aaron's run thus far. I'll wait the release to express my opinion.

Great Bebop and Rocksteady moment there though

CyberCubed
08-28-2025, 12:39 PM
It's weird to know Aaron's run ends with a jury storyline. I wasn't prepared to see the Turtles in Law and Order.

The whole thing with Karai and the dragon and the Foot Police all felt like build-up that won't even happen till the next writer does something with it.

nidza_maj2000
08-28-2025, 01:41 PM
It's weird to know Aaron's run ends with a jury storyline. I wasn't prepared to see the Turtles in Law and Order.

The whole thing with Karai and the dragon and the Foot Police all felt like build-up that won't even happen till the next writer does something with it.

Issue 12 might feature Savanti which will set up TMNT Battle Nexus comic maybe

Andrew NDB
08-28-2025, 02:03 PM
Didn't this run begin with one of the Turtles in jail? And now they're basically still there?

nidza_maj2000
08-28-2025, 02:19 PM
Didn't this run begin with one of the Turtles in jail? And now they're basically still there?

Yeah, this can basically be like Spider-Man No Way Home movie where like Spider-Man at beginning of movie Turtles have to face some legal charges but unlike Spider-Man they will be on trial for charges and if issue 12 really features teaser for TMNT Battle Nexus comic than it will really be similar to Spider-Man No Way Home movie in a way that after legal troubles they have to face some multiverse threats like Spider-Man in that movie

ToTheNines
08-28-2025, 02:20 PM
Didn't this run begin with one of the Turtles in jail? And now they're basically still there?

Yeah it was Raph. Except… he’s so cool and so rude that he actually likes it in prison!

CyberCubed
08-28-2025, 05:18 PM
Honestly I wonder why Jason Aaron even wanted to write TMNT to begin with. He only signed on for 12 issues, he couldn't advance the story much and had to stick to IDW's continuity. The first 4 issues were solo for each Turtle (which I liked, his first 4 issues were probably his best), then the rest has been mostly stalling with Foot Soldier fights and the Turtles arguing since he's not allowed to progress Karai's story. I don't know if he is the one who created this Hale character but he's the worst new character in awhile. I'm sure IDW would have kept him on if they could afford him but even then I don't know why he signed the contracts.

Like what is Jason Aaron's run even going to be remembered for at this point?

ToTheNines
08-28-2025, 06:08 PM
The good art lol

Zog The Magnificent
08-28-2025, 06:18 PM
Well, at the end of the day, no matter how little he acomplishes, his run still has one thing going for it:

It's not the Campbell run.

nidza_maj2000
08-28-2025, 06:31 PM
Well, at the end of the day, no matter how little he acomplishes, his run still has one thing going for it:

It's not the Campbell run.

Writers and artists that start in issue 13 might also be good

Daytona
08-28-2025, 07:56 PM
Honestly I wonder why Jason Aaron even wanted to write TMNT to begin with. He only signed on for 12 issues, he couldn't advance the story much and had to stick to IDW's continuity. The first 4 issues were solo for each Turtle (which I liked, his first 4 issues were probably his best), then the rest has been mostly stalling with Foot Soldier fights and the Turtles arguing since he's not allowed to progress Karai's story. I don't know if he is the one who created this Hale character but he's the worst new character in awhile. I'm sure IDW would have kept him on if they could afford him but even then I don't know why he signed the contracts.

Like what is Jason Aaron's run even going to be remembered for at this point?

It’s a fair question but I do think he just did it on a whim more or less. It’s the first era where he hasn’t been under contract with Marvel in a longtime and he took up a lot of projects from other companies in that time.

If anything I’d say it’s possible he took on too much and that’s why the run is starting to feel a bit rudderless - arguably at least.

Dancefloran
08-28-2025, 11:26 PM
Perhaps we'll see what Aaron was trying to convey at the end of issue 12...
You know

Dancefloran
09-03-2025, 09:53 AM
Well, Hale's downfall was kinda satisfying, and I believe it was the point of his character to be hated.

The court part was a bit unrealistic, but fun still, I give a point for creativity.

April was cool this issue !

It's interesting to see that the city is divided about mutants, I hope this will be explored in the future.

And I suppose this Hale guy is meant to be some parody of the late Donald Trump or that Tatorozu weirdtuber.

TheLabRat
09-03-2025, 10:29 AM
We still don't know about "rat" thing and how does Donnie become a hippie wise man who overdosed on marijuana, as if everything is in his plan, although this is more like peeking at the script.

Kinda funny how these foot soldiers trying to pretend they have some boundaries, as if they don't know about the many massacres that Foot Clan has committed or Shredder is a tyrant.

Daytona
09-03-2025, 12:45 PM
I don’t get it. Hopefully issue #12 ends in a satisfying way but this series basically fell off for me after the solo issues. Idk what happened.

jestergoblin
09-03-2025, 02:27 PM
Like Splinter's spirit is the new Rat King, right?

Also really like the new Karai look.

Ending page reveal... guess we're doing Mutant Mayhem 2.

But the idea that the Foot draw the line NOW? Those better be the newest, lowest recruits.

Smithguy789
09-03-2025, 04:51 PM
Well, Hale's downfall was kinda satisfying, and I believe it was the point of his character to be hated.

The court part was a bit unrealistic, but fun still, I give a point for creativity.

April was cool this issue !

It's interesting to see that the city is divided about mutants, I hope this will be explored in the future.

And I suppose this Hale guy is meant to be some parody of the late Donald Trump or that Tatorozu weirdtuber.


I haven't read any of Aaron's run, so I'm unaware of any parallels, but I sincerely hope nobody involved with TMNT in a professional capacity has any idea who Tatoruzu is.

neatoman
09-03-2025, 05:32 PM
Oh hey, something cool finally happened... And the run is almost over... Yay? Well OK, in all fairness the Aaron run does at the very least have action and a somewhat clear throughline in the story, it's just that I'm not entirely sure... OK it's like this, the first four issues are dedicated to establishing that the Turtles have been apart for a while but the stuff they get up to doesn't really seem all that relevant to me and now that I know that's one entire third of the run made it seem like a waste in hindsight, because who really thinks the next guy is going to care about Mike's former Japanese acting career? Most of what mattered about those first four issues seems like it could have been dealt with in one. And the stuff about rat carcasses and what not just seemed weird.

But, at least this time I wasn't bored out of my skull and thinking practically everything was pointless. The eleventh issue of the previous run was nothing but some Home Alone crap that didn't matter, Mona Lisa trying to contact her parents that didn't matter and set-up for another story that was... Quite possibly the single worst instance of a writer somehow both failing to stick to what a previous writer had established about the characters, and what they themselves established about the characters, just so there could be a happy ending there that made no sense at the time or further down the line...

So yeah, nothing here as bad as that. Maybe the Aaron run isn't that great but it is still a clear improvement from the one right before it.

TheLabRat
09-03-2025, 05:58 PM
Why doesn't he appear in spirit form or enter The Turtles dreams to warn them? Is it necessary to mess up Donnie's head?

My another option is that this "Splinter" is actually Rat King himself because he is trickster. We all know that The Pantheon's member are immortal, so he may have been resurrected but in a weakened state. He wanted to help the turtles, perhaps just for fun or he admits that he lost and wants to make amends this time. He also doesn't like The Traveler, which means that The Traveler is their dragon god father.

Honestly, if Leo had travel to spirit world earlier to find the source of the "dead rat", there would be no need to waste so many issues to make suspense. It's like they had to make the other three turtles incompetent to make anything justified.

CyberCubed
09-03-2025, 07:01 PM
The art is really fantastic in some pages, will miss this artist after this run. I guess April's stint in Casey's mask is already over? With Casey having his own mini coming up there's no reason for April to wear his gear. So that was only for 2 issues? lol

Karai went full mystic superpower here, I hope the next writer does her justice. Hale turns into a monster, hopefully he dies next issue rather than surviving. Overall though, this whole arc just felt like set-up for whatever they do with Karai. It's like Jason Aaron wasn't "allowed" to progress the plot so he had to create Hale who is like a "filler" villain and just had him control the Foot for this short run.

ToTheNines
09-03-2025, 08:03 PM
Had nothing better to do but sit in my hotel room, so I punished myself for another round lol. The courtroom stuff continued to be absolute nonsense. Why was it some big “gotcha” moment when Hail stupidly admitted to working with the Foot Clan if his extrajudicial gestapo (that has somehow been fully legal this whole time) is called the Foot Patrol? What?

Hale being mutated was such an obvious outcome from the start, although I guess I’ll give them credit for doing it in an unexpected way.

Juan Ferreyra should have gone down as one of the all time greats of the IDW era, sadly I think he’ll be forgotten along with this garbage run. That splash page was incredible, even with April’s eye-roll inducing inclusion.

Karai’s direction is pretty interesting, especially with Shredder coming back. I will give the next team a chance before I dip out for good.

jestergoblin
09-03-2025, 08:19 PM
The art is really fantastic in some pages, will miss this artist after this run.

The double page spread was such a nice reveal on the page turn.

TheLabRat
09-05-2025, 12:42 AM
Karai went full mystic superpower here, I hope the next writer does her justice. Hale turns into a monster, hopefully he dies next issue rather than surviving. Overall though, this whole arc just felt like set-up for whatever they do with Karai. It's like Jason Aaron wasn't "allowed" to progress the plot so he had to create Hale who is like a "filler" villain and just had him control the Foot for this short run.
They have to repeat brother's quarrel plot, and mini comic like Mutant Nation didn't explain some of the remaining questions in the main book. They'll probably leave the dead rat issue to the next writer.

Smithguy789
09-19-2025, 01:11 PM
Had a random thought. What if IDW volume two is just their version of the Guest Era, but instead of cartoonists doing an issue or two, it's big-name writers doing year-long stints?

clockstomper
09-20-2025, 01:32 PM
Had a random thought. What if IDW volume two is just their version of the Guest Era, but instead of cartoonists doing an issue or two, it's big-name writers doing year-long stints?

Not a bad idea, maybe even shorter runs? It'd certainly be cheaper for IDW if you could get a more high profile writers and artists for shorter stints.

Smithguy789
09-22-2025, 07:43 AM
Not a bad idea, maybe even shorter runs? It'd certainly be cheaper for IDW if you could get a more high profile writers and artists for shorter stints.

Better for readers, too. Easier to jump in on a new creative team than in the middle of a years-long story arc by a single writer.

MikeandRaph87
09-23-2025, 07:57 AM
What pushed #12 to October 23rd?


Also, anyone else's LCS having trouble getting Penguin Publishing distributed to their shops?

Heyowakka
09-23-2025, 08:18 AM
What pushed #12 to October 23rd?

I would imagine it’s due to standard IDW incompetence.

Mexiun
10-15-2025, 12:15 PM
I'm officially done with IDW TMNT after this run, the writers don't know what to do anymore and are just grasping at ideas at this point. Who can blame them? Every villian is either dead or an ally, every side character is either dead or a fighter to help fight against the villians making it even easier to win now, Splinter is dead too.
The stories are obviously over and its pretty obvious they are now milking it out for god knows whatever reason... the ideas are done, new villians aren't interesting and the stories lead nowhere or are insanely padded because there is nothing left!!

After #100 it became worse than poop smelling trash where people quit reading it, including me as a life long TMNT fan. Then they somehow get the idea for spin-offs to divide the TMNT allies even more for some reason, giving them all their own pointless story with lame original villians because there's nothing else to pull from anymore.

Now we got good-guy Shredder working for some company and constantly talking about worms for some reason. He cannot be a worm filled Shredder like Mirage was because he got ressurected through some mythic thing.
Why would i wanna read this? I want Shredder as a villian, not his own superhero "working for a company" comic.
He should've remained dead, he has done absolutely nothing interesting after his pointless ressurection.

IDW TMNT is one of those "time to stop" moments, stop when the story is over... and its over- finished after #100!
Time to stop or reboot the comic because this is just sad and a trainwreck...

Man i needed this vent.

TheLabRat
10-15-2025, 12:46 PM
Now we got good-guy Shredder working for some company and constantly talking about worms for some reason. He cannot be a worm filled Shredder like Mirage was because he got ressurected through some mythic thing.
Why would i wanna read this? I want Shredder as a villian, not his own superhero "working for a company" comic.
He should've remained dead, he has done absolutely nothing interesting after his pointless ressurection.


I think compared with other Shredder, IDW Shredder was highly reliant on his fox girlfriend since the beginning. Without Kitsune he will be nothing and even worse than Karai. Even his "redemption" was given by Splinter, not earned by himself. He deserved to die and maybe he should killed by Karai. Let him die under the rules and traditions he had taught Karai.

ToTheNines
10-15-2025, 03:27 PM
Man i needed this vent.

It was well said!

I often liken IDW TMNT to the family dog that clearly needs euthanized but no one wants to take it to the vet and do the deed.

I’m sure it still makes money, and part of that is probably residual from the inexplicable hype Last Ronin has received. But like you said, there’s nothing left to do. So now the game plan is to polish the turd and turn it into a DC or Marvel-style book and bring in a big name writer/artist team every twelve months.

I would say the last really good issue* was #89 or #90. Which was like 7 years ago by now.

(* I haven’t read anything from 126-150 yet)

I think compared with other Shredder, IDW Shredder was highly reliant on his fox girlfriend since the beginning. Without Kitsune he will be nothing and even worse than Karai. Even his "redemption" was given by Splinter, not earned by himself. He deserved to die and maybe he should killed by Karai. Let him die under the rules and traditions he had taught Karai.

I guess that’s one of the few interesting plots going right now. Karai vs. Saki.

I think it could be cool if she killed him, but he already died so I don’t know how interesting that would be.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2025, 04:18 PM
It seems like their best/only chance was with Vol. 2 of IDW to totally chill things out. Create that "missing time" aspect, and basically soft reboot everything into "a little bit in the future." Not tons of specials, not tons of minis, not tons of one-shots -- at least not anywhere near at first, or for the first year or two. Just a nice, slow, grassroots re-growing of good faith with readers with just the core cast and new adventures.

It seems like they've done the complete opposite.

ToTheNines
10-16-2025, 11:44 AM
Yeah kind of puzzling.

They clearly want to distance themselves from stuff like Mutant Town and the other Tumblr cringe from the Sophie era, but they’re still keeping it in the background.

CyberCubed
10-16-2025, 01:00 PM
At this point the only IDW plotlines I need to see resolved is whatever they're doing with Karai and that's about it. Old Hob is an ally, Baxter can be president, all the other main villains are dead, Shredder will probably die again or sacrifice himself or something eventually. Most of the recurring mutants are allies.

There's also Null, but IDW's Null has been so boring for almost 10 years now I just no longer care. Pretty much every other major antagonists arc is done. There really is nothing else to do.

sdp
10-16-2025, 01:57 PM
let's be honest, was IDW really ever that good, and I mean people hailed it as the best TMNT interpretation ever made. I don't know IDW lost me pretty much since the beggining with the whole turtles being incarnated descendants and the art style.

CyberCubed
10-16-2025, 09:44 PM
IDW TMNT was never perfect but at least under Tom Waltz it had a proper narrative and story structure. The issue now is all the major arcs are now done:

- Shredder died...now he's back again. And he's not really a villain but we don't know what he's going to do

- Krang is dead

- Ch'rell is dead

- Bishop is dead

- Hun is dead

- Slash is dead

- All the Triceratons are dead besides The Regenta

- Traag and Granitor are arrested

- Rat King and all the Pantheon are dead (for now, we know they're immortal)

- Old Hob is an ambiguous ally like he's always been

- Baxter is now going to be U.S. president, so his villain arc is over for the most part

- Karai has been a mixed of an ally/villain. Right now she's the main arc.

- Koya and Bludgeon have been allies with the Turtles and aren't villains anymore. Natsu as well

- Bebop/Rocksteady more or less the same, but they sometimes go off on their own

- Null was captured but escaped to space...with Metalhead. They're the only other villain loose ends

- Savanti Romero is a joke in IDW



And all the other recurring mutants are basically good guys or allies, like the Mutanimals, all the mutant town mutants, Leatherhead, the Punk Frogs, Alopex, etc. Most of the human villain gangs get beaten up or killed by the Foot or Purple Dragons almost immediately. Other villains like Dr. Barlow, Darius, etc. are all dead or done with. Hale will be done with after #12 hopefully too.

There's no real villains anymore.

Zog The Magnificent
10-16-2025, 10:03 PM
IDW TMNT was never perfect but at least under Tom Waltz it had a proper narrative and story structure. The issue now is all the major arcs are now done:

- Shredder died...now he's back again. And he's not really a villain but we don't know what he's going to do

- Krang is dead

- Ch'rell is dead

- Bishop is dead

- Hun is dead

- Slash is dead

- All the Triceratons are dead besides The Regenta

- Traag and Granitor are arrested

- Rat King and all the Pantheon are dead (for now, we know they're immortal)

- Old Hob is an ambiguous ally like he's always been

- Baxter is now going to be U.S. president, so his villain arc is over for the most part

- Karai has been a mixed of an ally/villain. Right now she's the main arc.

- Koya and Bludgeon have been allies with the Turtles and aren't villains anymore. Natsu as well

- Bebop/Rocksteady more or less the same, but they sometimes go off on their own

- Null was captured but escaped to space...with Metalhead. They're the only other villain loose ends

- Savanti Romero is a joke in IDW



And all the other recurring mutants are basically good guys or allies, like the Mutanimals, all the mutant town mutants, Leatherhead, the Punk Frogs, Alopex, etc. Most of the human villain gangs get beaten up or killed by the Foot or Purple Dragons almost immediately. Other villains like Dr. Barlow, Darius, etc. are all dead or done with. Hale will be done with after #12 hopefully too.

There's no real villains anymore.

Savanti Romero is a joke everywhere. That's his whole deal.

In all seriousness, IDW was good. It really was. It felt like a proper "Ultimate" TMNT univers, and the narrative was very well plotted for the most part, and I was always excited for the next issue. But the Dragon ending up as the biggest anticlimax was the first axe blow to the roots, which it never really recovered from. Then the Campbell run happened, and it all went to hell after that. But for a long while there, it really was good. A shame, really. I'd have rather they went straight from City at War to a better Armageddon Game, then called it a day. IDW should, by all rights, have ended when the Pantheon was dealt with. But now, we have... all of this.

Did IDW ever get back to Maligna, or did they completely forget about her?

CyberCubed
10-16-2025, 10:27 PM
Did IDW ever get back to Maligna, or did they completely forget about her?

Nope, I'm assuming they're saving her for some future Dimension X story. I suspect they'll have Null try to free Noi Tar Daar from prison in Dimension X and they may team up with Maligna.

And that's because in Archie, Null and Maligna were allies in the last arc she was in, so I suspect IDW will do something similar.

Also forgot to mention Armaggon was turned to stone and finished too, unless they bring him back.

Andrew NDB
10-16-2025, 10:34 PM
Has IDW done much with space? If not, send the Turtles alone into space for like a year going across multiple worlds, then make it a big deal when they return and everything is different when they come back. And maybe they inadvertently drag a big alien threat/race back to Earth and that could be the next story. I don't think TMNT beyond something like FW lends itself well to shuffling around the same toys in the box over and over again.

Zog The Magnificent
10-16-2025, 10:56 PM
Has IDW done much with space? If not, send the Turtles alone into space for like a year going across multiple worlds, then make it a big deal when they return and everything is different when they come back. And maybe they inadvertently drag a big alien threat/race back to Earth and that could be the next story. I don't think TMNT beyond something like FW lends itself well to shuffling around the same toys in the box over and over again.

There's an idea. A prolonged space journey, that could also serve as a soft reboot. They get back years later because of reletivity or whatever, all the crap is gone, and it could be Maligna who follows them back, allowing them to finally do something with her. Three birds with one stone.

TheLabRat
10-17-2025, 12:21 AM
Or we could have a battle between Hamato Clan/The Turtles vs Foot Clan/Karai as the final storyline. Let Bebop/Rocksteady get a Disney villain-style death or have Donnie give them a "fate worse than death". Karai will either be consumed by her own evil or, like Azula, fall into eternal madness.

Coola Yagami
10-17-2025, 12:58 AM
IDW TMNT was never perfect but at least under Tom Waltz it had a proper narrative and story structure. The issue now is all the major arcs are now done:

- Shredder died...now he's back again. And he's not really a villain but we don't know what he's going to do

- Krang is dead

- Ch'rell is dead

- Bishop is dead

- Hun is dead

- Slash is dead



Imma need a short synopsis of who/what killed all of them. I just know Splinter killed Shredder the first time around. Um... I think... cause I remember Shredder also killed Splinter.

Now I'm confused. I don't think IDW had the balls to have Leo kill Shredder.

CyberCubed
10-18-2025, 12:34 AM
A lot of them died either by the end of issue 100 or during the Armaggedon game arc.

Literally the only villains from the start of the book still alive are Baxter, Karai and Old Hob, and Hob has always been an ambiguous ally. I won't count Shredder because he died and came back to life. Besides that Karai still has her henchmen mutants (Koya/Bludgeon and Bebop/Rocksteady), but everyone else is on and off.

Null is really the only other major villain they barely ever had time for, which is why I'm hoping the next arc majorly focuses on space with her, Noi Tai Daar and Maligna all teaming up.

TheLabRat
10-18-2025, 02:15 AM
Some of the prophecies in Donnie's macro comic have already come true in other ways. Now, Karai plans to open the gate of hell. Not sure if this former apprentice of Shredder called Ria/The Mourner will do the same because she did prepare to make a extradimensional bomb.

Andrew NDB
10-18-2025, 02:27 AM
Now I'm confused. I don't think IDW had the balls to have Leo kill Shredder.

I don't believe IDW has the ability to do so even if they wanted to because of Nick. Turtles can't kill humans. They MIGHT be able to clear it if they make it clear who they're killing is not a human but something zombie-like or a monster or otherworldly, maybe.

TheLabRat
10-18-2025, 04:57 AM
They can't even kill some mutants, and so far, they have never thought of taking revenge on B&R.

ToTheNines
10-18-2025, 04:44 PM
let's be honest, was IDW really ever that good, and I mean people hailed it as the best TMNT interpretation ever made. I don't know IDW lost me pretty much since the beggining with the whole turtles being incarnated descendants and the art style.

I personally liked the reincarnation angle. Still do. But I get what you’re saying.

Part of me wants to do a full chronological re-read, but it’s hard to find the motivation when I know it never hits a satisfying narrative ending. I know many people demonize the Sophie era, but #100 ain’t it either. I hated their whole “City at War” arc (REALLY hate that they called it that).

It was a fun time in my life and technically the first TMNT series I was able to follow as it was coming out, since I didn’t start seriously collecting until well into Tales V2. Which was an anthology, not an ongoing. But yeah… it’s hard to look back on it and say it was all that great. They certainly pulled a lot of punches.

CyberCubed
10-18-2025, 06:10 PM
I think the issue is the way IDW TMNT is plotted...it doesn't feel like anything gets resolved...even when they DO wrap up some storylines.

What was the outcome of the whole Utrom/Triceraton stuff? All the other Utroms are still on Burnow Island, we haven't had any further stories about them for awhile. What are they still doing there? Both Krang and Ch'rell are dead, there aren't any "bad Utroms" taking charge anymore. Why haven't they searched for a new home in space? Are any Triceratons still alive at all? Are the ruins of the Technodrome still there?

The Patheon stuff turned out to be a huge anti-climax. All those countless issues with Rat King being hyped up and it basically led to pretty much nothing. Kitsune's arc also largely ended when Shredder came back to life. The others besides maybe the Toad Barron all barely did anything.

Null was introduced around 2015/2016 and her whole role in the comic has been so minimal for over 10 years now, she might as well not even be here.

TheLabRat
10-18-2025, 10:08 PM
Even the reincarnation isn't executed as well as it could have been. The turtles were Hamato Yoshi's children, and they wear different colored clothes to distinguish them. But how hard is it to give them a japanese name? It feels like the entire reincarnation storyline isn't about the the turtles, but about Splinter and Shredder. So not all the turtles have to be Yoshi's children. At least one or two turtles can have their own past life stories.

hypered1
10-18-2025, 11:38 PM
Even the reincarnation isn't executed as well as it could have been. The turtles were Hamato Yoshi's children, and they wear different colored clothes to distinguish them. But how hard is it to give them a japanese name? It feels like the entire reincarnation storyline isn't about the the turtles, but about Splinter and Shredder. So not all the turtles have to be Yoshi's children. At least one or two turtles can have their own past life stories.

If you read issue 150 it ties it all together.

Coola Yagami
10-19-2025, 11:41 AM
I think the issue is the way IDW TMNT is plotted...it doesn't feel like anything gets resolved...even when they DO wrap up some storylines.

What was the outcome of the whole Utrom/Triceraton stuff? All the other Utroms are still on Burnow Island, we haven't had any further stories about them for awhile. What are they still doing there? Both Krang and Ch'rell are dead, there aren't any "bad Utroms" taking charge anymore. Why haven't they searched for a new home in space? Are any Triceratons still alive at all? Are the ruins of the Technodrome still there?

The Patheon stuff turned out to be a huge anti-climax. All those countless issues with Rat King being hyped up and it basically led to pretty much nothing. Kitsune's arc also largely ended when Shredder came back to life. The others besides maybe the Toad Barron all barely did anything.

Null was introduced around 2015/2016 and her whole role in the comic has been so minimal for over 10 years now, she might as well not even be here.

Whenever she comes back (assuming she ever does) we def need some of those flashbacks to recap for the readers.