Mine would be this
First movie:
Like the original movie. Shredder is the enemy, April the reporter, Casey tries to help, Turtles fighting Shredder.
Two things different: Casey and April didn´t meet, so no stupid love story and the Turtles get serious wounds at the end and have to hide in Caseys Farmhouse (like in 2003 series).
Second movie:
Shredder wasn´t defeated and meet with Krang (who has just landed on earth and want to dominate it). Turtles have to train more and to overcome their fear of fighting shredder again (Mikeys is the most scared and raph just want to run into the fight without thinking). Leo and Raph fighting about the leadership and Don called April, so April and Casey meet.(no love story yet)
In the end they fight the unit of shredder and krang in the technodrome.
Turtles win.