PDA

View Full Version : Thoughts on "Turtle Prime"


Smithguy789
09-03-2025, 05:36 PM
I mentioned this a little in the "Battle Nexus" thread, but I'm thinking about it again now after re-reading Tales #58 and thought I'd shoot my thoughts into the void.

In Tales #58, when Galactose opened windows to other universes in the TMNT multiverse, we see four turtles that look almost exactly like the Turtles Forever "Turtle Prime" turtles. This confused me the first time I read it because, shouldn't the Mirage Turtles and "Turtle Prime" Turtles be one and the same?

I've read multiple interviews and puff pieces and what have you where Eastman and/or Laird mention that they never planned a series when they made the first issue. Of course there was the "if it's a hit, we'll do more" mentality but they were very much going seat-of-their-pants on that front. Of course it was a hit, and more stories and a franchise followed. But what if there had only been that one issue?

And THAT is what Turtle Prime is, in my head. A universe where all we know that happened for a fact is that first issue. These turtles never underwent any stylistic/design changes, never got refined, and were never in color. Maybe they met Casey and April and Renet and Savanti and Karai and Bloodsucker and whoever else, maybe they didn't. We don't know (apparently they met Batman though, I guess...)

Long story short, these are the mental gymnastics I go through when there's black-and-white turtles in an IDW book and they try to tell me it's the Mirage turtles.

Andrew NDB
09-03-2025, 05:44 PM
The Prime Turtles are the Mirage Turtles. I don't know what the B&W Turtles from IDW and Turtles Forever are but they're something else.

neatoman
09-03-2025, 06:00 PM
I had to look up that page to figure something out. It's really weird, I'll grant you that. It shows what are clearly the Archie Turtles in one universe but implies the Mutanimals are from another, unless those are intended to be the Mutanimals from the scrapped cartoon, I don't know what to make of that. I also don't know for sure If we're seeing the 2003 or 2007 Turtles on that page, they're a bit stockier like the 2003 Turtles but we can see the details of their eyes like the 2007 Turtles.

Which brings us the Turtles this thread is about. What do they look like? Granted, they look similar to the Mirage Turtles but that doesn't necessarily mean they are the Mirage Turtles proper or their depiction in Turtles Forever. Based on their beaks and stubby bodies, I think they might be the Mark Martin Turtles or some other Mirage-adjacent Turtles. You know a version of the Turtles can be described as "Mirage... But not really".

Andrew NDB
09-03-2025, 06:03 PM
Kind of like the IDW Turtles that crossover in stuff, but clearly stuff that wouldn't be compatible with the actual IDW TMNT comics. "Off-Brand Mirage Turtles," I guess, are the B&W ones.

We know this, of course, because the Mirage TMNT are not B&W.

neatoman
09-03-2025, 06:17 PM
We know this, of course, because the Mirage TMNT are not B&W.

Canonically no, but it is a good shorthand to make them stand out when next to their counterparts from other realities. Tell me, unless the artist is actively trying to emulate the art style of someone else, how are you going to tell Mirage Raph from IDW Raph if they have the same exact color scheme? They'd look virtually the same and would have way too similar personalities to just go off by context clues in how they're written. By constantly paying attention to where they were in the room and looking for which one of them have a tail?

If not in Black and White, which I'll admit is weird to insist is how they actually look just because the comics themselves were initially printed without color, how else are you going to do it? Make them look more like one of the common Mirage artists drew them, like Lawson, while drawing the IDW Turtles as differently from that as possible?

Andrew NDB
09-03-2025, 06:19 PM
Tell me, unless the artist is actively trying to emulate the art style of someone else, how are you going to tell Mirage Raph from IDW Raph if they have the same exact color scheme? They'd look virtually the same and would have way too similar personalities to just go off by context clues in how they're written.

Doesn't IDW TMNT still wear the wraps and all that? Give them the wraps.

Coola Yagami
09-03-2025, 06:42 PM
Doesn't IDW TMNT still wear the wraps and all that? Give them the wraps.

Yeah, keep Mirage Raph... Mirage Raph and give IDW Raph the extra wraps, wrist guards and bulky elbow/knee pads. Easy to tell apart. Plus the Mirage Turtles don't have pupils.

ToTheNines
09-03-2025, 09:02 PM
To me, the events of Turtles Forever interrupted the events of #1 and created a branched universe. Smithguy’s theory holds up here, because it was important for Ch’rell to go to that exact point in order to erase all the subsequent turtles from ever existing. He didn’t go kill them when they were babies, or when they were old men, or anywhere in between other than that exact issue.

Then the coda zooms out to the real world in 1984 and Kevin and Peter are clearly still working on #1 and are unsure if it will ever take off. The black and white stuff was just a creative decision for the audience to see them that way, no characters in the story ever acknowledge the lack of color.

Everything else… eh. Batman III I only vaguely remember. Read it once and wasn’t very happy with it. I view those “Mirage” turtles in the same light as the “IDW” turtles from that crossover. Loosely based on the main series turtles, probably have a similar history/backstory, but ultimately a separate continuity. They represent Mirage, but they’re not Mirage. To me, at least.

Verdict is still out on the Battle Nexus stuff, but I expect them to reference the events of Batman III. We’ll see.

Smithguy789
09-05-2025, 07:00 AM
I view those “Mirage” turtles in the same light as the “IDW” turtles from that crossover. Loosely based on the main series turtles, probably have a similar history/backstory, but ultimately a separate continuity. They represent Mirage, but they’re not Mirage. To me, at least.

Just curious, do you view the "Mirage" turtles in the Stranger Things crossover the same way? I know they're *supposed* to be the Mirage turtles, but they don't *feel* right for some reason, and I've yet to come across anyone that considers them to actually be the Mirage turtles

ToTheNines
09-05-2025, 07:08 AM
I only read it once, but I loved it. I haven’t really weighed its canon status too much, but I thought it felt authentic and very close to Mirage.

Andrew NDB
09-05-2025, 09:41 AM
Just curious, do you view the "Mirage" turtles in the Stranger Things crossover the same way? I know they're *supposed* to be the Mirage turtles, but they don't *feel* right for some reason, and I've yet to come across anyone that considers them to actually be the Mirage turtles

I consider those the Mirage Turtles. It fits well enough beyond a couple of strange oddities.