View Single Post
Old 08-28-2013, 12:05 AM   #4
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
I'd have to read all of it again, but definitely April's "Secret Origin" from Vol. 4. Nothing else in the whole thing bugged me as much as that did.
I'm of two minds about that.

The issue itself -- Vol. 4 #22 -- is one of the most disturbingly effective entries in the whole of TMNT canon. It works. I swear we were working toward some real payoff through Leo's discovery of the Battle Nexus as well.

Unfortunately that payoff never came, so we're just left with this bizarre footnote that really does undermine April's fundamental role as a character -- that of the Turtle's connection to normality (despite her life being anything but normal from the time she meets them). I suppose, current state, the series would probably read better without it. It wasn't doing much thematically either.

Quote:
Originally Posted by CyberCubed View Post
If you became Peter Laird for a day, but had your own personal preferences and not his, what Mirage TMNT comics would you retcon/erase?

- I'd gut a good chunk of Volume 1, but far from all of it. I'd also move Soul's Winter out of the main volume and into a separate, "Tales" series. Any zany/goofy stories would be erased, and any stories that wound up being dull or pointless (like #44 with the black girl, or #41 with Turtle dreams) would be gone.

- Volume 2 would have simply continued from Volume 1 in black and white, and without the rushed ending.

- All those TMNT specials like, "The Haunted Pizza," "Times Pipeline" "The Maltease Turtle," and "Casey Jones" would be gone.

- Image would removed that terrible, "Johnny Raeborn" story...that small segment where they crossover with Image superheroes, I think it was #11-13...that arc was awful.

- Volume 4 would be extremely condensed and all that padding would be gone.
I disagree almost unilaterally with these, except the Volume 3 bit, where I absolutely, one-hundred percent agree.

Those bizarre guest artist stories, while I'm sure they were excruciating to sit through on a longer-than-monthly basis, are part of what gives Mirage its tone for me. I like to imagine that they mostly happened, too, as far as the Turtles' world is concerned, if not quite as wacky as depicted on-page.

The colors on Volume 2 are great. Shame about the art and writing in the last half, though.

The Lucindra issue and "Turtle Dreams" are both boss. Some of the better character issues in Volume 1, though both still definitely riding the wave of the surreal guest artist era.

And the specials, while I'm not crazy about any of them, don't do anything offensive enough to make me wish they didn't exist.

There are a few issues of Tales Vol. 2 I feel that way about, though. Chief among them #35, "The Pantheon," which really kills the Rat King's character. I could probably live without the Moo-Mesa crossovers as well.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote