View Single Post
Old 04-11-2014, 05:11 PM   #4
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,623
Quote:
Originally Posted by graphic_content View Post
in past iterations they've been referred to, and referred to themselves as protectors of the city - my guess is, when all is said and done, by the end of this film, they will have adopted NYC as their territory, and begin the whole vigilante ninja/stop crime type thing.
Which would be a fallacy. Unless these are, in fact, humans that mutated into Turtles in this universe... that would make sense, as they would have grown up in our society. Why else would they spend their days and nights protecting a society that they have nothing to do with while living underneath it in a sewer? And come to think of it, even if they were humans that mutated into Turtles and not the other way around, it's not like they could even return to our society anyway... so why be doing us favors like that, full time? In that case they should be spending their time, full time, working on a retro-mutagen so they can return to our society, not worrying themselves with crap like patrolling the streets for muggers and bank robbers.

Either way... doesn't compute.

Quote:
Originally Posted by FellowChucker View Post
They're commonly referred to as vigilantes by the screen writer, director, and producers.
They can refer to them as that all they want and you can parrot them all you like, but they're not. Now, TPTB can force them to take on those duties in whatever strange alternate TMNT universes (they get to do that now, they paid $63 million for the property and Peter and Kevin don't get to say "No" to horrible ideas anymore)... but that doesn't either have any precedent in the source material, or make any sense.

Quote:
Why? Because that's what the ninja turtles are ... they're heroes.
No they're not. Just in some children's spinoff stuff in ways that much thought was not put into whatsoever.

Quote:
Anyone remember the shirt used for crew members of the turtles all blurry with the words VIGILANTES underneath? Maybe from a new report in the film ...
Neither here nor there.

Quote:
But Andrew NDB just thinks they should be revenge assassins. That's what they were originally after all.
That's right. It's not a matter of opinion or poll... it's fact. That's what they were created to be.

Which, while that would always be a big part of their psyches, isn't to say that was what they were intended to always be. "City at War" tackled the question of, "Well... Shredder's dead and the Foot Clan isn't messing with us anymore. Mission accomplished. Now what?" And Volume 2 and Volume 4 were working on giving us a fully formed answer to that (which seemed to be "lots of things," including things like Michelangelo joining the Triceraton Empire and Leonardo finding his way in the Battle Nexus), but it wasn't ever going to be something pedantic like, "Let's go and fight crime, like Batman!"

That is literally the most creatively bankrupt avenue to take, and I like to think the TMNT are better than that. In the source material, they are.

Quote:
The vast majority of the franchise history they've become heroes, vigilante good guys. Not morally ambiguous, assassins. Turtles were vigilante heroes in the '87 OT, 1990 film, 2003 series, 2k7 film, Nick toon. Etc.
But there is no reason for the Turtles to become heroes, outside of some kind of setting like Volume 4's where aliens land and mutants can freely walk the Earth and be a part of society (but even then... why bother with that? they have their own problems, their own lives and adventures to worry about).

No reason, that is, beyond some kind of half-remembered, ill-thought out Fred Wolf fanboy nostalgia for wanting the Turtles to be like they were in the Fred Wolf cartoon... just because that's the way they were in the Fred Wolf cartoon. And that's dumb.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 04-11-2014 at 05:22 PM.
Andrew NDB is offline