View Full Version : Casey Jones #3 preview and discussion
hypered1
12-16-2025, 12:46 PM
https://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_1-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_2-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_3-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_4-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_5-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_6-666x1024.webphttps://comicbookclublive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CaseyJones_03_7-666x1024.webp
Dancefloran
12-16-2025, 01:14 PM
I like how this Geena Getz character subplot was hinted at in both issues #1 and #2. Very subtle.
neatoman
12-16-2025, 04:02 PM
I like how this Geena Getz character subplot was hinted at in both issues #1 and #2. Very subtle.
Geena Getz? The name didn't seem that familiar, so I googled it. Interesting first result:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/aa/Fly_poster.jpg
In case you don't know:
Geena Davis and John Getz are the actors who play Ronnie and Stathis, the two journalists who are the only ones who know what's going on with Brundle. I can't really think of anything else it could be a reference to, they're fairly unique names (at least in spelling) and I don't believe they're in any other movie together.
Dancefloran
12-17-2025, 01:23 AM
Geena Getz? The name didn't seem that familiar, so I googled it. Interesting first result:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/aa/Fly_poster.jpg
In case you don't know:
Geena Davis and John Getz are the actors who play Ronnie and Stathis, the two journalists who are the only ones who know what's going on with Brundle. I can't really think of anything else it could be a reference to, they're fairly unique names (at least in spelling) and I don't believe they're in any other movie together.
That's quite the reference !
jestergoblin
12-17-2025, 11:58 AM
I love how reckless Casey is.
The mirroring of Casey going to a veterinarian and Ludovic seeing a doctor was a fun switch.
Surprised to see a Jennika appearance on the couch.
So Nostrum makes mutants more human allegedly, and gives humans healing/rejuvenation powers, plus super strength - clearly at the expense of sanity.
Either way, Casey looks pissed in issue 4.
ToTheNines
12-17-2025, 03:28 PM
Really not feeling this series.
Only notable thing for me was how the writer and editor seemingly forgot the reincarnation origin. Casey says “they were training in ninjutsu while I was still learning to ride my tricycle”. No, they were dead lol
Obviously you can no-prize it and say Casey has brain damage or something, but it was obviously a screw-up. Time to reboot this ****!
Also, Jennika looked so out of place on that couch. Like she was drawn in by a different artist after the fact.
Dancefloran
12-17-2025, 04:07 PM
I enjoy where this serie is going, we're only halfway through and it seems that Casey will get some character development ! Hopefully before he gets himself killed !
So Ludovic really is an animal-born mutant who wants to be human, so he's not the same as Bob and Barlow. Old Hob would call him a "Bounty" (when a black person wants to be white and acts like it) lollll.
So the Nostrum enhances strenght, healing and cognitive abilites, so this what replaces the psychotropic compound. Was Stockman involved I wonder ? He might be part of that rich guy club.
We also might have an explanation for Lao Ban's cognitive abilites.
I also noticed that more TMNTverse cartoon characters have been adapted : Warren Stone the TV talk show host and Jane the Veterinarian.
Dancefloran
12-17-2025, 04:10 PM
Only notable thing for me was how the writer and editor seemingly forgot the reincarnation origin. Casey says “they were training in ninjutsu while I was still learning to ride my tricycle”. No, they were dead lol
Obviously you can no-prize it and say Casey has brain damage or something, but it was obviously a screw-up. Time to reboot this ****!
.
You know he meant to compare what they were doing as kids when they had the same age, not what they were doing at the time Casey was a kid.
Andrew NDB
12-17-2025, 04:34 PM
You know he meant to compare what they were doing as kids when they had the same age, not what they were doing at the time Casey was a kid.
That would be the No-Prize answer, for sure.
CyberCubed
12-17-2025, 05:44 PM
So nobody caught that Dr. Jane Goodfellow from the original cartoon made her debut this issue? I recognize her right away, she's drawn exactly the same with the same hairstyle:
https://turtlepedia.fandom.com/wiki/Jane_Goodfellow
Another obscure Fred Wolf character appears this series. She was in Pigeon Pete's "original show" debut ep as well.
I wonder if Dr. Jane Goodfellow was April's original character model, before they whitewashed her and made her have vitiligo in the 1987 cartoon.
Heyowakka
12-17-2025, 06:42 PM
I wonder if Dr. Jane Goodfellow was April's original character model, before they whitewashed her and made her have vitiligo in the 1987 cartoon.
It makes perfect sense since Fujiko Mine was originally black in the episode she appeared in the yellow jumpsuit before they remembered she’s Japanese. Don’t look it up, I promise it’s true.
neatoman
12-17-2025, 07:12 PM
I enjoy where this serie is going, we're only halfway through and it seems that Casey will get some character development ! Hopefully before he gets himself killed !
So Ludovic really is an animal-born mutant who wants to be human, so he's not the same as Bob and Barlow. Old Hob would call him a "Bounty" (when a black person wants to be white and acts like it) lollll.
So the Nostrum enhances strenght, healing and cognitive abilites, so this whats replaces the psychotropic compound. Was Stockman involved I wonder ? He might be part of that rich guy club.
We also might have an explanation for Lao Ban's cognitive abilites.
I also noticed that more TMNTverse cartoon characters have been adapted : Warren Stone the TV talk show host and Jane the Veterinarian.
Hm, yeah I should have guessed he started out as an animal. I did wonder if he wasn't in the last issue because the artwork and dialogue wasn't clear about what he meant by "becoming more human". I thought it was implying his claws were turning into fingernails but now I guess it was just meant to look like his fine motor skills are improving, is that it?
Oh, and also:
I wonder if they'll actually turn that guy into an earthworm?
Also, Jennika looked so out of place on that couch. Like she was drawn in by a different artist after the fact.
Yeah, I don't know why the spin-off books still bother with this character when the main book has pretended she doesn't exist for over a year.
Heyowakka
12-17-2025, 07:15 PM
Yeah, I don't know why the spin-off books still bother with this character when the main book has pretended she doesn't exist for over a year.
Maybe they’re contractually obligated to remind readers she exists. :lol:
TheLabRat
12-17-2025, 08:20 PM
Somehow, he began to follow a path similar to Hun. I guess this is what they mean by "like father, like son." I wonder if side effect of Nostrum will be permanent? Especially his two previous near-death experiences had also damaged his brain, making him more irritable each time.
ToTheNines
12-18-2025, 11:26 AM
You know he meant to compare what they were doing as kids when they had the same age, not what they were doing at the time Casey was a kid.
That would be the No-Prize answer, for sure.
Yeah I checked it again. Feels like a stretch. The sentiment isn’t inaccurate, it just doesn’t seem like a thought Casey would actually have, knowing their story (and within the context of IDW, it should also be relevant that the turtles are jacked up on a super soldier serum and Casey isn’t, but that mostly feels forgotten about too.)
Between this and the Shredder series seemingly forgetting that Saki was only resurrected for a short time, it just feels like the writers have forgotten some important details from early in the run that made IDW unique and they’re just relying on general TMNT knowledge.
Which is probably fine for most readers. But I’m a borderline autistic weirdo on a message board in 2025, so it’s my job to point these things out lol.
Andrew NDB
12-18-2025, 11:28 AM
You really have to blame editorial for these types of things. They're asleep at the wheel. They should be able to guide good writers who are only casual fans to stay within the lines if they're actively doing their job. If DC used to be able to do that for books with hundreds upon hundreds of issues of continuity, there's no reason IDW can't do that for one damn book.
ToTheNines
12-18-2025, 11:32 AM
You really have to blame editorial for these types of things. They're asleep at the wheel. They should be able to guide good writers who are only casual fans to stay within the lines if they're actively doing their job.
True. Things were different when Tom and Bobby were on the book full time. Which was a VERY long time by comic book standards.
This issue was also likely written close to the time the last guy got replaced. Might have slipped through during the transition.
Although now that we’re having flubs like this and big name creatives on the main ongoing, TMNT is basically a Big Two book now haha
Heyowakka
12-18-2025, 05:19 PM
Just finished the issue, and yeah, Casey’s comment about the Turtles’ age caught me off guard like it did to others. Whatever the writer’s intentions were, they did not translate well in the dialogue, that is assuming they didn’t just make a mistake and thought the IDW Turtles had the same history as most iterations do, in which case it would be an issue with the editor.
All in all, I’m not feeling this Casey mini-series too much, which is sad because a mutant snow leopard who kidnaps mutants for his master to hunt down like animals has the making of a really entertaining story, but so far it just hasn’t sparked.
Seeing Dr. Jane Goodfellow get a cameo was nice. It’s funny how she looks EXACTLY like she does in the Fred Wolf toon.
Now all I can think about is Michelangelo’s pigeon Pete getting mutated in Saturday Morning Adventures since all continuities must have a Pigeon Pete now. :lol:
Look at Jennika acting like she’s one of the gang. Her dead-eyed stare is probably the funniest thing in the issue.
Dancefloran
12-18-2025, 06:53 PM
Hmm I still think you guys took Casey's thoughts too literally... which gives it a different meaning but OK.
That's why I'm not mad and not sarcastic about it.
Autism can be tricky sometimes, I know it all too well.
However, Jennika being included and sidelined at the same time feels weird...
neatoman
12-18-2025, 07:06 PM
Like I said, I don't see the point of even bothering to just have her there. I mean it's not like it's rare for unpopular characters to get quietly phased out or even dropped without explanation in other comics. She's already been dropped from the main book and I can't even see her on covers for books she's still in. Maybe it's difficult to figure out how to do it without "introducing" a way of turning her back into a human, but of we've already seen at least seven characters revert back to human form, so it's not like some "new" idea would be introduced if they did that.
Andrew NDB
12-18-2025, 07:55 PM
I'm sure the plan has always been for some big reintroduction of her in the main book. Later. Eventually. If whoever they have on the book actually wants to do that.
GameCobra
12-19-2025, 08:22 PM
I thought this series was pretty good. Ludovic was a pretty good character I find. Just a question of how long he'll push this agenda. Something tells me he's going to be Old Hob's antagonist down the road.
As for Casey:
I feel like they found an angle to get him to become stronger than even the turtles for a change, but are steering him into a possible villain role. Jennika showing up was weird as well. It either feels forced or they do have plans for her, but then again: She wants to still be by the turtle's side, so I might be overthinking it.
TheLabRat
12-20-2025, 01:41 AM
I
As for Casey:
I feel like they found an angle to get him to become stronger than even the turtles for a change, but are steering him into a possible villain role. Jennika showing up was weird as well. It either feels forced or they do have plans for her, but then again: She wants to still be by the turtle's side, so I might be overthinking it.
He may not become a villain, but his action could lead to worse situation that really screwed up his friendship with the turtles, and even April given up on giving him a chance.
However, I think this miniseries is just a allegory so Casey will get over difficult before things get worse. Perhaps after about 10 issues, he will repeat the same mistakes.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.