View Full Version : What would you have prefered Shredder to be.
Jarrah White
02-15-2004, 05:28 PM
While I haven't seen it myself, Secret Origins has lead to alot of contraversy. I personally dislike the idea of Shredder turning out to be a Utrom, for obvious reasons.
Splinter
02-15-2004, 05:31 PM
Yay. Another Shredder thread. *THUDS*
Jarrah White
02-15-2004, 05:33 PM
Yay. Another Shredder thread. *THUDS*
:roll:
*sigh* Jarrah, we warned you about making new threads on topics already being discussed. But I'm letting this one go because we haven't had one quite like this.
I would have preferred he be a demon.
Aztec General
02-15-2004, 06:03 PM
I love how all of your threads start with: "I haven't read it but...." or "I haven't seen it but..." or "I don't know anything about it but....".
Maybe you should post about some things that you have experienced :wink: .
To make this not a completely off topic post: I would have preferred him being some kind of demon/Tengu.
Stefano
02-15-2004, 07:44 PM
yeah demon or tengu definatly. the utrom thing takes so much away from him
Taloniss
02-15-2004, 08:10 PM
Yay. Another Shredder thread. *THUDS*
No kidding, what's this, like, the 8th Shredder thread? Can we make "The one and only Shredder isn't a human" thread and combine all of them or something?
Halfshell
02-15-2004, 08:22 PM
Just make a sticky labelled "Shredder Theories" in General TMNT Discussion. That way if anyone has a theroy, ideal, or comment on Shredder, they can put it in there.
Coola Yagami
02-15-2004, 09:24 PM
Naw the Shredder kicks ass and deserves as many topics as he can get. At least it's not someone as crappy as Lord Dregg.
jeff the cheff
02-15-2004, 09:35 PM
I definatly wouldn't want him to be a demon or tengu, so now that I think of it I voted for utrom. It isn't that bad that he is an utrom, he is still a ninja warrior, just an alien one.
Maybe you should have put "human" as a choice in that poll.
Jarrah White
02-15-2004, 09:40 PM
I definatly wouldn't want him to be a demon or tengu, so now that I think of it I voted for utrom. It isn't that bad that he is an utrom, he is still a ninja warrior, just an alien one.
Maybe you should have put "human" as a choice in that poll.
What do you think I put 'Other' in the poll for?
Stefano
02-15-2004, 10:02 PM
I definatly wouldn't want him to be a demon or tengu, so now that I think of it I voted for utrom. It isn't that bad that he is an utrom, he is still a ninja warrior, just an alien one.
Maybe you should have put "human" as a choice in that poll.
hes not a ninja. He can conrtol the robot suit to do ninja things
ZariusTwo
02-15-2004, 10:17 PM
Anyone up for a "Which Shredder topic will Jarrah White put up next before he finally shuts the hell up?" Thread?
I like the Utrom idea, it's original, and establishes the cartoon with it's own continunity whilst also pleasing some MIRAGE fans
VaughnMichael
02-15-2004, 10:45 PM
Anyone up for a "Which Shredder topic will Jarrah White put up next before he finally shuts the hell up?" Thread?
I like the Utrom idea, it's original, and establishes the cartoon with it's own continunity whilst also pleasing some MIRAGE fans
yea I am...I'm actully getting sick of people talking about shredder this and shredder that....*rolles eyes at this entire thread* :roll:
-Vaughn Michael
J Legault
02-15-2004, 11:40 PM
I agree, I don't care that Shredder isn't human. The whole utrom idea is one of the ways to keep the Shredder coming back.
Even I'm starting to like the Red Utrom being the true form of Shredder.
I said this a few times. He may not be the shredder from the original cartoon or comics,but he's still the Shredder.
If Laird wanted Shredder be be an Utrom for a change then that's fine.
GK Punk
02-16-2004, 12:12 AM
Just make a sticky labelled "Shredder Theories" in General TMNT Discussion. That way if anyone has a theroy, ideal, or comment on Shredder, they can put it in there.
I had that idea once, but it got shot down.
Halfshell
02-16-2004, 12:34 AM
The only thing i see is Jarrah using the same "topic" is spamming.
Coola Yagami
02-16-2004, 08:11 AM
Maybe he shoulda been a demon/tengu. Thing is, at least as a demon/tengu, it's still a thing fighting with awesome ninja skills of his own behalf. This Ultrom Shredder isn't a good fighter at all. He's just a brain in a ninja robot suit. I mean... just get him out of that suit and stab the lil bugger and no more Shredder.
Sakirules
02-16-2004, 09:53 AM
Shredder is better off as human or better yet an ancient Japanese Feudal Lord whi is immortal. Being a Utrom simply ruins his image. And its despicable.
Savanti Romero
02-16-2004, 10:43 AM
Human. Original Mirage.
Jarrah White
02-16-2004, 12:54 PM
Shredder is better off as human or better yet an ancient Japanese Feudal Lord whi is immortal. Being a Utrom simply ruins his image. And its despicable.
You took the words out of my mouth.
Halfshell
02-16-2004, 01:17 PM
OFF TOPIC: Please dont start that Meat Loaf Song "You Took the Words Right Outta My Mouth"
ON TOPIC: I like Shredder in is human form
Shreddette
02-16-2004, 02:20 PM
I chose "other" because I prefer him being human.
An ancient human mystic ninja could be cool too... with or without "ancient" in the title. He's always reminded me more of a samurai/ronin...
I like these Shredder threads :D
ZariusTwo
02-16-2004, 03:39 PM
Being a Utrom simply ruins his image. And its despicable.
Noone told me Daffy Duck was a member here
Buslady
02-16-2004, 05:20 PM
:roll: :roll: :sick: boring.........
tmntpower2003
02-16-2004, 05:41 PM
samauri utrom b/c it follows the new line better and it just makes the story flow really well. That doesn't change that he is a bad ass ninja, he operates a mechanical body as if it was his own.
J Legault
02-16-2004, 08:42 PM
Maybe the City at War and Rougue in the House might make some of you change your mind about the Shredder idea.
Just give it some time and things will look better in the future.
we have alot of comeback episodes and fillers until the City at War will come.
Sakirules
02-16-2004, 08:50 PM
Noone told me Daffy Duck was a member here
Don't ever mock me!! :evilgrin: .
Sakirules
02-16-2004, 08:51 PM
Maybe the City at War and Rougue in the House might make some of you change your mind about the Shredder idea.
Just give it some time and things will look better in the future.
I doubt it. But it won't stop me from watching the show.
tmntpower2003
02-17-2004, 05:31 AM
its crazy to think how far the show has come along, a year ago i couldn't wait for the first episode where we could see the shredder fight, now Im waiting for city at war :o
GK Punk
02-17-2004, 06:25 AM
I would have prefered him to be a Clow Card.
milweskee
02-17-2004, 06:47 AM
A demon would be my preference. There's so much you can do with that. It makes him way more powerful and gives you a lot to work with for the future. It's just disappointing to see him as an Utrom.
Remember in Secret Origins Ep. 3, when they revealed him as an Utrom? Shredder flies out of the body and attacks Raph's head. Then he gets helplessly tossed across the room. It's like, this is the archenemy they couldn't destroy time and time again. It's a puny blob for God's sake! All this time and all they needed was a steel toe work boot.
heretic888
02-17-2004, 10:43 AM
samauri utrom b/c it follows the new line better and it just makes the story flow really well. That doesn't change that he is a bad ass ninja, he operates a mechanical body as if it was his own.
Actually, it does the exact opposite of everything you have just claimed.
This was a very, very lame plot device on the part of the writers. I personally would have liked a sort of indirect homage to the old cartoon and have the Utrom prisoner "team up" with Oroku Saki's descendent in exchange for technology (of course, Saki would probably end up offing him :evilgrin: ).
In my opinion, that would have been a much better idea.
Shreddette
02-17-2004, 09:10 PM
I would have prefered him to be a Clow Card.
LMFAO!!
J Legault
02-17-2004, 11:02 PM
Even if the series does have an evil brain creature. Atleast it's original for some of the old fans. The Red Utrom is still dangerous even without his exosuit.
Few of you hate the idea but alot of you like it. Many people have different ways in creating their own Shredder charater. Atleast I'm glad Shredder is going to be in the show for a long time. :wink:
GK Punk
02-18-2004, 01:17 AM
I would have prefered him to be a Clow Card.
LMFAO!!
heh, I'm glad to see someone got that :lol:
Halfshell
02-18-2004, 01:28 AM
Card Capturers (cant think od the spell att the moment)
GK Punk
02-18-2004, 02:01 AM
Cardcaptor Sakura.
(we don't acknowledge the Kids WB version)
Jarrah White
02-18-2004, 03:04 PM
GRRRR, Cardcaptures is what they replaced TMNT with, :tevil: :tevil: :tevil: They should die!
GK Punk
02-18-2004, 11:06 PM
Cardcaptors is only like I 'unno, 50 episodes or less I think.
I know they cut a whole bunch from the Japanese series, so It's not very long. (Hell they, even cut out like the first 7 episodes)
heretic888
02-19-2004, 10:29 AM
I remember Cardcaptors. I quite enjoyed the series. :P
Even if the series does have an evil brain creature. Atleast it's original for some of the old fans.
Actually, I thought it was cliched and predictable. I'm not going to hide the fact that I'm beginning to like this series less and less (most of which having to do with misportrayals of Mirage mythos).
The Red Utrom is still dangerous even without his exosuit.
Uhhh... right. Maybe to other Utroms.
Few of you hate the idea but alot of you like it.
Actually, as far as I can tell, most everyone I've discussed this with (both online and offline) thinks it was a horridly contrived and stupid idea.
Laterz.
Jarrah White
02-19-2004, 12:43 PM
Exactly, look at the pole: While thirteen people think the idea of a Utrom samurai is cool, eighteen think otherwise.
J Legault
02-19-2004, 05:31 PM
I remember Cardcaptors. I quite enjoyed the series. :P
Even if the series does have an evil brain creature. Atleast it's original for some of the old fans.
Actually, I thought it was cliched and predictable. I'm not going to hide the fact that I'm beginning to like this series less and less (most of which having to do with misportrayals of Mirage mythos).
The Red Utrom is still dangerous even without his exosuit.
Uhhh... right. Maybe to other Utroms.
Few of you hate the idea but alot of you like it.
Actually, as far as I can tell, most everyone I've discussed this with (both online and offline) thinks it was a horridly contrived and stupid idea.
Laterz.
Now I don't know how to put all this in a better way.
If Shredder was human he would be dead by now and there wouldn't be any villian to chase the TMNT all the time.
If Laird is fine with the Red Utrom idea, then there couldn't be anything wrong.
Now if there were some other "big" changes on the Turtles or Splinter then that would be horrible.
But just know that this whole thing is just "Different origin but same villian" Shredder their using on the show.
If you still hate Red utrom then just write to Laird and he might answer your complaint.
ZariusTwo
02-19-2004, 06:55 PM
Laird would simply shrug it off, he did this deliberatly knowing it would produce this kind of reaction.
This is HIS baby and he can do whatever the hell he wants with it.
J Legault
02-19-2004, 07:47 PM
Well atleast he has better control of TMNT than he did years ago.
Tetsu Deinonychus
02-21-2004, 02:33 AM
Cardcaptor Sakura.
(we don't acknowledge the Kids WB version)CLAMP RULES! :D
Skeletoncrew
02-21-2004, 03:24 AM
All I know is that I'd like to see all of the Shredders from all of the different universes meet. I'm sure it would turn into a giant battle royale, the likes of which have never been seen before. :o I'd put put my money on old cartoon Shredder, cause he'd turn tail and run, thus not getting blown up by Mirage Shredder or Utrom Shredder. Winner by default.
Jarrah White
02-21-2004, 03:44 AM
For a man who says he wants the new series to remain true to the Mirage comics, the contents of Secret Origins prove Laird to be the exact opposite.
Tetsu Deinonychus
02-21-2004, 04:10 AM
Well, true in mood, not form, I guess.
For the record there have been and will be many Mirage stories adapted there. But he must of been out taking a whiz or something when they ran that idea by him.
Still, as bad an idea as it was. They pulled it off quite well. And really, isn't TMNT itself just a stupid idea that was brilliantly executed.
J Legault
02-21-2004, 05:27 PM
Atleast there isn't any changes for the Turtles or Splinter as well.
And the series is now one of the most watched shows of today. So everything is fine for now.
Mandi-chan
02-23-2004, 07:37 PM
Wow, please don't throw tomatoes at me but...I kinda liked the evil little goober being the Shredder, I've got no clue what they'll do now with it but I thought it was an interesting twist for all the fans. It sure shocked me, and I will admit that I was a bit annoyed at first but after a while to think about it I grew to like the idea ( I feel the same way about the theme song! :P ) But I also wanted him to be human too.
The thing is, I like the fact that with every version of this awsome story there's differences with the villians and such (the only thing I didn't like was Yoshi being Splinter in the old toon), I mean...in the comics Shredder kept getting cloned whenever he got killed(or something like that), the movies he was a very evil non-cloned human who became a mutant in the 2nd movie(right?), and in this show he's an evil little goober! :P
I like it and I still love the show!
Mulsis
02-24-2004, 12:05 AM
I thought of an idea they could do and was gonna make a topic about it a bit ago. With this reaction, I'm glad I didn't. :)
I don't like red brained shredder.
I thought of something like this. The Utroms are being pursued in space by a war-like race (maybe Triceritons) and have to crash land on Earth. They still have to wait for the technology to develop.
In fairly recent Japan, the Utroms make their first attempt at returning home, but something goes horribly wrong and Oroku Nagi (leader of the Japanese branch of the foot clan) is killed in the process. They let Yoshi "die" so they could easily let Nagi die.
Enraging the clan, the Utroms flee to NY and enlist the help of the guardians. Saki starts a NY branch of the foot clan to avenge his brother.
Some major reworking would be required, but I think I would have perfered that.
Jarrah White
02-24-2004, 12:25 AM
I thought of something like this. The Utroms are being pursued in space by a war-like race (maybe Triceritons) and have to crash land on Earth. They still have to wait for the technology to develop.
In fairly recent Japan, the Utroms make their first attempt at returning home, but something goes horribly wrong and Oroku Nagi (leader of the Japanese branch of the foot clan) is killed in the process. They let Yoshi "die" so they could easily let Nagi die.
Enraging the clan, the Utroms flee to NY and enlist the help of the guardians. Saki starts a NY branch of the foot clan to avenge his brother.
Some major reworking would be required, but I think I would have perfered that.
That's brillent.
Jester
02-27-2004, 04:28 PM
not terible....like the line of shredders....expand it....not just his brother....this shredder is a warior who's eith an ancester of nagi...or nagi's brother made imortal by some spell....or maybe to combine some ideas demonic possesion...that would be cool...The utrom crash killes ninja leader nagi kinda wicked witvh of the east style and the japanese hail the utroms as heros...have nagi be a villianus dictator who rules with an iron fist....anyway hence sword of tengu....a sword made for the first guardian...who must protect the utroms...bodyless mind u....from saki...or some nagi ancester...depending on the view u use...have them be Yoshi's ancsetors....kinda painting a reason saki/ansestor would kill yoshi. kinda like the gargoyles....man everything comes back to this with me doesn't it....where the hunter mask was passed from generation to generation to chace and kill demona...just an extencion of ur utrom/shredder link....make them enemies of old cause he killed his brother/ancestor
lhb412
02-27-2004, 09:05 PM
Well, I had a problem with it at first, but the idea was brilliantly executed in one the shows coolest eppisodes so now I'm kinda with it. It does brilliantly connect everything, in fact if you go back you relise all these clues that were out there.
The fact that Yoshi was a Gaurdian also helps alot. When the show began I was kinda mad; no Teng Shin- I though that they were just taking out all the real intrsting emotional stuff of the origin and making it bland, but instead they create a deferent intresting story that still stays true to the charcters. Yoshi was a honorable warrior who died defending good and something tells me his, "He who lives without honor, dies with no honor", line will come to fruition near the end, if not at the ned, of this show (which is hopefully a long while away)
Rainbow Daze
02-28-2004, 12:50 PM
I voted for Utrom, but then I remembered what I really think. :lol:
I wish that Oroku Sagi would have been a guardian like Yoshi. I kind of thought that the Utroms had technology to lenghten the life span of their guardians. So, both Oroku Sagi and master Yoshi would have been centuries old. Maybe foot was originally the human ninja clan that Utroms used to protect them and then Sagi siezed its control. :)
RD
The Big Bad
03-05-2004, 06:08 AM
I would have preffered he be a human, who had managed to obtain inmortality and unkillability.
I have several problems with the Utrom. First of all is the fact that, as it stands now, every Utrom can potentially gain the Shredder's skill. Hell, BAXTER could probably become a new Shredder. Unless it is later established that the things the Shredder can do shouldn't be possible, then he is worthless. Second problem is his involvement with Baxter Stockman whom he hates. Utrom-Boy is supposedly a genius, and an expert with Utrom technology. If so, why use Stockman when he could probably do most of the stuff himself? Unless Baxter was a lot smarter than Utroms, (which honestly seems to be the case) it's a big contrivance.
That being said, I'd be okay with the idea if Utrom-Boy were killed in Secret Origins retired the Shredder identity, or ceased all affiliation with the Foot. Unfortunately, it seems that that is not the case.
All this and I LIKE the lil' Utrom! Just not as The Shredder.
Edit: Grammar is nice.
R-iZZy
03-05-2004, 12:42 PM
Man... I hated the idea of Shredder being an Utrom. UGH!!! It's like looking at Krang with a Bruce Lee crossover. I truly hated that idea, and I usually love anything that the writers did with the turtles. Ugh... an Utrom of all things to make Shredder.
Anyway, I said an ancient mystic ninja, just seems more like a deadly foe for someone.
J Legault
03-05-2004, 05:17 PM
How much more do we have to discuss about this?
Even if alot of people hated Red Evil Utroms mimicing a Ninja assasian.
But it doesn't mean that the show is no longer good to watch cause of one "little change". Villians aren't judged by their true identies. It's the charater and comic mischeif that counts.
Ofcourse sometimes there can be a little twist added to a series.
And be glad that none of the other charaters haven't been changed too much.
But don't be too sure that the Red Utrom is dead. Since you can tell that Shredder will be in the series for a while now.
Now if Laird is letting Shredder to be an Utrom then everything should be fine for him.
I said it once and will say it again He may be an utrom, but he's still The Shredder!
I don't know if some of you will still whatch the series. but I no long have any good reasons why the whole thing isn't that bad at all.
I'll just go to another topic. :(
Jarrah White
03-05-2004, 06:26 PM
I said it once and will say it again He may be an utrom, but he's still The Shredder!
But not The Shredder we know and love. NM Shredder may have been short-lived, but at least he was human.
J Legault
03-05-2004, 08:05 PM
And atleast he isn't dead. :wink:
Jarrah White
03-05-2004, 08:19 PM
Shredder turning out to be a Utrom ruins his image, his reputation, and contradics the magority of Season 1. Put yourself in Shredder shoes for a minute, your just a brain, a little brain living inside a android body. Loose your body and what are you? Nothing.
Shredder turning out to be a Utrom ruins his image, his reputation, and contradics the magority of Season 1.
It contradicts nothing in season one. In fact, Peter says in the new interview over at Ninja Turtles Network, that they had planned for Shredder to be an Utrom since the beginning of the show, and put in clues to point that way. Anything else was there to add an air of mystery and confusion around the character to keep us guessing. If we hadn't found that spoiler character sheet, it would have been a huge surprise to many. We were still very scattered about our guesses until that sheet showed up.
All truely "classic" stories are told, and retold with new twists every time. Survival depends on adaptation. It says a lot about the integrity of TMNT, that it can go through so many changes, so many "versions", and still keep it's audience.
J Legault
03-05-2004, 11:07 PM
Shredder turning out to be a Utrom ruins his image, his reputation, and contradics the magority of Season 1.
It contradicts nothing in season one. In fact, Peter says in the new interview over at Ninja Turtles Network, that they had planned for Shredder to be an Utrom since the beginning of the show, and put in clues to point that way. Anything else was there to add an air of mystery and confusion around the character to keep us guessing. If we hadn't found that spoiler character sheet, it would have been a huge surprise to many. We were still very scattered about our guesses until that sheet showed up.
All truely "classic" stories are told, and retold with new twists every time. Survival depends on adaptation. It says a lot about the integrity of TMNT, that it can go through so many changes, so many "versions", and still keep it's audience.
Now that was good point.
Jarrah White
03-05-2004, 11:24 PM
It still ruins his image, when ever I watch the new show it's hard to look at Shredder the same way.
Raven
03-06-2004, 10:25 AM
i liked him as a ultrom, but a demon would of been cool to.
Jo Dawn
03-06-2004, 10:26 AM
All truely "classic" stories are told, and retold with new twists every time. Survival depends on adaptation. It says a lot about the integrity of TMNT, that it can go through so many changes, so many "versions", and still keep it's audience.
I totally agree.
Mecha Cow
03-06-2004, 03:06 PM
Jarrah, have you even seen Secret Origins?
My apologies if you have but I get the impression you haven't.
I admit, I didn't like the idea of Shredder being an Utrom at first either, in fact, I hated it.
But after seeing Secret Origins, I must say I think they handled it really well, and I've learned to live with it, and even like it.
And saying it 'contradics' who Shredder is is BS, for this incarnation of Shredder anyway. Go watch season one again and you'll see what I mean.
Either way, like it or not, 2003 Shredder is an Utrom. Get over it.
cqb101
03-06-2004, 03:36 PM
Human that died the first time around.
tmntpower2003
03-07-2004, 02:08 AM
Shredder turning out to be a Utrom ruins his image, his reputation, and contradics the magority of Season 1.
It contradicts nothing in season one. In fact, Peter says in the new interview over at Ninja Turtles Network, that they had planned for Shredder to be an Utrom since the beginning of the show, and put in clues to point that way. Anything else was there to add an air of mystery and confusion around the character to keep us guessing. If we hadn't found that spoiler character sheet, it would have been a huge surprise to many. We were still very scattered about our guesses until that sheet showed up.
All truely "classic" stories are told, and retold with new twists every time. Survival depends on adaptation. It says a lot about the integrity of TMNT, that it can go through so many changes, so many "versions", and still keep it's audience.
Where do you see this on the site? cause I don't can you point me to it? Thanks
Jarrah White
03-07-2004, 02:00 PM
And saying it 'contradics' who Shredder is is BS, for this incarnation of Shredder anyway. Go watch season one again and you'll see what I mean.
Maybe you should watch Season 1 again,
Things Change: Shredder drinks, impossible if he is a robot.
The Shredder Strikes Part 1: Shredder litterally vanishes when he walks backwards into the shadow-- evidence suggesting he's a mystic ninja or something.
Shredder Strikes Back Part 2: Shredder again vanishes when he walks into the flames- more evidence suggesting a mystic ninja.
Return to New York Part 2: Shredder clones. We also see mystic ninja, this suggests Shredder is able to summon evil spirits.
And if it counts, the GBA game had Shredder split into four tini demons.
cqb101
03-07-2004, 02:19 PM
And saying it 'contradics' who Shredder is is BS, for this incarnation of Shredder anyway. Go watch season one again and you'll see what I mean.
Return to New York Part 2: Shredder clones. We also see mystic ninja, this suggests Shredder is able to summon evil spirits.
Wrong again, Jarrah. They never said they were clones. Don suggested they were clones. And you're basicaly saying that to be able to summon spirits you have to be an evil spirit? Why can't an utrom summon evil spirits?
Jarrah White
03-07-2004, 02:32 PM
It seems doubtful to me. You must have mystic powers to summon spirits.
cqb101
03-07-2004, 03:22 PM
It seems doubtful to me. You must have mystic powers to summon spirits.
So? Why can't an utrom have mystic powers? There's nothing saying one can't. And what if he had one of his underlings summoned them for him? What if they don't need to be summoned?
Taloniss
03-07-2004, 04:26 PM
Things Change: Shredder drinks, impossible if he is a robot
It's not impossible. The Utrom could have built a food/drink storage compartment so he could partake in important Japanese rituals, like Tea, so people would not suspect that he wasn't a human.
The Shredder Strikes Part 1: Shredder litterally vanishes when he walks backwards into the shadow-- evidence suggesting he's a mystic ninja or something.
Shredder Strikes Back Part 2: Shredder again vanishes when he walks into the flames- more evidence suggesting a mystic ninja.
Batman does the same thing, is he a mystic? It's just a cool thing to enhance the cool factor of the show/character.
Return to New York Part 2: Shredder clones. We also see mystic ninja, this suggests Shredder is able to summon evil spirits.
They never said they were clones. Don said they may be but there was never any evidence that they were. They could have been robots as well, or genetic experiments.
And if it counts, the GBA game had Shredder split into four tini
demons.
The game doesn't really count, and that was just taking liberties to make the fight better.
Mecha Cow
03-08-2004, 07:34 AM
Jarrah, not only are your arguments very weak, what you are trying to prove is besides the point.
You said that Shredder being an Utrom contradics who Shredder is and ruins his image. I said that was untrue, because it doesn't contradict anything, Shredder was an Utrom to begin with.
Like I said, go watch season one again, there are plenty of clues that suggest he might be an Utrom.
Yes, there are still some plotholes, but I'm sure they will be explained as the series progresses, perhaps 'Rogue in the House' will reveal some more info about the Shredder.
And since you haven't answered wether you have seen 'Secret Origins' or not, I'll assume you haven't, and tell you to hold your Shredder Utrom-bashing until you have actually seen how they handled it.
GhostPoet
03-08-2004, 02:27 PM
I er...actually liked the idea of Shredder being an Utom. *gasp!* I know..shocking...but the idea of him living thousands of years...and coming from another world...the only one of his kind to be evil and hateful..
Kinda interesting.....as much as I liked the other idea of him being a demon...it's been done sooo many times...it would be to predictable...
GhostPoet
03-08-2004, 02:30 PM
It seems doubtful to me. You must have mystic powers to summon spirits.
Like someone said before...humans/demon are not the only ones that can have mystic powers...
From what I gathered in Secret Orgins...it seems like that the Shredder took a liking to the way of the Ninja and the mystic arts...maybe the little utom decided to learn more and develop skills in them...after all...he learned material arts..why not the mystic arts as well?:)
Jarrah White
03-08-2004, 02:43 PM
Like I said, go watch season one again, there are plenty of clues that suggest he might be an Utrom.
Name one. I saw plenty of evidence to convince me Shredder was a mystic samurai or demon. And it destroys his image, it's difficult to look at Shredder the same way again.
(sigh) No wonder Laird and Eastman broke up.
Taloniss
03-08-2004, 03:10 PM
Name one.
1) In Darkness on the Edge of Town, Shredder dug up an "ancient artifact" that resembles a utrom exoskelton. The good Utroms are ahead of him in technology, and he wanted to use the suit to "catch up" to them.
2) In The Shredder Strikes Back, one of the Turtles mentions how "nothing human could have survived that" refering to being crushed by the water tower.
3) The Guardians make make numerous references to Saki being their ancient enemy, and they work for the Utroms.
And it destroys his image, it's difficult to look at Shredder the same way again.
Then don't look at him again.
No wonder Laird and Eastman broke up.
They broke up before the show started, did they not? So I doubt it was over this, and we don't know the *exact* reason they did either.
Jarrah White
03-08-2004, 03:24 PM
Name one.
1) In Darkness on the Edge of Town, Shredder dug up an "ancient artifact" that resembles a utrom exoskelton. The good Utroms are ahead of him in technology, and he wanted to use the suit to "catch up" to them. Why wouldn't he just use his own suit to gain technology?
2) In The Shredder Strikes Back, one of the Turtles mentions how "nothing human could have survived that" refering to being crushed by the water tower. It's figure of speech
3) The Guardians make make numerous references to Saki being their ancient enemy, and they work for the Utroms. So? Demons and mystic warriors live for hundreds of years too.
No wonder Laird and Eastman broke up.
They broke up before the show started, did they not? So I doubt it was over this, and we don't know the *exact* reason they did either.
Did Laird sit down with Eastman one day and say "Hey Kevin, here's a idea, why don't we make Shredder (A character fans have grown to know a man) turn out to be a Utrom?
Mecha Cow
03-08-2004, 03:55 PM
(sigh) No wonder Laird and Eastman broke up.
:roll:
Oh yes Jarrah, Eastman and Laird 'broke up'(They were a couple?) because Laird wanted to make Shredder an Utrom(even though his character is still the same, just his species is different.).
Actually, the Utrom thing is more like something Eastman would come up with, after all, he was responsible for *Shudder* the Next Mutation(In wich, might I add, Shredder was a pathetic wimp...No, that doesn't 'ruin his image' at all.).
And for the last time, how can Shredder being an Utrom 'ruin his image'?
What image? He's been an Utrom the entire series, it's not like his true identity being revealed suddendly changes personality. He's still the same as in episode one.
And like I said before, watch the damn episode before you critise it. :roll:
Taloniss
03-08-2004, 04:27 PM
Why wouldn't he just use his own suit to gain technology?
If you read the whole post, you'd note that I said he seems to be behind in the technology department (utroms have a transmat, and he doesn't seem to, flying pods, ect) so maybe he wanted to study their suit to try to gain something to give him an advantage in his fight.
It's figure of speech
It could also be forshadowing something.
So? Demons and mystic warriors live for hundreds of years too.
So do Utroms. So, it points to both, but it still a clue to him being an Utrom.
cqb101
03-08-2004, 05:39 PM
Jarrah, you just got
http://www.rit.edu/~acw7898/owned.jpg
Jarrah White
03-08-2004, 05:43 PM
(sigh) No wonder Laird and Eastman broke up.
:roll:
Oh yes Jarrah, Eastman and Laird 'broke up'(They were a couple?) because Laird wanted to make Shredder an Utrom(even though his character is still the same, just his species is different.).
Actually, the Utrom thing is more like something Eastman would come up with, after all, he was responsible for *Shudder* the Next Mutation(In wich, might I add, Shredder was a pathetic wimp...No, that doesn't 'ruin his image' at all.).
And for the last time, how can Shredder being an Utrom 'ruin his image'?
What image? He's been an Utrom the entire series, it's not like his true identity being revealed suddendly changes personality. He's still the same as in episode one.
And like I said before, watch the damn episode before you critise it. :roll:
At least The Next Mutation Shredder was human and fought in his true form. Shredder turning out to be a Utrom ruins his image, it makes him seem so small and too much like a pissant. As said before, take away his body and what is he? Nothing. In a fair fight, the Turtles would squish him like a little bug. As said above, it's difficult to look at Shredder the same way. If Laird wants a Utrom Samurai in the series, I suggest invent one and keep Shredder human, as he was in the comics.
This website will explain the way I look at Shredder http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/muses/353/shred.html
Taloniss
03-08-2004, 07:56 PM
it makes him seem so small
Small is having one of the largest personal armies in NY, while maintaining a strong hold on crime in NYC, whilst taking on all four Turtles? Damn, I wish I was small.
As said before, take away his body and what is he? Nothing. In a fair fight, the Turtles would squish him like a little bug
He seemed to be getting the best of Raph in Secret Origins without the body.
As said above, it's difficult to look at Shredder the same way
As said above, then don't watch it. If you don't like something, why torture yourself by watching it?
J Legault
03-08-2004, 08:29 PM
Yeah it's not like the TMNT are no long great anymore just because of one little change that's making all the "true human" supporters out there angry.
If you hate pour little Red Utrom then stop watching the show if it's poison for your mind.
I say, one little change in the main villian and it just makes some people want to argue and argue. :roll:
Atleast Shredder will only appear in a few episodes for Season 2. But I've said this like several times:
You don't judge villians by their true form, it's not the outside that counts it's the inside where the true evilness comes from.
Let's just say that human shredder works for the old comics and TV show.
And the Utrom works for the new show as well. 8)
I think this argument is pretty much over. Jarrah is allowed to not like the idea of Utrom Shredder, but all this bashing is getting ridiculous. None of your arguments are going to change things. It's not like Peter's gonna go "Oh no, someone's upset with Utrom Shredder, I better go back and change things." One, he can't, and two, he don't work that way.
TMNT, and Shredder, have changed a lot over the decades. Shredder originally was a criminal ninja master focusing on "protection" and such. Then he died and became a clone. I'd say that was a big change, and one could argue that he was no longer human then, but did it "ruin" him? No. He's been a truly I-wanna-take-over-the-world villain with a much different background, but was still Shredder. He's been a relatively small-time crime leader (Just New York vs. International), using teens instead of "real" ninjas to do his bidding. He's very "Shredder" there, too.
Hey, if we're gonna argue, I could say that movie Shredder isn't human either, because no human could have survived being crushed by a garbage truck like that.
Shredder has been many, many things, and none of them effect any of the others. No one's saying anyone has to like it, but the argument is now getting stupid. Wanting Shredder to be something else is one thing, but trying to argue against the facts? Might as well try using your head to punch a hole in a steel door. You'll be more productive then.
creativerealms82
03-09-2004, 05:18 PM
You know complaining about it won't change it. Sure Shredder is a Utrom now in the new series but hey at least the turtles history was not ruined by adding a fifth female turtle into the group. Shredder in the new show is still a bad ass sure he is no longer human but quite frankly in my mind that only makes him more intimadating not less. I would have rather had him be a demon myself but hey I can live with the Utrom.
Jarrah White
03-09-2004, 05:43 PM
at least the turtles history was not ruined by adding a fifth female turtle into the group.
:roll: I like the concept of a fifth turtle...
creativerealms82
03-09-2004, 06:21 PM
And I like the concept of the Utrom Shredder.
rayfillet101
03-09-2004, 06:47 PM
I like shredder Utrom. JW, You said u havent seen the second season yet so u havent seen the secret origions arc? You dont know how they handle it , you might be surprised. I think shredder is a adjective,.. or more so a spirit. Everyone can have shredder in them. Shredder is ultimate evil. Plain and simple.
cqb101
03-09-2004, 08:00 PM
at least the turtles history was not ruined by adding a fifth female turtle into the group.
:roll: I like the concept of a fifth turtle...
And people like the concept of an utrom shredder. Get over it.
IMO, Venus ruined the image of the turtles(for that universe) as much as you say Shredder being an Utrom ruins shredder. But, I'm not gonna get into this argument here. I would have preferred Shredder to be a human, but I'm not against shredder being an Utrom. It's a new twist, and I like it.
ZariusTwo
03-09-2004, 08:57 PM
Oh don't waste your time with Jarrah, he thinks Venus was the mother of Jesus F'ing Christ...
The bottom Line is this, there exists a Utrom Shredder, he's not going to go away, no amount of b*tching is going to change that, it's a divided opinion, but one that will not change what Laird has done.
Better to get over it, I like this new concept, it's a great idea, and it will keep the fans watching, and the show more original.
Jarrah White
03-09-2004, 09:06 PM
Oh don't waste your time with Jarrah, he thinks Venus was the mother of Jesus F'ing Christ...
Oh shut up Zarius, before I shut you up! You know what, I am so sick of you always attacking people who like the Next Mutation, and reducing yourself to slander and nasty comments. Do everybody on the forum a favor a grow up.
Forum Rule No. 2: Attacking or harassing other members on the forums is not allowed.
You know what, Zarius? If I catch you giving me, or anyone else a hard time about Next Mutation I will personally see to it that you are banned for attacking other members. Car'piece?
Stefano
03-09-2004, 09:17 PM
you know what i havnt had in a while
big league chew
J Legault
03-09-2004, 10:01 PM
For me I'll still watch the show, even if it has a red-utrom for a villian.
Since we do know from the very begginning that this will be a new generation for TMNT. So no one really said in the begginning that there's new changes for the main villian.
(man, even Karpo has better ways of using words to solve these problem :roll: )
You know what, Zarius? If I catch you giving me, or anyone else a hard time about Next Mutation I will personally see to it that you are banned for attacking other members. Car'piece?
And I could do the same thing to you, "Car'piece"?
Both of you better settle down before you both get another warning. In fact, I am reporting this latest arguement because verbal warnings ain't working anymore.
Have a nice day.
R-iZZy
03-09-2004, 11:20 PM
How much more do we have to discuss about this?
Even if alot of people hated Red Evil Utroms mimicing a Ninja assasian.
But it doesn't mean that the show is no longer good to watch cause of one "little change". Villians aren't judged by their true identies. It's the charater and comic mischeif that counts.
Ofcourse sometimes there can be a little twist added to a series.
And be glad that none of the other charaters haven't been changed too much.
But don't be too sure that the Red Utrom is dead. Since you can tell that Shredder will be in the series for a while now.
Now if Laird is letting Shredder to be an Utrom then everything should be fine for him.
I said it once and will say it again He may be an utrom, but he's still The Shredder!
I don't know if some of you will still whatch the series. but I no long have any good reasons why the whole thing isn't that bad at all.
I'll just go to another topic. :(
First of all, who said that I didn't like the show, period? I've been a turtle fan since who knows? These guys were around before my birth, and I've brushed up on their history. I've been patiently waiting for a new show for maybe 5 years. The last thing I want to do is trash something I've waited for.
I simply said I didn't like the idea of Shredder being an Utrom. Does that automatically mean that I never liked the show as a whole? No! I fell in love with the Notes From Underground series, the City At War, etc.; but just because I'm proud the turtles are back, doesn't mean I can't be honest and state whatever I feel is a bad idea (while I'm at it, I also hated NANO).
Yeah, I'm glad they twisted and tweaked a couple of things, it's nice to experiment. But that's the purpose of experimenting, to find out the mysteries of the results. Will old school fans like it or leave it? Will people understand it or arch an eyebrow in confusion? Results vary, my friend, and I happened to be part of the statistics that didn't like the end results.
I don't care anymore, what's done is done. It's pretty hard to make a change.
And no he is no longer "The Shredder". He's just Krang in a Shredder suit. This isn't the Oroku Saki that feuded with Hamato Yoshi over a women, and then moved to Splinter. We still see that Splinter and Shredder feud, but it's not quite the same.
But that doesn't mean I don't enjoy the show. I usually don't even waste money on recordable tapes. Ever since the new show came out, I found reason. I think that's a good sign in my interest of the show.
Jarrah White
03-09-2004, 11:32 PM
And no he is no longer "The Shredder". He's just Krang in a Shredder suit. This isn't the Oroku Saki that feuded with Hamato Yoshi over a women, and then moved to Splinter. We still see that Splinter and Shredder feud, but it's not quite the same.
I couldn't have said it better myself. That's what I mean destroying Shredder's image, difficult to look at the same way. Instead of remaining true to Mirage they've just made the characters of Krang and Shredder the same person. Only this time Krang himself is modelled on Darth Maul.
R-iZZy
03-09-2004, 11:54 PM
And no he is no longer "The Shredder". He's just Krang in a Shredder suit. This isn't the Oroku Saki that feuded with Hamato Yoshi over a women, and then moved to Splinter. We still see that Splinter and Shredder feud, but it's not quite the same.
I couldn't have said it better myself. That's what I mean destroying Shredder's image, difficult to look at the same way. Instead of remaining true to Mirage they've just made the characters of Krang and Shredder the same person. Only this time Krang himself is modelled on Darth Maul.
^ Exactly the point I was trying to come across, words were chosen well Jarrah. It's a shame, because Shredder was my all-time favorite villain (yes, I truly meant that). His background, his build-up, he had a lot of history. The new Shredder wasn't the Shredder I loved. As a matter of fact, his (or its) history isn't even as captivating anymore. There was a lot more tension between Splinter and Shredder back in the movies, the Mirage Comics, and even in the original cartoon series.
Now, it seems the history between Splinter and Shredder was just extremely toned down. Not even worth comparing to the past origins. I just can't see why they would have a Krang-a-like kill Hamato Yoshi rather than an actual human. It just backs up far beyond what we all grew up with. I agree with Kali when she commented that this was just the different versions of the story told, just to show how the audience can still be captivated. Unfortunately, I just found this version of the story very poorly put together. Not to say it wasn't well-planned, but the idea was just terrible.
ZariusTwo
03-10-2004, 01:38 PM
I think this says it better:
Laird does'nt give a crap what FANS want, this is what HE wants, this is Laird showing how much he "cares" for his ungratful fanbase who want a perfect world.
Shredder is Krang, sure he is, that is the ULTIMATE tribute to the original cartoon, even if he is'nt "really" Krang, it's a tribute/joke to show Laird will never forget what the original series had done for the franchise.
Despite not being true to the MIRAGE comics, this Shredder appeared more times than the MIRAGE Shredder, kicked a lot of Turtle ass, and was a great, very developed character.
So you see, every person blasting this "Shredder is Utrom" concept is one big freaking hypocrite, because they go on and one about this new Shredder being "Not like the Shredder I loved", some of those hypocrites mewntion the original cartoon Shredder, who was'nt even HALF the MIRAGE version, though he had an aura of menace around him.
Bottom Line: this version of Shredder is the most faifthful adaptation of the MIRAGE version, repsect it for that alone
Sakirules
03-10-2004, 03:52 PM
I think this says it better:
So you see, every person blasting this "Shredder is Utrom" concept is one big freaking hypocrite, because they go on and one about this new Shredder being "Not like the Shredder I loved", some of those hypocrites mewntion the original cartoon Shredder, who was'nt even HALF the MIRAGE version, though he had an aura of menace around him.
Bottom Line: this version of Shredder is the most faifthful adaptation of the MIRAGE version, repsect it for that alone
First of all watch who you call a hypocrite. If people don't like it then let it be. I don't like the idea of Shredder being an Utrom but does that mean I'm gonna let it stop me from watching the show ever again?!! NO!!! I enjoy TMNT wherever, whenever, whatever. Yes, Shredder was most evil in this new series. But once we discovered he was an Utrom it changes many things and most fans will never look at Shredder the same way again. We turtles fans can deal with it but that's much different from liking it.
Raven
03-10-2004, 04:56 PM
I think this says it better:
Laird does'nt give a crap what FANS want, this is what HE wants, this is Laird showing how much he "cares" for his ungratful fanbase who want a perfect world.
Shredder is Krang, sure he is, that is the ULTIMATE tribute to the original cartoon, even if he is'nt "really" Krang, it's a tribute/joke to show Laird will never forget what the original series had done for the franchise.
Despite not being true to the MIRAGE comics, this Shredder appeared more times than the MIRAGE Shredder, kicked a lot of Turtle ass, and was a great, very developed character.
So you see, every person blasting this "Shredder is Utrom" concept is one big freaking hypocrite, because they go on and one about this new Shredder being "Not like the Shredder I loved", some of those hypocrites mewntion the original cartoon Shredder, who was'nt even HALF the MIRAGE version, though he had an aura of menace around him.
Bottom Line: this version of Shredder is the most faifthful adaptation of the MIRAGE version, repsect it for that alone
i have to agree with you on that, people need to get over it, its a cartoon.
god were all going to die because shredder turned out to be a ultrom.
ZariusTwo
03-10-2004, 05:26 PM
LOL, blasted Russians...their weapon has been unvieled
These fans are saying The Shredder rocks at one point...then say he sucks because he's a freaking alien the next, he's the SAME FREAKING ASS-KICKER YOU'VE BEEN WATCHING, it does'nt make him look any less pathetic
You're a bunch of hypocrites, sad but true
Machias Banshee
03-10-2004, 06:28 PM
Guys, last warning. STOP the fighting.
Everyone's got their own opinions, but that doesnt mean you try to shove them down other people's throats. some will like it, some will hate it. Get over it.
host_punktmy
03-10-2004, 06:32 PM
I can't possibly complain about the cartoon in any way. If it weren't for the cartoon I would have never been a turtle fan. NINJA TURTLES! I'm sure Eastmen and Laird are grateful for the success that the show did for them and you know what it's not important what happened in the cartoon. It's just a cartoon, a very good one at that.
Jarrah White
03-10-2004, 06:35 PM
One might call you a hypocrit Zarius for liking ninja magic in the old toon/movies (Sword of Tengu, Myistic ninjas, time-travelling ceptors), yet hating a certain female Ninja Turtle with mystic powers.
On Topic, all previous versions of the Shredder were true fighters, the new version's only a pretender. He ain't no fighter, in his true form he doesn't even have fists. Sad really.
ZariusTwo
03-10-2004, 08:16 PM
One might call you a hypocrit Zarius for liking ninja magic in the old toon/movies (Sword of Tengu, Myistic ninjas, time-travelling ceptors), yet hating a certain female Ninja Turtle with mystic powers..
What did Machias Banshee JUST tell you?
Venus was a POORLY DEVELOPED Mystic Ninja, The Shredder was'nt
And a PRETENDER? His kicking the Ninja Turtles' asses in "The Shredder Strikes Back Part 2" was no joke.
Picking on The Shredder because of his size...stupid, absolutley stupid.
Oh wait, did'nt you make some crappy thread about saying Silver Sentry and Baxter were the same because they were both black?
I'm out of this thread before anything else happens, all it's proven to me is that those uncomfortable with The Shredder/Utrom scenario don't know a good Shredder from a screwdriver
J Legault
03-10-2004, 09:55 PM
OK OK so some of the people who hate the Red Utrom are still going to watch the show no matter what. That's fine with me, as long as your not stop watching the show because of one little change.
I sometimes get a little annoyed by people who make big deals with small mistakes or plotlines. Take for example i got annoyed with people keep complaining that the Mobs didn't had any guns in "Lone Raph and Cub"
For now I just don't know what to say to make a good point right now.
:-?
Jarrah White
03-10-2004, 11:40 PM
Venus was a POORLY DEVELOPED Mystic Ninja, The Shredder was'nt
Yeah, he was a poorly developed alien samurai, oh sure he kicked turtle butt, but only in his exosuit. Ha, I'd like to see him take on the turtles without it.
Yeah, he was a poorly developed alien samurai, oh sure he kicked turtle butt, but only in his exosuit. Ha, I'd like to see him take on the turtles without it.
Heh, he did. He almost suffocated Raph, and came within an inch of biting Leo's fingers off. Besides, it's not physical prowess that's important but the evil genius that truly defines the character,
Jarrah White
03-11-2004, 12:00 AM
He almost suffocated Raph, and came within an inch of biting Leo's fingers off.
Oh, please... :roll:
Machias Banshee
03-11-2004, 12:01 AM
Hey, he was doing what he could with his body type. Give him a break...
Jarrah White
03-11-2004, 12:13 AM
That's exactly my point, in his true form he's the very definition of the word weakling.
That's exactly my point, in his true form he's the very definition of the word weakling.
Not true. If you think that a small size makes one "weak", try again. The Red Utrom has a ferocity that rivals Raph's, and obviously Utroms aren't as fragile as we think they are. Brains over brawn, Jarrah, and I've officially lost my patience with you. You've completely ruined yet another discussion.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.