PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Annual 2025 preview and discussion


hypered1
10-28-2025, 12:16 PM
https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_1-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_2-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_3-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_4-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_5-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_6-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1https://i0.wp.com/graphicpolicy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/TMNT_Annual_2025_7-scaled.jpg?resize=666%2C1024&ssl=1

Heyowakka
10-28-2025, 06:14 PM
Just when you think the brotherly drama is over, Leonardo comes in clutch and gets all moody and cranky! That was certainly a close one!

TheLabRat
10-29-2025, 02:29 AM
I'm not sure which one is worst for Leo.

In the Campbell's final run, he stopped to save Donnie, then sat there crying like a baby because Future Bob turned Lita back into human.

In the Jason Aaron's run, he becomes a hippie, goes to India, and hopes to be eaten by a group of softshell turtles.

Dancefloran
10-29-2025, 03:17 AM
Well life is tough...
I don't really get why you expect characters to not have feelings, that's what makes them more "real" or "relatable"

Zog The Magnificent
10-29-2025, 08:01 AM
There's a difference between "having feelings" and "being a whiny baby." When a character becomes whiny, it's not endearing. It's just annoying, especially when that character is acting out of character, and has had all their plots hijacked by other characters the writers were more interested in writing about.

Coola Yagami
10-29-2025, 09:00 AM
There's a difference between "having feelings" and "being a whiny baby." When a character becomes whiny, it's not endearing. It's just annoying, especially when that character is acting out of character, and has had all their plots hijacked by other characters the writers were more interested in writing about.

I've noticed writers seem to have an issue in displaying feelings for normally stoic characters without somehow turning them into whiny little bitches.

The Lita incident is just so non-sensical within the context of the story and the overall world of the TMNT that it had to be some sort of shoe-horned trans-allegory based on real world politics that have no bearing in that world.

I'm sure there's some sort of trans-protest somewhere within the world of the IDW TMNT, but the lives of the TMNT dealing with mutants and monsters, the Foot Clan and you know... GOING TO OUTER SPACE AND TIME TRAVEL that they're so far removed from 'human world' problems that you really wouldn't see it except for maybe a poster or flag in the background if they absolutely must mention it somewhere. In fact unless Trump has a new order to dismantle the New York sewer system, nothing going on with us in the real world would affect the Turtles in any way. And the comic isn't really about 'can April and Casey get a job in today's economy' so none of that stuff should affect the story.

Leo's reaction would only have made sense if Lita was an actual mutant turtle (rather than a mutated human) and turned back into a regular pet shop turtle.

TheLabRat
10-29-2025, 10:40 AM
Basically, this is another story about Leo feeling angry and helpless because he couldn't protect his family, so he need a hug.

For a similar story, I prefer 2003 TMNT where 2003 Leo becomes ruthless towards his enemies, and even approaches self-destruction tendencie in S4. He also angry about his brothers can't take training seriously and the potential threats they might face, but he had good reason.

ToTheNines
10-29-2025, 03:52 PM
Got a chance to pick this up. Didn’t hate it, but it wasn’t great either.

I did like the art. It reminded me of a more refined Dan Duncan. One nitpick is what’s at the end of Donnie’s bo? The cover makes it looks like plumbing elbows.

I felt it was kind of weird that Donnie didn’t really have a story to share.

I did not care for Mikey’s story, which makes sense because I hate the whole famous actor in Japan thing.

I know Raph’s contribution was mostly there for humor, but I thought it was dumb. I hate the trope of “Raph just likes to fight!” No. Raph just has trouble controlling his anger at times. He’s trained in martial arts his whole life, he should know the potential consequences of throwing down with someone and never just do it for no reason.

And I’m talking about Raph in general. If we’re specifically talking about IDW Raph… isn’t he in like his mid-20’s by now? Why is he regressing in maturity? He was a ****ing cop in Mutant Town for Christ sake.

The Leo part was fine. I’m an eldest, so I could relate. I did think the 4 Fleck brothers parallel was too heavy handed. Could have been 3 brothers, or throw a sister or two in there. Would have been less on the nose.

Ultimately a pretty forgettable annual. Mild spoiler, but zero connection to Battle Nexus. I assume this just exists as a precursor to how the next writer wants to portray Leo.

Andrew NDB
10-29-2025, 04:03 PM
Yeah, I thought "Is that Dan Duncan?" too, right off the bat.

Speaking of Dan Duncan... did that guy ever do even any small TMNT stuff after his run? Just totally "done" with it, huh? Enough was enough?

ToTheNines
10-29-2025, 04:07 PM
Yeah, I thought "Is that Dan Duncan?" too, right off the bat.

Speaking of Dan Duncan... did that guy ever do even any small TMNT stuff after his run? Just totally "done" with it, huh? Enough was enough?

He penciled the Shredder micro, which was really good. One splash page for the City Fall issue where Kitsune brain washed Leo. Several covers, most notably the Ultimate hardcovers.

I think that’s it.

Heyowakka
10-29-2025, 04:56 PM
I believe Dan Duncan drew issue 4 of Turtles in Time as well.

ToTheNines
10-29-2025, 05:08 PM
I believe Dan Duncan drew issue 4 of Turtles in Time as well.

Yes, good catch! If Hypered sees this, he’ll tell us everything. He’s a living IDW encyclopedia lol

CyberCubed
10-29-2025, 05:24 PM
Honestly this felt very similar to an old Mirage Tales of the TMNT issue. Basically a one-shot story without a cliffhanger that could fit into the timeline. They introduce a new villain who is more or less dealt with in the same issue and doesn't have to come back. Reminded me of a Tales issue a lot, both the artwork and the story.

Also the Lynx mutant reminded me a lot of a cartoon villain from somewhere, but I can't place it. I've been thinking back to all the cartoons I've watched over the last 30+ years and he reminds me of someone, maybe a Disney cartoon villain? He looks familiar.

hypered1
10-29-2025, 06:51 PM
Yes, good catch! If Hypered sees this, he’ll tell us everything. He’s a living IDW encyclopedia lol

I think the only thing that hasn't been mentioned is the short story 'A Lot to Learn' from the 30th Anniversary special.

TheLabRat
10-29-2025, 10:24 PM
And I’m talking about Raph in general. If we’re specifically talking about IDW Raph… isn’t he in like his mid-20’s by now? Why is he regressing in maturity? He was a ****ing cop in Mutant Town for Christ sake.

To be honest, even in Mutant Town arc, Raph become a cop didn't bring him any positive dynamic. Alopex hate him. Jennika blamed him for not arriving in time to stop Punk Frogs from burning down the dojo. Leo should have been able to understand Raph's situation and could even have tried to help him, but he did nothing. It feels like "Raph become a cop" isn't part of character development, but rather a way to create conflict.

Dancefloran
10-30-2025, 01:36 AM
I've noticed writers hseem to have an issue in displaying feelings for normally stoic characters without somehow turning them into whiny little bitches.

The Lita incident is just so non-sensical within the context of the story and the overall world of the TMNT that it had to be some sort of shoe-horned trans-allegory based on real world politics that have no bearing in that world.

I'm sure there's some sort of trans-protest somewhere within the world of the IDW TMNT, but the lives of the TMNT dealing with mutants and monsters, the Foot Clan and you know... GOING TO OUTER SPACE AND TIME TRAVEL that they're so far removed from 'human world' problems that you really wouldn't see it except for maybe a poster or flag in the background if they absolutely must mention it somewhere. In fact unless Trump has a new order to dismantle the New York sewer system, nothing going on with us in the real world would affect the Turtles in any way. And the comic isn't really about 'can April and Casey get a job in today's economy' so none of that stuff should affect the story.

Leo's reaction would only have made sense if Lita was an actual mutant turtle (rather than a mutated human) and turned back into a regular pet shop turtle.

Feel free to make a connection between trans and mutants but I don't think that was the point...
What Bob did to Lita is called a violation, Lita didn't have a say in the matter. It isn't relevant to the characters if you think that its better to be human than mutant here. By that logic Leo should be a self-hating weirdo and commit seppuku.

Everything in art doesn't need to tell something, but a story without themes, questions or lessons is boring at my age.

I can see your emotions in your post, and I won't call you a "whiny little bitch" for that. It's okay to not like everything.

Dancefloran
10-30-2025, 01:42 AM
To be honest, even in Mutant Town arc, Raph become a cop didn't bring him any positive dynamic. Alopex hate him. Jennika blamed him for not arriving in time to stop Punk Frogs from burning down the dojo. Leo should have been able to understand Raph's situation and could even have tried to help him, but he did nothing. It feels like "Raph become a cop" isn't part of character development, but rather a way to create conflict.


That was bad writing honestly, I didn't understand that part either

Dancefloran
10-30-2025, 01:48 AM
This Annual was great !
The new villain is horrific and interesting.
The four brothers are represented with their personalities respected and I loved the dynamic here.

ToTheNines
10-30-2025, 05:33 AM
I think the only thing that hasn't been mentioned is the short story 'A Lot to Learn' from the 30th Anniversary special.

Clutch. I knew you’d come with something we forgot haha.


Off topic, but are you into any other versions of TMNT? You’re like an IDW expert, but I don’t believe I’ve seen you post in any other sections here.

Zog The Magnificent
10-30-2025, 08:06 AM
Feel free to make a connection between trans and mutants but I don't think that was the point...
What Bob did to Lita is called a violation, Lita didn't have a say in the matter. It isn't relevant to the characters if you think that its better to be human than mutant here. By that logic Leo should be a self-hating weirdo and commit seppuku.

Everything in art doesn't need to tell something, but a story without themes, questions or lessons is boring at my age.

I'd say the allegory was pretty clear. The Campbell run was pretty blatent in it's themes and messaging many times. The problem is that there was no "violation." Lita was cured. Fixing Mutant Town was something that was set up as a net good back at the start. If she had been a turtle, turned back into a turtle, then it would have made sense to mourn the loss of the person. But she wasn't. She was a person who got cured of a disease, which in ANY OTHER story, including other TMNT versions, would have been a good thing. But because it was tied into the really laboured and nonsensical point the author wanted to make, we have the characters suddenly acting like it's a bad thing. That moment was one of the single stupidest things in the entire Cambpell run.

hypered1
10-30-2025, 08:17 AM
Clutch. I knew you’d come with something we forgot haha.


Off topic, but are you into any other versions of TMNT? You’re like an IDW expert, but I don’t believe I’ve seen you post in any other sections here.

I grew up with the og movies and cartoon and I know of some bts stuff from them but fell off when they ended.
We didn't really have the Mirage comics here in the UK and the Archie run was partially incorporated into our own Fleetway publication which I never kept up with either.
Wasn't until about issue 55/56 that I discovered the IDW series and had to do some catching up, but fortunately the first couple of hardcovers were out by then so I grabbed them up immediately.

Also I double checked, Dan Duncan also did a couple of pages for issues 23, 100 & 150.