View Full Version : Why is IDW suddenly giving fans everything we want? A change in management?
CyberCubed
03-04-2026, 06:30 AM
It really feels there's been some sort of change with the higher-ups at IDW lately. All of a sudden they seem to be doing what fans have been asking for about 10+ years:
1. Mirage Vol. 1 compendium trades in black and white without the awful coloring they did before and in proper order. Also unlike The Ultimate collections these also include all the guest issues. They still skipped The River and Sky Highway but there's rumors even those might be coming eventually.
2. Volume 2 finally got a proper compendium with "The Mirage Years," and it had the original colors unlike the first Vol. 2 tpb's from 10 years ago.
3. Image got both a full colorization (and unlike the previous ones this time the colors were good), of two tpb's with all 26 issues, and now we're even getting Image again in black and white this time with all 26 issues. So we have best of both worlds with the Image run
4. Vol. 4 is getting individual issues, and it will obviously get collections later on after they finished putting out single issues. Vol. 4 has never been collected before so this is exciting.
5. Tales of the TMNT compendiums were announced, where they are not only planning on collecting all 70 issues of Vol. 2 but also the 16 mini-series that went alongside them like Leonoard: Blind Sight and the Raph/Don/Mike ones.
6. Archie TMNT compendiums were announced, where not only are they putting them in proper order splicing in the specials and mini-series where they belong, but they're also not skipping over the middle eastern arc this time like the first trades did.
7. Even the movie adaption comics are getting re-released, with the 1990 adaption, TMNT II: Secret of the Ooze announced. Hopefully TMNT III and the 2007 movie prequel comics get a collection soon, the latter haven't been re-released since like 2007-2008.
All of a sudden IDW seems to be giving the fans exactly what we've been asking for all these years. Why the sudden change?
ToTheNines
03-04-2026, 07:00 AM
Yes it’s been quite nice. I’m pretty critical of IDW, but they’ve been doing a lot right lately.
Positive answer to your question: the right guy(s) got promoted.
Negative answer to your question: they put out trash on purpose the first time around knowing people would buy whatever since Mirage basically never reprinted anything… and now they’re doing it “right” so people will double dip.
I don’t mean to cast aspersions. But it’s a business tactic we’ve all seen elsewhere.
TurtleGurkle
03-04-2026, 08:09 AM
Cranking things out until the merger goes through and DC takes over the comics maybe.
GameCobra
03-04-2026, 09:49 AM
I do feel like we've been eating very good since Battle Nexus. Though that was before the merger announcement. I suspect management changes.
Is Bobby Curnow still the new EiC? He was always awesome.
CyberCubed
03-04-2026, 08:08 PM
Negative answer to your question: they put out trash on purpose the first time around knowing people would buy whatever since Mirage basically never reprinted anything… and now they’re doing it “right” so people will double dip.
I don’t mean to cast aspersions. But it’s a business tactic we’ve all seen elsewhere.
That's exactly what happened to me. I had to sell all my IDW collections on ebay despite buying them the first time around because I didn't think they would do them "better" later on. I still have the Ultimate Collections because those are good, but I sold all the Vol. 1 guest issue collections, the old Vol. 2 trades, the old Archie trades, and the old Tales of the TMNT IDW trades.
Even selling on ebay I only got roughly half the money I originally spent on them, so I lost probably hundreds of dollars. What a mess. At least this time around these collections look like the definitive versions so I don't ever have to sell or rebuy them again even if more collections come later from either IDW (or DC?) in the future.
ToTheNines
03-04-2026, 08:49 PM
See? It worked lol.
The next move might be to reprint Mirage with beautiful colors. I wouldn’t subscribe, but there’s certainly a select few issues I would pick up if they looked really good in color.
Heyowakka
03-05-2026, 01:12 AM
If I were in charge of the franchise, I’d give the fan community what they really want!
A complete retelling of the Fred Wolf TMNT series in epic graphic novel form!
The kicker? The entire story is told from Vernon Fenwick’s point of view, each story showing how he helped the Heroes in a Half-Shell save the day time and time again!
‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Vernon’s Views’!
200 issues!
NO!
200 years of Vernon’s Views!
Year after year with no signs of slowing down!
Yeah, I’m pretty much a genius.
Andrew NDB
03-05-2026, 01:20 AM
I wouldn't say "everything," but maybe the "reprint team" (Bobby's words from years ago) have become more sympatico with the main team. Or something. Somehow.
Daytona
03-05-2026, 01:29 AM
See? It worked lol.
The next move might be to reprint Mirage with beautiful colors. I wouldn’t subscribe, but there’s certainly a select few issues I would pick up if they looked really good in color.
I’m pretty choosy these days but I’d definitely buy new colored Mirage collections if they did a great job. Most modern colors look pretty weak to me though - I’m just really not into the digital look. That said, Urban Legends made it work for me.
I also wonder if they’ll ever reprint the backup material from the Ultimate Collections. The comments from Peter and Kevin on each issue feel essential to me now. I wouldn’t want to buy Mirage collections without them.
CyberCubed
03-05-2026, 05:20 PM
Paramount buying WB couldn't have happened at a worse time for TMNT fans. I really hope Paramount doesn't yank the license from IDW to give to DC. At least not for a few years yet. These trades need to be completed and IDW TMNT itself needs to get a good conclusion after being one of the longest running TMNT comic ever.
Andrew NDB
03-05-2026, 05:36 PM
Paramount buying WB couldn't have happened at a worse time for TMNT fans. I really hope Paramount doesn't yank the license from IDW to give to DC. At least not for a few years yet. These trades need to be completed and IDW TMNT itself needs to get a good conclusion after being one of the longest running TMNT comic ever.
Presumably IDW hasn't announced anything that is outside of the expiration date of their current license with Paramount, so everything they've already announced should be fine.
hypered1
03-06-2026, 06:02 AM
Pretty sure IDW will have it until at least 2029/30 as that was length of contract that was as signed in 2024.
ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 09:53 AM
Presumably IDW hasn't announced anything that is outside of the expiration date of their current license with Paramount, so everything they've already announced should be fine.
Right, but if the TMNTA Compendiums stop at volume 4 or whatever, that's gonna bite. It's highly unlikely that DC would pick up where they left off, much more likely that they'd start over.
And maybe they'd do a better job, but it'll be frustrating to sink money into the current collection and just have to start over.
Pretty sure IDW will have it until at least 2029/30 as that was length of contract that was as signed in 2024.
Interesting. I can see several articles saying that it happened in 2024, but none of them specify for how long.
Andrew NDB
03-06-2026, 11:19 AM
Right, but if the TMNTA Compendiums stop at volume 4 or whatever, that's gonna bite. It's highly unlikely that DC would pick up where they left off, much more likely that they'd start over.
And maybe they'd do a better job, but it'll be frustrating to sink money into the current collection and just have to start over.
And I wouldn't be super convinced that even if the license leaves IDW and Paramount just starts making their own comics through DC that DC would be interested in a big TMNT reprint program.
ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 11:49 AM
Yes, good point. I think the license going to Dark Horse would be an undeniably good thing for reprints, DC not so much.
Andrew NDB
03-06-2026, 12:12 PM
I think the license going to Dark Horse would be an undeniably good thing for reprints
Though now it's uncertain with Mike Richardson getting ousted yesterday at Dark Horse. Their robust reprint and REAL omnibus program might have been a him thing.
TurtleGurkle
03-06-2026, 01:17 PM
And I wouldn't be super convinced that even if the license leaves IDW and Paramount just starts making their own comics through DC that DC would be interested in a big TMNT reprint program.
That doesn’t make any sense, TMNT reprints are a cash cow. DC would jump at the chance to do their own.
Daytona
03-06-2026, 03:19 PM
Everything you mentioned is primarily aimed at older fans. What happened was The Last Ronin. It told all avenues of TMNT to wake up and take advantage of an older market. Game announcements, movie announcements, toy lines, etc
Not everything has come to fruition yet but it’s obvious TLR has had an impact across the entire spectrum of TMNT.
Hell, only months after Mutant Mayhem failed at the box office, Paramount completely backtracked on their disinterest in a TLR movie. I’d say the one-two punch of Mutant Mayhem underwhelming while TLR broke sales records across the board was a legitimate wake-up call.
TMNT will always be primarily aimed at kids but it doesn’t take much business sense to see those results happening simultaneously and decide that maybe it’s time to re-assess the potential customer base. Everyone here knows TMNT is just as flexible as Batman and I believe they finally got the hint.
ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 04:02 PM
Eh, they had reprinted Vol. 1, Vol. 2, Archie and part of Tales. They were just poorly done for the most part. Also worth mentioning that the entirety of Urban Legends happened before TLR #1 dropped.
They’re putting out the same stuff, they’re just being more thorough and focusing on gigantic hardcovers.
CyberCubed
03-06-2026, 05:21 PM
By my calculations they'll need at least 3 years to complete the trades if they keep up the current pace. Vol. 1 is done, Vol. 2 is done, Image is going to be done again by the end of this year. Archie trades should probably take about 3 years, if they put out maybe 2 collections a year? I guess?
Tales V. 2 is 70 issues + the 16 mini-series, so altogether it's 86 issues, so that will probably take 3+ years to get through as well.
For Vol. 4 they're likely to wait till they put out all the single issues till the collection, and again, it'll take us about 3ish years to get back up to issue 32.
Andrew NDB
03-06-2026, 05:24 PM
By my calculations they'll need at least 3 years to complete the trades if they keep up the current pace. Vol. 1 is done, Vol. 2 is done, Image is going to be done again by the end of this year. Archie trades should probably take about 3 years, if they put out maybe 2 collections a year? I guess?
Tales V. 2 is 70 issues + the 16 mini-series, so altogether it's 86 issues, so that will probably take 3+ years to get through as well.
For Vol. 4 they're likely to wait till they put out all the single issues till the collection, and again, it'll take us about 3ish years to get back up to issue 32.
This is IDW's own fault, though. If it was Dark Horse you'd have these big 1,400 page omnibuses for a good price and all Mirage collecting would be done inside of one year. With IDW you get these razor thin hardcover "omnibuses" for $100 that come out like once every leap year.
CyberCubed
03-08-2026, 01:20 PM
Aren't big books like that too heavy or uncomfortable to hold? Already IDW's Ultimate Collections kind of strain my hands when holding/reading them for too long a time. I honestly don't like really big or fat collections, they're good in terms of value but when you're actually sitting down reading them they get uncomfortable in your hands. Like I can't read much more than 15-20 minutes without having to put a book like that down.
Meanwhile if it was small trades I could spent 1 hour reading if I want to get through a specific series.
ToTheNines
03-08-2026, 02:36 PM
Are you really that dainty?
The TMNTA Compendium was about 800 pages, and it isn’t too big. Wouldn’t really want anything much bigger than that. The Armageddon Game hardcover was a big too large. The splash pages are kind of annoying because the book doesn’t want to open all the way.
Daytona
03-08-2026, 05:42 PM
Eh, they had reprinted Vol. 1, Vol. 2, Archie and part of Tales. They were just poorly done for the most part. Also worth mentioning that the entirety of Urban Legends happened before TLR #1 dropped.
They’re putting out the same stuff, they’re just being more thorough and focusing on gigantic hardcovers.
Those are fair points. I still fully believe it gave them a kick-in-the-pants wake up call.
ToTheNines
03-08-2026, 06:20 PM
Those are fair points. I still fully believe it gave them a kick-in-the-pants wake up call.
Maybe. It’s certainly more mainstream than ever now. IDW treats the ongoing like a DC title. You can’t score cheap back issues anywhere anymore, unless you get crazy lucky.
rs_jr
03-20-2026, 07:44 PM
IDW launched their own podcast. I hope they do episodes dedicated to talking to the team doing the TMNT collections a couple of times a year.
FrederikWolferson
04-04-2026, 01:42 PM
I guess they sorted out the rights issues with Wild West Cowboys Of Moo Mesa.
I wonder how they will deal with Mecca and Tibet issues of Archie comics.
And I'm sorta hoping we might actually get an ending to Vol. 4. But that's probably too optimistic.
Daytona
04-04-2026, 02:17 PM
Potential scenarios for volume 4 completion and my hip-fire assessment of the chances:
1. Peter finishes the series off himself - 25%
2. Peter and Kevin reunite, do a quick time jump and give us one last authentic Eastman and Laird TMNT story before we shut our eyes - 35%
3. Peter offers Jim Lawson his notes and allows him to finish off the series and they sell it as a “collab” similar to TLR - 40%
*Possibly with scenario #2 afterwards if we’re lucky.
Yeah I actually think a time jump is somehow more possible than Peter just wrapping it up. Not that I’m holding my breath for either. On one hand Peter tends to know what he wants, so I could see him saying “no, no, I already know how this ends, I can wrap this up quick”. On the other, Peter seems almost as nostalgic as Kevin does these days, and is very warm towards him, so it wouldn’t totally surprise me if he wants to reunite one more time.
At first I thought there’s nearly a zero percent chance of any type of conclusion to Mirage TMNT but it seems incredibly awkward to reprint the series and leave us with a cliffhanger all over again. I feel like if that were the case it would make more sense to just give us an omnibus and call it a day. Don’t drag everyone along for nothing.
Abnormal Freak
04-04-2026, 03:37 PM
My question about the compendiums: is the print quality better? The ultimate collections had faded duotones and pixelated lineart, while some City at War issues were missing tones altogether. I've gotten burned by IDW in the past so I haven't looked into the newer collections. I still think it's funny and kind of sad that the original-color Vol. 2 collection had a single page with the redone colors.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.