View Full Version : IDW Vol. 2 #23 preview/discussion
ToTheNines
10-12-2026, 03:36 PM
https://comicsbodega.com/preview-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-23/
Out Wednesday.
TheLabRat
10-14-2026, 05:34 AM
Oh, please... don't tell me that Karai will regret her actions in the next issue and decide to help the turtles.
https://img.ifunny.co/images/89413fb19ba7bc0525386019e76397d8e6ec577a47c959f247 a64de1a98c6473_1.jpg
By the way, if I remember correctly, in The Untold Destiny of the Foot Clan comic, wasn't it Toshiro's ghost who gave her the information about the dragons and magic power?
Dancefloran
10-14-2026, 05:41 AM
By the way, if I remember correctly, in The Untold Destiny of the Foot Clan comic, wasn't it Toshiro's ghost who gave her the information about the dragons and magic power?
Wait something's wrong !
Toshiro's soul should have been erased in Untold Destiny of the Foot Clan, so there are only two explanations :
1. Plot hole
2. Karai wasn't talking to Toshiro's soul back then, she has been tricked by the Dragon from the very beginning
neatoman
10-14-2026, 10:08 AM
You know, Baxter really could just streamline his process:
tLzoveu2Wyc
TylerD
10-14-2026, 10:26 AM
Oh, please... don't tell me that Karai will regret her actions in the next issue and decide to help the turtles.
https://img.ifunny.co/images/89413fb19ba7bc0525386019e76397d8e6ec577a47c959f247 a64de1a98c6473_1.jpg
By the way, if I remember correctly, in The Untold Destiny of the Foot Clan comic, wasn't it Toshiro's ghost who gave her the information about the dragons and magic power?
I’m expecting that at some point. Will read the issue today, but at some point I’m expecting f Karai to realize she messed up, and eventually help the turtles. Seems a bit predictable but
Fenryr
10-14-2026, 05:00 PM
If they use the kusarigama that Lady Izanami gave to Tang Shen to kill General Eight Thunders, I'm quitting TMNT.
Also, Shinigami's whole deal is stupid. If we're just gonna make up nonsense without any attempt to explain any of it even remotely, let me write a comic about how cool Sisyphus from Tournament Fighters is.
CyberCubed
10-14-2026, 05:42 PM
Next issue is the last of this arc, I wonder how the chinese writer can wrap it up and make it satisfying. At this point I'm confused what villains will stay dead and which won't. Like will Hun die again or will they keep him around? Seems kind of repetitive.
TheLabRat
10-14-2026, 06:38 PM
Next issue is the last of this arc, I wonder how the chinese writer can wrap it up and make it satisfying. At this point I'm confused what villains will stay dead and which won't. Like will Hun die again or will they keep him around? Seems kind of repetitive.
https://aiptcomics.com/2026/09/08/tmnt-tuesday-73-gene-luen-yang/
Yang did said he bring a Chinese mythological figure into #24. I wouldn't be surprised if he brought Chi You back.
Or maybe it's Monkey King? In the Journey to the West, he crosses out both his name and the names of all the monkeys in his tribe from the Yama King's book, which free them from death.
Dancefloran
10-16-2026, 06:38 AM
Next issue is the last of this arc, I wonder how the chinese writer can wrap it up and make it satisfying. At this point I'm confused what villains will stay dead and which won't. Like will Hun die again or will they keep him around? Seems kind of repetitive.
I have the same fear ! I am not certain Shredder's crossover issue will be enough
ToTheNines
10-16-2026, 08:54 AM
Wait something's wrong !
Toshiro's soul should have been erased in Untold Destiny of the Foot Clan, so there are only two explanations :
1. Plot hole
2. Karai wasn't talking to Toshiro's soul back then, she has been tricked by the Dragon from the very beginning
Business as usual. The current volume wants to reap the benefits of pulling from 12+ years of continuity without actually adhering to the details.
ToTheNines
10-18-2026, 12:08 AM
I didn't really have much to say after reading this one. I'm just ready to wrap this arc up.
This video pointed out a few problems I hadn't considered (Karai's undead Foot don't seem to be afflicted by "the hunger") and one that I talk about all the time (Splinter is offering ZERO insight into the situation and we still don't really understand the circumstances he returned under. How involved as Karai?)
LiHZITtVOik?si=AcM68GvuCT9W5LmO
TheLabRat
10-19-2026, 06:22 AM
According to this (https://chinese.stackexchange.com/questions/30517/what-is-the-difference-between-%E9%AD%82-and-%E9%AD%84), once these ghosts come to the land of the living, they need to absorb the yang (life force) from living people to sustain themselves. There are many similar examples in Hong Kong horror movies. As for why Shredder, Splinter, and Tang Shen were unaffected, maybe their situation is special or it is just a plot device. I guess Yang would simply ignore this plot hole.
GameCobra
10-19-2026, 07:08 AM
I'm pretty sure it's because they came back from the afterlife already, isn't it?
ToTheNines
10-20-2026, 04:38 AM
Splinter killed plenty of people as Ujigami. Shredder came back under entirely different circumstances. Shen might be a plot hole though.
Dancefloran
10-20-2026, 06:11 AM
Splinter killed plenty of people as Ujigami. Shredder came back under entirely different circumstances. Shen might be a plot hole though.
I have to disagree on this one.
Splinter, Hamato Yoshi, Tang Shen and Cassandra Jones (1st resurrection) who used the Ujigami magic portal didn't have green eyes and the hunger thing.
It only happens when people are resurrected with Stockman's version of the portal.
There is a logic, even if we can find it weird for other reasons
CyberCubed
10-20-2026, 06:49 AM
Also at least they showed that with examples like Casey's mother trying to strangle April, or that other mutant killing an innocent man and then regretting it when he came back to life...is that all these spirits aren't quite "themselves." It allows the dead to act out of character due to the hunger they're feeling to restore to life.
TheLabRat
10-20-2026, 07:12 AM
At least after this event, Splinter and Tang Shen had no reason to stay, but in fact, they stayed until christmas. It was unclear whether they would return to the underworld after christmas.
Daytona
10-21-2026, 04:40 AM
Curious about the sales on this run. Book has disappeared from my periphery and they seemed to pick a new team for the book pretty quickly. Tried a couple issues and it didn’t work for me but I have some optimism for Rosenberg’s upcoming run.
TheLabRat
10-21-2026, 05:46 AM
https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/20/tmnt-tuesday-79-26/
Okay, so it seems Splinter is still in #26, and he's been kidnapped.... again.
TylerD
10-22-2026, 09:15 AM
https://aiptcomics.com/2026/10/20/tmnt-tuesday-79-26/
Okay, so it seems Splinter is still in #26, and he's been kidnapped.... again.
Seems to be the way with splinter in this run. Not sure what the end game is with splinter. It’s nice to have him back, but I have a feeling he won’t stick around. Bringing him and Shen back for a short run with the turtles is a nice twist, similar to how vol 2 brought back Barry Allen in the flash (thought it was Thawne and only for 4 issues) I actually thought they would kill splinter off by now, but maybe they are planning on him sticking around for a while
Kidnapping makes sense. Keeps him in the story, but he’s not the main focus. Turtles go looking for him for the next million issues leading to a showdown and eventually bringing him back. I’m not overly feeling this “afterlife” story. It’s cool they brought back Tang Shen, but overall every issue just ends with some previous characters there coming back from the afterlife. Gets redundant after a while
Fenryr
10-22-2026, 01:53 PM
They should be the ones to take over caring for the Tree of Fates. Keeps them available for future stories, makes them reaching out through the veil when they inevitably will into a big deal again, but they're not active in the day to day and the brothers can move on knowing their parents are reunited and proud and waiting, etc, etc.
ToTheNines
10-22-2026, 02:39 PM
They should be the ones to take over caring for the Tree of Fates. Keeps them available for future stories, makes them reaching out through the veil when they inevitably will into a big deal again, but they're not active in the day to day and the brothers can move on knowing their parents are reunited and proud and waiting, etc, etc.
That is 100 percent what I expected to happen. I guess Yang thought that would be too predictable? Sometimes the obvious outcome in a story is the best choice…
TylerD
10-22-2026, 04:41 PM
They should be the ones to take over caring for the Tree of Fates. Keeps them available for future stories, makes them reaching out through the veil when they inevitably will into a big deal again, but they're not active in the day to day and the brothers can move on knowing their parents are reunited and proud and waiting, etc, etc.
That would be sweet actually. Whether it’s predictable or not that’s a solid way to end the arc and go on to the next
TheLabRat
10-22-2026, 06:48 PM
Or perhaps they could enter the next cycle of reincarnation, so that at least one day in the future they would have the opportunity to meet their children in some way.
Heyowakka
10-29-2026, 05:38 AM
The lack of Vernon Fenwick returning from the dead leaves us with only one real solid conclusion; Vernon Fenwick, Ace Reporter, never actually lost his life during the Triceraton invasion and must be keeping a low profile until the world is in need of his bravery and charisma once again.
Stu_Padasso
10-29-2026, 04:00 PM
The lack of Vernon Fenwick returning from the dead leaves us with only one real solid conclusion; Vernon Fenwick, Ace Reporter, never actually lost his life during the Triceraton invasion and must be keeping a low profile until the world is in need of his bravery and charisma once again.
Probably been laying in traction in a hospital all this time. That’s how I see it.
TheLabRat
10-29-2026, 05:42 PM
That is 100 percent what I expected to happen. I guess Yang thought that would be too predictable? Sometimes the obvious outcome in a story is the best choice…
Or let Death take only Tang Shen's soul and the turtles, Splinter's Hamato QNA, allowing the Hamato family to reunite in a way.
As for the turtles and Splinter now, although they still have these memories, at least each of them would have the opportunity to choose to let it go and think about a new life.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.