PDA

View Full Version : Will IDW Karai ever become an ally, or is she iredeemable?


CyberCubed
07-23-2026, 05:35 PM
IDW Karai has basically been around the entire run of the comic, debuting way back in 2011 when IDW TMNT first started. In every other incarnation, Karai eventually becomes an ally of the Turtles (Mirage, 2k3, Nick 2012, the 4th movie, etc) that she appeared in.

Meanwhile IDW Karai is still attacking the Turtles and causing trouble for them over 180+ issues in (and 15 years later in real life!). She shows no signs of changing her ways and every time the Turtles try to work with her, she turns on them.

Is this version of Karai irredeemable? Or will she become an ally and declare the Foot and TMNT at peace?

Andrew NDB
07-23-2026, 06:00 PM
As far as I'm concerned the only version of Karai worth talking about is the Mirage one. And possibly the 2012 version (which I maintain should have just been Pimiko).

TheLabRat
07-23-2026, 11:12 PM
I hope she is irredeemable. At least she ultimately did terrible things because of her ambition, and even crossed the line. It would be interesting if one day she had a conflict with her grandfather and eventually kill him.

Having Karai kill Shredder not only symbolizes that the Oroku family cannot escape the shadow of Takeshi Tatsuo and The Dragon. This is also how Oroku Saki ultimately suffered similar retribution for his patricide.

GameCobra
07-24-2026, 01:12 PM
My guess is she's being setup as irredeemable and Shredder 2.0. too blind by rage and ambition. She only liked Shredder when he was ambitious.

Dancefloran
07-24-2026, 02:45 PM
That Karai killed her own parents, claimed many lives for her ambitions, sacrificed the soul of her mentor (grandfather figure) for knowledge and sold her soul to a god for power.

Well they tried to redeem the ruthless and cruel Shredder at some point, but I don't see her redemption coming anytime soon.

She could be an ally to the Turtles when they have common enemies (like what happened with Stockman and Old Hob), but ultimately she's a villain.

GameCobra
07-24-2026, 05:23 PM
Heck, i wouldn't be surprised if it turns out Alopex and Karai have to mutually finish each other off for the story to end because Alopex wants to destroy Shredder's legacy while Karai embraces it.

TheLabRat
07-26-2026, 07:55 PM
That Karai killed her own parents, claimed many lives for her ambitions, sacrificed the soul of her mentor (grandfather figure) for knowledge and sold her soul to a god for power.

Well they tried to redeem the ruthless and cruel Shredder at some point, but I don't see her redemption coming anytime soon.

She could be an ally to the Turtles when they have common enemies (like what happened with Stockman and Old Hob), but ultimately she's a villain.

She always get away with it, and didn't paid much price, except for the damage to her self-esteem caused by failure. That's why this character is just a bad villain.

ToTheNines
07-27-2026, 11:55 AM
As far as I'm concerned the only version of Karai worth talking about is the Mirage one. And possibly the 2012 version (which I maintain should have just been Pimiko).

2012? You mean FAKE Karai? Have you seen her birth certificate? Not even born in America and her real name is Hamato HUSSEIN Miwa!

sdp
07-27-2026, 12:26 PM
2012 Karai is also a lesbian mutant snake who becomes one of the good guys

I have no idea why Andrew would defend her, is he a Shinigami shipper?

ToTheNines
07-28-2026, 09:38 AM
Jokes aside, IDW Karai sucks ass. She had some real potential at the end of #50, which was what, a decade ago? Longer?

She honestly should have just stuck around and worked for Splinter. Since then she disappeared to “find herself” and got possessed by an evil sword or whatever. Then was doing human/mutant trafficking in mutant town I guess? That all stunk. Then they tried to make her interesting and act like she turned over a new leaf with Armageddon Game/The Alliance, but she was just acting in pragmatism when she realized Rat King was going to literally destroy the entire planet.

Untold Destiny was actually really good and fun, but ended with her being possessed again. This time by an evil dragon lol. Now that she came out of her goon cave, she’s just doing mustache twirling villain crap. They squandered her rivalry with Yoshi Chen. Just kill her off already.

Better yet, end the book. It’s been 15+ years.

Cloudrunner
07-28-2026, 03:06 PM
The IDW run currently suffers from "too many allies, not enough villains". I don't think it would serve Karai's character, nor the Foot Clan and its other side characters, to have them turn ally with the turtles. That would likely just write them out of the story as it's done to so many in the past.

TheLabRat
07-28-2026, 06:08 PM
Untold Destiny was actually really good and fun, but ended with her being possessed again. This time by an evil dragon lol.

But it was entirely her own choice. The problem is that before she could commit any truly evildoing, like commit a massacre or at least harm the turtles' good friend, she quickly regretted her decision and tried to get rid of it, as if she were also a victim. That's why IDW Karai is such a failed and shallow main villain.

ticktack
07-30-2026, 11:46 AM
People 'change':
• when it fits (nessesary),
• whenever they feel like it.

But their old self might come back, idk. !!!DON'T BE nice, melting, mellow, soft!!!

!!CENTER YOURSELF!!

Be in tune to your emotions, real emotion and LISTEN TO YOURSELF. My suggestion. Don't get under fire and risk YOURSELF for smb else. Hmm. !!!And NEVER BELIEVE!!!!! To promices and soft words, hearts emojis. PLEASE DON'T!!!! I AM TELLING YOU!!

Yeah, just keep coldness, YOU SHOULD ACTUALLY. Save YOURSELF and be MERCIFUL to yourself FIRST. Keep/mercy/save yourself.

<3 I HEAR YOU. <3 YOU <3 MATTER. <3

Andrew NDB
07-30-2026, 11:50 AM
2012 Karai is also a lesbian mutant snake who becomes one of the good guys

I have no idea why Andrew would defend her, is he a Shinigami shipper?

I don't think my daughter and I even made it to meet Shinigami.

ToTheNines
07-30-2026, 11:51 AM
Damn dude, you gotta finish season 4 at least.

ticktack
07-30-2026, 11:51 AM
Is this version of Karai irredeemable? Or will she become an ally and declare the Foot and TMNT at peace?

Possible, but it is a risk to your well-being. And that they can come back to their old ways. Let them suffer for a while 100% (with a final escape option and quitting at mind, also valid. You are more important, not a therapy person and emotional chewtoy), let them self-reflect and finally think deep. If they can/like. *sideeye*

ToTheNines
08-05-2026, 07:48 PM
Thread theme

0dCPK5ddB-Q?is=RH56NlM73oY7eyoJ