Quote:
Originally Posted by The Big Bad
To a degree, yes: part of my problem is that many characters currently reside in that anti-Goldilocks zone where they're both too different and/or too similar. And yet no, because the solution, I feel, to characters like Nobody is not to make them more like their other selves, but to embrace that these are new concepts and just go whole-hog instead of retreating and going "hey, old concept!" in an attempt to make them more palatable.
To repeat: there is nothing to tie IDW Nobody to the character from the Mirage books and the 4Kids toon except for a name and costumes that share several elements. They could have called her something else or nothing at all, and I don't think many who like this development would have complained (at least unless the reason they like this development is because of the name, which case, consider my eyebrow raised in Spock-like manner). And yet, there the name is, which raises the question: why?
(There are several answers, the most satisfying being that they wanted to tie the name to her self-esteem issues. And by "satisfying" I mean "too literal and contrived by half".)
In any case, here we are. What does it add? A nod to an established character, for people who like that sort of thing. What does it add to our understanding about Nobody the cop? Nothing, since that's not the character we're getting. What does it take away? The opportunity to see Nobody the cop, at least anytime soon. I feel the whole thing would have felt more honest, daring, and interesting if they'd let it stand on its own without the name. I might not have liked it, but I'd at least feel it would have had more merit. And I feel that way about a whole bunch of characters, whose incarnations here tend to lose a lot of what made them interest without adding a whole lot.
Change in general is fine. The 4Kids cartoon's transformation of Karai into the Shredder's daughter is a huge change, one that fundamentally changes the character. And yet, I get it. It turns the character into the turtles' dark mirror--themselves, trained by the bad guy. Giving Hamato Yoshi a daughter? That's a fantastic change, because the idea that the turtles are Splinter's second attempt at raising a family is something I find inherently interesting, and was disappointed that Miwa turned out to be a baby when she was lost, because it cuts off a lot of that potential. I respect all of the liberties the original cartoon took with the source material, and, those the Archie book took with the original cartoon. I may not have liked them all, but there's a sense that the writers had the courage of their convictions. They didn't do things halfway. The IDW series on the other hand, specials notwithstanding, almost always feels halfway.
|
I really don't get why you're okay with the liberties the cartoons took with pre-existing characters like Karai, yet you hate every liberty the IDW comic has taken. It seems completely arbitrary to me, especially your complaint that the IDW comic is both too similar and too different. If you don't like the IDW comic that's fine, but your logic here makes no sense at all.
However, your accusation that the IDW comic doesn't differentiate itself enough from other iterations of the TMNT does warrant discussion. IMO the IDW comic has, as others have said before, set itself up as a sort of "Ultimate TMNT", a series that grabs from every facet of the TMNT franchise and introduces old elements in a new way. And this IMO is how IDW differentiates itself from other TMNT media.
Before the IDW comic started, most TMNT iterations had kept to themselves, coming up with their own supporting characters and status quos, independent of anything that had come before it. Even the Archie comic based on the 80's cartoon became its own unique thing before too long. There had never really been a TMNT comic (or movie, or cartoon) that was a conglomeration of all previous TMNT incarnations in an attempt to unify everything into a single cohesive whole. This is precisely what the IDW comic is attempting to do, to bring all these disparate elements together into one singular narrative. You could almost call it an attempt to be the definitive TMNT experience, though I doubt Kevin, Tom or Bobby would ever call it that.
I totally understand if you would prefer a TMNT comic that paves its own way and ignores the franchise's history. But you have to appreciate that IDW's approach to TMNT is unique, and in many ways was a long time coming. I mean come on, how did it take 25 years for Bebop and Rocksteady to show up in TMNT again?