PDA

View Full Version : Secret Origins review by the Australians.


Jarrah White
06-27-2004, 01:03 AM
It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE (http://www.thetechnodrome.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8874). It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment. I will say it explains alittle, just alittle, like why Hamato Yoshi was targeted by The Shredder. But Alas, Yoshi just being a Guardian has stripped him of that heroism he had in the comics, defending the honour of the woman he loved from the hands of Oruko Nagi. Also, a few things are yet to be explained, mainly how did the Utroms get from Japan to America? What are these Shredder clones really? I remember Laird quoting on the DVD that 'In the second season we'll learn the secret origin of the sword of tengu, and it's a cool secret origin'. This is just me speeking my mind but I found the sword's origin quite dull actually, I was hoping the sword began as, I don't know, a weapon of peace created by the Utroms. A weapon used to bring justice in the universe, maybe used in a fight against the Tricerations, but only to fall into Shredder's evil hands and become a weapon of mass destruction. Instead, all we learn is it was created using metal from the Utrom crashsite, that's about it. Finally, it is time to talk about The Shredder himself, or should I say Krang dressed as The Shredder himself. I didn't find his origin interesting. The Mirage comics featured a small boy called Oruko Saki, overcome with grief from the loss of his older brother. The Foot Clan took him under their wing and trained him how to become a warrior. He rose in the ranks quickly and Saki, now called The Shredder, slaughtered the killer of his brother along with his wife. Like Yoshi, Shredder has been stripped of who the comics made him to be. And here they've just made Shredder another Krang, a deranged war criminal. He even has the same image, which I find (And this is my verdict from watching the episode) downright pathectic. Not only have they taken away what made Saki become The Shredder, they have taken away what made Shredder a warrior. He doesn't fight in his true form, he fights from the controls of an exo suit. Of sure he can do plenty of damage with this suit, but outside it he is a threat to no one (Except maybe other Utroms). It's alot like a tank driver, behind the wheel of this heavily armoured vehicle he can crush everything in his way. But outside this assault vehicle he's vulerable to lethal gun shot wounds, aircraft missiles, etc, etc. It's the same case with Shredder, in his true form he is at the mercy of creatures larger than he is. He isn't a warrior, he's just a little blob living inside a body, a body that he relies on to fight with. Loose his body and what is he? Exactly. And the concept of seeing this alien stick to Raphael's face took the biscuit, a classic example of his weakness. Not only do I find the idea of Shredder turning out to be a Utrom moronic, but I also find it highly unnessacary. There was nothing to convince us that Shredder was tied to the Utroms in Season 1, in fact the evidence presented in that season suggested the opposite; that Shredder was the least likely person to turn out to be an alien, when you look at everything that points against it, Shredder being able to drink, the appearence of his clones, the Guardians believing he died. The only thing that was concrete was the fact that he was the Utroms arch enemy. And for all we knew he could have been a man trying to rid the world of these aliens, aliens who were accidentally/deliberately responsible for the death of his brother. As for him getting up and picking up his head, would there not have been a possibility that his soul lived on through the armour? Laird told me two reasons why they made Shredder a Utrom was to tie him to the turtles' origin and so they could do the decapitation scene on Saturday morning TV. Sorry, but I am not convinced: The old toon perfectly tied Shredder to the turtles' origin, for it was he who dropped that ooze on them, and the old toon was able to keep him in the human race. And as for not being able to do the decapitation scene, I don't no about you Americans, but the Australian network shows graphic violence on the television all the time. Sometimes fictional, like cartoon violence, othertimes it's often reality violence, but most of the time it is potentually lethal. Just weeks ago I saw some poor fellow being brutally decapitated with a Machete. Why is it right to show reality beheadings but wrong to show cartoon beheadings? Finally, I see Shredder's red and black skin colour a poor excuse to colour Krang as Darth Maul. The new Shredder may have the superior armour, but the Mirage Shredder has the superior origin.

Sad to say, I have begun to like this series, the series that made me a turtle fan in the first place, less. Sad really. What next? What other Mirage characters are gonna be miss-used and miss-potrailed and stripped of what the comics what them? Is April O’Neil going to turn out to be a shape-shifting blob of slime that ‘resembles’ Lurch from the image comics? Maybe there are no mutant turtles, maybe each of them is an Utrom and we don’t know it. I know alot of you are fine with the idea of Shredder being an alien, I have no problem with you liking it. But as you can clearly see in my review, I don't like the idea. To me the idea of making Shredder’s character turning out to be a Utrom is a pathetic as say, the idea of changing James Bond’s gender to female. As such, I don't want to see the Red Utrom anywhere outside the new toon, much like Peter Laird not wanting to see Venus anywhere outside the Next Mutation series. I won’t go on, but here’s what I will say, if you want a Utrom samurai in a TV show based on a comic book, I strongly suggest invent one.


Just so I'm not being byassed, the Secret Origins episodes did have a few nice touches, like Krang's return and April's news reporters disguise. Spider Baxter rocks!

(Pants) Glad I got that off my chest, anyone else from downunder wanna contribute?

Spitfire
06-27-2004, 01:18 AM
Well I guess we cant ALL like every episode but dont say that. Have some faith for the new show I mean "deacapation on a kids show" Ill deal with Shrdder being a Uthrom to see that!

Jarrah White
06-27-2004, 01:48 AM
The Ultimate Ninja comes on tomorrow, hope it's better than Secret Origins...

Spitfire
06-27-2004, 02:00 AM
I dont get to see that until september :(

Coola Yagami
06-27-2004, 01:52 PM
the thing that gets me, is how can the TMNT ever take him seriously anymore knowing he's just a lil bug in a metal suit? How did the TMNT react around 'Shredder' in 'Rogue in the House' now that they knew what he really was.

ZariusTwo
06-27-2004, 02:37 PM
It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE (http://www.thetechnodrome.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8874). It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

[color=blue]Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment.?
You're not fooloing anyone, not at all, I knew from DAY ONE you were going to attack "Secret Origins" no matter how good it was, you're hatred towards The Shredder Utrom knew no bounds

And "just to show you're not biased?" What a load of f'ing crock, just because you liked three things about "Secret Origins" (one of which was beacuse of KRANG'S appearance) does'nt change the facts that you GRILLED this episode, just like you grilled the original series episodes.

Wake up, you're not qualified to judge EITHER of these two series, you're a Next Mutation fan, completly and totally, I guarantee you could'nt give that show a bad review if someone offered you $1000, and THAT is what causes your reviews to fall apart.

Whatever problems you have had with The Shredder Utrom, they have always been addressed and proven WRONG in SEVERAL threads by other members, fans of this new cartoon, fans of the franchise, and you have learned NOTHING from what they have said to you.

Your constant hatred of Peter Laird just attributes to the fact why some people are always going to groan every time we find a thread you make challenging or shooting down the original ideas that Laird creates.

At least some members here who hate Laird don't constantly ramble on about how lame his ideas are, you seem to do it constantly just to gain attention, but you're really just showing how ignorant you really are, and how disrespctful you are to the co-creator of the very franchise you CLAIM to like.

I laugh at every review you make, because it's never objective, it never TRIES to be objective, you just rely on your own inaccurate accusations of the Shredder Utrom concept to back you up

cqb101
06-27-2004, 02:53 PM
It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE (http://www.thetechnodrome.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8874). It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

[color=blue]Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment.?
You're not fooloing anyone, not at all, I knew from DAY ONE you were going to attack "Secret Origins" no matter how good it was, you're hatred towards The Shredder Utrom knew no bounds

And "just to show you're not biased?" What a load of f'ing crock, just because you liked three things about "Secret Origins" (one of which was beacuse of KRANG'S appearance) does'nt change the facts that you GRILLED this episode, just like you grilled the original series episodes.

Wake up, you're not qualified to judge EITHER of these two series, you're a Next Mutation fan, completly and totally, I guarantee you could'nt give that show a bad review if someone offered you $1000, and THAT is what causes your reviews to fall apart.

Whatever problems you have had with The Shredder Utrom, they have always been addressed and proven WRONG in SEVERAL threads by other members, fans of this new cartoon, fans of the franchise, and you have learned NOTHING from what they have said to you.

Your constant hatred of Peter Laird just attributes to the fact why some people are always going to groan every time we find a thread you make challenging or shooting down the original ideas that Laird creates.

At least some members here who hate Laird don't constantly ramble on about how lame his ideas are, you seem to do it constantly just to gain attention, but you're really just showing how ignorant you really are, and how disrespctful you are to the co-creator of the very franchise you CLAIM to like.

I laugh at every review you make, because it's never objective, it never TRIES to be objective, you just rely on your own inaccurate accusations of the Shredder Utrom concept to back you up

Well put. Anf Jarrah, would you rather have an origin that is just like all of the others or have something new and original that HASN'T been used before? I personally like new things and not the same old thing recycled over and over again. But then again, you like James Bond so you probably wouldn't like anything that's new.

DrSpengler
06-27-2004, 04:53 PM
I thought the Shredder Utrom was f*cking cool.

But that's my two cents. I may not like Laird for his personality, but idea-wise he's awesome. So I'll never bach him for that.

Secret Origins rocked.

Jarrah White
06-27-2004, 10:08 PM
It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE (http://www.thetechnodrome.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8874). It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

[color=blue]Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment.?
You're not fooloing anyone, not at all, I knew from DAY ONE you were going to attack "Secret Origins" no matter how good it was, you're hatred towards The Shredder Utrom knew no bounds

And "just to show you're not biased?" What a load of f'ing crock, just because you liked three things about "Secret Origins" (one of which was beacuse of KRANG'S appearance) does'nt change the facts that you GRILLED this episode, just like you grilled the original series episodes.

Wake up, you're not qualified to judge EITHER of these two series, you're a Next Mutation fan, completly and totally, I guarantee you could'nt give that show a bad review if someone offered you $1000, and THAT is what causes your reviews to fall apart.

Whatever problems you have had with The Shredder Utrom, they have always been addressed and proven WRONG in SEVERAL threads by other members, fans of this new cartoon, fans of the franchise, and you have learned NOTHING from what they have said to you.

Your constant hatred of Peter Laird just attributes to the fact why some people are always going to groan every time we find a thread you make challenging or shooting down the original ideas that Laird creates.

At least some members here who hate Laird don't constantly ramble on about how lame his ideas are, you seem to do it constantly just to gain attention, but you're really just showing how ignorant you really are, and how disrespctful you are to the co-creator of the very franchise you CLAIM to like.

I laugh at every review you make, because it's never objective, it never TRIES to be objective, you just rely on your own inaccurate accusations of the Shredder Utrom concept to back you up

My, for a five year old child who's this close to being banned you sure have alot of guts. Firstly, I never 'grilled' the old series, I simply said the action didn't match my tastes. You know what I myself knew from DAY ONE you'd try to find a negitive comment to add to my review, deliberatly try to turn, yet another one of my threads, into one of your childish arguments and relentless personal attacks. You think you can have the right to tell me what to like and what not to like? Think you can tell me what I'm qualified and not qualified to watch? What are you? Dictator of Jarrah White's mind? Get off your high horse and smell the roses, there's always gonna be something you dislike about franchises. It's a free country, what you think because someone dislikes something you like or likes something you hate you can treat them like third-world citizens and shove your opinion down their throats? As for my 'constant hate for Peter Laird', I don't see why I should have to respect a chap you can't even reply to some nice fan mail without proving his massive ego and negative attitude to anything outside his own mind.

We're all sick of you Zarius, sick of your constant attacks on people who happen to like Image, NM, etc, etc. Give it a rest, we have had a gut full of your crap and constant whining.

Barkworm
06-27-2004, 11:03 PM
There's nothing more fun here than reading you two guys' arguments. You should go easy though, since you're BOTH extreeeeeeeeeeemely close to being banned.
And Jarrah, I heard about the stuff you've E-mailed Laird and it's totally emberassing to read that crap. For god's sake, STOP annoying him!!! He must think all TMNT fans are a bunch of morons.

Jo Dawn
06-27-2004, 11:11 PM
*Sigh* I'm reeallly tired of the fighting. C'mon guys. I know that not everyone gets along, and that opinions differ. But please. Stop with the fighting. Let it go. I'm not sticking up for ANYONE here... I'm just asking you to stop with the comments.

You've both been warned, and you're getting closer to banned! Why keep feeding the other's fire??

Whitewolf89
06-27-2004, 11:18 PM
It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE (http://www.thetechnodrome.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8874). It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

[color=blue]Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment.?
You're not fooloing anyone, not at all, I knew from DAY ONE you were going to attack "Secret Origins" no matter how good it was, you're hatred towards The Shredder Utrom knew no bounds

And "just to show you're not biased?" What a load of f'ing crock, just because you liked three things about "Secret Origins" (one of which was beacuse of KRANG'S appearance) does'nt change the facts that you GRILLED this episode, just like you grilled the original series episodes.

Wake up, you're not qualified to judge EITHER of these two series, you're a Next Mutation fan, completly and totally, I guarantee you could'nt give that show a bad review if someone offered you $1000, and THAT is what causes your reviews to fall apart.

Whatever problems you have had with The Shredder Utrom, they have always been addressed and proven WRONG in SEVERAL threads by other members, fans of this new cartoon, fans of the franchise, and you have learned NOTHING from what they have said to you.

Your constant hatred of Peter Laird just attributes to the fact why some people are always going to groan every time we find a thread you make challenging or shooting down the original ideas that Laird creates.

At least some members here who hate Laird don't constantly ramble on about how lame his ideas are, you seem to do it constantly just to gain attention, but you're really just showing how ignorant you really are, and how disrespctful you are to the co-creator of the very franchise you CLAIM to like.

I laugh at every review you make, because it's never objective, it never TRIES to be objective, you just rely on your own inaccurate accusations of the Shredder Utrom concept to back you up

My, for a five year old child who's this close to being banned you sure have alot of guts. Firstly, I never 'grilled' the old series, I simply said the action didn't match my tastes. You know what I myself knew from DAY ONE you'd try to find a negitive comment to add to my review, deliberatly try to turn, yet another one of my threads, into one of your childish arguments and relentless personal attacks. You think you can have the right to tell me what to like and what not to like? Think you can tell me what I'm qualified and not qualified to watch? What are you? Dictator of Jarrah White's mind? Get off your high horse and smell the roses, there's always gonna be something you dislike about franchises. It's a free country, what you think because someone dislikes something you like or likes something you hate you can treat them like third-world citizens and shove your opinion down their throats? As for my 'constant hate for Peter Laird', I don't see why I should have to respect a chap you can't even reply to some nice fan mail without proving his massive ego and negative attitude to anything outside his own mind.

We're all sick of you Zarius, sick of your constant attacks on people who happen to like Image, NM, etc, etc. Give it a rest, we have had a gut full of your crap and constant whining.

And you just called Zarius a five year old child. Jarrah, I think that YOU'RE the one who needs to grow up. I liked the "Secret Origins" trilogy, AND the REST of the eps, just fine. Just because it isn't "New Mutation", doesn't mean that you have to trash it all the time. Honestly, I think that Zarius raised some VERY valid points about you so-called "review", and all I can say is this: If you hate it THAT much, don't watch it. It ISN'T going to turn into "The Next Mutation", no matter HOW much you want it to. That show, and your beloved *shudder* Venus are dead. Leave them that way.

As to your hatred for Peter Laird, kindly just remember ONE THING, bud: if it hadn't been for HIM, AND Kevin Eastman's flash of inspiration, there would be NO Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to adore, and yes, FUSS over, PERIOD! You might try chewing on THAT for a bit.

Whitewolf89
06-27-2004, 11:19 PM
*Sigh* I'm reeallly tired of the fighting. C'mon guys. I know that not everyone gets along, and that opinions differ. But please. Stop with the fighting. Let it go. I'm not sticking up for ANYONE here... I'm just asking you to stop with the comments.

You've both been warned, and you're getting closer to banned! Why keep feeding the other's fire??

VERY well put, Jo Dawn. Very well put, indeed.

VaughnMichael
06-27-2004, 11:33 PM
I may not agree with what Jarrah said or Zarrus but please
For the love of freaking god knock it off...I mean seriously your both so damn predictable every time Jarrah posts I wait for you to say something Zarrus it's so freaking annoying!
And btw can you all shut the hell up about the next mutation I happen to like some of it to for what it's worth. So please stop bashing the turtles when you go to bash someone and have nothing better to say or use...it just seems "ignorant" as you'd put it.
-VM

Jarrah White
06-28-2004, 12:26 AM
Whitewolf89, who said I want the new show to be The Next Mutation? I simply stated that I would have prefered it had the new show not changed Shredder's origin.

As to your hatred for Peter Laird, kindly just remember ONE THING, bud: if it hadn't been for HIM, AND Kevin Eastman's flash of inspiration, there would be NO Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to adore, and yes, FUSS over, PERIOD! You might try chewing on THAT for a bit.

Need I remind you it was Eastman's idea in the first place? And I can tell from the e-mails Laird writes that it was his own additude that caused Eastman to walk away from the TMNT project.

Bottom line, I didn't put up this thread to disguse our opinions on Laird, Venus, Next Mutation, etc, etc. Nor did I put it up to yet again be verbally bashed by Zarius. I started this thread so us Australian, citizens who have had to wait countless months for Season 2, to state their opinion on Secret Origins.

Jo Dawn
06-28-2004, 01:06 AM
As to your hatred for Peter Laird, kindly just remember ONE THING, bud: if it hadn't been for HIM, AND Kevin Eastman's flash of inspiration, there would be NO Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to adore, and yes, FUSS over, PERIOD! You might try chewing on THAT for a bit.

Need I remind you it was Eastman's idea in the first place? And I can tell from the e-mails Laird writes that it was his own additude that caused Eastman to walk away from the TMNT project.

Wait, wait... I don't know that that's the reason Eastman walked away from it. So that's very unfair to say. Laird... Hey, I don't think they guy's a jerk or anything... He created the TMNT for goodness sake!! So he gets a little frustrated when people ask the same question over and over, or when people bash HIS creations. You guys are fighting over what someone else here bashes, and it's not even YOUR creations...

BUT, needless to say, saying that his attitude pushed Eastman away... very unfair to say.

Jarrah White
06-28-2004, 05:57 AM
Wait, wait... I don't know that that's the reason Eastman walked away from it. So that's very unfair to say. Laird... Hey, I don't think they guy's a jerk or anything... He created the TMNT for goodness sake!! So he gets a little frustrated when people ask the same question over and over, or when people bash HIS creations. You guys are fighting over what someone else here bashes, and it's not even YOUR creations...

BUT, needless to say, saying that his attitude pushed Eastman away... very unfair to say.

I'm willing to bet it was Laird that caused Eastman to quit, I myself can't even have a decent conversation with Laird with out him shoving his opinion down my throat or without question shooting down certain ideas or aspects that I believe are cool. He can't even be decent enough to answer my questions. He even calls certain non-Mirage artists 'less creative thinkers, people who unfortunately think they are creative' and in some massive ego believes himself to be some kind of superior big shot simply because he helped Eastman create the turtles.

I don't blame Eastman, if I had a narrow-minded and ridged person as a partner helping me with say, the lego movies that I shoot, I'd quickly be pushed away from the project too. I'll give him credit for helping Eastman with the turtles, but in the end I believe no question that Eastman grew tired of his partner's fixed additude and simply turned his back on him.

Now, would any other Australians like to review Secret Origins?

Barkworm
06-28-2004, 06:31 AM
I myself can't even have a decent conversation with Laird with out him shoving his opinion down my throat or without question shooting down certain ideas or aspects that I believe are cool.
If I were Laird and got stupid E-Mails about your NASA bullsh*t, Shredder being an "alien brain" and suggestions to make April a turtle I'd be much less polite than he was. Don't you get it? He don't have to answer your E-Mails!!! He does it nevertheless and you call him "not decent enough". If people like you go on getting on his nerves he'll probably stop replying E-Mails to ANY TMNT-fan. SO... KNOCK... IT... OFF!!!!

Jo Dawn
06-28-2004, 09:55 AM
*Whispers* Barkworm... I didn't say that... Jarrah did. ;) Quoted the wrong person, dear.

jestergoblin
06-28-2004, 11:24 AM
*shakes head and walks out of the thread*

Keep them in check Jo Dawn, please.

creativerealms82
06-28-2004, 11:33 AM
Jarrah Your open minded enough to want a fifth ninja turtle, and your open enough for April to become a Turtle but you mind is closed to the idea of changing the Shredder. Why?

This new cartoon is based on the original comics but at the same time is its own show with its own ideas. Sure some people are not going to like these ideas but you never gave this one a chance.

It is one thing if you hated just the third part because of the Shredder Utrom but it was because you were spoiled and already knew what Shredder already was that you watched the whole three parter with low expectations.

Yes you have said for months that you would give Shredder Oot a chance but you still already had your mind set on what you thought about him. That never changed. It made you go into this episode not looking forward to it. Spoilers ruined this episode for you. You did not give any of it a chance because of for feelings for Shredder the Oot.

creativerealms82
06-28-2004, 11:41 AM
As for the turtles still taking Shredder seriously well it is less what he truely is and more what he did. Little alian or not the Shredder as still came close to killing them countless times and has proven himself as a treat. Knowing what is is takes away none of the fear he brings to them.

Barkworm
06-28-2004, 11:54 AM
*Whispers* Barkworm... I didn't say that... Jarrah did. ;) Quoted the wrong person, dear. Errrm, I don't know what you're talking about. :goofygri:
Being called "dear" by you is such an honour.... *blushes*

Coola Yagami
06-28-2004, 01:46 PM
As for the turtles still taking Shredder seriously well it is less what he truely is and more what he did. Little alian or not the Shredder as still came close to killing them countless times and has proven himself as a treat. Knowing what is is takes away none of the fear he brings to them.

do they joke about it or call him 'shrimp¿ or somethin? or like 'hey shredder, how bout you come out and fight like a squid?' or somethin? If I were the TMNT, I'd aim most of my attacks to his gut.

Jarrah White
06-28-2004, 04:17 PM
Jarrah Your open minded enough to want a fifth ninja turtle, and your open enough for April to become a Turtle but you mind is closed to the idea of changing the Shredder. Why?



Because it takes away what made him a fighter. All that time we saw the turtles fighting The Shredder, a character we've all come to know and remember as an all mighty warrior, we were watching the turtles fight a tiny red blob inside a robot. In a fair fight he'd be squished like a bug. That's why I hate the idea, no longer am I able to see Shredder as a fighter. That'd be like Jaws (the mightiest of all 007 villians, a man who can't die not even when a building falls on him or when he drops from a plane) turn out to be a robot suit for a tiny, defenceless worm.

Jo Dawn
06-28-2004, 04:32 PM
Right... but see, as they were fighting the Shredder (a tiny "blob" you call him), he was a formidable opponent. KNOWING that he's an Utrom doesn't take away from his ability as a fighter. He still gave them quite a fight, AND he's an Utrom. It doesn't take away at ALL the fact that he's a fighter.

He was a fighter before we knew he was an Utrom. Knowing what he really is doesn't make him any less of one. He's still giving the guys quite a go around in a fight.

Jarrah White
06-28-2004, 04:37 PM
It does take away what made him a fighter, because they're not fighting The Shredder, their fighting his exo suit.

Jo Dawn
06-28-2004, 04:42 PM
*Sigh* Well, hey... even out of his suit he's a fiesty litle guy, hehe...

Either way, I'm tired of arguing in this thread. No one's gonna change ANYone's mind here... And I have better things to do than to waste my time trying.

Jarrah White
06-28-2004, 04:54 PM
I'm tired of arguing in this thread.

There we agree, I'm tired of all this childish bickering and fighting. I put up this thread, not so we could argue, but so the Australians could state their review on Secret Origins.

Spitfire
06-28-2004, 07:48 PM
I'm tired of arguing in this thread.

There we agree, I'm tired of all this childish bickering and fighting. I put up this thread, not so we could argue, but so the Australians could state their review on Secret Origins.
This isnt Australians and their review this you and your review. Which is fine Im glad someone stated their thoughts its good to see both sides of the card. Not everyone is going to think every episode is great theres always going to be someone who doesnt like something. Even though me and Im sure alot of people liked the Turtles In Space arc theres still someone if not more then one person who thought it was stupid. Its all a matter of opinion and its someones right to state it. No one in here had any right to make fun of Jarrah's opinions if you didnt adgree you could have simply wrote your own review. Insted of argueing about it. People just need to learn to get along

cqb101
06-28-2004, 08:33 PM
I'm tired of arguing in this thread.

There we agree, I'm tired of all this childish bickering and fighting. I put up this thread, not so we could argue, but so the Australians could state their review on Secret Origins.

If you didn't out it up for arguments than why did you fuel the arguements so much?

Jo Dawn
06-29-2004, 12:56 AM
Just to be clear, I hope that I am not coming across as argumentative... I'm not trying to be. Spitfire is right. Everyone has their opinions, and are free to express them. Not everyone will love every single second of every single episode of TMNT. That's not possible. What's also not possible is everyone AGREEing with everyone else's opinions.

We need to learn to just discuss things, and not argue.

Thank you.

Mecha Cow
06-29-2004, 03:25 AM
Jarrah, try looking at it this way; Sure, Saki is fighting from inside of an android, but it's not like the android is doing all the work for him. He is still the one at the controls, the one that does all the fighting. The androskeleton is very much a part of him, it is in a way his body, not just a weapon.

But the way I see the Shredder, it doesn't matter whether he is human or not, he still has the same evil mind, wich is what makes him the Shredder. He's nothing like Krang, who was a whiny moron.

Size isn't everything. :)

(Not trying to continue an arguement, just bringing up a point of discussion.)

ZariusTwo
06-29-2004, 01:25 PM
Jarrah, try looking at it this way; Sure, Saki is fighting from inside of an android, but it's not like the android is doing all the work for him. He is still the one at the controls, the one that does all the fighting. The androskeleton is very much a part of him, it is in a way his body, not just a weapon.

But the way I see the Shredder, it doesn't matter whether he is human or not, he still has the same evil mind, wich is what makes him the Shredder. He's nothing like Krang, who was a whiny moron.

Size isn't everything. :)

(Not trying to continue an arguement, just bringing up a point of discussion.)

You called Krang a "moron" how is that NOT fueling an argument?

But anyway, I'm apologising for what I said in this thread, but after seeing so many threads Jarrah wasted blasting the Shredder Utrom, AND Peter Laird, I finally decided that it was time someone spoke out

There are so many other ways to insult Laird whilst keeping some degree of dignity, and he did'nt show any of that, he just comes off as so hateful of Laird it's ridiculous, be more objective in the future or don't spray these ludicrous "reviews" if all they are going to contain are the usual hateful comments

He does'nt have to keep shoving his opinions in our face, but he does, and that's sad really, he can't seem to grasp that what he does is annoy some people with this kind of crap

But in any case, I apologise, I really should'nt have insulted him like that, but seriously, next time you make a review Jarrah, leave your hatred of Laird OUT of it, or at least criticise it without calling anything he creates "stupid"

tmntpower2003
06-29-2004, 01:26 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

cqb101
06-29-2004, 01:27 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

Hahhahahahahahahahaha! I think you just said what everyone wanted to say but were to afraid to.

tmntpower2003
06-29-2004, 01:33 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

Hahhahahahahahahahaha! I think you just said what everyone wanted to say but were to afraid to.

No problem, I had to get it off my chest!! This kid thinks he is the end all, know all of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and that he only knows whats best for it. It's a damn tragedy Laird didn't respond to one of your emails by driving to your house, knocking on jarrahs door, ask his mom if he is home, and then proceed to beat the living crap out of jarrah :D

cqb101
06-29-2004, 01:34 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

Hahhahahahahahahahaha! I think you just said what everyone wanted to say but were to afraid to.

No problem, I had to get it off my chest!! This kid thinks he is the end all, know all of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and that he only knows whats best for it. It's a damn tragedy Laird didn't respond to one of your emails by driving to your house, knocking on jarrahs door, ask his mom if he is home, and then proceed to beat the living crap out of jarrah :D

Hahahhahahaha! I'd pay to see that!

Mecha Cow
06-29-2004, 03:42 PM
You called Krang a "moron" how is that NOT fueling an argument?

I didn't mean 'moron' as a way of insulting him, but let's face it, Krang wasn't exactly a genius, not to me anyway. I mean, old cartoon Shredder was a moron, Bebop and Rocksteady were morons, and it fitted perfectly in the old cartoon. They're morons, and that's why I like them. :)

Lighten up.

cqb101
06-29-2004, 04:00 PM
Zarius, PLEASE shrink or change your avatar, it's way over the size limit.

ZariusTwo
06-29-2004, 04:20 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

Well done dude, Jarrah deserved that.

If I see any more of his so-called "reviews", I'll just ignore them rather than waste my time on a TMNT "Fan" with no taste or an objective opinion.

Jarrah White
06-29-2004, 05:21 PM
Jarrah, how are you going to call Laird close minded? When you are the one bashing all the new creative ideas the man had put in place to make this new show the best representation, besides Mirage in turtles folk lore. The Utrom SHredder concept ties everything together. Besides this Shredder has lasted a little longer than the mirage Shredder :P and if you think about it, after Shredder died in the first comic he wasn't really human after that. Anyway, Laird is a good guy, and you should not sit here and humilate him, when the man takes time to answer your emails, when he knows damn well your a jackass. :)

All I said was I hated this one little concept, and that is the Shredder Utrom. Because it ruins his image. A blade encrusted samurai slaughtering the killer of his brother and then come close to killing the turtles only to be blasted by his own grenade is a creative idea. A creature who's most powerful tactic is to stick to his oppionents face in the hope of sufficating him isn't. Don't get me wrong, I like the new series. I really do, but sadly I just don't see the Red Utrom as Shredder, more like Krang with a massive Shredder alter ego.

And Zarius, I find it strange that you doubt my being a fan of TMNT when all you ever seem to do is bash it yourself, NM, Image, The third movie, Lord Dregg, etc, etc. Such an odd coincidence deserves an explanation don't you think.

creativerealms82
06-29-2004, 07:11 PM
Jarrah The Shredder has never been done correctly on any format but the comics. The Old Toon Shredder's first name was Oroko and last name was Saki. The episode where the turtles meet his brother Sergeant Saki is evidence of that. Also the Old toon shredder was a follower; Shredder is no follower especially to a giant brain. The real Shredder would also never have underlings as incompetent as Bebop or Rocksteady.

The Movie Shredder came close but also did not get it right. They took out Nagi from his back story which really was not too bad. The movie made the Foot more of a street game then any over version of them, they were still ninja but they were also punk kids. The Shredders base was an Arcade/skate park, not really what you would expect from the Shredder.

Yes Utrom Shredder does take away some of the impact of the real Shredder but in other ways does better in capturing it then the other two incarnations do. On one hand you can say that all his badass fighting is because of the robot suit and yes your right, however that takes away nothing. The turtles fear Shredder no less now they did when they thought he was human. All things the Shredder suit does are still the actions of the Utrom controlling the suit. It takes nothing away from the deaths he caused, or the pain he made others suffer. Utrom or not The Shredder is still a bad ass character whose size does not change.

He is in some ways the farthest Shredder incarnation from the original but in other ways the closest. However you have all right not to like the twist.

Oh The Shredder Clones are not evidence against the Utrom Shredder like you keep saying. Never was it made clear that they were Shredders clones that were just the best bet. The writers did not want us to know what Shredder was back then so they though in the would be clones to throw off. Shredder drinking tea was also in there to throw us off. Sure the robot does not need to drink but the Utrom does. Anyway the clones, they were probably mutated humans who had shredder suits on. Why is that so hard to believe? Shredder Oot was planned from the start with hints to point us too it and against it.

Jarrah White
06-29-2004, 08:59 PM
I'm willing to bet it wasn't planned from the start, but that's just my theory.

Yes, neither the old toon or live action versions of TMNT perfectly reflected the Mirage version of The Shredder, I'll agree with you there. But what makes these two versions superior to the new toon Shredder, I think, is that they kept him in the human race. Yes the Shredder's doing in this exo suit is truly evil and violent, but it doesn't change what he really is. He is still a weak squid thing in a robot, and that's something no amount of machinery will change. You are perfectly correct: I do have the right not to like the twist, and I don't for obvious reasons. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, but this website (http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/muses/353/shred.html) perfectly discribes my vision of The Shredder. Let's just leave it at that.

cqb101
06-29-2004, 10:34 PM
I'm willing to bet it wasn't planned from the start, but that's just my theory.

Yes, neither the old toon or live action versions of TMNT perfectly reflected the Mirage version of The Shredder, I'll agree with you there. But what makes these two versions superior to the new toon Shredder, I think, is that they kept him in the human race. Yes the Shredder's doing in this exo suit is truly evil and violent, but it doesn't change what he really is. He is still a weak squid thing in a robot, and that's something no amount of machinery will change. You are perfectly correct: I do have the right not to like the twist, and I don't for obvious reasons. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, but this website (http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/muses/353/shred.html) perfectly discribes my vision of The Shredder. Let's just leave it at that.

Actually, I'm sure it WAS planned from the start.....Why else would the Shredder design and info sheet(That we got in the first season) say that Shredder wasn't human and that he was an alien race?

Secondly, STOP using the "Shredder clones" as evidence against him being an Utrom....Since when were they clones of him? Don guessed(based on the armor they were wearing) that they MIGHT be clones of the Shredder. That's it.

VaughnMichael
06-29-2004, 10:47 PM
I'm willing to bet it wasn't planned from the start, but that's just my theory.
well you are wrong jarrah.
this is from the most reccient issue of tmnt in which a fan David Griffin Blyth not sure if he posts here but anyways he goes to ask
"what inspired you to make shredder a utrom & include krand in that episode"
peter laird states as fallows
"The bit with "krang" was merely an affectionate nod to the old show. The Decision to make the shredder an utrom was something that came up in our initial discussions when we were planning the new show, and it seemed like a great way to connect the backstory of the turtles, as well as give us a foe for the turtles who could be seriously beat on within the constraints of a Saterday morning TV show. -PL"
I don't have a problem with you but please for the love of god nock of your theory ******** because your wrong about this.
and I just proved you wrong and I can go even further and do so.
-Vaughn Michael

Mecha Cow
06-30-2004, 03:11 AM
Jarrah, I find it funny how you keep saying that a change in the Shredder's origin completely destroys his image when you consider a fifth female turtle who came out of nowhere to be completely harmless to the image of the TMNT.

And now I will say no more about Utrom Shredder, I am tired of this.

Jarrah White
06-30-2004, 03:26 AM
I'm willing to bet it wasn't planned from the start, but that's just my theory.
well you are wrong jarrah.
this is from the most reccient issue of tmnt in which a fan David Griffin Blyth not sure if he posts here but anyways he goes to ask
"what inspired you to make shredder a utrom & include krand in that episode"
peter laird states as fallows
"The bit with "krang" was merely an affectionate nod to the old show. The Decision to make the shredder an utrom was something that came up in our initial discussions when we were planning the new show, and it seemed like a great way to connect the backstory of the turtles, as well as give us a foe for the turtles who could be seriously beat on within the constraints of a Saterday morning TV show. -PL"
I don't have a problem with you but please for the love of god nock of your theory sh** because your wrong about this.
and I just proved you wrong and I can go even further and do so.
-Vaughn Michael

Your only echowing what Laird told me in his last e-mail. Anyway, weather or not it was planned originally, there was no evidence in Season 1 to suggest that Shredder was an alien. None at all, which is why I find it unnessacary and hard to believe the Utrom concept wasn't added at the last minute.

I won't go on, but what I've been trying to say is there are other ways to tie Shredder to the turtles' origin, ways that keep him human. The old toon is a perfect example.

Just a question to you Americans, but what is the level of violence allowed to be shown on your TV? Because down here in Australia most cartoon violence is far more brutal than beheadings. Mainly mass murder and destruction, characters being completely vaporised, and people bring burned to death. These are some of the sadistic methods used in cartoons down here in Australia, and most on them are Saturday morning cartoons. Forgive me for not being American, but when I look at all the violence shown on television here one starts to wonder what it must be like in the US if they can't show one simple head being chopped off :-?

Barkworm
06-30-2004, 03:46 AM
Could anyone finally lock this?

Jarrah White
06-30-2004, 03:57 AM
Could anyone finally lock this?

Could any other Aussies finally state their review like I originally started this thread for? :roll:

raphael_is_cool
06-30-2004, 04:55 AM
this is from the most reccient issue of tmnt in which a fan David Griffin Blyth not sure if he posts here

Hehe. Actually I think it's Zarius, since he mentions he's an editor of the TV tome TMNT bit. And yes he's a TMNT fan, he likes the truer aspects that are very mirage like

As other people have said I'm sure Utrom Shredder was planned from the start. You'll even notice in earlier episodes (Darkness On The Edge of Town, I think) without the armour he has a belt thing wrapped high around his stomach

Barkworm
06-30-2004, 05:01 AM
Could anyone finally lock this?

Could any other Aussies finally state their review like I originally started this thread for? :roll:
Jarrah, your post before this one was nothing more than a provocation. If you want this thread to be on-topic again, why are you trying to start more flame wars?

Jarrah White
06-30-2004, 05:06 AM
I'm not trying to start any flame wars, I'm just answering people's replies.

My call, I think we should just agree to disagree.

cqb101
06-30-2004, 09:06 AM
I'm willing to bet it wasn't planned from the start, but that's just my theory.
well you are wrong jarrah.
this is from the most reccient issue of tmnt in which a fan David Griffin Blyth not sure if he posts here but anyways he goes to ask
"what inspired you to make shredder a utrom & include krand in that episode"
peter laird states as fallows
"The bit with "krang" was merely an affectionate nod to the old show. The Decision to make the shredder an utrom was something that came up in our initial discussions when we were planning the new show, and it seemed like a great way to connect the backstory of the turtles, as well as give us a foe for the turtles who could be seriously beat on within the constraints of a Saterday morning TV show. -PL"
I don't have a problem with you but please for the love of god nock of your theory sh** because your wrong about this.
and I just proved you wrong and I can go even further and do so.
-Vaughn Michael

Your only echowing what Laird told me in his last e-mail. Anyway, weather or not it was planned originally, there was no evidence in Season 1 to suggest that Shredder was an alien. None at all, which is why I find it unnessacary and hard to believe the Utrom concept wasn't added at the last minute.

I won't go on, but what I've been trying to say is there are other ways to tie Shredder to the turtles' origin, ways that keep him human. The old toon is a perfect example.

Just a question to you Americans, but what is the level of violence allowed to be shown on your TV? Because down here in Australia most cartoon violence is far more brutal than beheadings. Mainly mass murder and destruction, characters being completely vaporised, and people bring burned to death. These are some of the sadistic methods used in cartoons down here in Australia, and most on them are Saturday morning cartoons. Forgive me for not being American, but when I look at all the violence shown on television here one starts to wonder what it must be like in the US if they can't show one simple head being chopped off :-?

Jarrah, it WAS planned from the start...As I said before, the character/design sheet fro Shredder said he wasn't human. Things like that are made before the show even goes into production. Plus, there's more evidence to him being an Utrom than there is to him not being an utrom in season 1.

ZariusTwo
06-30-2004, 12:11 PM
Jarrah, stop flooging a dead horse, you're beaten, Laird answered my question, it WAS always going to be The Shredder Utrom.

"Agree to disagree?" there's nothing to disagree about, Laird has proven you wrong. the cast sheets proved you wrong, the evidence in Season One proved you wrong

ZariusTwo
06-30-2004, 12:21 PM
Zarius, PLEASE shrink or change your avatar, it's way over the size limit.

Whoops, sorry dude.

Jarrah White
06-30-2004, 04:12 PM
Jarrah, stop flooging a dead horse, you're beaten, Laird answered my question, it WAS always going to be The Shredder Utrom.

"Agree to disagree?" there's nothing to disagree about, Laird has proven you wrong. the cast sheets proved you wrong, the evidence in Season One proved you wrong

What evidence?!

And I'm serious, what is the level of violence allowed to be shown in the US? Please answer.

Anarchistguy
06-30-2004, 07:58 PM
Jarrah, stop flooging a dead horse, you're beaten, Laird answered my question, it WAS always going to be The Shredder Utrom.

"Agree to disagree?" there's nothing to disagree about, Laird has proven you wrong. the cast sheets proved you wrong, the evidence in Season One proved you wrong

What evidence?!

And I'm serious, what is the level of violence allowed to be shown in the US? Please answer.

In Saturday morning cartoons?

I'm not american, but I know people can't bleed, can't be seen getting punched, kicked or elbowed across the face (think Dragon Ball Z), can't suffer mutilation (If there is death, it is shown off-screen), can't be seen using ANY kind of real-life guns (or if they do, they can't shoot with them) and they ESPECIALLY cannot swear.

In Canada (in my province, anyway) You can see people bleed, use guns, we can actually see people die and sometimes they can swear.

rayfillet101
06-30-2004, 08:03 PM
um notice how we never saw saki's chest, even when he was practicing? It was taped up. Hmmm I wonder what could be hididng behind that tape? How else would you explain shredder's enemies?

ZariusTwo
06-30-2004, 08:08 PM
This thread is about to be locked so let's hope other Aussies contribute BETTER reviews than our close-minded associate Jarrah.

I mean, come on, anyone else from the land down under that speaks common sense in these forums and hates Desmond Lewellyn? :lol:

Spitfire
06-30-2004, 09:41 PM
Yeah when I re-watched season 1 after seeing SO part 3 I noticed all the hints towards Shredder being a Uthrom.
Anyways DBZ is lame who cares if its censored I know I sure as hell dont. And plus they release so called uncensored versions of DBZ movies and their still not as graphic as the orgnial cuts. Amercia is so lame sometimes. We spend time dubbing crappy animes like Bayblades, dragon ball z and Yu gi o but not good ones like Naurto or the get backers. Hence amercians are retards

cqb101
06-30-2004, 09:48 PM
Yeah when I re-watched season 1 after seeing SO part 3 I noticed all the hints towards Shredder being a Uthrom.
Anyways DBZ is lame who cares if its censored I know I sure as hell dont. And plus they release so called uncensored versions of DBZ movies and their still not as graphic as the orgnial cuts. Amercia is so lame sometimes. We spend time dubbing crappy animes like Bayblades, dragon ball z and Yu gi o but not good ones like Naurto or the get backers. Hence amercians are retards

Actually, it's usually the dubbing and the editing that makes them bad. They're actually pretty good to begin with.

And Jarrah, do you not read ANY of my posts or ANY of my evidence to prove you wrong? Or are you just ignoring it?

Spitfire
06-30-2004, 09:58 PM
Yeah when I re-watched season 1 after seeing SO part 3 I noticed all the hints towards Shredder being a Uthrom.
Anyways DBZ is lame who cares if its censored I know I sure as hell dont. And plus they release so called uncensored versions of DBZ movies and their still not as graphic as the orgnial cuts. Amercia is so lame sometimes. We spend time dubbing crappy animes like Bayblades, dragon ball z and Yu gi o but not good ones like Naurto or the get backers. Hence amercians are retards

Actually, it's usually the dubbing and the editing that makes them bad. They're actually pretty good to begin with.

And Jarrah, do you not read ANY of my posts or ANY of my evidence to prove you wrong? Or are you just ignoring it?
Yeah thats true for Yu Gi O in the Jap version of the show this guy tries to kill Joey with a chainsaw and Joey sets him on fire and it burns the guy to death. And you see it so yeah you have a point

cqb101
06-30-2004, 10:10 PM
Yeah when I re-watched season 1 after seeing SO part 3 I noticed all the hints towards Shredder being a Uthrom.
Anyways DBZ is lame who cares if its censored I know I sure as hell dont. And plus they release so called uncensored versions of DBZ movies and their still not as graphic as the orgnial cuts. Amercia is so lame sometimes. We spend time dubbing crappy animes like Bayblades, dragon ball z and Yu gi o but not good ones like Naurto or the get backers. Hence amercians are retards

Actually, it's usually the dubbing and the editing that makes them bad. They're actually pretty good to begin with.

And Jarrah, do you not read ANY of my posts or ANY of my evidence to prove you wrong? Or are you just ignoring it?
Yeah thats true for Yu Gi O in the Jap version of the show this guy tries to kill Joey with a chainsaw and Joey sets him on fire and it burns the guy to death. And you see it so yeah you have a point

And the Japanese version of DBZ actually makes sense.

Spitfire
06-30-2004, 10:48 PM
Its not that the show doesnt make sense its that the plot is always the same
Collect dragon balls to make wish
Kill bad guy
Thats it theres never any liek love storys or anything its just stupid plot. Vegeta getting with Bluma was totally out of no where they didnt build up to or show them flirting it was stupid

ZariusTwo
07-01-2004, 02:22 PM
Its not that the show doesnt make sense its that the plot is always the same
Collect dragon balls to make wish
Kill bad guy
Thats it theres never any liek love storys or anything its just stupid plot. Vegeta getting with Bluma was totally out of no where they didnt build up to or show them flirting it was stupid

Not really, it was given some good development, when Vegeta was injured training, Bulma stayed at his bedside.

DBZ skips a few years on purpose so the fans can discuss how certain characters get together, like Krillin and Android 18, it makes for excellent fanfiction.

Dragonball's plot is much more than "collecting the Dragonballs", it's also training and surpassing your own levels, and redeeming your past in Goku and Vegeta's case.

I suggest you watch the entirty of "The Cell Games Saga" I know at least five people who liked DBZ after watching that saga, it is the most character-driven, and the most emotional next to the original saga.

Spitfire
07-01-2004, 03:44 PM
Its not that the show doesnt make sense its that the plot is always the same
Collect dragon balls to make wish
Kill bad guy
Thats it theres never any liek love storys or anything its just stupid plot. Vegeta getting with Bluma was totally out of no where they didnt build up to or show them flirting it was stupid

Not really, it was given some good development, when Vegeta was injured training, Bulma stayed at his bedside.

DBZ skips a few years on purpose so the fans can discuss how certain characters get together, like Krillin and Android 18, it makes for excellent fanfiction.

Dragonball's plot is much more than "collecting the Dragonballs", it's also training and surpassing your own levels, and redeeming your past in Goku and Vegeta's case.

I suggest you watch the entirty of "The Cell Games Saga" I know at least five people who liked DBZ after watching that saga, it is the most character-driven, and the most emotional next to the original saga.
I used to own the entire Series on DVD I think Ive seen it enough times hahaha

ZariusTwo
07-01-2004, 04:25 PM
Its not that the show doesnt make sense its that the plot is always the same
Collect dragon balls to make wish
Kill bad guy
Thats it theres never any liek love storys or anything its just stupid plot. Vegeta getting with Bluma was totally out of no where they didnt build up to or show them flirting it was stupid

Not really, it was given some good development, when Vegeta was injured training, Bulma stayed at his bedside.

DBZ skips a few years on purpose so the fans can discuss how certain characters get together, like Krillin and Android 18, it makes for excellent fanfiction.

Dragonball's plot is much more than "collecting the Dragonballs", it's also training and surpassing your own levels, and redeeming your past in Goku and Vegeta's case.

I suggest you watch the entirty of "The Cell Games Saga" I know at least five people who liked DBZ after watching that saga, it is the most character-driven, and the most emotional next to the original saga.
I used to own the entire Series on DVD I think Ive seen it enough times hahaha

:lol:

Ahhhhh well, if you don't like it fine, but a lot of people still like it.

How much did you get for selling it?

Spitfire
07-01-2004, 04:40 PM
Sadly I got uber ripped off! I sold it to Rasputin(Their a music, DVD store that pays the most for used stuff) and I only got 80 bucks! This is for the whole show on DVD in box sets I might add and all the movies Deadzone-Three Super Saiyans, It was a rip off but it cleared room on my DVD rack for my new turtles DVDs. I should have sold my DVDs on Ebay I would have gotten more. I still have a bunch of toys though if you like the show maybe you would liek to buy some. I have all the Irwin toys mint not on the card but I still have the card. PM me if your intrested. I have pictures of them all frount and bakc views

Jarrah White
07-01-2004, 05:22 PM
um notice how we never saw saki's chest, even when he was practicing? It was taped up. Hmmm I wonder what could be hididng behind that tape? How else would you explain shredder's enemies?

I've seen lots of people in real life dress like that in the dojo, I don't know why though.


In Saturday morning cartoons?

I'm not american, but I know people can't bleed, can't be seen getting punched, kicked or elbowed across the face (think Dragon Ball Z), can't suffer mutilation (If there is death, it is shown off-screen), can't be seen using ANY kind of real-life guns (or if they do, they can't shoot with them) and they ESPECIALLY cannot swear.

In Canada (in my province, anyway) You can see people bleed, use guns, we can actually see people die and sometimes they can swear.

If that's the case, I strongly suggest you move down under, because here, Saturday Morning TV has violence gallore! Some cartoon violence involves people being punched in the face, people in their cars being vaporised by space laser beams, people being litterally blown up, people being gassed to death, kick boxxed off a ship, mass destruction of civilian population, etc. Now, if your networks can't show any of this, this is my only comment,

"You have my pitty, really :cry: "

Jo Dawn
07-01-2004, 06:15 PM
Violence does not a great show make.

Why does it NEED to be uber-violent?? It doesn't need to be.

Spitfire
07-01-2004, 06:28 PM
Violence does not a great show make.

Why does it NEED to be uber-violent?? It doesn't need to be.
Violence makes people happy for some reason. Damn amercians! You know half the people who like Kill Bill like it because its violent. I like it for the story but no its cool because she kills people

Jo Dawn
07-01-2004, 06:36 PM
I know alot of people like that stuff... I'm not saying they don't. I'm not saying it's WRONG to like the violence. I was just saying, that just because it's less violent doesn't mean it's bad, or that we need to be felt bad for. That's all. :)

Spitfire
07-01-2004, 06:47 PM
I know alot of people like that stuff... I'm not saying they don't. I'm not saying it's WRONG to like the violence. I was just saying, that just because it's less violent doesn't mean it's bad, or that we need to be felt bad for. That's all. :)
Yeah I adgree with you I would rather watch a movie with some good plot then a blood bath

cqb101
07-01-2004, 07:33 PM
Again Jarrah, you seem to totally annoy all the points I make that totally destroy your theory that it wasn't planned all along....I take it that you don't have anything to say in defense?

Albrecht
07-01-2004, 08:16 PM
Why dosent every one shut the **** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what. I'm sure that at one time in your life you have felt differently about a subject while a ton of ass-holes looked down on you for it, and you thought that they were a buch of silly ****-heads, this is probably how he feels. :|

cqb101
07-01-2004, 08:22 PM
Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what. I'm sure that at one time in your life you have felt differently about a subject while a ton of ass-holes looked down on you for it, and you thought that they were a buch of silly f***-heads, this is probably how he feels. :|

This is totally different, Jarrah is trying to force his opinions as fact. Not to mention that he's a total ****ing hypocrit.

ZariusTwo
07-01-2004, 08:24 PM
Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what.:|

Jarrah is an opinionated narcasist who thinks he is better than Peter Laird, and that his opinion is LAW, he makes a lot of people here furious with his constant ignorence and refusal to acknowledge that facts always prove him wrong, and that most Ninja Turtle fans LIKE The Utrom Shredder idea, something he has been against even before he saw the damn episode.

His threads are not "strange", there downright irritating and continue to raise old questions and bring back subjects and old flame wars that this board is trying to ignore and move forward.

He's a Next Mutation fan, and every time someone gives that series even a HUMEROUS attack, he acts like we've bombed Iraq, he's an attention w*ore who is THIS close to being banned permanently

I have yet to see any more Australians post thier opinions in this thread, which means that this was yet ANOTHER time wasting excuse for Jarrah to again moan and whine about the same crap that he hates.

Don't like it Jarrah? Do us ALL a HUGE favour and DON'T BLOODY WATCH IT!

Jarrah White
07-01-2004, 09:14 PM
Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what. I'm sure that at one time in your life you have felt differently about a subject while a ton of ass-holes looked down on you for it, and you thought that they were a buch of silly f***-heads, this is probably how he feels. :|

This is totally different, Jarrah is trying to force his opinions as fact. Not to mention that he's a total f*** hypocrit.

I'm not trying to force anything as fact, I am just stating my opinion. How does disliking one aspect of a television show make me a hypocrit?

And, Albrecht, thanx for standing up for me :)


Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what.:|

Jarrah is an opinionated narcasist who thinks he is better than Peter Laird, and that his opinion is LAW, he makes a lot of people here furious with his constant ignorence and refusal to acknowledge that facts always prove him wrong, and that most Ninja Turtle fans LIKE The Utrom Shredder idea, something he has been against even before he saw the damn episode.

His threads are not "strange", there downright irritating and continue to raise old questions and bring back subjects and old flame wars that this board is trying to ignore and move forward.

He's a Next Mutation fan, and every time someone gives that series even a HUMEROUS attack, he acts like we've bombed Iraq, he's an attention w*ore who is THIS close to being banned permanently

I have yet to see any more Australians post thier opinions in this thread, which means that this was yet ANOTHER time wasting excuse for Jarrah to again moan and whine about the same crap that he hates.

Don't like it Jarrah? Do us ALL a HUGE favour and DON'T BLOODY WATCH IT!

I wouldn't talk if I were you Zarius. May I ask who is the one who's hobby it is to bash many certain aspects of TMNT? Who couldn't say one decent thing about Image, The Next Mutation, The third movie, Lord Dregg, etc, if he was paid 500 trillion dollars in radioactive gold bullion? Who not only attacks these certain TMNT franchises/characters, but the fans of them? Who gets pleasure in deliberately starting all these arguements instead of living and let live? Who tries to strip these fans of their credibility and starts telling them what they can and can not do, what their allowed to like and what not to likw? I think we both know the answer, don't we Zarius.

GK Punk
07-01-2004, 09:26 PM
i....am...so...sick...of...cleaning...up...you...t wo....fighting...

ZariusTwo
07-01-2004, 09:33 PM
i....am...so...sick...of...cleaning...up...you...t wo....fighting...

I ain't the only one fighting with him, look around you, Jarrah is ticking almost ALL of us off.

Jarrah White
07-01-2004, 09:34 PM
i....am...so...sick...of...cleaning...up...you...t wo....fighting...

Believe me I'm sick of the fighting too...

All I wanted was to make a thread where us Aussies could finally state their review on SO. Instead this happens. What did I do wrong in a passed life?

ZariusTwo
07-01-2004, 09:41 PM
[quote="cqb101"][quote=Albrecht]I'm not trying to force anything as fact

That is quote of the freaking month, you've been ignoring all the facts that have proved you wrong about the Shredder Utrom in favour of what you THINK you know.

I'm out of this thread, it has served it's purpose, it was never designed for Australians to talk about "Secret Origins" all it was was to give Jarrah another excuse to moan about his hatred for Laird and the new cartoon.

And stop portraying yourself as a victim, the mods are not idiots, they know damn well what you've done in this thread

Jarrah White
07-01-2004, 09:43 PM
YOUR the one who started this fight, Zarius! There was none of this arguing in this thread until you came along! I'm glad your leaving this thread! It'll be much more quiet without you around.

cqb101
07-01-2004, 09:47 PM
Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what. I'm sure that at one time in your life you have felt differently about a subject while a ton of ass-holes looked down on you for it, and you thought that they were a buch of silly f***-heads, this is probably how he feels. :|

This is totally different, Jarrah is trying to force his opinions as fact. Not to mention that he's a total f*** hypocrit.

I'm not trying to force anything as fact, I am just stating my opinion. How does disliking one aspect of a television show make me a hypocrit?

And, Albrecht, thanx for standing up for me :)


Why dosent every one shut the f*** up and leave Jarah alone, yes a few of his opinions are a bit crazy, but so what.:|

Jarrah is an opinionated narcasist who thinks he is better than Peter Laird, and that his opinion is LAW, he makes a lot of people here furious with his constant ignorence and refusal to acknowledge that facts always prove him wrong, and that most Ninja Turtle fans LIKE The Utrom Shredder idea, something he has been against even before he saw the damn episode.

His threads are not "strange", there downright irritating and continue to raise old questions and bring back subjects and old flame wars that this board is trying to ignore and move forward.

He's a Next Mutation fan, and every time someone gives that series even a HUMEROUS attack, he acts like we've bombed Iraq, he's an attention w*ore who is THIS close to being banned permanently

I have yet to see any more Australians post thier opinions in this thread, which means that this was yet ANOTHER time wasting excuse for Jarrah to again moan and whine about the same crap that he hates.

Don't like it Jarrah? Do us ALL a HUGE favour and DON'T BLOODY WATCH IT!

I wouldn't talk if I were you Zarius. May I ask who is the one who's hobby it is to bash many certain aspects of TMNT? Who couldn't say one decent thing about Image, The Next Mutation, The third movie, Lord Dregg, etc, if he was paid 500 trillion dollars in radioactive gold bullion? Who not only attacks these certain TMNT franchises/characters, but the fans of them? Who gets pleasure in deliberately starting all these arguements instead of living and let live? Who tries to strip these fans of their credibility and starts telling them what they can and can not do, what their allowed to like and what not to likw? I think we both know the answer, don't we Zarius.

You're a hypocrit because you say you don't like Utrom SHredder because it ruins what he is as a character, yet you LOVE Venus and she ruins everything that the TMNT originally stood for. That's hypocritical.

Jarrah White
07-01-2004, 09:52 PM
Liking Venus and hating the Red Utrom doesn't make me a hypocrit. I'll admit the turtles were no longer four of a kind when Venus came along, but she didn't strip the turtles of what made them warriors.

cqb101
07-01-2004, 10:03 PM
Liking Venus and hating the Red Utrom doesn't make me a hypocrit. I'll admit the turtles were no longer four of a kind when Venus came along, but she didn't strip the turtles of what made them warriors.

Yes, she did. They were originally meant to be special and one of a kind, Venus came along and ruined their image and what they stood for muhc like you say Shredder being an Utrom has ruined his image.

JaffleMan
07-01-2004, 10:18 PM
I know this is entertaining and all but could someone please lock this topic?

There is a certain point where things start to get seriously out of hand and I think that point has been passed a few pages back.

Seriously, anyone serious about posting doesn't need to read all this *-*-*.

Jo Dawn
07-01-2004, 10:19 PM
i....am...so...sick...of...cleaning...up...you...t wo....fighting...

Agreed.

It'll be much more quiet without you around.

It's about to get MUCH more quiet. I've let this thread go for far too long.