|
(I avoid previews and spoilers so I can go into stories fresh, so I've only read the last few posts in this thread; forgive me)
On the subject of Shredder's competence as a fighter and leader, I had a similar reaction to Andrew's after issue #12, but I think in retrospect I'm partly to blame, as I had my own loaded expectations as to how a first encounter with Shredder ought to go. I was anticipating a Shredder in a league far and beyond what the Turtles were in, so when they were able to hold their own against him (even by teaming up), on their first encounter no less, I felt like Shredder's threat was diminished before it could even be established. I know it makes for a more "human" Shredder, that he'd have trouble fighting 4-on-1, and perhaps that's what the scene was going for; not a monstrous, juggernaut Shredder that cannot be touched.
But #12 didn't get released in a vacuum, either, and was part of a bigger picture that also built toward my feeling of slight disappointment in the big showdown. The Foot Soldiers had just made their first appearance in a fight against the TMNT in the Leo Micro, and Leo singlehandedly wrecks them all in his first encounter (and without killing any of them because Rules). While the Foot Soldiers have always been cannon fodder, this was their big introduction, so to make them that in their debut didn't do them any favors.
Then we get to Shredder, who takes 3 issues to move from the spot he's standing in (I'm sorry, but that was kind of ridiculous) and there's all this build up and anticipation... and the Turtles hold their own against him on their first bout ("defeat" might be an excessive description, looking back, but they did rescue Splinter and accomplish their mission). True that Shredder took Leo down single handed in the micro, but I was expecting a little more from him, even when ganged up on.
And shortly after THAT was the 2012 Annual where we finally got the Savate in their big starring role, and they were treated as comedy relief and ineffectual.
It was just... a lot of build up that didn't quite hit the mark for me personally, and all in rapid succession. "Krang War" really turned things around, I think, as THAT was finally a situation where the Turtles were completely out of their depth and completely overwhelmed and overpowered and it finally felt like they were up against a threat utterly beyond them (not to mention they essentially lost that one).
And I suppose that had the TMNT been trounced by Shredder in #12 and then battered around during Krang War, it would have been excessive in its own way, yeah.
As for Shredder's lack of foresight, well, Tazi listed the grievances fairly well. He seems to be surrounding himself with scheming dissidents worse than Cobra Commander. But "City Fall" isn't over yet, so that may well turn out to have been intentional. But it's hard to give him the benefit of the doubt, is all, considering his track record so far.
|