View Full Version : Now that Jason Aaron's run on IDW TMNT is over (#1-12) how would you rate it?
CyberCubed
10-23-2025, 08:56 PM
Jason Aaron just completed his 1-year run on IDW TMNT taking over from Sophie after #150. He wrote issues #1-12 which have just concluded. How did you feel about his run as a whole?
Vote on the poll as well.
TheLabRat
10-23-2025, 09:46 PM
It's not the worst, but I didn't like the character assassination this story did to the turtles, especially Leo and Mikey who suffered the most.
Hale is just a boring villain, and entire of Karai's plot is just another foreshadowing set up by the writer and then irresponsibly handed off to the next writer.
Vote on poor.
Dancefloran
10-24-2025, 01:49 AM
I enjoyed the run.
Well, there were some flaws: Karai giving powers to a mediocre man out of nowhere, an unrealistic (but fun) trial, and a very risky cliffhanger at the end.
However, having an arrogant and mediocre man like Hale in power was a fitting representation of some of our real-life corrupt politicians. The Foot Patrol also felt like a representation of a fascist police force exercising brutality and bigotry. The idea of weaponizing the law was an interesting concept as well.
It’s interesting to see these themes explored, but I think they could have been handled better.
I appreciated April’s role in this run.
Art-wise, the designs I found nice or fun were: the Foot Patrol, April wearing Casey’s gear, and Hale’s mutation.
The four brothers were the best part of this run. They’ve grown — they’re different, but still the same. I especially loved the first four issues.
In the end, the fights were fun, and seeing the turtles struggle to bond again made for an interesting story!
Andrew NDB
10-24-2025, 01:54 AM
I think this was either always designed as a "brief" palette cleanser or something happened. I can't get over the beginning of it. Spend 4 issues of a 12 issue run on basically just catching up with the 4 Turtles, individually? Or maybe this was really just a job and he needed filler to pad things out.
ToTheNines
10-24-2025, 05:00 AM
“Generally poor” only because the art was incredible. Jason Aaron stinks. It’s been many years since I sold all my trades, but I LOVED his Star Wars run when it was coming out. What happened?
I mean, it’s incredibly obvious that he just doesn’t get TMNT. But beyond that, his dialogue is so forced and unnatural.
I can’t believe I stuck out all 12 issues. I guess I’ll just keep telling myself I’m making a small donation to my local comic shop by reading a book I hate lol.
neatoman
10-24-2025, 05:22 AM
I could follow the plot which was actually moving along from issue to issue and I got consistency from it instead of seeing things just happen because they needed to, so I didn't get annoyed by it at least, I just didn't think it was a very interesting story and it was really hard for me to stay invested. Which sucks because I was really hoping we would finally get an interesting story again on top of more coherent writing from a technical standpoint.
Then there are things like the Raphael spending time in a human prison, Mike starring in a TV show and all of them being sent to stand trial in a regular courtroom which are just... It has never sat right with me when the Turtles are pretty much treated like they're human and/or are allowed to walk around in the open, it's why I really hate the ending of Mutant Mayhem, that kind of stuff just seems to just wreck the entire concept.
Heyowakka
10-24-2025, 07:07 AM
It wasn’t as good as things were when I enjoyed the book in the past; but it wasn’t as bad as things were when I hated reading the book.
At the very least, despite weird dialogue and boring antagonists I was able to read 12 issues through without giving up in frustration, which is more than I can say about Campbell’s run.
I was about to say that maybe the next writer will have a better feel for the Turtles, but then I remembered he’ll only be writing 12 issues before being replaced by someone else, so I guess it wouldn’t even matter.
liugeaux
10-27-2025, 01:52 PM
I my biggest issues with Aaron's run is that it felt too tonally different from all other IDW books, and the pacing was WAY too slow. So, having this be a soft reboot in the same continuity had the entire 12-issue run seem disjointed. This was only amplified by the Mutant Nation and Nightwatcher books still feeling like pre-reboot TMNT.
Had this been a full reboot with Aaron reestablishing an all-new continuity, it might have hit better, and the plodding pace would have felt more justified. Honestly, this whole arc could have been edited down to 6 issues, and we wouldn't have lost much of the story.
I don't think the reboot combo of books (Aaron's Ongoing/MN/NW) proved to be as successful as IDW wanted/needed. I say this because not only did they not re-up Aaron's (probably expensive) contract, they swiftly cancelled both companion "ongoing" titles, both of which were trying to build on top of relatively unknown grounds.
Replacing the two failed ongoing series with 2 recognizably named minis in Shredder and Casey Jones, and following that up with the stunty Multiverse Battle Nexus suggests they aren't looking to take giant, risky creative swings like they were 12 months ago.
Ultimately, I don't think I'm happier with where the Turtles are right now than I was this time last year and that's not good.
CyberCubed
10-28-2025, 12:58 PM
Mutant Nation was probably intended to last longer, but I don't think Nightwatcher/Jennika had much steam left. Her character has been almost entirely written off the series for now, I think the interest in a female Turtle is dead again. Notice how the summaries for 13 and onward mention nothing of Jennika rejoining the 4 Turtles either.
Let Jennika stay with her lesbian pig mutant lover off-screen or until they get demutated to humans if that ever happens.
Andrew NDB
10-28-2025, 01:12 PM
Whatever happened to Venus? Is she still around?
Heyowakka
10-28-2025, 02:49 PM
I just checked and apparently she went to Afterlife Land with Yoshi and Shen, but if Splinter coming back is actually any indication, that means absolutely nothing.
liugeaux
10-29-2025, 09:05 PM
Whatever happened to Venus? Is she still around?
Yeah, she sacrificed herself in issue #150, but with the peculiar nature of how Armagon and QNA were written, bringing her back wouldn't be hard at all.
CyberCubed
10-29-2025, 10:43 PM
I think what's weird is it seems IDW TMNT is going in circles. Like Karai is STILL mastering dark arts/magic power which it feels like she's been doing for the last 50+ issues, and fighting rival gangs (now the Dog Star gang).
Baxter has been in politics forever. I feel he lost his purpose awhile ago.
Old Hob is now setting up Mutant Island which is basically the same thing as Mutant Town only with mutants who are loyal to him. He also is still just the same ambiguous ally he's always been.
Null has just always been in the background really, now she's in space with Metalhead and will probably free Noi Tar Daar from prison. Maybe that will be good.
The Utroms/Triceraton stuff on Burnow Island has been left off-screen ever since the Armaggedon game arc ended. With no evil Utroms anymore I don't know why they haven't searched for a new planet to call home. Why are they still on Earth?
The Patheon/Rat King are gone for now, but we know they're immortal, so they're probably just going to re-form as children or something like Aka did when she died at some point.
Like...none of these plots have ever had a complete ending. They keep circling around the same villains over and over again.
Coola Yagami
10-29-2025, 11:12 PM
I think what's weird is it seems IDW TMNT is going in circles. Like Karai is STILL mastering dark arts/magic power which it feels like she's been doing for the last 50+ issues, and fighting rival gangs (now the Dog Star gang).
Baxter has been in politics forever. I feel he lost his purpose awhile ago.
Old Hob is now setting up Mutant Island which is basically the same thing as Mutant Town only with mutants who are loyal to him. He also is still just the same ambiguous ally he's always been.
Null has just always been in the background really, now she's in space with Metalhead and will probably free Noi Tar Daar from prison. Maybe that will be good.
The Utroms/Triceraton stuff on Burnow Island has been left off-screen ever since the Armaggedon game arc ended. With no evil Utroms anymore I don't know why they haven't searched for a new planet to call home. Why are they still on Earth?
The Patheon/Rat King are gone for now, but we know they're immortal, so they're probably just going to re-form as children or something like Aka did when she died at some point.
Like...none of these plots have ever had a complete ending. They keep circling around the same villains over and over again.
Welcome to comics.
I mean sure, Batman has a son now and we have a few more Robins and Batgirls running around... but Joker is still insane and committing mass murder. Scarecrow is still gassing Gotham with fear toxin every other month. Two-Face, Penguin and whoever else are still doing mob stuff. Harley has been the same 'lol so random' shtick for the last decade by now. Bane still brags about how he once 'broke the bat' and tries to take over Gotham every other year.
Marvel keeps running in circles where the heroes just seem to waste more time fighting each other than actual villains.
TheLabRat
10-31-2025, 02:23 AM
I'm still curious about the fate of future Raph in Annual 2023. He was attack by foot soldiers and never appeared again. How did they find him? What did they had to attack him? Does future Raph still hold some unknown information? I don't know if they have any future plans for him, or they might simply ignore this contradictory plot.
Fenryr
10-31-2025, 04:47 AM
Interim tenure at best.
Aaron has written quality before. So have many, if not all, of the other writers/editors involved. The artists continually turn in amazing work.
And then this.
From Untold History of the Foot Clan to the 2025 Annual, where the run really begins and ends, this was a complete mess. Casey and Karai and The Foot and Hale could have been a plot line. Mutant Town and the Nightwatcher and Lao Ban and Hale could have been a plot line. The Turtles reconvening after six months to a year or so apart (the timeline is never really clear on how long they've been separated or what they're even angry at each other about) and having to actually find one antoher and fight a common enemy together could have been a plot line. But none of it is.
None of these books have provided escapism from and/or interesting/necessary/appropriate commentary on actual proceedings in the world to justify their existence for a calendar year.
TheLabRat
10-31-2025, 10:15 AM
I think what's weird is it seems IDW TMNT is going in circles. Like Karai is STILL mastering dark arts/magic power which it feels like she's been doing for the last 50+ issues, and fighting rival gangs (now the Dog Star gang).
She got a evil sword, but was later betrayed and used by Kitsune. Now, she allows a dragon to possess her in order to gain power. Perhaps in a future story she will win again, but then the dragon will take everything from her to pay the price she promised. Although the turtles had reason to beat her to a pulp first, since she had resurrect their father with dark magic, they had no choice but to solve the problem she caused again.
CyberCubed
10-31-2025, 05:20 PM
Not to mention Karai cycles through the same mutants over and over. Didn't Bludgeon say he gave up fighting in Sophie's run? Now he's back working for Karai again. Bebop/Rocksteady also went off on their own for awhile and now they're back with Karai. And then Null's two mutants were working for Karai for a bit and now that's done too, with the scorpion mutant being arrested by Blackwater and Krisa went off. All they do is revert back to status quo.
Welcome to comics.
I mean sure, Batman has a son now and we have a few more Robins and Batgirls running around... but Joker is still insane and committing mass murder. Scarecrow is still gassing Gotham with fear toxin every other month. Two-Face, Penguin and whoever else are still doing mob stuff. Harley has been the same 'lol so random' shtick for the last decade by now. Bane still brags about how he once 'broke the bat' and tries to take over Gotham every other year.
Marvel keeps running in circles where the heroes just seem to waste more time fighting each other than actual villains.
But that's the thing, we all know TMNT universes do not go on forever. Unlike Batman or Spider-man, TMNT villains can have an ending. We do not expect a series to go on forever, so characters can conclude.
I just hope if/when IDW finally does get canceled someday, they know enough ahead of time to wrap up all the storylines they can.
Coola Yagami
11-01-2025, 04:54 PM
But that's the thing, we all know TMNT universes do not go on forever. Unlike Batman or Spider-man, TMNT villains can have an ending. We do not expect a series to go on forever, so characters can conclude.
I just hope if/when IDW finally does get canceled someday, they know enough ahead of time to wrap up all the storylines they can.
IDW missed the memo on that one. This is their main TMNT universe and it will continue until they go out of business or it just stops selling. They might do soft reboots, but they're not going to end this run and restart it. This one is gonna go as long as they can possibly stretch it.
It might not be panned to go forever, but I don't think they have an ending in sight. For all we know Hun might somehow get resurrected in a year or two.
ToTheNines
11-01-2025, 05:03 PM
Interim tenure at best.
Aaron has written quality before. So have many, if not all, of the other writers/editors involved. The artists continually turn in amazing work.
And then this.
From Untold History of the Foot Clan to the 2025 Annual, where the run really begins and ends, this was a complete mess. Casey and Karai and The Foot and Hale could have been a plot line. Mutant Town and the Nightwatcher and Lao Ban and Hale could have been a plot line. The Turtles reconvening after six months to a year or so apart (the timeline is never really clear on how long they've been separated or what they're even angry at each other about) and having to actually find one antoher and fight a common enemy together could have been a plot line. But none of it is.
None of these books have provided escapism from and/or interesting/necessary/appropriate commentary on actual proceedings in the world to justify their existence for a calendar year.
Very well said.
I can’t believe this is what they came up with as after hyping up a new volume.
TheLabRat
11-01-2025, 10:14 PM
I still don't understand what the point of Casey join the Foot Clan? Is it some kind of "I can save her" crap?
Interim tenure at best.
Aaron has written quality before. So have many, if not all, of the other writers/editors involved. The artists continually turn in amazing work.
And then this.
From Untold History of the Foot Clan to the 2025 Annual, where the run really begins and ends, this was a complete mess. Casey and Karai and The Foot and Hale could have been a plot line. Mutant Town and the Nightwatcher and Lao Ban and Hale could have been a plot line. The Turtles reconvening after six months to a year or so apart (the timeline is never really clear on how long they've been separated or what they're even angry at each other about) and having to actually find one antoher and fight a common enemy together could have been a plot line. But none of it is.
None of these books have provided escapism from and/or interesting/necessary/appropriate commentary on actual proceedings in the world to justify their existence for a calendar year.
Apparently, IDW TMNT series needs clear planning, editorial oversight, and management.
GameCobra
11-02-2025, 04:44 PM
For me, it feels like after the 100th issue they had Sophie volunteer to take the reins and turn the series into a slow recovery, but after her run they tried turning the series back to it's roots again. Though personally, I think that's the issue here: Instead of trying to capitalize on the MutantTown arc they decided that the foot clan had to be evil again and Karai was the new shredder for some reason.
If they wanted to get rid of the Pantheon in the story, logically speaking to me - they should've instead focused on Dragon's immortality issue instead. To me, The MutantTown arc was like a moment of peace for the turtles after losing splinter and a larger threat was coming - mianly dragon. Though i do recall they used that similar storyline in the 2012 cartoon series i believe.
TheLabRat
11-12-2025, 10:52 PM
Embattled IDW Replaces TMNT Group Editor Andy Khouri After Less Than a Year
https://fandompulse.substack.com/p/embattled-idw-replaces-tmnt-group
neatoman
11-13-2025, 07:57 AM
Embattled IDW Replaces TMNT Group Editor Andy Khouri After Less Than a Year
https://fandompulse.substack.com/p/embattled-idw-replaces-tmnt-group
That seems bad.
Yeah, it does.
Fenryr
11-14-2025, 09:34 AM
That article is all over the place.
Making April the Turtles' primary human ally over Casey Jones was controversial? Doubtful!
IDW switching to Penguin Random House caused order confusion? It most certainly did not.
Sales dropped from #1 to #12 because NOTHING HAPPENS until #8 when Donatello turns himself over to the bad guys, at the end of the issue, to set up a boring, nonsensical court case built around crimes that were never really explained and definitely wouldn't apply blanketly to all four brothers.
Your sales were bad because your story was bad.
CyberCubed
11-14-2025, 04:14 PM
Lol, that "fake outrage" over April replacing Casey because she wore his hockey mask for a grand total of 2 issues was the dumbest thing ever. People just love to exaggerate.
Andrew NDB
11-14-2025, 04:17 PM
From the article:
But there’s more to the Khouri situation. Those same sources indicate Khouri upset Nickelodeon, IDW’s licensing partner for TMNT, early in his tenure. The details remain unclear, but there was friction between Khouri and Nickelodeon representatives that created problems for the working relationship. When you’re licensing someone else’s IP, keeping the licensor happy is non-negotiable. If Nickelodeon wasn’t comfortable with Khouri, IDW had no choice but to make a change.
Well yeah, I mean... when Nickelodeon won't let your Ninja Turtles be ninjas, that's probably really frustrating.
Heyowakka
11-14-2025, 05:11 PM
I have my doubts that that’s the reason Khouri and Nickelodeon weren’t getting along.
ToTheNines
02-09-2026, 01:59 PM
Then there are things like the Raphael spending time in a human prison, Mike starring in a TV show and all of them being sent to stand trial in a regular courtroom which are just... It has never sat right with me when the Turtles are pretty much treated like they're human and/or are allowed to walk around in the open, it's why I really hate the ending of Mutant Mayhem, that kind of stuff just seems to just wreck the entire concept.
That stuff is all pretty stupid, but the ultimate kick in the nuts for me was the Foot Clan being turned into the Foot Patrol and somehow being the ****in District Attorney's personal army. I mean, that's just so ****ing stupid as a concept. It just doesn't work like that lol. The State Police and federal government just wouldn't allow that.
Like a lot of people, one of the reasons I love TMNT is the ninjas. They're just cool. I know they're not real, but the idea that ancient gangs of warriors that are so skilled and sneaky that they could be working behind the scenes in our world is just a lot of fun. But to bring them out of the shadows and have them literally usurp the NYPD and just be an army of armed thugs operating in broad daylight sucks the fun out of it.
And even accepting that for what it is, the crux of that whole plot is just plain dumb. Karai's explicit instructions to Hale were to keep the enemies of The Foot distracted while she was in the chamber. So not only are the 4 turtles not really enemies of the Foot... two of them were literally imprisoned and the other two were separated in Japan and India with no intention of coming back to NYC! They were already distracted! Hale could have literally done whatever he wanted without the turtles interfering had he not sent assassins after them.
Clearly set up in Untold Destiny, the only enemies of the Foot at that time would be the Dog Star Clan, who only have a brief skirmish with the Foot Patrol in Mutant Nation, and that's it. I understand Karai isn't in her right mind or whatever, but why wouldn't she just leave Natsu in charge? Why draw this much unnecessary attention the The Foot?
Dancefloran
02-09-2026, 03:49 PM
And even accepting that for what it is, the crux of that whole plot is just plain dumb. Karai's explicit instructions to Hale were to keep the enemies of The Foot distracted while she was in the chamber. So not only are the 4 turtles not really enemies of the Foot... two of them were literally imprisoned and the other two were separated in Japan and India with no intention of coming back to NYC! They were already distracted! Hale could have literally done whatever he wanted without the turtles interfering had he not sent assassins after them.
Yup, the pretense was really bad, even if you accept the idea that Hale is incompetent or awfully arrogant.
Its clear the intention was to make the turtles fight the Foot again for the relaunch, but it seems they couldn't do it without sacrificing writing or consistency, but at least we had some cool moments out of it.
I think the weirdest part was that scene where Hale used some "power" that is either out of this world eloquence or magic charisma making a village commit suicide, I didn't think that was necessary.
neatoman
02-09-2026, 05:40 PM
I think the ninjas and mutants of TMNT are a bit like the wizards and monsters of Harry Potter. The idea that there are several settlements and buildings, including segments of London, as well as giant creatures are completely hidden from most people might be somewhat absurd even with magic in play... But there is a pretty good reason wizard/muggle interaction mostly ends at Harry being abused by his aunt and her family, it would be pretty weird if there was stuff like the UN holding trials for the Death Eaters and forest rangers dealing with dragons in regular forests, it's kinda hard to imagine the whole premise of the regular world chugging along like normal if that stuff is common knowledge.
Andrew NDB
02-09-2026, 05:51 PM
https://s.faketrumptweet.com/mlfttzqv_eeecya_144827.png
ToTheNines
02-09-2026, 06:14 PM
Yup, the pretense was really bad, even if you accept the idea that Hale is incompetent or awfully arrogant.
Its clear the intention was to make the turtles fight the Foot again for the relaunch, but it seems they couldn't do it without sacrificing writing or consistency, but at least we had some cool moments out of it.
If by cool moments, you mean good art/action in a piece of trash story, then sure.
I also hated the contentiousness between the guys. Sophie split them up in a melancholic/bittersweet way that felt like they were growing up. Then this volume starts and they’re furious with each other for no reason.
I think the weirdest part was that scene where Hale used some "power" that is either out of this world eloquence or magic charisma making a village commit suicide, I didn't think that was necessary.
Yeah that was bizarre, and only happened once.
I also didn’t like how Splinter’s spirit was controlling hordes of rats. Unless they’re setting him up as the Rat King of a new Pantheon or something.
I think the ninjas and mutants of TMNT are a bit like the wizards and monsters of Harry Potter. The idea that there are several settlements and buildings, including segments of London, as well as giant creatures are completely hidden from most people might be somewhat absurd even with magic in play... But there is a pretty good reason wizard/muggle interaction mostly ends at Harry being abused by his aunt and her family, it would be pretty weird if there was stuff like the UN holding trials for the Death Eaters and forest rangers dealing with dragons in regular forests, it's kinda hard to imagine the whole premise of the regular world chugging along like normal if that stuff is common knowledge.
Yes, they certainly should be like that.
And I have no problem with the Foot working for the government, in a secretive capacity. The Foot being in the pocket of a powerful senator, the CIA director, or even the NYC District Attorney could be done very well. But them being a “public safety” goon squad that the NYPD rolls over for is just deeply stupid.
https://s.faketrumptweet.com/mlfttzqv_eeecya_144827.png
lol thank you *tip of the hat*
Speaking of Trump, Aaron was doing a bunch of cringey “MAGA bad” stuff, but the dumbest thing was fatso’s name. Hieronymous Hale = HH = Heil Hitler.
So clever!
TheLabRat
02-09-2026, 06:39 PM
The turtles had no reason to hate each others, and blame each other for abandoning them, especially since in the pre-Armaggon arc they agreed to to separate and start new life.
I also dislike they try to pretend Foot Clan is some kind of super corporation. There is a Foot Clan helicopter crashed in a protected area in India, and they also publicly replaced the entire New York department of public safety. These increasingly blatant actions should have triggered some international disputes. Logically, the Japanese government would take a tougher stance against Foot Clan to appease the discontent of India and the US Meanwhile, other yakuza groups might choose to side with the Japanese government and police, or sever all ties with Foot Clan for their own benefit. But even now, Foot Clan has still get away with it.
Dancefloran
02-10-2026, 05:39 AM
If by cool moments, you mean good art/action in a piece of trash story, then sure.
No comment.
Speaking of Trump, Aaron was doing a bunch of cringey “MAGA bad” stuff, but the dumbest thing was fatso’s name. Hieronymous Hale = HH = Heil Hitler.
So clever!
Oh I didn't catch that ! "Hale/Heil", that's funny.
However I didn't find any sources to back up this claim, you made that up ?
Hale enforcing fascist policies isn't something that refers only to naz!s or the rich ped0phile leading the US... there are a lot of regimes, past and present, that uses such methods
Andrew NDB
02-10-2026, 03:41 PM
Oh I didn't catch that ! "Hale/Heil", that's funny.
Boy, that's some great in depth humor right there.
Dancefloran
02-10-2026, 03:45 PM
Boy, that's some great in depth humor right there.
Heck, what the hell
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.