PDA

View Full Version : Who do you think is the best Turtles writer?


Mr. Entertainment
03-25-2026, 03:19 PM
You could choose anyone between the various companies that have published TMNT comic books.

For me, going back to Mirage, it'd have to be Jim Lawson. Say what you want about his art (lord knows I've heard the criticism), but the man was a damn good storyteller. City at War and Volume 2 were some of the best TMNT comics in my opinion. All of his single issue stuff was great too like I' Monster, The Path, Blind Faith (which had a unique way of telling the story), and Shades of Gray (both issues).

Some other favorites of mine are the classic 15 issue run of Eastman and Laird (obviously), Rick Veith, Dan Berger, and Tristan's work on Tales Vol 2.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2026, 03:22 PM
The best TMNT writer is the pockets of time when Laird and Eastman's brain fused together to basically become one writer. Generally speaking.

That was always golden.

Mr. Entertainment
03-25-2026, 04:53 PM
The best TMNT writer is the pockets of time when Laird and Eastman's brain fused together to basically become one writer. Generally speaking.

That was always golden.
When the Cartoonist Kayfabe channel was active, in one of their interviews with Kevin and Peter, Pete talked about a possibility of getting back with Kev to tell new stories and see what else they could to do with the Turtles. I don't know how serious he was though and one of the co-hosts passed since then, which could've killed Pete's enthusiasm about it. And if this were to happen, it would be after Volume 4, of course.

GameCobra
03-26-2026, 10:04 AM
Laird and Eastman i would say as well, but special mention goes for Ian Flynn. He gave us the key moments of Mikey Vs. Splinter and gave that very interesting storyline that unfortunately didn't end up going anywhere much afterwards: I'm talking about Null and Zodi in general. Could've been written also as a main antagonist for Alopex considering how much she hated them back then.

Daytona
03-26-2026, 10:29 AM
Definitely Eastman and Laird imo. They were great at channeling their influences like Frank Miller and Jack Kirby. The space adventures are fun and the hard boiled ninja action legitimately kicks ass. They took care to balance multiple threads, despite a bumpy release schedule, build upon previously planted seeds, and kept the characters and scenarios evolving. At worst they had amateur charm but they also were capable of making great comic books.

Jim Lawson seemed to understand the tone that the series had evolved into by the time we reached City at War. He feels as confident with the characters as they do and I almost view him as an extension of the duo.

And shoutout to Rick Veitch, bc The River is a premium comic as well and possibly the best of the guest era. I would have gladly taken a whole TMNT series done by Veitch.

Whoever write Sons of the Silent Age should probably be a contender too.

Mr. Entertainment
03-26-2026, 11:26 AM
Whoever write Sons of the Silent Age should probably be a contender too.
That would be Stephen Murphy. Also the main writer of Archie's TMNT Adventures at the time under the name "Dean Clarrain".

Andrew NDB
03-26-2026, 11:39 AM
You know, pound for pound I might actually have to give it to Steve Murphy. When he's cooking, he's cooking and his volume of writing TMNT is pretty vast.

Zog The Magnificent
03-26-2026, 07:53 PM
Besides Eastman and Laird Together, I think I might have to agree with Steve Murphy as well. His sheer output means that he has more bad stories than most writers, true, but he also has more good stories than most of the writers for the same reason. When he was good, he was REALLY good.

And honestly? I'm also giving props to Gary Carlson, because the whole of Vol. 3 is my favorite TMNT story tied only with the original City at War.

Braeden99
03-26-2026, 09:09 PM
Jim Lawson and Tristan Jones

frank_one
03-26-2026, 09:11 PM
For me, going back to Mirage, it'd have to be Jim Lawson. Say what you want about his art (lord knows I've heard the criticism), but the man was a damn good storyteller. City at War and Volume 2 were some of the best TMNT comics in my opinion. All of his single issue stuff was great too like I' Monster, The Path, Blind Faith (which had a unique way of telling the story), and Shades of Gray (both issues).City at war was not written solely by Lawson.

According to miragelicensing.com:
Story: Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird
Script: Peter Laird and Jim Lawson
Except the first issue which was written by Eastman and Laird.

Andrew NDB
03-27-2026, 11:13 AM
Story: Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird
Script: Peter Laird and Jim Lawson

Presumably it would be like, for #51 - 62....

* Kevin and Peter wrote a big synopsis for all of those issues, detailed plot points and what happens to who and when and why.

* Like, Vol. 2, Peter would draw all the pages from a "loose script" based on the synopsis he and Kevin came up with and then Lawson would write in the captions and dialogue, then Laird would come back in afterward with any additions/corrections to what Lawson did.

Kevin's limited involvement in CAW on the whole probably explains why he somehow thinks Karai is Shredder's daughter. Probably he and Laird never discussed that she ISN'T -- obviously -- Shredder's daughter while doing the synopsis, and then he finds out she's his "daughter" in the 4Kids cartoon and all that.

Powder
03-27-2026, 03:12 PM
Murph, without hesitation. I love all the Mirage gang's work, but his is the most poignant. The somber existential stuff he did was just too good.

Andrew NDB
03-27-2026, 03:12 PM
Murphy's done enough Mirage stuff that I'd count him as part of the "Mirage gang," too, for sure.

ToTheNines
03-27-2026, 03:27 PM
Great thread topic!

Murph, without hesitation. I love all the Mirage
gang's work, but his is the most poignant. The somber existential stuff he did was just too good.

Yes, I agree. His brotherly banter was also always really good. I liked how he wrote all the turtles, especially Leo (except for the cringe anti-gun PSA stuff from Archie Leo). I loved how he wrote Splinter.

TMNTA was always really well paced and showed his ability to write a long overarching narrative.

I enjoyed Berger being the editor too, but Murphy’s era of Tales was so good. His vision for that book was incredible and he brought in some great talent.