The first one was and always will be awesome in my eyes.
Secret of the Ooze... I see what you mean. To me it hasn't aged well either.
I don't recall, from the last time I watched it, at any point in the movie did the turtles use their trademark weapons.
Instead they use inflated clowns, salami, donuts, every possible excuse to not use their weapons.
There are some parts of the movie that I liked... Wether for the cheesy factor, or just because it still builds up excitement:
-The build up to the very first fight. Just gotta love how it all builds up to the moment where the Turtles jump and shout Cowabunga in unison, right before the title pops up.
-Turtles vs Tokka and Razhar + Vanilla Ice + Super Shredder for a brief second.
I think both of these moments are the only moments worth watching, to me.
It was overall a pretty good idea, when Shredder gets oozed and turns into Super Shredder, but wasn't executed well enough.
I still like Turtles III over Secret of the Ooze, just for its superior action scenes. (And I really really liked Mitsu as a kid)
But, this doesn't mean I don't re-watch it from time to time.

It may be the weaker film of the four (to me), but I still love it, and it's still a classic.