Thread: where to start?
View Single Post
Old 03-27-2014, 05:29 PM   #6
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Quote:
Originally Posted by us_sofcskey View Post
so vol 1-5 idw hardcover editions are mirage's volume 1 correct.

they have or have not done volume 2 of mirage?

volume 3 is image..... you mean we can download from td forums

then what about that last volume by Mirage?

k that's mirage stuff.... like I said don't know if I would care for archie but is there stuff in collected volumes like idw has for some of mirage stuff?

Plus I probably will get into the new IDW comic... saw another thread that helps you know what comes in order there.
We ought to have a sticky for this:

IDW's "Ultimate Collection" hardcovers collect all the material from Vol. 1 plotted by Eastman and Laird. This includes the micro-series. Together, they form one narrative that makes up the main plot of Volume 1. It can be read on its own. If you're dabbling, I actually recommend starting on Volumes 4 and 5. They do build on previous material, but they're absolute standouts and can be read as their own as a better indication of the series' later tone (the one that will carry through Volume 2, Volume 4, and the second Tales series).

IDW's Tales of the TMNT collections collect color reprints of Mirage's Tales series. This is really two series, one of which ran for seven issues during the Volume 1 era (collected in the first two IDW collections), and one of which began during the post-2002 revival and ran for 70 issues jumping all over the Turtles' timeline (collected in the third book and beyond). Both are very good. In terms of story-importance, the original Tales Volume has some important beats to Volume 1. Overall, I'd recommend the whole thing.

IDW's "Classics" series collects color reprints of guest-artist issues from Volume 1, and as of Volume 8, collects Mirage Volume 2. The first seven volumes contains stories of varying quality and varying importance to the overall story, so I'd check for individual reviews if you aren't sure. From Volume 8 onward, it's more of the main story from Mirage Volume 2.

Hopefully that helps! I should point out there's also the "The Works" hardcovers, which collect (pretty well done) color reprints of the Eastman and Laird Volume 1 issues. You could really go either way between those or the Ultimate Collection books. The main difference (besides the color) is that the "The Works" books don't contain commentary from Eastman and Laird. And it's uncertain and unlikely at this point that they'll go further than issue #21.

For your other questions, we don't know how "Volume 3" (originally published by Image) or Mirage's Volume 4 will be re-printed yet. I guess we'll see after they're done with Volume 2.

The Archie series, TMNT Adventures, is being reprinted in its own line by IDW. It begins with a "100-page Spectacular," which you should still be able to find and which collects the opening three-issue mini-seres (retelling of the opening arc from the cartoon), and continues on into the main series proper with numbered volumes. I think they're on volume 7 or 8 now; I've fallen a bit behind. The entire series is seventy-some issues with ancillary mini-series here and there.

Let me know if you have any other questions, as I know it can get fairly confusing with all the different uses of "volume" etc. necessary to describe this.

Last edited by Cipher; 03-27-2014 at 05:35 PM.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote