View Full Version : Could Saturday Morning Adventures last as long as the Archie Adventures run?
CyberCubed
12-01-2025, 09:42 PM
Archie Adventures run lasted 72 issues (although if you count all the specials/mini-series, it's over 100+ issues), and Saturday Morning Adventures is up to issue 31 and one or two specials so far.
Assuming IDW itself doesn't implode or lose the license, could we have another TMNT cartoon comic last as long as the Archie run did?
Coola Yagami
12-01-2025, 09:46 PM
One thing for sure. It already ran circles around the Dreamwave run.
Heyowakka
12-01-2025, 10:07 PM
I’d like to think that as long as the comic’s quality stays consistent and IDW doesn’t die that Saturday Morning Adventures would have a long life ahead of it. It’s certainly doing better than most here thought it would.
CyberCubed
12-01-2025, 10:11 PM
IDW canceled the Rise of the TMNT comics early.
IDW canceled the Tales/Mutant Mayhem comics already (although that was inevitable)
IDW's Nick 2012 comics did last a long time, probably over 50 issues if you count everything together. So this series has a bit to go before taking over the 2012 comics.
ToTheNines
12-02-2025, 03:33 AM
2012 ended up with 48 issues between NAA, AA, Batman, RobotAnimals and the Carmelo Anthony special.
SMA will be at 43 issues at the end of this upcoming Pantheon arc. That includes the original 4 issue miniseries, and 4 specials. There’s also the “What About Tomorrow” short from the 40th anniversary comic. I’m not counting that as an issue, but it’s really good and worth mentioning.
I think it could go on a long time. There’s no shortage of FW characters to play with and they also pull from Mirage, IDW, 2012, 4kids, etc.
It just has to survive the meme of “IDW is going out of business any day now!”
neatoman
12-02-2025, 06:06 AM
Well, SMA has already lasted much longer than I expected and it didn't need to get relabeled/revived to achieve this unlike the 2012 tie-in comics, so it very well could go on to last 73+ issues. It's just... A little sad to think to think that what started out as FW tie-in might get surpassed by another FW tie-in, over 30 years after that show ended.
Heyowakka
12-02-2025, 06:18 AM
How could it possibly be sad when I’m having such a good time?
CyberCubed
12-02-2025, 06:21 AM
I'm just surprised it has so many issues already. I feel like this series came out of nowhere to cash in on the Shredder's Revenge game and Cowabunga Collection when the games were coming out, and it already has over 40 issues?
I mean this series would be something I would be all over if it came out 20 years ago when I was a teen/early 20's. I'm still following it but I admit I would have been 10 times more enthused if it came out when I was younger.
ToTheNines
12-02-2025, 02:06 PM
Well, SMA has already lasted much longer than I expected and it didn't need to get relabeled/revived to achieve this unlike the 2012 tie-in comics, so it very well could go on to last 73+ issues. It's just... A little sad to think to think that what started out as FW tie-in might get surpassed by another FW tie-in, over 30 years after that show ended.
Well TMNTA spun-off from early season 2 and SMA picks up after season 7 and has like 30 years of lore from other versions to pull from. I get what you’re saying. The inability/unwillingness to move on from FW stuff, but it’s a solid book and it’s not the flagship title or anything.
I’m much more frustrated by the state of TMNT film, animation and the main line of comics.
How could it possibly be sad when I’m having such a good time?
Yeah, it’s pretty darn good. It’s probably the best paced monthly comic series I’ve followed in the past 20 years that wasn’t an anthology.
I was being such a little hard-ass about continuity and some of the art, but I’ve grown to accept it as its own thing and really enjoy Meyers’ art now. But nothing beats the Ghostbusters holy trinity when they get together.
I'm just surprised it has so many issues already. I feel like this series came out of nowhere to cash in on the Shredder's Revenge game and Cowabunga Collection when the games were coming out, and it already has over 40 issues?
I mean this series would be something I would be all over if it came out 20 years ago when I was a teen/early 20's. I'm still following it but I admit I would have been 10 times more enthused if it came out when I was younger.
I know what you mean. It would have seemed like a bigger deal. When I saw it was announced I felt like the significance was lost in a sea of TMNT content.
But now that I’m into it, it’s probably the book I look forward to the most each month at this point.
This comic seemed like a no brainer for IDW since they acquired the license, I'm surprised it took them this long counting they were doing similar stuff with their other properties like transformers.
It technically already outlasted the 'original' Archie run that was based off the FW cartoon before it became its own continuity. And I actually think IDW did not treat this title with respect when it was first announced, glad that it's apparently doing good.
I'd like to see them incorporate robot Tokka/Rahzar and any other exclusive FW stuff that has been made up after the show ended, like it'd be cool to see TigerClaw one day since he did get stuck there for a while, or some reference to Shredder's revenge, grow the Casey/April relationship since all FW Licensing stuff now always has FW casey/april together a lot despite barely interacting before. I read that they briefly hint at the crossovers happening etc. As long as they respect continuity I think it's neat. I wish they had canonized Lotus Blossom as karai but whatever.
Heyowakka
12-02-2025, 05:44 PM
Karai was name dropped in issue #25, so there’s more than a possibility of her appearing! I imagine they’d base her on her Shredder’s Revenge incarnation.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2025, 05:49 PM
Not a good chance before IDW cancels it and starts a new volume with a new #1 they can capitalize on at least once or twice.
Coola Yagami
12-02-2025, 06:07 PM
Not a good chance before IDW cancels it and starts a new volume with a new #1 they can capitalize on at least once or twice.
Honestly if the Red Sky wasn't looked so down upon, they could easily end it after issue 50 and start a new number 1 with TMNT Saturday Morning Red Sky Adventures. Though if they did that I'm sure they'd find some way to either explain what happened to the rest of the cast or show off new 'Red Sky' versions of them. I doubt knowing fan reception of Red Sky, they wouldn't resist the urge to still throw in Leatherhead, Slash, Mona Lisa and the rest.
ToTheNines
12-02-2025, 06:40 PM
So if you count everything, TMNTA had exactly 100 issues. Plus 3 more if you count Year of the Turtle and 12 more if you count both volumes of Mighty Mutanimals. So 115.
And of course Turtles Club has continued the main volume up to #80, with more to come. So 123 issues after #80 comes out.
I would be very surprised if SMA surpasses that.
This comic seemed like a no brainer for IDW since they acquired the license, I'm surprised it took them this long counting they were doing similar stuff with their other properties like transformers.
It technically already outlasted the 'original' Archie run that was based off the FW cartoon before it became its own continuity. And I actually think IDW did not treat this title with respect when it was first announced, glad that it's apparently doing good.
I'd like to see them incorporate robot Tokka/Rahzar and any other exclusive FW stuff that has been made up after the show ended, like it'd be cool to see TigerClaw one day since he did get stuck there for a while, or some reference to Shredder's revenge, grow the Casey/April relationship since all FW Licensing stuff now always has FW casey/april together a lot despite barely interacting before. I read that they briefly hint at the crossovers happening etc. As long as they respect continuity I think it's neat. I wish they had canonized Lotus Blossom as karai but whatever.
Tiger Claw showed up as a group of villains assembled by Mr. Ogg that was comprised of villains from the turtles’ past, present and future. Obviously Dregg and Rat Queen were from the future. But TC could have gone either way, so it’s not entirely clear if the 2012 crossover already happened or not.
Turtles Forever’s Technodrome makes a cameo and is referred to as a Technodrome from the future.
Karai was name dropped in issue #25, so there’s more than a possibility of her appearing! I imagine they’d base her on her Shredder’s Revenge incarnation.
I couldn’t tell if that was a throwaway reference or if they have plans for her. Regardless, I thought it was weird that Krang knew of her but Shredder didn’t.
Coola Yagami
12-02-2025, 07:44 PM
So if you count everything, TMNTA had exactly 100 issues. Plus 3 more if you count Year of the Turtle and 12 more if you count both volumes of Mighty Mutanimals. So 115.
And of course Turtles Club has continued the main volume up to #80, with more to come. So 123 issues after #80 comes out.
I would be very surprised if SMA surpasses that.
Tiger Claw showed up as a group of villains assembled by Mr. Ogg that was comprised of villains from the turtles’ past, present and future. Obviously Dregg and Rat Queen were from the future. But TC could have gone either way, so it’s not entirely clear if the 2012 crossover already happened or not.
Turtles Forever’s Technodrome makes a cameo and is referred to as a Technodrome from the future.
I couldn’t tell if that was a throwaway reference or if they have plans for her. Regardless, I thought it was weird that Krang knew of her but Shredder didn’t.
The way it sounded, Krang made it sound like Karai was another ninja for hire and not a member of the Foot Clan. The FW Foot Clan doesn't even exist anymore other than something for Shredder to constantly boast about being the leader of. I mean... at this point the clan is just the robot Foot Soldiers right? Krang would never call himself a member and Shredder would never consider Bebop and Rocksteady to be members.
The FW Foot Clan is just Shredder and Splinter.
ToTheNines
12-03-2025, 02:45 AM
The way it sounded, Krang made it sound like Karai was another ninja for hire and not a member of the Foot Clan. The FW Foot Clan doesn't even exist anymore other than something for Shredder to constantly boast about being the leader of. I mean... at this point the clan is just the robot Foot Soldiers right? Krang would never call himself a member and Shredder would never consider Bebop and Rocksteady to be members.
The FW Foot Clan is just Shredder and Splinter.
That’s a largely skipped over part of the origin. Clearly there are members that outrank Saki and Yoshi, like the old sensei that believed Yoshi was trying to kill him after Saki framed him.
Yoshi being exiled somehow allowed Saki to take over and turn the clan into an “empire of crime” and there’s the very brief scene of humans in the same outfits as the robot Foot Solider’s that rob the lady eating ice cream (stick em up!).
But it’s never explained what happened to his human forces between that moment and him falling in with Krang.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.