View Full Version : Do you consider Saturday Morning Adventures in-continuity with the original cartoon?
CyberCubed
02-24-2026, 07:18 PM
Similar to the Archie TMNT Adventures thread, we now have Saturday Morning Adventures which was originally based on the original cartoon. While it started off more or less being in continuity, it now feels like it's doing the same thing Archie did and splintering off into its own unique canon.
What do you think? Do you still take Saturday Morning Adventures in continuity with the original TMNT cartoon? Or is this like a second Archie Adventures timeline where things are going off on their own...a second time?
neatoman
02-24-2026, 08:40 PM
Compared to what happened with Archie, any inkling of SMA becoming its own thing is rather difficult to discern. I can't tell if there is anything that contradicts the show (more than the show contradicted itself that is) and the comic keeps connecting itself to the show.
The thing that made Archie its own thing wasn't just that it focused on characters specifically created for it, it's also that it had interpretations of characters that differed from their FW counterparts in irreconcilable ways and had stories that just straight up couldn't happen in the show. The origin of Splinter and the Turtles was retconned about as drastically as possible in order to be more like Mirage, Leatherhead is practically a different character in all but looks and the plot just can't happen in the FW show.
What SMA has done so far is call Krang an Utrom, retcon Ogg's initial characterisation as "a weird phase" so he could be more like Mxyzptlk and generally insert some elements that were never part of the show but are generally accepted (TCRI and Renet for example). But it's not like the comic has ignored the connection to the show as of yet, if they did for example state that the Turtles were originally Turtle Tots or decided on a completely different reason for April to leave Channel 6 than it being blown up in season 8, then we'd be talking.
Andrew NDB
02-24-2026, 09:12 PM
My guess is if there's anything contradictory in it vs. the Fred Wolf show it means someone screwed up, not some intentional branching.
Heyowakka
02-24-2026, 10:30 PM
ToTheNines and I recently had a small conversation about this in another thread. I don’t really care if IDW considers SMA a continuation of the Fred Wolf series, I consider it its own branched off continuity..
In the second issue of the mini-series, TCRI is introduced to this continuity. However, this issue doesn’t fit in at the tail end of season 7 like advertised, there are too many continuity nods that land it instead right in season 2.
Shredder is stranded on Earth with Bebop and Rocksteady with no resources while Krang is in Dimension X in complete control of a functional Technodrome.
There’s also taking into account that Vernon is terrified that the Turtles are going to hurt them, and acts like they’re scary monsters.
Vernon in seasons 4-6 was pretty well acquainted with the turtles by that point, let alone the end of season 7, he wouldn’t be frightened of them.
The only way this issue makes sense is if, oddly enough, it takes place before all of the other issues in the series, which works fine with me even if it’s a bit unorthodox.
So, my personal headcanon is that TMNT Saturday Morning Adventures is a branch-off continuity where TCRI was introduced to the 1987 mythos in Season 2, which led to Shredder and Krang losing the Technodrome and taking refuge in the Hall of Science *without* the event of Channel 6 being destroyed, and I’ll stand by that headcanon until the comic itself contradicts this.
Coola Yagami
02-25-2026, 07:24 AM
Like most comics based on existing cartoons, I'd say it's canon until some new FW revival show is made, since you know any actual cartoon show or special is going to completely disregard the comics.
ToTheNines
02-25-2026, 08:15 AM
Much of what Heyowakka said.
It’s absolutely a branch continuity. I’ll spare everyone the timeline minutiae, but we’ve seen 2 winters pass, so seasons 8 and 9 would have already happened by now in the FW continuity. In reality, it’s more likely that everything is progressing in “Peanuts Time”, but it has tromped all over season 8 in other ways.
Not to say that some Red Sky type sh*t can’t happen eventually, but it will be an alternate take. And there’s just no feasible way this series fits neatly between season 7 and 8, even at this point in time. Assuming the book has a couple of years left in it, that’ll become even more evident as time goes on.
There’s plenty of little things that contradict. One big one recently was Burnham confirming Old Man Mikey in Battle Nexus #5 was from the future of SMA, still in fighting shape, in Last Ronin garb, the only surviving member of his family. We know from “Once Upon a Time Machine” that FW Michelangelo lives to be a fat old geezer in an old folks home with his brothers lol
Regardless of what anyone says, I didn’t really enjoy the book when I was viewing it through the lense of “FW continuation”. Now that I’ve accepted that it is its own thing, it’s much more enjoyable to me.
CyberCubed
02-25-2026, 12:42 PM
Would like to see a time skip where they do a "Season 11" set after the events of Dregg and see what could happen from there.
neatoman
02-25-2026, 01:10 PM
Would like to see a time skip where they do a "Season 11" set after the events of Dregg and see what could happen from there.
And what exactly do you expect to be interesting about post-Dregg?
ToTheNines
02-26-2026, 03:49 AM
I have proof that it isn’t FW canon: there’s never been a single mask-color error. It’s too well made lol
And what exactly do expect to be interesting about post-Dregg?
Anything could happen, but that’s after the point when Splinter acknowledges them as equals and is no longer training them. They’re entering their 20’s. Maybe they start to grow up and go their separate ways a little bit.
CyberCubed
02-26-2026, 06:52 AM
Also anything can happen if they're not restricted between seasons. Maybe they can kill off characters, or defeat Tempestra permanently, or we find out where Bebop/Rocksteady were left in Dimension X when Shrddder/Krang returned in Season 10 without them. Maybe better closure for Baxter Stockman rather than leaving him trapped in Dimensional limbo.
neatoman
02-26-2026, 02:26 PM
Also anything can happen if they're not restricted between seasons. Maybe they can kill off characters, or defeat Tempestra permanently, or we find out where Bebop/Rocksteady were left in Dimension X when Shrddder/Krang returned in Season 10 without them. Maybe better closure for Baxter Stockman rather than leaving him trapped in Dimensional limbo.
Uh... Sure, here's a list of things that need to be done:
Confirm that Bebop and Rocksteady were indeed eaten by that monster and are therefore never coming back.
Give Leatherhead a redemption arc and make him stop wearing that stupid and drop the idea of using crayfish as weapons.
Have Krang get permanently imprisoned by the Utrom high council.
Actually make a Fugitoid story this time.
Make a story in which the Punk Frogs go on vacation in France... That turns out to not be a very good vacation... Yet they still don't come home...
ToTheNines
03-08-2026, 09:31 AM
Another timeline detail for me: there’s a bunch of stuff in season 4 and 5 placing them in 1991. Which makes season 7 1992.
SMA has had several instances indicating it’s 1989, and it’s not just Schoening. It’s been a couple different artists, so I think it’s on purpose.
Coola Yagami
03-08-2026, 10:05 AM
SMA has had several instances indicating it’s 1989, and it’s not just Schoening. It’s been a couple different artists, so I think it’s on purpose.
Like which instances?
ToTheNines
03-11-2026, 08:34 PM
Like which instances?
Off the top of my head, there’s a flyer blowing down the street in the issue where Casey gets electricity powers. Then again in the newspaper when Chromedome is running for mayor.
Easily dismissed, but also seems like it’s purposeful.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.