PDA

View Full Version : Who do you want to see work on Turtles Comics?


Smithguy789
03-26-2026, 02:00 PM
What comic artists/writers are on y'all's wishlist to work on the TMNT? Either on the main ongoing or a special/mini, whatever.

Here's mine -

Peach Momoko - #1 on my wishlist. Man, I wanna see IDW give Momoko a mini or graphic novel and just give her free-reign to go absolutely nuts. No continuity or status quo, no preconceived versions of the turtles, just her re-interpretation in her style.

Humberto Ramos - I've always loved Ramos' art, and I just learned today that he did some variants for IDW TMNT. Seeing them made me want a whole comic story with his art.

Cullen Bunn - really the only modern (he's been writing comics for ten plus years now, but whatever) writer I'd be interested in seeing their take on the TMNT. He's written a lot of licensed stuff, and always seems to do his homework and take care of the properties he works with. Plus he's just a good writer all the way around. He wrote a fill-in issue of Amazing Adventures, but I want to see him on something more substantial.

neatoman
03-26-2026, 05:24 PM
Alex Ross. I think about it, look at this artwork:
https://www.alexrossart.com/cdn/shop/collections/timeless_1920x.jpg?v=1701806137
It's very realistically detailed and yet still faithful to what the original designs of these characters were. Imagine, the issue 1 designs of the Turtles rendered like this? It would make me cry tears of joy.

Andrew NDB
03-26-2026, 05:27 PM
Some kind of "Ninja Turtles For All Seasons" magazine-sized painted 48 page book would be great from Alex Ross. Which means you'd probably want someone like Mark Waid to write it.

Is Paul Jenkins still alive? He could do it.

Smithguy789
03-27-2026, 08:20 AM
Is Paul Jenkins still alive? He could do it.

Jenkins is another good choice I didn't think about. I always liked the Spider-man stuff he did with Humberto Ramos, so the two of them reuniting on TMNT would be sick.
And yes, he's still alive, he's just recently returned to Marvel.

As far as Alex Ross goes, no doubt he's a fantastic artist. However, sometimes (usually just on covers, not when he's doing interiors) his stuff looks like models cosplaying, and doesn't *feel* like the characters it's supposed to be. My one trepidation with him doing a turtle project is that he'd model them based off the 1990 movie suits. Which, mind you, look great, but that doesn't mean I want to see them in a comic.

ToTheNines
03-27-2026, 09:12 AM
Great topic for a thread and some good answers so far. Off the top of my head I would say Sean Murphy for art and Matt Fraction for story.

Andrew NDB
03-27-2026, 10:59 AM
Jenkins is another good choice I didn't think about. I always liked the Spider-man stuff he did with Humberto Ramos, so the two of them reuniting on TMNT would be sick.
And yes, he's still alive, he's just recently returned to Marvel.

If anyone recalls, Jenkins already wrote "The Halls of Lost Legends." That A.C. Farley drew.

frank_one
03-27-2026, 01:10 PM
I would like to see Alex Ross's take on the Mirage Turtles #1 cover. And maybe some more covers by Glenn Fabry (he did four wonderful covers in early 90s).

Daytona
03-27-2026, 01:42 PM
Ideally it would be Grant Morrison or Alan Moore, which is either unlikely or nigh impossible so I don’t much consider the possibility.

Strategically I’d say Warren Ellis is the best possible pick. He had some controversy so maybe he’d be more willing to take the work. Double-edged sword though bc publishers, and likely IDW especially, will be hesitant to work with him. That’s said it’s been a while and there’s no doubt in my mind he’d write one of the most kick-ass TMNT stories ever.

If you’re curious what he can do then I’d suggest his run on Thunderbolts. It’s quite accessible as long as you’re familiar with the Marvel Civil War event and it’s just a total blast to read. It’s pure entertainment at full throttle.

Another somewhat strategic choice would be Donny Cates - another guy who has the chops but also some of the controversy.

Idk maybe there’s hope now to get some prestige writers to do shorter runs. It certainly feels like The Last Ronin raised the status of TMNT among the comics community. I’m sure that was helpful in bringing Jason Aaron is, who’s a prestige name in comics, personal opinions aside. So yeah, give me one of the elite British dudes for a contained mini-series.

Smithguy789
03-27-2026, 01:47 PM
If anyone recalls, Jenkins already wrote "The Halls of Lost Legends." That A.C. Farley drew.

I always forget about that. Do we know if that was a Jenkins idea that he wrote for Farley to draw, or was Farley involved with the plot?

Great topic for a thread and some good answers so far. Off the top of my head I would say Sean Murphy for art and Matt Fraction for story.

Got the idea for this thread when I heard Sam Kieth passed away. He's my all-time favorite comics artist, and I always wanted to see him work on TMNT.

Another somewhat strategic choice would be Donny Cates - another guy who has the chops but also some of the controversy.

Cates is a good pick as well, but I'll be (pleasantly) surprised if he ever makes it back to writing comics with his injuries.

Powder
03-27-2026, 03:28 PM
I am very out of touch with the western comics industry/scene. I'd just like to see a TMNT manga. Let's have an entirely different cultural approach. Japan did interesting things with the turtles in the past, I want more.

neatoman
03-27-2026, 04:36 PM
I am very out of touch with the western comics industry/scene. I'd just like to see a TMNT manga. Let's have an entirely different cultural approach. Japan did interesting things with the turtles in the past, I want more.

Had he been alive, TMNT written and drawn by Shotaro Ishinomori might have been interesting to see.

Andrew NDB
03-27-2026, 04:42 PM
I always forget about that. Do we know if that was a Jenkins idea that he wrote for Farley to draw, or was Farley involved with the plot?

I doubt Farley did much script-related.

Fun fact: Jenkins did "Origin," the first time ever we got the origin of Wolverine.

Ideally it would be Grant Morrison or Alan Moore, which is either unlikely or nigh impossible so I don’t much consider the possibility.

I was going to say Grant Morrison, but if he had the level of love needed to do it (the same level of love he has for the DCU and its rich history before the DEI hires took over in like the 2010s) then he would have made a try at it already.

Alan Moore? Oh god, can you imagine? It would have been AMAZING. But it would have had to have been a pre-Alan Moore jaded from everything. So we'd have to go back quite a ways. But man oh man, if that man had taken a deep dive into even a 20 issue run of TMNT... we'd be talking about it for decades.

Smithguy789
03-28-2026, 06:51 AM
I am very out of touch with the western comics industry/scene. I'd just like to see a TMNT manga. Let's have an entirely different cultural approach. Japan did interesting things with the turtles in the past, I want more.

I emailed IDW around the time TMNTxNaruto starting coming out, asking them if the relationship with VIZ would lead to an official English release of the TMNT Manga. I got an email back saying IDW had "no plans" to do anything with TMNT Manga.

Fun fact: Jenkins did "Origin," the first time ever we got the origin of Wolverine.

Alan Moore? Oh god, can you imagine? It would have been AMAZING. But it would have had to have been a pre-Alan Moore jaded from everything. So we'd have to go back quite a ways. But man oh man, if that man had taken a deep dive into even a 20 issue run of TMNT... we'd be talking about it for decades.

Jenkins also did Wolverine: The End, my preferred "Final Wolverine Story"

If I'm not mistaken, Alan Moore's time working with Image overlapped with the TMNT being published there. If so, it's a real shame those streams couldn't cross for a mini or special or something.

Daytona
03-28-2026, 11:14 AM
Alan Moore? Oh god, can you imagine? It would have been AMAZING. But it would have had to have been a pre-Alan Moore jaded from everything. So we'd have to go back quite a ways. But man oh man, if that man had taken a deep dive into even a 20 issue run of TMNT... we'd be talking about it for decades.

That’s exactly how I look at the notion of Morrison writing TMNT. I imagine he has zero interest. At same time he could probably give new life to the entire concept in 30 seconds if he tried. He has an uncanny ability to see what makes a character amazing. Usually something that’s been there all along but wasn’t really acknowledged.

I can’t even imagine what Moore would do with them. Probably something that would sound blasphemous as an elevator pitch. I mean if this were a Swamp Thing message board pre-Moore and we heard he was basically going to say Swamp Thing isn’t actually Alec Holland, we could very well be having a “TMNT are from a turtle planet” moment. Yet since it’d be Moore doing it, it’d be the most incredible comic we’ve ever read and would probably accept it wholeheartedly.

Jephael
03-28-2026, 08:30 PM
I got to meet John Romita Jr. at San Diego Comic Con back in 2017, and he was a cool guy! Given his history with Spider-Man, Kick-@$$ and many other popular characters, I would love to see his take on the TMNT!!!

FrederikWolferson
03-29-2026, 12:23 AM
Anyone but IDW at this point.

Daytona
03-29-2026, 04:33 AM
I got to meet John Romita Jr. at San Diego Comic Con back in 2017, and he was a cool guy! Given his history with Spider-Man, Kick-@$$ and many other popular characters, I would love to see his take on the TMNT!!!

That’s an awesome choice. Idk if he’s past his prime or just needs a new colorist but I’d love to see Romita Jr on the Turtles. I’m surprised we don’t even have a cover from him.

Braeden99
03-29-2026, 05:16 PM
It really depends on what version they're writing.

For Mirage, I just wanna see Tristan Jones finally finish Gang Wars. I messaged him on Instagram, and he said he'd be more than happy to return if IDW allowed it. He also mentioned he'd like to start from square one again and even do the art too.

neatoman
03-29-2026, 05:22 PM
I wonder what Kirkman would do? Invincible meets the TMNT? Like the Spider-Man crossover?