View Full Version : Do you consider the Archie series to be a sub-continuity of FW or its own thing?
neatoman
02-17-2026, 08:39 PM
This subject proved more controversial than I thought it was, so we might as have a thread about it. Keep in mind, the poll will show which user voted for what, which I don't normally do but I think is relevant here.
I'd say it does count as its own thing, direct adaptation at the beginning aside, this comic clearly didn't care about keeping consistency with FW and the two are incompatible after a few retcons. It really has no more to do with the FW show than, let's say, the 2012 cartoon.
Heyowakka
02-17-2026, 08:46 PM
The answer is really so simple.
It did indeed start off as a branched off continuity of the Fred Wolf cartoon, but due to story retcons later in the comic’s life it became a continuity that is similar to the Fred Wolf cartoon in many ways, but vastly different in most.
It’s hard to argue about it being anything else.
Powder
02-17-2026, 11:34 PM
Not really sure what the appropriate vote to give is, but yeah, it started as a faithful adaptation of the FW series, then splintered off into its own thing almost immediately, making it a unique continuity/timeline. So they have a shared origin, many similarities, but they're not one cohesive thing, obviously. For me, the Archie turtles & their doings exist independently to that of the Fred Wolf cartoon turtles. I have no problem with the idea that these two universes carry on simultaneously. After all, even the Archie series has issues that are non-canon, so much like Mirage, IDW, there are clearly little deviations that create other, additional parallel universes.
I'm sure it's somewhat similar to how The Legend of Zelda's timeline works.
Smithguy789
02-18-2026, 07:34 AM
I think about it like DC's Hypertime (inasmuch as I'm able to understand about it, not being Grant Morrison)
The FW and Archie timeliness are seperate timelines that begin and end in different places. When we say they "started the same," we're referring to Season One and the first few comics, because that'swhere we as the audience come in. In-universe, the timelines themselves began eons before we see April doing that first newscast.
We know through retcons and flashbacks in both series that the two timelines for the most part, can't exist on the same plane. However, there are moments where the two timelines rub up against each other and intersect, creating similar and, sometimes, one-to-one exact moments between the two. After these intersections, the timelines go their own way and run parallel to each other again.
You could also add the Hero Turtles comics, the newspaper strip, and any other iteration that uses FW as its base, to this hullabaloo if you wanted.
Not sure which poll option covers this.
ToTheNines
02-18-2026, 07:56 AM
What thread were we discussing this in? I’d like to compile an exhaustive list things that transpired before “Turtle Tracks”/TMNTA #1 that make them demonstrably separate universes.
I think about it like DC's Hypertime (inasmuch as I'm able to understand about it, not being Grant Morrison)
The FW and Archie timeliness are seperate timelines that begin and end in different places. When we say they "started the same," we're referring to Season One and the first few comics, because that'swhere we as the audience come in. In-universe, the timelines themselves began eons before we see April doing that first newscast.
We know through retcons and flashbacks in both series that the two timelines for the most part, can't exist on the same plane. However, there are moments where the two timelines rub up against each other and intersect, creating similar and, sometimes, one-to-one exact moments between the two. After these intersections, the timelines go their own way and run parallel to each other again.
You could also add the Hero Turtles comics, the newspaper strip, and any other iteration that uses FW as its base, to this hullabaloo if you wanted.
Not sure which poll option covers this.
Precisely this. FWIW, l voted “No but they are similar”
I can't really speak to the "sub-continuity" thing because that term doesn't really apply from any angle. But the Archie series is clearly it's own continuity that originated with a story that was intentionally similar to the FW season 1 mini-series.
Real World Explanation: Archie got the license to adapt the FW show with a mini-series. It was successful and they retained the license and were told to "just make your own comic book as an approachable kids book rooted in an animation style".
Fantasy World Explanation: The Archie Universe was rooted in the same foundational events as the FW Universe but deviated slightly after the events with the Technodrome and drifted into a different timeline.
Andrew NDB
02-18-2026, 01:48 PM
We could dig in a LITTLE bit, though. Like, at what precise moment had "Dean Clarrain" made up his mind that this was its own thing? RIGHT at #5, with Ray Fillet? With Leatherhead's appearance as Jess Harley, then?
But looking at that... Leatherhead didn't show up in Fred Wolf until November 3, 1989.... while Archie Leatherhead debuted in TMNTA #6 in a cover-dated November, 1989 issue, which means it ACTUALLY hit shelves around September or October. So TMNTA's Leatherhead actually pre-dated Fred Wolf and it was, then, Fred Wolf that was going off the reservation in terms of canon, and not Archie. Probably Dean Clarrain had no idea Fred Wolf would use Leatherhead that early or even at all, and then shortly threw his hands up about that sort of stuff.
ToTheNines
03-03-2026, 01:26 PM
Here's a big one nobody ever talks about: Vernon Fenwick doesn't exist in the Archieverse. Vernon is in the early adaptation stuff, but his last name is "Prinole".
Case closed. Thank you Vernon.
We could dig in a LITTLE bit, though. Like, at what precise moment had "Dean Clarrain" made up his mind that this was its own thing? RIGHT at #5, with Ray Fillet? With Leatherhead's appearance as Jess Harley, then?
But looking at that... Leatherhead didn't show up in Fred Wolf until November 3, 1989.... while Archie Leatherhead debuted in TMNTA #6 in a cover-dated November, 1989 issue, which means it ACTUALLY hit shelves around September or October. So TMNTA's Leatherhead actually pre-dated Fred Wolf and it was, then, Fred Wolf that was going off the reservation in terms of canon, and not Archie. Probably Dean Clarrain had no idea Fred Wolf would use Leatherhead that early or even at all, and then shortly threw his hands up about that sort of stuff.
The early early stuff was all scripted by Dooney (original mini), Dave Garcia (#1-2), and Ken/Beth Mitchroney (#3-4). They brought in Murph to write original stories starting with #5 because Fred Wolf Films was getting litigious over Archie using their scripts.
I don't know if this was related to them suing Mirage over royalties, or a separate legal matter all together.
Coola Yagami
03-03-2026, 09:20 PM
It's funny how those early comics didn't even bother to draw Irma on-model. Vernon was off-model too but vaguely looked like himself and Burne mostly kept the same look but they didn't even try with Irma.
But yea, the Archie comics were its own thing. Not even the Man Ray story fits because Shredder just randomly had Bebop and Rocksteady with him before Krang ever sent them back.
neatoman
03-03-2026, 09:48 PM
We could dig in a LITTLE bit, though. Like, at what precise moment had "Dean Clarrain" made up his mind that this was its own thing? RIGHT at #5, with Ray Fillet? With Leatherhead's appearance as Jess Harley, then?
But looking at that... Leatherhead didn't show up in Fred Wolf until November 3, 1989.... while Archie Leatherhead debuted in TMNTA #6 in a cover-dated November, 1989 issue, which means it ACTUALLY hit shelves around September or October. So TMNTA's Leatherhead actually pre-dated Fred Wolf and it was, then, Fred Wolf that was going off the reservation in terms of canon, and not Archie. Probably Dean Clarrain had no idea Fred Wolf would use Leatherhead that early or even at all, and then shortly threw his hands up about that sort of stuff.
I mean... I guess not? Then again, Leatherhead's backstory in Archie doesn't really resemble the one he has in Archie either, if anything FW is more accurate in that department. What was expected to happen there? That the FW would respect what Archie established? That would be rich, if it wasn't for the toyline, I don't think these two iterations would have anything in common past the point where the comic stopped adapting the show. If characters Cherubae or Ninjara were to show up in FW, it would be quite odd simply because it was more likely for FW to steal scripts from Transformers than ever look into what other iterations of the franchise did.
And it's not like when this stuff happened really matters. Even if it wasn't the intention to split that early and the assumption really was that Leatherhead's origin wouldn't pose any contradiction, it doesn't actually matter, it's still an irreconcilable difference.
But still, when exactly was it decided that it was going to be its own thing? Ignoring, as you said, the contradictory characters that appeared in Archie first? Well, I doubt there was ever any real intention to stick to continuity, but it seems like the "decision" still happened at least as early as issue 13. Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady getting (essentially permanently) exiled and separated from Shredder simply can't have happened in FW and it's pretty damn obvious that the show was never going to go there.
ToTheNines
03-04-2026, 03:53 AM
That’s not what he’s saying at all. He’s saying that if you were following that book as it came out, the mini and first 4 issues of the ongoing are obviously FW adaptations (except for little things like Vernon Prinole, or Irma’s drastically different appearance like Coola said), then #5 was obviously a new story but doesn’t necessarily contradict anything, so maybe it’s still the same continuity.
But with #6, the show staff and comic staff were just obviously not in any form of contact. It’s hard to know the actual timeline of conception, pre-production, completion and release of #6 vs. Leatherhead’s debut, but they had clearly already completely diverged and neither team cared what the other was doing.
neatoman
03-04-2026, 04:32 PM
That’s not what he’s saying at all. He’s saying that if you were following that book as it came out, the mini and first 4 issues of the ongoing are obviously FW adaptations (except for little things like Vernon Prinole, or Irma’s drastically different appearance like Coola said), then #5 was obviously a new story but doesn’t necessarily contradict anything, so maybe it’s still the same continuity.
But with #6, the show staff and comic staff were just obviously not in any form of contact. It’s hard to know the actual timeline of conception, pre-production, completion and release of #6 vs. Leatherhead’s debut, but they had clearly already completely diverged and neither team cared what the other was doing.
I don't get why you think I misunderstood that. Of course I understand that if you were to read the Leatherhead debut issue when it came out, the contradiction with the show wouldn't technically happen until a few weeks later when his debut episode aired. All I did was just point out that it doesn't really matter if the contradiction happened on purpose or not.
The rest of the post is building on the question on when it was "decided" it should be its own thing, rather than just possibly being contradictory by accident/indifference, then it would at the latest be villain exile because that's a huge deliberate turn in the story that the show was never going to do that. This is however a different premise from whether or not the early stories could have fit into the show's continuity, I'm not claiming either creative team knew or cared what the other did. It's that if the intention was to stick to continuity with the show at the beginning, which I don't believe was the case just to be clear, then the clearest deliberate deviation from that would be the exile. It's a different discussion building on the same post. Sorry if that was a bit confusing.
Pointing out that FW Leatherhead's backstory is more similar to the Mirage origin (though only vaguely resembling it in the first place) than Archie's, which is something completely different from either origin, at the start of the post probably didn't help with clarity either. I'll admit it doesn't have much relevance, I was just kind of trying to express that Archie Leatherhead's origin is so unique and different from what anyone would expect even at the time, that I can't exactly blame anyone for this particular contradiction. Had Archie Leatherhead simply been a mutated alligator, like he was in Mirage and ultimately in FW, then one could have conceivably still acted as if there was continuity for longer.
Zog The Magnificent
03-05-2026, 07:34 PM
It's just a branching continuity. It starts out identical to the Fred Wolf show, and then completely splits into it's own timeline from #5 onward. As to why and when, we have a definitive answer to this question: It was definitively it's own thing starting with Issue #5, and it was entirely due to the fact that they didn't have the legal rights to use the Fred Wolf Scripts, necessitating original stories. Here's a quote from Ryan Brown post, that I found through TMNT Entity:
"Summer:1989. The archie book is in utter chaos and on serious brink of
breach of contract. I get the idea to take over the title and dump the
adaptions for new,original stories that meld the Mirage TMNTs with the
animated TMNT and combine the best of both worlds. But I can't do it alone
so before approaching Kev and Pete I go to new-found friend Steve Murphy and
discuss my plans with him and ask if he'd be interested in writing it."
If that hadn't happened, I think it's fair to say they probably would have kept doing episode adaptations for a while.
https://lavignebrownart.blogspot.com/2008/10/dean-clarrain-expos.html
TigerClaw
03-05-2026, 09:14 PM
It's just a branching continuity. It starts out identical to the Fred Wolf show, and then completely splits into it's own timeline from #5 onward. As to why and when, we have a definitive answer to this question: It was definitively it's own thing starting with Issue #5, and it was entirely due to the fact that they didn't have the legal rights to use the Fred Wolf Scripts, necessitating original stories. Here's a quote from Ryan Brown post, that I found through TMNT Entity:
"Summer:1989. The archie book is in utter chaos and on serious brink of
breach of contract. I get the idea to take over the title and dump the
adaptions for new,original stories that meld the Mirage TMNTs with the
animated TMNT and combine the best of both worlds. But I can't do it alone
so before approaching Kev and Pete I go to new-found friend Steve Murphy and
discuss my plans with him and ask if he'd be interested in writing it."
If that hadn't happened, I think it's fair to say they probably would have kept doing episode adaptations for a while.
https://lavignebrownart.blogspot.com/2008/10/dean-clarrain-expos.html
I'm glad that they did, They produced some fantastic stories, Stories that went places no other TMNT comic had ever done.
neatoman
03-05-2026, 09:51 PM
I'm glad that they did, They produced some fantastic stories, Stories that went places no other TMNT comic had ever done.
Well, considering this all happened like five years into the franchise and the main comic was unscheduled with only 26 issues released at that point, it's not all that surprising, is it? It's not exactly shocking that a monthly book that lasted 70+ issues told more stories.
TigerClaw
03-06-2026, 08:22 AM
Well, considering this all happened like five years into the franchise and the main comic was unscheduled with only 26 issues released at that point, it's not all that surprising, is it? It's not exactly shocking that a monthly book that lasted 70+ issues told more stories.
The kind of stories that caused clashes between the writers and the publisher of the comics.
I read about how the people at Archie comics at the time didn't like how the stories were dealing with mature themes.
ToTheNines
07-18-2026, 07:57 PM
The answer is really so simple.
It did indeed start off as a branched off continuity of the Fred Wolf cartoon, but due to story retcons later in the comic’s life it became a continuity that is similar to the Fred Wolf cartoon in many ways, but vastly different in most.
It’s hard to argue about it being anything else.
To expand on this and get specific, TMNTA #45 retcons a ton of aspects of the origin. Mainly they made Yoshi’s frame job that got him banished make much more sense.
Also “Turtle Tracks” makes it clear that Yoshi lived with the turtles as his pets for some time before Shredder poured the ooze on him. The Archie retcon has him happen upon them already in the puddle of mutagen (more in line with the standard “canon event”).
And of course Forever War expands on exactly how and why the turtles and the ooze went down the drain simultaneously.
The kind of stories that caused clashes between the writers and the publisher of the comics.
I read about how the people at Archie comics at the time didn't like how the stories were dealing with mature themes.
Regardless of how they felt, they sure didn’t complain about all the money rolling in. By all accounts it was blowing all their other titles away, including “Archie”.
I’ve heard Chris Allan and others in interviews say that they only put their foot down and vetoed anything like once or twice, max.
neatoman
07-18-2026, 08:11 PM
To expand on this and get specific, TMNTA #45 retcons a ton of aspects of the origin. Mainly they made Yoshi’s frame job that got him banished make much more sense.
Yeah... That's one of the major issues I have with the FW depiction of the origin. I mean, really? He gets banished for holding a knife, a knife he clearly pulled out of the wall because his clothes were pinned by it, not even making any threatening moves with it at all? What kinda crap is that?
ToTheNines
07-18-2026, 08:24 PM
Yeah even as a kid, I always thought it was ridiculous. He didn’t hear or feel Saki doing that behind him? You have to push pretty damn hard to stick a knife in a wall. Also, they saw him struggling to bow.
Then he doesn’t even attempt to explain himself and plead his case? He just stares with his mouth opens and agrees to leave quietly?
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.