View Full Version : For IDW’s reprint department: A list of what is missing
ToTheNines
07-12-2026, 04:27 AM
Archie:
Year of the Turtle #1-3 (they never did this story in the TPB series)
TMNT meet Archie (they’re definitely aware of this, must be a rights issue)
“Seed of Destruction” (unfinished story from Furrlough. I think Turtles Club is going to reprint and finish this, but I’m just being through)
Mutant Universe Sourcebook #1-3
Dreamwave:
TMNT #1-7 (might be a good idea for the 25th anniversary of the 4kids show in 2028?)
IDW:
Mirage Ultimate Collection Volume 6 (treasure trove of rare Mirage shorts. Almost all of Shellshock is in there. Both the hardcover and TPB are out of print and have become exorbitantly expensive)
Urban Legends TPBs (I know the black and white hardcover is coming soon, but there’s currently no easy way to collect the colored series for some reason).
Image:
EXTRA PAGE FROM TMNT #2 (only ever printed in the 1997 TPB)
Savage Dragon #2 & Savage Dragon/TMNT #1
TMNT/Savage Dragon #1 & Savage Dragon #22
Big Bang Comics #10
Mars Attacks Image #1 (Image should just reprint this mini in a TPB)
(If you’re being a real nut there’s also Shattered Image #2 [single panel cameo], Savage Dragon/Destroyer Duck #1 [small role], Savage Dragon #41 [cameos at the wedding], Savage Dragon #71 [Horridus hooks up with Dragon as mentioned in an editor’s note in the Modeen/Dubakov version of Vol. 3 #25], and Savage Dragon #262 [Horridus dies from COVID-19], and I think that’s it)
Mirage:
“Old Times” - Plastron Cafe #1
“A Christmas Carol” - Michaelangelo #1 second printing
Frontpieces and Epilogue - Tales of the TMNT Treasury Edition (Spinal Tapped is being collected, so these will probably come too)
All the Rick Veitch stuff, an absolute shame that River Tales isn’t happening. Pay the man!
Bad Moon Rising, The Third Kind and The Brain Thief (I fully expect these in the upcoming Tales hardcover series, just being thorough)
TMNT III movie adaptation
TMNT 2007 movie prequels #1-5 and the adaptation
The Maltese Turtle (yuck)
Times Pipeline
The Haunted Pizza
Muscle and Faith
TMNT/Flaming Carrot #1-4
Plastron Cafe #1-4 (placeholder, I will breakdown relevant shorts later)
Turtle Soup and Turtle Soup #1-4 (also a placeholder)
Smithguy789
07-12-2026, 11:56 AM
Couple additions (i know it's still in-progress, but I'll share what I know)
Fred Hembeck's backup short from the 3rd (i believe) printing of Vol 1, #2
Don Simpson's "Techno Turtles Plus One" short is, to my knowledge, the only thing from Shell Shock that's NEVER been reprinted ever.
Roseangelo
07-12-2026, 05:54 PM
You guys seriously need to stop working for free.
Zog The Magnificent
07-12-2026, 06:37 PM
There's also the Mirage short story from Digital Webbing Presents #24. Can't forget that one.
Powder
07-12-2026, 06:46 PM
You guys seriously need to stop working for free.
This would only apply if they actually gave a damn about & heeded this stuff (they don't & won't).
CyberCubed
07-12-2026, 07:19 PM
Also a checklist like this is handy, it's not like IDW hasn't been putting more effort into recent collections. They're collecting old Mirage material none of us could have imagined they would (like Spinal Tapped from the 2007 Tales collection), and Michael Dooney's Challenges book.
Also ToTheNines would indeed work for them for free to get proper collections.
ToTheNines
07-12-2026, 08:51 PM
Couple additions (i know it's still in-progress, but I'll share what I know)
Fred Hembeck's backup short from the 3rd (i believe) printing of Vol 1, #2
Don Simpson's "Techno Turtles Plus One" short is, to my knowledge, the only thing from Shell Shock that's NEVER been reprinted ever.
There's also the Mirage short story from Digital Webbing Presents #24. Can't forget that one.
Thank you gents, will add these.
I think I’ll made some subcategories for Mirage that delineates canon stuff, which I guess could be subjective. I’ll think about it.
This would only apply if they actually gave a damn about & heeded this stuff (they don't & won't).
I haven’t bothered to actually confirm a personnel change, but there’s been a noticeable shift in reprint quality and scope roundabout 2024. I’m going to shoot my shot and email this list to the proper channels once it’s complete and see what happens.
Also ToTheNines would indeed work for them for free to get proper collections.
I do it for the homies! IDW can’t afford me anyway :lol:
Andrew NDB
07-13-2026, 12:20 AM
To be fair, you could make that post and at the end write, "... and I just sent this to _____, the editor of the reprints."
I'm pretty sure all their E-mail addresses are public. I'm not against Mirage collections "Getting it right" finally but so much damage has been done to the average reader/consumer I'm not sure "Collect some IDW TPBs" is really going to ever be great advice to anyone.
CyberCubed
07-13-2026, 06:57 AM
The old trades they put out decades ago are long out of print. I don't even think you can buy new copies of the Ultimate collections anymore, and those were printed in black and white. They basically phased out their older collections, unless you search ebay or a comic shop there's no way to buy them anymore.
Smithguy789
07-13-2026, 07:07 AM
Another addition, probably in the "if you really want to be a nut" category--
The 2 Last of the Viking Heroes specials
Also, Sonic the Hedgehog #10, one-panel cameo
ToTheNines
07-13-2026, 07:13 AM
To be fair, you could make that post and at the end write, "... and I just sent this to _____, the editor of the reprints."
I'm pretty sure all their E-mail addresses are public. I'm not against Mirage collections "Getting it right" finally but so much damage has been done to the average reader/consumer I'm not sure "Collect some IDW TPBs" is really going to ever be great advice to anyone.
Yeah it’s a damn mess. But a tale as old as time: comics being much more needlessly complicated than they have to be.
The idea here isn’t for them to do it right per se, but while they’re on this streak of doing right by Tales, TMNTA, Volume 3 and more, I’m hoping to bring a couple of obscure ones to their attention.
At least they’ll be more readily available for the people seeking them.
The old trades they put out decades ago are long out of print. I don't even think you can buy new copies of the Ultimate collections anymore, and those were printed in black and white. They basically phased out their older collections, unless you search ebay or a comic shop there's no way to buy them anymore.
They reprinted the Ultimate Collection stuff as softcover TPBs with the turtles in rainbow masks on the cover art. They’re all incredibly cheap on Amazon and I see them on shelves occasionally.
Except, of course, for Vol. 6. The one with most of Shell Shock and several other rare shorts. That’s going for $300+ for either version. Seems unwise to not do another printing of that, but what do I know?
Smithguy789
07-13-2026, 07:31 AM
And while we're on the subject, the fact that a person can't walk into any comic shop and pick up a reasonably priced trade of whatever era of Mirage they feel like reading is ludicrous. Especially when you consider the fact there's like four different ways to collect and read Invincible or most of Marvel/DC's big stories.
ToTheNines
07-13-2026, 07:50 AM
Another addition, probably in the "if you really want to be a nut" category--
The 2 Last of the Viking Heroes specials
Also, Sonic the Hedgehog #10, one-panel cameo
Noted. Thank you my friend.
And while we're on the subject, the fact that a person can't walk into any comic shop and pick up a reasonably priced trade of whatever era of Mirage they feel like reading is ludicrous. Especially when you consider the fact there's like four different ways to collect and read Invincible or most of Marvel/DC's big stories.
For real. Last Ronin and even the main IDW book are also normally pretty well stocked in a couple of different options in an intuitive manner.
It’s also crazy to me that IDW never ponied up and did a really nicely colored series of Mirage hardcovers or something. The Color Classics line was ATROCIOUS.
Great Hierophant
07-13-2026, 09:12 AM
Does Green-Gray Sushi Turtles, the Official Parody of the 1990 Movie, and its four follow-ups in Turtle Soup Vol. 2 #1-4 count on this list?
rs_jr
07-13-2026, 04:23 PM
There was also a short story in grunts.
The first palladium book had art by eastman and laird not sure if it was unique to it.
The mirage mini comics.
The Wii version of one the tmnt games had a story by Lawson, not sure if it counts as mirage.
The unreleased source book.
Was the puma blue short story ever collected by IDW?
ToTheNines
07-13-2026, 05:11 PM
Does Green-Gray Sushi Turtles, the Official Parody of the 1990 Movie, and its four follow-ups in Turtle Soup Vol. 2 #1-4 count on this list?
Not something I personally care about at all, but I might as well add it.
0. There was also a short story in grunts.
1. The first palladium book had art by eastman and laird not sure if it was unique to it.
2. The mirage mini comics.
3. The Wii version of one the tmnt games had a story by Lawson, not sure if it counts as mirage.
4. The unreleased source book.
5. Was the puma blue short story ever collected by IDW?
0. It was in Ultimate Collection Vol. 6, which itself needs reprinted at this point.
1. I’m pretty sure those have all been collected. Plus Palladium reprinted most of their stuff in those big hardcovers last year.
2. The only TMNT stories from that were “Casey Jones: Private Eye” (included in the reprint of Vol. 1 #11 that came with the black and white Playmates Mirage turtles 4-pack, as well as Ultimate Collection Vol. 6) and “A Forgotten TMNT Adventure” (collected in Archie Compendium Vol. 1)
3. I don’t really count that. I own the original and Turtles Club included it in Obscure Comics Vol. 1. I guess it would be a cute bonus if they collected all the 2007 movie comics, but I don’t think it’s necessary.
4. I used to think there wasn’t much there, but it recently occurred to me the Viacom sale went through only 2 months before it was supposed to come out. I bet it’s damn near complete, sitting in a filing cabinet or hard drive somewhere.
5. It was in Ultimate Collection Vol. 6, but they should collect it again. That and a couple other shorts giving a peek into the distant future should get some kind of special release if they’re doing the Tales Treasury Edition epilogue soon.
CyberCubed
07-14-2026, 09:15 AM
And while we're on the subject, the fact that a person can't walk into any comic shop and pick up a reasonably priced trade of whatever era of Mirage they feel like reading is ludicrous. Especially when you consider the fact there's like four different ways to collect and read Invincible or most of Marvel/DC's big stories.
I'm pretty sure you can do that now. IDW has compendiums of Vol. 1, and the Volume 2 collection. Image is getting another compendium in black and white this time, and Tales is ongoing.
This stuff is all available on amazon too. I don't really visit book stores, so I have no idea if say Barnes and Noble carries comic compendiums or not.
Smithguy789
07-15-2026, 07:31 AM
I'm pretty sure you can do that now. IDW has compendiums of Vol. 1, and the Volume 2 collection. Image is getting another compendium in black and white this time, and Tales is ongoing.
This stuff is all available on amazon too. I don't really visit book stores, so I have no idea if say Barnes and Noble carries comic compendiums or not.
The thing is, everything you mentioned is hardcover, collector type reprints. And from what I've seen, you're lucky to find the volume one compendiums for cover price at this point.
CyberCubed
07-15-2026, 12:09 PM
The cover price was $150, Amazon usually has them for about $70-$80 a lot of the time. They're sold for less than cover price more often than not
TurtleGurkle
07-15-2026, 05:01 PM
The thing is, everything you mentioned is hardcover, collector type reprints. And from what I've seen, you're lucky to find the volume one compendiums for cover price at this point.
All three of the volume one compendiums are easily available and pretty cheap. Volume 1 is $68 on Amazon right now.
CyberCubed
07-15-2026, 06:30 PM
Yeah, they should definitely do a Mirage Compendium #4 collecting all the Shell Shock stories, but also all the additional Mirage specials like Turtle Soup, the crossovers, the other one-shots as well into one big book. That would be ideal to cover all the rest of Mirage's "loose ends" that don't fall under the "Tales of the TMNT" umbrella.
Maybe you should suggest that in the e-mail, that we need one more big Mirage compendium to collect the Shell Shock shorts and the "loose ends" that I just mentioned above. I think only the Flaming Carrot crossovers might have rights issues for obvious reasons, but everything else should be fair game.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.