Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656
ZING!
By the way, the TMNT aren't an actual honest-to-goodness-for-real ninja clan. Kev and Pete based literally everything "Japanese" in TMNT on the cheesy stuff one often found on TV and on VHS in those days. None of which was in any way "authentic". It's cool that TMNT eventually got people into studying Japanese culture, or martial arts, or Eastern religion, or whatever, all that is great... but it's really not at all present in the source material past a very superficial level. I don't get why some people get so bent on how authentic things like the Turtles' weapons or headbands would be to an "actual ninja clan". Were Kev & Pete actually trying to keep it that real? Because... I'm pretty sure they were just drunk, high, and riffing on Daredevil. Preeeeetty sure that's all it was.
I always thought the colored bandannas thing was fine. I wouldn't call it blatantly necessary but I'd say it helps more than it hurts. Especially very young children who are just getting into the franchise. I know a lot of people pretty much wish "young kids" and "TMNT" had nothing at all to do with each other, but that's a whole different argument and anyway, too late. But anyway, a lot of young kids are bad at remembering names but good at identifying things by color, and for that reason alone, I fail to see why it would ever be a bad thing. Toys, yeah, sure, but at the same time, my niece watching TMNT when she was 10 or 11 could get into Mikey because he's "the goofy one", and at the same time, my nephew, who was like 4 or 5, could like Raph because "he wears red and I like red", or whatever. I think that sort of thing means the colored headbands has more upside than not; it's just one more thing to help some people identify with the characters. Some of those same fans can evolve and grow up into other versions of the franchise, too; a kid who started liking Leo on the cartoon just because he wore blue might grow up and develop an appreciation for Leo in Mirage as simply a well-written character, for example.
Other than strictly the most purist of reasons, I never saw why some people are so offended by it. Necessary? Eh, maybe not, but I fail to see what it hurts. Since they're just a bunch of punk kids hanging out in a sewer and not actually a strict, rigid, by-the-books ninja clan or anything.
|
This is so correct! Kevin and Peter drew zip from real Ninja. They, just like most of the other martial arts comics from the 80's, drew what they liked from Kung-fu and martial arts movies and stuck the 'ninja' motif in there because they thought it was cool. Throw in a layer of hollowood 'ninja are kewel killer assasins who dress all in black cut people up and leave lots of blood!' and you get the hollywood ninja a fry cry from a histoical shinobi.
The worst I've seen is taking celtic clan honor, and trying to slap it copy-paste onto Japan to tell the dramatic story of 'he killed my father, honor demands that I ethier kill him, or kill myself'. While there is truth in that secenario, it's much more culturally complex and layered than 'gritty martial arts flick' makes it out to be. I have yet to see a hollywood martial arts film fully capture the esscence of those aspects of Japanese culture.
Even Japanese culture treats Ninja diffrently! look at thier potrayals in anime, films, and manga- heroic, village defending ninja outnumber thier assassin counterparts. Ninja Scroll and a few other Japanese masterpieces nowithstanding, it's over here they are potrayed as the gritty assasins everyone seems to want the turtles to be.