PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #1 Final First Edition reprint/recreation


ToTheNines
05-07-2026, 06:31 PM
kTP0DfyflsM?si=Q1ysdDPrZhc_IEbl

Have you seen this? Have you heard about this? Our old pal Rich Horn pulled this off with the negatives of the original art of #1 that he owns.

I got my copy this week. It’s very nice! Much better than spending $20k on a real first printing :lol:

frank_one
05-07-2026, 08:06 PM
This is something I could get, if he is willing to ship it to Europe.

CyberCubed
05-07-2026, 08:46 PM
Is this legal?

ToTheNines
05-07-2026, 09:15 PM
This is something I could get, if he is willing to ship it to Europe.

I’m pretty sure he does.

Is this legal?

https://media1.tenor.com/m/8im-JIG1ST0AAAAd/indian-meme-indian-guy.gif

Obviously.

Basically the only way it differs from a real copy is the blurbs and the legal jargon on the inside front cover. “Published under license of IDW” right there.

The inside back cover even has the Gobbledygook #1 ad!

nicobobinus
05-11-2026, 06:04 AM
I got the signed triple pack of this directly from Kevin Eastman's site.

It's a wonderful project and it's lovely to have some mint copies so close to the original print run. It makes me feel better about having a slabbed copy of Issue 1 v.3 on my wall that can't be read anymore.

Great Hierophant
05-13-2026, 09:18 PM
I bought one of his 9.6s and can highly recommend them. $50 versus $500 for a 3rd Print in ok quality. They are fully licensed and have obvious fakery-prevention features on the rear back cover, the inside front cover and on page 21.

ToTheNines
05-20-2026, 01:53 PM
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/scoop-a-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-1-facsimile-from-idw-in-august/

The ****ers at IDW are copying Rich. SAD!

Great Hierophant
05-20-2026, 11:35 PM
That scoop said "44 pages", the original 1st-3rd prints and the Final First Edition only have 40.

Will the cover be wraparound? The article was not clear and some of these reprints only use the front cover and the back cover is relegated to ad space.

Will the interior pages be printed on newsprint like Rich's?

Will the original negatives for the 1st-2nd prints that Rich acquired be used?

nicobobinus
05-21-2026, 04:41 AM
If it's not printed on news print it completely misses the point IMO...

ToTheNines
05-21-2026, 05:45 AM
If it's not printed on news print it completely misses the point IMO...

I agree. This is just for normies lol

Great Hierophant
05-22-2026, 11:53 AM
On the positive side, if you get white paper it will likely be more durable than newsprint and should not yellow. If IDW takes from a high resolution scan of the original artwork pages instead of a photostatic negative of that artwork, then the print quality should be improved over any printing relying on the negatives. They will probably have the fixes incorporated into later printings ("Under Nagi's leadership" vs. Under Saki's leadership.") that the early printings suffered from. The advertised price is better than a FFE in any condition as advertised for sale on the TMNT: A Collection site.

Andrew NDB
05-22-2026, 11:56 AM
Is this legal?

https://y.yarn.co/654a4f0a-4eb5-4b4c-8288-9d21b9cbe075_text.gif

CyberCubed
05-23-2026, 11:02 AM
Now that IDW is doing an official version of this, is this version pointless? It's almost like IDW saw what this guy was doing and deciding to put it out themselves.

ToTheNines
05-23-2026, 11:23 AM
Now that IDW is doing an official version of this, is this version pointless? It's almost like IDW saw what this guy was doing and deciding to put it out themselves.

We’ll see.

I highly doubt the IDW version will be on newsprint paper. Also, if you watch the video from my first post at x1.25 speed or whatever, you’ll see that Rich had the art scanned in the EXACT same way it was in the first two printings in 1984, down to the errors and irregularities on some of the panel borders and ****ed up splash pages.

The main benefit is that this will just be more accessible and inexpensive since you don’t have to pay shipping.

And… if it sells well it would be cool if they did this for more issues. I would probably buy #2-4 and the Raphael Micro.

Great Hierophant
06-07-2026, 05:37 PM
And… if it sells well it would be cool if they did this for more issues. I would probably buy #2-4 and the Raphael Micro.

If they did true reproductions of these, that would be awesome. If they just reissued the 2019 35th Anniversary box set, that would be lame because those lost original lettering, ads and letters and Turtle Tracks editorials.