PDA

View Full Version : I finally revisited Last Ronin after trashing it for 5 years


ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 09:32 AM
Finally decided to give it another shot after all these years. Reading it in one sitting was a better experience than waiting over a year for 5 issues. It’s certainly not a bad comic, but I truly can’t wrap my head around the phenomenon it became. It’s just not that good. And I still wince every time I see some casual say it’s “basically Mirage” or Tom Waltz call it “Mirage adjacent”. Stop. Get help.

I’m going to start by getting into Lost Years #1 (the only issue of that I’ve read so far), because I want to highlight how TLR has WAY more IDW in its DNA than anything else.

The flashback of the 4 turtles and Splinter storming a Foot compound to kill Shredder. First of all nothing like that ever happened in Mirage (not saying that’s a strong point, I have a whole thread about Mirage Splinter was mishandled between #10 and RTNY). In fact, it’s very similar to “Vengeance” from IDW.

Obviously they’re different scenarios, but that whole scene is straight out of the Tom Waltz IDW playbook. Mikey dropping to his knees and trying to quit in the middle of a fight because he can’t handle it? Splinter kneeling down to give him a pep talk? While the other 3 continue to take an army of ninja? What a ridiculous scene. They both would have been dead within 10 seconds.

Several times throughout Mirage, the turtles question the point of their fight against the Foot and their purpose in life. But Mike would NEVER stop in the middle of a fight to go boo-hoo over the violence. That’s pure IDW Mikey there and there’s no way around it.

Another whopper for me is Karai. She obviously was never Shredder’s daughter, but this is a pretty bad characterization of her, on top of that. She’s just a bloodthirsty idiot.

Alright, with “Mirage adjacent” debunked I will shift over to what I liked before I get back into the negative:

Raphael. He easily got the best death and I think the timing of it was one of the most interesting things they did. The fact that he died pretty young and the other’s went on for 10 years without him feels like a lot of untapped story potential for that decade long period. Felt a little strange they didn’t show his funeral.

The larger Hamato clan. They kept all of this very vague, but I enjoyed the idea. Even the “strike teams” in NYC were cool. I don’t know if I buy there being a team of Good Guy ninjas running around. How are they funding that operation?

Splinter. Did they ever specify if he a rat first or human first? Either way, Splinter is my favorite TMNT character in general, so I did enjoy him going beast mode in Japan in #4. It obviously wasn’t tactically wise to split up and attend that meeting, but I guess something like that was necessary for the plot.

Ok, that was pretty much all that I liked. On to the neutral and negative.

Leo and Don. They were kind of just there. Neither one of them got a particularly good or heroic death and had to share them with Splinter and Casey.

April and Casey Marie were ok. I’ve complained about this in the past, but I’m actually glad they didn’t name her “Shadow”. She’s a very different character.

Hiroto sucked. Not an interesting villain and the big fight in #5 wasn’t anything spectacular. Also, the way he died was just lame. I won’t even post it, but it reminded me of the meme of Naruto sleeping on his stomach with his ass cheeks up in the air haha

The ending and Mike’s death was pretty good. However you want to interpret the whole afterlife scene, it was poignant.

So yeah, it’s not a bad comic by any means. It just doesn’t deserve the praise it gets. I would respect it a lot more if they just made it IDW canon and used in to end the series a few years ago. It certainly feels more at home there than anywhere else. That also would have provided actual stakes. As it stands, the Roninverse is essentially just another one of these throwaway versions that pop up in the crossovers, with no real history other than piggybacking off the general idea of TMNT.

TheLabRat
03-06-2026, 12:15 PM
I think if they already have plans to make a sequel, then they should keep Mikey alive. Maybe the sequel could be like Batman Beyond, Mikey become Splinter and continue to training Marie. Or perhaps Mikey could continue wandering the world, encounter new adventures and crises, and he also have regained his optimism after complete his revenge.

Smithguy789
03-06-2026, 01:42 PM
I re-read TLR recently as well, and went on to the prequel/sequel as well after I got over my own "this **** ain't Mirage" phase.

On the whole, I agree with your reassessment. The Last Ronin is fine. It's not a masterpiece, but it ain't garbage either. Hiroto's the biggest sore thumb, if they could've developed him more and made him a legitimate thread (and given him a costume that wasn't dumb) it would have made the series better overall.

ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 02:16 PM
Another major nitpick: the whole "I must kill the Last Oroku" thing. Why wasn't Hiroto reproducing? He was in his 30's and didn't have any kids? Maybe he was really that crazy and truly believed he was an immortal/god and didn't have to?

Andrew NDB
03-06-2026, 02:31 PM
Another major nitpick: the whole "I must kill the Last Oroku" thing. Why wasn't Hiroto reproducing? He was in his 30's and didn't have any kids?

Yeah, I was doing that a couple years ago and I'm in my 40s. What's his excuse?

Someone should make a meme of John Marston from Red Dead drowning, but replace him with Hiroto instead in some obviously shallow water.

Daytona
03-06-2026, 03:12 PM
There’s a disparity between issue #1 and the rest of the series. The first issue has excellent pacing, story boarding, and doesn’t bog you down with exposition - it’s a legitimately great comic with intrigue and style. Then the rest of the series sort of flops all over the place to varying degrees of success, with pacing becoming the biggest issue.

I felt The Lost Years was quite good and a step in the right direction and then TLR2 was the weakest yet. Still hoping they can bring back the quality of issue 1 for the finale - maybe if they slow way down instead of announcing a series and then playing catch up as they try to piece everything together.

That said, I have nothing but appreciation for TLR as I welcome the new fans it has brought in and the way it forced Nickelodeon to pay attention to older fans. It could very well have saved my interest in the future of the property, because I don’t think they had any intention of aiming tmnt beyond the kiddie-market before this book blew up.

ToTheNines
03-06-2026, 03:45 PM
Yeah, I was doing that a couple years ago and I'm in my 40s. What's his excuse?

Someone should make a meme of John Marston from Red Dead drowning, but replace him with Hiroto instead in some obviously shallow water.

:lol: might make that later

There’s a disparity between issue #1 and the rest of the series. The first issue has excellent pacing, story boarding, and doesn’t bog you down with exposition - it’s a legitimately great comic with intrigue and style. Then the rest of the series sort of flops all over the place to varying degrees of success, with pacing becoming the biggest issue.

Yeah, I agree.

Just a guess, but I’m betting #1 was pretty much the extent of what Peter and Kevin cooked up all those years ago and the rest was all new ideas.

I felt The Lost Years was quite good and a step in the right direction and then TLR2 was the weakest yet. Still hoping they can bring back the quality of issue 1 for the finale - maybe if they slow way down instead of announcing a series and then playing catch up as they try to piece everything together.

I read #2 of Lost Years today. It’s a decent series so far.

I don’t even know what Re-Evolution is about. Who are the new turtles fighting?

That said, I have nothing but appreciation for TLR as I welcome the new fans it has brought in and the way it forced Nickelodeon to pay attention to older fans. It could very well have saved my interest in the future of the property, because I don’t think they had any intention of aiming tmnt beyond the kiddie-market before this book blew up.

I’m torn here. I resent the underserved accolades, but if it’s what is facilitating stuff like these nice reprints, the many incredible NECA lines, and other cool stuff… I’ll take it!

Daytona
03-06-2026, 08:35 PM
I can’t see the success being anything but good if you’re a fan over 12 years old but it’s all subjective.

I could hardly tell you what happened in TLR2. I found it painful to read quite honestly. Kevin stopped doing layouts and I think he handed main script duties over to Tom Waltz. Between the messier layouts and lack of Kevin’s concise scripting, the thing reads like a mess. Maybe I’ll appreciate it more once part three completes it (bc it essentially ends abruptly) but I’m not counting on it.

I’m a big cheerleaders for all things TLR but I can’t pretend it’s flawless by any means.

TheLabRat
03-06-2026, 08:45 PM
Another major nitpick: the whole "I must kill the Last Oroku" thing. Why wasn't Hiroto reproducing? He was in his 30's and didn't have any kids? Maybe he was really that crazy and truly believed he was an immortal/god and didn't have to?

I suspect he might have a mother complex. In fact, if they had explored that more, he would at least be like Alfred Ashford from Resident Evil: Code Veronica, an incestuous psychopath. Unfortunately they decided to let Hiroto kill his own mother because they wouldn't allowed Mikey to kill Karai.

Daytona
03-07-2026, 06:38 AM
Why wouldn’t Mikey be allowed to kill Karai? I don’t know if that’s accurate.

ToTheNines
03-17-2026, 01:29 PM
I just got completely caught up last night. My hot takes:

- The Lost Years. Quite good! Much better than TLR. Felt like a much more cohesive story and they quit pulling punches with the violence. I also enjoyed the levity of the “present day” stuff. I felt it was necessary considering Mikey went through another 15 years of hell even after his entire family dies lol. The Death Worm reveal felt a little underwhelming, considering the buildup. But still, decent story that does nothing but help make TLR better, actually.

- The Lost Day. Great special. One of the best April stories ever told, not that the bar is high lol. Uno is absolute mother ****er, but I guess that’s his role. I feel like I missed something with Jigsaw. He seemed very pleasant and honorable in this, why did he have such a score to settle in TLR II?

- Re-Evolution. Not bad. I found myself wanting to learn more about the new generation of turtles more than anything else they were getting into. They’re quite likable. All the gang stuff was pretty boring and the British gang with the Knight motif was beyond stupid.

The twist at the end was very interesting and I’m cautiously looking forward to TLR III. The death felt kind of rushed, but they might make up for it at the beginning of the sequel. Kind of interesting who did the deed, then they were immediately dealt with, so no vengeance story to be had there really.

TheLabRat
03-17-2026, 05:59 PM
Mikey like a crybaby and complain about everything in prequel. I had hoped to see an "burst of anger" in the final issue, but the result was disappointing.

This series should end after Mikey'death, or at least these old enemies, like Foot Clan shouldn't appear as main rivals of new protagonists in the sequel. Let them decline with the times, even becoming lackeys of other emerging forces or being eliminated.

rs_jr
03-20-2026, 07:52 PM
I would be interested to see an adaptation closer to the original vision of the story from the 80s ( not sure how much was fleshed out). Maybe get Lawson to draw it.

ToTheNines
06-29-2026, 03:20 PM
I recently realized why TLR is so popular with normies. It’s a comic with almost zero baggage. It’s not an ongoing and it only requires a very basic working knowledge of TMNT. You can just read the 5 issues and be done.

Even if you want to get into the prequel and sequel, it’s not an overwhelming amount of content and the reading order is very intuitive.

Diving into basically any comic book series takes hours of research and will still often leave you confused between renumbering, multiple volumes, crossovers, minis, annuals, noncanon stuff, events, etc.

The Last Ronin doesn’t have any of that.

Andrew NDB
06-29-2026, 03:23 PM
It's almost exactly like The Dark Knight Returns model. At also the time it seemed like TDKR COULD fit into DC's future, kind of like TLR seemed like it could with Mirage for about two minutes.

ProphetofGanja
06-29-2026, 04:38 PM
I’ve been thinking about checking this out too finally (I have never read Mirage or Image so I didn’t feel like I knew enough to check out this sequel series)

Andrew NDB
06-29-2026, 04:48 PM
I’ve been thinking about checking this out too finally (I have never read Mirage or Image so I didn’t feel like I knew enough to check out this sequel series)

Rest assured, TLR has NOTHING to do with the Mirage/Image universe.

Powder
06-29-2026, 06:55 PM
I recently realized why TLR is so popular with normies. It’s a comic with almost zero baggage. It’s not an ongoing and it only requires a very basic working knowledge of TMNT. You can just read the 5 issues and be done.

Even if you want to get into the prequel and sequel, it’s not an overwhelming amount of content and the reading order is very intuitive.

Diving into basically any comic book series takes hours of research and will still often leave you confused between renumbering, multiple volumes, crossovers, minis, annuals, noncanon stuff, events, etc.

The Last Ronin doesn’t have any of that.

I’ve been thinking about checking this out too finally (I have never read Mirage or Image so I didn’t feel like I knew enough to check out this sequel series)

I think this sums up exactly why it doesn't resonate with a lot of old school Mirage fans. It's designed in part for the people who wouldn't invest time in the original comics, by all measures a completely different, casual audience. Meanwhile, there's still a void that needs filling.

Allio
06-29-2026, 08:04 PM
Another major nitpick: the whole "I must kill the Last Oroku" thing. Why wasn't Hiroto reproducing? He was in his 30's and didn't have any kids? Maybe he was really that crazy and truly believed he was an immortal/god and didn't have to?

I mean hiroto is literally a huge manchild mama’s boy.

ToTheNines
06-29-2026, 08:17 PM
I mean hiroto is literally a huge manchild mama’s boy.

True. But he’s rich and powerful, you’d think he had a harem or something.

They should have had Splinter cut his dick off in TLR #4 to explain why he has no progeny.

Heyowakka
06-29-2026, 08:24 PM
If there’s one thing the Japanese male fears, it’s having children.

ToTheNines
06-29-2026, 08:37 PM
It’s also kind of odd that Nagi only had one kid, apparently Saki only had one kid, then Karai has one kid and there is no sign of the father. Why didn’t Hiroto take his surname? What’s his deal?

Andrew NDB
06-29-2026, 08:43 PM
I think this sums up exactly why it doesn't resonate with a lot of old school Mirage fans. It's designed in part for the people who wouldn't invest time in the original comics, by all measures a completely different, casual audience. Meanwhile, there's still a void that needs filling.

There are several ways they could have gone about TLR to make it "matter" more.

1. Actually make it a Mirage coda. Dive full on into Mirage.

2. Make it a distant future tale for their existing IDW comics.

3. Make TLR's background/flashbacks vague and open enough to make it either a future tale of Mirage, IDW, or something else. Make people speculate.

Roseangelo
06-29-2026, 09:39 PM
IMO the hype for TLR is entirely based on the concept, not the actual content of the books.

Issue 1 was the concept; the most effort went into setting it up.

It also had to basically be drawn twice. This gave them more time to tighten things up.

The rest of the series floundered through delays and other issues. The series came out right when we were still deep in COVID territory, so I have no doubt that played part of it.

I didn't read TLR until it was complete. I didn't hate it and it was a nice diversion from what the IDW series had become.

I think the cover of #1 is fairly iconic, and I picked up the matching action figure for $5 at a flea market. But, ultimately, I find that I don't really care about any of the continuing characters.

sdp
06-29-2026, 10:25 PM
You guys are all tourists, tru fans know TLR is a sequel to the Mirage continuity. I know because I heard it in the CowaShredhead Podcast.

TheLabRat
06-30-2026, 06:24 AM
True. But he’s rich and powerful, you’d think he had a harem or something.

They should have had Splinter cut his dick off in TLR #4 to explain why he has no progeny.

If he is truly that lonely, he could actually create a robot that looks like his mother so that he can live with her. He's a villain so incest can be used as a gimmick for him.