PDA

View Full Version : Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years Omnibus vol. 1


ToTheNines
02-19-2026, 03:37 PM
This has been hinted at in a few threads but it deserves its own thread now the I have a real link (thanks to Chaotix12345): https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/804806/tales-of-the-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-mirage-years-omnibus-vol-1-by-kevin-eastman-peter-laird-steve-murphy/

https://images2.penguinrandomhouse.com/cover/9798887244082

This is good news for sure, just not exactly how I would do it. They’re obviously keeping the same theme running from that volume 2 hardcover. They should have also done “The Image Years 1996-1999” before this.

I feel like Tales vol. 1 has been collected and reprinted enough. They should have left those out, stopped at Tales #18 and called this “Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2004-2005” and stuck with that format until they hit 2010.

Back to reality, “Spinal Tapped” is an interesting inclusion. Perhaps the final volume will include the Treasury Edition epilogue. It is one of the most important pieces of Mirage, but would kind of be missing context without those new frontpieces. We’ll see.

Also weird to see Tristan Jones credited. I think his Mirage debut was Tales #36.

CyberCubed
02-19-2026, 04:13 PM
Yeah this is probably the third or even fourth time IDW has collected Tales 1-7, but hey if this gets us the rest of the 70 issue Tales V.2 run and the 16 mini-series issues like Leonardo: Blind Sight then so be it.

Between this and Vol. 4 when the latter gets trades we'll finally be close to IDW collecting most of Mirage outside of specials like Turtle Soup or Flaming Carrot which could come eventually too.

CyberCubed
02-19-2026, 09:23 PM
Also you can all thank me for IDW putting out Tales V. 2 trades and continuing the Archie trades, last year I sold my entire Tales 70+ issue collection on ebay and all my Archie issues, in the hope IDW would reprint them soon in modern collections. I somehow worked my magic.

Andrew NDB
02-20-2026, 12:03 AM
Also you can all thank me for IDW putting out Tales V. 2 trades and continuing the Archie trades, last year I sold my entire Tales 70+ issue collection on ebay and all my Archie issues, in the hope IDW would reprint them soon in modern collections. I somehow worked my magic.

You might not be wrong to some extent. I think the IDW reprint people were spurred into action by realizing not only the scarcity but VALUE of the TMNT Vol. 4 auctions, for example.

Though didn't you take a bath on part of your sales?

member_removed
02-20-2026, 02:24 AM
I gotta buy this to get Blindsight! I already have the Vol 2 issues.

Might be cheaper to buy the single issues :tconfuse:

ToTheNines
02-20-2026, 09:20 AM
I feel like Tales vol. 1 has been collected and reprinted enough. They should have left those out, stopped at Tales #18 and called this “Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2004-2005” and stuck with that format until they hit 2010.

This is a waste of time, but I was deeply pondering this on my nightly dog walk. They could have came out something like this:

Second book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2006-2007". #19-#41 and Raphael: Bad Moon Rising. 27 issues.

Third book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2008-2009". #42-#65 and Michelangelo: The Third Kind. 28 issues.

Fourth and final book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2010-Infinity" #66-70 and then you have to start playing around and getting creative. Donatello: The Brain Thief was late '09, but include that and you're at 9 issues.

Tales 71/"The Paradox of Chudnovsky" makes 10.

Eastman's "Ready, Set, Go" and Lawson's "Night of the Ninja Girl" for the 30th anniversary are a combined 11 pages.

"Monsters", "Gang Wars" and "Old Scores" from the 40th anniversary are a combined 24 pages.

That's still pretty light, so there would have to be a ton of bonus content, but that could be cool. Maybe include the 2007 prequel comics and adaptation? Not Mirage continuity, but an interesting forgotten relic that was written and drawn by the Tales Vol.2 bullpen.

Then instead of leading with Tales Vol. 1, close this one out with the Treasury Edition version with the new frontpieces and of course top it off with that epilogue of old man Donatello putting on the Coltrane record.

The end.

Also you can all thank me for IDW putting out Tales V. 2 trades and continuing the Archie trades, last year I sold my entire Tales 70+ issue collection on ebay and all my Archie issues, in the hope IDW would reprint them soon in modern collections. I somehow worked my magic.

Thank you.

rs_jr
02-21-2026, 04:26 AM
This is a waste of time, but I was deeply pondering this on my nightly dog walk. They could have came out something like this:

Second book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2006-2007". #19-#41 and Raphael: Bad Moon Rising. 27 issues.

Third book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2008-2009". #42-#65 and Michelangelo: The Third Kind. 28 issues.

Fourth and final book "Tales of the TMNT: The Mirage Years 2010-Infinity" #66-70 and then you have to start playing around and getting creative. Donatello: The Brain Thief was late '09, but include that and you're at 9 issues.

Tales 71/"The Paradox of Chudnovsky" makes 10.

Eastman's "Ready, Set, Go" and Lawson's "Night of the Ninja Girl" for the 30th anniversary are a combined 11 pages.

"Monsters", "Gang Wars" and "Old Scores" from the 40th anniversary are a combined 24 pages.

That's still pretty light, so there would have to be a ton of bonus content, but that could be cool. Maybe include the 2007 prequel comics and adaptation? Not Mirage continuity, but an interesting forgotten relic that was written and drawn by the Tales Vol.2 bullpen.

Then instead of leading with Tales Vol. 1, close this one out with the Treasury Edition version with the new frontpieces and of course top it off with that epilogue of old man Donatello putting on the Coltrane record.

The end.



Thank you.

Maybe the can add the unrealeased Mirage sourcebook.

Also they might be rereleasing vol 1 with new front pieces from the treasury edition.


You think if they do the image years that they might do them in black and white

ToTheNines
02-21-2026, 06:09 AM
You think if they do the image years that they might do them in black and white

I do. They did Volume 2 in its original colors and this Tales Omnibus is black & white.

The Sourcebook could be fun. I don’t know how much work was actually done, but I’m sure Tristan would be willing to continue where he left off.

rs_jr
02-22-2026, 05:48 PM
I do. They did Volume 2 in its original colors and this Tales Omnibus is black & white.

The Sourcebook could be fun. I don’t know how much work was actually done, but I’m sure Tristan would be willing to continue where he left off.

I hope they do the volume 3 in black and white.

I hope they come out at faster pace instead of one year maybe two.

I really hope IDW plans to collect not just tales and minis but also all the short stories, including special issues, turtle soup, challenges and mirage mini

DrSpengler
02-23-2026, 08:01 PM
Back to reality, “Spinal Tapped” is an interesting inclusion. Perhaps the final volume will include the Treasury Edition epilogue. It is one of the most important pieces of Mirage, but would kind of be missing context without those new frontpieces. We’ll see.

When I saw "Spinal Tapped" in the content list, I had the same thought. That exclusive content from the Tales Treasury Edition has been some of the rarest and most sought after Mirage stuff for over a decade.

While a part of me can't underestimate IDW's ineptitude and I can't put it past them to miss the new Frontispieces and Epilogue from the Tales Treasury (or to include the Epilogue without the new Frontispieces, which really seems like something they'd do), they've been surprising me a bit lately with some of their deep dives into the Mirage catalog. Like stories from the Mirage Mini Comic Collection getting reprinted. Or "The Paradox of Chudnovsky" popping up in that Best of Renet collection (with no fanfare, like they somehow both did and didn't know how rare that story was).

CyberCubed
02-23-2026, 10:28 PM
I feel like someone working at IDW really is doing their research into comics and timelines. Whoever was in charge of putting out the first trades IDW did for Mirage and Archie from like 2013-2020 or so obviously didn't put any care to what they were doing, from skipped issues to those awful colorizations (remember how the Shredder clones in Return to New York were colored like Power Rangers colors? Yikes.), and other extremely weird colorization choices like Shredder always being in blue and coloring his arms when he didn't have sleeves, etc.

Hopefully whoever was in charge back then got fired or quit, and the new people in charge are doing a much better job. Granted we should have had all this stuff 10 years ago...but I guess better late than never.

rs_jr
02-24-2026, 02:02 AM
When I saw "Spinal Tapped" in the content list, I had the same thought. That exclusive content from the Tales Treasury Edition has been some of the rarest and most sought after Mirage stuff for over a decade.

While a part of me can't underestimate IDW's ineptitude and I can't put it past them to miss the new Frontispieces and Epilogue from the Tales Treasury (or to include the Epilogue without the new Frontispieces, which really seems like something they'd do), they've been surprising me a bit lately with some of their deep dives into the Mirage catalog. Like stories from the Mirage Mini Comic Collection getting reprinted. Or "The Paradox of Chudnovsky" popping up in that Best of Renet collection (with no fanfare, like they somehow both did and didn't know how rare that story was).

Maybe you could approach them to hire to consult on these collection.

ToTheNines
02-25-2026, 07:18 AM
Or "The Paradox of Chudnovsky" popping up in that Best of Renet collection (with no fanfare, like they somehow both did and didn't know how rare that story was).

:lol: this is such a funny statement, but so spot on.

Truly a “Paradox”!

Maybe you could approach them to hire to consult on these collection.

I’m willing to bet they use TMNTEntity as a reference periodically. And I’m definitely willing to bet they’d rather not pay him if they don’t have to lol.

Great Hierophant
02-26-2026, 05:55 PM
I have two questions about this Omnibus.

1. Will all seven issues of Tales Vol. #1 use the original DuoShade versions? In the Compendiums, Tales Vol. 1 #2, #3, #5 & #6 lacked DuoShade tones.

2. Will the frontispieces to the original Vol. 1 stories be included? I do not recall that that they were in the Compendiums. If so, which frontispieces will be includes, the ones from the original issues or the ones from the 2007 Treasury Edition reprint (or both)?

rs_jr
03-01-2026, 08:44 PM
I do. They did Volume 2 in its original colors and this Tales Omnibus is black & white.

The Sourcebook could be fun. I don’t know how much work was actually done, but I’m sure Tristan would be willing to continue where he left off.

Its in black and white :)

https://prhcomics.com/book/?isbn=9798887245188

ToTheNines
03-02-2026, 03:37 PM
Incredible! Thank you!

CyberCubed
05-16-2026, 04:03 PM
Any updates?

TurtleGurkle
05-16-2026, 05:37 PM
Any updates?

Like what?

ToTheNines
07-06-2026, 11:00 AM
First book is currently due out November 4th.

Second book information has LEAKED! Due out April 7th, next year.

https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/838419/tales-of-the-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-mirage-years-omnibus-vol-2-by-peter-laird/9798887245614/

https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/Tales-of-the-TMNT-TMY-Omnibus-Vol-2_Cover-Regular.jpg

CyberCubed
07-06-2026, 12:11 PM
They're collecting the Challenges book from Michael Dooney from the 90's in this? Those stories have never been reprinted before. The story with Raph and the blind woman was adapted into Season 3 of the 4kids cartoon.

Chaotix12345
07-06-2026, 07:56 PM
Great to see the first Moo Mesa crossovers collected. I know they weren't to everyone's taste, but I just love the novelty of the Turtles actually crossing paths with one of their "clones." (All thanks to the Ryan Brown connection.)

ToTheNines
07-06-2026, 09:01 PM
They're collecting the Challenges book from Michael Dooney from the 90's in this? Those stories have never been reprinted before. The story with Raph and the blind woman was adapted into Season 3 of the 4kids cartoon.

Yeah that’s a nice surprise. I still have mine, but it’ll be interesting to see them printed at full size.

They confirmed this will be 4 volumes. I wonder if they’ll have any other deep cuts in the next two. The first two volumes are both 808 pages exactly, according to their listings. This second volume gets exactly half way through Tales, and I’m assuming the fourth book will have The Third Kind and Brain Thief.

The means the third book will just have the Bad Moon Rising mini. I wonder what they’ll do to even out 4 issues worth of pages.

Personally, I’m praying for the 2007 movie prequel comics. Those all felt Tales-adjacent and haven’t been reprinted since the TPB from 20 years ago.

Great to see the first Moo Mesa crossovers collected. I know they weren't to everyone's taste, but I just love the novelty of the Turtles actually crossing paths with one of their "clones." (All thanks to the Ryan Brown connection.)

Yes, that is great news. I hadn’t considered any potential rights issues coming up.

Smithguy789
07-07-2026, 07:03 AM
Personally, I’m praying for the 2007 movie prequel comics. Those all felt Tales-adjacent and haven’t been reprinted since the TPB from 20 years ago.

I'm only quoting/replying to this because it's my wish as well and I want any potential IDW spies on this forum to see this.

CyberCubed
07-07-2026, 07:04 AM
Yeah I noticed Raphael: Bad Moon Rising wasn't listed here, I hope they didn't forget the other 3 mini's, I forgot when the Raph one originally came out, but I know the Mike/Don ones came out at the tail-end of Tales run so they would be one the last book. And yeah, they originally skipped the first Moo Mesa crossover in the softcover Tales trades from 10+ years ago, glad to see they including it this time.

As for the movie books, they should just get their own collection. They reprinted the first and second movie books, they should reprint the third, then collect the 2007 movie prequel comics and the movie adaption into one book like Mirage did. I actually still have the Mirage collection of all the 2007 comics, it's pretty rare now. I'd put it up on ebay the second IDW announces a reprint like I did with all my other Mirage books.

ToTheNines
07-07-2026, 02:28 PM
I'm only quoting/replying to this because it's my wish as well and I want any potential IDW spies on this forum to see this.

I was thinking about this on my long drive today, now I'm kind of doubting they'll be a part of this if they're trying to keep the 4 volumes as even as possible.

The second volume is 24 issues, plus "Challenges". If the third volume is Bad Moon Rising and #36-55, that's 24 plus maybe some rare bonus. Then the fourth would likely be #55-70, The Third Kind and Brain Thief. That makes 24 issues.

That's probably the best was the split it up. I hope they're reprinted in some other way soon though.

Yeah I noticed Raphael: Bad Moon Rising wasn't listed here, I hope they didn't forget the other 3 mini's, I forgot when the Raph one originally came out, but I know the Mike/Don ones came out at the tail-end of Tales run so they would be one the last book. And yeah, they originally skipped the first Moo Mesa crossover in the softcover Tales trades from 10+ years ago, glad to see they including it this time.

As for the movie books, they should just get their own collection. They reprinted the first and second movie books, they should reprint the third, then collect the 2007 movie prequel comics and the movie adaption into one book like Mirage did. I actually still have the Mirage collection of all the 2007 comics, it's pretty rare now. I'd put it up on ebay the second IDW announces a reprint like I did with all my other Mirage books.

They didn't forget Bad Moon Rising. Tales #35 came out June 2007 and BMR #1 was July 2007.

Good point about the 2007 movie comics. Next year is the 20 year anniversary, I'd bet dollars to donuts it gets a hardcover reprint. I do hope they reuse the same cover from the old TPB, with the Mirage #1 rooftop pose.

CyberCubed
07-08-2026, 10:19 PM
I'm wondering, maybe we can get the old Turtle Soups collected in these too? Those comics and their shorts have never been reprinted in anything. The 1987 issue and the 4-issue mini would make 5 issues overall, and they're a pretty big omission in IDW's reprint catalog. IDW has never reprinted them, and they feel like one of the big Mirage stuff still missing.

ToTheNines
07-09-2026, 05:00 AM
Off the top of my head “Turtle Soup and Rabbit Stew” was collected in an out of print TMNT/Usagi TPB and long time ago and “Donatello: The Ring” was included in Vol. 2 of those huge Mirage Compendiums that came out recently.

So IDW is aware of Turtle Soup, at least.

Boco
07-09-2026, 06:11 PM
Some of the Turtle Soup stories were reprinted in that "TMNT Classics" line of TPBs IDW did. And if not there, then in Volume 6 of the Ultimate Collection (that one has "The Howl" and "Turtle Dreams" at least).

And of course one of Zulli's stories was in Turtle Soup volume 2 before IDW reprinted all of his stuff in the "Souls Winter" hardcover.

Andrew NDB
07-09-2026, 06:32 PM
Personally, I’m praying for the 2007 movie prequel comics. Those all felt Tales-adjacent and haven’t been reprinted since the TPB from 20 years ago.

"Tales adjacent" in that they go into the garbage bin adjacent to the desk with all of your Tales comics.

ToTheNines
07-09-2026, 07:46 PM
"Tales adjacent" in that they go into the garbage bin adjacent to the desk with all of your Tales comics.

:lol:

Yeah, they range from “not bad” to “absolutely horrendous”. I just meant they were written by guys like Murph, “Bill Moulage”, Jake Black, etc. & drawn by guys like Ponce, Brizuela and Lawson.

Jim got done soooo dirty. 3 different inkers and one of them was truly one of the worst ink jobs I’ve ever seen in a comic.

I’m just kicking myself in the ass for selling them, since I used to own every Mirage issue, period.

Great Hierophant
07-09-2026, 10:34 PM
The trouble with reprinting all the Turtle Soup stories is that some of them were not written by Mirage staffers. Mirage considered that if an independent artist contributed a TMNT story then they shared joint ownership of that story with Mirage. Mirage held the copyright and trademarks to the TMNT, the author held the copyright to the story and the artwork. Neither could republish the story without the permission of the other. For the full stories, Mirage eventually got most of the independent artists to sign retroactive work for hire contracts (but not Rick Veitch). For these short story jam issues of varying quality, it was not worth it to get exclusive rights to them. Steve Bissette's "Turtle Dreams" from Vol. 1, #1 is a rare exception.

CyberCubed
07-10-2026, 05:34 PM
They also never reprinted some of the one-shot Mirage specials like, "The Haunted Pizza," "Times Pipleline," "The Maltease Turtle," and Casey Jones #1-2. They should throw these in somewhere. Maybe collect them with all the Turtle Soup stories in one big "TMNT Mirage specials" compendium or something.

I mean I never expected Dooney's Challenges of all things to be collected in a Tales collection (that book had nothing to do with Tales), so who knows.

Funnily enough Bodycount was reprinted in a hardcover collection twice, but not by IDW but Eastman's publishing label. I got the most recent Bodycount collection, I wonder if IDW is avoiding those due to the violence.

ToTheNines
07-11-2026, 04:32 AM
Eastman put out the super rare one from 2008 through Heavy Metal, but the more recent one was published by Top Shelf Productions, which is just an IDW imprint.

CyberCubed
07-11-2026, 10:21 AM
So basically we should be making a list of all the random old Mirage issues that IDW hasn't collected yet, or aren't planned so far. We can assume all 70 issues of Tales and the Raph/Mike/Don mini's will be collected in these collections. We can also assume Volume 4 will all get larger hardcover trades eventually after they finish putting them all out in single issues.

So the only thing IDW hasn't collected is the specials I listed above, the 4 Rich Veitch issues from Vol. 1, "Sky Highway" and "The River" trilogy, and some of the random crossovers like the Savage Dragon ones, the Gizmo and Fugitoid crossover, and some others I'm forgetting off the top of my head.

If IDW manages to get all this stuff out, we could very well get around 95% of the old Mirage material collected. And of course the 2007 movie books, and the rest of Archie hopefully.

ToTheNines
07-22-2026, 08:14 AM
I was recently at a comic shop and randomly picked up one of IDW’s old colored TPB reprints of Tales just so I had something to read in the hotel and realized they have the frontpieces but not the title card/credits page.

It’s a small thing, but I hope these hardcovers bring those back. A lot of them had really beautiful art and visuals, and they worked with the frontpiece to help set the tone for the story.

ToTheNines
10-28-2026, 12:43 PM
Amazon has preview pages up: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GNZ3DXNT?lv=shuf&channelId=520&plpRedirect=mhFallback

Survival Game seems to be missing its tones for some reason.

They're doing the original Tales frontpieces for Vol. 1, not the Treasury Edition.

Spinal Tapped randomly get put right before Vol. 2 #1. All the other backups go with their corresponding main story.

There is a pinup gallery.

CyberCubed
10-28-2026, 04:09 PM
I could see them saving the Future Turtle Frontpieces for the very last Tales collection, since they take place the furthest in the timeline. Hopefully by that point someone reminds them.

ToTheNines
10-28-2026, 05:02 PM
It would be kind of weird to just put them in there by themselves though. Do you think they’ll reprint volume 1 AGAIN?

CyberCubed
10-28-2026, 08:16 PM
No, just throw in the 5-6 (or so) frontpieces at the end of the last collection when they get up to Tales #69-70, basically pages at the back of the book like pin-up pages. Issue 69 is a future story with an adult Shadow so it would be perfect around there. Of course, someone should e-mail/remind the editors once we get up to the last collection so they don't forget to include them. It's something only us hardcore fans would even know about or care about.

ToTheNines
10-29-2026, 05:40 AM
No, just throw in the 5-6 (or so) frontpieces at the end of the last collection when they get up to Tales #69-70, basically pages at the back of the book like pin-up pages. Issue 69 is a future story with an adult Shadow so it would be perfect around there. Of course, someone should e-mail/remind the editors once we get up to the last collection so they don't forget to include them. It's something only us hardcore fans would even know about or care about.

I dunno man, those frontpieces directly reference each issue they’re introducing. They don’t really function separately from them.

And they definitely are aware of them, because they inexplicably included Spinal Tapped (a non-canon story) in a random spot here. Weird.

Great Hierophant
10-29-2026, 07:22 PM
Amazon has preview pages up: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GNZ3DXNT?lv=shuf&channelId=520&plpRedirect=mhFallback

Survival Game seems to be missing its tones for some reason.

They're doing the original Tales frontpieces for Vol. 1, not the Treasury Edition.

Spinal Tapped randomly get put right before Vol. 2 #1. All the other backups go with their corresponding main story.

There is a pinup gallery.

The Survival Game is also missing its tones in The Ultimate Collection Vol. 6, IDW seems to be consistent with its lack of toning when it comes to reprints. I would not expect any improvements with other stories lacking tones in prior reprints.

I thought Spinal Tapped was somehow related to the other new material in the Tales Treasury Editions. I've read the Frontispieces and the Epilogue but not Spinal Tapped.

ToTheNines
10-29-2026, 07:33 PM
It ties in to Tales #7, but it pretty strongly contradicts “Masks”.

ToTheNines
11-03-2026, 11:53 AM
First book is currently due out November 4th.

Second book information has LEAKED! Due out April 7th, next year.

https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/838419/tales-of-the-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-mirage-years-omnibus-vol-2-by-peter-laird/9798887245614/

https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/Tales-of-the-TMNT-TMY-Omnibus-Vol-2_Cover-Regular.jpg

Bad news, folks. This volume won’t have #21 or #32. Presumably because of the Cowboys of Moo Mesa.

Roseangelo
11-03-2026, 05:29 PM
Bad news, folks. This volume won’t have #21 or #32. Presumably because of the Cowboys of Moo Mesa.

There is no way Ryan said no to that. They just don't want to pay him. It has to be the same with Cerebus. Leaving out these issues is ridiculous. Why even make an Omnibus?

Chaotix12345
11-03-2026, 09:43 PM
Man, that's a bummer. I wonder if it's an issue with Nacelle?

ToTheNines
11-04-2026, 05:54 AM
Man, that's a bummer. I wonder if it's an issue with Nacelle?

I didn’t know this until now, but apparently there’s a new Moo Mesa cartoon coming out next year. You’d think they would be happy to put the characters out there in a premium hardcover TMNT reprint. But maybe they’re asking too much?

This is just an idea from my clueless brain, but perhaps they will just put all 4 Moo Mesa Tales issues in the same volume so they only have to pay them/share profits on one book instead of two? It would also align more with the reboots release. Holding out hope.

CyberCubed
11-04-2026, 06:46 AM
Is there any way to get into contact with the editors to ask them about this?

ToTheNines
11-04-2026, 06:59 AM
There’s [email protected] but I’ve never received a response or had anything printed in the past 2 years. I certainly miss the Bobby Curnow days.

Some IDW guys are active on social media, but I don’t know how much they have to do with reprints. You could try Gregg Katzman or Tommy Stella. I think Ryan Balkam had something to do with Journeys.

Powder
11-05-2026, 01:52 AM
Why even make an Omnibus?

Sorry to be a hater, but like, has there been a single Mirage/Archie reprint collection from IDW that actually comprehensively collects what it's meant to without missing pages or entire issues or duo-tones or whatever?

I sat out on everything for the longest time as there were always deal-breaker omissions, IMO. I stopped checking up on new ones after a while. :ohwell:

I'm sure glad I have my floppies so that I have (most) everything one would ever need, but it's a pain to read them sometimes.

ToTheNines
11-05-2026, 04:32 AM
Sorry to be a hater, but like, has there been a single Mirage/Archie reprint collection from IDW that actually comprehensively collects what it's meant to without missing pages or entire issues or duo-tones or whatever?

The current Archie compendium hardcover series ain’t bad. I think the only thing they’re going to skip is “TMNT meets Archie”, which is a throwaway crossover and easy enough to find the floppy.

They made a pretty boneheaded error with where they placed “Origin of the Species” and some of the scans are pretty rough. Otherwise I can’t complain. They’ve been pretty thorough. They even remembered the black & white Dooney mini comic, Murphy’s last hurrah from the 30th anniversary book, etc.

Let’s see what they do about The Prophet Muhammad…


I'm sure glad I have my floppies so that I have (most) everything one would ever need, but it's a pain to read them sometimes.

Dude I know. It’s so nice to just pull a hardcover off my bookshelf and get reading.

Otherwise I have to go to our guest room, pull out the correct long box, hope my addled brain can remember where I put each series, thumb through to find what I’m looking for without getting distracted by something else. Then to top it all off, some of these old Mirage books are so rare and valuable that I don’t even want to touch them, especially with the youngster running around.

CyberCubed
11-05-2026, 07:02 AM
A lot of the old Mirage and Archie issues, the paper was degrading and turning yellow. Archie was printed on cheap paper to begin with and those issues were falling apart no matter how good I took care of them. Mirage was also rubbing off the ink on my hands, that was around the time I realized I should just sell them when we got better collections.

ToTheNines
11-05-2026, 06:17 PM
I just found this super informative post on Reddit detailing everything IDW has bungled with Mirage reprints: https://www.reddit.com/r/TMNT/s/QQnKBFapsG

So yeah, looks like Tales #2, 3, 5 and 6 are all missing their tones. That’s kind of whatever to me since the main attraction of these is Volume 2. Very unfortunate about the skipped issues… #32 is particularly rare.

Great Hierophant
11-05-2026, 07:59 PM
I just found this super informative post on Reddit detailing everything IDW has bungled with Mirage reprints: https://www.reddit.com/r/TMNT/s/QQnKBFapsG

So yeah, looks like Tales #2, 3, 5 and 6 are all missing their tones. That’s kind of whatever to me since the main attraction of these is Volume 2. Very unfortunate about the skipped issues… #32 is particularly rare.

That post was rather comprehensive, even I found something to add in my own, much more lengthy, work on the subject. Regarding missing colorizations, all the art in TMNT #33 (pencils, inks and colors) was done by Richard Corben, one of Eastman's idols. A great deal is lost by the removal of the colors and IDW's flat recolorization does not compare to the original. I find it most difficult to believe that IDW would have the rights to the inks but not the colors. As for D'Ants Fever, the color was originally supplied by Linda Lessman when it was published in Grimjack #26. She was working for First Comics in the mid-1980s, not Mirage, so IDW may not have inherited the rights to her color work.

ToTheNines
11-07-2026, 04:25 AM
Ya know, the more I think about this, the less sense it makes. When you look at the fine print in all these issues in question, all the Moo Mesa characters are trademarks of R.E. Bee Inc. and “used with permission” and Galactose is “created by” Murphy/Brown…

But this is well after the era of Gary Richardson basically forcing everyone to sign the retroactive work for hire contracts. How and why was something like this allowed to be published in Tales after Veitch and everyone else’s old stories were either bought up or mothballed?

ToTheNines
11-09-2026, 10:37 AM
Ok, got mine today. It is a very nice looking book and I'm pleased to report that they did keep all of the credits pages that go between the frontpiece and the first page of the story.

The awful looking tone-less V1 issues are there, but not a deal breaker for me. For better or worse, this book is still a very economical option just by virtue of including Blindsight, alone. So I think I will be supporting these and continuing to preorder. Doubt I'll ever part with my singles, but at least I'll be able to consider it in the future thanks to these.

Oh, and the editor is Alonzo Simon if anyone wants to figure out a way to contact him and get an answer on the Moo Mesa issues.

CyberCubed
11-09-2026, 02:08 PM
Since the Moo Mesa issues is actually a 4-parter based on the same story (and not like several single issues), maybe they are going to have all 4 in the same collection (probably the last one), so the story flows better. Either way if we keep asking the editors/IDW about this we'll either get an answer or remind them they need to be included in future collections.