We're not counting the X-Files crossover because it's a shoe-in, huh?
It would have to be the first annual. That book is just plain hard to read--the lack of color, the squashed too-dark panels, the jumping around in chronology and the focus on a bunch of same-looking human characters we'd never met before made it hard to tell what the hell was going on most of the time. It joins the X-Files crossover on the list of issue I'm likely to skip next re-read.
Not to jump on Kevin Eastman, but #21 is definitely in second place (or first if you only count the main series). It feels like a backup instead of a full issue.
Frankly, I like Kevin's covers but I'm not crazy about his full issues. Also, I liked the Mikey micro and Utrom Empire, but I'm not wild about Kuhn's work on the main book and I hope he stays on side projects only.