View Single Post
Old 05-24-2014, 04:38 AM   #239
Powder
40 Years of TMNT
 
Powder's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Shell-Ri-La
Posts: 26,956
Quote:
Originally Posted by Powder View Post
Between yesterday & today 5 artists have already spoiled their contribution to the book on Facebook & Deviantart respectively. Way to make me wanna buy it, guys...

Seriously, if the book is supposed to have exclusive content, DON'T FREAKIN' POST WHAT YOU DID BEFORE ANYONE'S EVEN READ THE GOD DAMN THING.

Put a leash on your artists, IDW!

& yes, I know, Bobby gave the okay. Shame on you, Bobby!
Really want to reiterate on this. It's my only disappointment with the book. The day before release, the day of release, and the day after release had 75% of the pin-ups already posted by the artists on their websites. That really freakin' sucks. & all the rest of the pin ups were older pieces that Steve & Ken posted on Facebook months ago. The back cover, while awesome, is a 2012 piece. So none of those 'bonuses' felt like bonuses. & I could deal with Eastmans story being a reprint, but WTF @ the quality! It was blurry as hell...

Quote:
Originally Posted by funatic View Post
Pleasantly surprised with this, a great retrospective! Really dug Lawson's revisit to volume 4, and big ups to Tom and Dan for the IDW tale, which my have been my favorite of all of them. I was really missing this 'beat' of Raph adjusting to his new life amongst his brothers back in IDW year 1, and this filled the notch perfectly. Tom if you're listening, I'd LOVE to see more of these little introspective 1-offs looking into characters thoughts and feelings. (Maybe as little shorts at the end of regular issues?) These slower, family-oriented pieces are what made me fall for the turtles in the first place. Action packed stories are awesome too, but little bits like this really flesh things out and make the IDWverse all the more stronger for it! Keep it up! And kudos to Bobby et al for getting all these great artistic teams back together to honor the 30th anniversary!
Nailed it. That part of the book was surprisingly good all in all. & it was nice to see Duncan's turtles' heads return to their original look rather than the very tall dome-like shape they had in later issues.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
I read it today. Awesome, awesome work from everyone at every point. I hadn't read the Kevin Eastman short before but I know it was published elsewhere previously... good, but, it looked a little puzzlingly pixelated, though? Were lower res files used? The rest was all aces. The Jim Lawson short was great, and it was nice to see his work in full color for the first time since Vol. 2. The Archie story was an unexpected gem -- Archie Bebop and Rocksteady, back on Earth from their paradise world, looking for snacks... it worked! The IDW short was nice, too, and it felt right to see more from Dan Duncan here. The Image piece I'd seen the art from earlier, but not in full color (from my good buddy and frequent collaborator Courtland Brugger/Sabacooza, who knocks it out of the park here!)... really pops. I wish the actual Image series had been rendered in lavish, eye-popping full color like this. I can imagine the initial inclination would have been to have the Lawson and Fosco pages be in B&W, but I'm glad they were allowed to look like a modern, color-rendered comic.

This was a truly classy offering from IDW. Cover to cover, pound for pound awesome-sauce.
Sums up my thoughts quite well. Foscos work was great but holy hell those colors were magic. Great job, Sab.

Thanks to everyone involved in putting this together, it was an awesome offering.
Powder is offline   Reply With Quote