Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow
I'm mildly surprised by this reaction. In TMNT #12, Shredder beats Splinter, easily beats the Turtles two-on-one, and is dominant for 3 of the 4 pages that he is fighting the Turtles (just went back and looked at it!). Only when the all gang up on him, are they able to get any hits in. At the end of the fight, Shredder is left standing and talking, ready to fight more, and the Turtles flee. To me, that doesn't really equate to Shredder being ineffectual. That was the intent at least, but clearly we fell short of the mark for you.
Obviously, that issue didn't work for you Andrew, and that's fine. TMNT #12 remains one of the issues I am most dissatisfied with, for a variety of reasons, but mostly because we had to do that issue in 2/3rd of the time we usually have. We were rushed, both in script and art, and I think it shows. Excuses, excuses- ultimately it wasn't as strong of an issue as I would have liked, given how important it is meant to be as the conclusion to the first Turtles/Shredder story, and that's on all of us involved with it.
But in terms of introducing a villain, I think it's more interesting if we see that character grow and adapt, rather than be an unstoppable force right from the get go. I think it gives more depth and range, and makes them more unpredictable. Again, to each their own. Not saying your opinion is wrong, just voicing my thoughts, as obviously enough time has passed since that issue to make verdicts about it. Personally, I think Gauntlet in the Nick toon did a better job of introducing Shredder vs. the Turtles. I agree with that-- that's a pretty flawless episode, and had we seen it before our issues, I'm curious if it would have affected our presentation.
As for him being an 'incompetent strategist' I'm not sure what you're referring to but maybe you'll feel differently by the end City Fall. So far everything is going pretty well for him, but maybe that's because we're artificially constructing it that way and I'm too close see it. But honestly it sounds like this book just isn't for you, and again-- that's totally fine. It will work for some, not for others.
|