View Single Post
Old 11-13-2013, 03:56 PM   #165
Davetello
Banned
 
Davetello's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Greater Glasgow, Scotland, The Ununited Kingdom
Posts: 1,712
Quote:
Originally Posted by Type 97 Chi-ha View Post
I won't, except to say that I never said that colonialism was benign. Far from it. But it is equally bad to say that the West is responsible for all the Third World's problems. Mao Zedong, after all, was far more murderous toward the Chinese people than the Japanese or any Western colonialists were-even though past colonial nations are still unpopular in China.
Indeed. However, I don't believe that the west is fully responsible for the developing world's ills. As with most things, it's not black and white, and there are faults on both sides. However, it cannot be denied that what we did was self-serving and evil, even if it ultimately had unintentional positive consequences. However, those were a by-product of less than noble intentions.

My entire issue was that you seemed to be attempting to remove all responsiblity from the west. You seem like a reflective sort of guy so I think we both know that that wouldn't be the correct stance to take.

We can extrapolate all manner of theories and deductions from the actions of our ancestors, and we can try to excuse their actions with the usual arguments ('it was a different time, people weren't as civilised and it's easy to place guilt with the benefit of a contemporary lens' etc) but we played our part in causing untold suffering to millions of people and, whilst we have aided former colonies in some ways, we've also constrained them in others.

That's my only point, that things aren't black and white. I won't deny that I think the British empire - for example - was evil, but I also don't deny that some good came out of it, ironically.

The genocidal tendencies of power-mad dictators is something I'm in agreement with, but again, two wrongs don't make a right.

Anyway, it's good to talk to someone else who's passionate about such subjects, even if we have butted heads.

EDIT: my original comment regarding despising western culture was more about modern media networks and attempts at censorship than historical accounts of slavery or colonialism, by the way (although it is all interconnected). Just to make that clear.
Davetello is offline   Reply With Quote