PDA

View Full Version : NYCC 2026: Matthew Rosenberg teases all-out war in ‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ #25


TheLabRat
10-09-2026, 04:22 AM
https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/08/nycc-2026-matthew-rosenberg-tmnt/

Rosenberg first discussed how his first exposure to the TMNT universe was the original Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird run. Rosenberg went on to describe how that shaped his perspective on the characters, which bumped up against his schoolmates’ opinions, who only watched the cartoon. Despite that relationship with the original text, he doesn’t view his upcoming stewardship as any more valid than past or future runs. He reveres what came before so much that the “first two issues” will not feature any new villains.

Speaking of villains, Rosenberg claimed the one “mistake” Eastman and Laird made was underestimating Shredder’s character. He compared Shredder to Darth Vader, saying his army and physical prowess make him the most dangerous TMNT character.

-

Rosenberg compared the opening arc’s conflict to movies such as Escape from New York and Friday the 13th. His first issue is TMNT #25, and he said he’s plotted through issue #33, meaning the Turtles have many more hardships ahead that will require them to work together.

Dancefloran
10-09-2026, 06:09 AM
I can see Shredder going at the Christmas special and pulling up a "I declare the fourth great ninja war!", oops sorry wrong manga, I mean comics.

CyberCubed
10-09-2026, 12:05 PM
But how is this going to be different than the 100 other wars IDW has had since the first issue in 2011? This is just the same thing they always do.

Andrew NDB
10-09-2026, 12:09 PM
Rosenberg first discussed how his first exposure to the TMNT universe was the original Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird run. Rosenberg went on to describe how that shaped his perspective on the characters, which bumped up against his schoolmates’ opinions, who only watched the cartoon.

I like the guy already. But he's still going to run head-on into Nickelodeon sticky notes. Probably.

TheLabRat
10-09-2026, 12:44 PM
I can see Shredder going at the Christmas special and pulling up a "I declare the fourth great ninja war!", oops sorry wrong manga, I mean comics.

IDW Shredder has already got too many favor in the story. Wouldn't it be better to give Stockman more spotlight, or turn Karai into a real big bad?

Dancefloran
10-09-2026, 02:04 PM
IDW Shredder has already got too many favor in the story. Wouldn't it be better to give Stockman more spotlight, or turn Karai into a real big bad?

The way they sold the plot, I imagine the Turtles fighting absolutely everyone lol : Shredder's EPF, Karai's Foot Clan, Hun's Purple Dragons, maybe even Papa Beng's Ghost boys, Stockman and Old Hob LMAO. All in one night

Daytona
10-09-2026, 07:59 PM
Well, another writer and yet another chance for me to give the book a try. Seems somewhat promising.

The artist has me hesitant. Talented but I just have a hard time getting into a slick digital style like that. To me it comes across a bit sterile. Especially for a TMNT book, which I like to have some texture. That said, the artist can win me over if they’re a great storyteller and knows how to frame a story.

TheLabRat
10-13-2026, 09:37 AM
The way they sold the plot, I imagine the Turtles fighting absolutely everyone lol : Shredder's EPF, Karai's Foot Clan, Hun's Purple Dragons, maybe even Papa Beng's Ghost boys, Stockman and Old Hob LMAO. All in one night

Look like Rat King is "back (https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/13/tmnt-tuesday-78-27/)", not sure if this is the same one but use classic look, or is it a different person?

frank_one
10-13-2026, 12:11 PM
Look like Rat King is "back (https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/13/tmnt-tuesday-78-27/)", not sure if this is the same one but use classic look, or is it a different person?The Hunchback of Notre-Rat

neatoman
10-13-2026, 12:48 PM
Look like Rat King is "back (https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/13/tmnt-tuesday-78-27/)", not sure if this is the same one but use classic look, or is it a different person?

Well, I guess it could be the hospital patient the character started out as or the Bishop clone or something. Anyway these pantheon guys don't really remain dead regardless and I assume we're getting something like we did in Shredder #6, where it is and isn't him.

Dancefloran
10-13-2026, 04:01 PM
Look like Rat King is "back (https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/13/tmnt-tuesday-78-27/)", not sure if this is the same one but use classic look, or is it a different person?

Could be a resurrected version of the character who succeeded where Kitsune failed.
I wonder if they'll tie him to some loose ends plot points of Jason Aaron's run (like the rats helping the Turtles and the mystery homeless character who talked to Michelangelo).

He could also be a "new" character why not

CyberCubed
10-13-2026, 10:29 PM
I would be interested if we have a more "normal" Rat King like we're used to as opposed to the Patheon/God version. Maybe he either reincarnates as a normal guy, or his essence embodies a regular human, or something like that.

TheLabRat
10-14-2026, 06:15 AM
Could be a resurrected version of the character who succeeded where Kitsune failed.
I wonder if they'll tie him to some loose ends plot points of Jason Aaron's run (like the rats helping the Turtles and the mystery homeless character who talked to Michelangelo).

He could also be a "new" character why not

I doubt whether they really want to solve these problems. Maybe the new writer just want to write some kind of a Mickey's House of Villains or The Evil League of Mutants-like story, in the each issue, the turtles fight one of these villains, and are almost always on the defensive, the difference being that these villains don't sing disney villain song.

ToTheNines
10-14-2026, 06:58 AM
I like when Rosenberg says about what makes the TMNT cool characters. How you get the sense that they’re fighting for their lives. Obviously they have plot armor, but they’re just 4 mortals taking on an army and they get their asses kicked a little along the way. Cuts, bruises, broken weapons. All their victories feel earned.

Veering off topic, but this is exactly what I hate about IDW’s Shredder series. He just waltzes through the story in god mode and all the side characters just bask in his awesomeness. It’s boring.

TheLabRat
10-14-2026, 08:03 AM
I like when Rosenberg says about what makes the TMNT cool characters. How you get the sense that they’re fighting for their lives. Obviously they have plot armor, but they’re just 4 mortals taking on an army and they get their asses kicked a little along the way. Cuts, bruises, broken weapons. All their victories feel earned.

Veering off topic, but this is exactly what I hate about IDW’s Shredder series. He just waltzes through the story in god mode and all the side characters just bask in his awesomeness. It’s boring.

For other ninja turtle, but IDW turtles? This is their biggest revenge against Bebop and Rocksteady so far. haha.
https://i.postimg.cc/632gcvBL/6514569.png

Of course, perhaps one day a writer will realize this problem and make them truly edge and violence, so that even if killing is still not allowed, they can at least beat these villains black and blue just like Powerpuff Girls.

ToTheNines
10-14-2026, 08:40 AM
I meant Mirage. That’s what Rosenberg was saying he liked when he first read the early Eastman and Laird stuff.

ToTheNines
10-29-2026, 06:15 AM
https://www.cbr.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-rosenberg-new-writer-interview/

TheLabRat
10-29-2026, 06:38 AM
Meh. Does IDW turtles really need another "Worst Night of the Turtles' Lives"?

Daytona
10-30-2026, 03:17 PM
Too bad Rosenberg is a crazy person. Too distracting to allow me to appreciate the book.

Fenryr
10-30-2026, 04:18 PM
Fingers crossed for this new team, but the solicits and publicity are killing my enthusiasm and that is a lot of words about very little. He likes Grant Morrison. Yawn. TMNT has had a lot of The Warriors in it from the beginning. Not exactly a new take. He's excited for them to... ride a subway? Okay.

Never thought I'd yearn for Campbell's slower pacing, but a few issues without throwing every single villain at them all at once to nobody's benefit would go a long way. If the villains never succeed and the heroes never grow, does anybody really win? Certainly not the audience.

Dancefloran
10-31-2026, 04:07 AM
Too bad Rosenberg is a crazy person. Too distracting to allow me to appreciate the book.

Where does this come from ?

Asks a crazy person

ToTheNines
11-01-2026, 08:13 AM
Daytona is a red-pilled Florida-Man. I assume Rosenberg is a shitlib, but I’m just guessing.

Dancefloran
11-01-2026, 01:21 PM
Daytona is a red-pilled Florida-Man. I assume Rosenberg is a shitlib, but I’m just guessing.

Holy cow !
I saw Rosenberg's tweets about white people
This dude's either a libtroll or a performative liberal, because he's white himself, which makes it a bit cringe
Although I do enjoy seeing red-pilled people crying a river over stuff like this

It's not that hard to let "non-white" folks speak for themselves

He may intend to include some ragebaiting in his TMNT run

CyberCubed
11-01-2026, 07:05 PM
Go woke, go broke.

Either way, I "separate the art from the artist." I'll judge him on how his writing is for the new arc, not what he's like in real life. Although I'm surprised IDW hired him given this.

Dancefloran
11-02-2026, 01:28 AM
Go woke, go broke.


You said the thing !

13963

ToTheNines
11-02-2026, 06:34 PM
Go woke, go broke.

Either way, I "separate the art from the artist." I'll judge him on how his writing is for the new arc, not what he's like in real life. Although I'm surprised IDW hired him given this.

The Jewish Writer will never go broke

ToTheNines
11-19-2026, 01:52 PM
UUUUUGGGGHHHH

https://bleedingcool.com/comics/scoop-spoilers-what-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-25-is-really-about/

CyberCubed
11-19-2026, 02:32 PM
Art style looks good, sort of reminds me of the animated Batman/TMNT movie. I suppose this "gang war" he keeps talking about must include Shredder/Dog Star Gang vs Karai/Foot, or the EPF in general if Shredder loses his command and they take it back from him.

But IDW has had so many gang wars over and over it's hard to imagine how it'll be different than usual.

Andrew NDB
11-19-2026, 03:12 PM
It's too bad politics-into-comics only goes in one direction. With all of these gang wars it'd be a great chance to show Mamdani's (or you know, a Mamdani stand-in like they'll always do a Trump stand-in) new civilian-led de-escalation units that replaced all those police in New York and show how they contend with all of that going on.

Then when it falls apart it could all lead into like a Magnum Force-like unit being formed, like in Dirty Harry.

frank_one
11-19-2026, 03:44 PM
There's a variant cover by Mark Bagley! And he gave 'em nostrils :(

Andrew NDB
11-19-2026, 04:11 PM
There's a variant cover by Mark Bagley! And he gave 'em nostrils :(

I have a friend who, for some reason, he's very mild-mannered and generally timid in most situations... but if you say the name "Mark Bagley" he gets raging mad. As if you just whispered the right code words into the Winter Soldier's ear or something.

Just hates the man with a passion. I have no idea why. His art isn't that bad. I think he did the art for all 52 issues of 52, or was it Brightest Day? One of those 52 issue weekly series DC did for 2 or 3 years and then stopped.

IMJ
11-19-2026, 04:25 PM
I have a friend who, for some reason, he's very mild-mannered and generally timid in most situations... but if you say the name "Mark Bagley" he gets raging mad. As if you just whispered the right code words into the Winter Soldier's ear or something.

Just hates the man with a passion. I have no idea why. His art isn't that bad. I think he did the art for all 52 issues of 52, or was it Brightest Day? One of those 52 issue weekly series DC did for 2 or 3 years and then stopped.

It's probably because he's a f'n @$$hole in real life. I've also had some experiences with "THE Mark Bagley" at conventions. I love his art and have since his New Warriors and ASM days but as a person? Absolutely prickly.

And that book you are talking about was I think the long Trinity mini-series.

frank_one
11-19-2026, 04:37 PM
I love his Spider-Man of the early 90s, even if his anatomy was weird sometimes.

IMJ
11-19-2026, 05:05 PM
I love his Spider-Man of the early 90s, even if his anatomy was weird sometimes.

Right? His art is very "bronze-era" fun in the best of ways. A really great combination of cartoony-realism and his figures are compelling if not incredibly varied.

TheLabRat
11-20-2026, 01:39 AM
Art style looks good, sort of reminds me of the animated Batman/TMNT movie. I suppose this "gang war" he keeps talking about must include Shredder/Dog Star Gang vs Karai/Foot, or the EPF in general if Shredder loses his command and they take it back from him.

But IDW has had so many gang wars over and over it's hard to imagine how it'll be different than usual.

The simplest way is to make conflict gradually spirals out of control, eventually leading to the deaths of many innocent people.

ZariusTwo
11-20-2026, 01:46 AM
It's probably because he's a f'n @$$hole in real life. I've also had some experiences with "THE Mark Bagley" at conventions. I love his art and have since his New Warriors and ASM days but as a person? Absolutely prickly.

I remember hearing Bagley drew a few pictures of the 2000s era Ultimate Universe version of Mary Jane in revealing swimwear...bear in mind Ultimate MJ was a high school student in that comic and not college age.

Andrew NDB
11-20-2026, 01:47 AM
I just read an article that basically surmises that a lot of people (and this appears to be a known phenomenon, which is interesting to me) were pissed when he immediately followed Erik Larsen on art duties on I think Spider-Man. The point being that both of their art styles are pretty similar, but Bagley's natural style emerges like a "Poor Man's Erik Larsen" so whether that equated to fans thinking -- mistakenly -- he was poorly imitating Larsen's style, that sort of sank in then. That and that he "works fast" and "rushes everything."

ToTheNines
11-20-2026, 06:45 AM
It's too bad politics-into-comics only goes in one direction. With all of these gang wars it'd be a great chance to show Mamdani's (or you know, a Mamdani stand-in like they'll always do a Trump stand-in) new civilian-led de-escalation units that replaced all those police in New York and show how they contend with all of that going on.

Then when it falls apart it could all lead into like a Magnum Force-like unit being formed, like in Dirty Harry.

Baxter Stockman is clearly Eric Adams. So Zohran is coming next election.

Andrew NDB
11-20-2026, 07:12 AM
Baxter Stockman is clearly Eric Adams. So Zohran is coming next election.

Not in any comics. Wrong aisle.

frank_one
11-20-2026, 08:12 AM
I remember hearing Bagley drew a few pictures of the 2000s era Ultimate Universe version of Mary Jane in revealing swimwear...bear in mind Ultimate MJ was a high school student in that comic and not college age.I see no problem, it's just a drawing. Have you ever read a manga? Hell must be full of japanese artists then :D