View Single Post
Old 08-04-2014, 08:43 PM   #2
Specimen B
Mouser
 
Specimen B's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by Commenter 42 View Post
Good to see there's at least one person here that gets that a mutated turtle needs to express the traits of an actual turtle.

Not sure why some people can't understand that. I was never arguing that it's the only way to depict the designs, and variations are interesting to see - but if you're using real actors, why not do real turtles?
hmm.
i think all of the incarnations express the traits of actual turtles, but, and this is especially true of the film designs, these creatures need to be capable of human movement and human speech on a believable level. so they have many, but not all turtle traits.

so, i don't think simply making them giant turtles with longer limbs will do.

in order to speak human words, they need a humanoid mouth. in order to move as ninjas move, they need to be capable of the full range of human movement.

i think this is what the film makers had in mind when they gave the turtles reduced, almost vestigial plastrons. on a sci-fi level, i think it's "ideal genetic compromise"- giving the TMNT the best of turtle and human traits.
Specimen B is offline   Reply With Quote