View Full Version : What did you think of Mirage's old Turtle Soup specials?
CyberCubed
11-22-2025, 01:44 PM
The first Turtle Soup came out in 1987, and then they made a second edition of 4-issues after that featuring short stories from a whole bunch of artists.
To my knowledge these comics have never been reprinted, I don't think IDW has ever reprinted the stories here in any of their collections.
You can actually buy them all on this site:
https://fan.kevineastmanstudios.com/product/a-turtle-soup-anthology-cowabundle/
What did you think of them?
ToTheNines
11-23-2025, 08:22 PM
I feel like most of the stories were non-canon, but they’re all really fun. Leonardo and Usagi’s first meeting is in the first issue, so that’s pretty significant.
I’m having trouble remembering much else specifically. There are so many great shorts from Mirage in the 80’s. It’s hard to remember which books they came from sometimes.
That series of Dooney covers on the second volume are all incredible too. I might bust these out next time I get the chance.
CyberCubed
11-23-2025, 09:06 PM
IDW really needs to do a Turtle Soup trade, the 1987 issue and the second volume of 4-issues, all 5 issues in one collection.
People forget that outside of Vol. 4 and Tales V.2, there's a whole bunch of Mirage specials and mini-series like these IDW has never collected. Sadly I don't think we'll ever get them as they're relatively obscure compared to everything else. Same for the Flaming Carrot 4-issue crossover, the 2-part Savage Dragon ones, the Michael Dooney Challenges book, etc.
Andrew NDB
11-23-2025, 11:23 PM
Plenty of great canon stories in there. Prelude to Twilight of the Ring, the story where grown up Chet meets the Turtles. A Lucindra bit story.
Smithguy789
11-24-2025, 07:09 AM
Like any anthology comic, they're hit-and-miss. When Turtle Soup hits, it hits BIG. When it misses, it's pretty rough. "In the Army Now" from TS #1 is up there with some of the worst Turtle comics ever. But the Anderson/McCollum and Farley stuff alone is worth the price of admission.
I really wish Turtle Soup and Plastron Café would have caught on more than they did and went on for more issues. I think anthologies with cartoonists really work with the Turtles. Hell, Black, White & Green is the best thing IDW's put out since the first arc of the ongoing.
Great Hierophant
02-26-2026, 07:07 PM
IDW might have difficulties republishing some of these stories, specifically those not created by Mirage employees, due to Mirage's unstructured approach to reprinting rights in the early years. How many of those short stories escaped the work for hire contracts is unknown.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.