View Single Post
Old 09-30-2013, 03:38 PM   #2
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
Well, the IDW comic began before the Nick series did with little frame of reference as to what Nick was going to do; it's series mythology, characterization and relationships are wildly different from what Nick is doing. I just don't see the IDW series as really giving a hoot what the Nick series is up to.

I mean like or hate New Animated Adventures, that title works to absorb any corporate demand for a comic version that reflects the current cartoon version, freeing IDW's ongoing series to do whatever it wants. Likewise, I'm sure it satisfies any personal desires from a creative team to "keep it consistent with the cartoon" rather than any corporate decrees, too.

Looking at the IDW series, I honestly haven't detected any influences, large or small, from the Nick cartoon even a year after that series has been on the air. So I'm not too concerned with anything like that happening in the future.

On the surface, one might think Santolouco giving each Turtle a unique look in terms of their physique is a concession to the Nick series models. But even then, his renderings don't reflect Nick's (no freckles on Mikey or tooth gap on Donnie, etc). And having looked at Santolouco's older stuff on DA, he was making the TMNT physically distinct long before any Nick influences could have been felt.

Would I *like* to see concepts from the Nick cartoon adapted into the IDW ongoing? I dunno, maybe. But only if it felt organic (ie; if all of a sudden Donnie was madly in love with April with no catalyst, THAT would feel terribly inorganic).

The Nick cartoon is still young and we should probably give it some more time to actually develop ITS OWN concepts before other media like the IDW ongoing jumps the gun and begins integrating said concepts.
DrSpengler is offline   Reply With Quote